Emergence of Bogoliubov Fermi Surfaces in hybrid Al/InAs heterostructures
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Emergence of Bogoliubov Fermi Surfaces in hybrid Al/InAs heterostructures".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Emergence of Bogoliubov Fermi Surfaces in hybrid Al/InAs heterostructures investigates microwave electrodynamics in proximitized two-dimensional electron gases to directly probe superfluid stiffness and reveal a gapless superconducting phase characterized by the emergence of Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces Experimental Setup and Measurement Technique The study utilizes lumped-element resonators with inductor wires oriented relative to an in-plane magnetic field to directly probe the superfluid stiffness via the kinetic inductance This method allows for the direct measurement of anisotropic gapless superconductivity in hybrid systems The resonance frequency shift, which is proportional to the diagonal components of the stiffness tensor Dxx, serves as a direct, thermodynamic probe of Dxx(B) Specifically, the shift in microwave resonance frequency f0 = 2π/p(Lg + Lk)C−1 is lowered by the kinetic inductance Lk Theoretical Framework of Bogoliubov Fermi Surfaces Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces (BFS) are zero-energy Bogoliubov quasiparticles, coherent superpositions of electrons and holes, residing on two isolated segments on opposite sides of the original Fermi surface These BFS correspond to a gapless superconducting phase that is induced by an in-plane magnetic field and stabilized by the resilience of the parent superconductor The microscopic calculations capture the observed anisotropy driven by the interplay of Zeeman and orbital Fulde-Ferrell effects The stability of these phases is mediated by an in-plane magnetic field penetrating the interface between the parent superconductor and the 2D layer, leading to an orbital Fulde-Ferrell (OFF) type of phase Anisotropic Response and Field Dependence The response becomes strongly anisotropic and exhibits a non-monotonic dependence as the field increases, which is a definitive signature of BFS selectively suppressing the supercurrent response The impact on the resonance frequency depends on the angle between the field B and the current J in the inductor, being stronger when B ⊥ J (orange curves) The maximum suppression of the superfluid stiffness occurs around θ =90◦ and 270◦ due to the enlarging of the BFS Role of Disorder and Phase Diagram The enhancement in anisotropy is attributed to the critical role of disorder in gapless superconducting phases, where scattering of zero-energy Bogoliubov quasiparticles against the local disorder landscape provides a strong mechanism for further suppressing the stiffness The total ground state energy is described by EtotGS(q) = EBCSGS + EBFSGS(q + qD) + βq + qD2 + 2DAlq2, where the second term describes the change of behavior due to the formation of the BFS The phase diagram shows successive transitions: gapped phase → 1-BFS → 2-BFS as summarized in Fig.
Kai: S9(k) Implications for Topological Matter The experimental stabilization and direct measurement of this gapless phase carry profound implications for the understanding of topological quantum matter Demonstrating strong orbital effects in Al/InAs heterostructures introduces critical new considerations into the quest for Majorana fermions in nanowires tailored from these platforms The results establish microwave stiffness as a powerful thermodynamic probe capable of uncovering similar unconventional and topological phases in strongly correlated layered materials Understanding anisotropic momentum relaxation provides crucial microscopic insight into nonreciprocal transport phenomena, such as the superconducting diode effect Theoretical Modeling of Gapless States The BdG Hamiltonian in the Nambu basis, when considering both Zeeman and SOC effects, yields energy spectra that depend on the relative magnitude of VZ and VD The resulting Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces develop when VZ = ∆0, leading to banana shapes that are significantly anisotropic The minimal momentum q required for the development of the BFS is qc = ∆0/ħvF The total ground state energy is given by EtotGS(q) = EBCSGS + EBFSGS(q + qD) + βq + qD2 + 2DAlq2 Model Comparison and Parameter Extraction The fitting of experimental data to the theoretical models, including the combined Zeeman/Orbital scenario, yields critical parameters such as Bc1 = 0.068 T and Bc2 = 0.093 T for resonators a and b The best fit within each scenario is provided by the set of parameters that globally minimize the error The