Midlatitude cloud radiative effects reinforce storm tracks on seasonal timescales
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Midlatitude cloud radiative effects reinforce storm tracks on seasonal timescales".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Midlatitude storm tracks are maintained by cloud radiative effects reinforcing temperature gradients that sustain them on seasonal timescales Observational Evidence for Cloud-Radiative Reinforcement Observational evidence suggests that early summer storm activity in the Southern Hemisphere is supported by cloud-radiative reinforcement of meridional temperature gradients Because summer insolation is large and absorbed primarily at the surface, researchers focused on the meridional gradient in absorbed surface shortwave radiation Under clear-sky conditions, this gradient is weak across the Southern Hemisphere midlatitudes This picture changes dramatically when shortwave cloud radiative effects are included because extensive cloud fields on the poleward flank of the storm track strongly reduce surface shortwave absorption at high latitudes These clouds generate meridional radiative gradients roughly five times larger than those under clear-sky conditions and comparable in magnitude to wintertime insolation gradients The observations point to a self-reinforcement mechanism where storms produce an extensive cloud field, the clouds preferentially cool high latitudes, and the resulting sea surface temperature and temperature gradients reinforce subsequent storm activity Aquaplanet Simulations Isolating Cloud-Radiative Effects Idealized aquaplanet simulations were used to isolate the dynamical importance of cloud-radiative effects by reducing shortwave and longwave cloud radiative effects by 25% over the midlatitudes Reducing shortwave cloud radiative effects substantially weakens the storm track, with a pronounced weakening during late summer and autumn The response to longwave cloud radiative effects is qualitatively opposite but substantially weaker, strengthening storm activity throughout the year When both shortwave and longwave cloud radiative effects are reduced simultaneously, the storms’ response is approximately equal to the sum of the individual responses, indicating that the system behaves nearly linearly Furthermore, simulations showed that when sea surface temperatures are fixed to climatology, storm-track response is negligible, indicating that cloud-radiative effects influence storm activity primarily through their impact on surface temperatures and resulting meridional temperature gradients Minimal Theory for Cloud-Radiative Feedback A minimal dynamical framework was developed to couple storm activity, meridional sea-surface temperature gradients, and cloud radiative effects The model approximates the evolution of the meridional SST difference as a balance between differential solar heating and atmospheric storms’ heat transport Storm-associated clouds modify this seasonal structure by preferentially reflecting sunlight on the poleward side of the storm track, with cloud albedo increasing as a sigmoid function of storm strength The model contains two key parameters that characterize the cloud feedback: the maximum attainable cloud albedo attainable over the storm track (alpha c) and the sensitivity of cloud albedo to storm activity (c) Increasing alpha c strengthens storm activity throughout the year while substantially reducing its seasonal cycle The sensitivity of cloud albedo to storm activity highlights a second key aspect of the feedback, where non-linear responses lead to a rapid transition between weak- and strong-summer-storm regimes Discussion and Broader Implications The results suggest that cloud radiative effects constitute an additional maintenance mechanism alongside latent heat release, operating through coupled interactions among storms, clouds, and the ocean The climatic influence of cloud-radiative effects is difficult to infer from the evolution of individual storms because the perturbation is mediated through SST gradients rather than direct atmospheric heating Understanding cloud-circulation coupling requires integrating CREs across the lifetimes of many storms and relating them to the evolving SST field, rather than attempting to infer the feedback from the dynamics of individual cyclones The framework suggests that understanding cloud-circulation coupling may require moving beyond traditional diagnostics based on mean properties of cloud fields, focusing instead on how storm activity organizes its meridional and seasonal structure Ocean dynamics are identified as the next major challenge, as ocean circulation and mixed-layer depth directly affect the evolution of SST gradients and thus the strength of the cloud-radiative forcing Observational estimates for storm activity were obtained from the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) ERA5 reanalysis Radiative fluxes and cloud radiative effects were obtained from the Clouds and the Earth’s Radiant Energy System (CERES) SYN1deg product Aquaplanet simulations used the Community Earth System Model version 2 (CESM2) with a slab ocean configuration modified to include a seasonal cycle of insolation The control simulation used CRE scaling factors set to s = 1, while sensitivity experiments reduced SW CRE by 25%, LW CRE by 25%, or both To separate the direct atmospheric response from changes mediated by surface temperature, simulations repeated the CRE-modification experiments with SST fixed to the climatology of the control simulation Atmospheric baroclinicity was quantified using the Eady Growth Rate, a measure of atmospheric capacity to support baroclinic growth References The references listed support the claims made in the paper regarding physical concepts and prior research Peixoto, J.
Kai: P.
Mira: & Oort, A.
Kai: H., Physics of Climate (American Institute of Physics, 1992) Stephens, G.
Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper, "Midlatitude cloud radiative effects reinforce storm tracks on seasonal timescales." It sounds like they're arguing that the way we usually think about how storms stay going—that it’s just about the temperature difference between high and low latitudes being driven by solar heating—that’s not the whole story.
Mira: Exactly. She says that during summer, when the sun is hitting everything more evenly, those usual temperature gradients weaken because of that insolation pattern. But this paper suggests that clouds actually play a role in keeping those gradients strong enough for storms to survive on a seasonal basis.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if we only look at solar forcing, we see a clear drop in storm activity during summer because the gradient is weak; but the authors are bringing in these cloud radiative effects as an additional heating or cooling mechanism that sustains that difference.
Kai: It's interesting how they focus on the Southern Hemisphere specifically when looking at this seasonal maintenance. They point out that even though summer insolation is big, it’s absorbed mostly near the surface, and those clouds up poleward really mess with that absorption pattern in a way we hadn't accounted for before.
Mira: That’s the core idea: these clouds create a meridional radiative gradient roughly five times larger than what you see without them, and it’s comparable to the gradients we get in wintertime. So they’re proposing a self-reinforcing loop where storms make clouds, those clouds cool the high latitudes more strongly, which then feeds back to keep the storm activity going.
Lev: If you take that feedback mechanism seriously for real hardware, we need to know how sensitive that response is to changes in the cloud structure itself because those feedbacks can be very non-linear.
Kai: Right, and it gets into how they test this idea. They didn't just look at observations; they did idealized aquaplanet simulations where they reduced shortwave and longwave cloud radiative effects by twenty-five percent to see what happens to the storm track response.
Mira: And the results there are telling because reducing the shortwave effect substantially weakens the storm track, especially in late summer and autumn, which supports their claim that those clouds are crucial for maintaining activity during those times of low insolation.
Title and authors: Lev: What they found is that when you reduce both shortwave and longwave cloud radiative effects simultaneously, the storms respond almost exactly like the sum of what each effect would have caused individually, which suggests a fairly linear response in that part of the system.
Kai: But then they also tested how much sea surface temperature differences matter. They found that when they kept sea surface temperatures fixed to their normal climatology, the storm track response became negligible, which really highlights that these cloud effects influence storm activity mainly by modifying those surface temperatures and the resulting meridional temperature gradients.
Mira: So, to put it plainly, the paper is arguing that cloud radiative effects aren't just a minor adjustment; they are an essential maintenance mechanism working alongside latent heat release to keep midlatitude storm tracks alive on seasonal timescales.
Lev: For us building error-correction for real hardware, this means we have to consider how uncertainties in the atmospheric forcing from these cloud feedbacks would propagate into our system over time.
Kai: And moving beyond just looking at individual storms, they developed a minimal dynamical framework that couples storm activity, meridional sea surface temperature gradients, and these cloud radiative effects together. This is where they try to get a handle on the whole feedback structure rather than just observing one cyclone at a time.
Mira: That framework introduces two parameters that really matter for understanding the feedback strength: the maximum attainable cloud albedo over the storm track, which we call alpha c, and how sensitive that cloud albedo is to storm activity itself, which they call c.
Lev: So if you want to know how strong this feedback loop is, you look at those two numbers because they tell you whether increasing alpha c strengthens activity throughout the year or just changes the seasonal cycle.
Kai: They show that increasing that maximum cloud albedo makes storm activity stronger all year long while actually reducing its seasonal cycle, which is a pretty big piece of information for understanding how these feedbacks operate.
Mira: And that sensitivity parameter, c, shows another key aspect where non-linear responses can cause a rapid switch between weak and strong summer storm regimes. It suggests there’s a threshold effect in how storms interact with the clouds.
Lev: That threshold behavior is what makes things hard to model accurately because you need to capture that transition from one regime to another, which is often where the biggest errors creep into numerical simulations.
Title and authors: Kai: So, the big picture here for anyone listening is that understanding cloud-circulation coupling requires looking at how storm activity organizes its meridional and seasonal structure, not just looking at the mean properties of clouds in isolation.
Mira: It points toward ocean dynamics as a major next step because how the ocean circulation and mixed layer depth directly affect those sea surface temperature gradients which then feed back into the cloud radiative forcing. That’s where things get complex.
Lev: We need better models for that ocean component because if we don't get the SST gradient right, even with perfect cloud physics, the whole storm maintenance mechanism fails.
Kai: So to wrap up on this paper, "Midlatitude cloud radiative effects reinforce storm tracks on seasonal timescales," it shows that these clouds are a vital component in sustaining those winter and summer storms by modifying surface heating patterns through temperature gradients.
Mira: The main implication is that we can no longer treat the maintenance of midlatitude storm activity as being driven only by differential solar heating, because the cloud radiative effects provide an additional, crucial stabilizing influence on the seasonal structure.
Lev: From my side, it means any real-world system we build that tries to predict this cycle needs to account for these coupled interactions between storms and their associated cloud fields affecting surface conditions.
