Greedy-Like Defective Coloring: Distributed Algorithms and Applications

arXiv:2608.02386 · cs.DC · Submitted 2026-08-03 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Computer Science. The day in computer science: software, systems and theory on arXiv.

Tom: We're looking at the paper: "Greedy-Like Defective Coloring".

Jane: Here's the gist of the paper. A d-defective c-coloring of a graph G = (V, E) is a coloring of the nodes V with c colors such that every node has at most d neighbors of the same color.

Tom: The central difficulty in understanding the distributed complexity of defective colorings lies in determining whether certain problems can be solved in time O(* n) or require omega(n) rounds.

Jane: The paper investigates the effectiveness of a greedy-like two-pass algorithm for computing defective colorings, generalizing this approach to the list defective coloring problem.

Tom: This generalization yields an alternative algorithm for computing a proper (delta + 1) -coloring in O(sqrt delta tilde) + O(* n) rounds within the CONGEST model.

Title and authors: Tom: So we're looking at this paper, "Greedy-Like Defective Coloring: Distributed Algorithms and Applications," and the authors are Marc Fuchs from the University of Freiburg and Fabian Kuhn from the same university. I think that title tells us right away what this is about: taking a standard coloring problem, which is already tricky in a distributed system, and adding a twist—defects—and then figuring out how to solve it using distributed algorithms.

Jane: It sounds like they're tackling defective colorings where every node can have at most some number of neighbors with the same color. The authors are suggesting that this problem has important implications for other types of distributed graph algorithms because it touches on the core challenge of when a coloring problem is solvable in just a few communication rounds versus needing a huge number of rounds.

Lu: Yeah, I'm interested in how they frame the difficulty around that round complexity question, because understanding if you need logarithmic rounds or maybe polynomial rounds is fundamental to whether you can even solve something efficiently in this model.

Meng: From my side, it sounds like they are looking at a way to improve existing distributed coloring algorithms by incorporating this defect constraint. I wonder if this approach is practical for deploying colorings on large, real-world networks where communication rounds are strictly limited.

Lalam: I see they are focusing on the distributed complexity aspect right from the start, which is crucial because in these settings, the time it takes to communicate often dictates what kind of algorithm you can even run successfully.

The paper's summary: Tom: So, this paper goes into detail about a specific method called a greedy-like two-pass algorithm and generalizes it to the list defective coloring problem. Essentially, they are trying to find a better way to compute these colorings in the distributed setting than what was previously known.

Jane: It seems like they present this two-pass approach as an alternative way to get a proper coloring, but with the added constraint that we only care about having at most some number of same-colored neighbors for each node. They explore how this specific algorithm performs when you change the number of available colors or the degree of the graph.

Lu: What I find interesting is their focus on optimizing the defect as a function of the number of colors, because they show that this method can improve things in certain scenarios, even though it has inherent limitations when we fix how many colors we are using.

Meng: If this method can actually reduce the required rounds or improve the quality of the coloring under certain conditions, then it might mean something for deploying colorings on massive graphs where communication is a bottleneck. I'm curious about what happens to its runtime when you look at very large graphs with high degrees.

Lalam: The summary emphasizes that they are not just doing a simple coloring; they are looking at how the defect level changes based on the number of colors and how that relates back to the maximum degree of the graph, which is key for understanding these problems.

The paper's improvements: Tom: So, one of the main things they highlight is a specific improvement they get by using this two-pass algorithm—it yields an alternative algorithm for computing a proper coloring with a defect level of at most some value in round complexity that is O square root of the maximum degree plus something logarithmic in n.

Jane: That's quite concrete, so it moves us away from potentially much worse complexities and suggests we can achieve this level of quality within a manageable number of communication rounds. I'm curious about the specific complexity bound they are aiming for when they apply this to list defective coloring.

Lu: They extend the approach to oriented list defective coloring, which is a more complex version, and they manage to get a deterministic algorithm in the CONGEST model with round complexity of O square root of the maximum degree plus something logarithmic in n. That extension shows that their core idea is quite versatile.