anisotropy magnitude is roughly a factor of four larger than predicted for a pristine system, highlighting the critical role of disorder The phenomenological anisotropy factor γ is introduced to account for disorder-driven momentum relaxation, showing that the orientation of the supercurrent flow intersects the emergent Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces The paper presents the first clear observations of a gapless phase characterized by BFS in a hybrid superconductor/semiconductor platform The distinct, non-monotonic hook-like evolution of the kinetic inductance cannot be captured by standard pair-breaking mechanisms but serves as a definitive macroscopic fingerprint of zero-energy Bogoliubov quasiparticles This work establishes microwave stiffness as a sensitive probe of anisotropic gapless superconductivity in hybrid systems The findings suggest that the interplay of finite-momentum pairing, spin-orbit coupling, and emergent Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces is a unifying thread across a broad frontier of modern condensed matter physics Supplementary Information Details The supplementary information details the fabrication of the devices using molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) resulting in a clean interface between the aluminum top layer and the underlying InAs 2DEG The measurement routine involves precise determination of resonance frequency free from vortex-induced dissipation by heating above Tc and cooling down The material parameters used, such as the effective mass m = 0.0403 me and carrier density n2D = 8.5 ×1011 cm−2, are extracted from literature and independent cyclotron resonance measurements The model incorporates the Doppler shift VD(B) = ηDevF dB ≈ 10 ηDB
meV/T: using d = 15 nm as distance between the layers The analysis confirms that the transition at zero temperature occurs once the Zeeman energy equals the induced gap The model successfully captures the distinct functional form of the anisotropic response through analytical models derived from Eq.
Mira: (S44) The results are equivalent to calculating the diamagnetic component of the current response function, which is an alternative procedure to calculate the superfluid stiffness The analysis shows that temperature dependence is important since thermal quasiparticles increase losses and decrease the superfluid density The model establishes only that the transition at zero temperature occurs once the Zeeman energy equals the induced gap The model provides additional information on kBT /∆0, showing that the transition is sharper if kBT /∆0 ≪ 1 while it gets smoother at kBT /∆0 ≳ 0.25 The anisotropy is caused by the effect of disorder depending on the presence or absence of Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces in the direction of the current The model successfully captures the distinct functional form of the anisotropic response through analytical models derived from Eq.
Kai: (S44) The results are equivalent to calculating the diamagnetic component of the current response function, which is an alternative procedure to calculate the superfluid stiffness The model provides additional information on kBT /∆0, showing that the transition is sharper if kBT /∆0 ≪ 1 while it gets smoother at kBT /∆0 ≳ 0.
Title and authors: Kai: So, we’re talking about this paper now, "Emergence of Bogoliubov Fermi Surfaces in hybrid Al/InAs heterostructures". It’s from Feyrer and his team. We need to talk about what they actually built and measured here at the core of it.
Mira: Yeah, I think the title itself points toward something really specific. They're looking at how these two materials interact when we put an in-plane magnetic field on them, trying to see if that field can induce a kind of gapless state.
Lev: From my side, I’m wondering what kind of fabrication fidelity they achieved with this hybrid structure, because those interface effects are where things usually get messy and hard to control in real hardware.
Kai: Right, the setup involves these lumped-element resonators with inductor wires oriented against the magnetic field to measure the kinetic inductance. It’s about directly probing that superfluid stiffness.
Mira: Exactly, they use this resonance frequency shift as a direct thermodynamic probe for the diagonal component of that stiffness tensor, Dxx at a given magnetic field B. That’s a really direct link between what we see with microwaves and the underlying superconducting properties.
Lev: If we were trying to build something like this on a real chip, how much overhead would the measurement setup itself add to the actual signal you're trying to extract from the material?
