Freezing Swampland: A Krylov Complexity Diagnostic for the Weak Gravity Conjecture

arXiv:2607.23747 · hep-th, quant-ph · Submitted 2026-07-26 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Freezing Swampland: A Krylov Complexity Diagnostic for the Weak Gravity Conjecture".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Freezing Swampland: A Krylov Complexity Diagnostic for the Weak Gravity Conjecture proposes a quantum-information-theoretic perspective on the Weak Gravity Conjecture through Krylov spread complexity, suggesting that the absence of exact freezing in the presence of an available discharge channel provides a complexity-based interpretation of this conjecture <ref:2607.23747#pg19>.

Kai: Connecting Swampland and Quantum Information The paper investigates the connection between the swampland program and black hole physics by using quantum complexity, specifically Krylov spread complexity, as a diagnostic tool.

Mira: The authors aim to reformulate some swampland criteria in terms of more general dynamical or informational properties of quantum-gravitational systems.

Kai: This approach seeks to diagnose consistency conditions on quantum gravity by linking low-energy effective field theories to black hole dynamics and quantum information theory.

Title and authors: Kai: We're starting by looking at who wrote this. It's Amin Faraji Astaneha and Reza Ghomi Shurkaie, both from Sharif University of Technology in Iran.

Mira: That’s interesting because it’s a collaboration between theoretical physics perspectives from different areas. The title itself is quite descriptive about the method they are using to diagnose these consistency conditions.

Lev: I wonder what the authors were hoping to find when they chose Krylov complexity over some other measure of quantum information spreading.

Kai: Well, they focus specifically on Krylov spread complexity because it’s systematic through the Lanczos construction, which is a very concrete way to look at state dynamics.

Mira: They want to use this specific definition to probe how the approach toward extremality is encoded in the dual quantum state dynamics holographically.

Lev: So they’re trying to see if the mathematics of approaching an extremal black hole shows up as a specific kind of complexity behavior in the dual quantum system.

Kai: Right, and they are setting this up with a charged thermofield double state that is holographically dual to an AdS Reissner–Nordstr¨om black hole. That’s where the setup gets very specific.

Mira: That setup lets them probe the near-extremal regime, which is where things get really interesting because that's often the boundary for these types of constraints.

The paper's summary: Lev: So, what’s the main finding from this study? What exactly does this Krylov complexity diagnostic tell us about black hole physics and the Weak Gravity Conjecture?

Kai: The main finding is that when you look at the extremal limit on the black-hole side, there is an effective freezing of Krylov spreading. The return amplitude becomes effectively a pure phase, and the dual quantum state stops spreading nontrivially in Krylov space.

Mira: That suggests that extremality itself is associated with an obstruction to sustained complexity growth in this system. It’s not just a smooth transition; it gets stuck.

Lev: So if you only have that freezing part, what does that imply for the Weak Gravity Conjecture? Does it mean certain black holes are disallowed?

Kai: They suggest that a physically admissible theory should not allow for exact freezing of spread complexity in a regime corresponding to an extremal charged black hole because such black holes must admit a discharge channel.

Mira: So the key idea is that the presence of a discharge channel lifts this frozen behavior and allows for nontrivial dynamics again. It’s about instability being linked to consistency.

The paper's improvements: Kai: They go further by incorporating charged matter into the system and studying what happens when Schwinger pair production opens up a discharge channel in the near-horizon region.

Mira: That's where things get dynamic again. When that channel is opened, the frozen behavior is lifted, and the dynamics become nontrivial for the coupled black hole and matter system.

Lev: I see how that provides the physical mechanism for unfreezing Krylov dynamics, which seems necessary to resolve this apparent contradiction.

Kai: They show that the lower bound on Krylov complexity is proportional to one minus the vacuum-persistence probability, and this probability decays exponentially once a discharge channel is available.

Mira: That exponential decay of the vacuum persistence probability directly leads to a nonzero lower bound on spread complexity, meaning there’s always some spreading left.

Lev: So they are linking the onset of Krylov growth to the same near-horizon parameters that govern Schwinger pair production. That’s a very specific control mechanism.

