Reformation of Supercritical Perpendicular Shock

arXiv:2607.09389 · physics.space-ph, physics.plasm-ph · Submitted 2026-07-10 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Reformation of Supercritical Perpendicular Shock".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Super-critical collisionless shocks are not static structures but evolve continuously as they reflect incoming ions back upstream The shock alternates between narrow Hall-dominated ramps and broad reflectedion feet, producing quasi-periodic ion-scale non-stationarity This reformation cycle, spatially organized by the two-dimensional shock structure, explains most of the observed non-stationarity Observational Evidence and Key Signatures MMS observations reveal repeated ion phase-space holes and intense, localized Hall electric fields The physical origin of the observed variability remains uncertain, specifically whether it is explained by obliquely propagating shock ripples or cyclic shock reformation The observations establish three key properties of the shock: (1) pronounced nonstationarity evidenced by multiple phase-space holes, (2) strong Hall electric fields localized near the ion reflection point, and (3) a large, time-dependent reflected-ion population The presence of the foot is reflected in positive bulk Vt2 and reduced Vn compared to the upstream (panel b) Simulation Methodology Two-dimensional hybrid particle-in-cell simulations were performed using the HYPSI code based on the current advance method and cyclic leapfrog (CAM-CL) algorithm Protons are treated kinetically as macroparticles, while electrons are described as a massless, charge-neutralizing adiabatic fluid with γe = 5/3 Quantities in the simulation are normalized to their unperturbed, upstream values using ion inertial lengths di and inverse cyclotron frequencies omega−1ci The simulation domain is 50 × 50, d2i with ∆x = ∆y = 0.2di, and is evolved to 20, omega−1ci using an ion time step ∆t = 0.01 Mechanism of Non-Stationarity The shock transition alternates between two distinct local states: a first thin state consisting of a narrow ramp with little or no upstream foot, and a second thick state where reflected ions have propagated upstream to form a dense foot In the first thin state, the normal electric field is dominated by the Hall term, producing a large cross-shock potential capable of specularly reflecting a substantial fraction of the incoming ions In the second thick state, En is largely balanced by the ion convection term associated with the reflectedion population This leads to a self-regulating feedback cycle where strong Hallfield reflection produces the reflected-ion foot, while the foot subsequently weakens the Hall electric field, suppressing further reflection Virtual Spacecraft Analysis and Conclusion A virtual spacecraft analysis demonstrates that this evolving shock naturally reproduces many of the qualitative features observed by MMS, including multiple magnetic compressions, localized Hall electric fields, ion phase-space holes, and intermittent reflected-ion populations The close correspondence between the VSC and MMS observations demonstrates that the observed magnetic structures, ion phase-space holes, and localized Hall electric fields are naturally explained by repeated encounters with a structured shock front However, differences between the simulations and observations indicate that fully three-dimensional effects remain important for reproducing the detailed morphology of the observed shock structure The result is a highly structured, non-stationary shock in which neighboring regions simultaneously occupy different phases of the reflection cycle REFERENCES Biskamp, D., & Welter, H.

Kai: (1972, dec).

Mira: Numerical studies of magnetosonic collisionless shock waves.

Kai: Nuclear Fusion, 12 (6), 663.

Paper summary: Kai: So we've established that this paper investigates whether those phase-space holes we see are due to shock ripples or this cyclic rebuilding process of the shock transition.

Mira: The thesis is that for a nearly perpendicular, supercritical bow shock, the observations strongly favor cyclic shock reformation as the dominant source of non-stationarity.

Lev: What they claim is that this reformation cycle—alternating between a narrow ramp and a broad reflected ion foot—is governed by a specific feedback mechanism involving the Hall electric field.

Kai: They show that this feedback loop, where strong Hall field reflection creates the foot which then weakens the field, suppresses further reflection until the foot decays and the cycle starts over.

Mira: The reason this matters is that it provides a physical mechanism to explain why we see these repeated ion phase-space holes and localized Hall electric fields in our MMS data.

Lev: It gives us a way to model this non-stationarity using two dimensional hybrid simulations, which the authors say are quite effective at capturing this process.

Kai: The paper essentially says that the spatial organization of this reformation cycle across the two dimensional shock structure is what explains most of the variability we see.

Mira: It connects those observed magnetic structures and ion dynamics to a specific, repeatable physical process happening right at the shock front.

Lev: And they show how this mechanism works by comparing different states, looking at how the normal electric field behaves in both the thin ramp state and the thick foot state.

Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up this, the paper "Reformation of Supercritical Perpendicular Shock" by Khotyaintsev, Trotta, and Graham is showing us that non-stationarity in these shocks isn't just noise or a single ripple pattern.

Mira: It’s a continuous process where the shock surface physically reforms itself over and over, driven by the interaction between the Hall field and reflected ions.

Lev: The implication for real hardware running this stuff is that if you build a simulation, you have to model this alternating cycle of reflection and decay to get the right physics onto your system.

Kai: For anyone listening who doesn't deal with plasma physics daily, it means that the structure of the shock itself is constantly changing its shape in a very specific way.