Kai: Well, they use these resonators tuned at frequencies like four point nine GHz and five point seven GHz, and they have this large Hall bar structure for DC access and heating <ref:2608.06553#pg1>. They’re using those measurements to get a picture of how the stiffness changes with the angle between the current density J and that magnetic field B.
Mira: And what’s really interesting is that they see a nonmonotonic dependence on the field strength, which suggests something beyond simple pair-breaking mechanisms are at play here.
Lev: A nonmonotonic response sounds complicated to model on real hardware because you usually expect a monotonic suppression of superconductivity as you increase the field. What mechanism would cause that dip or peak?
Kai: They attribute that to the emergence of Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces, which are these zero-energy quasiparticles residing on two separate segments of the original Fermi surface.
Mira: So, these Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces correspond to a gapless superconducting phase. It’s induced by that in-plane magnetic field and stabilized by how robust the parent superconductor is.
Lev: How does this microscopic description translate into something you can actually measure with these microwave probes? Is it a clean signature or is it really buried in noise?
Title and authors: Kai: The experimental evidence suggests they can directly observe this anisotropy. They found that the maximum suppression of the superfluid stiffness happens when the angle theta is around ninety degrees and two hundred seventy degrees.
Mira: That angular dependence, where it gets strongest when you’re perpendicular to the current flow, is a definitive signature of these surfaces appearing and expanding.
Lev: If we were trying to implement this on a device, how sensitive would the measurement be to that specific angular sweet spot? Is it easy to hit those exact orientations in a real system?
Kai: The anisotropy magnitude they measured was roughly four times larger than what you’d expect from a pristine system, which strongly hints at the critical role of disorder.
Mira: That brings us into the theoretical modeling where they incorporate this disorder. They describe the total ground state energy by adding a term that accounts for these Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces forming.
Lev: What does that extra energy term look like mathematically when you try to run this on hardware? Does it add significant complexity to the error correction overhead?
Kai: The model shows that the phase diagram has successive transitions: from a gapped phase, then to one Bogoliubov Fermi surface, and then to two. That’s a whole sequence of changes depending on how much field you apply.
Mira: That sequence implies that this isn't just one simple transition; it’s a richer phase space driven by the interplay of things like Zeeman energy and orbital Fulde-Ferrell effects.
Lev: And those are the two main forces driving it, right? How does the AI handle modeling the competition between those two effects on a quantum level?
Kai: The BdG Hamiltonian in this case, when you include both Zeeman and spin-orbit coupling, produces energy spectra that depend heavily on the relative strength of those two things.
Mira: When they set the Zeeman energy equal to the zero-point gap, they get these banana shapes for the Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces that are extremely anisotropic.
Lev: So, if we were trying to design a system for Majorana fermions from this platform, how does this specific anisotropy guide your design choices?
Kai: It suggests that understanding this anisotropic momentum relaxation is crucial because it’s linked to nonreciprocal transport phenomena like the superconducting diode effect.
Mira: And the paper emphasizes that disorder plays a critical role in enhancing this anisotropy, where scattering of those zero-energy quasiparticles against the local landscape suppresses the stiffness even more.
Title and authors: Lev: So if we were simulating this on a real error correcting system, how much does incorporating that disorder term change your required code distance or gate operations?
Kai: The phenomenological anisotropy factor gamma is introduced to account for that disorder-driven momentum relaxation, which means the orientation of the supercurrent flow actually intersects those emergent Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces.
Mira: It’s a big picture point because it shows that microwave stiffness can be a very sensitive tool for finding these kinds of unconventional and topological phases in layered materials.
Lev: So, to wrap up on the theory side, what is the main limitation they state about their model? What doesn't this specific calculation cover?
Mira: They mention that the temperature dependence is important because thermal quasiparticles increase losses and decrease the superfluid density. And they note that for zero temperature, the transition happens once Zeeman energy equals the induced gap.
