Unconventional Mixed-Parity Magnetism in Rare-Earth Tetraborides

arXiv:2607.02117 · cond-mat.str-el, cond-mat.mtrl-sci · Submitted 2026-07-02 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Unconventional Mixed-Parity Magnetism in Rare-Earth Tetraborides".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Unconventional Mixed-Parity Magnetism in Rare-Earth Tetraborides unveils a fundamentally different regime: component-resolved mixed-parity spin splitting in a fully three-dimensional compensated magnet This work establishes rare-earth tetraborides as a robust platform for engineering complex spin-charge conversion phenomena The Core Discovery The central finding is the demonstration that the non-coplanar ground state of TbB4 enforces a unique momentum-space spin texture where in-plane components exhibit oddparity p- and f-wave-like textures, while the out-of-plane component retains an even-parity d-wave altermagnetic character This mixed structure is driven not by relativistic spin-orbit coupling, but by a staggered Berry phase arising from the inherent scalar spin chirality Symmetry and Texture Analysis The magnetic structure of TbB4 is described as a linear combination of the GdB4- and TmB4-type orders, but its momentum-space texture defies a mere linear combination Specifically, the in-plane spin components exhibit odd-parity textures characterized by the coexistence of f-wave-like and p-wave-like patterns, whereas the out-ofplane component exhibits an even (d-wave) parity texture The constraints imposed by the noncoplanar spin group symmetries are rigorously shown to dictate these mixed-parity spin textures, where odd-parity sx and sy components coexist with an even-parity sz component Transport Fingerprints The distinct parity components give rise to complementary transport fingerprints, which are crucial for probing the system The odd-parity in-plane texture generates a bulk non-relativistic Edelstein response.

Kai: The even-parity out-of-plane texture supports an intrinsic spin Hall response.

Mira: Furthermore, the coexistence of these mixed-parity sectors leads to distinct transport fingerprints Observable Consequences The study investigates several key observable quantities induced by this unique coexistence in TbB4 The non-relativistic Edelstein effect (NREE) is finite due to the odd-parity in-plane components, while the non-relativistic spin Hall effect (NR SHE) is supported by the even-parity out-of-plane texture.

Kai: In the presence of SOC, a symmetry-allowed Berry curvature dipole (BCD) emerges, providing an additional route to nonlinear Hall phenomena The analysis shows that while in-plane components vanish upon Brillouin zone integration without SOC, the out-of-plane component remains finite for GdB4 and TbB4.

Paper summary: Kai: So to wrap up on "Unconventional Mixed-Parity Magnetism in Rare-Earth Tetraborides," they’ve shown how component resolved mixed parity splitting happens in a fully three dimensional compensated magnet, TbB4.

Mira: The big idea is that this material has a momentum space spin texture where the in plane parts are odd parity p and f wave like, and the out of plane part is even parity d wave altermagnetism.

Lev: It’s important because it shows that you can get these mixed states without needing relativistic spin orbit coupling to drive them; it comes from the scalar spin chirality.

Kai: They found that this intrinsic non coplanar magnetic ground state creates a staggered Berry phase, which is what causes that mixed parity splitting.

Mira: So the results lead to distinct transport fingerprints: the odd parity in plane texture gives you a bulk non relativistic Edelstein response, and the even parity out of plane texture gives you a non relativistic spin Hall response.

Lev: For someone who just listens to the show, this means that we can engineer these specific spin charge conversions using the built-in geometry of materials like TbB4.

Kai: This paper sets up rare-earth tetraborides as a natural bulk platform for probing mixed parity magnetism because it’s operating entirely independent of external tuning.

Conclusion: Kai: So we’re wrapping up on this paper, "Unconventional Mixed-Parity Magnetism in Rare-Earth Tetraborides." Basically, they found a way to get a fully three dimensional compensated magnet, TbB4, to have something fundamentally different than what you see in other rare-earth tetraborides like GdB4 or TmB4.

Mira: Yeah. The authors are showing that this isn't just one simple magnetic order; it’s a mixed parity situation where the in plane parts are odd parity p and f wave like, but the out of plane part is even parity d wave altermagnetism.

Lev: From my side, what makes me look at this is that they say this mixed structure comes from a staggered Berry phase, which they link to inherent scalar spin chirality rather than needing relativistic spin orbit coupling to happen.

Kai: That’s a big deal because it suggests we don't always need those strong relativistic effects just to get these complex textures in materials like this.

