Nonlocality relates cuprate photoemission omega/T scaling to a broad dielectric loss peak

arXiv:2608.03013 · cond-mat.str-el · Submitted 2026-08-04 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Nonlocality relates cuprate photoemission omega/T scaling to a broad dielectric loss peak".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Nonlocality can generate ω/T scaling without criticality in high Tc strange metals The paper proposes a mechanism involving nonlocality induced by poorly screened effective repulsions Vα(r) ∼ 1/rα, where a continuously doping-dependent exponent 1 ≤ α ≤ 3 interpolates between the Mott insulating and Fermi liquid limits The Core Hypothesis The central idea is that high Tc strange metals are spatially nonlocal systems rather than local ones.

Kai: The authors argue that long-ranged poorly screened interactions Vα(r) ∼ 1/rα where α < 2 can qualitatively alter the structure, violating conventional hydrodynamics and information-propagation bounds.

Mira: This nonlocality is introduced as a phenomenological hypothesis for hydrodynamic screening in Eqn 2, exploiting the fact that diffusive hydrodynamics is generally violated for α < 2.

Kai: Phenomenology of Scaling Laws The paper develops a scale-covariant quasiparticle decay rate Γ(ω, T) ∝ TγΦ(ω/T) in energy ω and temperature T, with γ = 2 − 1/α for nonlocal 1 < α < 2.

Paper summary: Kai: Okay, so to recap, this paper argues that the unusual energy and temperature scaling we see in highTc strange metals isn't just some local thing happening at a single point <ref:2608.03013#pg1>.

Mira: They propose a mechanism where long-ranged interactions, specifically those decaying as one over alpha r, create spatial nonlocality that dictates the scaling behavior <ref:2608.03013#pg1>.

Lev: Essentially, they are saying that these interactions couple the charge carriers to a much wider set of energy and momentum relaxation modes than a simple local model would predict <ref:2608.03013#pg2>.

Kai: The key result they derive is a specific scaling for the quasiparticle decay rate, which depends on temperature and energy in a way that is scale-covariant <ref:2608.03013#pg1>.

Mira: This scaling rate has an exponent gamma equal to two minus one over alpha when alpha is between one and two <ref:2608.03013#pg1>.

Lev: That means the structure of the decay rate itself is directly determined by this spatial nonlocality, which they call a phenomenological hypothesis for hydrodynamic screening <ref:2608.03013#pg2>.

Kai: They then connect this to experimental measurements by saying that spectroscopy-fitted exponents should match each other if you compare photoemission and loss spectroscopy data <ref:2608.03013#pg2>.

Mira: They are essentially providing a way to test this nonlocality directly, suggesting that the relationship between ARPES self energy and EELS dielectric loss L q omega should be consistent at each fixed doping <ref:2608.03013#pg2>.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if you can measure both those things independently, you have a testable hypothesis about the underlying physics of the charge fluid <ref:2608.03013#pg1>.

Kai: They also distinguish between underdoped and overdoped strange metals as two qualitatively different electronic states <ref:2608.03013#pg2>.

Mira: The paper suggests that the way they approach the scaling laws changes depending on whether you are in that underdoped regime or the overdoped regime <ref:2608.03013#pg2>.

Lev: So, it’s not a single theory for all strange metals; there are different physical pictures depending on where you are on the doping chart <ref:2608.03013#pg2>.

Conclusion: Kai: So, looking at this paper by Jian Xian Sim et al., it really ties together two major experimental observables in these strange metals: the energy scaling from photoemission and the spectral features from dielectric loss <ref:2608.03013#pg1>.

Mira: The main implication is that if this nonlocality mechanism is right, we can use the relationship between those two measurements to extract a fundamental parameter about how spatially extended those interactions are <ref:2608.03013#pg2>.

Lev: It shifts the origin of this observed scale covariance away from quantum criticality and towards spatial properties of the interaction itself <ref:2608.03013#pg2>.

Kai: In simple terms, they are saying that the strange metal behavior comes from how widely those interactions spread out in space rather than some kind of a sharp phase transition <ref:2608.03013#pg1>.

Mira: They provide a concrete tool: they show that you can compare the exponents you measure from ARPES and EELS to verify this spatial nonlocality hypothesis <ref:2608.03013#pg2>.

Lev: It gives us a specific physical picture to run against what we are trying to build for real hardware, focusing on how those spatial correlations affect the dynamics <ref:2608.03013#pg1>.