Kai: That means if you’re testing this at a finite temperature, your measurements will get smoother around that transition point depending on whether the thermal energy is much smaller than or larger than that induced gap.
Lev: So for real hardware implementation, that means we need to be very careful about the temperature regime when we try to observe these transitions.
Kai: We’ve seen how this paper investigates the emergence of Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces in hybrid Al/InAs heterostructures. It shows that microwave stiffness is a powerful thermodynamic probe for anisotropic gapless superconductivity in hybrid systems.
Mira: It sets up a framework where we can see how the interplay between finite momentum pairing, spin-orbit coupling, and those emergent surfaces creates this unique physics.
Lev: For us on the error correction side, it gives us concrete parameters like Bc1 equal to zero point sixty-eight tesla and Bc2 equal to zero point ninety-three tesla for resonators a and b. That’s something we can use to benchmark what we expect from real superconducting materials.
Kai: And the conclusion is that this distinct, nonmonotonic hook-like evolution of the kinetic inductance isn't just some standard pair-breaking thing; it’s a macroscopic fingerprint of zero-energy Bogoliubov quasiparticles.
Mira: It really connects these microscopic concepts—finite momentum pairing and spin-orbit coupling—into one unifying thread across a broad area of condensed matter physics.
Lev: We need to keep watching how this anisotropy plays out when we try to realize Majorana fermions in nanowires tailored from these Al/InAs platforms. That’s the practical implication for the next generation of quantum devices.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, this paper shows that when you put an in-plane magnetic field on an aluminum and Indium Arsenide structure, you can actually induce a gapless superconducting phase without just destroying the superconductivity entirely.
Mira: Yeah, what they're saying is that these zero-energy Bogoliubov quasiparticles create this specific shape on the energy surface of electrons and holes.
Lev: So they aren't looking at a simple suppression of the gap; they’re seeing something more complex happening there.
Kai: Exactly, because these surfaces are coherent superpositions of electrons and holes on opposite sides of the original Fermi surface.
Mira: And those surfaces are what stabilize this gapless state in response to that magnetic field, which is kind of a new way to induce superconductivity.
Lev: I wonder how they manage to get this specific physics where the in-plane magnetic field drives both the Zeeman effect and something else related to the orbital effects.
Kai: They say it’s because of that interplay between the Zeeman energy and what they call Fulde-Ferrell effects, both orbital and spin based.
Mira: And when those two energies are equal, they get these banana shapes for their Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces that are really stretched out in a particular way.
Lev: That stretching must be what causes the nonmonotonic behavior they see in the microwave measurements later on.
Kai: Right, because that shape is what selectively suppresses the supercurrent response at certain angles of the magnetic field.
Mira: And when you look at those angles, like ninety degrees or two hundred seventy degrees, that’s where you see the biggest drop in superfluid stiffness measured by them with those resonators.
Lev: So if we were designing a qubit based on this material, knowing exactly where that maximum suppression happens is critical for understanding its limits.
Kai: They found that the whole effect is really enhanced by disorder in the material, which means impurities help make these surfaces even more pronounced.
Mira: That's a big thing because it shows that in these hybrid systems, you can’t just assume perfect crystal behavior when studying these gapless phases.
Lev: And for someone building error correction hardware, that disorder term they introduce with the anisotropy factor gamma is actually quite large, which means our noise budget needs to account for this extra scattering.
Kai: So the main point here is that microwave stiffness measurements are a really sensitive way to see these exotic gapless states in layered materials.
Mira: It opens up a way to probe things like topological matter, which is important because it could be relevant for Majorana fermions down the line.
Lev: And their model confirms that this isn't just some standard pair-breaking mechanism; it’s a distinct macroscopic fingerprint of those zero-energy quasiparticles.
Kai: It really connects the microscopic pairing and spin-orbit coupling into one unified picture for these materials.
Mira: So they’re not just seeing superconductivity; they’re seeing how specific geometric shapes on the Fermi surface dictate the response to external fields.