Conclusion: Kai: To wrap up, this paper suggests a quantum information-theoretic interpretation of the Weak Gravity Conjecture. It argues that admissible theories should not permit exact freezing of spread complexity for extremal charged black holes because they require those channels to open up.

Mira: The restoration of nontrivial Krylov growth is seen as a manifestation of the instability expected from the Weak Gravity Conjecture, providing a complexity-based diagnostic tool for consistency conditions on quantum gravity.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, this work gives us a concrete way to see what would happen if we tried to build something near that extremal limit where vacuum persistence is dying off exponentially.

Kai: So once the Schwinger discharge channel is available, the initial frozen state becomes metastable because the vacuum persistence probability decays, and that decay leads directly to a nonzero lower bound on spread complexity.

Mira: That means once the black hole is metastable to Schwinger discharge, it’s not truly frozen anymore; amplitude leaks away from the initial site and Krylov complexity starts growing again.

Lev: It’s a very neat way to show how dynamics are controlled by decay channels rather than just static geometry or extremality itself.

Kai: That's what they showed in "Freezing Swampland: A Krylov Complexity Diagnostic for the Weak Gravity Conjecture". It's a lot to take in, but it gives us a new way to check quantum gravity ideas.

Amin Faraji Astaneha, Reza Ghomi Shurkaiea

Sharif University of Technology · Research Center for High Energy Physics

hep-th, quant-ph

Submitted: 2026-07-26

Updated: 2026-11-03

Comments: 27 pages

License: http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/

Importance score: 87/100

The gist: Freezing Swampland: A Krylov Complexity Diagnostic for the Weak Gravity Conjecture proposes a quantum-information-theoretic perspective on the Weak Gravity Conjecture through Krylov spread…

Key concepts

Krylov Spread Complexity
This measures how far a quantum state has spread along an effective one-dimensional chain representing its evolution. It quantifies the average Krylov index, indicating the extent of wavefunction spreading in Krylov space.
Weak Gravity Conjecture (WGC)
This conjecture suggests that physically admissible theories should not allow for exact freezing of spread complexity in regimes corresponding to extremal charged black holes, as such black holes must possess a discharge channel.
Schwinger Pair Production
This is the process where charged matter opens a discharge channel near the black hole horizon, allowing for Schwinger pair production. This instability lifts the effective freezing of Krylov dynamics and allows complexity to grow again.
Crossover Temperature (Tc)
This temperature marks the point where thermal Krylov time scales and Schwinger decay time scales match. It helps determine whether early-time dynamics are dominated by ordinary thermal fluctuations or by Schwinger discharge.

Terminology

Summary

Freezing Swampland: A Krylov Complexity Diagnostic for the Weak Gravity Conjecture proposes a quantum-information-theoretic perspective on the Weak Gravity Conjecture through Krylov spread complexity, suggesting that the absence of exact freezing in the presence of an available discharge channel provides a complexity-based interpretation of this conjecture <ref:2607. p. 0

Where the paper says it

This suggests that the Weak Gravity Conjecture may admit a complexity-based interpretation in terms of the absence of exact freezing in the presence of an available discharge channel. More broadly, our results point to a new connection between the swampland program, black-hole physics, and quantum information theory.

23747#pg19>.

Connecting Swampland and Quantum Information

The paper investigates the connection between the swampland program and black hole physics by using quantum complexity, specifically Krylov spread complexity, as a diagnostic tool. The authors aim to reformulate some swampland criteria in terms of more general dynamical or informational properties of quantum-gravitational systems. p. 1

Where the paper says it

It is therefore natural to ask whether these two directions are related, and in particular whether concepts from quantum information theory can provide useful diagnostics for swampland constraints. If so, one may hope to reformulate at least some swampland criteria in terms of more general dynamical or informational properties of quantum-gravitational systems.

This approach seeks to diagnose consistency conditions on quantum gravity by linking low-energy effective field theories to black hole dynamics and quantum information theory. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Upon closer inspection, however, both aim to diagnose consistency conditions on quantum gravity, suggesting that they may be connected in nontrivial ways. The swampland program seeks to distinguish low-energy effective field theories that admit a consistent ultraviolet completion including gravity from those that do not, and therefore belong to the swampland rather than the landscape [1–4].

