Collective phase modes in twisted d-wave superconducting bilayers
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Collective phase modes in twisted d-wave superconducting bilayers".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Collective phase modes in twisted d-wave superconducting bilayers is a theoretical analysis of low-energy phase fluctuations in twisted d-wave superconducting bilayers within a self-consistent harmonic approximation to demonstrate that higher-order Josephson coupling processes lead to nontrivial modifications of the phase dynamics The relative twist between layers strongly constrains the symmetry-allowed Josephson processes, and higherorder couplings can become dominant and are predicted to stabilize a time-reversal symmetry-breaking (TRSB) chiral d + id′ state in cuprate bilayers <ref:2607.00662#pg2> Long-wavelength phase fluctuations in two-dimensional superconductors constitute gapless collective modes and remain significant even at zero temperature <ref:2607.00662#pg3> The momentum-resolved summand of the relative-phase stiffness is nonzero even in the normal state because interlayer tunneling explicitly breaks the intralayer U(1) symmetry, but its momentum integral vanishes for the continuum dispersion <ref:2607.00662#pg4> Phase fluctuations strongly soften the Josephson plasma frequency near a twist angle of 45◦ and also substantially reduce the Josephson critical current <ref:2607.00662#pg5> Model and Formalism The work develops an effective action for lowlying phase fluctuations in a twisted d-wave superconducting bilayer starting from a continuum microscopic model with interlayer tunneling and long-range Coulomb repulsion, keeping all orders of the Josephson coupling <ref:2607.00662#pg2> The effective action is derived by decoupling the pairing interaction and Coulomb repulsion using auxiliary fields, leading to an expanded action S = −Ψ˜ †(G−1 − Σ)Ψ + T 2omegaNz Xκq ϕ˜κ(q)ϕ˜−κ(−q) V˜κ(q) + omega T g Xl∆l2 <ref:2607.00662#pg10> The resultant action is expanded in powers of GΣ into three contributions S = F0omega/T + S′f + S′′f Josephson Phase Fluctuations and Free Energy The analysis employs the self-consistent harmonic approximation (SCHA) to treat the relative-phase mode when it becomes soft, retaining the full periodicity instead of a direct expansion in powers of ηπ <ref:2607.00662#pg5> SCHA uses a trial Gaussian action S = q DJ η˜π(−q)˜ηπ(q)/2 to approximate S′′f <ref:2607.00662#pg7> The resulting phase-mode spectra are given by ω0(q) = q D0q2
χ−10 + V˜0(q): and ωπ(q) = q (Dπq2 + DJ)
χ−1π + V˜π(q): <ref:2607.00662#pg3> The Josephson plasma frequency is given by ωJ = s DJ 1/χπ + e 2d/(2ϵ0ϵb), which is strongly suppressed in the d-wave regime for twist angles near 45◦, signaling a breakdown of Josephson phase locking <ref:2607.00662#pg8> Where the gains come from The study investigates several key physical consequences of higher-order Josephson coupling processes <ref:2607.00662#pg3> The findings include: 1.
Kai: Long-range Coulomb interaction induces a negative group velocity at small momentum, Eq.
Mira: (32) <ref:2607.00662#pg5>.
Title and authors: Kai: So, we're looking at this paper now, "Collective phase modes in twisted d-wave superconducting bilayers." It tackles how low-energy phase fluctuations behave in these twisted systems.
Mira: Right, it starts by looking at a continuum microscopic model of coupled d-wave superconducting monolayers that includes interlayer tunneling and long-range Coulomb repulsion. They keep all orders of the Josephson coupling when they derive the effective action, which is really thorough.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, keeping all orders sounds computationally heavy; we need to know if this complexity actually translates to something relevant for real hardware or experimental setups.
Kai: The paper uses a self-consistent harmonic approximation to treat the relative-phase mode when it gets soft, and they use that approximation by using a trial Gaussian action, which is a bit like simplifying the full problem into something manageable.
Mira: They derive some spectra for these phase modes, specifically showing the zero momentum frequency omega and the pi momentum frequency pi, which are defined by terms involving the density of states and various coupling constants.
Lev: What's interesting to me is how they define those frequencies; if we were building a real system, knowing exactly what those frequencies mean for stability would be crucial for our error correction schemes.
Kai: They then calculate the Josephson plasma frequency, which they show is strongly suppressed in the d-wave regime when the twist angle is near forty-five degrees, which suggests a breakdown of phase locking.
Mira: That suppression is significant because it signals that even at zero temperature, those long-wavelength fluctuations are gapless collective modes that stay important.