Lev: It gives us concrete parameters like Bc1 and Bc2, which helps us benchmark what we expect from real superconducting materials in our simulations.
Kai: And their conclusion is that this entire sequence of transitions—gapped phase to one BFS to two BFS—is a very rich phase diagram driven by these effects.
Mira: It really shows that the way you structure your material interface dictates not just the basic gap, but also the whole landscape of possible superconducting states.
Lev: That leads us into how this affects transport; they even link it to nonreciprocal movement, like a superconducting diode effect.
Kai: So we’re looking at how these weird Fermi surfaces change the fundamental way current flows through these hybrid structures.
The paper's improvements: Kai: So, the authors point out that their model is pretty good at capturing the main physics of these systems but they're not perfect on everything yet.
Mira: They admit that incorporating disorder effects was a key part of their analysis, and they say if you don't include it, your results won't match what’s actually seen experimentally.
Lev: That makes sense for hardware; if you build something clean, the model will only give you an idealized picture of the stiffness.
Kai: They suggest that they need to be more careful with how they treat temperature dependence because thermal quasiparticles really do mess with your superfluid density at higher temperatures.
Mira: Exactly, and they point out that their analysis for zero temperature is pretty clean—it says the transition happens once the Zeeman energy hits the induced gap.
Lev: So if we try to test this on a real device where you can't keep it at absolute zero, that sharp transition might get smeared out depending on how much thermal energy is present.
Kai: They also discuss how they can sharpen that transition by looking at the ratio of the thermal energy, k to T, divided by the induced gap size.
Mira: And they suggest that if k to T is really small, say less than one point zero times the gap size, then you get a much sharper transition in your measurements.
Lev: That tells me we need to focus on operating conditions where the thermal energy is low relative to that induced gap for us to see these clean phase transitions.
Kai: They also mention that their way of calculating the superfluid stiffness, which is using the diamagnetic component of the current response function, is an alternative method to just measuring kinetic inductance directly.
Mira: That’s important because it means you have a different way to calculate it based on how you measure the current flow itself.
Lev: For error correction, if we use that alternative calculation path, we need to make sure our simulation accurately reflects that relationship between the current response and the stiffness tensor.
Kai: They also note that their model successfully captures the functional form of the anisotropic response when they use analytical models derived from equation four four.
Mira: That confirms their theoretical approach works well for modeling how those geometric shapes on the Fermi surface affect the measurement readout.
Lev: So, while they can't fix every detail yet, they’ve given us a solid roadmap for what needs to be modeled next to get a complete picture.
Kai: The main limitation they flag is that their model shows that the anisotropy is caused by disorder depending on whether those Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces are present in the direction of the current flow.
Mira: It's a bit circular, but it just means we have to keep checking if our assumption about the presence or absence of those surfaces in a certain direction is correct.
Lev: For us on the hardware side, that means we need better characterization of where these surfaces actually form spatially in our fabricated devices.
Kai: So basically, the authors are saying their framework is solid for now, but it’s not a final answer on how to model every single quirk of disorder.
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, this paper shows that measuring kinetic inductance via those resonators gives us a direct way to find these gapless superconducting phases in hybrid Al and Indium Arsenide structures.
Mira: It really nails how the interplay between finite momentum pairing and spin-orbit coupling creates these unique, anisotropic shapes on the Fermi surface.
Lev: From an error correction standpoint, having those concrete parameters for the material constants like Bc1 and Bc2 is actually pretty helpful for setting up our simulation boundaries.
Kai: The main implication is that microwave stiffness measurements are a very sensitive tool for uncovering unconventional and topological phases in layered materials.
Mira: They establish this framework where we can see how the structure of the interface dictates not just the basic gap, but also the whole landscape of possible superconducting states.
Lev: It’s interesting that they link this to nonreciprocal transport phenomena, like a superconducting diode effect, which is something we need to look at for next-generation devices.
