Photon-Tagged Energy Flow in Inclusive Endpoint B Decays

arXiv:2607.27367 · hep-ph, hep-ex · Submitted 2026-07-29 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Photon-Tagged Energy Flow in Inclusive Endpoint B Decays".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Photon-Tagged Energy Flow in Inclusive Endpoint B Decays introduces a B-decay tagged energy correlator (BTEC) to resolve the angular structure of energy flow in inclusive B decays in the endpoint region, focusing on the direct-photon contribution to B → Xsγ Leading Power Factorization The leading-power factorization relation is derived by showing that a measurement acts only on the collinear sector at leading power and then using the Bauer–Pirjol–Stewart (BPS) field redefinition to separate the collinear and soft matrix elements B.

Kai: The factorization relation is restricted to the direct O7 contribution in the endpoint region P+ ∼ ΛQCD and at the natural collinear angular scale s ∼ τ ∼ QΛQCD ≪ Q2 B, with the measurement made relative to the fixed photon-defined axis >.

Mira: The leading shape function remains one-dimensional and universal, but the measured jet kernel maps the same nonperturbative input into a family of observable (Eγ, τ) distributions B.

Kai: How the training signal is built The BTEC observable is defined as the photon-energy and angular double-differential decay spectrum B.

Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper by Shuai Zhao called "Photon-Tagged Energy Flow in Inclusive Endpoint B Decays" and it introduces this new tool called the B-decay tagged energy correlator or BTEC.

Mira: It seems like the main goal here is to sort out the angular structure of energy flow in inclusive B decays specifically in that endpoint region, focusing on how that direct photon contribution to B to X s gamma works.

Kai: Right, so what they claim is that at leading power and at this natural collinear angular scale tau similar to s being similar to Q lambda squared the measurement can be factored into a standard hard coefficient and a specific B meson shape function along with this new measured quark jet function.

Lev: And that's an important distinction because it says no brand new leading power nonperturbative functions are introduced, which is good for running on real hardware.

Mira: They calculate this measured jet function at one loop accuracy and they show that when you integrate its angular dependence over all angles, it reproduces the standard inclusive quark jet function.

Kai: That's a strong check because it means the new angular information they are measuring is consistent with what we already know about the inclusive spectrum.

Lev: But they also note that this factorization relation breaks down in a region where tau is dimension two times lambda squared, which is where soft transverse momentum becomes leading and you need something more like TMD shape information.

Mira: And to get that angular dependence, they define this new quark jet function as a cut operator matrix element and calculate it at one loop as a distribution in the variables s and tau.

Kai: They give us a specific mathematical expression for this measured jet function when s and tau are positive, showing that the angular dependence is encoded in something called the dimensionless function g of r where r is tau over s.

Lev: That function g of r actually contains some new angular information, which is what they're trying to probe beyond just looking at the standard inclusive spectrum.

Mira: The paper also does a closure test by comparing photon spectra and cumulatives to infer a posterior shape function from the ordinary photon spectrum, and they find that leading power endpoint factorization predicts zero change in this inferred shape function up to power corrections.

Kai: That closure test is basically asking if the shape function calibrated by looking at everything else also describes these angularly resolved projections.

Lev: If there's a nonzero residual in that test after propagating uncertainties, it suggests an incomplete leading power description but it doesn't point to a specific subleading mechanism yet.

Mira: The paper suggests this approach might improve the separation of signals from backgrounds that have different angular profiles.

Kai: And they do show some illustrative numerical benchmarks, for example with the Bosch Lange Neubert Paz parameter set, where an illustrative one loop calculation shows a three to sixteen percent migration outside the common cuts tau c equal to two to four giga-electron volts squared.

Lev: That migration is clearly dependent on which specific photon energy bin you are looking at, which is a caveat we have to consider when translating this to real data.

Mira: And they show that for a cut of tau c equal to three giga-electron volts squared, the one loop kernel places about four point one percent, seven point three percent, and twelve point two percent of the normalized weight above that cut across those different bins.

Kai: So what this means for us is that this angular information resolves the internal energy flow of that inclusive recoil jet in a way that goes beyond just the ordinary spectrum we see.

Lev: And they mention that they can transfer this measured jet framework to the endpoint region of B to X u l nu bar decays, provided you fix the recoil direction and keep transverse momentum balance power suppressed at the natural angular scale.

Mira: That sounds like a nice extension because it suggests this same measurement technique could apply to semileptonic decays too, using the same measured light-quark jet function and leading shape function.