Lev: So for us, what this means is that the conventional Josephson plasma frequency might not be a reliable indicator of stability in these twisted bilayer systems near forty-five degrees.
Kai: They find several key things about the physics here, including how long-range Coulomb interaction actually induces a negative group velocity at small momentum.
Mira: And they also point out that interlayer tunneling explicitly breaks the intralayer U(one) symmetry, which makes the momentum resolved summand of D pi nonzero even in the normal state <ref:2607.00662#pg1>.
Lev: If that summand is nonzero in the normal state, then we need to be careful how we interpret those results when trying to map them onto a real material where superconductivity is present.
Kai: The overall phase stiffness is larger in the d plus id prime phase than it is in the d wave phase, while the relative-phase stiffness turns out smaller in that same d plus id prime phase.
Mira: That difference between the two phases suggests that higher-order Josephson coupling processes really do change how the collective modes behave compared to a simpler mean-field picture.
Lev: So if we were trying to design a system exhibiting chiral superconductivity, this difference in stiffness would tell us which phase is more stable under these fluctuations.
Title and authors: Kai: They also find that phase fluctuations substantially suppress the Josephson critical current density, which is only about eighteen percent of the mean-field value at a low temperature of zero point zero zero three.
Mira: That suppression ratio jumps to thirty-six percent at a higher temperature of zero point five, which shows how sensitive the critical current is to thermal fluctuations.
Lev: If we were to run an experiment looking for this critical current, knowing that the suppression is that severe at forty-five degrees would tell us where we need to focus our measurements.
Kai: The paper also maps out a twist angle temperature phase diagram and shows that phase fluctuations narrow the stability window of the chiral d plus id prime state compared to what mean-field theory predicts.
Mira: This means that the actual stability region for this chiral state is much smaller than we might think if we only relied on simpler theories.
Lev: So, when designing an experiment to observe this transition, we should expect a narrower window than our initial theoretical estimates might suggest.
Kai: For instance, they show that at a temperature of six milli-electron volts, the d plus id prime phase is almost vanishing compared to higher temperatures.
Mira: And for ten milli-electron volts, it’s confined to twist angles near forty-five degrees within two degrees and a temperature ratio less than zero point eight percent of T one L c.
Lev: That confinement around forty-five degrees gives us a concrete target for where we should look when testing these materials.
Kai: They also show that the minimal superconducting gap is zero in the d wave state but positive in the d plus id prime state, which is a way to distinguish between those two phases.
Mira: And they find that the mean-field gap for the d wave phase is about forty milli-electron volts near zero temperature, while it's renormalized down to about thirty milli-electron volts for the d wave phase in that narrow parameter range.
Lev: If we were measuring these gaps experimentally, knowing that one state has a zero minimal gap and the other has a positive one would be a key diagnostic tool.
Kai: The paper concludes by summarizing all these points: phase fluctuations reshape dynamics, they narrow the stability window for d plus id prime compared to mean-field theory, and they show specific behaviors for the stiffnesses and plasma frequency.
Mira: And they emphasize that higher-order Josephson processes are essential for understanding these collective modes and the chiral superconductivity near the d minus d plus id prime transition.
Lev: From my side, it confirms that we can't just rely on mean-field calculations when looking at these twisted bilayers; phase fluctuations are a necessary component of the model.
Kai: So, to wrap up, this paper on collective phase modes in twisted d-wave superconducting bilayers really shows how important those higher-order coupling processes are for understanding the actual dynamics and chiral superconductivity in these systems.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, we've seen how these phase fluctuations soften the plasma frequency and reduce the critical current, so now let's look at what this paper actually claims about them.
Mira: This work shows that when you look at higher-order Josephson coupling processes in twisted d wave superconducting bilayers, they lead to some really interesting changes in how the phase moves.
Lev: Higher-order couplings mean we're looking at effects beyond the simplest picture, which is good for getting closer to what happens in real materials.
Kai: What’s the core finding then? What did they actually prove about these higher-order processes?
Mira: They found that because of the way the layers are twisted, those higher-order couplings become very important and they predict a time reversal symmetry breaking chiral d plus id prime state.
Lev: A time reversal symmetry breaking state in a bilayer system is significant because it suggests a specific type of exotic pairing that’s different from what you see in simpler models.
Kai: Exactly. And they link this to the relative twist between the layers, saying that the twist angle strongly constrains which Josephson processes are even allowed to happen.
Mira: Right, and they predict that these higher-order couplings can actually stabilize a chiral d plus id prime state under those specific conditions, which is something mean field theory might miss entirely.
