Stoner transitions beyond mean-field in two-dimensional electronic systems: a diagrammatic Monte Carlo study
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Stoner transitions beyond mean-field in two-dimensional electronic systems".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Stoner transitions beyond mean-field in two-dimensional electronic systems: a diagrammatic Monte Carlo study In this study, they investigate Stoner instabilities for fermions with repulsive interaction in two-dimensional electronic systems using a diagrammatic Monte Carlo algorithm to go beyond the ladder approximation.
Kai: The authors employ a diagrammatic Monte Carlo (DiagMC) technique to analyze how Stoner magnetism depends on the strength of gate screening of the Coulomb interaction.
Mira: They model a gate-screened Coulomb interaction by approximating it as a step function U(q) = U0Θ(q∗ − q), where Θ(x) = 1 for x > 0 and Θ(x) = 0 for x < 0.
Kai: For a one-valley system, they consider a dispersion relation of the form epsilonk = ck2α where c has a dimension of energy.
Title and authors: Kai: Let's start with the title and the authors of this work, "Stoner transitions beyond mean-field in two-dimensional electronic systems: a diagrammatic Monte Carlo study." It tells us right away that they are going beyond just the basic mean-field theory we often use for these kinds of magnetic instabilities.
Mira: And it points to their method, diagrammatic Monte Carlo, which is a way to calculate these interactions beyond the simplest approximations. This isn't just a theoretical exercise; it’s a computational study designed to get closer to what happens in reality than simpler models allow.
Lev: For us building real hardware, that means they are trying to capture physics that might be important for error correction or material design, even if the calculation itself is computationally intensive.
Kai: So when we look at the authors, Yueh-Chen Lee, Nikolay V. Prokof’ev, and Andrey V. Chubukov—they are people deeply rooted in condensed matter theory and many of us in this field—and they are tackling a fundamental problem about how magnetism emerges in these materials.
Mira: Their work connects several ideas here, like the role of screening from the gate interaction and how different shapes of the electron energy structure, or dispersion relations, dictate whether we get one transition or two transitions.
Lev: I wonder if that distinction between one transition and two transitions is something that would be really hard to predict on a real quantum simulator setup.
The paper's summary: Kai: So what’s the core finding they summarize in this paper? They found that in a one-valley system, a Stoner transition into ferromagnetism only happens at low density if there is some kind of cutoff on the momentum transfer carried by the interaction.
Mira: And they also looked at two-valley systems and found that the restriction imposed by this cutoff is less severe than in the one-valley case. They found either a direct Stoner transition into a spin and valley polarized state, or sometimes they see a set of two Stoner transitions through an intermediate valley polarized state.
Lev: That distinction between those pathways based on the dispersion relation seems like it would be really crucial for us to understand how we might engineer these states in any device.
Kai: They also highlighted that the pathway is controlled by the anisotropy of the fermionic dispersion, meaning how the energy depends on momentum in different directions matters a lot.
Mira: And they pointed out that this holds even when you tune the system to a van Hove singularity, which is a point where things get particularly interesting in terms of density and interaction effects.
The paper's improvements: Kai: Now let's talk about what they suggest improves upon previous work or what their study adds to the picture. They emphasize that the screening of the Coulomb interaction is determinative to whether Stoner ferromagnetism actually develops at a certain gate distance.
Mira: That’s a big point because earlier variational Monte Carlo studies, like those by Valenti et al., found a range of gate distances where ferromagnetic order did develop for a screened interaction, which suggests this screening effect is key.
Lev: From an error correction standpoint, knowing that the transition depends on the gate distance gives us something concrete to tune when designing any experimental setup.
Kai: They also show that they can tune the transition order itself by changing the cutoff momentum transfer. For example, with a k six dispersion, you can move from a first-order transition to a second-order one just by adjusting that cutoff value.
Mira: That ability to tune the order based on density or interaction parameters is really powerful for understanding how these systems behave across different regimes.