Mira: It tells us that these shocks are highly structured objects where different parts of them are always doing different things simultaneously based on where they are in this reformation cycle.

Lev: And while this two dimensional analysis explains most of the observed non-stationarity, the authors admit that fully three dimensional effects still matter for getting the exact shape right <ref:2607.09389#pg1>.

Kai: So, we've moved from just asking if ripples cause it to showing that a self-regulating reformation cycle is a very strong candidate for explaining these ion dynamics.

Swedish Institute of Space Physics · Space and Plasma Physics Department of Uppsala University · European Space Agency European Space Astronomy Centre

physics.space-ph, physics.plasm-ph

Submitted: 2026-07-10

Updated: 2026-11-12

Comments: 12 pages, 3 figures, 1 table

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: Super-critical collisionless shocks are not static structures but evolve continuously as they reflect incoming ions back upstream The shock alternates between narrow Hall-dominated ramps and broad…

Key concepts

Non-stationarity
This refers to the shock not being a fixed structure but constantly changing its properties over time. In this context, it means the shock alternates between two distinct local states: a thin ramp and a thick foot where ions have been reflected upstream.
Hall Electric Fields
These are strong electric fields localized near where ions reflect off the shock. They are caused by the Hall term in the equations, which dominates in the narrow ramp state, allowing for specular reflection of incoming ions.
Shock Reformation Cycle
The shock undergoes a self-regulating feedback loop: a thin state creates a strong Hall field that reflects ions to form a foot. This foot then weakens the Hall field, suppressing further reflection, leading to an alternating cycle of thin ramp and thick foot states.

Terminology

Summary

Super-critical collisionless shocks are not static structures but evolve continuously as they reflect incoming ions back upstream The shock alternates between narrow Hall-dominated ramps and broad reflectedion feet, producing quasi-periodic ion-scale non-stationarity This reformation cycle, spatially organized by the two-dimensional shock structure, explains most of the observed non-stationarity

Observational Evidence and Key Signatures

MMS observations reveal repeated ion phase-space holes and intense, localized Hall electric fields The physical origin of the observed variability remains uncertain, specifically whether it is explained by obliquely propagating shock ripples or cyclic shock reformation The observations establish three key properties of the shock: (1) pronounced nonstationarity evidenced by multiple phase-space holes, (2) strong Hall electric fields localized near the ion reflection point, and (3) a large, time-dependent reflected-ion population The presence of the foot is reflected in positive bulk Vt2 and reduced Vn compared to the upstream (panel b)

Simulation Methodology

Two-dimensional hybrid particle-in-cell simulations were performed using the HYPSI code based on the current advance method and cyclic leapfrog (CAM-CL) algorithm Protons are treated kinetically as macroparticles, while electrons are described as a massless, charge-neutralizing adiabatic fluid with γe = 5/3 Quantities in the simulation are normalized to their unperturbed, upstream values using ion inertial lengths di and inverse cyclotron frequencies omega−1ci The simulation domain is 50 × 50, d2i with ∆x = ∆y = 0.2di, and is evolved to 20, omega−1ci using an ion time step ∆t = 0. p. 4

Where the paper says it

The simulation domain is 50 × 50, d2 i with ∆x = ∆y = 0. 2di , 500 particles per cell upstream, and is evolved to 20, Ω −1 ci using an ion time step ∆t = 0.

01

Mechanism of Non-Stationarity

The shock transition alternates between two distinct local states: a first thin state consisting of a narrow ramp with little or no upstream foot, and a second thick state where reflected ions have propagated upstream to form a dense foot In the first thin state, the normal electric field is dominated by the Hall term, producing a large cross-shock potential capable of specularly reflecting a substantial fraction of the incoming ions In the second thick state, En is largely balanced by the ion convection term associated with the reflectedion population This leads to a self-regulating feedback cycle where strong Hallfield reflection produces the reflected-ion foot, while the foot subsequently weakens the Hall electric field, suppressing further reflection

Virtual Spacecraft Analysis and Conclusion

A virtual spacecraft analysis demonstrates that this evolving shock naturally reproduces many of the qualitative features observed by MMS, including multiple magnetic compressions, localized Hall electric fields, ion phase-space holes, and intermittent reflected-ion populations The close correspondence between the VSC and MMS observations demonstrates that the observed magnetic structures, ion phase-space holes, and localized Hall electric fields are naturally explained by repeated encounters with a structured shock front However, differences between the simulations and observations indicate that fully three-dimensional effects remain important for reproducing the detailed morphology of the observed shock structure The result is a highly structured, non-stationary shock in which neighboring regions simultaneously occupy different phases of the reflection cycle

REFERENCES

Biskamp, D., & Welter, H. p. 1

Where the paper says it

1 Introduction Collisionless quasi-perpendicular supercritical shocks are intrinsically non-stationary, but the nature of this non-stationarity remains a long-standing problem. Early one-dimensional particle simulations showed that periodic reflection of incoming ions causes the shock transition to rebuild itself cyclically, a process known as shock reformation (Biskamp & Welter, 1972; Burgess, 1989; Lembege & Savoini, 1992).

