Boundary Completion of Vacuum Persistence Probability

arXiv:2607.20936 · hep-th, gr-qc · Submitted 2026-07-23 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Boundary Completion of Vacuum Persistence Probability".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The vacuum persistence probability is not prescription dependent because including endpoint vacuum wave functionals restores the Bogoliubov result.

Kai: Ambiguity in Effective Action Prescriptions The apparent ambiguity in evaluating the vacuum persistence probability arises because the Green’s function prescription omits the nontrivial contribution from the endpoint vacuum wavefunctionals, which should be present in the complete in-out amplitude.

Mira: This missing contribution is what causes different expressions between Bogoliubov and Green’s function prescriptions.

Kai: The Green’s function prescription captures only the bulk variation of the in-out path integral, while the missing endpoint variation of the vacuum functional provides a compensating contribution.

Paper summary: Mira: To get more detail on what they're doing, they point out that the functional integral for an in-out amplitude includes not just the bulk action but also those initial and final vacuum wave functionals twenty-three twenty-seven <ref:2607.20936#pg2,that the functional integral for an in-out amplitude>.

Kai: Right. And they show how varying the mass squared naturally splits into a bulk part and an endpoint part, which they call the endpoint contribution denoted by partial m squared W Psi.

Lev: That endpoint contribution is what exactly cancels out that boundary obstruction that prevents the Green's function result from matching the Bogoliubov expression, which is pretty concrete for us to see.

Mira: They derive this endpoint contribution and demonstrate that it removes the thing blocking the Green's function result from agreeing with the Bogoliubov expression. This means they show how to complete that prescription using those endpoint terms.

Kai: So, what they're saying is that this boundary-completed in-out amplitude reduces exactly to the Bogoliubov expression, which uniquely determines the vacuum persistence probability.

Lev: If we think about running this on real hardware, it means the overhead of accounting for these endpoint contributions is manageable because they precisely fix a mathematical inconsistency.

Mira: It’s important because it shows that the ambiguity isn't really in the physics itself, but in how we set up the mathematical framework—specifically, whether we are using a bulk-only description or a complete one.

Kai: So, for someone listening to this show, the main point is that when calculating vacuum particle production from quantum fields, you need to account for those boundary terms at the beginning and end of your calculation.

Conclusion: Lev: Looking at the title "Boundary Completion of Vacuum Persistence Probability," what it really tells us is that prescription dependence in this area isn't a deep mystery, but a bookkeeping error in our setup.

Mira: It confirms that the vacuum persistence probability is actually uniquely defined, and that definition comes from including all parts of the in-out amplitude, not just the bulk action.

Kai: So for us working with superconducting qubits or any quantum hardware, it means we need to be careful about what boundary conditions we assume are "trivial" and which ones need to be explicitly included.

Lev: It clarifies that when you move from a simplified Green's function approach to the full in-out amplitude, you get the correct physics because those endpoint terms balance out the difference between the two methods.

Mira: The implication is that for future work, we don't have to wonder if prescription dependence is an intrinsic property; it seems like a choice of which mathematical terms you decide to keep or drop.

Kai: So, the paper shows that by including those specific endpoint wave functionals, we get the Bogoliubov result for the imaginary part of the effective action, which is precisely what we expect from vacuum instability.

Lev: And it’s a good thing because it means our real hardware experiments should be able to target that Bogoliubov result without getting stuck on prescription ambiguities in this fundamental quantity.

Center for Gravitational Physics, Department of Space Science, Beihang University

hep-th, gr-qc

Submitted: 2026-07-23

Updated: 2026-11-05

Comments: v1: 6+10 pages. Comments are welcome. v2: 7+13 pages. Revised version with improved readability. The discussion has been expanded, and two illustrations of the boundary-completion mechanism have been added to the Supplemental Material. Accepted by Physical Review D

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 88/100

The gist: The vacuum persistence probability is not prescription dependent because including endpoint vacuum wave functionals restores the Bogoliubov result.

