Dissipative hydrodynamic actions and horizon symmetries in gravity
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Dissipative hydrodynamic actions and horizon symmetries in gravity".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper presents a prescription for computing a dissipative action describing large-scale thermal stress tensor dynamics in a holographic quantum field theory dual to AdS4 gravity, utilizing the Schwinger-Keldysh formalism.
Kai: This prescription is valid to quadratic order in perturbations around the thermal equilibrium state and to first order in the hydrodynamic derivative expansion.
Mira: The hydrodynamical degrees of freedom are realized gravitationally as relative diffeomorphisms between the black hole horizon and two asymptotic boundaries defined by a Crossley-Glorioso-Liu contour.
Kai: The calculation confirms that this prescription correctly reproduces known hydrodynamic Green’s functions when computed to first order in derivatives, provided a choice of horizon boundary conditions is made.
Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper today titled "Dissipative hydrodynamic actions and horizon symmetries in gravity" by Blake, Das, and Davison. It sounds pretty technical, but basically they are trying to figure out how to write down an action that describes the flow of stress tensors in a holographic quantum field theory that's dual to AdS4 gravity.
Mira: Right. They're using the Schwinger-Keldysh formalism for this, which is a specific way of handling quantum dynamics in real time, and they are doing it up to quadratic order around thermal equilibrium. It’s about finding a way to get an action principle from which the classical hydrodynamics emerges.
Lev: From my side, I see that constructing these actions systematically is tough because you're dealing with effective theories constrained by underlying symmetry principles <ref:2607.00866#pg3>. It’s not just plugging things in; you have to make sure the action respects the structure of the theory.
Kai: Exactly. And they are using relative diffeomorphisms between the black hole horizon and two boundaries defined by a specific contour, called a Crossley-Glorioso-Liu contour, to realize those hydrodynamic degrees of freedom. It’s how they get their fluid dynamics from gravity in this setup <ref:2607.00866#pg1>.
Mira: That realization is key because it connects the bulk geometry—the black hole and the boundaries—directly to the fluid variables we expect in hydrodynamics, like temperature and velocity. It sets up a framework for deriving things like Green's functions from gravity itself <ref:2607.00866#pg2>.
Lev: And they confirm that this prescription works when you compute the hydrodynamic Green's functions to first order in the derivative expansion, provided you choose a specific way to define those boundary conditions on the horizon <ref:2607.00866#pg1>.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, what’s actually happening in this paper? They are deriving a consistent Schwinger-Keldysh action, which they call the hydrodynamical action, denoted as Shydro <ref:2607.00866#pg2>. This action only depends on the hydrodynamic fields and external sources for the stress tensor, and its dependence comes through some combinations called B sigma mu <ref:2607.00866#pg1>.
Mira: The most important part is how they define the stress tensor itself. They define two different versions of it, T mu nu one and T mu nu two by taking derivatives of this Shydro action with respect to the different boundary metrics on each branch of the contour <ref:2607.00866#pg1>.
Lev: And then they show that the equations of motion for these two versions are equivalent to imposing covariant conservation of the stress tensor, which is what we expect in hydrodynamics, and also equivalent to the standard Einstein equations without any extra stuff <ref:2607.00866#pg2>.
Kai: That’s a strong result because it means they’ve constructed an action that automatically enforces those conservation laws from the start, instead of just checking if they hold after you solve the equations <ref:2607.00866#pg1>.
Mira: And when you integrate out those hydrodynamic fields, you get a generating functional for real-time two-point functions of the stress tensor <ref:2607.00866#pg2>. These functions match what we get from variational hydrodynamics and the fluctuation-dissipation relation, which is pretty solid <ref:2607.00866#pg4>.
Lev: It’s a big step because it moves us closer to a non-perturbative understanding of how these dynamics arise in this holographic setup, rather than just relying on low-order approximations.
The paper's improvements: Kai: The authors then move on to looking at symmetries that keep these horizon boundary conditions intact. They find some interesting symmetries for the diffeomorphisms that preserve the original boundary conditions of one set <ref:2607.00866#pg1>.