(1972, dec). p. 1
Where the paper says it

1 Introduction Collisionless quasi-perpendicular supercritical shocks are intrinsically non-stationary, but the nature of this non-stationarity remains a long-standing problem. Early one-dimensional particle simulations showed that periodic reflection of incoming ions causes the shock transition to rebuild itself cyclically, a process known as shock reformation (Biskamp & Welter, 1972; Burgess, 1989; Lembege & Savoini, 1992).

Numerical studies of magnetosonic collisionless shock waves. p. 1
Where the paper says it

This ”bow shock” is not a smooth, unchanging wall of plasma — it constantly rebuilds itself as some of the incoming particles bounce off and pile up in front of it before the shock catches up and absorbs them. Exactly how this rebuilding happens has been debated for decades: does the shock’s surface simply ripple like a flag in the wind, or does the entire shock front repeatedly break down and reform, like waves crashing on a beach?

Nuclear Fusion, 12 (6), 663. Retrieved from https://dx. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Conflict of Interest The authors declare no conflicts of interest relevant to this study. Availability Statement MMS data are available at the MMS Science Data Center (https://lasp.

doi.org/10.1088/0029-5515/12/6/006 doi: 10. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Data analysis was performed using the IRFU-Matlab analysis package (Khotyaintsev et al. All the simulation data used in this work can be downloaded from https://doi.

1088/0029-5515/12/6/006

Burgess, D. (1989, May). p. 1

Where the paper says it

1 Introduction Collisionless quasi-perpendicular supercritical shocks are intrinsically non-stationary, but the nature of this non-stationarity remains a long-standing problem. Early one-dimensional particle simulations showed that periodic reflection of incoming ions causes the shock transition to rebuild itself cyclically, a process known as shock reformation (Biskamp & Welter, 1972; Burgess, 1989; Lembege & Savoini, 1992).

Cyclic behavior at quasi-parallel collisionless shocks. p. 1
Where the paper says it

This self-repeating cycle, occurring at slightly different times across the shock’s surface, explains most of the disturbed, ever-changing structure seen by the spacecraft. 1 Introduction Collisionless quasi-perpendicular supercritical shocks are intrinsically non-stationary, but the nature of this non-stationarity remains a long-standing problem.

Geophys. Res. Lett., 16 (5), 345-348. doi: 10.1029/GL016i005p00345

Burgess, D., Hellinger, P., Gingell, I., & Tr´avn´ıˇcek, P. M. (2016). Microstructure in two- and three-dimensional hybrid simulations of perpendicular collisionless shocks. p. 1

Where the paper says it

1 Introduction Collisionless quasi-perpendicular supercritical shocks are intrinsically non-stationary, but the nature of this non-stationarity remains a long-standing problem. Early one-dimensional particle simulations showed that periodic reflection of incoming ions causes the shock transition to rebuild itself cyclically, a process known as shock reformation (Biskamp & Welter, 1972; Burgess, 1989; Lembege & Savoini, 1992).

Journal of Plasma Physics, 82 (4), 905820401. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Khotyaintsev1,2 , Domenico Trotta3 , Daniel B. Graham1 1Swedish Institute of Space Physics, Uppsala, Sweden 2Space and Plasma Physics, Department of Physics and Astronomy, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden 3European Space Agency (ESA), European Space Astronomy Centre (ESAC), Camino Bajo del Castillo s/n, 28692 Villanueva de la Ca˜nada, Madrid, Spain Key Points: • MMS observations and high-resolution simulations investigate the non-stationarity of a perpendicular supercritical collisionless shock.

doi: 10.1017/S0022377816000660

Burgess, D., & Scholer, M. p. 4

Where the paper says it

In the following section, we compare these observations with two-dimensional hybrid simulations to determine the physical origin of this non-stationarity. 3 Simulations We perform two-dimensional hybrid particle-in-cell simulations using the HYPSI code (Burgess & Scholer, 2007; Trotta et al.

(2007, January). p. 4
Where the paper says it

In the following section, we compare these observations with two-dimensional hybrid simulations to determine the physical origin of this non-stationarity. 3 Simulations We perform two-dimensional hybrid particle-in-cell simulations using the HYPSI code (Burgess & Scholer, 2007; Trotta et al.

Shock front instability associated with reflected ions at the perpendicular shock. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In two dimensions, shock reformation persists, though the dynamics become more complex as reflected ions gyrate upstream and return to the shock at locations displaced from their original reflection points. Two-dimensional geometry also permits the development of the Alfv´en ion cyclotron (AIC) instability, which corrugates the shock front with ion-scale ripples (Winske & Quest, 1988).