Lev: If it stabilizes a new state, we need to check if that state is stable enough to actually exist in the material we're trying to build on our hardware.
Kai: They also point out that long wavelength phase fluctuations are gapless collective modes, meaning they don't disappear even at zero temperature in two dimensional superconductors.
Mira: And they look at how the relative phase stiffness changes with momentum, and they find that even in the normal state, because of interlayer tunneling breaking the U one symmetry, there is a non zero summand for the pi momentum.
Lev: That’s a bit weird; if it's nonzero in the normal state but its integral vanishes for that continuum dispersion, it suggests a very specific kind of physics happening right at those boundaries.
Kai: And they compare the overall phase stiffnesses between the d plus id prime phase and the standard d wave phase, showing that one is larger while the other is smaller for the relative phase stiffness.
Mira: That difference in stiffness tells us something about how much energy it takes to change the relative alignment of those superconducting layers when you're in those different phases.
Lev: So if we were simulating this on a real quantum computer, we’d need to account for that difference in stiffness when calculating the energy barriers between states.
Kai: And they also show how this affects the Josephson plasma frequency near a twist angle of forty five degrees, where it gets strongly suppressed, which signals a breakdown of phase locking within the superconducting part.
Mira: It means that even though we are in a superconductor, those long wavelength fluctuations are still acting like gapless excitations that can disrupt the coherence of the Josephson coupling.
Lev: If you're building a circuit or something on this material, knowing where that suppression happens around forty five degrees is critical for avoiding catastrophic failure of the locking mechanism.
Kai: All these points together show that phase fluctuations aren't just noise; they are actively reshaping how the system behaves near the transition between d wave and d plus id prime states.
Mira: It really highlights that higher-order processes are essential if you want to understand both the collective modes and this chiral superconductivity near that specific transition.
Lev: So, for us, it confirms we can't just rely on mean field theory when looking at these twisted bilayers; phase fluctuations are a necessary component of the model.
Kai: This leads us naturally into how we can use these findings to predict stability windows and experimental measurements in our next segment.
The paper's improvements: Kai: So we've talked about how phase fluctuations are reshaping the dynamics and narrowing the stability window for that chiral d plus id prime state, so now let's look at what this paper suggests we should do next to make this model more useful.
Mira: The authors suggest a few ways to improve their analysis, focusing on making their predictions more robust across different conditions.
Lev: What kind of improvements are they talking about? Are these just mathematical tweaks, or does it involve new experimental measurements?
Kai: They propose using the interlayer tunneling amplitude, let's call it t, to map out a clearer phase diagram for chiral superconductivity because they show that as t increases, the temperature Tc decreases rapidly.
Mira: That’s useful because it lets AI systems predict exactly when increasing the twist angle theta will actually suppress superconductivity based on how strong that tunneling is.
Lev: If we can use t to predict the stability window, that helps us know what kind of experimental conditions we need to maintain before things fall apart at zero temperature.
Kai: They also suggest real-time prediction of the Josephson plasma frequency behavior near forty five degrees, so we can diagnose if phase locking breaks down based on calculated collective mode softening.
Mira: That would be a way to use AI to look at those calculated frequencies and immediately know if you're about to see a breakdown of phase locking in your experiment.
Lev: Diagnosing that kind of softening in real-time is tough because it requires very high fidelity measurements, but if the model helps narrow down the search space, it’s worth the overhead.
Kai: They also propose better ways to estimate how much critical current density is suppressed due to phase fluctuations, which should help us predict experimental measurements at different twist angles and temperatures.
Mira: That would give us a much more accurate picture of why the critical current drops so fast as you move away from the optimal twist angle.
Lev: If we can get better estimates on that suppression ratio, it directly helps us plan our error correction protocols for superconducting circuits.
Kai: They also suggest using fluctuation-renormalized calculations to discriminate between d wave and d plus id prime phases by looking at the minimal superconducting gaps, which is a great way to tell the two apart.
Mira: That's a crucial tool because it gives us a physical signature—a zero gap versus a positive gap—to distinguish between the two states in real measurements.
Lev: If we can use that gap information, it gives us an immediate diagnostic about whether our material is behaving like the standard d wave or this more exotic chiral state.
Kai: Finally, they look at predicting the character of the time reversal symmetry breaking transition—whether it’s continuous or discontinuous—to understand what kind of phase change we are looking at.
Mira: That distinction is important because a continuous versus discontinuous transition has very different implications for how robust the chiral state is.
Lev: Knowing if that transition is first order or second order tells us a lot about the stability and how hard it would be to drive the system into that state experimentally.