Kai: The authors state that the exact constraint gives p X sub n perpendicular equal negative k x s perpendicular similar to lambda squared, which sets the resolution of the collinear function.

Lev: And they also give a specific constraint on transverse momentum reduction where two relative corrections are about zero point plus order two lambda squared tau factorial and order two lambda squared s factorial.

Mira: So what we have here is a framework that uses this photon-tagged correlator to probe structure in B decays that goes beyond the standard inclusive measurements.

Kai: And the final result of this work is that the angular information resolves the internal energy flow of the inclusive recoil jet beyond just what we see in the ordinary spectrum and it might help us separate signals from backgrounds with different angular profiles.

Conclusion: Kai: So, we're wrapping up on "Photon-Tagged Energy Flow in Inclusive Endpoint B Decays."

Mira: It boils down to them building this new tool, a B decay tagged energy correlator or BTEC, to look at the angular structure of energy flow in those specific endpoint regions of inclusive B decays.

Lev: They're focusing on how the direct photon contribution to that decay works.

Kai: What they did is take that measurement and factor it apart at leading power. They show it breaks down into a standard hard coefficient, the same shape function we already use for the inclusive photon spectrum, and this new measured quark jet function.

Mira: That means they're not introducing a whole new set of nonperturbative inputs; they're just measuring how that existing input behaves when you resolve it angularly.

Lev: And they calculate this new jet function at one loop accuracy. It’s a real check on the theory because it shows the angular information is encoded in something called a dimensionless function g of r, where r is tau over s.

Kai: That function g of r actually contains the new angular information they're trying to pull out beyond just looking at the standard inclusive spectrum.

Mira: They also ran this closure test comparing photon spectra to fixed cut cumulatives and found that leading power endpoint factorization predicts zero change in the inferred shape function, which is a tight constraint on their model.

Lev: But they flag a breakdown region where tau is dimension two times lambda squared, which tells them they need something like TMD shape information there.

Kai: So, the main implication here is that this angular measurement resolves the internal energy flow of the inclusive recoil jet beyond what we see in the ordinary spectrum.

Mira: It could actually help us separate signals from backgrounds that have different angular profiles, which is a real practical benefit for experiments.

Lev: The next quantitative step they point to involves doing a covariance aware closure analysis including scale variations and subleading shape functions.

Shuai Zhao

Tianjin University

hep-ph, hep-ex

Submitted: 2026-07-29

Updated: 2026-07-29

Comments: 23 pages, 5 figures, 1 table

Journal ref: JHEP11(2026)028

DOI: 10.1007/JHEP11(2026)028

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 80/100

The gist: Photon-Tagged Energy Flow in Inclusive Endpoint B Decays introduces a B-decay tagged energy correlator (BTEC) to resolve the angular structure of energy flow in inclusive B decays in the endpoint…

Key concepts

BTEC
The photon-energy and angular double-differential decay spectrum used as an observable. It is designed to resolve the angular structure of energy flow in inclusive B decays, particularly in the endpoint region where direct-photon contributions are important.
Leading Power Factorization
A theoretical framework showing that measurements at leading power only depend on the collinear sector. This allows separating matrix elements using field redefinitions, simplifying the calculation by restricting analysis to specific angular scales and kinematic regions.
Shape Function (SbB)
A universal one-dimensional nonperturbative input function derived from factorization. It describes the leading-power behavior of energy flow in inclusive B decays. The measured jet kernel maps this input into observable distributions like Eγ and τ.
Jet Function (Jq_TEC)
A new measured quark jet function calculated perturbatively in the hard-collinear region. It encodes angular dependence, with its one-loop result containing a dimensionless function g(r) that captures the angular information of the energy flow.

Terminology

Summary

Photon-Tagged Energy Flow in Inclusive Endpoint B Decays introduces a B-decay tagged energy correlator (BTEC) to resolve the angular structure of energy flow in inclusive B decays in the endpoint region, focusing on the direct-photon contribution to B → Xsγ

Leading Power Factorization

The leading-power factorization relation is derived by showing that a measurement acts only on the collinear sector at leading power and then using the Bauer–Pirjol–Stewart (BPS) field redefinition to separate the collinear and soft matrix elements B. The factorization relation is restricted to the direct O7 contribution in the endpoint region P+ ∼ ΛQCD and at the natural collinear angular scale s ∼ τ ∼ QΛQCD ≪ Q2 B, with the measurement made relative to the fixed photon-defined axis >. p. 1

Where the paper says it

We define this function as a cut operator matrix element, calculate it at one loop as a distribution in (s, τ ), where τ is a dimension-two angular variable, and verify that its inclusive projection reproduces the standard quark jet function. The factorization relation is restricted to the direct O7 contribution in the endpoint region P+ ∼ ΛQCD and at the natural collinear angular scale s ∼ τ ∼ QΛQCD ≪ Q2 , with the measurement made relative to the fixed photon-defined axis.