Kai: That’s right; understanding how these Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces change the way current flows is crucial for the next generation of quantum hardware.
Mira: So, by looking at the sequence of transitions they found—gapped phase to one and then two Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces—they show a really rich phase diagram here.
Lev: That sequence tells us that we’re not just looking at one simple transition; there’s a whole path of change depending on the magnetic field strength.
Kai: And they confirm that this distinct, nonmonotonic behavior in the kinetic inductance isn't just some standard pair-breaking thing; it’s a real fingerprint of those zero-energy quasiparticles.
Mira: It really connects these microscopic concepts—finite momentum pairing and spin-orbit coupling—into one unifying thread across a broad area of condensed matter physics.
Lev: So for us, the next step is taking those parameters, like Bc1 equal to zero point zero six eight tesla and Bc2 equal to zero point zero nine three tesla, and seeing what those constraints mean for our error correction codes.
Kai: It’s exciting because it shows that this kind of direct measurement technique can find physics that standard tunneling spectroscopy might miss.
Mira: This paper, "Emergence of Bogoliubov Fermi Surfaces in hybrid Al/InAs heterostructures," really sets up a solid foundation for exploring these topological aspects further.
Institut f¨ur Experimentelle und Angewandte Physik University of Regensburg · Department of Physics and Astronomy Purdue University · Microsoft Quantum Purdue · Elmore Family School of Electrical and Computer Engineering Purdue University · School of Materials Engineering Purdue University · Purdue Quantum Science and Engineering Institute Purdue University Department de Solidos Cuanticos y Sistemas Desordenados Centro Atomico Bariloche Instituto de Nanociencia y Nanotecnologia CONICET-CNEA and Instituto Balseiro · Laboratoire de Physique des Solides CNRS UMR 8502 Université Paris-Sud Grupo de Circuitos Cuanticos Bariloche Div. Dispositivos y Sensores Centro Atomico Bariloche-CNEA Instituto Balseiro CONICET
cond-mat.supr-con, cond-mat.mtrl-sci
Submitted: 2026-08-06
Updated: 2026-11-11
Comments: 8 pages, 4 figures and supplementary information
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 82/100
The gist: Emergence of Bogoliubov Fermi Surfaces in hybrid Al/InAs heterostructures investigates microwave electrodynamics in proximitized two-dimensional electron gases to directly probe superfluid stiffness…
Key concepts
- Bogoliubov Fermi Surfaces (BFS)
- These are zero-energy quasiparticles formed by coherent superpositions of electrons and holes on opposite sides of the original Fermi surface. They signify a gapless superconducting phase induced by an in-plane magnetic field, which is stabilized by the parent superconductor's resilience.
- Kinetic Inductance
- This property relates to how a material responds to changes in magnetic flux, particularly in superconductors. In this study, it is used as a direct probe of the superfluid stiffness. Changes in this inductance are measured via shifts in microwave resonance frequency.
- Anisotropic Response
- The system's response varies significantly depending on the direction of an applied magnetic field relative to the current flow. The emergence of BFS causes a strong anisotropy, with maximum suppression of stiffness observed when the field is perpendicular to the current at angles like 90 and 270 degrees.
- Orbital Fulde-Ferrell (OFF) Effect
- This effect describes how an in-plane magnetic field penetrates the interface between a superconductor and a 2D layer. It plays a critical role in stabilizing the gapless phase by interacting with spin-orbit coupling and Zeeman effects, leading to complex, anisotropic behavior.