Mira: They find symmetries reminiscent of what others argued in a different paper, including time independent shifts of hydrodynamic fields, and even exponentially growing or decaying symmetries that suggest something related to quantum chaos
forty-two–forty-four: <ref:2607.00866#pg2>.
Lev: That’s intriguing because those exponential modes are often connected to chaos in other areas, so seeing them appear here is a sign they might be capturing some non-trivial dynamics <ref:2607.00866#pg1>.
Kai: But then they look at a second set of horizon boundary conditions, which involves specific constraints on the metric perturbations near the horizon <ref:2607.00866#pg1>.
Mira: When they use that second set, the resulting near-horizon diffeomorphisms turn out to be exactly those symmetries that were argued for in paper forty-four, which is what we are hoping to connect to other holographic systems <ref:2607.00866#pg1>.
Lev: So, it suggests that the specific way you set up those boundary conditions dictates which symmetries you actually see, and this helps us pinpoint the right setup for studying these things <ref:2607.00866#pg1>.
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up on "Dissipative hydrodynamic actions and horizon symmetries in gravity," the paper shows that this prescription correctly reproduces known results for the momentum density two-point functions, specifically getting G R T tyT ty(omega, k) = -r 20k squared i omega - k squared 3r zero omega + ik squared <ref:2607.00866#pg4>.
Mira: This matches the results from variational hydrodynamics for a conformal fluid at first order in the derivative expansion, which is consistent with what we already know about shear viscosity, where eta = s / (four pi) = r twentyfifty-four fifty-five <ref:2607.00866#pg4>.
Lev: It confirms the consistency of their first-order calculation with established results for shear viscosity, but it’s important to remember that this is only at the first order in derivatives <ref:2607.00866#pg1>.
Kai: And they also show that the symmetric and retarded correlators derived from this action satisfy the fluctuation-dissipation relation within their calculation's accuracy <ref:2607.00866#pg4>.
Mira: This is a solid piece of evidence, but we need to remember what they say about limitations: they note that those terms suppressed by higher powers of derivatives aren't trustworthy at this first order <ref:2607.00866#pg1>.
Lev: So the limitation is that we haven't gotten a consistent action that is non-perturbative in derivatives yet, which means we still have to rely on these low-order checks instead of a full calculation of KMS symmetry <ref:2607.00866#pg3>.
School of Mathematics, University of Bristol · School of Mathematics and Maxwell Institute for Mathematical Sciences, University of Edinburgh · Higgs Centre for Theoretical Physics, University of Edinburgh · Department of Mathematics and Maxwell Institute for Mathematical Sciences, Heriot-Watt University
hep-th, gr-qc
Submitted: 2026-07-01
Updated: 2026-11-05
Comments: 56 pages (including refs), 1 figure. v2: improved presentation slightly, added Weyl-invariant form of the hydro action, updated refs, main results unchanged, accepted in JHEP
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 97/100
The gist: The paper presents a prescription for computing a dissipative action describing large-scale thermal stress tensor dynamics in a holographic quantum field theory dual to AdS4 gravity…
Key concepts
- Dissipative Action
- This is a mathematical framework used to describe how a system loses energy (dissipates) when it is out of equilibrium. Here, it's applied to the stress tensor dynamics of a hot black hole described by gravity, allowing researchers to study how fluid-like properties emerge from the underlying quantum field theory.
- Schwinger-Keldysh Formalism
- This is a specific mathematical technique used in quantum field theory to calculate real-time dynamics. It allows physicists to study systems that are not in thermal equilibrium, such as a hot fluid, by using a contour integral that tracks the evolution of the system over time.
- Horizon Boundary Conditions
- These are specific constraints placed on the metric perturbations near the black hole's event horizon. The paper explores different choices for these conditions to see which ones preserve certain symmetries related to quantum chaos and hydrodynamic behavior.