The leading shape function remains one-dimensional and universal, but the measured jet kernel maps the same nonperturbative input into a family of observable (Eγ, τ) distributions B. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The BTEC provides an angularly resolved view of endpoint dynamics that the ordinary inclusive spectrum projects onto a one-dimensional convolution. The leading shape function remains one-dimensional and universal, but the measured jet kernel maps the same nonperturbative input into a family of observable (Eγ, τ ) distributions.

How the training signal is built

The BTEC observable is defined as the photon-energy and angular double-differential decay spectrum B. The leading-power factorization relation is given by Eq. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Photon-Tagged Energy Flow in Inclusive Endpoint B Decays Shuai Zhao∗ Department of Physics and Center for Joint Quantum Studies, School of Science, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300350, China (Dated: July 31, 2026) We introduce a B-decay tagged energy correlator (BTEC) to resolve the angular structure of energy flow in inclusive B decays in the endpoint region, focusing on the direct-photon contribution to B → Xsγ. At leading power and at the natural collinear angular scale τ ∼ s ∼ QΛQCD, we derive a factorization relation involving the standard hard coefficient and B-meson shape function together with a new measured quark jet function; no new leading-power nonperturbative function is introduced.

(45), which relates the differential decay rate to the hard coefficient, the shape function SbB, and a new measured quark jet function Jq TEC B. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Photon-Tagged Energy Flow in Inclusive Endpoint B Decays Shuai Zhao∗ Department of Physics and Center for Joint Quantum Studies, School of Science, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300350, China (Dated: July 31, 2026) We introduce a B-decay tagged energy correlator (BTEC) to resolve the angular structure of energy flow in inclusive B decays in the endpoint region, focusing on the direct-photon contribution to B → Xsγ. At leading power and at the natural collinear angular scale τ ∼ s ∼ QΛQCD, we derive a factorization relation involving the standard hard coefficient and B-meson shape function together with a new measured quark jet function; no new leading-power nonperturbative function is introduced.

This relation applies at the natural collinear angular scale; it breaks down in the parametrically smaller region τ ∼ Λ2QCD, where soft transverse momentum becomes leading and TMD-like shape information is required B. p. 1
Where the paper says it

At τ ∼ Λ 2 QCD, soft–collinear transverse-momentum balance becomes leading and a TMD-like soft function is required. This parametrically smaller-angle regime lies beyond the present analysis.

Where the gains come from

The measured jet function Jq TEC can be calculated with perturbation theory in the hard-collinear region B. The one-loop result for Jq TEC is given by Eq. p. 1

Where the paper says it

III gives the leading-power factorization derivation as a self-contained part of the main text. IV and V present the one-loop result and the renormalization-group evolution of the measured jet function, respectively.

(54), which shows that for s, τ > 0, Jq R TEC(s, τ) = αsCF/(2π)Eγϵ/s 2+ϵgϵτ/s B. p. 9
Where the paper says it

(50) into Eqs. (52) and (53), then performing the x integral for each of the two measurement terms gives, for s, τ > 0, J q,R TEC(s, τ ) = αsCF 2π e γEϵ Γ(1 − ϵ) µ 2ϵ s 2+ϵ gϵ τ s , (54) where gϵ(r) = r −ϵ (1 + r) 4−2ϵ 2 r + 3 + 3r + 2r 2 − ϵ(1 + r) .

The angular dependence is encoded in the dimensionless function g(r), with r = τ / s B. p. 1
Where the paper says it

We focus on the direct O7 contribution to B → Xsγ at the natural collinear angular scale and derive the leading-power factorization relation, by showing that the measurement acts only on the collinear sector at leading power and then using the Bauer–Pirjol–Stewart (BPS) field redefinition [4] to separate the collinear and soft matrix elements. We will demonstrate that the tagged angular measurement preserves the standard leading B-meson shape function, while the new angular dependence is encoded in a measured quark jet function.