Mira: Exactly. They establish TbB4 as a natural platform for engineering these complex spin charge conversion phenomena because of that intrinsic non coplanar magnetic ground state they found.

Lev: And what changes for us is that this material family could be a broader platform than just the ones we’ve been looking at, like ErB4 or PrB4.

Kai: So it means we can use these rare-earth tetraborides to build systems where you have these specific non relativistic spin charge conversions happening without needing external tuning or heavy spin-orbit coupling.

Mira: It opens up a lot of doors for exploring how magnetism and charge flow interact in a way that’s driven by the geometry itself.

Lev: It sets the stage for us to look at how this might translate into actual hardware, but first we need to figure out exactly how robust these transport fingerprints are when you introduce real noise and temperature effects.

Dong-Choon Ryu, Jae-Ho Han, Bongjae Kim, Chang-Jong Kang

Department of Physics, Chungnam National University · Institute for Sciences of the Universe, Chungnam National University · Department of Physics and Chemisty, Korea Military Academy · Department of Physics, Kyungpook National University

cond-mat.str-el, cond-mat.mtrl-sci

Submitted: 2026-07-02

Updated: 2026-11-02

Comments: Main manuscript: 10 pages, 3 figures, Supplementary Material: 20 pages, 16 figures, 2 tables

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 92/100

The gist: Unconventional Mixed-Parity Magnetism in Rare-Earth Tetraborides unveils a fundamentally different regime…

Key concepts

Mixed-Parity Spin Splitting
This describes a magnetic state where different parts of the material's spin behave differently based on their orientation. In TbB4, the in-plane spins have odd parity (like p or f waves), while the out-of-plane spins have even parity (like d waves). This coexistence is what makes the magnetism unconventional.
Scalar Spin Chirality
Chirality refers to a property that describes the handedness or twist in a magnetic structure. In this paper, a 'scalar' spin chirality arises naturally from the inherent magnetic state of TbB4. This intrinsic property acts as the driver for creating the staggered Berry phase, which is responsible for generating the mixed-parity spin textures.
Edelstein Response (NREE)
The non-relativistic Edelstein response is a transport phenomenon where an electric field applied to a material generates a spin current. In TbB4, this effect is finite because of the odd-parity components in the plane of the material. This shows how the mixed magnetism can directly influence charge and spin flow.
Spin Hall Effect (NR SHE)
The non-relativistic spin Hall effect is another transport property where a current flowing through a material generates a transverse spin current. In TbB4, this effect is supported by the even-parity component of the magnetism oriented out-of-plane, demonstrating how different magnetic symmetries lead to different physical responses.

Terminology

Summary

Unconventional Mixed-Parity Magnetism in Rare-Earth Tetraborides unveils a fundamentally different regime: component-resolved mixed-parity spin splitting in a fully three-dimensional compensated magnet This work establishes rare-earth tetraborides as a robust platform for engineering complex spin-charge conversion phenomena

The Core Discovery

The central finding is the demonstration that the non-coplanar ground state of TbB4 enforces a unique momentum-space spin texture where in-plane components exhibit oddparity p- and f-wave-like textures, while the out-of-plane component retains an even-parity d-wave altermagnetic character This mixed structure is driven not by relativistic spin-orbit coupling, but by a staggered Berry phase arising from the inherent scalar spin chirality

Symmetry and Texture Analysis

The magnetic structure of TbB4 is described as a linear combination of the GdB4- and TmB4-type orders, but its momentum-space texture defies a mere linear combination Specifically, the in-plane spin components exhibit odd-parity textures characterized by the coexistence of f-wave-like and p-wave-like patterns, whereas the out-ofplane component exhibits an even (d-wave) parity texture The constraints imposed by the noncoplanar spin group symmetries are rigorously shown to dictate these mixed-parity spin textures, where odd-parity sx and sy components coexist with an even-parity sz component

Transport Fingerprints

The distinct parity components give rise to complementary transport fingerprints, which are crucial for probing the system

** The odd-parity in-plane texture generates a bulk non-relativistic Edelstein response. **

The even-parity out-of-plane texture supports an intrinsic spin Hall response. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Instead, the noncoplanar order enforces a component-resolved mixedparity spin splitting: the in-plane spin components form odd-parity textures characterized by the coexistence of f-wave-like and p-wave-like patterns, whereas the out-ofplane component retains an even-parity d-wave altermagnetic texture. We further demonstrate that these distinct parity components give rise to complementary transport fingerprints: the odd-parity in-plane texture generates a bulk non-relativistic Edelstein response, whereas the even-parity out-of-plane texture supports an intrinsic spin Hall response.

