Dynamic Flexibility Requests in Local Flexibility Markets: Quantifying the DSO Willingness to Pay
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Robotics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest robotics and control papers.
Rosa: We're looking at the paper: "Dynamic Flexibility Requests in Local Flexibility Markets".
Paper summary: Rosa: So we're looking at this paper called "Dynamic Flexibility Requests in Local Flexibility Markets: Quantifying the DSO Willingness to Pay". Basically, it's about how Distribution System Operators, or DSOs, should decide how much flexibility they want to buy and what price they're willing to pay for it during market clearing.
Dev: Right. And the authors argue that current ways of doing this are often too simple. They point out that most existing methods rely on these unrealistic centralized algorithms or just very basic local requests based only on congestion management, completely ignoring the actual economic value of flexibility.
Taro: So what they claim is a dynamic flexibility request methodology where you bake the DSO's willingness to pay right into the market clearing objective. They do this by putting a price on things like transformer and cable aging, network losses, and voltage congestion.
Rosa: That sounds pretty comprehensive. So how do they make it work computationally? They need to keep it fast enough for real-time decisions, right?
Dev: Exactly. To handle that, they develop these exact convex piecewise-linear epigraph reformulations for the transformer aging model and the Arrhenius-based cable aging model. They prove that this way of approximating those nonlinear models keeps the accuracy exactly the same as the original complex models.
Taro: So it’s like they took a really messy, curvy problem and turned it into a set of straight lines that’s easy to solve while still being super accurate on how old the equipment is getting.
Rosa: That makes sense for real-time operation. And how do they tie all those asset costs together? They formulate this unified DSO valuation framework where you quantify transformer and cable aging, medium-low voltage losses, and voltage limit violations into locational flexibility prices.
Dev: They break down the economic value of flexibility by looking at avoided impacts relative to a baseline operating point. So they calculate the cost of aging based on normal insulation life to find the monetary aging cost from loss of life.
Taro: And then they look at network losses, quantifying them using sensitivity calculations from baseline operation, where total active-power losses are expressed as a linear expression of time varying total loss sensitivities. That turns a complex loss calculation into something they can use in the market.
Rosa: And for voltage violations, they use voltage sensitivity coefficients to estimate how activating flexibility changes nodal voltages and that leads to a monetary benefit for the DSO. It’s like measuring how much better your grid is when you activate that flexibility and putting a dollar value on that improvement.
Dev: The complete local market-clearing algorithm then maximizes net welfare by adding all these benefits together relative to the anticipated baseline operating point, subject to constraints that use all those piecewise linearizations to enforce the thermal models.
Taro: So the key is maximizing this objective function while making sure it stays within those constraints that accurately reflect the physical limits of the equipment and network.
Rosa: The results show that this dynamic approach really boosts market liquidity by activating flexibility whenever the overall network benefit exceeds what it costs to procure it, even when there isn't much congestion. It exploits economic opportunities beyond just congestion management.
Dev: It seems they’re showing that when you look at the base-case results, flexibility activation goes up significantly during late afternoon and evening hours when transformer loading, voltage violations, and network losses all get critical. This behavior is explained by the exponential dependence of transformer and cable thermal aging and the quadratic dependence of electrical losses on loading.
Taro: So even under lightly congested conditions, this framework finds economically beneficial flexibility, which really increases market liquidity and improves overall social welfare. It keeps the network running close to the desired operating limits.
Rosa: They also noted that the remaining difference between what their optimization results show and what an AC validation would find is just due to the voltage approximation error from using sensitivity-based linearization.
Dev: That's a fair caveat. The authors flag that this method doesn't solve every single small error introduced by that specific linearization technique under high flexibility activation, which is where future work will focus on making it more robust.
Taro: So what does this mean for the real world? It means DSOs can use these dynamic requests to manage assets like transformers and cables not just when the wires are overloaded, but based on their long-term health and voltage stability.
Rosa: And if you look at the comparison to a recent state-of-the-art flexibility request methodology, they found that this new dynamic approach actually showed better utilization of flexibility and improved congestion management overall.
Dev: So it seems like embedding the asset degradation costs directly into the clearing price gives DSOs a much richer signal than just reacting to immediate congestion signals.