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The closure test of endpoint factorization compares the photon spectrum and the cumulatives in Eq. (82) to infer a posterior SbpostB from the ordinary photon spectrum B. p. 0

Where the paper says it

With an independently constrained shape function, the angular cumulatives provide a closure test of leading-power endpoint factorization and are sensitive to directO7 power corrections and resolved-photon effects. The BTEC thereby adds information on the angular structure of the inclusive recoil jet beyond the ordinary photon spectrum and may improve signal–background discrimination when their energy-flow profiles differ.

After correlated theoretical and experimental uncertainties are propagated, leading-power endpoint factorization predicts ∆i(τc) = 0 up to power corrections B. p. 0
Where the paper says it

For the central Bosch–Lange– Neubert–Paz parameter set, an illustrative benchmark gives 3 − 16% migration outside the fixed angular cuts τc = 2 − 4 GeV2 . With an independently constrained shape function, the angular cumulatives provide a closure test of leading-power endpoint factorization and are sensitive to directO7 power corrections and resolved-photon effects.

The test asks whether the shape function calibrated by the inclusive projection also describes its angularly resolved projections >. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The BTEC provides an angularly resolved view of endpoint dynamics that the ordinary inclusive spectrum projects onto a one-dimensional convolution. The leading shape function remains one-dimensional and universal, but the measured jet kernel maps the same nonperturbative input into a family of observable (Eγ, τ ) distributions.

Experimental feasibility

The required event topology is already available in hadronic-tag analyses of the inclusive photon spectrum at Belle II B. Fixed-cut cumulatives are the most robust first observables B. p. 1

Where the paper says it

IV and V present the one-loop result and the renormalization-group evolution of the measured jet function, respectively. VI constructs fixed-cut cumulatives, presents an illustrative numerical benchmark, and develops the closure test, experimental feasibility, and semileptonic extension.

The main practical limitations would be the efficiency of hadronic tagging, neutral-energy reconstruction, detector acceptance, and signal-side particle assignment >. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The photon direction is integrated over the full solid angle; detector acceptance and fiducial photon cuts are not part of the theoretical definition and can be applied separately. Thus TX(τ ) is the measurement function assigned to one hadronic state, whereas d 2Γ sγ BTEC/(dEγdτ ) is the ensemble observable to be measured in finite (Eγ, τ ) bins.

Semileptonic extension

Once the radiative construction has been tested, the same measured-jet framework can be transferred to the endpoint region of B → Xulν¯ B. The same measured light-quark jet function and leading shape function appear when the recoil direction is fixed by the nonhadronic system, the observable is azimuthally inclusive, and transverse-momentum balance remains power suppressed at the natural angular scale >. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Photon-Tagged Energy Flow in Inclusive Endpoint B Decays Shuai Zhao∗ Department of Physics and Center for Joint Quantum Studies, School of Science, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300350, China (Dated: July 31, 2026) We introduce a B-decay tagged energy correlator (BTEC) to resolve the angular structure of energy flow in inclusive B decays in the endpoint region, focusing on the direct-photon contribution to B → Xsγ. At leading power and at the natural collinear angular scale τ ∼ s ∼ QΛQCD, we derive a factorization relation involving the standard hard coefficient and B-meson shape function together with a new measured quark jet function; no new leading-power nonperturbative function is introduced.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Photon-Tagged Energy Flow in Inclusive Endpoint B Decays Shuai Zhao∗ Department of Physics and Center for Joint Quantum Studies, School of Science, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300350, China (Dated: July 31, 2026) We introduce a B-decay tagged energy correlator (BTEC) to resolve the angular structure of energy flow in inclusive B decays in the endpoint region, focusing on the direct-photon contribution to B → Xsγ. At leading power and at the natural collinear angular scale τ ∼ s ∼ QΛQCD, we derive a factorization relation involving the standard hard coefficient and B-meson shape function together with a new measured quark jet function; no new leading-power nonperturbative function is introduced.

Summary of Findings

The paper develops a photon-tagged one-point energy correlator for inclusive endpoint B decays B. For the directphoton contribution to B → Xsγ, the leading spectrum factorizes into the standard hard coefficient, the same universal hatted shape function SbB as in the photon spectrum, and a new measured quark jet function Jq TEC B. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Photon-Tagged Energy Flow in Inclusive Endpoint B Decays Shuai Zhao∗ Department of Physics and Center for Joint Quantum Studies, School of Science, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300350, China (Dated: July 31, 2026) We introduce a B-decay tagged energy correlator (BTEC) to resolve the angular structure of energy flow in inclusive B decays in the endpoint region, focusing on the direct-photon contribution to B → Xsγ. At leading power and at the natural collinear angular scale τ ∼ s ∼ QΛQCD, we derive a factorization relation involving the standard hard coefficient and B-meson shape function together with a new measured quark jet function; no new leading-power nonperturbative function is introduced.