Furthermore, the coexistence of these mixed-parity sectors leads to distinct transport fingerprints

Observable Consequences

The study investigates several key observable quantities induced by this unique coexistence in TbB4

** The non-relativistic Edelstein effect (NREE) is finite due to the odd-parity in-plane components, while the non-relativistic spin Hall effect (NR SHE) is supported by the even-parity out-of-plane texture. **

** In the presence of SOC, a symmetry-allowed Berry curvature dipole (BCD) emerges, providing an additional route to nonlinear Hall phenomena The analysis shows that while in-plane components vanish upon Brillouin zone integration without SOC, the out-of-plane component remains finite for GdB4 and TbB4. p. 4

Where the paper says it

The coexistence of these mixed-parity sectors leads to distinct transport fingerprints: the odd-parity in-plane texture generates a bulk non-relativistic Edelstein response, whereas the even-parity out-of-plane texture supports a non-relativistic spin Hall response. In the presence of SOC, TbB4 further develops a symmetry-allowed Berry curvature dipole, providing an additional route to nonlinear Hall phenomena [61].

**

Computational Methodology

The researchers employed a combination of first-principles calculations using VASP with GGA + U scheme to capture the magnetic ground states They utilized tight-binding and k·p models, along with spin-group symmetry analysis, to explore the electronic band structures and spin textures The tight-binding model successfully reproduces key DFT features around the M point, explicitly demonstrating the coexistence of f-wave-like and p-wave-like spin textures

Material Platform Significance

Rare-earth tetraborides (RB4) serve as a natural material platform for this research due to their high-symmetry crystal symmetries and diverse magnetic ground states TbB4 is highlighted as a natural bulk platform for realizing and probing mixed-parity magnetism This unique state emerges purely from the intrinsic non-coplanar magnetic ground state and non-symmorphic constraints, operating entirely independent of spin-orbit coupling or external tuning The results suggest rare-earth tetraborides as a broader materials family for engineering nonrelativistic spin-charge conversion in compensated magnets

Conclusion

The paper concludes that component-resolved mixed-parity spin splitting can be realized in a fully three-dimensional compensated magnet TbB4 exhibits a qualitatively different regime compared to GdB4 and TmB4 The coexistence of p- and f-wave-like textures originates from a staggered Berry phase induced by the scalar spin chirality inherent to TbB4, rather than from relativistic spin-orbit coupling This establishes TbB4 as a natural bulk platform for realizing and probing mixed-parity magnetism

Acknowledgment

The authors acknowledge support from the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) and the KISTI Supercomputing Center They are also grateful to Igor Mazin, Hyun-Woo Lee, Yong Baek Kim, Hae-Young Kee, Kyoung-Whan Kim, and Hosub Jin for useful discussions The research was supported by Global - Learning & Academic research institution for Master’s·PhD students and Postdocs (G-LAMP) Program of NRF grant funded by the Ministry of Education The work was also supported by “Creation of the quantum information science R&D ecosystem (based on human resources)” through the NRF funded by the Korean government The authors acknowledge the hospitality of the Aspen Center for Physics during the 2026 Aspen Winter Conference and of APCTP (Pohang, Korea) during the conference

References

The paper cites numerous foundational works related to altermagnetism, spin-orbit coupling in magnets, and specific material properties like RuO2 and MnTe Key references include those by Smejkal et al. on crystal time-reversal symmetry breaking and spontaneous hall effect, Jungwirth et al. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Jungwirth, and ˇ J. Sinova, Crystal time-reversal symmetry breaking and spontaneous hall effect in collinear antiferromagnets, Science Advances 6, eaaz8809 (2020).

p. 5
Where the paper says it

Jungwirth, and ˇ J. Sinova, Crystal time-reversal symmetry breaking and spontaneous hall effect in collinear antiferromagnets, Science Advances 6, eaaz8809 (2020).

