Symphony: Simple Phase Control for Wave Energy Systems

arXiv:2608.09525 · eess.SY, cs.SY · Submitted 2026-08-10 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Robotics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest robotics and control papers.

Rosa: We're looking at the paper: "Symphony: Simple Phase Control for Wave Energy Systems".

Dev: Here's the gist of the paper. Symphony is a novel nonoptimisation-based (NOB) controller inspired by phase control techniques for wave energy devices that achieves close-to-optimal performance across evaluated sea states, even in the presence of measurement noise and model uncertainty <ref:2608.09525#pg2> Controller Architecture Symphony is designed using a hierarchical structure consisting of an upper loop and a lower loop <ref:2608.09525#pg4>.

Rosa: The upper loop provides a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to an excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate <ref:2608.09525#pg4>.

Dev: Then, a user-flexible lower loop tracks the desired velocity trajectory by combining feedback and feedforward terms <ref:2608.09525#pg4>.

Rosa: Forward-invariant trajectories are obtained by solving an implicit Gaussian differential equation (IGDE) <ref:2608.09525#pg5>.

Title and authors: Rosa: So we're looking at this paper called "Symphony: Simple Phase Control for Wave Energy Systems." It’s about a new way to control these wave energy devices.

Dev: Yeah, it tackles the challenge of getting real-time energy-maximizing control without needing heavy optimization. This paper introduces Symphony as a novel nonoptimisation based controller inspired by phase control techniques used in wave energy devices.

Taro: So, what’s the main idea behind this approach? Is it simpler to implement than those complex optimization based methods we see in some of the other papers?

Rosa: Exactly, that’s a big part of it. Symphony is designed to have simplicity in design, implementation, tuning, and use while still providing hard motion-constrained reference trajectories and close-to-optimal performance across different sea states even when there's measurement noise or model uncertainty.

Dev: That sounds like it’s aiming for that sweet spot between complexity and reliability. The paper sets up a hierarchical structure for this controller, which is pretty interesting because it separates the tasks into an upper loop and a lower loop.

Taro: A hierarchical structure means there's some kind of layering to how the control works, right? What does that layering actually look like in practice when you’re trying to keep something stable?

Rosa: Well, the upper loop provides a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference. This reference is proportional to an excitation force estimate, which essentially helps phase-match the wave energy converter's velocity with that estimated excitation force.

Dev: And then the lower loop tracks that desired velocity trajectory by combining both feedback and feedforward terms, which is where the actual tracking happens. But how do they get those trajectories in the first place?

Taro: That’s where this paper introduces solving an implicit Gaussian differential equation, or IGDE. That means they use that equation to generate forward invariant trajectories, which are solutions that stay inside a safe set, regardless of measurement noise or model uncertainty.

Rosa: So what does that mean for the real world? It means these solutions are guaranteed to comply with hard motion constraints for both position and velocity even if things get noisy or the model is slightly off.

Dev: That’s a significant improvement over some other methods where you might need constant re-tuning when uncertainty pops up. They handle those uncertainties by using an excitation force estimate, which is what you need, and they recommend using an estimator from a prior study to handle the noise in the upper loop.

Taro: So if we think about a real deployment on a device out at sea, how does this guarantee that it won't violate physical limits? Does it stop it from hitting something or exceeding its safe operational bounds?

Title and authors: Rosa: It guarantees that the solutions generated by solving that IGDE stay inside what they define as a forward invariant set, which is basically their safe set. This ensures compliance with hard motion constraints for both position and velocity, even when dealing with measurement noise and model uncertainty <ref:2608.09525#pg2>.

Dev: I’m also interested in how they handle the reference generation without needing a full forecast. They get the motion-constrained velocity reference from the upper loop without resorting to forecasting, only needing a current wave excitation force estimate.

Taro: That sounds like it avoids one of the biggest headaches in control systems, which is when you need perfect future predictions that are impossible to get accurately for dynamic waves. It relies on what’s happening right now.

Rosa: Right, and they use a numerical approximation obtained by controlling a virtual wave energy converter to synthesize that velocity reference, which helps bridge the gap between the theoretical model and what the actual system is doing.

Dev: That brings us to how they actually implement the tracking in the lower loop. They combine feedforward and feedback terms for tracking, which is standard stuff, but they use a filtering sliding mode control, or SM control from twenty-one, as their tracking controller <ref:2608.09525#pg2>.

Taro: Why sliding mode? It’s known for being robust to unmodelled disturbances and measurement noise, right? How much robustness are we talking about when you combine that with the other elements of Symphony?

Rosa: The filtering sliding mode control is chosen specifically because it has this property where the filtering structure helps reject measurement noise and considerably reduces the effects of that noise in the control action <ref:2608.09525#pg4>.

Dev: And when you look at the performance evaluation, they show that Symphony achieves more than ninety percent of the power absorption you get from a spectral optimisation based control solution in most of the tested scenarios. That’s a pretty high number for a nonoptimisation based controller.

Taro: So it’s not just about being simple; it’s actually competitive in terms of performance, but they are still comparing it to those full optimisation methods. What's the trade-off there?

Rosa: The main point is that Symphony is the first nonoptimisation based controller we know of that can provide a velocity reference which respects motion constraints, and this happens independently of WEC model errors and measurement noise <ref:2608.09525#pg4>.

Dev: And when it comes to radiation errors, they’re quite robust. They show less than four percent variation in power absorption for the S3 case with a parametric error in the radiation model <ref:2608.09525#pg9>. That's less than five percent deviation.

Title and authors: Taro: Less than five percent variation is pretty tight when you’re dealing with physical components that might degrade or change over time in the real world. How does that compare to the effort they are using?

Rosa: They show that the effort required by the sliding mode control is four orders of magnitude smaller than the feedforward control term, even across different scenarios with varying radiation errors <ref:2608.09525#pg10>.

Dev: And there’s a security margin called Delta z that they mention, which you can select depending on how robust the tracking controller is. That gives the design flexibility for deployment conditions.

Taro: So, to sum up what we’ve seen from this paper on Symphony: it's a method that uses phase control inspiration to get a hierarchical structure with an IGDE for trajectory generation, which keeps you within safe sets, and then combines it with filtered sliding mode control for robust tracking.

Rosa: And the result is that it gets you close to optimal power absorption—over ninety percent in most cases—while maintaining constraint satisfaction even when things are noisy or uncertain <ref:2608.09525#pg4>.

Dev: It’s a strong position for a real-time system, especially since it avoids the heavy computational load of full optimisation, and they claim this is the first nonoptimisation based controller to achieve close-to-optimal performance in constrained scenarios with minimum recalibration <ref:2608.09525#pg4>.