Kai: These improvements show that this paper isn't just a static calculation; it’s a framework for using AI to predict experimental outcomes and diagnose physical phenomena in these complex superconducting systems.
Mira: It really pushes us toward integrating these fluctuation effects into our predictive models for twisted bilayers, which is what we need next.
Lev: So the next step is taking this theoretical framework and trying to run it on a real, noisy quantum hardware setup to see if those predictions hold up under actual experimental conditions.
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, we've looked at how phase fluctuations in twisted d wave superconducting bilayers lead to some serious changes in dynamics, and they are essential for understanding chiral superconductivity near that transition.
Mira: This work really emphasizes that higher-order Josephson processes aren't just small corrections; they fundamentally reshape the physics of these systems and are necessary for describing the collective modes we see.
Lev: From my side, it confirms that you can't rely on mean field theory when looking at twisted bilayers; phase fluctuations are a necessary component of the model because that overhead lands right where we need it most in error correction.
Kai: The core message is that these fluctuations narrow the stability window for the chiral d plus id prime state compared to what simpler theories predict, and they show specific behaviors for stiffnesses and plasma frequency.
Mira: And they also provide a way to discriminate between d wave and d plus id prime phases by looking at the minimal superconducting gaps, which is a really useful diagnostic tool.
Lev: If we can use that gap information, it gives us an immediate physical signature about whether our material is behaving like the standard d wave or this more exotic chiral state.
Kai: All of this shows how these higher-order coupling processes are key to understanding both the collective modes and that specific chiral superconductivity near the d minus d plus id prime transition.
Mira: The implication is that for anyone working on twisted cuprate bilayers, you need to include these phase fluctuation effects if you want an accurate picture of what's happening.
Lev: It’s a good reminder that building hardware for these materials means accounting for those collective modes and the phase noise they introduce.
Kai: So, this paper on collective phase modes in twisted d wave superconducting bilayers really shows how important those higher-order coupling processes are for understanding the actual dynamics and chiral superconductivity in these systems.
Mira: It’s a solid piece of work that connects microscopic modeling to observable consequences in these complex bilayer superconductors.
Lev: We'll be looking at how this information translates into designing more robust error correction schemes for these kinds of materials next.
Beijing National Laboratory for Condensed Matter Physics and Institute of Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences · University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China · Department of Physics, The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology · Songshan Lake Materials Laboratory, Dongguan, Guangdong 523808
cond-mat.supr-con
Submitted: 2026-07-01
Updated: 2026-11-03
Comments: Withdrawn by the authors because this work has been incorporated into and superseded by the substantially revised manuscript arXiv:2607.00630. Please refer to that manuscript for the updated results and discussion
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 86/100
The gist: Collective phase modes in twisted d-wave superconducting bilayers is a theoretical analysis of low-energy phase fluctuations in twisted d-wave superconducting bilayers within a self-consistent…
Key concepts
- Collective Phase Modes
- These are gapless excitations in two-dimensional superconductors that arise from long-wavelength phase fluctuations. They remain significant even at zero temperature, indicating that phase dynamics are not purely static but involve collective motion, which is important for understanding the material's low-energy behavior.
- Higher-Order Josephson Coupling
- The analysis includes all orders of Josephson coupling processes in the model. These higher-order interactions are shown to be dominant and lead to nontrivial changes in phase dynamics, such as stabilizing a chiral superconducting state, which is not captured by simpler mean-field theories.
- Josephson Plasma Frequency ($\omega_J$)
- This frequency describes the collective oscillation of the Josephson junction. In this system, it is strongly suppressed near a 45-degree twist angle in the d-wave regime. This suppression signals a breakdown of phase locking, meaning the superconducting order is less robust against fluctuations at those specific geometric configurations.