Taro: It’s about getting the full picture—the long-term health of the grid combined with real-time operational needs. But they did admit that future work will involve extending this through an iterative market clearing process to smooth out those small AC feasibility errors.
Rosa: Right, so it shows how we can move beyond just managing immediate flow problems and start optimizing for the whole system over time, even when congestion isn't the main driver.
Conclusion: Rosa: So this paper is about how Distribution System Operators should decide how much flexibility to buy and what they should pay for it in local markets.
Dev: Yeah, the title is "Dynamic Flexibility Requests in Local Flexibility Markets: Quantifying the DSO Willingness to Pay". The authors are working on making that decision process smarter than just reacting to immediate congestion.
Rosa: It basically takes those hidden costs—like aging transformers and cable wear—and puts them directly into the market clearing objective.
Dev: Right, they're using these exact mathematical reformulations of the asset degradation models to keep things accurate while making it fast enough for real-time loops. The big idea is monetizing all that network stress into a single value for flexibility.
Rosa: So what does this mean if you’re driving home and you’re just trying to keep your power on? It suggests we can find economic value in flexibility even when the wires aren't totally overloaded, based on how old the equipment is getting.
Dev: That’s right, they show that this dynamic approach increases market liquidity by activating flexibility whenever it makes sense economically relative to those asset costs. It’s about using the whole system cost picture instead of just looking at one bottleneck.
Rosa: So for someone just listening, it means the grid can start making decisions based on the long-term health of its hardware, not just today's traffic jam. But they did admit there’s still a little error in how they approximate voltage effects using sensitivity calculations.
Dev: True, that approximation error is what they flagged as something to work on next time—they plan to do an iterative market clearing process to smooth out those small errors when flexibility is really high. That's the safety case we need for real-time deployment.
Rosa: It’s a step toward a system that balances immediate operational needs with the long-term maintenance of the physical infrastructure. Next, we’re going to talk about how this new way of pricing flexibility actually compares to what other cutting-edge methods are doing right now.
Cyprus University of Technology
eess.SY, cs.SY
Submitted: 2026-08-04
Updated: 2026-11-17
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
Importance score: 80/100
The gist: Local Flexibility Markets (LFMs) require Distribution System Operators (DSOs) to determine both the quantity of flexibility to procure and the corresponding willingness to pay during market clearing.
Key concepts
- Dynamic Flexibility Request Methodology
- A new approach where the DSO determines how much flexibility to buy and what price they are willing to pay during market clearing. Instead of fixed requests, this method dynamically calculates this willingness-to-pay by considering all network costs and benefits.
- Monetization of Network Operation
- Assigning a monetary value to various network issues. This includes quantifying the cost associated with aging transformers and cables, calculating the financial impact of network losses, and estimating the benefit derived from avoiding voltage violations.
Terminology
Summary
Local Flexibility Markets (LFMs) require Distribution System Operators (DSOs) to determine both the quantity of flexibility to procure and the corresponding willingness to pay during market clearing. p. 0 1
Dynamic Flexibility Requests in Local Flexibility Markets:
Quantifying the DSO Willingness to Pay
Savvas Panagi , Student Member, IEEE, Chrysovalantis Spanias , Member, IEEE, and Petros Aristidou , Senior
Member, IEEE
Abstract—Local Flexibility Markets (LFMs) require Distribution System Operators (DSOs) to determine both the quantity of flexibility to procure and the corresponding willingness
to pay during market clearing. Existing approaches typically
rely on unrealistic centralized AC-OPF clearing algorithms or
strictly localized, static flexibility requests driven primarily by
congestion management, while the economic value of flexibility
is largely neglected. 1
Dynamic Flexibility Requests in Local Flexibility Markets:
Quantifying the DSO Willingness to Pay
Savvas Panagi , Student Member, IEEE, Chrysovalantis Spanias , Member, IEEE, and Petros Aristidou , Senior
Member, IEEE
Abstract—Local Flexibility Markets (LFMs) require Distribution System Operators (DSOs) to determine both the quantity of flexibility to procure and the corresponding willingness
to pay during market clearing. Existing approaches typically
rely on unrealistic centralized AC-OPF clearing algorithms or