The factorization relation applies at the natural collinear angular scale and breaks down in the parametrically smaller region τ ∼ Λ2QCD, where soft transverse momentum becomes leading and TMD-like shape information is required B. p. 1
Where the paper says it

At τ ∼ Λ 2 QCD, soft–collinear transverse-momentum balance becomes leading and a TMD-like soft function is required. This parametrically smaller-angle regime lies beyond the present analysis.

Bounded cumulatives with an outer boundary τc ∼ QΛQCD remain leading-power observables B. p. 0
Where the paper says it

For the central Bosch–Lange– Neubert–Paz parameter set, an illustrative benchmark gives 3 − 16% migration outside the fixed angular cuts τc = 2 − 4 GeV2 . With an independently constrained shape function, the angular cumulatives provide a closure test of leading-power endpoint factorization and are sensitive to directO7 power corrections and resolved-photon effects.

The angular effect enters only through migration across that boundary, while the accompanying invariant-mass shift is likewise suppressed by ΛQCD/Q B. p. 8
Where the paper says it

It applies at the natural collinear angular scale; the omitted terms include relative corrections of order ΛQCD/Q, s/Q2 , τ /Q2 , and Λ 2 QCD/τ . The last term is specific to the angular sensitivity to soft–collinear transverse-momentum balance; the accompanying invariant-mass shift is Λ 2 QCD/s and is already of order ΛQCD/Q in the endpoint region.

The calculated one-loop kernel g(r) contains the new angular information B. p. 0
Where the paper says it

At leading power and at the natural collinear angular scale τ ∼ s ∼ QΛQCD, we derive a factorization relation involving the standard hard coefficient and B-meson shape function together with a new measured quark jet function; no new leading-power nonperturbative function is introduced. We calculate the measured jet function at one-loop accuracy and verify that its angular integral reproduces the standard inclusive quark jet function.

The result satisfies the inclusive sum rule and ordinary quark-jet renormalization, and its angular plus prescription requires no additional joint endpoint subtraction B. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Photon-Tagged Energy Flow in Inclusive Endpoint B Decays Shuai Zhao∗ Department of Physics and Center for Joint Quantum Studies, School of Science, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300350, China (Dated: July 31, 2026) We introduce a B-decay tagged energy correlator (BTEC) to resolve the angular structure of energy flow in inclusive B decays in the endpoint region, focusing on the direct-photon contribution to B → Xsγ. At leading power and at the natural collinear angular scale τ ∼ s ∼ QΛQCD, we derive a factorization relation involving the standard hard coefficient and B-meson shape function together with a new measured quark jet function; no new leading-power nonperturbative function is introduced.

For the central BLNP shape-function model, our illustrative one-loop benchmark finds a 3–16% migration outside the common cuts 2 ≤ τc ≤ 4 GeV2 and a clear dependence on the photon-energy bin B. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We calculate the measured jet function at one-loop accuracy and verify that its angular integral reproduces the standard inclusive quark jet function. For the central Bosch–Lange– Neubert–Paz parameter set, an illustrative benchmark gives 3 − 16% migration outside the fixed angular cuts τc = 2 − 4 GeV2 .

The cumulative increases as the common angular boundary is opened and approaches the inclusive normalization B. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The first moment is thus essentially a rewriting of the hadronic invariant mass and supplies a nontrivial consistency check on a fixed-order calculation. Genuinely new angular information resides instead in the differential distribution or in a bounded cumulative for which the collinear expansion is uniform.

For a representative cut τc = 3 GeV2, the one-loop kernel places approximately 4. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We calculate the measured jet function at one-loop accuracy and verify that its angular integral reproduces the standard inclusive quark jet function. For the central Bosch–Lange– Neubert–Paz parameter set, an illustrative benchmark gives 3 − 16% migration outside the fixed angular cuts τc = 2 − 4 GeV2 .

1%, 7.3%, and 12.2% of the normalized weight above the cut across the three bins B>. p. 8
Where the paper says it

(43) Here the color trace is normalized by 1/Nc and NJ = 1 in our convention. The cut-state measure, momentum-projector Jacobian, and tree-level normalization are detailed in Appendix B.

