Left-right symmetry breaking in E 6 L times E 6 R occurs only in spacetime -- with possible implications for strong CP

arXiv:2607.04132 · hep-ph, hep-th · Submitted 2026-07-05 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Left-right symmetry breaking in E 6 L times E 6 R occurs only in spacetime -- with possible implications for strong CP".

Paper summary: Kai: So, to wrap up, the paper "Left-right symmetry breaking in E six L times E six R occurs only in spacetime -- with possible implications for strong CP" is really about how this octonionic framework unifies the Standard Model and gravity by trinifying those exceptional factors <ref:2607.04132#pg1,occurs only in spacetime -- with possible implications for strong CP>.

Mira: The main point they make is that you don't need that extra second color group because the left-right symmetry lives in spacetime, and it means the right sector SU two R is just a gravitational frame group <ref:2607.04132#pg1>.

Lev: They also show how this structure connects to strong cp by having parity protect theta qcd and a reality condition that makes the mass determinant argument vanish at tree level <ref:2607.04132#pg3>.

Kai: It’s about showing that these things aren't imposed solutions but are actually consequences of using this specific octonionic structure for fermion masses <ref:2607.04132#pg3>.

Mira: The implication is that the way we see strong cp and the structure of particle charges could be linked through this single mathematical construction <ref:2607.04132#pg5>.

Conclusion: Kai: So, this paper is about how they tried to fit the Standard Model and gravity together using this octonionic structure, specifically looking at that left-right symmetry breaking happening only in spacetime.

Mira: Right, it’s about those E six L times E six R factors and how they claim the symmetry isn't broken by internal forces but by spacetime itself.

Lev: I gotta ask, what are the authors actually proposing is that this structure fixes some deep problems in particle physics without needing extra fields or forces?

Kai: Exactly. They’re suggesting that if you use this specific mathematical setup for fermion masses, it naturally handles things like strong cp and the reality of mass matrices at tree level.

Mira: And they link that to parity operations, implying that the vanishing of theta zero is protected by how spacetime acts on Dirac fields, which is a neat idea because it ties geometry into those internal parameters.

Lev: But this relies heavily on the assumption that this entire octonionic framework is the correct fundamental reality, which isn't tested in any way yet.

Kai: It’s a strong claim because it says that parity protecting theta zero and the mass matrix reality aren't tacked on ingredients, but are built into the structure of fermion masses themselves.

Mira: It changes things for us because it suggests we might not need to invent new mechanisms just to solve strong cp; maybe the structure of nature is already there if we look at it through this lens.

Lev: If they’re right, that would mean running these calculations on real hardware wouldn't involve an insane number of error correction steps just to manage the CP problem.

Kai: It opens up a new way to think about how fundamental symmetries might connect gravity and the Standard Model in a single mathematical construction.

Tejinder P. Singh

Tata Institute of Fundamental Research

hep-ph, hep-th

Submitted: 2026-07-05

Updated: 2026-11-17

Importance score: 72/100

The gist: The octonionic EL 6 times ER 6 program proposes a unification of the Standard Model with gravitation by trinifying each exceptional factor, E 6 to SU(3) times SU(3) times SU(3).

Key concepts

Octonionic $ ext{EL}^6 imes ext{ER}^6$ Program
This is a theoretical framework attempting to unify the Standard Model and gravity by using exceptional structures like E6 and ER6. It suggests that trinifying these factors leads to a specific structure for color groups and fermion representations, aiming to resolve fundamental physics problems.
Left-Right Symmetry Breaking
The paper argues that left-right symmetry breaking is not due to internal forces but is instead a property of spacetime itself. This identification means the right sector $ ext{SU}(2)_R$ is identified as the gravitational frame group, which dictates spacetime parity rather than being a separate weak force.
Strong CP and Reality Structure
The framework achieves vanishing strong CP ($ heta_{ ext{QCD}} = 0$) because the gravi-weak identification introduces spacetime parity. Furthermore, the reality of the Jordan spectrum ensures that $ ext{arg}( ext{det} M) = 0$ at tree level, leading to a strong CP structure where these two conditions coexist.
Single Vector-like Color
The structure allows for one single vector-like color group instead of two separate ones. This is possible because the left sector's charge ($Q$) comes from $ ext{Cl}(6)$ and the right sector's mass term ($\sqrt{m}$) comes from the Jordan structure, allowing them to be mutually independent without conflict.

Terminology

Summary

The octonionic EL 6 times ER 6 program proposes a unification of the Standard Model with gravitation by trinifying each exceptional factor, E 6 to SU(3) times SU(3) times SU(3). p. 0 This structure introduces two color groups: the visible SU(3) c from the left factor and a second SU(3) c' from the right. The argument posits that no such second color is necessary because left-right symmetry relates to spacetime rather than being in the internal sector. p. 0 The right-sector SU(2) R is identified as the gravitational frame group, not a second weak force. p. 0 This leads to a single vector-like color where SU(3) c' = SU(3) c, and the charged lepton is a color singlet.