Kai: So, the work of Jian Xian Sim and his team suggests that understanding the underlying interaction geometry is key to unlocking the physics of these highTc materials <ref:2608.03013#pg2>.

Centre for Quantum Technologies, National University of Singapore · Yukawa Institute for Theoretical Physics, Kyoto University

cond-mat.str-el

Submitted: 2026-08-04

Updated: 2026-11-16

Comments: 8 pages, 2 figure v2 changes: Included EELS numerical plot and comparison to past T-EELS data from Nucker et al

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 85/100

The gist: Nonlocality can generate ω/T scaling without criticality in high Tc strange metals The paper proposes a mechanism involving nonlocality induced by poorly screened effective repulsions Vα(r) ∼…

Key concepts

Nonlocality
The central hypothesis is that high Tc strange metals are spatially nonlocal systems, meaning the electronic interactions depend on spatial separation in a way that goes beyond simple local descriptions. This nonlocality is introduced via long-ranged effective repulsions ($V_\alpha(r) \sim 1/r^\alpha$), which qualitatively changes how charge carriers behave and violate conventional hydrodynamic bounds.
$\omega/T$ Scaling
The paper develops a scale-covariant quasiparticle decay rate, $\Gamma(\omega, T) \propto T^\gamma \Phi(\omega/T)$, where $\gamma = 2 - 1/\alpha$. This scaling captures the energy and temperature dependence of quasiparticles in strange metals across different doping levels, providing a specific signature that can be measured experimentally.
Experimental Falsification
The theory predicts a direct test by comparing ARPES and EELS measurements. Specifically, it suggests that for $1 < \alpha < 2$, the independently extracted exponents from ARPES self-energy ($\gamma_{expt}$) and EELS dielectric loss ($\alpha_{EELS}$) must be equal, providing a concrete way to verify the nonlocality hypothesis.
Dielectric Loss Peak
The paper calculates a unique prediction for the dielectric loss function, $\omega^* = D_\alpha q^\alpha + Dq^2$. This formula relates the peak frequency ($\omega^*$) to momentum ($q$) and the nonlocality exponent ($\alpha$), allowing researchers to extract $\alpha_{EELS}$ from EELS data and compare it with ARPES results.

Terminology

Summary

Nonlocality can generate ω/T scaling without criticality in high Tc strange metals The paper proposes a mechanism involving nonlocality induced by poorly screened effective repulsions Vα(r) ∼ 1/rα, where a continuously doping-dependent exponent 1 ≤ α ≤ 3 interpolates between the Mott insulating and Fermi liquid limits

The Core Hypothesis

The central idea is that high Tc strange metals are spatially nonlocal systems rather than local ones. The authors argue that long-ranged poorly screened interactions Vα(r) ∼ 1/rα where α < 2 can qualitatively alter the structure, violating conventional hydrodynamics and information-propagation bounds. p. 0 This nonlocality is introduced as a phenomenological hypothesis for hydrodynamic screening in Eqn 2, exploiting the fact that diffusive hydrodynamics is generally violated for α < 2. p. 0

Phenomenology of Scaling Laws

The paper develops a scale-covariant quasiparticle decay rate Γ(ω, T) ∝ TγΦ(ω/T) in energy ω and temperature T, with γ = 2 − 1/α for nonlocal 1 < α < 2. This result naturally captures the optimally doped to overdoped regimes, while the underdoped regime is qualitatively distinct. p. 0 The scaling dimension γ is defined as γ = 2β for the underdoped regime. p. 1

Experimental Falsification Strategy

To test this theory, the authors propose a direct experimental falsification by cross-referencing photoemission and momentum-resolved loss spectroscopy measurements. They suggest that for each sample, the idealized 2D model predicts αARP ES = αEELS. p. 0 This relationship is captured by the prediction that ARPES self energy = EELS dielectric loss L(q, ω) drifting peak data at small q in fine steps. p. 0

Implications for Different Regimes

The theory distinguishes between underdoped and overdoped strange metals as qualitatively distinct electronic states. Near optimal doping, the theory approaches linear scaling laws characteristic of a marginal liquid when β = 0. p. 15. The result indicates that the effective repulsion has ∼ 1/r decay law around optimal doping, specifically p ∼ 0. p. 216−0.17 for Reber et al [14]. p. 2