Krylov Complexity in the Extremal Limit

The study examines the Krylov complexity of a charged thermofield double state dual to an AdS Reissner–Nordstr¨om black hole, finding that as the extremal limit is approached, there is an effective freezing of Krylov spreading. In this regime, the return amplitude becomes effectively a pure phase and the corresponding spread complexity is strongly suppressed in the extremal limit. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Related questions have previously been explored using other notions of holographic complexity, such as the complexity=volume and complexity=action proposals [25–30], and we comment on these connections where appropriate. Our main observation is that, within this framework, the approach to extremality is accompanied by an effective freezing of Krylov spreading: the return amplitude becomes increasingly phase-dominated, and the corresponding spread complexity is strongly suppressed in the extremal limit.

This vanishing of spread complexity indicates that the state ceases to spread nontrivially in Krylov space, suggesting extremality is associated with an obstruction to sustained complexity growth. p. 8
Where the paper says it

The vanishing of CK(t) in the extremal limit indicates that the state ceases to spread nontrivially in the Krylov basis: the dynamics is effectively frozen at the level of operator growth or state spreading. In the language of the Krylov chain, hopping away from the initial site becomes increasingly suppressed as extremality is approached, so the wavefunction remains localized near its starting point rather than exploring the chain.

The Role of Discharge Channels

When charged matter is incorporated and Schwinger pair production opens a discharge channel in the near-horizon region, the frozen behavior is lifted, and the dynamics become nontrivial again. This instability provides the physical mechanism necessary to unfreeze Krylov dynamics of the coupled black-hole–matter system. p. 9

Where the paper says it

These decay channels populate previously inaccessible sectors of the global Hilbert space, describing charged matter excitations coupled to a partially discharged black hole. In this section, we demonstrate that this instability provides the physical mechanism necessary to unfreeze the Krylov dynamics of the coupled black-hole–matter system.

The lower bound on Krylov complexity is shown to be proportional to one minus the vacuum-persistence probability, which decays exponentially once a discharge channel is available. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Within this semiclassical near-extremal analysis, the frozen behavior is lifted once the discharge channel is opened, and the dynamics become nontrivial again. This suggests that the Weak Gravity Conjecture may admit a complexity-based interpretation in terms of the absence of exact freezing in the presence of an available discharge channel.

Comparison of Time Scales

The analysis compares the thermal Krylov time scale, which diverges as temperature approaches zero, with the Schwinger decay time scale, which remains finite. This implies that for sufficiently close to extremality, decay into charged sectors occurs on a parametrically shorter time scale than ordinary thermal Krylov spreading. p. 9

Where the paper says it

These decay channels populate previously inaccessible sectors of the global Hilbert space, describing charged matter excitations coupled to a partially discharged black hole. In this section, we demonstrate that this instability provides the physical mechanism necessary to unfreeze the Krylov dynamics of the coupled black-hole–matter system.

The crossover temperature Tc is defined by matching these two time scales, indicating that Schwinger discharge controls the loss of vacuum persistence at low temperatures.

Implications for the Weak Gravity Conjecture

The results suggest a quantum-information-theoretic interpretation of the WGC: a physically admissible theory should not permit exact freezing of spread complexity in a regime corresponding to an extremal charged black hole because such black holes must admit a discharge channel. The restoration of nontrivial Krylov growth is viewed as a complexity-side manifestation of the instability expected from the WGC. p. 9

Where the paper says it

From this perspective, our goal is to identify a quantuminformation-theoretic manifestation of the Weak Gravity Conjecture. 5 Complexity of a decaying black hole We propose that the freezing of Krylov space, and the corresponding vanishing of spread complexity, serves as a sharp quantum-informational diagnostic for the stability of extremal black holes, a stability that persists only in the absence of the WGC.

This work points toward a complexity-based diagnostic of a swampland consistency condition. p. 0
Where the paper says it

This suggests that the Weak Gravity Conjecture may admit a complexity-based interpretation in terms of the absence of exact freezing in the presence of an available discharge channel. More broadly, our results point to a new connection between the swampland program, black-hole physics, and quantum information theory.