Terminology
Summary
The paper presents a prescription for computing a dissipative action describing large-scale thermal stress tensor dynamics in a holographic quantum field theory dual to AdS4 gravity, utilizing the Schwinger-Keldysh formalism. p. 0 davison@hw. uk
Abstract: We give a prescription to compute a dissipative action describing the large-scale
thermal stress tensor dynamics of a holographic quantum field theory dual to AdS4 gravity,
in the context of the Schwinger-Keldysh formalism. uk
Abstract: We give a prescription to compute a dissipative action describing the large-scale
thermal stress tensor dynamics of a holographic quantum field theory dual to AdS4 gravity,
in the context of the Schwinger-Keldysh formalism. Our prescription is valid to quadratic
order in perturbations about the thermal equilibrium state. Our prescription is valid to quadratic
order in perturbations about the thermal equilibrium state. The hydrodynamical degrees
of freedom of this action are realised in gravity as relative diffeomorphisms between the
black hole horizon and the two asymptotic boundaries of the Crossley-Glorioso-Liu contour. We explicitly compute the action to first order in derivatives, and confirm it correctly
reproduces the known hydrodynamic Green’s functions. Our prescription requires a choice
of horizon boundary conditions for the metric.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The main result is the derivation of a consistent Schwinger-Keldysh action, Shydro[delta g sigma(s) mu, xi sigma mu], describing the stress-tensor dynamics. p. 3 By constructing such hydrodynamic actions, we can
test these important conjectures. The first main result of this paper is to present a consistent derivation of a SchwingerKeldysh action describing the stress-tensor dynamics of the holographic QFT dual to the
AdS4-Schwarzschild black hole. This action has, in particular, the following properties. The action depends only on hydrodynamic fields ξ
σ
µ and external sources for the stress
tensor (i. Defining the stress tensor on each branch of the Schwinger-Keldysh contour by
T
µν,1 =
2
√
−g
δShydro
δg1(s)
µν
, T µν,2 = −
2
√
−g
δShydro
δg2(s)
µν
, (1. 4)
the equations of motion of the hydrodynamical action are equivalent to imposing
covariant conservation of the stress tensor, and are furthermore equivalent to the
unimposed Einstein equations. Integrating out the hydrodynamical fields gives the generating functional for real-time
two-point functions of the stress tensor. These two point functions are consistent with
the known results computed using variational hydrodynamics and the fluctuationdissipation relation.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The study then focuses on identifying symmetries that preserve these horizon boundary conditions. p. 0 Our prescription requires a choice
of horizon boundary conditions for the metric. We study the horizon symmetries that
preserve these, and their relation to conjectured hydrodynamic symmetries responsible for
many-body quantum chaos. As we have highlighted, a key motivation for computing a hydrodynamic action – rather
than the correlators directly – is to understand if it possesses conjectured symmetries that
are related to quantum chaos [42–44]. In the context of our prescription, we argue that such
symmetries can be identified as diffeomorphisms preserving our horizon boundary conditions. They include certain time-independent shifts of the hydrodynamic fields, and we perform a
non-trivial check that our action is indeed invariant under such symmetries. Additionally,
they include exponentially growing and decaying (in time) symmetries reminiscent of those
conjectured via quantum chaos [42–44]. 3 However the profile of the exponentially growing
mode is distinct from that identified in [44]. With this distinction in mind, we also consider the hydrodynamic action obtained using
a second set of horizon boundary conditions, in which we replace (1. The near-horizon diffeomorphisms
preserving the boundary conditions (1. 5) are precisely equivalent to the horizon symmetries
argued for in [44].Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The resulting hydrodynamic action is expressed as Shydro[xi plus or minus y, delta g plus or minus(s) ty, delta g plus or minus(s) xy] = r 30 Z d 3x [3B+tyB-ty + 3i4 pi B-xyB-xy + 3i2 pi r 0 B-ty d x B-xy + i r 0 d t B y barx]. p. 4 The resulting symmetries are reminiscent, but not identical, to those argued for in [44]. They include certain time-independent shifts of the hydrodynamic fields, and we perform a
non-trivial check that our action is indeed invariant under such symmetries. The hydrodynamical degrees
of freedom of this action are realised in gravity as relative diffeomorphisms between the