Terminology
Summary
Emergence of Bogoliubov Fermi Surfaces in hybrid Al/InAs heterostructures investigates microwave electrodynamics in proximitized two-dimensional electron gases to directly probe superfluid stiffness and reveal a gapless superconducting phase characterized by the emergence of Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces
Experimental Setup and Measurement Technique
The study utilizes lumped-element resonators with inductor wires oriented relative to an in-plane magnetic field to directly probe the superfluid stiffness via the kinetic inductance This method allows for the direct measurement of anisotropic gapless superconductivity in hybrid systems The resonance frequency shift, which is proportional to the diagonal components of the stiffness tensor Dxx, serves as a direct, thermodynamic probe of Dxx(B) Specifically, the shift in microwave resonance frequency f0 = 2π/p(Lg + Lk)C−1 is lowered by the kinetic inductance Lk
Theoretical Framework of Bogoliubov Fermi Surfaces
Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces (BFS) are zero-energy Bogoliubov quasiparticles, coherent superpositions of electrons and holes, residing on two isolated segments on opposite sides of the original Fermi surface These BFS correspond to a gapless superconducting phase that is induced by an in-plane magnetic field and stabilized by the resilience of the parent superconductor The microscopic calculations capture the observed anisotropy driven by the interplay of Zeeman and orbital Fulde-Ferrell effects The stability of these phases is mediated by an in-plane magnetic field penetrating the interface between the parent superconductor and the 2D layer, leading to an orbital Fulde-Ferrell (OFF) type of phase
Anisotropic Response and Field Dependence
The response becomes strongly anisotropic and exhibits a non-monotonic dependence as the field increases, which is a definitive signature of BFS selectively suppressing the supercurrent response The impact on the resonance frequency depends on the angle between the field B and the current J in the inductor, being stronger when B ⊥ J (orange curves) The maximum suppression of the superfluid stiffness occurs around θ =90◦ and 270◦ due to the enlarging of the BFS
Role of Disorder and Phase Diagram
The enhancement in anisotropy is attributed to the critical role of disorder in gapless superconducting phases, where scattering of zero-energy Bogoliubov quasiparticles against the local disorder landscape provides a strong mechanism for further suppressing the stiffness The total ground state energy is described by EtotGS(q) = EBCSGS + EBFSGS(q + qD) + βq + qD2 + 2DAlq2, where the second term describes the change of behavior due to the formation of the BFS The phase diagram shows successive transitions: gapped phase → 1-BFS → 2-BFS as summarized in Fig. S9(k)
Implications for Topological Matter
The experimental stabilization and direct measurement of this gapless phase carry profound implications for the understanding of topological quantum matter Demonstrating strong orbital effects in Al/InAs heterostructures introduces critical new considerations into the quest for Majorana fermions in nanowires tailored from these platforms The results establish microwave stiffness as a powerful thermodynamic probe capable of uncovering similar unconventional and topological phases in strongly correlated layered materials Understanding anisotropic momentum relaxation provides crucial microscopic insight into nonreciprocal transport phenomena, such as the superconducting diode effect
Theoretical Modeling of Gapless States
The BdG Hamiltonian in the Nambu basis, when considering both Zeeman and SOC effects, yields energy spectra that depend on the relative magnitude of VZ and VD The resulting Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces develop when VZ = ∆0, leading to banana shapes that are significantly anisotropic The minimal momentum q required for the development of the BFS is qc = ∆0/ħvF The total ground state energy is given by EtotGS(q) = EBCSGS + EBFSGS(q + qD) + βq + qD2 + 2DAlq2
Model Comparison and Parameter Extraction
The fitting of experimental data to the theoretical models, including the combined Zeeman/Orbital scenario, yields critical parameters such as Bc1 = 0.068 T and Bc2 = 0. p. 6 If both mechanisms
are considered together (see Fig. 3(k)), the equations
VD(Bc1) + VZ(Bc1) = ∆0 and VD(Bc2) − VZ(Bc2) =
∆0 have to be satisfied for the critical fields Bc1, Bc2.Where the paper says it
Conclusion and Future Directions