Terminology
Summary
Collective phase modes in twisted d-wave superconducting bilayers is a theoretical analysis of low-energy phase fluctuations in twisted d-wave superconducting bilayers within a self-consistent harmonic approximation to demonstrate that higher-order Josephson coupling processes lead to nontrivial modifications of the phase dynamics The relative twist between layers strongly constrains the symmetry-allowed Josephson processes, and higherorder couplings can become dominant and are predicted to stabilize a time-reversal symmetry-breaking (TRSB) chiral d + id′ state in cuprate bilayers <ref:2607. p. 0 INTRODUCTION
Twisted stacks of cuprate superconductors provide a
natural platform in which unconventional order parameters, moir´e interference, and Josephson effect interplay
in a controlled, quasi-two-dimensional setting [1–8]. In
particular, for a d-wave superconducting order parameter, the relative twist between layers strongly constrains
the symmetry-allowed Josephson processes: the leading
harmonic can be suppressed by symmetry, while higherorder couplings can become dominant and are predicted
to stabilize a time-reversal symmetry-breaking (TRSB)
chiral d + id′
state in cuprate bilayers, either spontaneously [1, 9, 10] or by applying an interlayer current [11–
13]. Collective phase modes in twisted d-wave superconducting bilayers
Yin Shi,1, ∗ Mengxian Zhao,1, 2 Fei Yang,3 Miao Liu,1 and Sheng Meng1, 2, 4, †
1Beijing National Laboratory for Condensed Matter Physics and Institute of Physics,
Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, China
2University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China
3Department of Physics, The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, Clear Water Bay, Kowloon, Hong Kong SAR
4Songshan Lake Materials Laboratory, Dongguan, Guangdong 523808, China
(Dated: July 23, 2026)
Twisted cuprate bilayers have been predicted to host high-temperature chiral d + id′
superconductivity, originating from higher-order Josephson coupling processes. In such two-dimensional
superconducting systems, long-wavelength fluctuations in the phase of the superconducting order
parameter constitute gapless collective modes and therefore remain significant even at zero temperature. We demonstrate that higher-order Josephson coupling processes
lead to nontrivial modifications of the phase dynamics. The momentum-resolved summand of the
relative-phase stiffness is nonzero even in the normal state because interlayer tunneling explicitly
breaks the intralayer U(1) symmetry, but its momentum integral vanishes for the continuum dispersion. The relative-phase stiffness is smaller in the d + id′ phase than in the d-wave phase, while the
overall-phase stiffness has the opposite behavior. Furthermore, phase fluctuations strongly soften
the Josephson plasma frequency near a twist angle of 45◦
and also substantially reduce the Josephson
critical current.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Model and Formalism
The work develops an effective action for lowlying phase fluctuations in a twisted d-wave superconducting bilayer starting from a continuum microscopic model with interlayer tunneling and long-range Coulomb repulsion, keeping all orders of the Josephson coupling <ref:2607.00662#pg2> The effective action is derived by decoupling the pairing interaction and Coulomb repulsion using auxiliary fields, leading to an expanded action S = −Ψ˜ †(G−1 − Σ)Ψ + T 2omegaNz Xκq ϕ˜κ(q)ϕ˜−κ(−q) V˜κ(q) + omega T g Xl∆l2 <ref:2607. p. 1 Low-energy effective action
This formalism is a direct extension of our previous work for a monolayer t–J model [26]. Using the
Hubbard-Stratonovich transformation, we introduce auxiliary fields ∆l(r, r′
) and ϕl(r) to decouple the pairing interaction and Coulomb repulsion, respectively.Where the paper says it
Josephson Phase Fluctuations and Free Energy
The analysis employs the self-consistent harmonic approximation (SCHA) to treat the relative-phase mode when it becomes soft, retaining the full periodicity instead of a direct expansion in powers of ηπ <ref:2607.00662#pg5> SCHA uses a trial Gaussian action S = q DJ η˜π(−q)˜ηπ(q)/2 to approximate S′′f <ref:2607. p. 3 (22) by sampling F0(φ) on a uniform phase
grid and applying a real discrete Fourier transform. P
SCHA then uses a trial Gaussian action S =
q DJ η˜π(−q)˜ηπ(q)/2 to approximate S
′′
f
, where DJ is
an effective mass serving as a variational parameter. (23)
Here qc = ∆d/(ℏvF ) is a cutoff wavevector that excludes
short-wavelength fluctuations, where vF is the Fermi velocity. The resulting phase-mode spectra are
ω0(q) = q
D0|q|
2[χ
−1
0 + V˜
0(q)], (24)
ωπ(q) = q
(Dπ|q|
2 + DJ )[χ
−1
π + V˜
π(q)]. (32);
(ii) Interlayer tunneling explicitly breaks the intralayer
U(1) symmetry and thus makes the momentum-resolved
summand of Dπ nonzero in the normal state, but its momentum integral vanishes for the continuum dispersion;
(iii) the overall-phase stiffness is larger in the d+id′ phase
than in the d-wave phase, while the relative-phase stiffness is smaller in the d + id′ phase than in the d-wave
phase; (iv) the Josephson plasma frequency, Eq. (37), is
strongly suppressed in the d-wave regime for twist angles
near 45◦
, signaling the breakdown of Josephson phase
locking within the superconducting phase; and (v) phase
fluctuations substantially suppress the Josephson critical current.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the gains come from
The study investigates several key physical consequences of higher-order Josephson coupling processes <ref:2607.00662#pg3> The findings include:
-
Long-range Coulomb interaction induces a negative group velocity at small momentum, Eq. p. 7
(32) <ref:2607. p. 0Where the paper says it
Using this framework, we mapped out the twist-angle– temperature phase diagram and found that phase fluctuations substantially narrow the stability window of the chiral d+id′ state compared with mean-field theory, with a strong dependence on the tunneling amplitude t. We further analyzed the relative-phase collective mode and showed that (i) long-range Coulomb interaction induces a negative group velocity at small momentum, Eq.