Physics of Plasmas, 14 (1), 012108- 012108. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Khotyaintsev1,2 , Domenico Trotta3 , Daniel B. Graham1 1Swedish Institute of Space Physics, Uppsala, Sweden 2Space and Plasma Physics, Department of Physics and Astronomy, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden 3European Space Agency (ESA), European Space Astronomy Centre (ESAC), Camino Bajo del Castillo s/n, 28692 Villanueva de la Ca˜nada, Madrid, Spain Key Points: • MMS observations and high-resolution simulations investigate the non-stationarity of a perpendicular supercritical collisionless shock.

doi: 10.1063/1.2435317

Ergun, R. E., Tucker, S., Westfall, J., Goodrich, K. A., Malaspina, D. M., Summers, D.,... Cully, C. M. (2014, December). p. 2

Where the paper says it

We use the magnetic field measured by FGM (Russell et al. , 2014), ion data by FPI-DIS (Pollock et al.

The Axial Double Probe and Fields Signal Processing for the MMS Mission. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Fully three-dimensional hybrid simulations further show that field-aligned AIC fluctuations can couple to the quasiperpendicular reformation process, producing obliquely propagating ripples that combine characteristics of both surface corrugation and cyclic ion reflection (Burgess et al. Recent observations by the Magnetospheric Multiscale Mission (MMS) have revealed that non-stationarity is common at Earth’s bow shock.

Space Sci. Rev.: doi: 10.1007/s11214-014-0115-x

Johlander, A., Schwartz, S. J., Vaivads, A., Khotyaintsev, Y. p. 0

Where the paper says it

• A feedback between Hall-field ion reflection and the evolving reflected-ion foot governs the observed shock dynamics. Corresponding author: Yuri Khotyaintsev, yuri@irfu.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

• A feedback between Hall-field ion reflection and the evolving reflected-ion foot governs the observed shock dynamics. Corresponding author: Yuri Khotyaintsev, yuri@irfu.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

• A feedback between Hall-field ion reflection and the evolving reflected-ion foot governs the observed shock dynamics. Corresponding author: Yuri Khotyaintsev, yuri@irfu.

V., Gingell, I., Peng, I. B.,... Burch, J. L. (2016, Oct). p. 2
Where the paper says it

manuscript submitted to Geophysical Research Letters space holes within the shock transition (Johlander et al. , 2016, 2018), demonstrated the importance of strong sub-proton scale normal electric fields for ion reflection (Khotyaintsev et al.

Rippled quasiperpendicular shock observed by the magnetospheric multiscale spacecraft. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Fully three-dimensional hybrid simulations further show that field-aligned AIC fluctuations can couple to the quasiperpendicular reformation process, producing obliquely propagating ripples that combine characteristics of both surface corrugation and cyclic ion reflection (Burgess et al. Recent observations by the Magnetospheric Multiscale Mission (MMS) have revealed that non-stationarity is common at Earth’s bow shock.

Phys. Rev. Lett.: 117, 165101 Retrieved from https://link. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Conflict of Interest The authors declare no conflicts of interest relevant to this study. Availability Statement MMS data are available at the MMS Science Data Center (https://lasp.

aps.org/doi/10. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Data analysis was performed using the IRFU-Matlab analysis package (Khotyaintsev et al. All the simulation data used in this work can be downloaded from https://doi.

1103/PhysRevLett.117.165101 doi: 2607

Johlander, A., Vaivads, A., Khotyaintsev, Y. V., Gingell, I., Schwartz, S. J., Giles, B. L.,... Russell, C. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The shock parameters are summarized in Table 1. We use the magnetic field measured by FGM (Russell et al.

T. (2018, nov). p. 2
Where the paper says it

manuscript submitted to Geophysical Research Letters space holes within the shock transition (Johlander et al. , 2016, 2018), demonstrated the importance of strong sub-proton scale normal electric fields for ion reflection (Khotyaintsev et al.

Shock ripples observed by the mms spacecraft: ion reflection and dispersive properties. p. 1
Where the paper says it

These ripples locally rotate the shock normal and produce spatial variations in shock properties, including periodic changes in the normal magnetic field component, Bn (Lowe & Burgess, 2003). Fully three-dimensional hybrid simulations further show that field-aligned AIC fluctuations can couple to the quasiperpendicular reformation process, producing obliquely propagating ripples that combine characteristics of both surface corrugation and cyclic ion reflection (Burgess et al.

Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion, 60 (12), 125006 Retrieved from https://dx. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Khotyaintsev1,2 , Domenico Trotta3 , Daniel B. Graham1 1Swedish Institute of Space Physics, Uppsala, Sweden 2Space and Plasma Physics, Department of Physics and Astronomy, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden 3European Space Agency (ESA), European Space Astronomy Centre (ESAC), Camino Bajo del Castillo s/n, 28692 Villanueva de la Ca˜nada, Madrid, Spain Key Points: • MMS observations and high-resolution simulations investigate the non-stationarity of a perpendicular supercritical collisionless shock.

doi/ 10.1088/1361-6587/aae920 doi: 2607

Khotyaintsev, Y., Vaivads, A., Johansson, E. P. G., Nilsson, T., Karlsson, J., Graham, D.,... Lindberg, M. (2024, June). p. 2

Where the paper says it

, 2016, 2018), demonstrated the importance of strong sub-proton scale normal electric fields for ion reflection (Khotyaintsev et al. , 2024), and shown that shock non-stationarity is ubiquitous under a wide range of upstream conditions (Lotekar et al.

irfu/irfu-matlab: v1. p. 9
Where the paper says it

edu/mms/sdc/public). Data analysis was performed using the IRFU-Matlab analysis package (Khotyaintsev et al.

