The Ulam--Kaplansky problem in operator algebras

arXiv:2607.20593 · math.FA, math.OA · Submitted 2026-07-22 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematics. The day in mathematics: new theorems, new proofs, and what they open.

Ada: I'm Ada.

Emmy: And I'm Emmy, here with Kolya.

Ada: We're looking at the paper: "The Ulam--Kaplansky problem in operator algebras".

Emmy: Here's the gist of the paper. Kaplansky’s second test problem on similarity asks whether two operators T and S are similar in a unital Banach algebra B if their direct sums T ⊕ T and S ⊕ S are similar in M2(B) <ref:2607.205931,if T is an operator with property (J) in a type In von Neumann algebra M, i.e., there exists a bounded maximal abelian family of idempotents in the relative commutant of T in M <ref:2607.20593#pg3>.

Ada: The core problem and its context The paper investigates Kaplansky’s second test problem on similarity in type In von Neumann algebras and general Banach algebras <ref:2607.20593#pg2>.

Emmy: It addresses whether T is similar to S in B if T ⊕ T is similar to S ⊕ S in M2(B) <ref:2607.20593#pg2>.

Ada: The authors explore positive solutions for specific classes of operators, such as those with property (J) or those with essentially finite-dimensional commutants <ref:2607.20593#pg2>.

Paper summary: Ada: So, wrapping up this discussion on "The Ulam--Kaplansky problem in operator algebras," the main point is that for operators with property J in type In von Neumann algebras, the similarity of their direct sums in M two over B does imply similarity in B.

Emmy: And they extended this result by showing that this holds for a broader class of operators, specifically those with essentially finite-dimensional commutants within Banach algebras. It gives us a pathway to solve Kaplansky's second test problem in these important operator settings.

Kolya: What I find interesting is how they connect this similarity question to the finite strongly irreducible decomposition, which is a structural property of the operators themselves. It suggests that solving this similarity problem might be equivalent to understanding how an operator breaks down into its fundamental pieces.

Ada: Right, and one important part of the work is showing that these results can be generalized across different dimensions for type In von von Neumann algebras, specifically covering the cases with dimension one through three.

Emmy: The paper shows that they can reduce the problem to a simpler setting, Mn(L infinity), which makes it much more manageable to prove the general case for all type In von Neumann algebras. It's a systematic way to tackle these kinds of similarity questions.

Kolya: So, if you only listen for what this means practically, it suggests that in certain structured operator environments, if you can check the direct sum condition in a matrix algebra, you have a strong handle on the underlying operators themselves.

Ada: Precisely. The paper provides a framework that links similarity to these algebraic structures like property J and finite decomposition, giving us tools to analyze operators in these contexts more deeply.

Conclusion: Ada: So we're wrapping up on this paper about "The Ulam--Kaplansky problem in operator algebras." The main thing is they tackle whether you can prove similarity between two operators T and S by just looking at their direct sums in a matrix algebra, M two over B.

Emmy: Right, so it’s asking if the similarity holds up when you move from the original algebra B to that larger matrix setting. It seems like a big structural question about how these operators relate to each other.

Kolya: From my side, I’m looking at how they handle the specific cases where property J is present in type In von Neumann algebras and also when we look at elements inside general Banach algebras with essentially finite-dimensional commutants. That’s where the real meat of their proof seems to be.

Ada: Exactly. They show that having that property J, which means you have a bounded maximal abelian family of idempotents in the relative commutant, actually helps solve this similarity problem for those specific operator types. It connects it to a decomposition idea too.

Emmy: And they extend that connection by showing that this structure—property J—also carries over to the direct sums of operators. So if T and S have property J, then T plus T and S plus S also have it in some sense, which is a key structural link.

Kolya: For me, the important part is that they reduce the problem down to simpler settings like Mn(L infinity), making it possible to prove these results for a whole class of type In von Neumann algebras with dimension one through three. It’s a systematic way to see where the boundaries are.

Ada: So essentially, they've built a bridge connecting abstract similarity in these operator algebras to concrete structural properties like property J and finite decomposition. It gives us better tools for understanding these operators than just looking at the numbers directly.

Emmy: And it suggests that solving this similarity question isn't just about brute-force checking if T is similar to S, but about understanding the underlying algebraic geometry of the operator structure itself.