The benchmark does not predict the pointwise spectrum at τ ∼ Λ2QCD; its complete integrated weight is supplied by the inclusive term in Eq. (81) B>. The final result is that the angular information resolves the internal energy flow of the inclusive recoil jet beyond the ordinary spectrum and may improve the separation of signals from backgrounds with different angular profiles >. p. 0
Where the paper says it

With an independently constrained shape function, the angular cumulatives provide a closure test of leading-power endpoint factorization and are sensitive to directO7 power corrections and resolved-photon effects. The BTEC thereby adds information on the angular structure of the inclusive recoil jet beyond the ordinary photon spectrum and may improve signal–background discrimination when their energy-flow profiles differ.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

With an independently constrained shape function, the angular cumulatives provide a closure test of leading-power endpoint factorization and are sensitive to directO7 power corrections and resolved-photon effects. The BTEC thereby adds information on the angular structure of the inclusive recoil jet beyond the ordinary photon spectrum and may improve signal–background discrimination when their energy-flow profiles differ.

The next quantitative step is a covariance-aware closure analysis including correlated scale variations, subleading shape functions, resolved-photon effects, experimental response, and power-correction nuisance parameters B>. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The factorization relation is restricted to the direct O7 contribution in the endpoint region P+ ∼ ΛQCD and at the natural collinear angular scale s ∼ τ ∼ QΛQCD ≪ Q2 , with the measurement made relative to the fixed photon-defined axis. Resolved-photon effects enter at subleading power and require additional soft and jet functions [52–55], while wide-angle energetic radiation requires matching beyond the leading collinear description.

Illustrative numerical benchmark

To illustrate the resolved angular tail in Eq. (81), we evaluate Eq. (82) in a transparent benchmark rather than a precision fit B. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The BTEC thereby adds information on the angular structure of the inclusive recoil jet beyond the ordinary photon spectrum and may improve signal–background discrimination when their energy-flow profiles differ. INTRODUCTION Inclusive heavy-flavor decays provide precision tests of the heavy-quark expansion and determine fundamental flavor parameters.

The ratio Ni/Di is expanded before numerical evaluation, and the one-loop numerator can be written as the inclusive coefficient minus a positive out-of-cut migration term B>. p. 1
Where the paper says it

IV and V present the one-loop result and the renormalization-group evolution of the measured jet function, respectively. VI constructs fixed-cut cumulatives, presents an illustrative numerical benchmark, and develops the closure test, experimental feasibility, and semileptonic extension.

The final NLO result is F NLOi(τc) = 1 − αs(µJ)CF/(2π)ZBi/dP+Z P+0dωSbmodB(P+) + Oα 2s B>. The benchmark does not predict the pointwise spectrum at τ ∼ Λ2QCD; its complete integrated weight is supplied by the inclusive term in Eq. (81) B>. The final result is that the angular information resolves the internal energy flow of the inclusive recoil jet beyond the ordinary spectrum and may improve the separation of signals from backgrounds with different angular profiles >.

Closure test of endpoint factorization

The closure test compares SbpostB derived from the ordinary photon spectrum to fixed-cut cumulatives B>. After correlated theoretical and experimental uncertainties are propagated, leading-power endpoint factorization predicts ∆i(τc) = 0 up to power corrections B>. p. 0

Where the paper says it

For the central Bosch–Lange– Neubert–Paz parameter set, an illustrative benchmark gives 3 − 16% migration outside the fixed angular cuts τc = 2 − 4 GeV2 . With an independently constrained shape function, the angular cumulatives provide a closure test of leading-power endpoint factorization and are sensitive to directO7 power corrections and resolved-photon effects.

A nonzero residual diagnoses an incomplete leading-power description but does not identify a unique subleading mechanism >. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The factorization relation is restricted to the direct O7 contribution in the endpoint region P+ ∼ ΛQCD and at the natural collinear angular scale s ∼ τ ∼ QΛQCD ≪ Q2 , with the measurement made relative to the fixed photon-defined axis. Resolved-photon effects enter at subleading power and require additional soft and jet functions [52–55], while wide-angle energetic radiation requires matching beyond the leading collinear description.