strictly localized, static flexibility requests driven primarily by
congestion management, while the economic value of flexibility
is largely neglected. Existing approaches typically
rely on unrealistic centralized AC-OPF clearing algorithms or
strictly localized, static flexibility requests driven primarily by
congestion management, while the economic value of flexibility
is largely neglected. This paper proposes a dynamic flexibilityrequest methodology in which the DSO’s willingness-to-pay is
embedded directly into the market-clearing objective by monetizing transformer and cable aging, network losses, and voltage
congestion. 91 transformer aging model and an Arrhenius-based cable
aging model are developed and formally proven to preserve
exactness. The proposed framework is validated on a modified
CIGRE MV benchmark and compared with a recent state-ofthe-art flexibility-request methodology.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Pruning redundant reasoning tokens
The core contribution of this work is the development of a dynamic flexibility request methodology for LFMs where the DSO willingness-to-pay is determined endogenously through the monetization of network operation. This replaces static flexibility requests with a mechanism that embeds all relevant network impacts directly into the clearing objective. p. 0 Existing approaches typically
rely on unrealistic centralized AC-OPF clearing algorithms or
strictly localized, static flexibility requests driven primarily by
congestion management, while the economic value of flexibility
is largely neglected. This paper proposes a dynamic flexibilityrequest methodology in which the DSO’s willingness-to-pay is
embedded directly into the market-clearing objective by monetizing transformer and cable aging, network losses, and voltage
congestion.Where the paper says it
How the training signal is built
The methodology involves several key technical developments to ensure computational efficiency and accuracy. These include:
-
Developing exact convex piecewise-linear epigraph reformulations of the IEEE C57. p. 0
91 transformer and Arrhenius-based cable aging models to explicitly incorporate asset degradation into the framework. p. 1Where the paper says it
This paper proposes a dynamic flexibilityrequest methodology in which the DSO’s willingness-to-pay is embedded directly into the market-clearing objective by monetizing transformer and cable aging, network losses, and voltage congestion. To enable computationally efficient clearing, exact convex piecewise-linear epigraph reformulations of the IEEE C57.
Where the paper says it
• An exact convex epigraph-based piecewise-linear reformulation of the IEEE C57. 91 transformer and Arrheniusbased cable aging models, enabling the explicit incorporation of asset degradation into a computationally efficient market-clearing framework.
-
Formulating a unified DSO valuation framework that jointly quantifies transformer and cable aging, medium-low voltage (MV/LV) losses, and voltage-limit violations into locational flexibility prices. p. 1
Where the paper says it
91 transformer and Arrheniusbased cable aging models, enabling the explicit incorporation of asset degradation into a computationally efficient market-clearing framework. • A unified DSO valuation framework that jointly quantifies transformer and cable aging, medium-low voltage (MV/LV) losses, and voltage-limit violations into locational flexibility prices, validated on a modified CIGRE MV network and benchmarked against a recent state-ofthe-art methodology.
-
Linearizing the loading factor around the baseline operating point using a first-order Taylor approximation to create a tractable representation for market clearing. p. 3
Where the paper says it
Although (21) provides the exact loading level, it is nonlinear with respect to the active-power variation introduced by flexibility and is therefore not directly suitable for the market-clearing formulation. To obtain a tractable representation, the loading factor is linearized around the baseline operating point (P base t , Qbase t ) by means of a firstorder Taylor approximation.
Where the gains come from
The economic value of flexibility is quantified by defining the DSO willingness-to-pay relative to a baseline operating point to calculate avoided impacts. This valuation framework incorporates several cost components:
((A) Transformer and Cable Aging Cost)
The baseline aging cost is established using the normal insulation lifetime to calculate the monetary aging cost based on loss of life (LoL).
((B) Loss Cost Benefit Estimation)
Network losses are quantified using sensitivity calculations from baseline operation, where the total active-power losses are expressed as a linear expression of the time-varying total-loss sensitivities.
((C) Voltage Violation Modeling)
Voltage violations are quantified by using voltage sensitivity coefficients to estimate how flexibility activation modifies nodal voltages, leading to a monetary benefit.