Conclusion: Kai: So, wrapping up this paper, the main point is that in two-valley systems with elliptic dispersion, they prefer to be valley polarized over becoming fully ferromagnetic. They also found that upon increasing interaction strength in those elliptic cases, you see a sequence: first the valley-polarized state forms, followed by a subsequent ferromagnetic transition.
Mira: And at large enough cutoffs, this sequence leads to both spin and valley polarization when the transition is first-order. The whole picture shows that how the geometry of your system affects the outcome of this instability is what really matters here.
Lev: For me, what I'm hearing is that if we are designing a system where we want a specific kind of ordering, like just valley polarization, we need to be very careful about tuning both the interaction and the gate screening simultaneously.
Kai: That sounds like something our hardware teams would definitely focus on—controlling those parameters precisely. So this paper gives us a deeper understanding of how these transitions happen beyond just the basic mean-field picture.
School of Physics and Astronomy and William I. Fine Theoretical Physics Institute, University of Minnesota · Department of Physics, University of Massachusetts
cond-mat.str-el
Submitted: 2026-07-15
Updated: 2026-11-06
Comments: 35 pages, 17 figures
DOI: 10.1103/ttcb-7bh3
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 78/100
The gist: Stoner transitions beyond mean-field in two-dimensional electronic systems: a diagrammatic Monte Carlo study In this study…
Key concepts
- Stoner Instability
- This refers to a tendency for electrons in a material with repulsive interactions to spontaneously develop magnetic order (ferromagnetism). The study examines when this instability occurs in 2D systems using advanced simulation techniques.
- Diagrammatic Monte Carlo (DiagMC)
- A sophisticated computational method used here to go beyond basic approximations. It allows researchers to analyze how the Coulomb interaction, which is modified by gate screening, influences the magnetic properties of the electronic system.
- $q^*$ and $k_F$
- $q^*$ is a momentum cutoff that determines the range of interactions considered in simulations. $k_F$ represents the Fermi wave vector. Comparing these two values helps determine whether a magnetic transition is first-order or second-order.
- Dispersion Relation ($\epsilon_k$)
- This describes how the energy ($\epsilon$) of an electron depends on its momentum ($k$). The study tests different shapes, like parabolic or $k^6$, to see how the shape dictates the nature and location of magnetic transitions.
Terminology
Summary
Stoner transitions beyond mean-field in two-dimensional electronic systems: a diagrammatic Monte Carlo study In this study, they investigate Stoner instabilities for fermions with repulsive interaction in two-dimensional electronic systems using a diagrammatic Monte Carlo algorithm to go beyond the ladder approximation. p. 1 Abstract
Stoner instabilities for fermions with repulsive interaction have been well studied within the mean-field (ladder)
approximation. In this study, we consider two-dimensional electronic systems with one or two valleys and discuss a
Stoner transition beyond the ladder approximation.Where the paper says it
Methodology and Model Setup
The authors employ a diagrammatic Monte Carlo (DiagMC) technique to analyze how Stoner magnetism depends on the strength of gate screening of the Coulomb interaction. They model a gate-screened Coulomb interaction by approximating it as a step function U(q) = U0Θ(q∗ − q), where Θ(x) = 1 for x > 0 and Θ(x) = 0 for x < 0. p. 2 A gate-screened Coulomb interaction U(q) is roughly a constant U0 at
small momentum transfers and decays once q exceeds a certain scale q
∗
. We model this by approximating
U(q) by a step function U(q) = U0Θ(q
∗ − q), where Θ(x) = 1 for x > 0 and Θ(x) = 0 for x < 0. We summarize our results for a one-valley system in Fig. We consider a system of fermions with
dispersion relation ϵk = ck2α