Key concepts

Green’s function prescription
This simpler method for calculating path integrals only accounts for variations in the bulk of spacetime. It misses crucial information contained in the boundary conditions, specifically the endpoint vacuum wave functionals. This omission causes discrepancies when compared to more complete methods like Bogoliubov's.
Endpoint vacuum wave functionals
These are the specific mathematical functions describing the state of the vacuum at the beginning and end points of spacetime. They contain necessary information about how quantum fields behave at these boundaries, which is essential for a complete description of particle production.
Boundary Completion Mechanism
The authors demonstrate that adding these endpoint contributions exactly corrects the limitations of the Green's function approach. This mechanism removes the obstruction that prevents the simplified calculation from yielding the correct physical result, ensuring agreement with Bogoliubov's established formula.

Terminology

Summary

The vacuum persistence probability is not prescription dependent because including endpoint vacuum wave functionals restores the Bogoliubov result. p. 4

Ambiguity in Effective Action Prescriptions

The apparent ambiguity in evaluating the vacuum persistence probability arises because the Green’s function prescription omits the nontrivial contribution from the endpoint vacuum wavefunctionals, which should be present in the complete in-out amplitude. This missing contribution is what causes different expressions between Bogoliubov and Green’s function prescriptions. p. 0 The Green’s function prescription captures only the bulk variation of the in-out path integral, while the missing endpoint variation of the vacuum functional provides a compensating contribution. p. 1

Boundary Completion Mechanism

The authors show that this ambiguity reflects the boundary incompleteness of the Green’s function prescription. They derive the endpoint contribution and demonstrate that it exactly removes the obstruction which prevents the Green’s function result from agreeing with the Bogoliubov expression. p. 1 The boundary-completed in-out amplitude therefore reduces to the Bogoliubov expression, which uniquely determines the vacuum persistence probability. p. 1

Role of Endpoint Wavefunctionals

The complete in-out amplitude contains not only the bulk action but also the initial and final vacuum wavefunctionals. The variation of the mass squared naturally separates into a bulk part and an endpoint part, where the endpoint contribution is denoted by ∂m2WΨ. p. 1 This endpoint contribution exactly cancels the boundary obstruction in the Green’s function prescription. p. 1

Final Result and Implications

The imaginary part of the complete effective action is therefore given by ImW = 1/4 Tr log αα†. This is precisely the Bogoliubov result, meaning the vacuum persistence probability is not prescription dependent. p. 0 The residual endpoint phase affects only the real part of W, leaving the vacuum persistence probability unchanged. p. 3 The sensitivity found in de Sitter particle production reflects a genuine boundary sensitivity of the bulk Green’s function prescription rather than an intrinsic ambiguity of the complete vacuum persistence probability. p. 4 The final result is that the imaginary part of effective action reduces to the Bogoliubov expression after including endpoint wave functionals. p. 3 The work was partially supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grants No. p. 412175008).

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Boundary completion of vacuum persistence probability can be incorporated into effective action calculations by including endpoint vacuum wavefunctionals, which resolves ambiguity between Bogoliubov and Green’s function prescriptions. This allows for a unique determination of the vacuum persistence probability, as stated in the conclusion: The complete in-out effective action restores the Bogoliubov result and uniquely determines the vacuum persistence probability.

  2. AI systems can be improved to resolve discrepancies arising from prescription-dependent results by implementing a boundary completion procedure that accounts for endpoint wavefunctionals. This enhancement ensures that physical observables, such as vacuum persistence probability, are not dependent on regularization schemes like late-time or momentum cutoffs.

  3. The improved system can accurately predict particle production and vacuum instability in curved spacetime scenarios (like de Sitter spacetime) by consistently combining bulk Green's function variations with endpoint contributions. This addresses the issue where different regularization schemes yield strikingly different physical predictions for vacuum instability.

Sources

Related papers