Transverse-momentum reduction and its accuracy

The exact constraint gives pXn⊥ = −kXs⊥ ∼ ΛQCD B>. The larger scale Qλ belongs to transverse motion inside the collinear state and sets the resolution of the collinear function; it is not the value of the total momentum on the support of the delta function B>. p. 6

Where the paper says it

After the transverse delta function is integrated, the measured collinear state sum is evaluated at pXn⊥ = −kXs⊥. The leading-power approximation amounts to replacing this value by the one at pXn⊥ = 0.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

After the transverse delta function is integrated, the measured collinear state sum is evaluated at pXn⊥ = −kXs⊥. The leading-power approximation amounts to replacing this value by the one at pXn⊥ = 0.

With k 2⊥ ∼ Λ2QCD, both terms are ΛQCD/Q B>. p. 8
Where the paper says it

(45) is the main result of this work. It applies at the natural collinear angular scale; the omitted terms include relative corrections of order ΛQCD/Q, s/Q2 , τ /Q2 , and Λ 2 QCD/τ .

p. 8
Where the paper says it

(45) is the main result of this work. It applies at the natural collinear angular scale; the omitted terms include relative corrections of order ΛQCD/Q, s/Q2 , τ /Q2 , and Λ 2 QCD/τ .

The two relative corrections are therefore ∆W⊥W⊥ ∼ OΛ2QCDτ! p. 8
Where the paper says it

(45) is the main result of this work. It applies at the natural collinear angular scale; the omitted terms include relative corrections of order ΛQCD/Q, s/Q2 , τ /Q2 , and Λ 2 QCD/τ .

p. 8
Where the paper says it

(45) is the main result of this work. It applies at the natural collinear angular scale; the omitted terms include relative corrections of order ΛQCD/Q, s/Q2 , τ /Q2 , and Λ 2 QCD/τ .

+ OΛ2QCDs! B>.

The same measured-jet framework can be transferred to the endpoint region of B → Xulν¯ B. The same measured light-quark jet function and leading shape function appear when the recoil direction is fixed by the nonhadronic system, the observable is azimuthally inclusive, and transverse-momentum balance remains power suppressed at the natural angular scale >.

REFERENCES

[1] A. V. Manohar and M. B. Wise, Camb. Monogr. Part. Phys. Nucl. Phys. Cosmol 10, 1-191 (2000)

[2] M Neubert, Phys Rev D 49, 4623-4633 (1994)

[3] C W Bauer, S Fleming and M E Luke, Phys Rev D 63, 014006 (2000)

[4] C W Bauer, D Pirjol and I W Stewart, Phys Rev D 65, 054022 (29 Jul 26)

[5] S W Bosch, B O Lange, M Neubert and G Paz, Nucl Phys B 699, 335-386 (114010)

[6] B O Lange, M Neubert and G Paz, Phys Rev D 72, 073006 (141801)

[9] A Gunawardana and G Paz, JHEP 11, 141 (25 Jul 26)

[10] C L Basham, L S Brown, S D Ellis and S T Love, Phys Lett B 85, 297-299 (1585)

[11] C L Basham, L S Brown, S D Ellis and S T Love, Phys Rev D 17, 2298 (hep-ph/0409045)

[12] C L Basham, L S Brown, S D Ellis and S T Love, Phys Rev Lett 41, 1585 (hep-ph/9312311)

[13] I Moult and H X Zhu, [arXiv:2506.09119]

[14] E Craft, K Lee, B Meçaj and I Moult, [arXiv:2210.09311]

[15] A P Chen, X Liu and Y Q Ma, Phys Rev Lett 133, 19 (hep-ph/2405.10056)

[16] J Barata, J Brewer, K Lee and J M Silva, [arXiv:2508.19404]

[18] M E Luke, M J Savage and M B Wise, Phys Lett B 322, 154-158 (hep-ph/9311308)

Appendix A: Transverse-momentum reduction and its accuracy

The exact constraint gives pXn⊥ = −kXs⊥ ∼ ΛQCD B>. The larger scale Qλ belongs to transverse motion inside the collinear state and sets the resolution of the collinear function; it is not the value of the total momentum on the support of the delta function B>. With k 2⊥ ∼ Λ2QCD, both terms are ΛQCD/Q B>. The two relative corrections are therefore ∆W⊥W⊥ ∼ OΛ2QCDτ! + OΛ2QCDs! B>.

Appendix B: Jet-function normalization and cut phase space

For a one-quark state, the one-particle phase space with the fixed labels gives 1/(2Q) B>. The spin trace gives 2Q and the normalized color trace gives unity B>. p. 8

Where the paper says it

The measured jet function is normalized in d dimensions as J q TEC(s, τ, µ) ≡ NJ X Xn Tr n/¯ 2 ⟨0|χ (0) n (0)|Xn⟩⟨Xn|χ¯ (0) n (0)|0⟩ × (2π) d−1 δ(Q − n¯ · pXn )δ (d−2)(pXn⊥)δ(s − p 2 Xn )TXn (τ ). (43) Here the color trace is normalized by 1/Nc and NJ = 1 in our convention.