16.3 [software]. Zenodo.: doi: 10.5281/zenodo. p. 9
Where the paper says it

All the simulation data used in this work can be downloaded from https://doi. 5281/zenodo.

11550091

Khotyaintsev, Y. V., Graham, D. B., & Johlander, A. p. 2

Where the paper says it

manuscript submitted to Geophysical Research Letters space holes within the shock transition (Johlander et al. , 2016, 2018), demonstrated the importance of strong sub-proton scale normal electric fields for ion reflection (Khotyaintsev et al.

, (2024, November). p. 2
Where the paper says it

For this geometry, the signatures of shock rippling and cyclic reformation are more clearly separated, allowing us to show that the observed non-stationarity is dominated by cyclic shock reformation, locally modulated by the two-dimensional structure of the shock surface, rather than by large-scale surface rippling alone. 2 Observations We analyze a nearly-perpendicular bow shock, θBn ∼ 89◦ , observed by MMS on November 14, 2017, previously reported by Khotyaintsev et al.

Ion Reflection by a Rippled Perpendicular Shock. p. 9
Where the paper says it

As these bunches drift along the shock front, they carry the local reflection cycle with them, allowing the Hall electric field, magnetic overshoot, reflected-ion foot, and reflection efficiency to evolve coherently. 5 Conclusions We investigated the non-stationarity of a nearly perpendicular (θBn ≈ 89◦ ), supercritical (MA ≈ 6) bow shock observed by MMS using high-resolution two-dimensional hybrid simulations.

Phys. Rev. Lett.: 133 (21), 215201 doi: 10. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Data analysis was performed using the IRFU-Matlab analysis package (Khotyaintsev et al. All the simulation data used in this work can be downloaded from https://doi.

1103/PhysRevLett.133.215201

Khotyaintsev, Y. V., Vaivads, A., Retin´o, A., Andr´e, M., Owen, C. J., & Nilsson, H. (2006, November). p. 2

Where the paper says it

For this geometry, the signatures of shock rippling and cyclic reformation are more clearly separated, allowing us to show that the observed non-stationarity is dominated by cyclic shock reformation, locally modulated by the two-dimensional structure of the shock surface, rather than by large-scale surface rippling alone. 2 Observations We analyze a nearly-perpendicular bow shock, θBn ∼ 89◦ , observed by MMS on November 14, 2017, previously reported by Khotyaintsev et al.

Formation of inner structure of a reconnection separatrix region. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The downstream is until 19:57:03 UT, where we observe large-amplitude periodic oscillations in |B| and density; The ion VDFs (panels e, f) show a thermalized proton core and a gyrating proton component having large Vn and Vt2. The complex shock transition region is observed during the interval 19:57:03–19:57:20 UT, containing large variations in B (e.

Phys. Rev. Lett.: 97, 205003-+. Retrieved from http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-bib query? p. 9
Where the paper says it

Availability Statement MMS data are available at the MMS Science Data Center (https://lasp. edu/mms/sdc/public).

bibcode=2607

Lembege, B., & Savoini, P. p. 1

Where the paper says it

1 Introduction Collisionless quasi-perpendicular supercritical shocks are intrinsically non-stationary, but the nature of this non-stationarity remains a long-standing problem. Early one-dimensional particle simulations showed that periodic reflection of incoming ions causes the shock transition to rebuild itself cyclically, a process known as shock reformation (Biskamp & Welter, 1972; Burgess, 1989; Lembege & Savoini, 1992).

(1992, November). p. 1
Where the paper says it

1 Introduction Collisionless quasi-perpendicular supercritical shocks are intrinsically non-stationary, but the nature of this non-stationarity remains a long-standing problem. Early one-dimensional particle simulations showed that periodic reflection of incoming ions causes the shock transition to rebuild itself cyclically, a process known as shock reformation (Biskamp & Welter, 1972; Burgess, 1989; Lembege & Savoini, 1992).

Nonstationarity of a two-dimensional quasiperpendicular supercritical collisionless shock by self-reformation. p. 1
Where the paper says it

1 Introduction Collisionless quasi-perpendicular supercritical shocks are intrinsically non-stationary, but the nature of this non-stationarity remains a long-standing problem. Early one-dimensional particle simulations showed that periodic reflection of incoming ions causes the shock transition to rebuild itself cyclically, a process known as shock reformation (Biskamp & Welter, 1972; Burgess, 1989; Lembege & Savoini, 1992).