Kai: And before we move on, Lev, what’s one final thought you have about how this paper fits into the bigger picture of what you're trying to measure or simulate?
Lev: I think the real challenge is moving from these idealized aquaplanet results to seeing how this plays out when we introduce the actual complexity of a full atmosphere and ocean system, because that’s where we really see if this feedback is strong enough to matter in practice.
Mira: It really emphasizes that the correction depends on where you are, meaning these cloud feedbacks aren't uniform across the globe or even across different seasons in a simple way.
Kai: It’s fascinating stuff because it links atmospheric dynamics directly to radiative physics in a way that makes the storm tracks more robust than we initially thought.
Lev: We’ll keep digging into those coupling mechanisms, but for now, this paper gives us the necessary framework to start asking the right questions about how these interactions organize the system.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, to recap, this paper is arguing that we can’t just look at solar heating patterns when trying to understand why midlatitude storm tracks stick around for so long across seasons; the clouds are actively helping maintain those temperature differences.
Mira: Right. They’re saying that because of how those clouds react to sunlight, they create bigger temperature differences—a meridional gradient—that keep the storms alive on a seasonal scale when solar heating itself is changing during the summer.
Lev: From where I'm sitting, if this feedback mechanism is real, it means our current models might be underestimating how much these clouds influence the overall atmospheric forcing that dictates storm persistence.
Kai: Exactly. They used idealized simulations to show that when they included these shortwave and longwave cloud effects, reducing them by twenty-five percent significantly weakened the storm track response during late summer and autumn, which is a key observational clue.
Mira: And what’s really interesting is how they structured their minimal theory to capture this feedback; they focused on two specific parameters: the maximum attainable cloud albedo over the storm track and how sensitive that cloud albedo is to storm activity itself.
Lev: That framework gives us a way to quantify the strength of this coupling; it shows that increasing the maximum attainable cloud albedo, which we call alpha c, actually strengthens storm activity all year long but it also reduces its seasonal cycle.
Kai: So that means if you increase that cloud property, you get stronger storms consistently even when the sun is weaker in summer, which totally flips how we see the maintenance of these tracks.
Mira: And the sensitivity parameter, c, which describes how much those clouds change when storms are more active, points to a non-linear response where things can rapidly switch between weak and strong summer storm regimes based on that interaction.
Lev: That’s where the overhead lands for me; capturing that rapid transition in a real system requires very precise error correction because you need to know exactly how much the cloud state feeds back into the storm intensity at any given time.
Kai: Ultimately, this paper suggests that we have to stop looking at individual storms and start thinking about how storm activity organizes its entire meridional and seasonal structure by linking it directly to those cloud radiative effects.
Mira: And it points toward ocean dynamics as the next major hurdle because those surface sea surface temperature gradients are what ultimately drive those crucial cloud radiative forcings that sustain the whole system.
Lev: If we don't get the ocean circulation right, even with perfect atmospheric physics, we won't be able to model how these SST gradients evolve over time.
Kai: It’s interesting stuff because it links atmospheric dynamics directly to radiative physics in a way that makes the storm tracks more robust than we initially thought.
Mira: So, the big picture here is that the maintenance of midlatitude storm activity isn't just about solar heating; the clouds provide an additional, crucial stabilizing influence on those seasonal patterns.
Lev: For any real-world system we build to predict this cycle, it means we have to account for these coupled interactions between storms and their cloud fields affecting surface conditions.
Kai: We’ll keep digging into those coupling mechanisms, but for now, this paper gives us the necessary framework to start asking the right questions about how these interactions organize the system.
The paper's improvements: Tom: So, we just talked about how these cloud radiative effects are helping keep those midlatitude storm tracks going seasonally by modifying the surface temperature gradients and forcing them to stay strong during summer.
Kai: Right, and now we’re looking at what this paper suggests as improvements for the research itself; they aren't just settling for observations anymore.
Mira: They propose using these findings to build a minimal theoretical framework that quantifies the strength of this cloud feedback by identifying two specific properties: the maximum attainable cloud albedo over the storm track and how sensitive that cloud albedo is to storm activity itself.
Lev: That’s helpful because it moves us away from just saying "clouds matter" to actually having measurable parameters like alpha c and c that we can test on our hardware simulations.
Kai: And this framework lets them distinguish between different regimes of storm track response, essentially using those parameters as a switch between weak and strong summer storm regimes based on how those cloud properties are organized.
Mira: That’s a big step because it gives us a way to diagnose the actual organization of the cloud-circulation coupling rather than just looking at average cloud properties.
Lev: From my side, that sensitivity parameter c is what I need to focus on for error correction; if the response is non-linear like they suggest, you need robust algorithms to handle those rapid transitions between states.