, where c has a dimension of energy. In these units, k is dimensionless and each of the two components of k varies in the interval
−π < ki < π and k = (k
2
x +k
2
y
)
1/2 varies between 0 and π
√
2. The density of states (DOS) per spin projection is
N(ϵ) =
1
4παc
1/α
1
ϵ
(α−1)/α (1)
The Fermi energy is ϵF = ck2α
F
and
N(kF) = NF =
1
4παc
1
k
2(α−1)
F
(2)
At T = 0, the dimensionless coupling relevant to Stoner transition is λ = U0NF = U0Πph(0), where Πph(0) is
3Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Results for One-Valley Systems
For a parabolic dispersion, a ferromagnetic transition occurs for q∗ comparable to kF. The transition is predominantly first-order, except in a narrow window of q∗, where it is second order. p. 3 We find that for a parabolic dispersion, a ferromagnetic transition occurs for q
∗
comparable to kF. The
transition is predominantly first-order, except in a narrow window of q
∗
, where it is second order. The
transition is predominantly first-order, except in a narrow window of q
∗
, where it is second order. For the
k
6 dispersion, which is flat for k < 1 and steep at k > 1, a Stoner transition persists to larger q
∗
/kF due to
the larger DOS N(ϵ) at small ϵ (i. The
transition is predominantly first-order, except in a narrow window of q
∗
, where it is second order. For the
k
6 dispersion, which is flat for k < 1 and steep at k > 1, a Stoner transition persists to larger q
∗
/kF due to
the larger DOS N(ϵ) at small ϵ (i.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Results for Two-Valley Systems
In a two-valley system with an isotropic dispersion, spin and valley symmetries are either unbroken or broken simultaneously. For this case, they find a valley/spin ordering transition for q∗ comparable to kF. p. 3 For an isotropic dispersion (η = 1) spin and valley symmetries are either unbroken or broken simultaneously [19, 24, 25]. For this case we find valley/spin ordering transition for q
∗
comparable to kF. A full polarization is then reached at larger
couplings. For elliptic dispersion, we find at a larger q
∗
a sequence of two first-order transitions: first into a
valley-polarized state and then into a valley and spin polarized state.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusion on Transition Order
The transition order depends on the cutoff q∗; for parabolic dispersion, it is second-order for q∗ comparable to kF, while for k6 dispersion, the transition can be tuned from first- to second-order by decreasing the cutoff. In two-valley systems with elliptic dispersion, upon increasing interaction, the valley-polarized state is followed by a subsequent ferromagnetic transition and becomes both spin and valley-polarized at large enough cutoffs where the transition is first-order. p. 3 For elliptic dispersion, we find at a larger q
∗
a sequence of two first-order transitions: first into a
valley-polarized state and then into a valley and spin polarized state. At smaller q
∗
, we find a second-order
valley transition, while the spin symmetry is never broken.Where the paper says it
Final Summary of Findings
The paper concludes that in two-valley systems, compared to the system with isotropic dispersion, a system with elliptic dispersion prefers to be valley polarized over ferromagnetic. By tuning the cutoff, the transition can either be first- or second-order. p. 3 , small k) and a steep dispersion for k > 1, which effectively provides an
additional cutoff for the interaction. The transition is first-order for larger q
∗
and second-order for smaller
q
∗
. For elliptic dispersion, we find at a larger q
∗
a sequence of two first-order transitions: first into a
valley-polarized state and then into a valley and spin polarized state. At smaller q
∗
, we find a second-order
valley transition, while the spin symmetry is never broken.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Acknowledgments
The authors thank several individuals for their discussions and assistance with numerical simulations. The research was supported by the National Science Foundation grant NSF:DMR-2325357.