Physics of Fluids B, 4 (11), 3533-3548. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Khotyaintsev1,2 , Domenico Trotta3 , Daniel B. Graham1 1Swedish Institute of Space Physics, Uppsala, Sweden 2Space and Plasma Physics, Department of Physics and Astronomy, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden 3European Space Agency (ESA), European Space Astronomy Centre (ESAC), Camino Bajo del Castillo s/n, 28692 Villanueva de la Ca˜nada, Madrid, Spain Key Points: • MMS observations and high-resolution simulations investigate the non-stationarity of a perpendicular supercritical collisionless shock.

doi: 10.1063/1.860361

Lindqvist, P.-A., Olsson, G., Torbert, R. B., King, B., Granoff, M., Rau, D.,... Tucker, S. (2014, November). p. 2

Where the paper says it

For this geometry, the signatures of shock rippling and cyclic reformation are more clearly separated, allowing us to show that the observed non-stationarity is dominated by cyclic shock reformation, locally modulated by the two-dimensional structure of the shock surface, rather than by large-scale surface rippling alone. 2 Observations We analyze a nearly-perpendicular bow shock, θBn ∼ 89◦ , observed by MMS on November 14, 2017, previously reported by Khotyaintsev et al.

The Spin-Plane Double Probe Electric Field Instrument for MMS. p. 2
Where the paper says it

, 2014), ion data by FPI-DIS (Pollock et al. , 2016), and the electric field measured by the electric double probes (Lindqvist et al.

Space Sci. Rev.: doi: 10.1007/s11214-014-0116-9

Lotekar, A., Khotyaintsev, Y. V., Graham, D. B., Dimmock, A., Johlander, A. p. 2

Where the paper says it

manuscript submitted to Geophysical Research Letters space holes within the shock transition (Johlander et al. , 2016, 2018), demonstrated the importance of strong sub-proton scale normal electric fields for ion reflection (Khotyaintsev et al.

, & Lalti, A., (2025, September). Occurrence of Non-Stationarity at Earth’s QuasiPerpendicular Bow Shock. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Fully three-dimensional hybrid simulations further show that field-aligned AIC fluctuations can couple to the quasiperpendicular reformation process, producing obliquely propagating ripples that combine characteristics of both surface corrugation and cyclic ion reflection (Burgess et al. Recent observations by the Magnetospheric Multiscale Mission (MMS) have revealed that non-stationarity is common at Earth’s bow shock.

Geophys. Res. Lett.: 52 (17), e2025GL116121 doi: 10. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Data analysis was performed using the IRFU-Matlab analysis package (Khotyaintsev et al. All the simulation data used in this work can be downloaded from https://doi.

1029/2025GL116121

Lowe, R. E., & Burgess, D. p. 1

Where the paper says it

1 Introduction Collisionless quasi-perpendicular supercritical shocks are intrinsically non-stationary, but the nature of this non-stationarity remains a long-standing problem. Early one-dimensional particle simulations showed that periodic reflection of incoming ions causes the shock transition to rebuild itself cyclically, a process known as shock reformation (Biskamp & Welter, 1972; Burgess, 1989; Lembege & Savoini, 1992).

, (2003, March). p. 1
Where the paper says it

Two-dimensional geometry also permits the development of the Alfv´en ion cyclotron (AIC) instability, which corrugates the shock front with ion-scale ripples (Winske & Quest, 1988). These ripples locally rotate the shock normal and produce spatial variations in shock properties, including periodic changes in the normal magnetic field component, Bn (Lowe & Burgess, 2003).

The properties and causes of rippling in quasi-perpendicular collisionless shock fronts. p. 1
Where the paper says it

1 Introduction Collisionless quasi-perpendicular supercritical shocks are intrinsically non-stationary, but the nature of this non-stationarity remains a long-standing problem. Early one-dimensional particle simulations showed that periodic reflection of incoming ions causes the shock transition to rebuild itself cyclically, a process known as shock reformation (Biskamp & Welter, 1972; Burgess, 1989; Lembege & Savoini, 1992).

Annales Geophysicae, 21 (3), 671-679. doi: 10.5194/angeo-21-671-2003

Matthews, A. P., (1994). Current advance method and cyclic leapfrog for 2d multispecies hybrid plasma simulations. p. 4

Where the paper says it

, 2020, 2023; Vuorinen et al. , 2026), based on the current advance method and cyclic leapfrog (CAM-CL) algorithm (Matthews, 1994).

Journal of Computational Physics, 112 (1), 102-116 Retrieved from https://www. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Conflict of Interest The authors declare no conflicts of interest relevant to this study. Availability Statement MMS data are available at the MMS Science Data Center (https://lasp.

sciencedirect.com science/article/pii/S0021999184710849 doi: https://doi. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Data analysis was performed using the IRFU-Matlab analysis package (Khotyaintsev et al. All the simulation data used in this work can be downloaded from https://doi.

org/

Pollock, C., Moore, T., Jacques, A., Burch, J., Gliese, U., Saito, Y.,... Coffey, V. (2016, Mar). p. 2

Where the paper says it

manuscript submitted to Geophysical Research Letters space holes within the shock transition (Johlander et al. , 2016, 2018), demonstrated the importance of strong sub-proton scale normal electric fields for ion reflection (Khotyaintsev et al.