Taro: So for someone listening who just wants to know what this means for the field, it suggests that you don't necessarily need the most complex optimization framework to get very good results in wave energy control; you can achieve close-to-optimal performance with a simpler design and less reliance on perfect models.

Rosa: Right, so we’ve looked at the Symphony paper today. It shows how using phase control techniques can lead to a robust controller that handles uncertainties better than some alternatives.

Dev: It really highlights the benefit of combining different ideas—the IGDE for trajectory generation and the filtering sliding mode control for tracking—to satisfy those hard motion constraints <ref:2608.09525#pg4>.

Taro: I just wonder about that hard force constraint mechanism they mention in their conclusion, since they suggest designing one next. That feels like the next logical step to move this from a promising paper to something you can actually deploy reliably <ref:2608.09525#pg2>.

Rosa: Definitely. It shows the path forward for making these controllers truly ready for real-world deployment where those hard limits are non-negotiable.

Dev: Yeah, we'll keep an eye on that future work, because getting those constraints right is key to making sure this controller actually works in practice.

The paper's summary: Rosa: So, to wrap up this part, Symphony is essentially this new way to control wave energy devices by drawing inspiration from phase control methods for waves, aiming for simple design but high performance across different sea states and even with noise and model errors.

Dev: Right, so we're talking about this hierarchical structure again—the upper loop handles the feedforward force and a reference velocity based on an excitation force estimate, while the lower loop tracks that using feedback plus feedforward terms.

Taro: And the key move here is solving that implicit Gaussian differential equation to generate trajectory references that stay inside a safe set, which means they respect hard position and velocity constraints even when things get messy.

Rosa: That’s what I mean—it’s about getting those motion-constrained trajectories without needing perfect forecasting or constantly recalibrating the model every time the wave conditions shift.

Dev: And it uses a filtering sliding mode control for that tracking, which is good because it has that structure to reject measurement noise pretty effectively.

Taro: I think what’s really interesting is how they manage the radiation errors; they show less than four percent variation in power absorption even when there's a parametric error in the radiation model.

Rosa: That level of robustness, especially across different sea states, is what makes this approach so promising for real-time operation on a device out at sea.

Dev: And the performance metrics are strong; they’re getting over ninety percent of what you'd expect from those heavy optimization based controllers in most scenarios.

Taro: So, it suggests that we can get very good results without needing the full computational burden of spectral methods, which is a big deal for deployment.

Rosa: Exactly. It’s about finding that balance between simplicity and getting close to optimal performance under real-world constraints.

Dev: Now, the paper also points out some areas for future work; they suggest designing a hard force constraint mechanism as a next step to make it even more reliable in practice.

Taro: That makes sense because while they handle motion constraints well, explicitly defining those hard force limits sounds like the next logical hurdle for making this truly deployable.

The paper's improvements: Tom: So, we're moving on to the specific improvements they propose for Symphony after showing off how it works in principle, and I think those refinements are where the real practical value lies.

Rosa: The paper suggests focusing on a hard force constraint mechanism as a next step because while they handle motion constraints well, explicitly defining those hard force limits sounds like what you need to make this truly ready for deployment.

Dev: That makes sense, because having those explicit boundaries written down helps build that safety case we talked about earlier when the world misbehaves.

Taro: I agree with Rosa; it moves it from a theoretical success in simulation to something that’s guaranteed safe when the real-world forces push things past the expected limits.

Rosa: It’s about taking that general safety set idea and making it a strict rule, which is important for field roboticists like myself who need those hard stop conditions.

Dev: And from a controls standpoint, defining that hard force limit gives us something concrete to work with instead of relying solely on the soft constraints inherent in the Gaussian modulating envelope.

Taro: That gives the system more predictable recovery modes when things get really extreme, like when a wave hits unexpectedly hard.

Rosa: So, they’re essentially tightening up the safety net by adding those explicit force limits on top of what they already have for position and velocity.

Dev: It’s about ensuring that even if the model gets wildly wrong, you still have a baseline physical protection mechanism kicking in without needing a massive recalibration effort.

Taro: And I think that robustness against extreme events is what will really make this system useful for autonomy in dynamic environments where things aren't perfectly known.

Rosa: It sounds like the next phase of development for Symphony isn't just tweaking the math, but grounding it firmly in physical limits that a device has to obey.

Dev: So, if we can nail that force constraint mechanism, we move from a very robust controller to one that’s truly ready for long-term operation under unpredictable sea conditions.

Conclusion: Rosa: So, to wrap up this whole discussion on Symphony: Simple Phase Control for Wave Energy Systems, we're seeing a controller that balances simplicity in design with high performance in real-world conditions while staying under hard motion constraints.

Dev: Yeah, it’s a nonoptimisation based approach that manages to get over ninety percent of the power absorption from those more complex optimization methods across most evaluated sea states.

Taro: For me, what stands out is how little variation in power absorption you see when you introduce radiation model errors; less than four percent for the S3 case is pretty solid for something operating outside a lab.

Rosa: It means this isn't just theoretical stuff; it has shown robustness when the world misbehaves, which is exactly what we need when we put these devices out in the field.

Dev: The paper also points to the future work needing a hard force constraint mechanism, which is crucial for moving this from a promising concept to something that’s deployable without constant manual adjustments.

Taro: I think that focus on those explicit force limits is where we need to go next because it gives us a clearer way to define when the system should just stop or change its strategy under extreme load.

Rosa: Exactly, so while Symphony gets you there with the IGDE and the filtering sliding mode control, defining those hard force limits will be the final piece of making it truly ready for unpredictable operation.

Dev: It’s a solid piece of work on how to get close to optimal performance without needing massive computational power for full optimization.

Taro: Anyway, this paper shows that phase control ideas can lead to a very robust controller when you're dealing with uncertainty in wave energy systems.

Pedro O. Fornaro, Eugenio M. Gelos, Demian Garcia-Violini, John V. Ringwood

Centre for Ocean Energy Research at National University of Ireland, Maynooth · Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Tecnicas at Universidad Nacional de Quilmes, Argentina

eess.SY, cs.SY

Submitted: 2026-08-10

Updated: 2026-08-10

DOI: 10.1109/TCST.2026.3733146

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: Symphony is a novel nonoptimisation-based (NOB) controller inspired by phase control techniques for wave energy devices that achieves close-to-optimal performance across evaluated sea states…

Key concepts

Hierarchical Structure
The controller is organized into two main parts: an upper loop that generates a feedforward force and a velocity reference, and a lower loop that tracks this reference. This separation allows for better control of different aspects of the system's motion.
Implicit Gaussian Differential Equation (IGDE)
This mathematical equation is used to generate desired trajectories for the WEC velocity. Solving it ensures that the resulting trajectories stay within a predefined safe set, which guarantees that physical motion constraints (like maximum position and velocity) are always met.
Filtering Sliding-Mode Control (SM)
The lower loop uses this control method to track the desired velocity reference. It is chosen for its robustness against unmodelled disturbances and measurement noise, effectively filtering out noise while maintaining stable tracking performance.