on the emerging research landscape of altermagnetism, and studies concerning p-wave magnets The paper also references specific structural and magnetic studies on related materials like PrB4, TmB4, and ErB4 The computational methods rely on established techniques such as the projector augmented-wave (PAW) method [55–57] for DFT calculations The paper draws connections to topological Weyl altermagnetism in CrSb and studies on anomalous hall antiferromagnets The results are contextualized by previous work on spin-neutral currents for spintronics and the effects of SOC on spin textures in RB4 systems Finally, the paper cites works discussing the quantum nonlinear hall effect induced by berry curvature dipole in time-reversal invariant materials, which is relevant to the SOC effects discussed later. The paper also references specific studies on magnetic structures of Tbb4 revealed by resonant x-ray diffraction and electronic transport on the shastry-sutherland lattice in ising-type rareearth tetraborides. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Suzuki, and J. Checkelsky, Electronic transport on the shastry-sutherland lattice in ising-type rareearth tetraborides, Phys.

The computational details are further elaborated in the Supplemental Material which includes references [48, 55? p. 7
Where the paper says it

[58] See Supplemental Material for further computational details, the electronic structures of RB4, spin textures on the Fermi surfaces, tight-binding and k·p models, the effect of spin-orbit coupling on the spin textures and Edelstein response, as well as the Berry curvature and Berry curvature dipole in the absence of spin-orbit coupling. The Supplemental Material includes Refs.

–57] and others for specific structural and magnetic properties of RB4 systems. p. 0
Where the paper says it

This motivates the search for compensated magnets hosting component-resolved mixed-parity spin splitting, where magnetoelectric and spin-transport responses normally associated with separate parity classes can emerge within a single magnetic phase. Rare-earth tetraborides (RB4) provide an natural material platform for this, owing to their high-symmetry crystal symmetries and diverse, element-specific magnetic ground states [46–52].

The paper cites works on spin-group symmetry in magnetic materials with negligible spinorbit coupling and enumeration of spin-space groups. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Wan, and Q. Liu, Spin-group symmetry in magnetic materials with negligible spinorbit coupling, Phys.

The analysis of the k·p expansion is supported by references detailing the effective Hamiltonian construction and momentum-dependent spin textures in TbB4

Appendix Details

Appendix A details the 16 symmetry operations of TbB4's spin-space group (SSG) Appendix B shows the constraints imposed by the non-symmorphic spin group symmetry elements on band dispersion, leading to the mixed-parity textures Appendix C details an effective k·p Hamiltonian and its Taylor expansion around the M point, revealing how kinetic terms yield p-wave, f-wave, and d-wave spin textures Appendix D provides the Kubo formula for spin Hall conductivity and demonstrates that in the absence of SOC, all in-plane components of the spin Hall conductivity vanish The inclusion of SOC allows for a nonzero Berry curvature dipole (BCD), which is robustly corroborated by calculated Berry curvature under SOC The analysis confirms that the gauge field λ elegantly rescues the linear momentum terms from cancellation, generating the robust p-wave inner pocket, while the inherent lattice geometry naturally provides the higher-order kinetic modulations for the f-wave outer pocket The results establish TbB4 as a natural bulk platform for realizing and probing mixed-parity magnetism The authors emphasize that this unique state emerges purely from the intrinsic non-coplanar magnetic ground state and non-symmorphic constraints, operating entirely independent of spin-orbit coupling or external tuning

Summary of Key Findings

The paper successfully demonstrates that component-resolved mixed-parity spin splitting can be realized in a fully three-dimensional compensated magnet TbB4 exhibits a qualitatively different regime compared to GdB4 and TmB4 The coexistence of p- and f-wave-like textures originates from a staggered Berry phase induced by the scalar spin chirality inherent to TbB4, rather than from relativistic spin-orbit coupling This establishes TbB4 as a natural bulk platform for realizing and probing mixed-parity magnetism The coexistence of these mixed-parity sectors leads to distinct transport fingerprints: the odd-parity in-plane texture generates a bulk non-relativistic Edelstein response, whereas the even-parity out-of-plane texture supports a non-relativistic spin Hall response In the presence of SOC, TbB4 further develops a symmetry-allowed Berry curvature dipole, providing an additional route to nonlinear Hall phenomena The results establish TbB4 as a natural bulk platform for realizing and probing mixed-parity magnetism