Kai: It also suggests a way to interpret high-resolution climate simulations better; they show that when you use this framework, you can diagnose how resolution changes clouds while substantially underestimating their influence on storm tracks when sea surface temperatures are fixed.
Mira: So the implication is that capturing this interaction requires simulations where the sea surface temperatures are not just fixed, but evolve interactively with the clouds over timescales long enough for the ocean to adjust.
Lev: That makes sense; we need those coupled interactions integrated into our models because if we don't get that feedback loop right, even high resolution won't fix the fundamental modeling error.
Kai: So what this means for us is that future work has to move beyond just measuring individual storm properties and start focusing on how storm activity organizes its entire meridional and seasonal structure through these coupled cloud-radiative effects.
Mira: It really emphasizes that we need to look at ocean dynamics as the next major challenge because how the ocean circulation and mixed layer depth directly affect those sea surface temperature gradients which then feed back into the cloud radiative forcing.
Lev: If we don't get the SST gradient right, even with perfect atmospheric physics, we won't be able to model how these gradients evolve over time.
Kai: It’s fascinating stuff because it links atmospheric dynamics directly to radiative physics in a way that makes the storm tracks more robust than we initially thought.
Conclusion: Kai: So we're wrapping up this look at "Midlatitude cloud radiative effects reinforce storm tracks on seasonal timescales" by summarizing how those clouds actively help maintain those midlatitude storm tracks by modifying the surface temperature gradients and forcing them to stay strong during summer.
Mira: Right, and the big implication is that we can no longer treat the maintenance of midlatitude storm activity as being driven only by solar heating because these cloud radiative effects provide an additional, crucial stabilizing influence on the seasonal structure.
Lev: From my side, this paper suggests that we need to start focusing on how storm activity organizes its entire meridional and seasonal structure through these coupled cloud-radiative effects rather than just looking at individual storms.
Kai: It’s fascinating stuff because it links atmospheric dynamics directly to radiative physics in a way that makes the storm tracks more robust than we initially thought.
Mira: We've seen how these clouds modify the meridional temperature gradients and how that feedback loop works through those two key parameters, alpha c and c, which give us a handle on the cloud feedback strength.
Lev: I just want to say that moving from these idealized simulations to real hardware means we have to be really careful because of those non-linear responses we saw in the sensitivity parameter c.
Kai: Exactly; when you're building something real, you need that fidelity to capture how those clouds switch between regimes based on storm strength.
Mira: This paper also pointed toward ocean dynamics as the next major challenge because those surface sea surface temperature gradients are what ultimately drive those crucial cloud radiative forcings that sustain the whole system.
Lev: If we don't get the ocean circulation right, even with perfect atmospheric physics, we won't be able to model how those gradients evolve over time.
Kai: So to wrap up on "Midlatitude cloud radiative effects reinforce storm tracks on seasonal timescales," it shows that these clouds are a vital component in sustaining those winter and summer storms by modifying surface heating patterns through temperature gradients.
Mira: The main implication is that we can no longer treat the maintenance of midlatitude storm activity as being driven only by differential solar heating because the cloud radiative effects provide an additional, crucial stabilizing influence on the seasonal structure.
Lev: I just want to say that for us in error correction, this means any system we build to predict this cycle needs to account for these coupled interactions between storms and their cloud fields affecting surface conditions.
Kai: We’ll keep digging into those coupling mechanisms, but for now, this paper gives us the necessary framework to start asking the right questions about how these interactions organize the system.
O. Hadas
Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences, Weizmann Institute of Science
physics.ao-ph
Submitted: 2026-07-02
Updated: 2026-11-09
Code: https://github.com/ESCOMP/CESM
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
Importance score: 82/100
The gist: Midlatitude storm tracks are maintained by cloud radiative effects reinforcing temperature gradients that sustain them on seasonal timescales Observational Evidence for Cloud-Radiative Reinforcement…
Key concepts
- Cloud Radiative Effects (CREs)
- These are the effects of clouds on the Earth's radiation budget. In this context, they refer to how clouds reflect sunlight and heat back into space. These reflections create temperature differences between different parts of the atmosphere, which can then influence where storms form and persist.
- Meridional Temperature Gradients
- This refers to the difference in temperature between north and south latitudes along a storm track. The paper shows that clouds generate these gradients much stronger than clear skies, especially at high latitudes during summer. These gradients are key drivers that maintain storm activity over long seasons.
- Cloud Albedo ($\alpha_c$)
- This is a measure of how reflective a cloud is. The model introduces this as a key feedback parameter: as storm strength increases, the cloud albedo changes in response. This relationship helps quantify how storms dynamically alter their own cloud properties, influencing the overall storm track maintenance.
- Cloud-Radiative Reinforcement
- This describes a self-reinforcing mechanism where storms drive clouds, and those clouds then modify surface conditions (like temperature gradients) in a way that makes the original storm activity stronger. This coupling between storms, clouds, and ocean features is the core maintenance mechanism discussed.