Kolya: What this means practically is we have a roadmap for when we can expect these similarity results to hold in these complex settings. It’s a framework for what kind of operators we can actually hope to compare meaningfully across different algebras.

NSFC · China Postdoctoral Science Foundation

math.FA, math.OA

Submitted: 2026-07-22

Updated: 2026-11-05

Comments: 21 pages

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/

Importance score: 58/100

The gist: Kaplansky’s second test problem on similarity asks whether two operators T and S are similar in a unital Banach algebra B if their direct sums T ⊕ T and S ⊕ S are similar in M2(B)…

Key concepts

Property (J)
An operator T in a von Neumann algebra M has property (J) if there is a bounded maximal abelian family of idempotents within its relative commutant. This property is key because it helps characterize operators and links them to important structural decompositions.
Kaplansky's Second Test Problem
This problem asks whether two operators T and S are similar in a Banach algebra B if their direct sums, T ⊕ T and S ⊕ S, are similar in the algebra of $2 imes 2$ matrices over B. The paper seeks conditions under which this similarity implies the similarity of the original operators.
Finite Strongly Irreducible Decomposition
This concept describes how an operator can be broken down into a finite number of irreducible components within a specific type of algebra. The paper shows that property (J) is equivalent to having such a decomposition, providing a structural tool for analyzing operators.

Terminology

Summary

Kaplansky’s second test problem on similarity asks whether two operators T and S are similar in a unital Banach algebra B if their direct sums T ⊕ T and S ⊕ S are similar in M2(B) <ref:2607. p. 0

Where the paper says it

KAPLANSKY’S SECOND TEST PROBLEM IN OPERATOR ALGEBRAS CHUNLAN JIANG, MINGHUI MA, RUI SHI, AND YUANHANG ZHANG Abstract. Kaplansky’s second test problem on similarity asks: if T and S are elements in a unital Banach algebra B and T ⊕ T is similar to S ⊕ S in M2(B), is T similar to S in B?

205931,if T is an operator with property (J) in a type In von Neumann algebra M, i. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Kaplansky’s second test problem on similarity asks: if T and S are elements in a unital Banach algebra B and T ⊕ T is similar to S ⊕ S in M2(B), is T similar to S in B? We answer this problem affirmatively if T is an operator with property (J) in a type In von Neumann algebra M, i.

e., there exists a bounded maximal abelian family of idempotents in the relative commutant of T in M <ref:2607. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Jiang posed seven questions concerning the structure of Hilbert space operators and suggested studying strongly irreducible operators as infinite-dimensional Jordan blocks up to similarity (see [11] for recent progress on these questions). To answer the third question in [11], the authors in [13] proved that a Hilbert space operator T is similar to a direct integral of strongly irreducible operators if and only if its commutant {T} ′ contains a bounded maximal abelian family of idempotents.

20593#pg3>.

The core problem and its context

The paper investigates Kaplansky’s second test problem on similarity in type In von Neumann algebras and general Banach algebras <ref:2607.20593#pg2>. It addresses whether T is similar to S in B if T ⊕ T is similar to S ⊕ S in M2(B) <ref:2607. p. 0

Where the paper says it

KAPLANSKY’S SECOND TEST PROBLEM IN OPERATOR ALGEBRAS CHUNLAN JIANG, MINGHUI MA, RUI SHI, AND YUANHANG ZHANG Abstract. Kaplansky’s second test problem on similarity asks: if T and S are elements in a unital Banach algebra B and T ⊕ T is similar to S ⊕ S in M2(B), is T similar to S in B?

20593#pg2>. The authors explore positive solutions for specific classes of operators, such as those with property (J) or those with essentially finite-dimensional commutants <ref:2607. p. 2
Where the paper says it

To study the finite strongly irreducible decomposition of elements in Banach algebras, we say that an element T in a Banach algebra B has essentially finite-dimensional commutant if the relative commutant of T in B is finite-dimensional modulo its radical. For elements with essentially finite-dimensional commutants in Banach algebras, we prove the following result concerning Kaplansky’s second test problem up to similarity in Theorem 5.

20593#pg2>.