Fast Plasma Investigation for Magnetospheric Multiscale. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The physical process responsible for this non-stationarity — whether it is dominated by wave-like corrugation of the shock surface (rippling) or by a cyclic rebuilding of the shock transition (reformation) — remains debated. We combine Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) observations of a nearly perpendicular (θBn ≈ 89◦ ), supercritical (MA ≈ 6) bow shock with high-resolution two-dimensional hybrid simulations to address this question.

Space Sci. Rev.: 199 (1-4), 331-406 doi: 10. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Data analysis was performed using the IRFU-Matlab analysis package (Khotyaintsev et al. All the simulation data used in this work can be downloaded from https://doi.

1007/s11214-016-0245-4

Quest, K. B., (1985, April). p. 4

Where the paper says it

In the model, protons are treated kinetically as macroparticles, while electrons are described as a massless, charge-neutralizing adiabatic fluid with γe = 5/3. The shock is initiated with the injection method (Quest, 1985), where a super-Alfv´enic plasma flow is continuously injected from the left boundary, reflected at the right boundary, and forms a shock propagating in the −x direction, with periodic boundaries in y.

Simulations of high-Mach-number collisionless perpendicular shocks in astrophysical plasmas. p. 1
Where the paper says it

1 Introduction Collisionless quasi-perpendicular supercritical shocks are intrinsically non-stationary, but the nature of this non-stationarity remains a long-standing problem. Early one-dimensional particle simulations showed that periodic reflection of incoming ions causes the shock transition to rebuild itself cyclically, a process known as shock reformation (Biskamp & Welter, 1972; Burgess, 1989; Lembege & Savoini, 1992).

Phys. Rev. Lett.: 54 (16), 1872-1874 doi: 10. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Data analysis was performed using the IRFU-Matlab analysis package (Khotyaintsev et al. All the simulation data used in this work can be downloaded from https://doi.

1103/PhysRevLett.54.1872

Russell, C. T., Anderson, B. J., Baumjohann, W., Bromund, K. R., Dearborn, D., Fischer, D.,... Richter, I. (2014, August). p. 2

Where the paper says it

We use the magnetic field measured by FGM (Russell et al. , 2014), ion data by FPI-DIS (Pollock et al.

The Magnetospheric Multiscale Magnetometers. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The physical process responsible for this non-stationarity — whether it is dominated by wave-like corrugation of the shock surface (rippling) or by a cyclic rebuilding of the shock transition (reformation) — remains debated. We combine Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) observations of a nearly perpendicular (θBn ≈ 89◦ ), supercritical (MA ≈ 6) bow shock with high-resolution two-dimensional hybrid simulations to address this question.

Space Sci. Rev.: doi: 10.1007/s11214-014-0057-3

Trotta, D., Burgess, D. p. 1

Where the paper says it

1 Introduction Collisionless quasi-perpendicular supercritical shocks are intrinsically non-stationary, but the nature of this non-stationarity remains a long-standing problem. Early one-dimensional particle simulations showed that periodic reflection of incoming ions causes the shock transition to rebuild itself cyclically, a process known as shock reformation (Biskamp & Welter, 1972; Burgess, 1989; Lembege & Savoini, 1992).

p. 1
Where the paper says it

1 Introduction Collisionless quasi-perpendicular supercritical shocks are intrinsically non-stationary, but the nature of this non-stationarity remains a long-standing problem. Early one-dimensional particle simulations showed that periodic reflection of incoming ions causes the shock transition to rebuild itself cyclically, a process known as shock reformation (Biskamp & Welter, 1972; Burgess, 1989; Lembege & Savoini, 1992).

p. 1
Where the paper says it

1 Introduction Collisionless quasi-perpendicular supercritical shocks are intrinsically non-stationary, but the nature of this non-stationarity remains a long-standing problem. Early one-dimensional particle simulations showed that periodic reflection of incoming ions causes the shock transition to rebuild itself cyclically, a process known as shock reformation (Biskamp & Welter, 1972; Burgess, 1989; Lembege & Savoini, 1992).

, Prete, G., Perri, S., & Zimbardo, G. (2020, January). p. 4
Where the paper says it

3 Simulations We perform two-dimensional hybrid particle-in-cell simulations using the HYPSI code (Burgess & Scholer, 2007; Trotta et al. , 2020, 2023; Vuorinen et al.

Particle transport in hybrid PIC shock simulations: A comparison of diagnostics. p. 4
Where the paper says it

In the following section, we compare these observations with two-dimensional hybrid simulations to determine the physical origin of this non-stationarity. 3 Simulations We perform two-dimensional hybrid particle-in-cell simulations using the HYPSI code (Burgess & Scholer, 2007; Trotta et al.

MNRAS, 491 (1), 580-595 doi: 10. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Data analysis was performed using the IRFU-Matlab analysis package (Khotyaintsev et al. All the simulation data used in this work can be downloaded from https://doi.

1093/mnras/stz2760

Trotta, D., Pezzi, O., Burgess, D., Preisser, L., Blanco-Cano, X., Kajdic, P.,... Valentini, F. (2023, October). p. 4

Where the paper says it

3 Simulations We perform two-dimensional hybrid particle-in-cell simulations using the HYPSI code (Burgess & Scholer, 2007; Trotta et al. , 2020, 2023; Vuorinen et al.