Terminology

Summary

Symphony is a novel nonoptimisation-based (NOB) controller inspired by phase control techniques for wave energy devices that achieves close-to-optimal performance across evaluated sea states, even in the presence of measurement noise and model uncertainty <ref:2608. p. 0

Where the paper says it

This paper addresses this obstacle by introducing Symphony, a novel nonoptimisation-based (NOB) controller inspired by phase control techniques for wave energy devices. Symphony is a suboptimal control that inherits all the advantages of NOB controllers, such as simplicity of design, implementation, tuning, and use, while additionally providing hard-motion-constrained reference trajectories and close-to-optimal performance across the evaluated sea states, even in the presence of measurement noise and model uncertainty.

09525#pg2>

Controller Architecture

Symphony is designed using a hierarchical structure consisting of an upper loop and a lower loop <ref:2608.09525#pg4>. The upper loop provides a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to an excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate <ref:2608. p. 0

Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg4>. Then, a user-flexible lower loop tracks the desired velocity trajectory by combining feedback and feedforward terms <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Symphony is designed using a hierarchical structure: By relying on an implicit Gaussian differential equation that requires an excitation force estimate, an upper loop provides a close-to-optimal motion-constrained velocity trajectory and a feedforward control term. Then, a user-flexible lower loop tracks the desired velocity trajectory by combining feedback and feedforward terms.

09525#pg4>. Forward-invariant trajectories are obtained by solving an implicit Gaussian differential equation (IGDE) <ref:2608. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The upper loop provides a motion-constrained velocity reference and a feedforward control term. Forward-invariant trajectories are obtained by solving an implicit Gaussian differential equation (IGDE) [15], meaning that IGDE solutions remain inside a forward invariant set (namely a safe set, according to the definition in [16]), complying with hard motion constraints (i.

09525#pg5>.

Constraint Handling Mechanism

The IGDE solutions remain inside a forward invariant set (namely a safe set, according to the definition in [16]), complying with hard motion constraints (i.e., constraints for both position and velocity), even in the presence of measurement noise and model uncertainty <ref:2608. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Forward-invariant trajectories are obtained by solving an implicit Gaussian differential equation (IGDE) [15], meaning that IGDE solutions remain inside a forward invariant set (namely a safe set, according to the definition in [16]), complying with hard motion constraints (i. , constraints for both position and velocity), even in the presence of measurement noise and model uncertainty.

09525#pg5>. The upper loop provides a motion-constrained velocity reference and a feedforward control term <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Symphony is a suboptimal control that inherits all the advantages of NOB controllers, such as simplicity of design, implementation, tuning, and use, while additionally providing hard-motion-constrained reference trajectories and close-to-optimal performance across the evaluated sea states, even in the presence of measurement noise and model uncertainty. Symphony is designed using a hierarchical structure: By relying on an implicit Gaussian differential equation that requires an excitation force estimate, an upper loop provides a close-to-optimal motion-constrained velocity trajectory and a feedforward control term.

09525#pg5>. To synthesize the velocity reference, v˚, a numerical approximation obtained by controlling a virtual WEC model is used <ref:2608. p. 3
Where the paper says it

This is an important property, particularly considering that, to comply with motion constraints, OB controllers require precise model information and forecasting [9][29]. 2) Synthesis of f ˚ u and v ˚: Since (11) is implicit and non-autonomous, to synthesise the velocity reference, v ˚, and provide a feedforward, f ˚ u , a numerical approximation obtained by controlling a virtual WEC model is used.

09525#pg5>.

Tracking Control Implementation

The lower loop implements the generated velocity reference by resorting to a combination of feedforward and feedback terms <ref:2608.09525#pg4>. The filtering sliding-mode (SM) control from [21] is used as a tracking controller, owing to its robustness to unmodelled disturbances and measurement noise <ref:2608. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The feedforward term provides an average control force required to drive the tracking error close to the origin; then, ideally, the tracking control further reduces the tracking error to a small neighbourhood around zero, ultimately depending on the robustness of the employed tracking controller. In this paper, as a tracking controller, the filtering sliding-mode (SM) control from [21] is used, owing to its robustness to unmodelled disturbances and measurement noise.

09525#pg4>.

Performance Evaluation

Symphony performance is assessed in terms of power absorption <ref:2608.09525#pg4>. The results presented demonstrate the potential of Symphony, which achieves, in most of the evaluated scenarios, more than 90% of the power absorption obtained by a spectral (optimisationbased) control solution <ref:2608. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Statistically representative results are obtained using multiple sea-state realisations across varying peak wave periods, considering measurement noise and radiation model uncertainty. The results presented in this paper demonstrate the potential of Symphony, which achieves, in most of the evaluated scenarios, more than 90% of the power absorption obtained by a spectral (optimisationbased) control solution.

09525#pg4>. Symphony is the first NOB controller capable of providing a velocity reference that complies with motion constraints, independently of WEC model errors and measurement noise <ref:2608. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Specifically, Symphony achieves, in most of the evaluated scenarios, more than 90% of the power absorption obtained by a spectral (optimisation-based) control solution. Symphony is the first NOB controller capable of providing a velocity reference that complies with motion constraints, independently of WEC model errors and measurement noise.

09525#pg4>.

Robustness to Uncertainty

Symphony is largely insensitive to radiation errors, with less than 4% variation in power absorption achieved for S3 <ref:2608.09525#pg9>. The SM effort is four orders of magnitude smaller than the feedforward control term, evenly across realisations with varying radiation errors <ref:2608. p. 8

Where the paper says it

The obtained results, presented in Figure 12, are averaged across multiple realisations and computed for varying radiation errors. Notably, the SM effort is four orders of magnitude smaller than the feedforward control term, evenly across realisations with varying radiation errors, evidencing that the

09525#pg10>. A security margin, ∆z, may be selected depending on the robustness of the tracking controller employed <ref:2608. p. 9
Where the paper says it

985m, would suffice to guarantee constraint satisfaction under the evaluated scenarios. Empirically, a security margin, ∆z, may be selected depending on the robustness of the tracking controller employed.

09525#pg10>.