black hole horizon and the two asymptotic boundaries of the Crossley-Glorioso-Liu contour. We explicitly compute the action to first order in derivatives, and confirm it correctly
reproduces the known hydrodynamic Green’s functions.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The calculation yields the retarded two-point functions of the momentum density G R T tyT ty(omega, k) = -r 20k squared i omega - k squared 3r 0 omega + ik squared. p. 1 Contents
1 Introduction 1
2 Background geometry 5
3 Transverse perturbations 7
4 Longitudinal perturbations 14
5 The Schwinger-Keldysh action 22
6 Symmetries of the hydrodynamic action and horizon symmetries 27
7 Alternative horizon boundary conditions 31
8 Discussion 34
A Asymptotic boundary conditions 36
B Summary of partially on-shell solutions 38
C Variational principle near the horizon 40
D Explicit expressions for two-point functions 43
E Review of horizon symmetries of [44] 44
F An alternative approach in the literature 46
1 Introduction
Hydrodynamics provides a universal description of the long distance, late time dynamics
of conserved quantities in many-body quantum systems and quantum field theory. Traditionally, hydrodynamics is formulated at a classical level, in which the expectation values
of conserved currents are expanded in terms of hydrodynamical variables such as the local temperature and fluid velocity (see [1] for a pedagogical review). Our calculation will be performed to quadratic order in
the amplitude of perturbations about equilibrium, and to first order in the hydrodynamical derivative expansion. Our approach will be similar to that of [34], [35] and [36], in
that we will construct a partially on-shell action for relative diffeomorphisms, obtained by
imposing a subset of the Einstein equations. In particular, it was proposed in [42, 43] that in maximally chaotic systems
1Another example are SYK chains, for which an action for non-linear fluctuating hydrodynamics has
recently been derived (in the low temperature limit) in [9]. 2
JT [37–39] and AdS3 gravity [40] can be described by actions for reparameterisation fields, which
can be considered as a special case of hydrodynamical actions with no dissipation.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The final step involves contextualizing these findings by identifying horizon symmetries in a broader holographic framework. p. 3 This will allow us to
systematically include the effects of dissipation. A crucial aspect of our calculation is identifying appropriate boundary conditions to impose at the black hole horizon. The hydrodynamic variables that will arise naturally from our analysis are
ξ
σ
y
(t, x) = [ζ
y
]
∞
r0 = ζ
y,σ(t, r = ∞, x) − Y
σ
(t, x). 5)
These are relative diffeomorphisms in the y-direction between the asymptotic boundaries
of the CGL contour and the black hole horizon. Contents
1 Introduction 1
2 Background geometry 5
3 Transverse perturbations 7
4 Longitudinal perturbations 14
5 The Schwinger-Keldysh action 22
6 Symmetries of the hydrodynamic action and horizon symmetries 27
7 Alternative horizon boundary conditions 31
8 Discussion 34
A Asymptotic boundary conditions 36
B Summary of partially on-shell solutions 38
C Variational principle near the horizon 40
D Explicit expressions for two-point functions 43
E Review of horizon symmetries of [44] 44
F An alternative approach in the literature 46
1 Introduction
Hydrodynamics provides a universal description of the long distance, late time dynamics
of conserved quantities in many-body quantum systems and quantum field theory. Traditionally, hydrodynamics is formulated at a classical level, in which the expectation values
of conserved currents are expanded in terms of hydrodynamical variables such as the local temperature and fluid velocity (see [1] for a pedagogical review). 3 However the profile of the exponentially growing
mode is distinct from that identified in [44]. With this distinction in mind, we also consider the hydrodynamic action obtained using
a second set of horizon boundary conditions, in which we replace (1. As we have highlighted, a key motivation for computing a hydrodynamic action – rather
than the correlators directly – is to understand if it possesses conjectured symmetries that
are related to quantum chaos [42–44]. In the context of our prescription, we argue that such
symmetries can be identified as diffeomorphisms preserving our horizon boundary conditions.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improve ability to derive dissipative hydrodynamic actions by systematically exploring alternative horizon boundary conditions beyond those motivated by quadratic gravity variational principles (like condition 7.1). This allows for a more comprehensive study of which boundary conditions preserve conjectured symmetries related to many-body quantum chaos, as the paper demonstrates that the equations of motion might differ between different choices.