Characterization via Property (J)

The concept of property (J) is introduced, where an operator T in a von Neumann algebra M has property (J) if there exists a bounded maximal abelian family of idempotents in its relative commutant <ref:2607.20593#pg2>. This property is crucial for affirmatively answering Kaplansky’s second test problem for operators with property (J) in type In von Neumann algebras, as stated in Theorem 3. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Property (J) was first applied to study the strongly irreducible decomposition of operators up to similarity. In this paper, for operators with property (J) in type In von Neumann algebras, we affirmatively answer Kaplansky’s second test problem on similarity as stated in Theorem 3.

27 <ref:2607. p. 0
Where the paper says it

12271074); Yuanhang Zhang was supported in part by NSFC (No. 1 arXiv:2607.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

12271074); Yuanhang Zhang was supported in part by NSFC (No. 1 arXiv:2607.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

12271074); Yuanhang Zhang was supported in part by NSFC (No. 1 arXiv:2607.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

12271074); Yuanhang Zhang was supported in part by NSFC (No. 1 arXiv:2607.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

12271074); Yuanhang Zhang was supported in part by NSFC (No. 1 arXiv:2607.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

12271074); Yuanhang Zhang was supported in part by NSFC (No. 1 arXiv:2607.

20593#pg2>. Furthermore, the paper establishes an equivalence between having property (J) and admitting a finite strongly irreducible decomposition for operators in type In von Neumann algebras <ref:2607. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Property (J) was first applied to study the strongly irreducible decomposition of operators up to similarity. In this paper, for operators with property (J) in type In von Neumann algebras, we affirmatively answer Kaplansky’s second test problem on similarity as stated in Theorem 3.

20593#pg2>.

Reduction Theorems and Generalization

The authors present a reduction theorem that simplifies Kaplansky’s second test problem in type In von Neumann algebras to the case of Mn(L∞) = Mn ⊗ L∞ <ref:2607.20593#pg2>. They establish equivalences between the condition θn(t) < ∞ for every t ≥ 1 and Kaplansky’s second test problem being true for Mn ⊗ L∞ <ref:2607. p. 2

Where the paper says it

1 for the definition of the similarity function θn. The following statements are equivalent: (1) θn(t) < ∞ for every t ⩾ 1; (2) Kaplansky’s second test problem is true for Mn ⊗ ` ∞; (3) Kaplansky’s second test problem is true for every type In von Neumann algebra.

20593#pg2>. This reduction is further extended to show that the problem holds for every type In von Neumann algebra with 1 ≤ n ≤ 3 in Proposition 4. p. 8
Where the paper says it

But P0 is unbounded as kP1P2 · · · Pkk = 2k . Next we show that every bounded decreasing net of idempotents in a type In von Neumann algebra is weak-operator convergent to an idempotent.

7 <ref:2607.20593#pg2>.

Banach Algebra Results and Essential Finiteness

For elements in Banach algebras, the paper proves a result concerning elements with essentially finite-dimensional commutants <ref:2607.20593#pg2>. Theorem 5.13 states that if T is an element in B satisfying that T(n) 1 ∼ T(n) 2 in Mn(B) and T1 has essentially finite-dimensional commutant in B, then T1 ∼ T2 in B <ref:2607. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Moreover, the condition of property (J) can be removed for 1 ⩽ n ⩽ 3. A similar result is proved if T is an element in a unital Banach algebra B with essentially finite-dimensional commutant, i.

20593#pg2>. This result is extended to show that if both operators have property (J), their direct sums also have property (J) <ref:2607. p. 1
Where the paper says it

To answer the third question in [11], the authors in [13] proved that a Hilbert space operator T is similar to a direct integral of strongly irreducible operators if and only if its commutant {T} ′ contains a bounded maximal abelian family of idempotents. Inspired by this necessary-and-sufficient characterization, we introduce property (J) in the setting of von Neumann algebras.

20593#pg2>.

