Search for New Physics through the Observables of Semileptonic B c+ to D++- Decay
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Search for New Physics through the Observables of Semileptonic B c+ to D++- Decay".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Search for New Physics through the Observables of Semileptonic B+ c→ D∗+l+l− Decay is a model-independent study investigating how New Physics can be probed using rare semileptonic decays mediated by flavor changing neutral current b → d transition.
Kai: The decay serves as a complementary probe of the flavor structure of New Physics and can therefore be investigated in future measurements at LHCb and other high-luminosity flavor experiments.
Mira: Theoretical Framework The semileptonic B+ c→ D∗+l+l− decay receives contributions from the PB and WA topologies, along with long-distance resonance effects.
Kai: At the quark level, the decay is driven by b → dl+l− transition and its low energy effective Hamiltonian can be written as
43, 44: .
Title and authors: Kai: Let's look at who wrote this paper and what they're calling it. It’s "Search for New Physics through the Observables of Semileptonic B c+ to D++- Decay."
Mira: The authors are Zohaib Aarfi, Qazi Maaz Us Salam, Faisal Munir Bhutta, Ishtiaq Ahmed and M Ali Paracha. They come from different institutions in Pakistan and Lahore.
Lev: It’s good to see a collaboration across different settings since we're trying to figure out how these results would scale up on real hardware later on.
Kai: The main point they are making is that by studying this decay, we can constrain new physics contributions in the b to d transition.
Mira: Specifically, the paper focuses on how New Physics can show up through flavor changing neutral currents in this particular sector.
Lev: So what they're doing is taking these theoretical frameworks and checking them against actual experimental observables to see where the Standard Model predictions break down.
The paper's summary: Kai: Now, let's get into what the paper actually summarizes. It explains that this decay in the Standard Model is very rare, with a branching ratio of about O(ten to the power of negative eight) <ref:2606.30881#pg1>.
Mira: That small size is exactly why it makes it sensitive to new physics effects; anything new will show up as a deviation from those tiny Standard Model predictions.
Lev: The paper explains that this decay gets its main contribution from two topologies, the PB and WA, plus some long-distance resonance effects.
Kai: And at the quark level, they write down the effective Hamiltonian describing this as an interaction involving Wilson coefficients and local quark operators.
Mira: They then parameterize those hadronic matrix elements using Lorentz invariant form factors which come from models like the covariant confined quark model and the Bethe–Salpeter approach.
Lev: That’s where we need to be careful; those form factors are theoretical constructs, so it sets a foundation for what we expect to measure experimentally.
The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper suggests some improvements in how the analysis can be done. They say that using a set of four specific observables is key to doing a truly model-independent search for new physics.
Mira: They point out that combining the differential branching fraction, the forward-backward asymmetry, and the longitudinal helicity fraction helps to distinguish between different types of New Physics scenarios.
Lev: And they mention these angular coefficients like I2c, I3, I5, and I6s which show pronounced deviations from Standard Model predictions in some cases.
Kai: That's what’s important because it means we don't just look at one number; we look at the entire pattern of how all these observables behave together.
Mira: They also discuss correlations between the integrated branching fraction and those asymmetries, which helps constrain the allowed space for new physics Wilson coefficients.
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap this up, this paper on "Search for New Physics through the Observables of Semileptonic B c+ to D++- Decay" shows that these decays are rich probes.
Mira: The main implication is that by measuring things like the differential branching fraction and the lepton forward-backward asymmetry, we can constrain two-dimensional New Physics scenarios quite well.
Lev: And they conclude that combining those measurements with the longitudinal helicity fraction gives us a way to further narrow down the allowed parameter space for these new physics Wilson coefficients.
Kai: It's a strong call for future work at places like LHCb and other high-luminosity flavor experiments to really push these measurements.
Mira: Exactly, it’s about using this decay channel as a complementary probe of the flavor structure of physics beyond the Standard Model in the b to d sector.