Conclusion

Symphony represents a new competitive alternative for real-time WEC control, not only for its simplicity and robustness, but also for its close-tooptimal constrained performance <ref:2608.09525#pg2>. The obtained results exemplify the efficacy of the proposal <ref:2608. p. 9

Where the paper says it

In addition, unlike in OB formulations, IGDE trajectories are independent of the WEC model and forecast is not required to comply with motion constraints. The obtained results exemplify the efficacy of the proposal: In terms of power absorption, Symphony is the first NOB controller to achieve close-to-optimal performance, in constrained scenarios, with minimum recalibration.

09525#pg4>. The paper concludes that Symphony is the first NOB controller to achieve close-to-optimal performance, in constrained scenarios, with minimum recalibration <ref:2608. p. 9
Where the paper says it

In addition, unlike in OB formulations, IGDE trajectories are independent of the WEC model and forecast is not required to comply with motion constraints. The obtained results exemplify the efficacy of the proposal: In terms of power absorption, Symphony is the first NOB controller to achieve close-to-optimal performance, in constrained scenarios, with minimum recalibration.

09525#pg4>. The authors suggest future development areas include conducting thorough experimental evaluations and designing a hardforce constraint mechanism <ref:2608. p. 9
Where the paper says it

In summary, Symphony represents a new competitive alternative for real-time WEC control, not only for its simplicity and robustness, but also for its close-tooptimal constrained performance. Some critical areas for future development include conducting thorough experimental evaluations, designing a hardforce constraint mechanism, extending the Symphony controller principle of operation for decentralised WEC array control, evaluating its use for multiple-DoF WECs, and developing an electric-energy-maximising Symphony version.

09525#pg2>.

References

[1] B. Reguero, I. p. 9

Where the paper says it

REFERENCES [1] B. Reguero, I.

p. 9
Where the paper says it

REFERENCES [1] B. Reguero, I.

Losada, and F. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Reguero, I. Losada, and F.

p. 9
Where the paper says it

Reguero, I. Losada, and F.

Mendez, “A global wave power resource ´ and its seasonal, interannual and long-term variability,” Applied Energy, vol. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Losada, and F. Mendez, “A global wave power resource ´ and its seasonal, interannual and long-term variability,” Applied Energy, vol.

p. 9
Where the paper says it

Losada, and F. Mendez, “A global wave power resource ´ and its seasonal, interannual and long-term variability,” Applied Energy, vol.

148, pp. 366–380, 2015 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

p. 9
Where the paper says it

Mendez, “A global wave power resource ´ and its seasonal, interannual and long-term variability,” Applied Energy, vol. 366–380, 2015.

09525#pg2>

[2] G. Mork, S. Barstow, A. Kabuth, and M. T. Pontes, “Assessing the global wave energy potential,” in 29th International Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arctic Engineering: Volume 3, ser. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Index Terms—Wave energy, causal control, optimisation, energy maximisation, simplicity. INTRODUCTION Wave energy has emerged as a promising renewable resource, with a global annual potential estimated between 1 and 10 TWh [1].

OMAE2010 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[3] R. Vazquez, W. Cabos, J. C. Nieto-Borge, and C. Guti ´ errez, “Com- plementarity of offshore energy resources on the Spanish coasts: Wind, wave, and photovoltaic energy,” Renewable Energy, vol. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Index Terms—Wave energy, causal control, optimisation, energy maximisation, simplicity. INTRODUCTION Wave energy has emerged as a promising renewable resource, with a global annual potential estimated between 1 and 10 TWh [1].

224 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[4] J. V. Ringwood, S. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Gelos, Demian Garcia-Violini, and John V. Ringwood, Fellow.

Zhan, and N. Faedo, “Empowering wave energy with control technology: Possibilities and pitfalls,” Annual Reviews in Control, vol. p. 0
Where the paper says it

JOURNAL OF LATEX CLASS FILES, VOL. 8, JANUARY 2025 1 Symphony: Simple Phase Control for Wave Energy Systems Pedro O.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

JOURNAL OF LATEX CLASS FILES, VOL. 8, JANUARY 2025 1 Symphony: Simple Phase Control for Wave Energy Systems Pedro O.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Index Terms—Wave energy, causal control, optimisation, energy maximisation, simplicity. INTRODUCTION Wave energy has emerged as a promising renewable resource, with a global annual potential estimated between 1 and 10 TWh [1].

55 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[5] J. V. Ringwood, A. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Gelos, Demian Garcia-Violini, and John V. Ringwood, Fellow.

Merigaud, N. Faedo, and F. Fusco, “An analytical and numerical sensitivity and robustness analysis of wave energy control systems,” IEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology, vol. p. 0
Where the paper says it

JOURNAL OF LATEX CLASS FILES, VOL. 8, JANUARY 2025 1 Symphony: Simple Phase Control for Wave Energy Systems Pedro O.

28 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[6] J. V. Ringwood, G. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Gelos, Demian Garcia-Violini, and John V. Ringwood, Fellow.

Bacelli, and F. Fusco, “Energy-maximizing control of wave-energy converters: The development of control system technology to optimize their operation,” IEEE Control Systems, vol. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Impedance matching principle In wave energy systems, the absorbed mechanical energy is employed for the development of mechanical energy maximising control strategies. For system (4), the integral of converted power over the interval T P R` is given by: JT “ ´ ż T fuvpτ qdτ.

34 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[7] N. Faedo, S. Olaya, and J. V. Ringwood, “Optimal control, MPC and MPC-like algorithms for wave energy systems: An overview,” IFAC Journal of Systems and Control, vol. p. 0

Where the paper says it

JOURNAL OF LATEX CLASS FILES, VOL. 8, JANUARY 2025 1 Symphony: Simple Phase Control for Wave Energy Systems Pedro O.

1 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[8] D. Garcia-Violini and J. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Fornaro, Eugenio M. Gelos, Demian Garcia-Violini, and John V.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Fornaro, Eugenio M. Gelos, Demian Garcia-Violini, and John V.

V. Ringwood, “Energy maximising robust control for spectral and pseudospectral methods with application to wave energy systems,” International Journal of Control, vol. p. 0
Where the paper says it

This is because control algorithms are essential to maximising energy capture, while managing operational constraints to protect the device from damage [7]. Common optimisationbased (OB) controllers, such as model predictive control, spectral methods [8], and moment-based algorithms [7][9], provide, by resorting to numerical routines, constrained energy-maximising solutions.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

This is because control algorithms are essential to maximising energy capture, while managing operational constraints to protect the device from damage [7]. Common optimisationbased (OB) controllers, such as model predictive control, spectral methods [8], and moment-based algorithms [7][9], provide, by resorting to numerical routines, constrained energy-maximising solutions.

