GOOFy-compatible 3HDMs and beyond

arXiv:2608.05304 · hep-ph, hep-th · Submitted 2026-08-05 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "GOOFy-compatible 3HDMs and beyond".

Paper summary: Kai: So to wrap up, the paper "GOOFy-compatible 3HDMs and beyond" is about introducing a broader class of non-standard transformations called GOOFy transformations for scalar fields <ref:2608.05304#pg1,a broader class of non-standard>.

Mira: They argue that these aren't standard symmetries, but some of them can stabilize the scalar potential, and they introduce a sign-orbit technique to classify which bilinear structures are compatible with these transformations.

Lev: Essentially, they give us a tool to systematically categorize the admissible parameter space in multi-Higgs models before you start running simulations on real hardware.

Kai: The title suggests they are looking at going beyond just three-Higgs models and into larger sectors, and the method is formulated to extend that way.

Mira: And they suggest that once you have this classification, you can use standard renormalization group running as a secondary check to see which of those classified structures actually survive the flow.

Lev: So it provides a structured way to approach stability in these complex systems by combining structural symmetry constraints with dynamic stability checks.

Conclusion: Kai: So, this paper "GOOFy-compatible 3HDMs and beyond" is about finding new ways to look at those multi-Higgs models we’ve been studying for years <ref:2608.05304#pg1,GOOFy-compatible 3HDMs and beyond>.

Mira: It’s really about these GOOFy transformations, which are these non-standard ways you can transform your scalar fields that aren't the usual Higgs or CP symmetries.

Lev: What they do is show how to classify all the different possible parameter setups in three-Higgs models and even bigger ones using something called orbit construction.

Kai: They’re essentially saying that the stability we see in some of these potential shapes isn't just a lucky accident; it comes down to specific algebraic properties of the SU(two) symmetry itself.

Mira: The main point is that you can use these classifications to narrow down which models are even worth studying before you spend all your time on simulations.

Lev: If you’re building real hardware, this means we have a way to filter out the configurations that are doomed to run away during the renormalization group flow.

Kai: So, it moves us from just checking if a model *can* exist, to figuring out which ones *will* stay stable as we change our energy scales.

Mira: It opens up a whole new map for exploring these more complex scalar sectors, and you can use the standard stability checks on this new classification framework.

I. de Medeiros Varzielasa, A. KunÁcinas

Centro de Fósica Teɡrica de Partəculas, CFTP, Departamento de Fəsica, Instituto Superior Tnico, Universidade de Lisboa · Instituto de Fsica Corpuscular (IFIC), CSIC-Universitat de Val`encia

hep-ph, hep-th

Submitted: 2026-08-05

Updated: 2026-11-17

Project page: https://gap-packages.github.io/smallgrp

Importance score: 75/100

The gist: Beyond conventional Higgs-family and general CP transformations, one may also consider a broader class of non-standard “GOOFy” transformations in which scalar fields and their conjugates are…

Key concepts

GOOFy Transformation
A broad class of non-standard transformations where scalar fields and their conjugates are assigned related but different transformations. These explicitly violate usual kinetic invariance, which is the defining feature distinguishing them from standard Higgs-family or CP transformations.
Algebraic Obstructions to Stability
The crucial difference between the 2HDM and higher NHDMs lies in a symmetric invariant tensor, dabc. For SU(2), this tensor is zero, which explains why simple lifts of stability conditions fail under RG flow. This algebraic property dictates the stability landscape.
Orbit Construction
This method classifies different symmetry embeddings by looking at their orbits. It simplifies identifying admissible bilinear sectors into a problem solvable through character theory. This technique helps determine which sectors are symmetry-realizable and potentially stable.
Bilinear Formalism Interpretation
The bilinear formalism allows systematizing GOOFy transformations by defining a shift $\Delta r_{\mu} = r'\mu - r\mu$. The invariant subspace contributing to the quadratic potential is isolated by requiring this shift to be zero, directly revealing which bilinear directions remain invariant under the transformation.

