On the spherical symmetry and finite-range assumptions of the interaction potential in the low energy study of dilute Bose gases

arXiv:2607.00859 · math-ph, math.MP · Submitted 2026-07-01 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematical Physics. The day in mathematical physics: rigorous models of physical systems.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "On the spherical symmetry and finite-range assumptions of the interaction potential in the low energy study of dilute Bose gases".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We consider a Bose gas on the three-dimensional torus in the Gross–Pitaevskii regime and explain how to remove the assumptions of radiality and compact support on the interaction potential in the proof of Bose–Einstein condensation and convergence of the excitation spectrum to Bogoliubov’s prediction.

Kai: Theoretical Background The rigorous study of interacting Bose gases remains an active area of research both in mathematics and in physics.

Mira: Bogoliubov introduced his theory for interacting Bose gases

9: , which allowed him to compute the low-lying excitation spectrum of the system and to justify Landau’s criterion for superfluidity

39: .

Kai: The low-density Bose gas has been famously described by Lee, Huang, and Yang

41: and Wu

63: , who proposed a low-density expansion for its ground state energy e(ρ) = 4πaρ squared / (1 + 1/128√π q ρa cubed + 8/4π − √3 ρa cubed log(ρa 3) + O(ρa 3)).

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper now titled "On the spherical symmetry and finite-range assumptions of the interaction potential in the low energy study of dilute Bose gases". It sounds like it’s really digging into why we usually assume things about the shape of these potentials.

Mira: Yeah, it’s about how we remove those assumptions—specifically radiality and compact support—when proving two big things: Bose-Einstein condensation and that the low energy spectrum converges to Bogoliubov's prediction.

Lev: So, basically, they are taking a system where you usually assume the interaction is perfectly round and only happens over a small area, and they are showing how to handle potentials that aren't like that.

Kai: It suggests that this universal behavior—the way the ground state energy depends on the scattering length—should hold even when we use more realistic interactions.

Mira: That’s what they aim for, but they start by setting up the problem on a three-dimensional torus in the Gross-Pitaevskii regime.

Lev: It’s about making sure that whatever you're measuring, whether it's condensation or just how excited particles move, it gives you the same answer regardless of whether the potential is perfectly spherical or not.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, what they actually do in this paper is explain *how* to take those assumptions away when proving Bose-Einstein condensation and the convergence of the excitation spectrum to Bogoliubov’s prediction.

Mira: They tackle the problem by relaxing previous assumptions about radiality and compact support on the interaction potential.

Lev: The authors relax these to a more realistic scenario: potentials that are even, but they don't have compact support, meaning they decay sufficiently fast in this Gross-Pitaevskii regime.

Kai: To do this, the method involves approximating the interaction potential by something that *is* compactly supported and then using properties of the scattering solution for non-radial potentials.

Mira: They use some specific mathematical tools here to handle those non-radial potentials, like extending results from earlier work on minimizers in L1 spaces for non-radial, compactly supported potentials in L1.

Lev: They also introduce a modified version of omega with a cut off to manage the potential decay and they define new transforms called T one T c and T two for renormalization.

Kai: The main result they prove is that the ground state energy and the low-energy excitation spectrum are determined only by the scattering length of the interaction potential up to an error that vanishes as N goes to infinity.

The paper's improvements: Mira: So, what they suggest is a significant improvement over previous work. They show that for a large class of interaction potentials, the ground state energy and the low-energy excitation spectrum are determined only by the scattering length up to an error that vanishes in the limit N goes to infinity.

Kai: That’s strong because it means we don't need to know the exact detailed shape of the potential, like whether it’s perfectly spherical, just to get a good estimate for these low-energy properties.

Lev: And they show this universal behavior persists even in the third-order correction, which suggests that the error term in its expansion is actually of order log N over N as predicted by other related work.

Mira: They establish the convergence of the excitation spectrum to Bogoliubov’s prediction using these techniques, which was a key missing piece for many non-radial systems.

Kai: This really expands what we can model, because it means this result applies to a much wider class of interactions than just simple, perfectly symmetric ones.

Conclusion: Mira: So to wrap up the "On the spherical symmetry and finite-range assumptions of the interaction potential in the low energy study of dilute Bose gases", they conclude that even when you remove those assumptions about radiality and compact support, you still get this universal behavior.

Kai: They state that the ground state energy and excitation spectrum are determined only by the scattering length up to an error that goes to zero as N goes to infinity for a large class of potentials.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, this means we can trust these low-energy predictions even when the underlying physics is more complex than what we usually build our models on.

Mira: It’s about proving that the convergence of the excitation spectrum to Bogoliubov's prediction holds for a broader range of interaction potentials than before.

Kai: So, this paper gives us confidence that this universal behavior of the ground state energy persists in higher-order corrections too.

Lev: I think what they show is how we can make these rigorous bounds work on real hardware setups that aren't perfectly idealized models.

Mira: It’s a lot of machinery to get there, but it validates the physical intuition that the scattering length is the main thing that matters for low energy physics in this regime.

Kai: We’re looking forward to seeing how this helps us model those dipolar gases we mentioned earlier.

Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg · LMU Munich

math-ph, math.MP

Submitted: 2026-07-01

Updated: 2026-09-17

Comments: 30 pages

DOI: 10.1142/S0129055X26610040

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 86/100

The gist: We consider a Bose gas on the three-dimensional torus in the Gross–Pitaevskii regime and explain how to remove the assumptions of radiality and compact support on the interaction potential in the…

Key concepts

Gross–Pitaevskii regime
This refers to a specific physical regime for dilute Bose gases where interactions are weak. In this regime, the system's behavior can be accurately described by mean-field theory, allowing physicists to use simplified models like the Gross–Pitaevskii equation to study collective phenomena such as condensation.
Scattering length (a)
This parameter characterizes the strength of the interaction between two particles in a dilute Bose gas. The paper shows that for large systems, the ground state energy and excitation spectrum are determined solely by this scattering length, regardless of the detailed shape or radial symmetry of the interaction potential.
Bogoliubov prediction
This is a theoretical prediction for the low-energy excitation spectrum of interacting Bose gases. Bogoliubov's theory provides a benchmark against which the actual system's spectrum is compared. The paper proves that for this specific gas, its excitation spectrum converges to Bogoliubov's prediction as the system size increases.
Non-radial potentials
The paper addresses interaction potentials that do not possess radial symmetry or compact support. By relaxing the standard assumption of radial symmetry, the authors demonstrate that rigorous proofs for BEC and spectral convergence can still be achieved, making the results applicable to more complex physical systems.

Terminology

Summary

We consider a Bose gas on the three-dimensional torus in the Gross–Pitaevskii regime and explain how to remove the assumptions of radiality and compact support on the interaction potential in the proof of Bose–Einstein condensation and convergence of the excitation spectrum to Bogoliubov’s prediction. p. 0

Theoretical Background

The rigorous study of interacting Bose gases remains an active area of research both in mathematics and in physics. Bogoliubov introduced his theory for interacting Bose gases [9], which allowed him to compute the low-lying excitation spectrum of the system and to justify Landau’s criterion for superfluidity [39]. p. 0 The low-density Bose gas has been famously described by Lee, Huang, and Yang [41] and Wu [63], who proposed a low-density expansion for its ground state energy e(ρ) = 4πaρ squared / (1 + 1/128√π q ρa cubed + 8/4π − √3 ρa cubed log(ρa 3) + O(ρa 3)). p. 0 This expansion only depends on the interaction potential through its scattering length a, and not on the detailed shape of the potential, such as its radial symmetry or finite range. p. 1

Relaxing Assumptions

The proof of Bose–Einstein condensation and convergence of the excitation spectrum to Bogoliubov’s prediction requires removing assumptions about radiality and compact support on the interaction potential. The authors relax previous assumptions to the more physically realistic case of even potentials without compact support that decay sufficiently fast in the Gross–Pitaevskii regime. p. 3 The proof requires approximating the interaction potential by a compactly supported potential and using properties of the scattering solution for non-radial potentials. p. 4

Mathematical Tools

The proof involves several key mathematical steps to handle non-radial potentials. These steps include extending results from [51] on properties of the minimizer for the variational problem (3) for non-radial, compactly supported potentials in L1 to non-radial, compactly supported potentials in L1. p. 7 The authors also use a modified version of ω with a cut-off to handle the potential decay and define new transforms like T1, Tc, and T2 for renormalization. p. 7

Main Results

Theorem 2.2 states that the ground state energy and the low-energy excitation spectrum are determined only by the scattering length of the interaction potential up to an error that vanishes in the limit N → ∞. p. 6 Specifically, for a large class of interaction potentials, the ground state energy and the low-energy excitation spectrum are determined only by the scattering length of the interaction potential up to an error that vanishes in the limit N → ∞. p. 6 Furthermore, for every normalized sequence of approximate ground states ΨN satisfying ⟨ΨN, HN ΨN ⟩ = λ1(HN) + o(N) we have lim N→∞ ⟨u0, γΨN u0⟩ N = 1. p. 5 Finally, the lowest eigenvalue of the excitation Hamiltonian HeN satisfies λL(HeN) = λL(dΓ(EBog)) + O(N −κΘ(1−ϑ)). p. 7

Conclusion

The paper concludes that the ground state energy and the low-energy excitation spectrum are determined only by the scattering length of the interaction potential up to an error that vanishes in the limit N → ∞. This universal behavior of the ground state energy persists in the third-order correction, suggesting that the error term in its expansion is actually of order O(log(N)/N) as predicted by [36, 56, 63]. p. 6 The proof establishes the convergence of the excitation spectrum to Bogoliubov’s prediction. p. 0

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI system can rigorously derive bounds on ground state energy for a wide class of non-radial, non-compactly supported potentials by extending existing Dyson lemmas to these settings. This allows the system to predict universal behavior in terms of scattering length even when radial symmetry is not assumed from the start.

  2. Improved AI system can analyze low-energy excitation spectra by deriving precise formulas for the spectrum of HN minus its ground state energy, relating it directly to Bogoliubov's prediction with controllable error terms. This enables accurate calculation of spectral properties in regimes beyond the standard Gross-Pitaevskii approximation.

  3. Improved AI system can rigorously justify Bose-Einstein condensation for a large class of interaction potentials by proving the matching upper bound using trial states and localization arguments instead of relying solely on radial symmetry assumptions from prior BEC proofs. This expands applicability to systems with complex, non-radial interactions like dipolar gases without requiring the derivation of a new Gross-Pitaevskii functional.

  4. Improved AI system can determine optimal Bose-Einstein condensation by analyzing the eigenvalue distribution of the excitation Hamiltonian, providing a clear criterion for when and how condensation occurs based on parameters derived from the potential's decay rate. This allows for predictive modeling of condensation phenomena in dilute Bose gases across different interaction regimes.

Sources

Related papers