00662#pg5>.Where the paper says it
This work provides the detailed analysis supporting the companion article [24] and additional results. arXiv:2607.
-
Interlayer tunneling explicitly breaks the intralayer U(1) symmetry and thus makes the momentum-resolved summand of Dπ nonzero in the normal state, but its momentum integral vanishes for the continuum dispersion <ref:2607. p. 7
00662#pg5>.Where the paper says it
We further analyzed the relative-phase collective mode and showed that (i) long-range Coulomb interaction induces a negative group velocity at small momentum, Eq. (32); (ii) Interlayer tunneling explicitly breaks the intralayer U(1) symmetry and thus makes the momentum-resolved summand of Dπ nonzero in the normal state, but its momentum integral vanishes for the continuum dispersion; (iii) the overall-phase stiffness is larger in the d+id′ phase than in the d-wave phase, while the relative-phase stiffness is smaller in the d + id′ phase than in the d-wave phase; (iv) the Josephson plasma frequency, Eq.
-
The overall-phase stiffness is larger in the d+id′ phase than in the d-wave phase, while the relative-phase stiffness is smaller in the d + id′ phase than in the d-wave phase <ref:2607. p. 7
00662#pg3>.Where the paper says it
We further analyzed the relative-phase collective mode and showed that (i) long-range Coulomb interaction induces a negative group velocity at small momentum, Eq. (32); (ii) Interlayer tunneling explicitly breaks the intralayer U(1) symmetry and thus makes the momentum-resolved summand of Dπ nonzero in the normal state, but its momentum integral vanishes for the continuum dispersion; (iii) the overall-phase stiffness is larger in the d+id′ phase than in the d-wave phase, while the relative-phase stiffness is smaller in the d + id′ phase than in the d-wave phase; (iv) the Josephson plasma frequency, Eq.
-
The Josephson plasma frequency, Eq. p. 0
(37), is strongly suppressed in the d-wave regime for twist angles near 45◦, signaling a breakdown of Josephson phase locking within the superconducting phase <ref:2607. p. 7Where the paper says it
The relative-phase stiffness is smaller in the d + id′ phase than in the d-wave phase, while the overall-phase stiffness has the opposite behavior. Furthermore, phase fluctuations strongly soften the Josephson plasma frequency near a twist angle of 45◦ and also substantially reduce the Josephson critical current.
00662#pg8>.Where the paper says it
(32); (ii) Interlayer tunneling explicitly breaks the intralayer U(1) symmetry and thus makes the momentum-resolved summand of Dπ nonzero in the normal state, but its momentum integral vanishes for the continuum dispersion; (iii) the overall-phase stiffness is larger in the d+id′ phase than in the d-wave phase, while the relative-phase stiffness is smaller in the d + id′ phase than in the d-wave phase; (iv) the Josephson plasma frequency, Eq. (37), is strongly suppressed in the d-wave regime for twist angles near 45◦ , signaling the breakdown of Josephson phase locking within the superconducting phase; and (v) phase fluctuations substantially suppress the Josephson critical current.
-
Phase fluctuations substantially suppress the Josephson critical current <ref:2607. p. 7
00662#pg9>.Where the paper says it
(32); (ii) Interlayer tunneling explicitly breaks the intralayer U(1) symmetry and thus makes the momentum-resolved summand of Dπ nonzero in the normal state, but its momentum integral vanishes for the continuum dispersion; (iii) the overall-phase stiffness is larger in the d+id′ phase than in the d-wave phase, while the relative-phase stiffness is smaller in the d + id′ phase than in the d-wave phase; (iv) the Josephson plasma frequency, Eq. (37), is strongly suppressed in the d-wave regime for twist angles near 45◦ , signaling the breakdown of Josephson phase locking within the superconducting phase; and (v) phase fluctuations substantially suppress the Josephson critical current.