Terminology
Summary
Midlatitude storm tracks are maintained by cloud radiative effects reinforcing temperature gradients that sustain them on seasonal timescales
Observational Evidence for Cloud-Radiative Reinforcement
Observational evidence suggests that early summer storm activity in the Southern Hemisphere is supported by cloud-radiative reinforcement of meridional temperature gradients Because summer insolation is large and absorbed primarily at the surface, researchers focused on the meridional gradient in absorbed surface shortwave radiation Under clear-sky conditions, this gradient is weak across the Southern Hemisphere midlatitudes This picture changes dramatically when shortwave cloud radiative effects are included because extensive cloud fields on the poleward flank of the storm track strongly reduce surface shortwave absorption at high latitudes These clouds generate meridional radiative gradients roughly five times larger than those under clear-sky conditions and comparable in magnitude to wintertime insolation gradients The observations point to a self-reinforcement mechanism where storms produce an extensive cloud field, the clouds preferentially cool high latitudes, and the resulting sea surface temperature and temperature gradients reinforce subsequent storm activity
Aquaplanet Simulations Isolating Cloud-Radiative Effects
Idealized aquaplanet simulations were used to isolate the dynamical importance of cloud-radiative effects by reducing shortwave and longwave cloud radiative effects by 25% over the midlatitudes Reducing shortwave cloud radiative effects substantially weakens the storm track, with a pronounced weakening during late summer and autumn The response to longwave cloud radiative effects is qualitatively opposite but substantially weaker, strengthening storm activity throughout the year When both shortwave and longwave cloud radiative effects are reduced simultaneously, the storms’ response is approximately equal to the sum of the individual responses, indicating that the system behaves nearly linearly Furthermore, simulations showed that when sea surface temperatures are fixed to climatology, storm-track response is negligible, indicating that cloud-radiative effects influence storm activity primarily through their impact on surface temperatures and resulting meridional temperature gradients
Minimal Theory for Cloud-Radiative Feedback
A minimal dynamical framework was developed to couple storm activity, meridional sea-surface temperature gradients, and cloud radiative effects The model approximates the evolution of the meridional SST difference as a balance between differential solar heating and atmospheric storms’ heat transport Storm-associated clouds modify this seasonal structure by preferentially reflecting sunlight on the poleward side of the storm track, with cloud albedo increasing as a sigmoid function of storm strength The model contains two key parameters that characterize the cloud feedback: the maximum attainable cloud albedo attainable over the storm track (alpha c) and the sensitivity of cloud albedo to storm activity (c) Increasing alpha c strengthens storm activity throughout the year while substantially reducing its seasonal cycle The sensitivity of cloud albedo to storm activity highlights a second key aspect of the feedback, where non-linear responses lead to a rapid transition between weak- and strong-summer-storm regimes
Discussion and Broader Implications
The results suggest that cloud radiative effects constitute an additional maintenance mechanism alongside latent heat release, operating through coupled interactions among storms, clouds, and the ocean The climatic influence of cloud-radiative effects is difficult to infer from the evolution of individual storms because the perturbation is mediated through SST gradients rather than direct atmospheric heating Understanding cloud-circulation coupling requires integrating CREs across the lifetimes of many storms and relating them to the evolving SST field, rather than attempting to infer the feedback from the dynamics of individual cyclones The framework suggests that understanding cloud-circulation coupling may require moving beyond traditional diagnostics based on mean properties of cloud fields, focusing instead on how storm activity organizes its meridional and seasonal structure Ocean dynamics are identified as the next major challenge, as ocean circulation and mixed-layer depth directly affect the evolution of SST gradients and thus the strength of the cloud-radiative forcing
Methods for Data and Simulation
Observational estimates for storm activity were obtained from the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) ERA5 reanalysis Radiative fluxes and cloud radiative effects were obtained from the Clouds and the Earth’s Radiant Energy System (CERES) SYN1deg product Aquaplanet simulations used the Community Earth System Model version 2 (CESM2) with a slab ocean configuration modified to include a seasonal cycle of insolation The control simulation used CRE scaling factors set to s = 1, while sensitivity experiments reduced SW CRE by 25%, LW CRE by 25%, or both To separate the direct atmospheric response from changes mediated by surface temperature, simulations repeated the CRE-modification experiments with SST fixed to the climatology of the control simulation Atmospheric baroclinicity was quantified using the Eady Growth Rate, a measure of atmospheric capacity to support baroclinic growth