Derivation of Pair Production Rate

The pair production rate in the near-horizon throat is calculated using the locally constant field approximation, yielding an expression for the decay rate that is enhanced by the angular-momentum tower or transverse horizon volume. The initial rate of unfreezing, C˙K(0), is set directly by this Schwinger decay rate. p. 2

Where the paper says it

In Section 4, we compute the near-extremal cumulants and show that Krylov complexity freezes in the extremal limit. In Section 5, we include charged matter, derive the Schwinger discharge rate, and show how this channel unfreezes Krylov dynamics within the semiclassical near-horizon approximation.

This demonstrates that the onset of Krylov growth is exponentially controlled by the same near-horizon parameters that govern Schwinger discharge. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Rather, we view it as evidence that extremality is associated with an obstruction to sustained complexity growth in the dual description. We then incorporate charged matter and study the opening of a discharge channel through Schwinger pair production in the near-horizon region.

Conclusion on Dynamics

The paper concludes that once a Schwinger discharge channel is available, the initial frozen state becomes metastable, and the exponential decay of vacuum-persistence probability leads directly to a nonzero lower bound on spread complexity. This means that once the black hole is metastable to Schwinger discharge, the freezing of Krylov dynamics is lifted, and amplitude leaks away from the initial site. p. 8

Where the paper says it

In the language of the Krylov chain, hopping away from the initial site becomes increasingly suppressed as extremality is approached, so the wavefunction remains localized near its starting point rather than exploring the chain. The extremal limit thus corresponds to a freezing of motion along the Krylov chain, reflected in the disappearance of spread complexity.

The growth of Krylov complexity is bounded from below by this decay channel. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We do not interpret this as a complete dynamical description of extremal blackhole decay. Rather, we view it as evidence that extremality is associated with an obstruction to sustained complexity growth in the dual description.

Review of Complexity Measures

Krylov complexity is defined as the average Krylov index with respect to the probability distribution pn(t) ≡ φn(t)2. It measures how far the wavefunction has spread along the effective onedimensional Krylov chain. p. 8

Where the paper says it

In the language of the Krylov chain, hopping away from the initial site becomes increasingly suppressed as extremality is approached, so the wavefunction remains localized near its starting point rather than exploring the chain. The extremal limit thus corresponds to a freezing of motion along the Krylov chain, reflected in the disappearance of spread complexity.

The relationship between the first and second cumulants of the return amplitude is given by CK(t) = κ2t2 + 1/6κ4 - 1/4κ2/3 t4 + O(t6). p. 4
Where the paper says it

(9) Introducing δK ≡ K − ⟨K⟩, the first four cumulants are κ1 = ⟨K⟩, κ2 = ⟨(δK) 2 ⟩ = Var(K), κ3 = ⟨(δK) 3 ⟩, κ4 = ⟨(δK) 4 ⟩ − 3⟨(δK) 2 ⟩ 2 . (10) In particular, the first and second cumulants are the mean and variance of the grand-canonical Hamiltonian, respectively.

The leading term in Krylov complexity is determined by the variance of the grandcanonical Hamiltonian. p. 5
Where the paper says it

and thus the Krylov complexity, up to order O(t 4 ), can be written in terms of the cumulants as CK(t) = b 2 1 t 2 + 1 12 b 2 1 2b 2 2 − 4b 2 1 − (a1 − a0) 2 t 4 + O(t 6 ) = κ2t 2 + 1 6 κ4 − 1 4 κ 2 3 κ2 t 4 + O(t 6 ). (13) Thus, the leading term in the Krylov complexity is determined by the variance of the grandcanonical Hamiltonian.

Derivation of Heat Kernel

The derivation of the charged scalar heat kernel in a constant electric background yields the proper-time kernel as 1/4πs ωs sin(ωs) e − sm2j. This expression successfully matches the expected flat-space limit when curvature effects are parametrically suppressed in the large-E limit. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Related questions have previously been explored using other notions of holographic complexity, such as the complexity=volume and complexity=action proposals [25–30], and we comment on these connections where appropriate. Our main observation is that, within this framework, the approach to extremality is accompanied by an effective freezing of Krylov spreading: the return amplitude becomes increasingly phase-dominated, and the corresponding spread complexity is strongly suppressed in the extremal limit.