Dielectric Loss Prediction

The paper provides a prediction for the dielectric loss function L(q, ω) ≡ −Im[ϵ−1(q, ω)] that is unique to this hydrodynamic screening. A direct calculation gives a dielectric loss peak ω∗ = Dαqα + Dq2 if one scans over energy at a fixed momentum. p. 3 This relation allows for the extraction of αEELS from the slope of EELS data and comparison with ARPES results. p. 3

Conclusion on Nonlocality

The theory suggests that scale covariance arises from spatial nonlocality rather than quantum criticality. The nonlocality theory has a direct experimental falsification test due to the common hydrodynamic origin of one and two-particle response functions. p. 3 The theory prioritizes intermediate frequencies and momenta, where scale-covariant behavior arises through a mesoscopic middle way. p. 3

Acknowledgements

The authors thank Hideaki Nishikawa for introducing me to hydrodynamics when I visited RIKEN Kuwahara Group, Lin Er Chow for discussions on materials physics, and Kridsanaphong Limtragool for discussing his unparticles and nonlocality thesis. The paper is supported by the CQT Young Researcher Career Development Grant and the National Quantum Scholarships Scheme by the Centre for Quantum Technologies in Singapore. p. 3

References

[1] J. Zaanen, A modern, but way too short history of the theory of superconductivity at a high temperature (2011), arXiv:1012. p. 35461 [cond-mat. p. 3supr-con]

[2] L. D. Landau, Sov. p. 3 Phys. JETP 3, 920 (1957)

[4] J. Bardeen, L. p. 3 N. Cooper, and J. p. 3 R. Schrieffer, Physical Review 108, 1175 (1957)

[5] S. A. Hartnoll and A. p. 3 P. Mackenzie, Reviews of Modern Physics 94, 10. p. 31103/revmodphys. p. 394.041002 (2022)

[6] Y. Gu, X.-L. Qi, and D. Stanford, Journal of High Energy Physics 2017, 10. p. 31007/jhep05(2017)125 (2017)

[9] E. H. Lieb and D. p. 3 W. Robinson, Communications in Mathematical Physics 28, 251 (1972)

[14] T. J. Reber, X. Zhou, N. C. Plumb, S. Parham, J. A. Waugh, Y. Cao, Z. Sun, H. Li, Q Wang, J S Wen, Z J Xu

[15] S Smit, E Mauri, L Bawden F Heringa F Gerritsen E van Heumen Y K Huang T Kondo T Takeuchi N Hussey M Allan T Kim C Cacho A Krikun K Schalm H Stoof M Golden Nature Communications 15, 10.1038/s41467-024-48594-6 (2024)

[16] V J Emery, Phys. Rev. Lett. 58, 2794 (1987)

[17] H Lange, L Qiu R Groth A von Haaren L Muscarella T Franz I Bloch F Grusdt P M Preiss A Bohrdt Realizing the emery model in optical lattices for quantum simulation of cuprates and nickelates (2026) arXiv:2603.11037 [cond-mat. p. 4quant-gas]

[18] E I Kiselev, Physical Review B 103, 10.1103/physrevb. p. 4103.235116 (2021)

[24] This form follows directly from charge conservation, hydrodynamics, and linear response

[45] To rephrase things, the physical assumption we make here is that the anomalous in-plane interaction and the ordinary three-dimensional layered Coulomb field should be regarded as separate sectors

[47] The main assumption we make here is ordinary 3D Coulomb interaction between planes, since the partial Vα screening is an in-plane phenomenon

[49] This corresponds to the optimal to overdoped regime where the phenomenology is most applicable

[51] The largest experimentally fitted exponent γexpt ∼ 1.68 in [15], at p ∼ 0.29 outside the superconducting dome

[7] J Zaanen, Advances in Physics 73, 1 (2024)

[8] A A Patel J McGreevy D Arovas and S Sachdev Physical Review X 8, 10.1103/physrevx. p. 3 p. 3 p. 38.021049 (2018)

[9] E H Lieb and D W Robinson Communications in Mathematical Physics 28, 251 (1972)

[44] A L Fetter Annals of Physics 88, 1 (1974)

[45] To rephrase things, the physical assumption we make here is that the anomalous in-plane interaction and the ordinary three-dimensional layered Coulomb field should be regarded as separate sectors

[47] The main assumption we make here is ordinary 3D Coulomb interaction between planes, since the partial Vα screening is an in-plane phenomenon

[52] This corresponds to the optimal to overdoped regime where the phenomenology is most applicable

[54] The largest experimentally fitted exponent γexpt ∼ 1.68 in [15], at p ∼ 0.29 outside the superconducting dome