The complete local market-clearing algorithm maximizes net welfare by aggregating all these benefits relative to the anticipated baseline operating point. This objective function is maximized subject to constraints that utilize all piecewise-linearizations to enforce the epigraph representations of the thermal models. p. 5 The resulting DSO benefit aggregates the
aging terms of the primary and secondary transformers and
MV cables, the MV and LV loss benefits, and the voltageviolation component, all relative to the anticipated baseline
operating point (38). B
DSO
t = B
age
tra,t + B
age
l,t + B
MV
loss,t + B
LV
loss,t + B
V
t
(38)
The DSO clears flexibility by maximizing net welfare, where
inequality constraints are used for all piecewise-linearizations:
max X
t∈T
B
DSO
t −
X
a∈A
λ
FSP
a,t ∆P
flex
a,t ∆t
!Where the paper says it
The results demonstrate that this dynamic approach significantly increases market liquidity by activating flexibility whenever the overall network benefit exceeds the procurement cost. Unlike conventional congestion-driven requests, which focus only on congestion management, this method exploits additional economic opportunities beyond congestion management. p. 8 8, the benchmark
methodology of [21] requests flexibility only to alleviate
anticipated congestion, resulting in significantly lower market
participation. In contrast, the proposed approach activates flexibility whenever the overall network benefit exceeds the procurement cost, thereby exploiting additional economic opportunities beyond congestion management.Where the paper says it
The proposed piecewise-linear aging formulation preserves the linearity and convexity of the market-clearing problem while achieving accuracy nearly identical to that of the exact nonlinear transformer and cable thermal models. This enables explicit incorporation of asset degradation without sacrificing computational tractability. p. 8 First, the
proposed piecewise-linear aging formulation preserves the
linearity and convexity of the market-clearing problem while
achieving accuracy nearly identical to that of the exact nonlinear transformer and cable thermal models. This enables the
explicit incorporation of asset degradation into the marketclearing process without sacrificing computational tractability.Where the paper says it
The base-case results show that flexibility activation increases significantly during late-afternoon and evening hours when transformer loading, voltage violations, and network losses become critical. This behavior is primarily explained by the exponential dependence of transformer and cable thermal aging presented in (3) and (10), together with the quadratic dependence of electrical losses on loading. p. 7 Consequently, the proposed DLMP almost doubles, rising
from approximately 65 C/MWh to more than 120 C/MWh. This behavior is primarily explained by the exponential dependence of transformer and cable thermal aging presented in
(3) and (10), together with the quadratic dependence of electrical losses on loading.Where the paper says it
The proposed methodology successfully identifies economically beneficial flexibility even under lightly congested operating conditions, thereby significantly increasing market liquidity and improving overall social welfare. The framework maintains network operation close to the desired operating limits, and the remaining discrepancy between the optimization results and the AC validation is limited to the voltage approximation error of the adopted sensitivity-based linearization. p. 8 Expanding these requests into
five flexibility zones increases market participation but leads to
poorer technical performance, with remaining voltage and lineloading violations after AC power-flow validation. Conversely,
the proposed methodology maintains network operation close
to the desired operating limits, and the remaining discrepancy
between the optimization results and the AC validation is
limited to the voltage approximation error of the adopted
sensitivity-based linearization, which remains below 0. Expanding these requests into
five flexibility zones increases market participation but leads to
poorer technical performance, with remaining voltage and lineloading violations after AC power-flow validation. Conversely,
the proposed methodology maintains network operation close
to the desired operating limits, and the remaining discrepancy
between the optimization results and the AC validation is
limited to the voltage approximation error of the adopted
sensitivity-based linearization, which remains below 0.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Future work will focus on extending this framework through an iterative market-clearing process to reduce small AC feasibility errors introduced by sensitivity-based linearization under large flexibility activations. Additionally, more detailed flexibility-provider models will be incorporated into the market-clearing problem. p. 8 Future work will focus on extending the proposed framework through an iterative market-clearing process to further reduce the small AC feasibility errors introduced by sensitivitybased linearization under large flexibility activations. In addition, more detailed flexibility-provider models, including
internal operational constraints and realistic resource aggregation, will be incorporated into the market-clearing problem. In addition, more detailed flexibility-provider models, including
internal operational constraints and realistic resource aggregation, will be incorporated into the market-clearing problem. Finally, future research will investigate the design and bidding
strategies for flexibility offers, enabling a more comprehensive
representation of both DSO and FSP decision-making.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The proposed dynamic flexibility request successfully identifies economically beneficial flexibility even under lightly congested operating conditions, thereby significantly increasing market liquidity and improving overall social welfare. The comparison with a recent state-of-the-art methodology further shows improved flexibility utilization and enhanced congestion management. p. 8 the proposed methodology successfully identifies economically beneficial flexibility even under lightly congested operating conditions, thereby significantly increasing market liquidity and improving overall social welfare. Comparisons with
a recent state-of-the-art methodology further show improved
flexibility utilization and enhanced congestion management.Where the paper says it
The proposed methodology maintains network operation close to the desired operating limits, and the remaining discrepancy between the optimization results and the AC validation is limited to the voltage approximation error of the adopted sensitivity-based linearization.