The exact proper-time kernel for the j-th charged scalar mode in a constant electric background is 1/4πs ωs sin(ωs) e − sm2j, ω = qϕE. p. 1
Where the paper says it

1 Charged scalar probe in the near-horizon throat . 10 6 Conclusion 16 A A brief review of Krylov complexity 18 B Derivation of the Charged Scalar Heat Kernel 19 C Pair production in the AdS2 throat 21 1 Introduction Two active directions in quantum gravity research are the swampland program and the interface between black hole physics and quantum information theory.

Pair Production Threshold

The pair-production channel is open only when the global AdS2 threshold condition for the j-th mode is satisfied, which is given by L4/2ω2 > L2/2m2j + 1/4. When this condition is met, the leading semiclassical pair-production factor behaves as exp −2πωL2/2 − νj. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We then incorporate charged matter and study the effect of Schwinger pair production in the near-horizon region. Within this semiclassical near-extremal analysis, the frozen behavior is lifted once the discharge channel is opened, and the dynamics become nontrivial again.

This leads to an imaginary part in the effective action only when at least one charged mode is supercritical. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Such assumptions are not obviously applicable to holographic black holes. Their main claim is that, if one adopts the complexity = action proposal, then large charged AdS black holes are more naturally described in terms of simple gates, namely gates that induce only very small rotations of the wavefunction rather than nearly orthogonalizing it.

Final Interpretation

The physical picture is that the equilibrium near-extremal black-hole sector exhibits vanishing cumulants as T → 0, reflecting freezing of ordinary thermal Krylov spreading. Once charged matter is included, Schwinger pair production causes the state to develop support on additional sectors, providing new directions along the full Lanczos chain. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In this regime, the return amplitude becomes effectively a pure phase, and the dual quantum state ceases to spread nontrivially in Krylov space. We then incorporate charged matter and study the effect of Schwinger pair production in the near-horizon region.

This guarantees nontrivial Krylov spreading whenever the vacuum-persistence probability decreases from unity. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We then incorporate charged matter and study the opening of a discharge channel through Schwinger pair production in the near-horizon region. In this setting, the frozen behavior is replaced by nontrivial Krylov evolution.

The authors stress that a full treatment of black-hole discharge requires addressing a genuinely time-dependent and backreacting process, which is beyond the scope of this semiclassical analysis. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In this setting, the frozen behavior is replaced by nontrivial Krylov evolution. Our treatment is semiclassical and restricted to the near-extremal AdS2 throat, and therefore does not attempt to capture the full time-dependent, backreacting evolution of the discharging black hole.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Develop a quantum complexity diagnostic for swampland constraints by measuring Krylov spread complexity of charged thermofield double states dual to AdS Reissner-Nordstrom black holes. This allows AI systems to test whether extremal black hole physics exhibits an effective freezing of Krylov spreading when a discharge channel is absent, providing a quantum-information-theoretic signature of the Weak Gravity Conjecture.

  2. Implement a method to distinguish between generic dynamical regimes and those associated with swampland consistency conditions by analyzing the behavior of Krylov complexity under the presence or absence of Schwinger pair production. AI systems could predict whether a state remains localized near its initial site or develops support on additional sectors when charged matter is included in the near-horizon region.

  3. Create a crossover scale for complexity growth by matching thermal Krylov time and Schwinger decay time scales, which allows AI to determine if early-time dynamics are governed by ordinary thermal fluctuations or by Schwinger discharge, based on whether the temperature is above or below this scale Tc.

Abstract

We propose a quantum-information-theoretic perspective on the Weak Gravity Conjecture through the behavior of Krylov spread complexity. For a charged thermofield double state holographically dual to an AdS Reissner--Nordström black hole, we show that the extremal limit on the black-hole side is accompanied by an effective freezing of Krylov spreading. In this regime, the return amplitude becomes effectively a pure phase, and the corresponding Krylov spread is suppressed. We then incorporate charged matter and study the effect of Schwinger pair production in the near-horizon region. Within this semiclassical near-extremal analysis, the frozen behavior is lifted once an allowed discharge channel is opened, and the dynamics become nontrivial again. This suggests a possible complexity-based diagnostic of a characteristic physical consequence of the Weak Gravity Conjecture: the availability of a superextremal charged state that can mediate discharge. More broadly, our results point to a connection between the swampland program, black-hole physics, and quantum information theory.

Related papers