Approximate Total Weighted Completion Time with Convex Controllable Processing Times
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Computer Science. The day in computer science: software, systems and theory on arXiv.
Tom: We're looking at the paper: "Approximate Total Weighted Completion Time with Convex Controllable Processing Times".
Jane: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper studies the single-machine scheduling problem with controllable processing times to minimize total weighted completion time and provides approximation algorithms for this complex problem.
Tom: The computational complexity of this problem represents a long-standing open question, as it is currently neither known to be polynomial-time solvable nor NP-hard.
Jane: Problem Formulation and Context The instance of the problem is defined by a set J of n jobs, an integer k, and a global resource budget U.
Tom: Each job j in J is characterized by two parameters: its workload θj ∈ Q>0 and weight wj ∈ Q>0.
Paper summary: Tom: So we're looking at this paper here today called "Approximate Total Weighted Completion Time with Convex Controllable Processing Times". The main idea is dealing with single machine scheduling where you can control how long a job takes based on how much resource you give it, and the goal is to minimize the total weighted completion time.
Jane: Right, so the paper focuses specifically on when a job's processing time isn't fixed; it's a convex function of the resource you allocate to it. The big question they tackle is how hard this problem is computationally, because we don't even know yet if it can be solved in polynomial time or if it’s NP-hard.
Lu: That complexity issue is central because you have this coupling between choosing the order of jobs and deciding exactly how much resource to give each job under a total budget constraint. This whole setup, denoted as one sub one with convex processing times subject to a budget constraint, is what they are analyzing <ref:2607.22133#pg3>.
Meng: From a production standpoint, I'm more concerned about what this means for real-world deployment. If the exact solution is hard to find, how much does this approximation algorithm actually perform when we're running this on live data?
Tom: Well, the paper does provide some concrete results on approximability. They show a polynomial time algorithm that gives an e-approximation with e being two point seven one nine. That means for any instance they give you, their solution will be no worse than two point seven one nine times the actual minimum total weighted completion time.
Jane: And they also mention a quasi-polynomial approximation scheme under certain conditions, specifically when the largest workload or weight parameter is bounded by something that grows polynomially with the size of the instance. That’s a bit more hopeful for smaller, constrained problems.
Lalam: I see them demonstrating this polynomial time e two point seven one nine approximation algorithm that runs in n log n time <ref:2607.22133#pg1>. This is achieved using a simple sorting rule which gives an approximation ratio of one plus one over k plus one to the power of k plus one, and they bound that by e two point seven one eight for all positive values of k > zero.
Lu: That sorting rule is interesting because it's simpler than what you'd expect in this kind of scheduling problem <ref:2607.22133#pg3>. They show that simple sorting rules, like sequencing by weight or workload, don't guarantee a constant factor approximation for the general case.
Meng: Constant factor approximation is what I need when I'm trying to set performance SLAs. If the best simple sorts only give you something that grows with n, that’s not very useful at scale.
Tom: Exactly. They characterize the ratio of three natural sorting heuristics they tested <ref:2607.22133#pg1>. One heuristic, where jobs are sequenced by their weights in non-increasing order, gives an approximation ratio of theta n when you look at it <ref:2607.22133#pg1>.
Paper summary: Jane: And the other one, sequencing by workload in non-decreasing order, results in an approximation ratio of theta n to the power of k plus one when you look at that <ref:2607.22133#pg1>. So the performance really depends on which heuristic you pick and what constraints are on those job parameters.
Lalam: They also have a more specific scheme for when either the maximum workload or maximum weight is bounded by some constant value. In that case, they have an epsilon approximation scheme that runs in time proportional to q times n to the power of q, where q involves a minimum of n log theta max and some terms related to epsilon and k minus one.
Tom: That complexity for the scheme sounds quite heavy on the computation side. It suggests that getting very tight approximations for those constrained scenarios requires a lot of work, specifically dynamic programming based on reducing the problem to fewer distinct workloads or weights <ref:2607.22133#pg3>.