References
The references listed support the claims made in the paper regarding physical concepts and prior research Peixoto, J. P. & Oort, A. H., Physics of Climate (American Institute of Physics, 1992) Stephens, G. p. 9 Physics of Climate (American Institute of Physics, 1992). Stephens, G. Stephens, G. Cloud feedbacks in the climate system: A critical review. Climate 18, 237–273 (2005). Hartmann, D. Hartmann, D. Global physical climatology (Newnes, 2015). Global physical climatology (Newnes, 2015). , Wielicki, B. Toward optimal closure of the Earth’s top-of-atmosphere radiation
budget. Journal of Climate 22, 748–766 (2009). Tselioudis, G. & Grise, K. Midlatitude cloud systems. Clouds and Climate: Climate Science’s Greatest
Challenge, 279 (2020). Climate 18, 237–273 (2005). Hartmann, D. & Hartmann, D. Connections between clouds, radiation, and midlatitude dynamics: A
review. Connections between clouds, radiation, and midlatitude dynamics: A
review. Change Rep. 1, 94–102 (2015). Charney, J. Charney, J. The dynamics of long waves in a baroclinic westerly current. The dynamics of long waves in a baroclinic westerly current. 4, 136–162
(1947). Long Waves and Cyclone Waves. Tellus 1, 33 (Aug. Tellus 1, 33 (Aug. Baroclinic Adjustment. Baroclinic Adjustment. 35, 561–571 (Apr. 35, 561–571 (Apr. & Nakamura, H. & Nakamura, H. On the significance of the sensible heat supply from the ocean in the
maintenance of the mean baroclinicity along storm tracks. On the significance of the sensible heat supply from the ocean in the
maintenance of the mean baroclinicity along storm tracks. Climate 24, 3377–3401 (2011). Climate 24, 3377–3401 (2011). , Barpanda, P. , Barpanda, P. & Donohoe, A. & Donohoe, A. A moist static energy framework for zonal-mean storm-track
intensity. A moist static energy framework for zonal-mean storm-track
intensity. 75, 1979–1994 (2018). 75, 1979–1994 (2018). & Crane, M. & Crane, M. A satellite view of the synoptic-scale organization of cloud properties in
midlatitude and tropical circulation systems. A satellite view of the synoptic-scale organization of cloud properties in
midlatitude and tropical circulation systems. Weather Rev. Weather Rev. 123, 1984–2006 (1995). Predicting the frequency of low cloud mesoscale morphologies in
Southern Ocean extratropical cyclones using cloud controlling factors. Journal of Geophysical Research:
Atmospheres 130, e2024JD043248 (2025). Although they are typically viewed as a consequence of storm activity [15–17], their
large radiative impact [18, 19] raises the possibility that they also contribute to maintaining the circulation
that generates them. On synoptic timescales, midlatitude cloud radiative effects (CRE) can modify storm thermal structure
and baroclinic growth, although the sign and magnitude of these effects depend on the vertical distribution of
clouds and on compensating Shortwave (SW) and Longwave (LW) influences [20, 21]. Tselioudis, G. & Grise, K. On synoptic timescales, midlatitude cloud radiative effects (CRE) can modify storm thermal structure
and baroclinic growth, although the sign and magnitude of these effects depend on the vertical distribution of
clouds and on compensating Shortwave (SW) and Longwave (LW) influences [20, 21]. At the climatic scale,
CRE are also known to influence storm-track position and intensity in climate models [22–24]. 123, 1984–2006 (1995). Predicting the frequency of low cloud mesoscale morphologies in
Southern Ocean extratropical cyclones using cloud controlling factors. hadas@weizmann. il
Abstract
Midlatitude storm tracks play a central role in Earth’s climate by transporting heat from low to high
latitudes. Cloud radiative effects reinforce storm tracks
Or Hadas1,∗
1Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot 7610001, Israel
∗Corresponding author. hadas@weizmann. 02213v2 [physics. ao-ph] 19 Aug 2026 2, and the synoptic timescale (τs) to 10 days. summertime feedback: stronger storms generate more reflective clouds, strengthening SST gradients and
storm activity. 02213v2 [physics. ao-ph] 19 Aug 2026 We focus on
the evolution of the meridional SST difference in the midlatitudes (∆T = T30 − T60). Neglecting ocean heat
transport, consistent with the slab-ocean configuration used in the aquaplanet experiments, we approximate
the evolution of ∆T as a balance between differential solar heating and atmospheric storms’ heat transport
[26]:
Co
d∆T
dt = − Ca
Fe
∆y
| {z }
storms heat transport
+ [(1 − α30)I30 − (1 − α60)I60]
| {z }
radiative forcing
, (1)
where Co and Ca are the effective oceanic and atmospheric heat capacities per unit area, respectively, Fe is
the meridional heat transport by storms, and I30, I60, α30, and α60 denote the incoming solar radiation and
effective albedo at 30◦ and 60◦
latitude. We focus on
the evolution of the meridional SST difference in the midlatitudes (∆T = T30 − T60). Neglecting ocean heat
transport, consistent with the slab-ocean configuration used in the aquaplanet experiments, we approximate