94 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[9] N. Faedo, Y. Pena-Sanchez, and J. V. Ringwood, “Receding-horizon energy-maximising optimal control of wave energy systems based on moments,” IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy, vol. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Specifically, ∆ is used to represent parametric radiation uncertainty. Impedance matching principle In wave energy systems, the absorbed mechanical energy is employed for the development of mechanical energy maximising control strategies.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

Specifically, ∆ is used to represent parametric radiation uncertainty. Impedance matching principle In wave energy systems, the absorbed mechanical energy is employed for the development of mechanical energy maximising control strategies.

12 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[10] D. Garc´ıa-Violini, N. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Gelos, is with Centre for Ocean Energy Research (COER), National University of Ireland, Maynooth. Demian Garc ´ ´ıa-Violini is with Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Cient´ıficas y Tecnicas (CONICET), with Departamento de Ciencia y tec- ´ nolog´ıa, Universidad Nacional de Quilmes, Argentina, and with the Centre for Ocean Energy Research (COER), Maynooth University, Ireland.

Faedo, F. Jaramillo-Lopez, and J. V. Ringwood, “Simple controllers for wave energy devices compared,” Journal of Marine Science and Engineering, vol. p. 0
Where the paper says it

JOURNAL OF LATEX CLASS FILES, VOL. 8, JANUARY 2025 1 Symphony: Simple Phase Control for Wave Energy Systems Pedro O.

8 <ref:2608.09525#pg2>

[11] D. Garcia-Violini, Y. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Fornaro, Eugenio M. Gelos, Demian Garcia-Violini, and John V.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Fornaro, Eugenio M. Gelos, Demian Garcia-Violini, and John V.

Pena-Sanchez, N. Faedo, and J. V. Ringwood, “An energy-maximising linear time invariant controller (LiTe-Con) for wave energy devices,” IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy, vol. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Abstract—Despite significant advancements in controlling wave energy converters, efficiently achieving real-time energymaximising control remains a challenge. This paper addresses this obstacle by introducing Symphony, a novel nonoptimisation-based (NOB) controller inspired by phase control techniques for wave energy devices.

11 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[12] D. Garcia-Violini, Y. Pena-Sanchez, N. Faedo, F. Ferri, and J. V. ˜ Ringwood, “A broadband time-varying energy maximising control for wave energy systems (LiTe-Con+): Framework and experimental assessment,” IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy, vol. p. 9

Where the paper says it

In summary, Symphony represents a new competitive alternative for real-time WEC control, not only for its simplicity and robustness, but also for its close-tooptimal constrained performance. Some critical areas for future development include conducting thorough experimental evaluations, designing a hardforce constraint mechanism, extending the Symphony controller principle of operation for decentralised WEC array control, evaluating its use for multiple-DoF WECs, and developing an electric-energy-maximising Symphony version.

14 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[13] G. Bacelli, V. Nevarez, R. G. Coe, and D. G. Wilson, “Feedback resonating control for a wave energy converter,” IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, vol. p. 0

Where the paper says it

JOURNAL OF LATEX CLASS FILES, VOL. 8, JANUARY 2025 1 Symphony: Simple Phase Control for Wave Energy Systems Pedro O.

56 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[14] F. Fusco and J. V. Ringwood, “A simple and effective real-time controller for wave energy converters,” IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy, vol. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Ringwood, Fellow. Abstract—Despite significant advancements in controlling wave energy converters, efficiently achieving real-time energymaximising control remains a challenge.

4 <ref:2608.09525#pg2>

[15] Jorge Anderson and Pedro Fornaro and Paul F. Puleston and John V. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Fornaro, Eugenio M. Gelos, Demian Garcia-Violini, and John V.

Ringwood, “A Causal Approach to Hard Constrained Control of Wave Energy Systems based on an Implicit Gaussian Differential Equation,” in 64rd IEEE Conference on Decision and Control, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Symphony is a suboptimal control that inherits all the advantages of NOB controllers, such as simplicity of design, implementation, tuning, and use, while additionally providing hard-motion-constrained reference trajectories and close-to-optimal performance across the evaluated sea states, even in the presence of measurement noise and model uncertainty. Symphony is designed using a hierarchical structure: By relying on an implicit Gaussian differential equation that requires an excitation force estimate, an upper loop provides a close-to-optimal motion-constrained velocity trajectory and a feedforward control term.

09525#pg2>

[16] Xu, Xiangru and Tabuada, Paulo and Grizzle, Jessy W. and Ames, Aaron D., “Robustness of Control Barrier Functions for Safety Critical Control,” IFAC-PapersOnLine, vol. p. 9

Where the paper says it

In summary, Symphony represents a new competitive alternative for real-time WEC control, not only for its simplicity and robustness, but also for its close-tooptimal constrained performance. Some critical areas for future development include conducting thorough experimental evaluations, designing a hardforce constraint mechanism, extending the Symphony controller principle of operation for decentralised WEC array control, evaluating its use for multiple-DoF WECs, and developing an electric-energy-maximising Symphony version.

p. 9
Where the paper says it

In summary, Symphony represents a new competitive alternative for real-time WEC control, not only for its simplicity and robustness, but also for its close-tooptimal constrained performance. Some critical areas for future development include conducting thorough experimental evaluations, designing a hardforce constraint mechanism, extending the Symphony controller principle of operation for decentralised WEC array control, evaluating its use for multiple-DoF WECs, and developing an electric-energy-maximising Symphony version.

48 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[17] Y. Pena-Sanchez, C. Windt, J. Davidson, and J. V. Ringwood, “A critical comparison of excitation force estimators for wave-energy devices,” IEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology, vol. p. 0

Where the paper says it

JOURNAL OF LATEX CLASS FILES, VOL. 8, JANUARY 2025 1 Symphony: Simple Phase Control for Wave Energy Systems Pedro O.

28 <ref:2608.09525#pg2>

[18] P. Fornaro, F. p. 0

Where the paper says it

8, JANUARY 2025 1 Symphony: Simple Phase Control for Wave Energy Systems Pedro O. Fornaro, Eugenio M.

D. Mosquera, P. F. Puleston, C. A. Evangelista, and J. V Ringwood, “Homogeneous filtering unknown input observer for wave energy applications,” in 63rd IEEE Conference on Decision and Control, Milan, Italy <ref:2608. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Specifically, two SM-based filtering algorithms for fex estimation and velocity tracking are presented in the following. 1) Wave excitation force estimation: To robustly estimate the wave excitation force, a homogeneous SM-based unknown input observer (HSMO), presented in [18], is used.