The paper presents the first clear observations of a gapless phase characterized by BFS in a hybrid superconductor/semiconductor platform The distinct, non-monotonic hook-like evolution of the kinetic inductance cannot be captured by standard pair-breaking mechanisms but serves as a definitive macroscopic fingerprint of zero-energy Bogoliubov quasiparticles This work establishes microwave stiffness as a sensitive probe of anisotropic gapless superconductivity in hybrid systems The findings suggest that the interplay of finite-momentum pairing, spin-orbit coupling, and emergent Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces is a unifying thread across a broad frontier of modern condensed matter physics
Supplementary Information Details
The supplementary information details the fabrication of the devices using molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) resulting in a clean interface between the aluminum top layer and the underlying InAs 2DEG The measurement routine involves precise determination of resonance frequency free from vortex-induced dissipation by heating above Tc and cooling down The material parameters used, such as the effective mass m = 0.0403 me and carrier density n2D = 8. p. 5 We use an effective mass
for the InAs 2DEG of m =0. 0403 me and a carrier density
of n2D =8. 110) for an effective temperature Teff =176 mK. The analytical model successfully captures the distinct functional form of the anisotropic response. 110) for an effective temperature Teff =176 mK. The analytical model successfully captures the distinct functional form of the anisotropic response.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI can model microwave electrodynamics in hybrid superconductor/semiconductor heterostructures by directly probing superfluid stiffness through kinetic inductance measurements using lumped-element resonators.
-
The improved system can simulate the nonmonotonic and strongly anisotropic evolution of resonance frequency as a definitive signature of Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces, which cannot be explained by orbital pair breaking alone.
-
The AI can perform microscopic theoretical calculations to capture the observed anisotropy driven by the interplay of Zeeman and orbital Fulde-Ferrell effects, capturing a rich phase diagram that combines both mechanisms.
-
The system can be used to establish microwave stiffness measurements as a sensitive probe of anisotropic gapless superconductivity in hybrid systems, leveraging the relationship between resonance frequency shift and superfluid density change.
-
The AI can analyze the angular dependence of resonances for different in-plane magnetic field strengths to map out the emergence and evolution of Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces, showing how the maximum suppression occurs around theta equals 90 degrees and 270 degrees.
-
The improved system can incorporate disorder effects by parameterizing disorder-induced momentum relaxation through a phenomenological anisotropy factor gamma, which accounts for the enhancement of measured anisotropy in gapless phases.
Abstract
We investigate the microwave electrodynamics of a proximitized two-dimensional electron gas in hybrid superconductor/semiconductor heterostructures. Using lumped-element resonators with inductor wires oriented relative to an in-plane magnetic field, we directly probe the superfluid stiffness via the kinetic inductance. As the field increases, the resonance frequency exhibits a non-monotonic and strongly anisotropic evolution that cannot be explained by orbital pair breaking alone. We show that this behavior is consistent with the emergence of Bogoliubov Fermi surfaces, which selectively suppress the supercurrent response depending on the direction of the magnetic field. Microscopic calculations of the stiffness tensor capture the observed anisotropy driven by the interplay of Zeeman and orbital Fulde-Ferrell effects. Our results establish microwave stiffness measurements as a sensitive probe of anisotropic gapless superconductivity in hybrid systems.
Sources
- Emergence of Fermi-liquid and BCS physics in overdoped cuprates
- Theories of Superconducting Diode Effects
Related papers
- Microscopic Origin and Josephson Signatures of d-Wave Superconductivity in Monolayer FeSe
- Excitonic-Superconducting Coexistence and Emergent Nematic Superconductivity Driven by Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking
- Quantum phase fluctuations quench chiral superconductivity in twisted overdoped cuprate bilayers
- Interface-Confined Superconductivity with Thickness-Independent Superfluid Stiffness in (Pb,Sn)Te/FeTe Bilayers
- Kinetic Lifshitz invariants and dynamics of nonreciprocal fluctuations in superconductors
- Steering and Local Tunneling Signatures of Majorana Corner Modes in Altermagnetic Josephson Junctions