Conclusion and Applications

The paper concludes by showing that Kaplansky’s second test problem holds for every type In von Neumann algebra with 1 ≤ n ≤ 3 in Proposition 4.7 <ref:2607.20593#pg2>. This result is significant as it connects similarity to structural properties like property (J) and finite strongly irreducible decomposition, providing a unified framework for studying this problem across different operator algebras <ref:2607. p. 2

Where the paper says it

To study the finite strongly irreducible decomposition of elements in Banach algebras, we say that an element T in a Banach algebra B has essentially finite-dimensional commutant if the relative commutant of T in B is finite-dimensional modulo its radical. For elements with essentially finite-dimensional commutants in Banach algebras, we prove the following result concerning Kaplansky’s second test problem up to similarity in Theorem 5.

20593#pg2>. The work also touches upon applications in quantum information theory <ref:2607.20593#pg2>.

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The authors present basic definitions and results in the next section <ref:2607.20593#pg2>. In Section 3, they provide a complete characterization of strongly irreducible operators in type In von Neumann algebras in Theorem 3. p. 2

Where the paper says it

We present basic definitions and results in the next section. In Section 3, we provide a complete characterization of strongly irreducible operators in type In von Neumann algebras in Theorem 3.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

We present basic definitions and results in the next section. In Section 3, we provide a complete characterization of strongly irreducible operators in type In von Neumann algebras in Theorem 3.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

We present basic definitions and results in the next section. In Section 3, we provide a complete characterization of strongly irreducible operators in type In von Neumann algebras in Theorem 3.

10 <ref:2607. p. 0
Where the paper says it

12271074); Yuanhang Zhang was supported in part by NSFC (No. 1 arXiv:2607.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

12271074); Yuanhang Zhang was supported in part by NSFC (No. 1 arXiv:2607.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

12271074); Yuanhang Zhang was supported in part by NSFC (No. 1 arXiv:2607.

20593#pg2>. By introducing the concept of property (J) in Definition 3. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In Section 3, we provide a complete characterization of strongly irreducible operators in type In von Neumann algebras in Theorem 3. By introducing the concept of property (J) in Definition 3.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In Section 3, we provide a complete characterization of strongly irreducible operators in type In von Neumann algebras in Theorem 3. By introducing the concept of property (J) in Definition 3.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In Section 3, we provide a complete characterization of strongly irreducible operators in type In von Neumann algebras in Theorem 3. By introducing the concept of property (J) in Definition 3.

12, they study the finite strongly irreducible decomposition of operators in Theorem 3. p. 2
Where the paper says it

By introducing the concept of property (J) in Definition 3. 12, we study the finite strongly irreducible decomposition of operators in Theorem 3.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

By introducing the concept of property (J) in Definition 3. 12, we study the finite strongly irreducible decomposition of operators in Theorem 3.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

By introducing the concept of property (J) in Definition 3. 12, we study the finite strongly irreducible decomposition of operators in Theorem 3.

17 <ref:2607. p. 0
Where the paper says it

12271074); Yuanhang Zhang was supported in part by NSFC (No. 1 arXiv:2607.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

12271074); Yuanhang Zhang was supported in part by NSFC (No. 1 arXiv:2607.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

12271074); Yuanhang Zhang was supported in part by NSFC (No. 1 arXiv:2607.

20593#pg2>. In Section 4, they obtain Theorem 4. p. 2
Where the paper says it

17 and affirmatively answer Kaplansky’s second test problem for operators with property (J) in type In von Neumann algebras in Theorem 3. In Section 4, we obtain Theorem 4.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

17 and affirmatively answer Kaplansky’s second test problem for operators with property (J) in type In von Neumann algebras in Theorem 3. In Section 4, we obtain Theorem 4.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

17 and affirmatively answer Kaplansky’s second test problem for operators with property (J) in type In von Neumann algebras in Theorem 3. In Section 4, we obtain Theorem 4.

3, a reduction theorem, and remove the assumption of property (J) in Proposition 4. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In Section 4, we obtain Theorem 4. 3, a reduction theorem, and remove the assumption of property (J) in Proposition 4.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In Section 4, we obtain Theorem 4. 3, a reduction theorem, and remove the assumption of property (J) in Proposition 4.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In Section 4, we obtain Theorem 4. 3, a reduction theorem, and remove the assumption of property (J) in Proposition 4.