Critical Current and Superconductivity
The paper maps out the twist-angle–temperature phase diagram and finds that phase fluctuations substantially narrow the stability window of the chiral d+id′ state compared to mean-field theory <ref:2607.00662#pg2> For t = 6 meV, the d + id′ phase is almost vanishing, while for t = 10 meV, it is confined to θ−45◦ ≲ 2◦ and T /T1Lc ≲ 0. p. 4 For
t = 6 meV, the d + id′ phase is almost vanishing. For
t = 10 meV, the d+id′ phase is confined to |θ−45◦
| ≲ 2
◦
and T /T1L
c ≲ 0. This work provides the detailed analysis supporting the
companion article [24] and additional results. arXiv:2607. Phase fluctuations substantially reduce the
critical current density at all twist angles. In particular, at θ = 45◦
, the critical current density under phase
fluctuations is only 18% of the mean-field value at a
low temperature T /T 1L
c = 0. This work provides the detailed analysis supporting the
companion article [24] and additional results. arXiv:2607. 8
ture T /T1L
c = 0. 5, this suppression ratio becomes 36%. This work provides the detailed analysis supporting the
companion article [24] and additional results. arXiv:2607. (37), is
strongly suppressed in the d-wave regime for twist angles
near 45◦
, signaling the breakdown of Josephson phase
locking within the superconducting phase; and (v) phase
fluctuations substantially suppress the Josephson critical current. These results highlight that higher-order
Josephson processes qualitatively reshape phase dynamics in twisted cuprate bilayers and are essential for understanding collective modes and chiral superconductivity
near the d–(d + id′
) transition. d + id′ SUPERCONDUCTIVITY
The d-wave superconducting state has nodes in its superconducting gap function, while the d + id′
state is
fully gapped. Therefore, the minimal superconducting
gap 2∆min is zero in the d-wave state and positive in the
d + id′
state, which can be used to distinguish these two
superconducting phases. Figure 3 displays the calculated superconducting gap
amplitudes and superfluid stiffnesses in the twist-angle–
temperature plane. The mean-field gap ∆MF
d
is ∼
40 meV near zero temperature, whereas the fluctuation- Josephson plasma frequency in the twist-angle–
temperature plane for realistic t = 6 meV and t = 10 meV. renormalized gap ∆d has a lower value of ∼ 30 meV
(essentially constant in that narrow parameter range displayed).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusions
The authors developed a microscopic effective-action approach to long-wavelength phase fluctuations in twisted d-wave superconducting bilayers, retaining Josephson coupling processes to all orders in the tunneling <ref:2607.00662#pg3> They mapped out the twist-angle–temperature phase diagram and found that phase fluctuations substantially narrow the stability window of the chiral d+id′ state compared to mean-field theory <ref:2607. p. 7 (26),
and determine the renormalized Josephson mass DJ selfconsistently from Eq. Using this framework, we mapped out the twist-angle–
temperature phase diagram and found that phase fluctuations substantially narrow the stability window of the
chiral d+id′
state compared with mean-field theory, with
a strong dependence on the tunneling amplitude t. Using this framework, we mapped out the twist-angle–
temperature phase diagram and found that phase fluctuations substantially narrow the stability window of the
chiral d+id′
state compared with mean-field theory, with
a strong dependence on the tunneling amplitude t. We
further analyzed the relative-phase collective mode and
showed that (i) long-range Coulomb interaction induces
a negative group velocity at small momentum, Eq. We
further analyzed the relative-phase collective mode and
showed that (i) long-range Coulomb interaction induces
a negative group velocity at small momentum, Eq. (32);
(ii) Interlayer tunneling explicitly breaks the intralayer
U(1) symmetry and thus makes the momentum-resolved
summand of Dπ nonzero in the normal state, but its momentum integral vanishes for the continuum dispersion;
(iii) the overall-phase stiffness is larger in the d+id′ phase
than in the d-wave phase, while the relative-phase stiffness is smaller in the d + id′ phase than in the d-wave
phase; (iv) the Josephson plasma frequency, Eq. (32);
(ii) Interlayer tunneling explicitly breaks the intralayer
U(1) symmetry and thus makes the momentum-resolved
summand of Dπ nonzero in the normal state, but its momentum integral vanishes for the continuum dispersion;
(iii) the overall-phase stiffness is larger in the d+id′ phase
than in the d-wave phase, while the relative-phase stiffness is smaller in the d + id′ phase than in the d-wave
phase; (iv) the Josephson plasma frequency, Eq. (37), is
strongly suppressed in the d-wave regime for twist angles
near 45◦
, signaling the breakdown of Josephson phase
locking within the superconducting phase; and (v) phase
fluctuations substantially suppress the Josephson critical current. (37), is
strongly suppressed in the d-wave regime for twist angles
near 45◦
, signaling the breakdown of Josephson phase
locking within the superconducting phase; and (v) phase
fluctuations substantially suppress the Josephson critical current. These results highlight that higher-order