Final Remarks

The findings establish TbB4 as a natural bulk platform for realizing and probing mixed-parity magnetism The coexistence of these mixed-parity sectors leads to distinct transport fingerprints: the odd-parity in-plane texture generates a bulk non-relativistic Edelstein response, whereas the even-parity out-ofplane texture supports a non-relativistic spin Hall response The results establish TbB4 as a natural bulk platform for realizing and probing mixed-parity magnetism The authors emphasize that this unique state emerges purely from the intrinsic non-coplanar magnetic ground state and non-symmorphic constraints, operating entirely independent of spin-orbit coupling or external tuning

The paper cites numerous foundational works related to altermagnetism, spin-orbit coupling in magnets, and specific material properties like RuO2 and MnTe Key references include those by Smejkal et al. on crystal time-reversal symmetry breaking and spontaneous hall effect, Jungwirth et al. on the emerging research landscape of altermagnetism, and studies concerning p-wave magnets The computational methods rely on established techniques such as the projector augmented-wave (PAW) method [55–57] for DFT calculations The paper draws connections to topological Weyl altermagnetism in CrSb and studies on anomalous hall antiferromagnets The results are contextualized by previous work on spin-neutral currents for spintronics and the effects of SOC on spin textures in RB4 systems Finally, the paper cites works discussing the quantum nonlinear hall effect induced by berry curvature dipole in time-reversal invariant materials, which is relevant to the SOC effects discussed later. The paper also references specific studies on magnetic structures of Tbb4 revealed by resonant x-ray diffraction and electronic transport on the shastry-sutherland lattice in ising-type rareearth tetraborides The computational details are further elaborated in the Supplemental Material which includes references [48, 55? p. 7

Where the paper says it

Suzuki, and J. Checkelsky, Electronic transport on the shastry-sutherland lattice in ising-type rareearth tetraborides, Phys.

–57] and others for specific structural and magnetic properties of RB4 systems The paper cites works on spin-group symmetry in magnetic materials with negligible spinorbit coupling and enumeration of spin-space groups. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Wan, and Q. Liu, Spin-group symmetry in magnetic materials with negligible spinorbit coupling, Phys.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Advanced material design for spin-charge conversion systems: The improved AI system can predict novel rare-earth tetraborides with component-resolved mixed-parity magnetism by analyzing their crystal symmetries and magnetic ground states, specifically targeting TbB4 as a platform for engineering component resolved mixed parity spin splitting.

  2. Nonrelativistic transport property prediction: The system can calculate the bulk nonrelativistic Edelstein effect (NREE) tensor χij and the nonrelativistic spin Hall response σzxy directly from first-principles calculations, allowing engineers to design materials optimized for currentinduced spin accumulation without relying on traditional spin-orbit coupling mechanisms.

  3. Spin Hall effect optimization: The AI can predict the magnitude of the nonrelativistic spin Hall conductivity σzxy, specifically identifying TbB4 as a material where this response is allowed and non-zero due to the even-parity out-of-plane texture, guiding the search for materials with robust intrinsic spin current generation.

  4. Nonlinear transport phenomena modeling: The system can predict the emergence of a symmetry allowed Berry curvature dipole (BCD) in TbB4 when spin-orbit coupling is included, enabling the design of devices that exploit nonlinear Hall effects induced by this effect.

  5. Spin texture mapping for material screening: The AI can generate high-resolution maps of spin polarization distributions across different momentum space planes (kz = -0.04, 0, and 0.04) to verify the predicted coexistence of p-wave and f-wave like textures in TbB4, ensuring accurate modeling of the Fermi surface topology.

Abstract

Altermagnetism has advanced the study of compensated magnets by revealing non-relativistic spin splitting, traditionally classified into strictly even- or odd-parity spin textures. Here, we establish component-resolved mixed-parity spin splitting in a fully three-dimensional compensated magnet and identify its microscopic origin. Using first-principles calculations, tight-binding and k times p models, along with spin-group symmetry analysis, we demonstrate that the non-coplanar ground state of TbB 4 enforces odd-parity p - and f-wave-like textures for the in-plane spin components while the out-of-plane component retains an even-parity d-wave altermagnetic character. Crucially, the p-wave texture is driven not by relativistic spin-orbit coupling but by a staggered emergent flux arising from the scalar spin chirality of the non-coplanar order. This mixed-parity structure dictates distinct transport fingerprints, including bulk non-relativistic Edelstein and spin Hall responses that respond characteristically to reversal of the chirality domains. Spin-orbit coupling additionally enables a Berry curvature dipole. These results establish the rare-earth tetraborides as a robust platform for engineering complex spin-charge conversion phenomena.

Sources

Related papers