Jane: So, what does this mean for someone just listening to the show? It means that while we have an algorithm that's polynomial time and gives us a two point seven one nine approximation, if you are dealing with very specific constraints on your job parameters like bounded workload or weight, you might need a much more complex setup to get the best possible result.
Lu: Basically, the paper shows that when things get complicated—when those processing times become convex functions of resource allocation—you can’t rely on simple sorting rules to give you a guaranteed good approximation for the general problem <ref:2607.22133#pg3>.
Meng: For me, it means I can't just pick a heuristic and be done; I have to understand the structure of the input—the workloads and weights—to decide if the simpler bounds hold or if I need to run something much more intensive than a basic sort.
Tom: So, we have this problem that’s hard to solve exactly, but they give us tools for finding solutions that are provably close to optimal, depending on how much structure is in the input data.
Jane: And the paper itself is about minimizing total weighted completion time with controllable processing times <ref:2607.22133#pg3>. It’s a piece of research that shows how we can manage sequencing and resource allocation simultaneously even when those processing times are tricky functions.
Lalam: The implication here is that for this scheduling problem, the exact computational complexity remains an open question because the paper doesn't fully resolve it <ref:2607.22133#pg1>.
Tom: It’s a solid piece of analysis showing where the current methods fall short and what approximations we can rely on based on the input structure.
Jane: And looking at those results, this work helps define the boundaries of what's achievable in terms of approximation guarantees for these complex scheduling scenarios.
Conclusion: Tom: So we're wrapping up this look at "Approximate Total Weighted Completion Time with Convex Controllable Processing Times." Basically, this paper tackles scheduling jobs where you can change how long they take based on how much resource you give them.
Jane: Right, so it’s about finding the best order to schedule things while also figuring out the right amount of resource to give each job under a total budget limit. It’s complex because those processing times aren't just fixed numbers; they're functions of that resource allocation.
Lu: The authors look at this problem and realize it’s hard—they don't know if you can solve it exactly in polynomial time or if it’s NP-hard yet.
Meng: That uncertainty is what worries me because when I’m deploying models, I need to know what actually runs on real traffic, not just theoretical bounds.
Tom: The paper provides some tools for that uncertainty. They show a polynomial time algorithm that gives you an approximation ratio of about two point seven one nine.
Jane: two point seven nine is a concrete number; so, even though the exact solution is elusive, we have a method that gets us close to optimal in reasonable time.
Lu: They also have these more specialized schemes for when the workloads or weights aren't huge numbers—when they are bounded by some constant value.
Tom: Which means if you’re dealing with smaller jobs or simpler parameters, you might get a much tighter approximation scheme, though it can be computationally demanding.
Jane: So the implication is that for this scheduling problem, we can find solutions that are provably close to the best possible total weighted completion time, depending on the specific structure of your input data.
Meng: It’s about moving from just guessing a good order to having a method that gives you a reliable performance guarantee based on what you feed into it.
Tom: And this whole discussion points toward how we need to approach these problems when the constraints on processing times become more flexible and complex, leading us into the next area of research.
Klaus Heeger, Danny Hermelin, Dvir Shabtay
Fraunhofer IOSB-INA · Department of Industrial Engineering and Management, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
cs.DS
Submitted: 2026-07-24
Updated: 2026-11-06
Comments: The results of this manuscript are superseeded by the paper "Dual Techniques for Scheduling on a Machine with Varying Speed" by Megow and Verschae, SIDMA 2018
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 83/100
The gist: The paper studies the single-machine scheduling problem with controllable processing times to minimize total weighted completion time and provides approximation algorithms for this complex problem.
Key concepts
- Total Weighted Completion Time ($P_n$)
- This is the objective function to minimize. It calculates the sum of each job's weight multiplied by its completion time. The goal is to find a schedule where jobs with high weights are finished as early as possible, thus reducing this total cost.
- Controllable Processing Times
- The processing time for each job can be adjusted within certain limits, constrained by a global resource budget $U$. This means the scheduler has flexibility in how long each job takes to complete its task, which adds a layer of complexity to the scheduling problem.