Terminology

Summary

Beyond conventional Higgs-family and general CP transformations, one may also consider a broader class of non-standard “GOOFy” transformations in which scalar fields and their conjugates are assigned related but inequivalent transformations. p. 0 These transformations demonstrate that the renormalisation-group stability of the r0 → −r0 manifold in isolation is not a generic feature of multi-Higgs potentials, but rather a direct consequence of special algebraic properties of SU(2)

GOOFy Framework Definition

The defining feature of a GOOFy transformation is that it explicitly violates the usual kinetic invariance. Originally, Ref. p. 6 [34] identified within the 2HDM a set of RG-stable parameter relations: m211 + m22 = 0, λ1 - λ2 = 0, λ6 + λ7 = 0, (3. p. 61) written in the standard 2HDM notation and structurally reminiscent of the CP2-invariant model. p. 6

Algebraic Obstructions to Stability

The bilinear formalism for the 3HDM is summarised in Appendix A and RG conditions will be discussed in Subsection 5.3. The crucial distinction between the 2HDM and higher NHDMs is the existence of the symmetric invariant tensor dabc, defined through a symmetric map Sym2(Adj) → Adj. p. 8 This explains why the naive lift of the r0 conditions fails to remain invariant under the RG flow because for SU(2), dabc = 0. p. 8

Classification via Orbit Construction

The orbit method classifies basis-equivalence classes of symmetry embeddings, which reduces the identification of admissible bilinear sectors to a classification problem in character theory. This technique reduces the identification of admissible bilinear sectors to a classification problem in character theory. p. 0 The orbit construction also appears to be compatible with the outer automorphism criterion of Ref. p. 9 [70]. In contrast, partial sign-flipping transformations enforce arbitrary truncations on the scalar multiplet by forcing specific, U(1)N−1-allowed (maximal-torus) parameters to zero. p. 2 This parameter subspace cannot be trivially truncated and these radiative effects inevitably destabilise partial sign-flipping configurations. p. 1

Conclusion on Viability

The work provides a foundation for classification of larger GOOFy NHDMs by identifying the symmetry-realisable orbit sectors and their associated eigenvalue structures. The existing RG analyses may then be viewed as providing an independent criterion for determining which of these sectors remain invariant under renormalisation. p. 0

B Some examples of the GOOFy potentials

The overall sign-flipping GOOFy transformations are generated by Z˜1− = W (I, −I, 0) The unique GCP-like overall sign-flipping GOOFy transformations are (the even order of GCP transformations stems from their anti-linear (or anti-unitary) nature, as they involve complex conjugation)

B.1 The trivial embedding

In the trivial embedding case with XA = diag(−1, −1, 1), the invariant quadratic potential is given by V2 = µ233h33

B.2 The Z2 embeddings

The Z4-symmetric 4HDM yields four inequivalent configurations: O(3,0), O(2,1), O(2,0)O(1,0), and O(1,1)O(1,0)

B.3 Interpretation in the bilinear formalism

To systematise this in the bilinear formalism one may define the transformation shift ∆rµ = r'µ − rµ. The invariant subspace that contributes to V2 is isolated by demanding ∆rµ = 0. p. 6

The resulting invariant quadratic potential for the trivial embedding is given by V2 = µ211h11 + µ222h22 + µ213h13 + h.c.

The invariant scalar potential is therefore given by V2 = µ211h11 + µ222h23 + 0

The structure of the admissible quadratic sector can also be understood directly within the bilinear formalism. The problem reduces to identifying which bilinear directions remain invariant under a given transformation.

In this case, the surviving quadratic potential is given by V2 = µ233h33

The resulting invariant quadratic potential for the trivial embedding is given by V2 = µ211h11 + µ222h23 + 0

In this case, the surviving quadratic potential is given by V2 = µ211h11 + h.c.

The resulting invariant quadratic potential for the trivial embedding is given by V2 = µ211h11 + h.c.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Enhanced classification of scalar potentials based on GOOFy transformations: The system can classify admissible scalar sectors without asserting a definitive quantum-field-theoretic origin for the transformations themselves, using a classification entirely group-theoretical in terms of irreducible representations into sign-orbit pairs alongside the additional sign representation carried by X.

  2. Predictive analysis of renormalisation group stability: The improved system can explicitly verify the consistency of GOOFy potentials under the RG flow by employing PyR@TE and RGBeta codes, revealing that overall sign-flipping transformations are generically RG-stable because they act uniformly as parity across the entire bilinear space.

  3. Determination of physical viability constraints: The AI can identify that partial sign-flipping configurations are generically unstable under RG evolution by demonstrating that they force specific U(1N−1)-allowed (maximal-torus) parameters to zero, a condition that is generally not preserved by the RG flow.

  4. Systematic analysis of vacuum alignments: The system can evaluate stationary-point equations for various GOOFy configurations to determine the resulting mass spectra, identifying configurations that yield massless states or negative mass-squared eigenvalues (saddle points) present in Table 1.

  5. Basis freedom identification: The improved system can distinguish between inequivalent realisations by associating each generator with the pair of traces tr U and tr X, indicating that Generators with different trace pairs necessarily belong to different equivalence classes.

Sources

Related papers