Lev: For my side, it means that if we see these deviations in those angular coefficients like I2c across different q squared ranges, we might have a hint about which specific new physics model is responsible.
Department of Physics and Astronomy, National University of Sciences and Technology (NUST) · Department of Physics, Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS) · National Centre for Physics
hep-ph
Submitted: 2026-06-29
Updated: 2026-06-29
Comments: 21 pages, 10 figures, 4 tables
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 79/100
The gist: Search for New Physics through the Observables of Semileptonic B+ c→ D∗+l+l− Decay is a model-independent study investigating how New Physics can be probed using rare semileptonic decays…
Key concepts
- Semileptonic B+ c→ D∗+ℓ+ℓ− Decay
- This is a specific type of particle decay where a B meson decays into a D* meson, an electron or muon, and another lepton. It is studied because it can be affected by New Physics processes that involve flavor-changing neutral currents, providing sensitivity to new interactions in the b→d transition.
- PB and WA Topologies
- The decay process is described by two main theoretical frameworks: the PB (Penguin-Box) topology and the WA (Weak Annihilation) topology. These describe different ways quarks interact during the decay, and their combination significantly influences how observables like branching ratios change under New Physics scenarios.
- Normalized Angular Coefficients
- These are specific measurements derived from the decay kinematics that capture detailed information about the underlying physics. Coefficients like $\langle I_2c\rangle$, $\langle I_3\rangle$, etc., show how different amplitudes, including those from New Physics, interfere with each other.
- 1D vs 2D NP Scenarios
- The analysis tests different models of New Physics. A 1D scenario involves varying only one New Physics coupling (Wilson Coefficient), while a 2D scenario involves two couplings. The paper shows that the observables help distinguish between these scenarios, as the prediction ranges differ significantly.
Terminology
Summary
Search for New Physics through the Observables of Semileptonic B+ c→ D∗+l+l− Decay is a model-independent study investigating how New Physics can be probed using rare semileptonic decays mediated by flavor changing neutral current b → d transition. p. 0 The decay serves as a complementary probe of the flavor structure of New Physics and can therefore be investigated in future measurements at LHCb and other high-luminosity flavor experiments. p. 0
Theoretical Framework
The semileptonic B+ c→ D∗+l+l− decay receives contributions from the PB and WA topologies, along with long-distance resonance effects. At the quark level, the decay is driven by b → dl+l− transition and its low energy effective Hamiltonian can be written as [43, 44]. p. 2 The PB amplitude for the decay is described by terms involving Ceff9 and C'NP9, as well as T1,P Bµ and T2,P Bµ. The hadronic matrix elements appearing in Eqs. p. 2 (6) and (7) are parametrized in terms of Lorentz-invariant form factors. p. 2
Phenomenological Analysis
The analysis investigates the differential branching fraction dBr/dq2, the lepton forward-backward asymmetry AFB, the longitudinal helicity fraction fL, and a comprehensive set of normalized angular coefficients ⟨Ii⟩. The paper presents model-independent NP frameworks involving WCs CNP7, CNP9, CNP10, C'NP9, and C'NP10. The results show that the interplay between the PB and WA amplitudes can significantly modify the phenomenology of B+ c→ D∗+l+l− decay, particularly in the low-q2 muon range. p. 8
Sensitivity to Observables