- Approximation Scheme
- This is a method designed to find solutions that are close to the optimal solution. The paper presents schemes that guarantee a certain approximation ratio, meaning the resulting schedule's cost will not be much worse than the best possible cost, and it describes how to achieve this bound.
Terminology
Summary
The paper studies the single-machine scheduling problem with controllable processing times to minimize total weighted completion time and provides approximation algorithms for this complex problem. p. 0 The computational complexity of this problem represents a long-standing open question, as it is currently neither known to be polynomial-time solvable nor NP-hard. p. 0
Problem Formulation and Context
The instance of the problem is defined by a set J of n jobs, an integer k, and a global resource budget U. Each job j in J is characterized by two parameters: its workload θj ∈ Q>0 and weight wj ∈ Q>0. p. 1 A schedule is defined by a permutation σ = (σ(1),. p. 1.., σ(n)), where σ(j) denotes the index of the job scheduled in the j’th position in the job processing sequence. p. 1 The objective is to find a permutation σ and a resource allocation strategy u = (u1,. p. 2.., un) ∈ Qn ≥0 for the n given jobs that minimizes the total weighted completion time Pn j=1 wσ(j)Cσ(j), subject to the total resource budget constraint Pn j=1 uj ≤ U. p. 2
Approximation Results
The authors present a polynomial-time e ≤ 2.719-approximation algorithm, alongside a quasi-polynomial approximation scheme for instances where the largest parameter value is polynomially bounded by the instance size. p. 0 Specifically, Theorem 1 demonstrates that the 1conv,Puj ≤ UPwjCj problem admits an e-approximation algorithm running in O(n log n) time. p. 3 This is achieved by a simple sorting rule that yields an approximation ratio of (1 + 1/(k+1))(k+1), which is bounded by e ≈ 2. p. 2718 for all k > 0. p. 3
Approximation Scheme Details
The paper designs an (1 + ε)-approximation scheme for the problem when either the maximum workload θmax or the maximum weight wmax is bounded by some constant. This scheme runs in O(q · n q) time, where q = minn log θmax ((1 + ε)-1/(k − 1), log wmax / ε o. p. 4 The proof involves reducing the problem to one with a small number of distinct workloads or weights and applying dynamic programming. p. 4
Limitations of Simple Heuristics
The study demonstrates that simple sorting rules, which are optimal for certain special cases in the literature, cannot guarantee a constant-factor approximation for the general case. Theorem 3 characterizes the approximation ratio f(n, k) of three natural sorting heuristics:
**)&f(n, k) = Θ(n) when jobs are sequenced in non-increasing order of weights wj. **
**)&f(n, k) = Θ(n(k+1)) when jobs are sequenced in non-decreasing order of workloads θj. p. 4
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
- Approximation Algorithm for Total Weighted Completion Time
The system can solve single-machine scheduling problems with convex controllable processing times to minimize total weighted completion time within a constant factor of e approximately 2.718 in O(n log n) time, based on Theorem 1 and the associated sorting rule.
- Polynomial Time Approximation Scheme for Bounded Workloads or Weights
The system can solve the problem within any factor (1 plus epsilon) in quasi-polynomial time if either the maximum workload theta max or the maximum weight w max is bounded by some constant, as described in Theorem 2.
- Dynamic Programming Solvers for Structured Instances
The system can solve instances where there are only a few distinct workloads or weights using dynamic programming, achieving a time complexity of O(theta hash · n theta hash) or O(w hash · n w hash), as shown in Theorem 4 and Theorem 5.
Related papers
- PHastR: Faster Minimal Perfect Hashing with Rotated Layouts
- Fine-Grained Complexity of Approximating Vector Knapsack: A Faster Algorithm and Equivalence with k-SUM in 2D
- Polynomial-time computation of p-contraction fixed points for even p
- Separations Between Submodular-Like Graph Widths
- Bounded Integer Programming in Almost N 2d Time
- Fast Odd-Permutation Sums in Characteristic Two and Shortest Even Directed Cycles