the evolution of ∆T as a balance between differential solar heating and atmospheric storms’ heat transport
[26]:
Co
d∆T
dt = − Ca
Fe
∆y
| {z }
storms heat transport
+ [(1 − α30)I30 − (1 − α60)I60]
| {z }
radiative forcing
, (1)
where Co and Ca are the effective oceanic and atmospheric heat capacities per unit area, respectively, Fe is
the meridional heat transport by storms, and I30, I60, α30, and α60 denote the incoming solar radiation and
effective albedo at 30◦ and 60◦
latitude. hadas@weizmann. il
Abstract
Midlatitude storm tracks play a central role in Earth’s climate by transporting heat from low to high
latitudes. hadas@weizmann. il
Abstract
Midlatitude storm tracks play a central role in Earth’s climate by transporting heat from low to high
latitudes. Methods
ERA-5 Reanalysis and CERES
Observational estimates of storm activity are obtained from the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather
Forecasts (ECMWF) ERA5 reanalysis [35]. We analyze global sea-level pressure (SLP) fields at 3-hourly
resolution. Global physical climatology (Newnes, 2015). , Wielicki, B. Synoptic-scale storm activity is quantified using bandpass-filtered SLP anomalies with periods
between 2 and 10 days. Radiative fluxes and cloud radiative effects are obtained from the Clouds and the Earth’s Radiant Energy
System (CERES) SYN1deg product [36, 37]. Synoptic-scale storm activity is quantified using bandpass-filtered SLP anomalies with periods
between 2 and 10 days. Radiative fluxes and cloud radiative effects are obtained from the Clouds and the Earth’s Radiant Energy
System (CERES) SYN1deg product [36, 37]. We focus on
the evolution of the meridional SST difference in the midlatitudes (∆T = T30 − T60). Neglecting ocean heat
transport, consistent with the slab-ocean configuration used in the aquaplanet experiments, we approximate
the evolution of ∆T as a balance between differential solar heating and atmospheric storms’ heat transport
[26]:
Co
d∆T
dt = − Ca
Fe
∆y
| {z }
storms heat transport
+ [(1 − α30)I30 − (1 − α60)I60]
| {z }
radiative forcing
, (1)
where Co and Ca are the effective oceanic and atmospheric heat capacities per unit area, respectively, Fe is
the meridional heat transport by storms, and I30, I60, α30, and α60 denote the incoming solar radiation and
effective albedo at 30◦ and 60◦
latitude. Hartmann, D. Global physical climatology (Newnes, 2015). The dataset provides surface and top-of-atmosphere radiative
fluxes on a 1◦ ×1
◦ grid at hourly resolution, allowing diagnosis of the seasonal and spatial structure of cloud
radiative forcing. Aquaplanet simulations
To isolate the impact of CRE, we perform idealized aquaplanet simulations with the Community Earth
System Model version 2 (CESM2, [38]), using the Community Atmosphere Model version 5 (CAM5, [39]). Cloud radiative effects reinforce storm tracks
Or Hadas1,∗
1Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot 7610001, Israel
∗Corresponding author. hadas@weizmann. Midlatitude cloud systems. Clouds and Climate: Climate Science’s Greatest
Challenge, 279 (2020). The dataset provides surface and top-of-atmosphere radiative
fluxes on a 1◦ ×1
◦ grid at hourly resolution, allowing diagnosis of the seasonal and spatial structure of cloud
radiative forcing. Aquaplanet simulations
To isolate the impact of CRE, we perform idealized aquaplanet simulations with the Community Earth
System Model version 2 (CESM2, [38]), using the Community Atmosphere Model version 5 (CAM5, [39]). Radiative fluxes and cloud radiative effects are obtained from the Clouds and the Earth’s Radiant Energy
System (CERES) SYN1deg product [36, 37]. The dataset provides surface and top-of-atmosphere radiative
fluxes on a 1◦ ×1
◦ grid at hourly resolution, allowing diagnosis of the seasonal and spatial structure of cloud
radiative forcing. ERA5 sea level pressure data are
available through the Copernicus Climate Data Store [43]. CERES SYN1deg radiative fluxes are available
from the NASA Langley Atmospheric Science Data Center [44]. Another important implication of this work concerns the interpretation of high-resolution climate simulations. Increasing model resolution often produces substantial changes in cloud structure, cloud fraction,
and cloud-radiative effects [33], making such simulations a powerful tool for understanding cloud-circulation
interactions. Another important implication of this work concerns the interpretation of high-resolution climate simulations. Increasing model resolution often produces substantial changes in cloud structure, cloud fraction,
and cloud-radiative effects [33], making such simulations a powerful tool for understanding cloud-circulation
interactions. The dataset provides surface and top-of-atmosphere radiative
fluxes on a 1◦ ×1
◦ grid at hourly resolution, allowing diagnosis of the seasonal and spatial structure of cloud
radiative forcing. Aquaplanet simulations
To isolate the impact of CRE, we perform idealized aquaplanet simulations with the Community Earth
System Model version 2 (CESM2, [38]), using the Community Atmosphere Model version 5 (CAM5, [39]). The dataset provides surface and top-of-atmosphere radiative
fluxes on a 1◦ ×1
◦ grid at hourly resolution, allowing diagnosis of the seasonal and spatial structure of cloud
radiative forcing. Aquaplanet simulations