Appendix Details
The Appendix details the technical aspects of the Diagrammatic Monte Carlo algorithm, including updates and a resummation scheme to extrapolate results to infinite order. The resummation technique involves multiplying each term Dn by a factor g(n, Nmax) such that g goes to one when Nmax → ∞ and g decays faster than an exponential function when n → ∞. p. 2 In our study we adopt DiagMC technique to analyze how Stoner magnetism depends on the strength of gate
screening of the Coulomb interaction. A gate-screened Coulomb interaction U(q) is roughly a constant U0 at
small momentum transfers and decays once q exceeds a certain scale q
∗
. In our study we adopt DiagMC technique to analyze how Stoner magnetism depends on the strength of gate
screening of the Coulomb interaction. A gate-screened Coulomb interaction U(q) is roughly a constant U0 at
small momentum transfers and decays once q exceeds a certain scale q
∗
. 2 bottom right). The free part of the Hamiltonian is
H
′
0 =
X
k,σ,γ
ϵk,σ,γ − µ
c
†
k,σ,γ
ck,σ,γ (6)
with the dispersion relation given by
ϵk,γ=1 = c
ηk
2
x +
1
η
k
2
y
! 2 bottom right). The free part of the Hamiltonian is
H
′
0 =
X
k,σ,γ
ϵk,σ,γ − µ
c
†
k,σ,γ
ck,σ,γ (6)
with the dispersion relation given by
ϵk,γ=1 = c
ηk
2
x +
1
η
k
2
y
!Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
References
[1] E. C. Stoner, Collective electron ferromagnetism, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. p. 6 For a two-valley system, we consider the low-energy model with two elliptic electron pockets centered at
the X and Y points in the Brillouin zone, hereafter labeled by the valley indices γ = ±1, respectively [2, 24–26]
(see Fig. 2 bottom right).Where the paper says it
[2] M. S. Hossain, M. K. Ma, K. A. V Rosales, Y J Chung, L N Pfeiffer, K W West, K W Baldwin, and M Shayegan Observation of spontaneous ferromagnetism in a two-dimensional electron system Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 117 32244 (2020)
[3] M. S. Hossain, M. K. Ma, K A Villegas-Rosales, Y J Chung, L N Pfeiffer, K W West, K W Baldwin, and M Shayegan Spontaneous valley polarization of itinerant electrons Phys Rev Lett 127 116601 (2021)
[4] M. S. Hossain, M. K. Ma, K A Villegas-Rosales, Y J Chung, L N Pfeiffer, K W West, K W Baldwin, and M Shayegan Anisotropic two-dimensional disordered wigner solid Phys Rev Lett 129 036601 (2022)
[5] H Zhou, L Holleis, Y Saito, L Cohen, W Huynh, C L Patterson, F Yang, T Taniguchi, K Watanabe and A F Young Isospin magnetism and spin-polarized superconductivity in bernal bilayer graphene Science 375 774 (2022) https://www.science.org/doi/pdf/10.1126/science.abm8386
[6] L Holleis, C Patterson, Y Zhang, Y Vituri, H M Yoo Z H T T W K B E and A F Nadj-Perge Nematicity and orbital depairing in superconducting bernal bilayer graphene Nat Phys 21 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41567-024-02776-7 (2025)
[7] A Seiler, F Geisenhof, F Winterer, K Watanabe, T Taniguchi, T Xu, F Zhang and R Weitz Quantum cascade of correlated phases in trigonally warped bilayer graphene Nature 608 10.1038/s41586-022-04937-1 (2022)
[8] H Zhou, T Xie, A Ghazaryan, et al Half- and quarter-metals in rhombohedral trilayer graphene Nature 598 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-021-03938-w (2021)
[9] T Arp, O Sheekey, H Zhou, et al Intervalley coherence and intrinsic spin orbit coupling in rhombohedral trilayer graphene Nat Phys 20 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41567-024-02560-7 (2024)
[10] C Huang, T M R Wolf, W Qin, N Wei, I V Blinov, and A H MacDonald Spin and orbital metallic magnetism in rhombohedral trilayer graphene Phys Rev B 107 L121405 (2023)
[11] I V Blinov, C Huang, N Wei, Q Wei, T Wolf, and A H MacDonald Partial condensation of mobile excitons in graphene multilayers (2023) arXiv:2303.17350
[12] A Ghazaryan, T Holder, M Serbyn, and E Berg Unconventional superconductivity in systems with annular fermi surfaces Application to rhombohedral trilayer graphene Phys Rev Lett 127 247001 (2021)
[13] S Chatterjee, T Wang, E Berg, et al Inter-valley coherent order and isospin fluctuation mediated superconductivity in rhombohedral trilayer graphene Nat Commun 13 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-33561-w (2022)