Meng: But I'm also seeing some intrinsic limitations they prove, showing that this specific two-sweep algorithm can't guarantee a defect lower than something like one over the square root of the number of colors when using a fixed set of candidate colors. That’s a warning if we’re thinking about deploying this in production where we need strict quality guarantees.

Lalam: The analysis around the Two-Bucket Two-Sweep Algorithm is pretty detailed, showing how they can achieve lower bounds on the defect when the number of colors C is square, and they even give asymptotic bounds for when C isn't a perfect square.

Conclusion: Tom: So, to wrap up this paper on "Greedy-Like Defective Coloring: Distributed Algorithms and Applications," they’ve shown that the two-pass method gives us a constructive way to compute colorings with a bounded defect in round complexity O square root of the maximum degree plus logarithmic terms.

Jane: The big picture here is that this algorithm provides a deterministic approach for solving these coloring problems, and it sets some hard limits on how good the defect can be relative to the number of colors you choose.

Lu: They also provide a final complexity result for (delta + one) -coloring in any graph with bounded neighborhood independence, giving us bounds that depend on whether we are looking at something like theta or just the maximum degree delta <ref:2608.02386#pg1>.

Meng: From an engineering standpoint, this means we have a deterministic algorithm that runs in O theta two delta one/four rounds under certain conditions, which is much better than what we might expect from purely randomized approaches at scale <ref:2608.02386#pg2>.

Lalam: It’s important to remember that they also showed that if you use a fixed common candidate family, the method cannot surpass the one over square root of C relative defect barrier when employing a deterministic global tie-breaking rule based solely on local neighbor counts.

Tom: So, in short, they've provided a solid distributed algorithm for defective coloring with complexity around square root of degree, but we still have to be careful about the quality limits depending on the number of colors C. That’s what this paper is about.

Marc Fuchs, Fabian Kuhn

University of Freiburg

cs.DC

Submitted: 2026-08-03

Updated: 2026-11-06

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 93/100

The gist: A d-defective c-coloring of a graph G = (V, E) is a coloring of the nodes V with c colors such that every node has at most d neighbors of the same color.

Key concepts

Two-Sweep Algorithm
This algorithm has two phases: Phase I selects candidate color sets based on minimizing a defect upper bound, and Phase II chooses the final color by balancing neighbors with smaller versus larger input colors. It is the core mechanism for computing defective colorings.
List Defective Coloring
This problem involves coloring nodes such that each node has at most $d$ neighbors of the same color, while also respecting pre-assigned lists of available colors for each node. The paper extends its techniques to solve this more complex version.
CONGEST Model
This is a distributed computing model where nodes communicate by sending messages to their immediate neighbors in a graph. The complexity analysis focuses on how many rounds of communication are needed to achieve the coloring goal under these constraints.
Relative Defect Barrier
This refers to the inherent limitation on how small the defect (the maximum number of same-colored neighbors) can be made as the maximum degree $\Delta$ increases. The paper proves that for certain fixed color counts, this barrier is around $1/\sqrt{C}.

Terminology

Summary

A d-defective c-coloring of a graph G = (V, E) is a coloring of the nodes V with c colors such that every node has at most d neighbors of the same color. p. 0 The central difficulty in understanding the distributed complexity of defective colorings lies in determining whether certain problems can be solved in time O(* n) or require omega(n) rounds. p. 0

The paper investigates the effectiveness of a greedy-like two-pass algorithm for computing defective colorings, generalizing this approach to the list defective coloring problem. p. 0 This generalization yields an alternative algorithm for computing a proper (delta + 1) -coloring in O(sqrt delta tilde) + O(* n) rounds within the CONGEST model. p. 0 Furthermore, when applied to standard defective colorings with a fixed number of colors c, the generalized two-pass algorithm is shown to improve the defect for specific scenarios. p. 0 Crucially, it is demonstrated that for any fixed c at least 1, this generalized two-pass algorithm cannot guarantee a c-coloring with a defect less than (1 - o(1)) times delta/sqrt c as delta tends to infinity. p. 0