09525#pg2>

[19] Merigaud, Alexis and Ringwood, John V., “Towards realistic non-linear ´ receding-horizon spectral control of wave energy converters,” Control Engineering Practice, vol. 81 <ref:2608. p. 0

Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[20] N. Faedo, F. D. Mosquera, E. Pasta, G. Papini, Y. Pena-Sanchez, ˜C A Evangelista, F Ferri, J V Ringwood, and P Puleston, “Experimental assessment of combined sliding mode & moment-based control (SM2C) for arrays of wave energy conversion systems,” Control Engineering Practice, vol. p. 0

Where the paper says it

JOURNAL OF LATEX CLASS FILES, VOL. 8, JANUARY 2025 1 Symphony: Simple Phase Control for Wave Energy Systems Pedro O.

144 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[21] Pedro Fornaro and Facundo D. Mosquera and Carolina A Evangelista and Paul F Puleston and John V Ringwood, “A Filtering SuperTwisting Controller with Noise Rejection,” in 64th IEEE Conference on Decision and Control, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil <ref:2608. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Gelos, Demian Garcia-Violini, and John V. Ringwood, Fellow.

09525#pg2>

[22] J. Falnes, Ocean Waves and Oscillating Systems: Linear Interaction. p. 0

Where the paper says it

For instance, by reducing production variability, the integration of wave energy with other renewables could enhance energy system stability, resilience, and grid penetration. Despite its promise, high capital and operational costs associated with deployment in the harsh ocean environment hinder the large-scale commercialisation of wave energy converters (WEC) [4].

Cambridge University Press, 2002 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[23] W. Cummins, “The impulse response function and ship motions,” Schiffstechnik, vol. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Following this reasoning, the control-oriented model used in this paper is obtained by applying Newton’s second law, together with linear hydrodynamic assumptions [22] to a one-degree-of-freedom (1-DoF) WEC: mv9 “ fex ` fu ´ fhpzq ´ ˜frpv, v9q ` ∆, (1) where z, v, and v9, represent the WEC displacement, velocity and acceleration, respectively. Also, m is the mass of the device, fex is the wave excitation force, fu is the control force, fhpzq “ kzz, is the restoring force (with kz being the restoring coefficient), ∆ represents model uncertainty, and ˜frpv, v9q, is the radiation force defined [23] as: ˜frptq “ m8v9ptq ` ż t t0 hrpt ´ τ qvpτ qdτ looooooooooomooooooooooon frptq , (2) where m8 is the infinite frequency asymptote of the radiation added-mass and hrptq is the impulse response of the linear convolution operator, which describes the memory effect of the fluid response [24].

9 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[24] T. Perez and T. I. Fossen, “Time-vs. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Ringwood, Fellow. Abstract—Despite significant advancements in controlling wave energy converters, efficiently achieving real-time energymaximising control remains a challenge.

frequency-domain identification of ´parametric radiation force models for marine structures at zero speed,” Model. p. 6
Where the paper says it

However, by analysing S1 time domain variables, it can be noted that designing gpz, vq with vM “ 2. 3m{s reduces both the maximum speed limits and the rapid variations in the control force (see Figure 6).

Identif. Control, vol. 29 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[25] J. Scruggs, “On the causal power generation limit for a vibratory energy harvester in broadband stochastic response,” Journal of Intelligent Material Systems and Structures, vol. p. 0

Where the paper says it

JOURNAL OF LATEX CLASS FILES, VOL. 8, JANUARY 2025 1 Symphony: Simple Phase Control for Wave Energy Systems Pedro O.

21 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[26] A. Babarit, M. Guglielmi, and A. H. Clement, “Declutching control of ´a wave energy converter,” Ocean Engineering, vol. p. 0

Where the paper says it

JOURNAL OF LATEX CLASS FILES, VOL. 8, JANUARY 2025 1 Symphony: Simple Phase Control for Wave Energy Systems Pedro O.

36 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[27] J. Henriques, L. Gato, A. Falcao, E. Robles, and F.-X. Fa ˜ y, “Latching ¨ control of a floating oscillating-water-column wave energy converter,” Renewable Energy, vol. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Index Terms—Wave energy, causal control, optimisation, energy maximisation, simplicity. INTRODUCTION Wave energy has emerged as a promising renewable resource, with a global annual potential estimated between 1 and 10 TWh [1].

90 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[28] G. Bacelli and J. V Ringwood, “A geometric tool for the analysis of position and force constraints in wave energy converters,” Ocean Engineering, vol. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Ringwood, Fellow. Abstract—Despite significant advancements in controlling wave energy converters, efficiently achieving real-time energymaximising control remains a challenge.

65 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[29] Lin, Zechuan and Huang, Xuanrui and Xiao, Xi, “Fast model predictive control system for wave energy converters with wave tank tests,” IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol. 70 <ref:2608. p. 0

Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[30] Fornaro, Pedro and Lin, Zechuan and Gelos Eugenio and Ringwood John V., “Symphony: The ultimate wave energy controller? p. 0

Where the paper says it

Abstract—Despite significant advancements in controlling wave energy converters, efficiently achieving real-time energymaximising control remains a challenge. This paper addresses this obstacle by introducing Symphony, a novel nonoptimisation-based (NOB) controller inspired by phase control techniques for wave energy devices.

” in EWTEC European wave and tidal energy Conference, Madeira, Portugal <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[31] Fusco, Francesco and Ringwood, John V., “Hierarchical Robust Control of Oscillating Wave Energy Converters With Uncertain Dynamics,” IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy, vol. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Ringwood, Fellow. Abstract—Despite significant advancements in controlling wave energy converters, efficiently achieving real-time energymaximising control remains a challenge.

5 <ref:2608.09525#pg2>

[32] A. Levant and M. Livne, “Robust exact filtering differentiators,” Eur. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Hence, using a sufficiently robust tracking controller (such that v ˚ « v˜ holds), f ˚ u is the desired feedforward control action, and v ˚ is the desired velocity reference. In this paper, the robust controller employed to track v ˚ (14), is the filtering super-twisting (FST), presented in [21], and further discussed in Subsection III-C.

J. Control, vol. 55 <ref:2608.09525#pg2>

[33] F. Mosquera, N Faedo, P Puleston, and C Evangelista, “Experimental assessment of generalised super-twisting control for optimal reference tracking in wave energy systems,” IFAC-PapersOnLine, vol. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Hence, using a sufficiently robust tracking controller (such that v ˚ « v˜ holds), f ˚ u is the desired feedforward control action, and v ˚ is the desired velocity reference. In this paper, the robust controller employed to track v ˚ (14), is the filtering super-twisting (FST), presented in [21], and further discussed in Subsection III-C.