[1] A. V. Manohar and M. B. Wise, Camb Monogr Part Phys Nucl Phys Cosmol 10, 1-191 (2000)

[2] M Neubert, Phys Rev D 49, 4623-4633 (1994)

[3] C W Bauer, S Fleming and M E Luke, Phys Rev D 63, 014006 (2000)

[4] C W Bauer, D Pirjol and I W Stewart, Phys Rev D 65, 054022 (hep-ph/9312311)

[5] S W Bosch, B O Lange, M Neubert and G Paz, Nucl Phys B 699, 335-386 (hep-ph/0402094)

[6] B O Lange, M Neubert and G Paz, Phys Rev D 72, 073006 (hep-ph/114018)

[9] A Gunawardana and G Paz, JHEP 11, 141 (hep-ph/25 Jul 26)

[10] C L Basham, L S Brown, S D Ellis and S T Love, Phys Lett B 85, 297-299 (hep-ph/1585)

[11] C L Basham, L S Brown, S D Ellis and S T Love, Phys Rev D 17, 2298 (hep-ph/0409045)

[12] C L Basham, L S Brown, S D Ellis and S T Love, Phys Rev Lett 41, 1585 (hep-ph/9312311)

[13] I Moult and H X Zhu, [arXiv:2506.09119]

[14] E Craft, K Lee, B Meçaj and I Moult, [arXiv:2210.09311]

[15] A P Chen, X Liu and Y Q Ma, Phys Rev Lett 133, 19 (hep-ph/2405.10056)

[16] J Barata, J Brewer, K Lee and J M Silva, [arXiv:2508.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can perform leading-power endpoint factorization by deriving a factorization relation involving a standard hard coefficient, a B-meson shape function, and a new measured quark jet function as described in Section III.

  2. The improved system can calculate the measured jet function at one loop accuracy and verify that its angular integral reproduces the standard inclusive quark jet function, as shown in Section IV.

  3. The system can utilize the photon-energy and angular double-differential decay spectrum (BTEC) to resolve the angular structure of energy flow in inclusive B decays beyond what is possible with ordinary photon spectra.

  4. The improved AI can perform a closure test of leading-power endpoint factorization by propagating a shape function calibrated by the inclusive projection to fixed-cut cumulatives and quantifying the residual as delta i(τc) = F data i (τc) − F pred i,LP (τc; Sbpost B).

  5. The system can identify and quantify the migration outside common angular cuts τc = 2−4 GeV2, providing an illustrative numerical benchmark for resolved angular tails in a transparent setup.

  6. The system can perform semileptonic extension of the measured-jet framework to B → Xulν¯, using the radiative calibration to test shape function universality before applying it to inclusive Vub extractions.

  7. The improved AI can analyze fixed-cut cumulatives as robust first observables, where normalization to the photon spectrum in a common Eγ bin allows for cancellation of luminosity and photon-selection uncertainties.

  8. The system can perform closure tests by comparing shape functions calibrated by the ordinary photon spectrum against angularly resolved projections, diagnosing incomplete leading-power descriptions without requiring additional subleading mechanisms.

Abstract

We introduce a B-decay tagged energy correlator (BTEC) to resolve the angular structure of energy flow in inclusive B decays in the endpoint region, focusing on the direct-photon contribution to B to X sγ. At leading power and at the natural collinear angular scale τ about s about QΛ QCD, we derive a factorization relation involving the standard hard coefficient and B-meson shape function together with a new measured quark jet function; no new leading-power nonperturbative function is introduced. We calculate the measured jet function at one-loop accuracy and verify that its angular integral reproduces the standard inclusive quark jet function. For the central Bosch--Lange--Neubert--Paz parameter set, an illustrative benchmark gives 3 - 16% migration outside the fixed angular cuts τ c=2 - 4 GeV squared. With an independently constrained shape function, the angular cumulatives provide a closure test of leading-power endpoint factorization and are sensitive to direct- O 7 power corrections and resolved-photon effects. The BTEC thereby adds information on the angular structure of the inclusive recoil jet beyond the ordinary photon spectrum and may improve signal--background discrimination when their energy-flow profiles differ.

Sources

Related papers