The proposed methodology maintains network operation close to the desired operating limits, and the remaining discrepancy between the optimization results and the AC validation is limited to the voltage approximation error of the adopted sensitivity-based linearization.
The proposed methodology successfully identifies economically beneficial flexibility even under lightly congested operating conditions, thereby significantly increasing market liquidity and improving overall social welfare. The framework maintains network operation close to the desired operating limits, and the remaining discrepancy between the optimization results and the AC validation is limited to the voltage approximation error of the adopted sensitivity-based linearization.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Dynamic flexibility request methodology allows DSOs to determine their willingness-to-pay endogenously by embedding
the aggregate economic impact of each activation directly in the clearing objective.
This enables a system to activate flexibility wheneverthe overall network benefit exceeds the procurement cost,
leading to significantly increased market liquidity compared to static requests. -
The framework incorporates exact convex piecewise-linear reformulations of transformer and cable aging models, which ensures that
no epigraph relaxation gap
exists in the complete market-clearing objective. This allows AI systems to explicitly consider asset degradation alongside network losses and voltage congestion without sacrificing computational tractability. -
The system can quantify avoided impacts such as
transformer and cable aging, MV/LV losses, and voltage violations
into locational flexibility prices, which are then used to determine the DSO benefit through the formulaBso t = Bage tra t + Bage l t + BMV loss t + BLV loss t + BVt.
This provides a holistic valuation for flexibility procurement. -
The sensitivity-based formulation accurately captures network behavior, with the resulting discrepancy between optimization results and AC validation being
limited to the voltage approximation error of the adopted sensitivity-based linearization, which remains below 0.003 p.u. for the examined stress scenario.
This ensures that flexibility activation aligns closely with actual network performance during peak stress events.
Abstract
Local Flexibility Markets (LFMs) require Distribution System Operators (DSOs) to determine both the quantity of flexibility to procure and the corresponding willingness to pay during market clearing. Existing approaches typically rely on centralized AC-OPF clearing algorithms with limited practical scalability or strictly localized, static flexibility requests driven primarily by congestion management, while the economic value of flexibility is largely neglected. This paper proposes a dynamic flexibility-request methodology in which the DSO's willingness to pay is embedded directly into the market-clearing objective by monetizing transformer and cable aging, network losses, and voltage congestion. To enable computationally efficient clearing, exact convex piecewise-linear epigraph reformulations of the IEEE C57.91 transformer aging model and an Arrhenius-based cable aging model are developed and formally proven to preserve exactness. The proposed framework is validated on a modified CIGRE MV benchmark and compared with a recent state-of-the-art flexibility-request methodology. The results demonstrate significantly higher market liquidity, more efficient flexibility procurement, and improved network operations while preserving the market's transparency and non-discrimination principles.
Related papers
- Industrial Load Modeling and Optimization for Market-Based Interaction with Power Systems
- Exact and Approximate Convex Reformulation of Linear Stochastic Optimal Control with Chance Constraints
- Certified Set Convergence for Piecewise Affine Systems
- Symbolic Control for Stochastic Systems via Finite Parity Games
- Multiobjective optimization-based design and dispatch of islanded, hybrid microgrids for remote, off-grid communities in sub-Saharan Africa
- Physiology-informed layered sensing for intelligent human-exoskeleton interaction