-
Enhance the system's capability to perform non-perturbative checks on hydrodynamic actions by developing methods to go beyond first order in derivatives, potentially leading to a consistent action that is non-perturbative in derivatives. This would allow for a more direct verification of KMS symmetry rather than just checking consistency with the fluctuation-dissipation relation at finite order.
-
Strengthen the system's understanding of symmetry realization by integrating concepts from spontaneous breaking of strong to weak symmetries into its analysis of horizon symmetries. This would enable a more precise formulation of hydrodynamic symmetries related to quantum chaos in a language that might be more directly applicable to complex holographic systems.
-
Improve the accuracy and reliability of calculating two-point functions by developing robust methods for handling corrections suppressed by higher powers of derivatives, as the current calculation shows these terms are not trustworthy at first order. This would allow for reliable computation of symmetric and retarded Green's functions at higher orders in the derivative expansion.
-
Increase the precision in relating bulk gravitational symmetries to hydrodynamic symmetries by explicitly testing if conjectured exponential growing modes are indeed symmetries of the action under alternative horizon boundary conditions, which currently requires knowledge of the action to all orders in derivatives.
Abstract
We give a prescription to compute a dissipative action describing the large-scale thermal stress tensor dynamics of a holographic quantum field theory dual to AdS 4 gravity, in the context of the Schwinger-Keldysh formalism. Our prescription is valid to quadratic order in perturbations about the thermal equilibrium state. The hydrodynamical degrees of freedom of this action are realised in gravity as relative diffeomorphisms between the black hole horizon and the two asymptotic boundaries of the Crossley-Glorioso-Liu contour. We explicitly compute the action to first order in derivatives, and confirm it correctly reproduces the known hydrodynamic Green's functions. Our prescription requires a choice of horizon boundary conditions for the metric. We study the horizon symmetries that preserve these, and their relation to conjectured hydrodynamic symmetries responsible for many-body quantum chaos.
Sources
- Lectures on hydrodynamic fluctuations in relativistic theories
- Effective field theory of dissipative fluids
- Viscosity and dissipative hydrodynamics from effective field theory
- The Fluid Manifesto: Emergent symmetries, hydrodynamics, and black holes
- Two roads to hydrodynamic effective actions: a comparison
- Dissipative hydrodynamics in superspace
- Lectures on non-equilibrium effective field theories and fluctuating hydrodynamics
- Boulder Lectures on Thermal Dynamics and Hydrodynamic EFTs
- All-order fluctuating hydrodynamics of the SYK lattice
- Nonlinear Fluid Dynamics from Gravity
- Forced Fluid Dynamics from Gravity
- Hydrodynamics from charged black branes
- Fluid dynamics of R-charged black holes
- The fluid/gravity correspondence
- A prescription for holographic Schwinger-Keldysh contour in non-equilibrium systems
- Holographic Schwinger-Keldysh effective field theories
- The coset construction for non-equilibrium systems
- 2-group global symmetries, hydrodynamics and holography
- Fermionic Open EFT from Holography
- Holographic KMS relations at finite density
Related papers
- The facts on quantum self-dual Einstein gravity and self-dual Yang-Mills theory
- Quantum Langlands correspondence for Painlev'e II
- Fortuitous BMN Operators from Multiple Cores
- Building far-from-equilibrium effective field theories using shift symmetries
- Inflation, Cosmic Perturbations and Non-Gaussianities
- Wavefunctions of AdS 3 Universes and T-deformed Torus Partition Functions