[14] N Auerbach, S Dutta, M Uzan, Y Vituri, Y Zhou, A Y Meltzer, S Grover, T Holder, P Emanuel, M E Huber Y Myasoedov K Watanabe T Taniguchi Y Oreg E Berg and E Zeldov Isospin magnetic texture and intervalley exchange interaction in rhombohedral tetralayer graphene Nature Physics 21 1765 (2025)
[15] T Han, Z Lu, G Scuri, J Sung, J Wang, T Han, K Watanabe, T Taniguchi H Park and L Ju Correlated insulator and chern insulators in pentalayer rhombohedral-stacked graphene Nature Nanotechnology 19 181 (2024)
[16] Z M Raines, L I Glazman, and A V Chubukov Unconventional discontinuous transitions in a two-dimensional system with spin and valley degrees of freedom Phys Rev B 110 155402 (2024)
[17] J Kanamori, Electron correlation and ferromagnetism of transition metals Progress of Theoretical Physics 30 275 (1963) https://academic.oup.com/ptp/article-pdf/30/3/275/5278869/30-3-275.pdf
[18] V Y Irkhin, A A Katanin, and M I Katsnelson Effects of van hove singularities on magnetism and superconductivity in the t t't Hubbard model A parquet approach Phys Rev B 64 165107 (2001)
[19] Z M Raines and A V Chubukov Two-dimensional stoner transitions beyond mean field Phys Rev B 110 235433 (2024)
[20] R Ojajärvi, A Chubukov, Y C Lee, et al Pairing at a single van hove point npj Quantum Mater. 9 105 (2024)
[21] I Tupitsyn, B Currie, A Chubukov, B Svistunov, and N Kozik Avoided stoner instability at a single ordinary van hove point E Prokof’ev (2026) arXiv:2605.28761
[22] A Valenti, V Calvera, Y Yang, M A Morales, S A Kivelson, I Esterlis, and S Zhang Critical gate distance for wigner crystallization in the two-dimensional electron gas arXiv:2501.16430 (2025)
[23] O Antebi, A Stern, and E Berg Stoner ferromagnetism in a momentum-confined interacting 2d electron gas Phys Rev Lett 132 086501 (2024)
[24] A Valenti, V Calvera, S A Kivelson, E Berg, and S D Huber Nematic metal in a multivalley electron gas Variational monte carlo analysis and application to alas Phys Rev Lett 132 266501 (2024)
[25] V Calvera, A Valenti, S D Huber, E Berg, and S A Kivelson Theory of coulomb driven nematicity in a multivalley two-dimensional electron gas Phys Rev B 111 155135 (2025)
[26] M Shayegan, E P De Poortere, O Gunawan, Y P Shkolnikov, E Tutuc, and K Vakili Twodimensional electrons occupying multiple valleys in alas physica status solidi (b) 243 3629 (2006) https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1002/pssb.200642212
[27] R D Mayrhofer, M Schoenzeit, and A V Chubukov Stoner transition at finite temperature in a 2d isotropic fermi liquid (2025) arXiv:2507.16026
[28] This restriction is relevant for q∗ < 2kF For larger q∗, the region, over which p is integrated, covers the entire Fermi surface and Π˜ph(0) is the same as Πph(0)
[29] A V Chubukov, A Klein, and D L Maslov Fermi-liquid theory and pomeranchuk instabilities fundamentals and new developments Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics 127 826 (2018)
[30] K Van Houcke, E Kozik, N Prokof’ev, and B Svistunov Diagrammatic monte carlo Physics Procedia 6 95 (2010) computer Simulations Studies in Condensed Matter Physics XXI
[31] J Greitemann and L Pollet Lecture notes on Diagrammatic Monte Carlo for the Fröhlich polaron SciPost Phys Lect Notes 2 (2018)
Appendix A Details
The Appendix details the technical details of the Diagrammatic Monte Carlo algorithm, including updates and a resummation scheme to extrapolate results to infinite order. The resummation technique involves multiplying each term Dn by a factor g(n, Nmax) such that g goes to one when Nmax → ∞ and g decays faster than an exponential function when n → ∞. The extrapolation error is given by the difference between the maximum and minimum of the curves evaluated at 1/Nmax = 0.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved calculation of Stoner transition order by incorporating diagrammatic Monte Carlo results for beyond mean-field corrections. This allows AI systems to predict whether a Stoner transition is first or second order based on the momentum transfer cutoff q star relative to kF.