[7] J Zaanen, Advances in Physics 73, 1 (2024)

[8] A A Patel J McGreevy D Arovas and S Sachdev Physical Review X 8, 10.1103/physrevx.8.021049 (2608. p. 0 p. 003)

[9] E H Lieb and D W Robinson Communications in Mathematical Physics 28, 251 (1972)

[44] A L Fetter Annals of Physics 88, 1 (1974)

[55] The largest experimentally fitted exponent γexpt ∼ 1.68 in [15], at p ∼ 0.29 outside the superconducting dome

[7] J Zaanen, Advances in Physics 73, 1 (2024)

[8] A A Patel J McGreevy D Arovas and S Sachdev Physical Review X 8, 10.1103/physrevx.8.021049 (2608.03)

[9] E H Lieb and D W Robinson Communications in Mathematical Physics 28, 251 (1972)

[44] A L Fetter Annals of Physics 88, 1 (1974)

[55] The largest experimentally fitted exponent γexpt ∼ 1.68 in [15], at p ∼ 0.29 outside the superconducting dome

Where the gains come from

The key physical insight is that longer-ranged interactions couple charge carriers to a broader spectrum of superdiffusive charge-density relaxation modes, enhancing inelastic scattering and shortening quasiparticle lifetimes. This leads to the scale-covariant quasiparticle decay rate Γinel(kF, ω, T) = AγTγΦγωT in Eqn 6. p. 0 The scale-covariance emerges because the integrand scales as qomegaImWR(qomega, omega) ∼ omega(1-1/α) integrating over energy transfer yields an energy scaling dimension γ = 2 − 1/α. p. 2

Falsification and Testing

The theory provides a direct experimental falsification test by comparing ARPES and EELS measurements. The authors predict a relationship between independently extracted exponents: αARP ES = 1/2 - γARP ES = d ln ω∗ / d ln q = αEELS. p. 3 This implies that at each fixed doping for which 1 < α < 2, the exponents extracted independently from ARPES and EELS must agree. p. 3

Underdoped Limitations

The derivation of Eqn 6 is only valid for α > 1 and cannot be quantitatively extrapolated into the underdoped regime where β ∼ 0.34 at p ∼ 0.09. The authors expect that α = 1 saturates the bare Coulomb decay law across the underdoped regime. p. 2

Dielectric Loss Peak Tracking

The dielectric loss peak is known to be anomalously broad around 1eV, and this is explained by the layered structure of cuprates. The formula for the loss peak (which from our theory is extremely broad, the ideal 2D model has FW HM ∼ 3. p. 65 and thus cannot be defensibly called a plasmon) is ω∗ = 4πe2σϵd + Dαqα + (D + πe2σd/3ϵ)q2 + O(q4). p. 6 This relation provides an independent extraction of Dα, thus in the context of our theory one can obtain Dα(T) through observations of the shifting loss function peak ω∗ with T at small q << d−1. p. 6

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improve experimental validation protocols by requiring cross-referencing of ARPES nodal self-energy fitting with momentum-resolved electron energy loss spectroscopy measurements to find alphaARP ES and alphaEELS, as proposed in Fig 1. This allows for direct experimental falsification of the nonlocality hypothesis mentioned in the Introduction.

  2. Develop a predictive model for dielectric loss function L(q, omega) based on Eqn 2, which relates directly to measurable EELS data. The improved system can then extract alphaEELS from the slope of the momentum-resolved loss spectroscopy data and compare it to alphaARP ES using the predicted relationship in Eqn 7.

  3. Implement a method to distinguish between underdoped and overdoped strange metals based on hydrodynamic screening predictions. The improved AI system can analyze whether spectroscopic exponents match the scale-covariant quasiparticle decay rate derived from Eqn 6, which is expected for the optimal to overdoped regime.

  4. Incorporate temperature dependence into the scaling dimension γ by modifying Eqn 6 to include a term like (1/alpha - 1) delta, as suggested in Eqn 21. This allows the system to account for temperature-dependent diffusion coefficients D alpha(T) and provides a more physically realistic interpretation of experimental data.

  5. Enhance the analysis of momentum-resolved electron energy loss spectroscopy by tracking the shifting loss function peak omega star with temperature at small q values, as described in Eqn 24. This allows for an independent extraction of D alpha and subsequent determination of D alpha(T) through observations of how this peak shifts with T.

Sources

Related papers