7 for 1 ≤ n ≤ 3 by Proposition 4. p. 0
Where the paper says it

With the help of Voiculescu’s noncommutative Weyl-von Neumann theorem [5, Theorem II. 8], Kaplansky’s second test problem on approximate unitary equivalence also admits a positive solution [20, Proposition 4.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

With the help of Voiculescu’s noncommutative Weyl-von Neumann theorem [5, Theorem II. 8], Kaplansky’s second test problem on approximate unitary equivalence also admits a positive solution [20, Proposition 4.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

With the help of Voiculescu’s noncommutative Weyl-von Neumann theorem [5, Theorem II. 8], Kaplansky’s second test problem on approximate unitary equivalence also admits a positive solution [20, Proposition 4.

7 <ref:2607.20593#pg2>.

How the training signal is built

The authors present basic definitions and results in the next section <ref:2607.20593#pg2>. In Section 3, they provide a complete characterization of strongly irreducible operators in type In von Neumann algebras in Theorem 3.10 <ref:2607.20593#pg2>. By introducing the concept of property (J) in Definition 3.12, they study the finite strongly irreducible decomposition of operators in Theorem 3.17 <ref:2607.20593#pg2>. In Section 4, they obtain Theorem 4.3, a reduction theorem, and remove the assumption of property (J) in Proposition 4.7 for 1 ≤ n ≤ 3 by Proposition 4.7 <ref:2607.20593#pg2>.

Where the gains come from

The authors present basic definitions and results in the next section <ref:2607.20593#pg2>. In Section 3, they provide a complete characterization of strongly irreducible operators in type In von Neumann algebras in Theorem 3.10 <ref:2607.20593#pg2>. By introducing the concept of property (J) in Definition 3.12, they study the finite strongly irreducible decomposition of operators in Theorem 3.17 <ref:2607.20593#pg2>. In Section 4, they obtain Theorem 4.3, a reduction theorem, and remove the assumption of property (J) in Proposition 4.7 for 1 ≤ n ≤ 3 by Proposition 4.7 <ref:2607.20593#pg2>. In Section 5, they study Kaplansky’s second test problem for elements in Banach algebras (see Theorem 5. p. 2

Where the paper says it

To study the finite strongly irreducible decomposition of elements in Banach algebras, we say that an element T in a Banach algebra B has essentially finite-dimensional commutant if the relative commutant of T in B is finite-dimensional modulo its radical. For elements with essentially finite-dimensional commutants in Banach algebras, we prove the following result concerning Kaplansky’s second test problem up to similarity in Theorem 5.

13) <ref:2607. p. 0
Where the paper says it

12271074); Yuanhang Zhang was supported in part by NSFC (No. 1 arXiv:2607.

20593#pg2>.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved ability to determine similarity of operators in Banach algebras by checking if T has property (J) or essentially finite-dimensional commutant, as stated in Theorem 5.13: If T1 has essentially finite-dimensional commutant in B, then T1 ∼ T2 in B.

  2. Enhanced capability to analyze the local structure of operators in type In von Neumann algebras by using the characterization provided by Theorem 3.10: "T is strongly irreducible if and only if there exists a unitary operator U in Mn(A) such that U∗T U = (tij)1 j, i.e., T is upper triangular; (2) tjj = tnn for 1 <= j <= n - 1; and (3) R(tj,j+1) = IA for 1 <= j <= n - 1."

  3. Increased precision in classifying operators in type In von Neumann algebras by utilizing the finite strongly irreducible decomposition characterized in Theorem 3.27: T has property (J) if and only if T has a finite strongly irreducible decomposition.

  4. Capacity to perform similarity analysis between operators with property (J) by applying the uniqueness result from Theorem 3.26: if P and Q are two bounded maximal abelian families of idempotents in an operator's relative commutant, then there exists an invertible operator X in that relative commutant such that Q = X−1PX.

  5. Application to quantum information theory by relating local unitary equivalence to Kaplansky's second problem via the condition: local unitary equivalence and Kaplansky’s second problem are closely related.

Abstract

The Ulam--Kaplansky problem up to similarity in operator algebras asks whether A plus A about B plus B implies A about B. We construct block-diagonal compact operators for which this implication fails. For von Neumann algebras with separable predual, we prove that this cancellation property is equivalent to subhomogeneity. Moreover, we obtain a cancellation law for finite ampliations in unital Banach algebras when the commutant of one element is finite dimensional modulo its Jacobson radical.

Sources

Related papers