-
Enhanced modeling of gate screening effects in two-dimensional electronic systems. The AI can now determine how screening of the Coulomb interaction is
determinative to Stoner ferromagnetism
by analyzing results across different gate distances d and momentum cutoffs q star. -
Predictive capability for transition pathways in multi-valley systems. The system can distinguish between a
direct Stoner transition into a spin- and valley-polarized state, or a set of two Stoner transitions via an intermediate valley-polarized state
based on the anisotropy of the fermionic dispersion. -
Analysis of dispersion relation dependence on transition order. The AI can identify that for k6 dispersion, "a Stoner transition persists to larger q star due to the larger DOS N(epsilon) at small epsilon (i.e., small k) and a steep dispersion for k > 1," enabling tuning between first-order and second-order transitions by adjusting the cutoff.
-
Discrimination of polarization states in two-valley systems. The AI can predict if a system will exhibit
spin and valley ordering transition for q star comparable to kF
under isotropic dispersion, or if it will undergo a cascade of transitions into a spin and valley polarized state with an elliptic dispersion.
Abstract
Stoner instabilities for fermions with repulsive interaction have been well studied within the mean-field (ladder) approximation. In this study, we consider two-dimensional electronic systems with one or two valleys and discuss a Stoner transition beyond the ladder approximation. At weak coupling, the corrections to the ladder approximation come predominantly from the renormalization of the particle-hole vertex in the particle-particle channel, and the lowest-order corrections are logarithmically singular in the low-density limit. To investigate the problem beyond the lowest order, we apply the diagrammatic Monte Carlo algorithm and treat ladder and non-ladder renormalizations on equal footing. We find that in a one-valley system, a Stoner transition to a ferromagnetism occurs at low density only if there is a cutoff on the momentum transfer carried by the interaction. In a two-valley system, the restriction is less severe. Here we find either a direct Stoner transition into a spin- and valley-polarized state, or a set of two Stoner transitions via an intermediate valley-polarized state. The pathway is controlled by the anisotropy of the fermionic dispersion.
Sources
- Partial condensation of mobile excitons in graphene multilayers
- Avoided Stoner instability at a single ordinary Van Hove point
- Critical gate distance for Wigner crystallization in the two-dimensional electron gas
- Stoner Transition at Finite Temperature in a 2D Isotropic Fermi Liquid
Related papers
- Coupled Magnetic and Lattice Excitations in Multiferroic Ba3HoRu2O9: Insights from Neutron Scattering, Raman Spectroscopy, and Machine-Learned Phonon Calculations
- Gossamer Superconductivity in Moir'e WSe 2 Bilayer
- Spin-density wave of ferrimagnetic building blocks masking the ferromagnetic quantum-critical point in NbFe2
- Raman Circular Dichroism and spinon Quantum Geometry of Chiral Quantum Spin Liquids
- Twin Algebras: Condensable Algebras beyond Anyons
- Spin supersolid in triangular lattice easy-axis spin-1/2 antiferromagnet: a fermionic parton perspective