To isolate the impact of CRE, we perform idealized aquaplanet simulations with the Community Earth
System Model version 2 (CESM2, [38]), using the Community Atmosphere Model version 5 (CAM5, [39]). Cloud radiative effects reinforce storm tracks
Or Hadas1,∗
1Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot 7610001, Israel
∗Corresponding author. hadas@weizmann. The CESM2 source code is publicly available
through the ESCOMP GitHub repository [45]. The radiation scheme files used to implement the cloudradiative effect modifications in the CESM2 simulations are available on Zenodo [46]. The CESM2 source code is publicly available
through the ESCOMP GitHub repository [45]. The radiation scheme files used to implement the cloudradiative effect modifications in the CESM2 simulations are available on Zenodo [46]. Cloud radiative effects reinforce storm tracks
Or Hadas1,∗
1Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot 7610001, Israel
∗Corresponding author. hadas@weizmann.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI systems can predict summertime storm track weakening by incorporating cloud radiative effects that reinforce meridional temperature gradients, as shown in
cloud radiative effects reinforce storm tracks.
This allows for a more accurate assessment of storm activity maintenance during summer compared to models relying solely on solar insolation gradients. -
AI systems can better diagnose the dynamical importance of cloud-radiative forcing by performing sensitivity experiments where SW and LW CRE are independently reduced by 25% in aquaplanet simulations. This isolates the individual and combined effects, determining whether storm track responses are mediated through surface temperatures or direct atmospheric heating, as shown in
Isolating the impact of midlatitude CRE using aquaplanet simulations.
-
Improved AI systems can develop a minimal theoretical framework to quantify cloud feedback strength by identifying two emergent properties:
the maximum attainable cloud albedo and the sensitivity of cloud cover to storm activity.
This framework provides a simple way to interpret how cloud representations influence storm-track behavior, as described inA minimal theory for the cloud-radiative feedback.
-
AI systems can distinguish between regimes of storm track response by analyzing how changes in parameters like maximum attainable cloud albedo or sensitivity of cloud albedo to storm activity act as a switch between
weak- and strong-summer-storm regimes.
This allows for a more physically meaningful diagnostic of cloud-circulation coupling based on the organization of CRE. -
Improved AI systems can better interpret high-resolution climate simulations by using the framework to diagnose how resolution changes clouds while substantially underestimating their influence on storm tracks when SSTs are prescribed. This suggests that capturing this interaction requires simulations with interactive SSTs integrated over timescales long enough for the ocean surface to adjust, as noted in
Discussion.
Abstract
Midlatitude storm tracks play a central role in Earth's climate by transporting heat from low to high latitudes. Their strength is therefore set by the meridional temperature gradients, traditionally linked to differential solar heating. This framework predicts a substantial seasonal reduction in storm activity, as meridional insolation gradients vanish during summer. Yet in the Southern Hemisphere, storm activity decreases by only about 40% from its seasonal maximum. Here, we show that cloud radiative effects contribute to the seasonal maintenance of storm activity by reinforcing the temperature gradients that sustain it. Satellite observations reveal that sunlight reflected by midlatitude clouds in early summer creates a substantial meridional gradient in surface heating, despite the nearly uniform summer insolation. Idealized aquaplanet simulations then show that shortwave cloud radiative effects reinforce meridional sea-surface temperature gradients, thereby strengthening storm activity primarily during late summer and autumn, while longwave cloud effects partly offset this response. To interpret these results, we develop a simple theoretical model linking storms, clouds, and sea-surface temperature gradients. The model captures the seasonal response and demonstrates the importance of two emergent cloud properties: the maximum attainable cloud albedo and the sensitivity of cloud cover to storm activity. Together, these findings indicate that cloud radiative feedbacks help maintain the thermal gradients that sustain storm activity on seasonal timescales. More broadly, they reveal a strong coupling among storms, clouds, and the ocean spanning distinct spatial and temporal scales.
Related papers
- Anthropogenic Heat in Urban Climate Systems: Forcing, Sensitivity, and Feedback
- NORi: An ML-Augmented Ocean Boundary Layer Parameterization
- A Checklist to assess the energy and carbon impacts of ML/AI applications in Earth System Modeling
- Quantifying AI data center nitrogen oxide (NO x) emissions from space
- Skillful Thunderstorm Forecasts Learned Directly from Observations
- Wind vector retrieval from miniaturized wave-enabled sea-surface drifters