The core mechanism is the Two-Sweep Algorithm, which comprises two distinct phases: Phase I and Phase II. p. 4 In Phase I, nodes select candidate color sets by minimizing an averaging-based upper bound on the defect that the subsequent second pass can guarantee. p. 5 In Phase II, nodes choose a final color by minimizing a sum of terms related to neighbors possessing smaller input colors versus those with larger input colors. p. 5

The contributions are multifaceted:

  1. Algorithm Extension: The approach is extended successfully to oriented list defective coloring (OLDC), resulting in a new deterministic (delta + 1) -coloring algorithm in the CONGEST model with round complexity O(sqrt delta tilde) + O(* n).

  2. Intrinsic Limitations: The paper establishes intrinsic limitations, proving that the Two-Sweep Algorithm cannot surpass the 1/sqrt C relative-defect barrier when employing a fixed common candidate family and a deterministic global tie-breaking rule based solely on local neighbor counts (Theorem 2.5).

  3. Relative Defect Bounds: Analysis of the Two-Bucket Two-Sweep Algorithm provides upper bounds on the relative defect achievable, showing that for square C, it attains the 1/sqrt C lower bound established in Theorem 2.5, and providing asymptotic bounds for non-square C in Theorem 2. p. 27.

  4. Greedy Efficiency: It is shown that a d-defective c-coloring can be computed efficiently by a simple greedy-like algorithm if sqrt c(d + 1) > alpha delta for some constant alpha > 1, an extension valid in the list defective coloring setting.

  5. Final Complexity Result: Theorem 2.4 provides the final result, offering a deterministic CONGEST algorithm to solve (delta + 1) -coloring in any n-node graph with maximum degree delta and neighborhood independence at most theta, with a round complexity of (theta delta)O(delta) or O theta 2 delta 1/4 + O(* n). p. 9

The technical details include the analysis for OLDC, the construction of realizable palettes and later colors, and a proof for Theorem 2. p. 15 utilizing a numerical obstruction in finite undirected trees. p. 1 The complexity analysis confirms implementability in the CONGEST model when color space and initial color space are polynomial in n. p. 7 The results also establish bounds on achievable relative defect as a function of C, showing convergence towards 1/sqrt C for large C (Theorem 2. p. 57).

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Distributed coloring algorithms can achieve (degree + 1)-coloring in O(sqrt(Delta) + log star n) rounds in the CONGEST model for graphs of bounded neighborhood independence with a constant neighborhood independence theta. This allows AI systems to efficiently color complex network topologies under communication constraints while maintaining a low defect rate.

  2. The Two-Sweep Algorithm, when applied recursively using color space reduction, can solve oriented list defective coloring instances deterministically in O(log3 C + log C log star n) rounds with message sizes of O(log q + log C) bits in CONGEST. This enables the AI system to handle list coloring problems where node lists are large by breaking them down recursively.

  3. For a fixed number of colors C, the Two-Bucket Two-Sweep Algorithm can improve the best known relative defect from 1/sqrt(C) to better bounds like 3/7 for C=6, demonstrating enhanced capability in finding near-optimal colorings for a given constraint on output colors.

  4. The algorithm provides a deterministic guarantee that for any fixed number of colors C, the relative defect is at most max(p/C, 1/p) when using the Single-Bucket Two-Sweep Algorithm with candidate family size p. This allows AI systems to reliably compute near-optimal defective colorings when the list size is bounded by a parameter p.

  5. The system can solve list arbdefective coloring instances on graphs of bounded neighborhood independence in O(sqrt(C) log Delta log3 C + log C log star n) rounds, even when using a relaxed slack condition S >= 1. This capability is crucial for AI applications requiring structured decompositions of graphs into lower degree components.

Sources

Related papers