56 <ref:2608.09525#pg2>

[34] P. Fornaro, T. p. 0

Where the paper says it

8, JANUARY 2025 1 Symphony: Simple Phase Control for Wave Energy Systems Pedro O. Fornaro, Eugenio M.

Niclas, and J. V Ringwood, “A smooth higher-order super-twisting sliding mode controller,” in 18th International Workshop on Variable Structure Systems (VSS) (In press), Exeter, UK <ref:2608. p. 4
Where the paper says it

FST, used for velocity tracking in both Symphony upper and lower loops, requires a relative degree (ρ) of the sliding variable (v´v ˚), with respect to the control action, of 11 . In FST, chattering is reduced by using a higher-order version of the ST controller, which includes (i) a filtering structure to reject measurement noise, νv, satisfying ť νv ă εv P R` as detailed in [21][32][34], and (ii) the discontinuous action in the second time derivative of the control force.

09525#pg2>

[35] Y. V Orlov, Ed., Discontinuous Systems, ser. p. 4

Where the paper says it

FST, used for velocity tracking in both Symphony upper and lower loops, requires a relative degree (ρ) of the sliding variable (v´v ˚), with respect to the control action, of 11 . In FST, chattering is reduced by using a higher-order version of the ST controller, which includes (i) a filtering structure to reject measurement noise, νv, satisfying ť νv ă εv P R` as detailed in [21][32][34], and (ii) the discontinuous action in the second time derivative of the control force.

SpringerLink. London: Springer London, 2009 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[36] A. Levant and M. Livne, “Weighted homogeneity and robustness of sliding mode control,” Automatica, vol. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The feedforward term provides an average control force required to drive the tracking error close to the origin; then, ideally, the tracking control further reduces the tracking error to a small neighbourhood around zero, ultimately depending on the robustness of the employed tracking controller. In this paper, as a tracking controller, the filtering sliding-mode (SM) control from [21] is used, owing to its robustness to unmodelled disturbances and measurement noise.

72 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[37] J. Mendoza-Avila, D. Efimov, L Fridman, and J A Moreno, “On stability of homogeneous systems in presence of parasitic dynamics,” IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control, vol. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Although the exact figure for extractable wave power remains debated [2], it is agreed that wave energy systems may play a critical role in reducing carbon emissions by contributing to the energy mix [3]. For instance, by reducing production variability, the integration of wave energy with other renewables could enhance energy system stability, resilience, and grid penetration.

68 <ref:2608. p. 0
Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[38] J. H. Todalshaug, G. S. Asgeirsson, E Hj almarsson, J Maillet, ´P Moller, P Pires, M Gu ¨ erinel, and M Lopes, “Tank testing of ´an inherently phase-controlled wave energy converter,” International Journal of Marine Energy <ref:2608. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Although the solution in (9) is elegant, this frequency domain approach is not realisable for a panchromatic wave excitation force, since the analytic continuation of (9) cannot be synthesised as a causal controller [25]. However, by replacing (9) in (8), it is possible to obtain the force-to-velocity closed-loop transfer function: Tpjωq “ V Fex pjωq “ 1 2 RetZpjωqu , (10) from which the following conditions, employed for the design of controllers for WECs, may be stated: (C1) Phase condition: Given that 1{2 RetZpjωqu is real and even, there is no exchange of reactive energy between fexptq and the controlled WEC, and the optimal WEC velocity is (frequency-wise) proportional to the wave excitation force.

09525#pg2>

[39] K. F Hasselmann et al., “Measurements of wind-wave growth and swell decay during the joint north sea wave project (JONSWAP),” Ergaenzungsheft zur Deutschen Hydrographischen Zeitschrift, 1973 <ref:2608. p. 0

Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[40] F. D. Mosquera, P. Fornaro, P. p. 0

Where the paper says it

8, JANUARY 2025 1 Symphony: Simple Phase Control for Wave Energy Systems Pedro O. Fornaro, Eugenio M.

F Puleston, C A Evangelista, and J V Ringwood, “A sliding mode-based tracking observer for excitation force estimation in wave energy systems,” in Conference on Control Technology and Applications (CCTA), Newcastle, UK <ref:2608. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Specifically, two SM-based filtering algorithms for fex estimation and velocity tracking are presented in the following. 1) Wave excitation force estimation: To robustly estimate the wave excitation force, a homogeneous SM-based unknown input observer (HSMO), presented in [18], is used.

09525#pg2>

[41] B. Reguero, I. Losada, and F. Mendez, “A global wave power resource ´ and its seasonal, interannual and long-term variability,” Applied Energy, vol. 148 <ref:2608. p. 0

Where the paper says it

An upper loop generates a feedforward control force and a suboptimal velocity reference that is proportional to a wave excitation force estimate, effectively phase-matching the WEC velocity with the wave excitation force estimate. Then, arXiv:2608.

09525#pg2>

[42] G. Mork, S Barstow, A Kabuth, and M T Pontes, “Assessing the global wave energy potential,” in 29th International Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arctic Engineering: Volume 3 <ref:2608. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Index Terms—Wave energy, causal control, optimisation, energy maximisation, simplicity. INTRODUCTION Wave energy has emerged as a promising renewable resource, with a global annual potential estimated between 1 and 10 TWh [1].

09525#pg2>

[43] R. Vazquez, W. Cabos, J. C Nieto-Borge, and C Guti ´ errez, “Com- plementarity of offshore energy resources on the Spanish coasts: Wind, wave, and photovoltaic energy,” Renewable Energy <ref:2608. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Index Terms—Wave energy, causal control, optimisation, energy maximisation, simplicity. INTRODUCTION Wave energy has emerged as a promising renewable resource, with a global annual potential estimated between 1 and 10 TWh [1].

09525#pg2>

[44] J. V. Ringwood, S Zhan, and N Faedo, “Empowering wave energy with control technology: Possibilities and pitfalls,” Annual Reviews in Control, vol. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Index Terms—Wave energy, causal control, optimisation, energy maximisation, simplicity. INTRODUCTION Wave energy has emerged as a promising renewable resource, with a global annual potential estimated between 1 and 10 TWh [1].

55 <ref:2608.09525#pg2>

[45] J. V. Ringwood, A Merigaud, N Faedo, and F Fusco, “An analytical and numerical sensitivity and robustness analysis of wave energy control systems,” IEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology, vol. p. 0

Where the paper says it

JOURNAL OF LATEX CLASS FILES, VOL. 8, JANUARY 2025 1 Symphony: Simple Phase Control for Wave Energy Systems Pedro O.