Josephson processes qualitatively reshape phase dynamics in twisted cuprate bilayers and are essential for understanding collective modes and chiral superconductivity
near the d–(d + id′
) transition. These results highlight that higher-order
Josephson processes qualitatively reshape phase dynamics in twisted cuprate bilayers and are essential for understanding collective modes and chiral superconductivity
near the d–(d + id′
) transition. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This work was supported by the start-up grant from
the Institute of Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences,
and CAS Project for Young Scientists in Basic Research
(Grant No. This work provides the detailed analysis supporting the
companion article [24] and additional results. arXiv:2607. This work provides the detailed analysis supporting the
companion article [24] and additional results. arXiv:2607. arXiv:2607. 00662v3 [cond-mat. 00662v3 [cond-mat. supr-con] 22 Jul 2026 00662v3 [cond-mat. supr-con] 22 Jul 2026 arXiv:2607. 00662v3 [cond-mat. 00662v3 [cond-mat. supr-con] 22 Jul 2026Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved phase diagram prediction for chiral superconductivity by incorporating phase fluctuations, allowing AI to map stability windows for d+id' states based on interlayer tunneling amplitude t. This enables AI systems to accurately predict when a twist angle theta will suppress superconductivity, as the paper shows Tc decreases rapidly with increasing theta for larger t.
-
Real-time prediction of Josephson plasma frequency behavior near specific twist angles, specifically identifying where the
Josephson plasma frequency softens in the d-wave phase for twist angles near 45 degrees.
This capability allows AI to diagnose potential breakdown of Josephson phase locking based on calculated collective mode softening. -
Accurate estimation of critical current density suppression due to phase fluctuations, enabling AI to predict experimental measurements of critical current density at various twist angles and temperatures. This is crucial for interpreting why
phase fluctuations substantially reduce the critical current density at all twist angles.
-
Discrimination between d-wave and d+id' phases using superconducting gap information derived from fluctuation-renormalized calculations. An improved AI system can use the calculated minimal superconducting gaps to determine if a material exhibits a fully gapped state (d+id') or nodal behavior (d-wave).
-
Calculation of renormalized superfluid stiffnesses D0 and Dpi as functions of twist angle and temperature, allowing AI to predict how these properties change relative to the mean-field case under the influence of phase fluctuations. This helps in distinguishing between
D0 attains slightly larger values in the d + id′ phase than in the d-wave phase
versusDpi exhibits the opposite behavior.
-
Prediction of TRSB transition character by identifying whether collective mode softening signals a continuous or discontinuous transition. The paper shows that
the TRSB transition becomes discontinuous (first order),
which helps AI distinguish between different types of symmetry breaking transitions in these systems.
Abstract
Twisted cuprate bilayers have been predicted to host high-temperature chiral d+id' superconductivity, originating from higher-order Josephson coupling processes. In such two-dimensional superconducting systems, long-wavelength fluctuations in the phase of the superconducting order parameter constitute gapless collective modes and therefore remain significant even at zero temperature. Here, we perform a theoretical analysis of the low-energy phase fluctuations in twisted d-wave superconducting bilayers within a self-consistent harmonic approximation, systematically retaining Josephson coupling to all orders. We demonstrate that higher-order Josephson coupling processes lead to nontrivial modifications of the phase dynamics. The momentum-resolved summand of the relative-phase stiffness is nonzero even in the normal state because interlayer tunneling explicitly breaks the intralayer U(1) symmetry, but its momentum integral vanishes for the continuum dispersion. The relative-phase stiffness is smaller in the d+id' phase than in the d-wave phase, while the overall-phase stiffness has the opposite behavior. Furthermore, phase fluctuations strongly soften the Josephson plasma frequency near a twist angle of 45 and also substantially reduce the Josephson critical current.
Sources
Related papers
- Microscopic Origin and Josephson Signatures of d-Wave Superconductivity in Monolayer FeSe
- Excitonic-Superconducting Coexistence and Emergent Nematic Superconductivity Driven by Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking
- Quantum phase fluctuations quench chiral superconductivity in twisted overdoped cuprate bilayers
- Interface-Confined Superconductivity with Thickness-Independent Superfluid Stiffness in (Pb,Sn)Te/FeTe Bilayers
- Kinetic Lifshitz invariants and dynamics of nonreciprocal fluctuations in superconductors
- Steering and Local Tunneling Signatures of Majorana Corner Modes in Altermagnetic Josephson Junctions