Three-dimensional modelling of the shockturbulence interaction. p. 1
Where the paper says it

These ripples locally rotate the shock normal and produce spatial variations in shock properties, including periodic changes in the normal magnetic field component, Bn (Lowe & Burgess, 2003). Fully three-dimensional hybrid simulations further show that field-aligned AIC fluctuations can couple to the quasiperpendicular reformation process, producing obliquely propagating ripples that combine characteristics of both surface corrugation and cyclic ion reflection (Burgess et al.

MNRAS, 525 (2), 1856-1866 doi: 10. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Data analysis was performed using the IRFU-Matlab analysis package (Khotyaintsev et al. All the simulation data used in this work can be downloaded from https://doi.

1093/mnras/stad2384

Vuorinen, L., Burgess, D., Koller, F., & Trotta, D. p. 4

Where the paper says it

In the following section, we compare these observations with two-dimensional hybrid simulations to determine the physical origin of this non-stationarity. 3 Simulations We perform two-dimensional hybrid particle-in-cell simulations using the HYPSI code (Burgess & Scholer, 2007; Trotta et al.

(2026, June). p. 0
Where the paper says it

09389v1 [physics. space-ph] 10 Jul 2026

Plasma Stability in Turbulent Magnetic Flux Ropes Downstream of a Collisionless Shock. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Khotyaintsev1,2 , Domenico Trotta3 , Daniel B. Graham1 1Swedish Institute of Space Physics, Uppsala, Sweden 2Space and Plasma Physics, Department of Physics and Astronomy, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden 3European Space Agency (ESA), European Space Astronomy Centre (ESAC), Camino Bajo del Castillo s/n, 28692 Villanueva de la Ca˜nada, Madrid, Spain Key Points: • MMS observations and high-resolution simulations investigate the non-stationarity of a perpendicular supercritical collisionless shock.

Geophys. Res. Lett.: 53 (11), e2026GL122909 doi: 10. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Data analysis was performed using the IRFU-Matlab analysis package (Khotyaintsev et al. All the simulation data used in this work can be downloaded from https://doi.

1029/2026GL122909

Winske, D., & Quest, K. p. 1

Where the paper says it

In two dimensions, shock reformation persists, though the dynamics become more complex as reflected ions gyrate upstream and return to the shock at locations displaced from their original reflection points. Two-dimensional geometry also permits the development of the Alfv´en ion cyclotron (AIC) instability, which corrugates the shock front with ion-scale ripples (Winske & Quest, 1988).

B., (1988). Magnetic field and density fluctuations at perpendicular supercritical collisionless shocks. p. 1
Where the paper says it

This self-repeating cycle, occurring at slightly different times across the shock’s surface, explains most of the disturbed, ever-changing structure seen by the spacecraft. 1 Introduction Collisionless quasi-perpendicular supercritical shocks are intrinsically non-stationary, but the nature of this non-stationarity remains a long-standing problem.

Journal of Geophysical Research: Space Physics, 93 (A9), 9681-9693 doi: https://doi. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Data analysis was performed using the IRFU-Matlab analysis package (Khotyaintsev et al. All the simulation data used in this work can be downloaded from https://doi.

org/ 10.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI system can model non-stationary shock evolution by implementing a self-regulating feedback cycle where strong Hall-field ion reflection builds a reflected-ion foot, which weakens the Hall field and suppresses further reflection until the foot decays and the cycle restarts.

  2. Improved AI system can distinguish between shock rippling and cyclic reformation by analyzing phase space signatures; specifically, it can identify repeated ion phase-space holes as a hallmark of non-stationarity.

  3. Improved AI system can predict local shock structure variations by correlating magnetic field magnitude, density, and electric field spikes with the location of the reflected-ion population in 2D hybrid simulations.

  4. Improved AI system can generate virtual spacecraft trajectories that directly map observational signatures to simulation outputs by constructing a virtual spacecraft (VSC) that slowly moves through the simulation in the normal incidence frame using the measured shock speed.

Abstract

Super-critical collisionless shocks are not static but evolve continuously as they reflect incoming ions upstream. The process responsible for this non-stationarity -- whether wave-like corrugation of the shock surface (rippling) or cyclic rebuilding of the shock transition (reformation) -- remains debated. We combine Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) observations of a nearly perpendicular (θ Bn about89), supercritical (M A about6) bow shock with a high-resolution two-dimensional hybrid simulation. MMS reveals repeated ion phase-space holes and intense, localized Hall electric fields. A virtual-spacecraft analysis of the simulation reproduces these signatures and shows that they arise from a self-regulating feedback cycle: strong Hall-field ion reflection builds a reflected-ion foot, which weakens the Hall field and suppresses further reflection until the foot decays and the cycle restarts. This reformation cycle, spatially organized by the two-dimensional shock structure, can account for several principal signatures of the observed non-stationarity.

Related papers