The right sector contributes a single color-blind datum: the square-root of mass sqrt m, which acts as an exceptional-Jordan input (the colour-counting operator NR fixes only the colour representation, never the value of sqrt m). p. 0 The two-step right-sector breaking SU(3) R to SU(2) R times U(1) Y dem to U(1) dem leaves an unbroken dark-electromagnetic gauge factor. p. 0 An anomaly no-go proof demonstrates that on visible fermions, every anomaly-free abelian charge lies in the span of electric charge and B-L, which the sqrt m pattern does not—the gauged U(1) dem carries the mirror of electric charge, and its charged matter constitutes the dark sector. p. 0

The consequence for strong CP is derived from a single vector-like color together with spontaneous parity. p. 0 The vanishing of theta QCD rests on the gravi-weak identification, where SU(2) R is gravitational, leading to a spacetime parity operation that acts as ordinary spacetime parity on Dirac fields. p. 0 This implies theta QCD = 0 at tree level. p. 0 Furthermore, the reality of the Jordan spectrum ensures M = 0 at tree level because flavour rotors have real determinants and positive quark masses are real and positive from the exceptional-Jordan spectrum. p. 0 The two ingredients together yield a strong-CP structure where theta bar = theta QCD + M = 0 (tree level), coexisting with a non-zero CKM phase (delta CKM not equal to 0). p. 0 The novelty is the connection: in this framework, parity protects theta QCD and the reality structure that makes M vanish are both consequences of the single octonionic structure introduced for fermion masses, rather than ingredients imposed to solve strong CP. p. 1 This result holds at tree level, with radiative stability being open. p. 5

The force inventory shows three gauged groups: strong SU(3) c, electroweak SU(3) L, and gravidem SU(3) R, with the two flavour factors being global. p. 7 The anomaly no-go of Appendix A fixes the dark charge to the mirror-canonical pattern on the dark sector. p. 5 The framework predicts no visible fifth force, as kinetic mixing between the visible and dark electromagnetic sectors yields millicharged dark states rather than a visible fifth force. p. 0

The rigidity program posits that the actual world is a unique mathematical object, ending at O (Hurwitz), J 3(O) (Jordan/von Neumann), and E 8 (Cartan–Killing). This structure implies that gravity and the Standard Model and nothing else is a slogan because dynamics are imported from elsewhere. The analysis shows that the right sector fermion representations are fixed: quarks are triplets, leptons singlets, and the right-handed electron is a singlet. p. 6 No gauged U(1) on visible fermions can carry physical mass values due to anomaly constraints. p. 2 The dark-electromagnetic U(1) is color-blind and not color-welded, satisfying structural requirements. p. 0 The left–right asymmetry involves mutual independence: Q from the left Cl(6) and sqrt m from the right Jordan structure. p. 1 This permits a single vectorlike color because charge does not require both electroweak factors in standard E 6 trinification, allowing the two color groups to be identified without disturbance. p. 2 The right sector requires a color-blind, unwelded grading for NR to fix color reps, while the left requires Q=N/3 to be welded. p. 4 Each sector fixes its own charge internally— Q from the left Cl(6) (no right-sector generator), sqrt m from the right Jordan structure (no left-sector generator). p. 0 The dark photon's charge on each visible species equals its sqrt m, surviving as a spectral correspondence where visible fermions are dem-neutral with kinetic mixing as the one portal.

The net status is that sqrt m is not the welded NR/3 carrier, and the flip cannot recolour the electron. The right sector must not be welded, or the electron re-colours. p. 1 Thus, on the right, sqrt m is a color-blind, unwelded grading (U(1) dem-type), and NR is retained only to fix color reps. p. 4 Each sector fixes its own charge internally— Q from the left Cl(6), sqrt m from the right Jordan structure. p. 0 The two-sided E 6 times ER 6 construction allows this mutual independence to permit a single vectorlike color, as charge does not require both electroweak factors in standard single- E 6 trinification. p. 8

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can perform structural consistency checks on theoretical models by systematically verifying that internal symmetries are preserved across different sectors, such as confirming that the two colour groups are not independent but frame-conjugate based on the frame exchange e7 ↔ e8.

  2. Improved AI can derive physical constraints from algebraic structures by calculating that the reality of the spectrum is intrinsic to the slice on which the entire mass construction lives, ensuring that mass eigenvalues are real and positive, which is a property of the J3(OC) construction, not an additional assumption.

  3. Improved AI can analyze gauge theory dynamics by identifying how symmetry breaking affects force carriers, specifically determining that the gravi-weak identification assigns the visible weak group to the gravitational connection and that colour is vector-like because the breaking does not act on colour.

  4. Improved AI can perform rigorous anomaly checks by applying the anomaly no-go of Appendix A, which proves that on the visible content every anomaly-free U(1) lies in span[Y, B−L], leading to the conclusion that no gauged U(1) on visible fermions carries √m.

  5. Improved AI can assess theoretical robustness by comparing different solutions to the strong CP problem, concluding that the present framework is not in that class [minimal gauged-SU(2)R parity model] and is not directly bound by that result because it uses a gravitational frame group rather than a gauged weak factor.

  6. Improved AI can systematically map out the dependencies of a physical result by creating a dependency ledger, explicitly tagging claims as [D] derived here or in cited work, [P] program-level working hypothesis, and [O] open.

Sources

Related papers