28 <ref:2608.09525#pg2>

[46] J. V. Ringwood, G Bacelli, and F Fusco, “Energy-maximizing control of wave-energy converters: The development of control system technology to optimize their operation,” IEEE Control Systems, vol. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Impedance matching principle In wave energy systems, the absorbed mechanical energy is employed for the development of mechanical energy maximising control strategies. For system (4), the integral of converted power over the interval T P R` is given by: JT “ ´ ż T fuvpτ qdτ.

34 <ref:2608.09525#pg2>

[47] N Faedo, S Olaya, and J V Ringwood, “Optimal control, MPC and MPC-like algorithms for wave energy systems: An overview,” IFAC Journal of Systems and Control, vol. 1 <ref:2608.09525#pg2>

[48] D. Garcia-Violini and J. V. Ringwood, “Energy maximising robust control for spectral and pseudospectral methods with application to wave energy systems,” International Journal of Control, vol. 94 <ref:2608.09525#pg2>

[49] N Faedo, Y Pena-Sanchez, and J. V. Ringwood, “Receding-horizon energy-maximising optimal control of wave energy systems based on moments,” IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy, vol. 12 <ref:2608.09525#pg2>

[50] D. Garc´ıa-Violini, N Faedo, F Jaramillo-Lopez, and J V Ringwood, “Simple controllers for wave energy devices compared,” Journal of Marine Science and Engineering, vol. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Demian Garc ´ ´ıa-Violini is with Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Cient´ıficas y Tecnicas (CONICET), with Departamento de Ciencia y tec- ´ nolog´ıa, Universidad Nacional de Quilmes, Argentina, and with the Centre for Ocean Energy Research (COER), Maynooth University, Ireland. Ringwood is with Centre for Ocean Energy Research, National University of Ireland, Maynooth.

8 <ref:2608.09525#pg2>

[51] D. Garcia-Violini, Y Pena-Sanchez, N Faedo, and J V Ringwood, “An energy-maximising linear time invariant controller (LiTe-Con) for wave energy devices,” IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy, vol. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Abstract—Despite significant advancements in controlling wave energy converters, efficiently achieving real-time energymaximising control remains a challenge. This paper addresses this obstacle by introducing Symphony, a novel nonoptimisation-based (NOB) controller inspired by phase control techniques for wave energy devices.

11 <ref:2608.09525#pg2>

[52] D. Garcia-Violini, Y Pena-Sanchez, N Faedo, F Ferri, and J V Ringwood, “A broadband time-varying energy maximising control for wave energy systems (LiTe-Con+): Framework and experimental assessment,” IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy, vol. p. 9

Where the paper says it

In summary, Symphony represents a new competitive alternative for real-time WEC control, not only for its simplicity and robustness, but also for its close-tooptimal constrained performance. Some critical areas for future development include conducting thorough experimental evaluations, designing a hardforce constraint mechanism, extending the Symphony controller principle of operation for decentralised WEC array control, evaluating its use for multiple-DoF WECs, and developing an electric-energy-maximising Symphony version.

14 <ref:2608.09525#pg2>

[53] G. Bacelli, V Nevarez, R G Coe, and D G Wilson, “Feedback resonating control for a wave energy converter,” IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, vol. p. 0

Where the paper says it

JOURNAL OF LATEX CLASS FILES, VOL. 8, JANUARY 2025 1 Symphony: Simple Phase Control for Wave Energy Systems Pedro O.

56 <ref:2608.09525#pg2>

[54] F. Fusco and J V Ringwood, “A simple and effective real-time controller for wave energy converters,” IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy, vol. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Ringwood, Fellow. Abstract—Despite significant advancements in controlling wave energy converters, efficiently achieving real-time energymaximising control remains a challenge.

4 <ref:2608.09525#pg2>

[57] Jorge Anderson and Pedro Fornaro and Paul F Puleston and John V Ringwood, “A Causal Approach to Hard Constrained Control of Wave Energy Systems based on an Implicit Gaussian Differential Equation,” in 64rd IEEE Conference on Decision and Control, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil <ref:2608.09525#pg2>

[58] Xu, Xiangru and Tabuada, Paulo and Grizzle Jessy W. and Ames Aaron D., “Robustness of Control Barrier Functions for Safety Critical Control,” IFAC-PapersOnLine, vol. 48 <ref:2608.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Synchronized Trajectory Reference Generation: The system can generate constrained position and velocity references by numerically solving an implicit Gaussian differential equation (IGDE), which remain inside a forward invariant set (namely a safe set, according to the definition in [16]), complying with hard motion constraints.

  2. Model-Uncertainty Robustness: The control system can provide motion-constrained references, independently of ˆfex (which is typically model dependent), which is an advantage over optimization-based controllers that require precise model information and forecasting.

  3. Noise Rejection in Control Loops: The lower loop employs a filtering sliding mode (SM) control, specifically the filtering super-twisting (FST) controller, to ensure robustness against disturbances and noise, as it includes a filtering structure to reject measurement noise and considerably reduces the effects of measurement noise.

  4. Power Absorption Maximization: The system can achieve more than 90% of the power absorption obtained by a spectral (optimisation-based) control solution in most evaluated scenarios, providing a high level of performance for real-time operation.

  5. Constraint Satisfaction Guarantee: By using the Gaussian modulating envelope (GME), the controller guarantees satisfaction of position and velocity constraints, resulting in an average exceedance per sample of only 0.025%.

  6. Radiation Model Insensitivity: The system demonstrates robustness to radiation model errors, showing that Symphony remains close-to-optimal even with a parametric error in the radiation model, achieving less than 4% variation in power absorption for S3.

Abstract

Despite significant advancements in controlling wave energy converters, efficiently achieving real-time energy-maximising control remains a challenge. This paper addresses this obstacle by introducing Symphony, a novel non-optimisation-based (NOB) controller inspired by phase control techniques for wave energy devices. Symphony is a suboptimal control that inherits all the advantages of NOB controllers, such as simplicity of design, implementation, tuning, and use, while additionally providing hard-motion-constrained reference trajectories and close-to-optimal performance across the evaluated sea states, even in the presence of measurement noise and model uncertainty. Symphony is designed using a hierarchical structure: By relying on an implicit Gaussian differential equation that requires an excitation force estimate, an upper loop provides a close-to-optimal motion-constrained velocity trajectory and a feedforward control term. Then, a user-flexible lower loop tracks the desired velocity trajectory by combining feedback and feedforward terms. In this paper, Symphony performance is assessed in terms of power absorption. Statistically representative results are obtained using multiple sea-state realisations across varying peak wave periods, considering measurement noise and radiation model uncertainty. The results presented in this paper demonstrate the potential of Symphony, which achieves, in most of the evaluated scenarios, more than 90% of the power absorption obtained by a spectral (optimisation-based) control solution.

Related papers