The differential branching ratio dBr/dq2 and the FB asymmetry AFB exhibit a strong sensitivity to NP contributions in both the 1D and 2D NP scenarios. Furthermore, in the four-fold decay, several normalized angular observables, particularly ⟨I2c⟩, ⟨I3⟩, ⟨I5⟩, and ⟨I6s⟩ show pronounced deviations from their SM predictions and reveal valuable complementary information on the underlying NP structure. p. 0 The sensitivity of these observables arises from the NP-modified PB amplitudes and their interference with the WA contribution. p. 7
Conclusion
The analysis demonstrates that some observables show partially separated prediction ranges among the different NP scenarios, especially in the high-q2 τ range. The combined use of the branching fraction, AFB, and fL can help distinguish between different 2D NP scenarios and further constrain the allowed parameter space of the NP WCs. p. 6 The decay B+ c→ D∗+l+l− constitutes a phenomenologically rich and complementary probe of NP in the b → dl+l− sector. p. 0 The observables studied in this work should be explored at future LHCb upgrades and other high-luminosity experiments, providing valuable opportunities to reveal the flavor structure of physics beyond the SM. p. 0
TABLE III: Minimum and maximum values of the observables for the SM and 1D scenarios SI, SII, SIII and SIV. p. 6 Low-q2(µ) (0. p. 1083, 0.452) (0.077, 0.930) (0.046, 0.465) (S III Br × 1e9 Low-q2(µ) High-q2(µ) High-q2(τ) AFB Low-q2(µ) (S I Br × 1e9 SM SI SII SIII SIV (0. p. 6127, 0.145) (−0.077, 0.147)) High-q2(µ) (−0. p. 0240, −0.238) (−0.243, −0.197)) High-q2(τ) (−0. p. 0123, −0.118) (−0.178, −0.117)) fL Low-q2(µ) (S I Br × 1e9 SM SI SII SIII SIV (0. p. 6363, 0.543)) High-q2(τ) (S I Br × 1e9 SM SI SII SIII SIV (0. p. 7380, 0.389))
TABLE IV: Minimum and maximum values of the observables for the SM and 2D scenarios SV, SVI, SVII and SVIII. Low-q2(µ) (S V Br × 1e9 SM SV SVI SVII SVIII (0. p. 5 p. 5042, 1.417) (0.074, 1.232) (S III Br × 1e9 Low-q2(τ) (−0. p. 1300, 0.238) (−0.164, 0.286)) AFB Low-q2(µ) (S V Br × 1e9 SM SV SVI SVII SVIII (S I AF B(−0.300, 0.145)) High-q2(τ) (−0. p. 0147, 0.219)) fL Low-q2(µ) (S V Br × 1e9 SM SVI SVII SVIII (S III Br × 1e9 (0.358, 0.525)) High-q2(τ) (S V Br × 1e9 SM SVI SVII SVIII (0. p. 5324, 0.387))
FIG. 1: Predictions for the differential branching fraction dBr/dq2, the forward-backward asymmetry AFB, and the longitudinal helicity fraction fL of the decay B+ c→ D∗+l+l− in the SM and the 1D NP scenarios SI–SIV. p. 6 The first and second columns display these observables (from top to bottom) as functions of the dilepton invariant mass squared q2 for the low- and high-q2 ranges of the muon channel, respectively, whereas the third column shows the corresponding predictions for the high-q2 range of the tau channel
FIG. 5: Correlations between the integrated branching fraction and the observables ⟨AFB⟩ and ⟨fL⟩ in the 1D NP scenarios SI–SIV. p. 5 The left panels correspond to the low-q2 bin for muon channel, while the right panels show the high-q2 bin for tau channel
FIG. 9: Binned predictions for the observables of B+ c→ D∗+l+l− in the SM and the 2D NP scenarios SV–SVIII. p. 9 The panels display the low-q2 muon bin, high-q2 muon bin, and high-q2 tau bin
FIG. 10: Correlation plots between the integrated branching fraction and the observables ⟨AFB⟩ and ⟨fL⟩ for B+ c→ D∗+l+l− obtained from the allowed parameter space of the 2D NP scenarios SV–SVIII
TABLE IV: Minimum and maximum values of the observables for the SM and 2D scenarios SV, SVI, SVII and SVIII. Low-q2(µ) (S V Br × 1e9 SM SV SVI SVII SVIII (0.042, 1.417) (0.059, 0.957)) High-q2(τ) (−0. p. 0164, 0.286))
TABLE IV: Minimum and maximum values of the observables for the SM and 2D scenarios SV, SVI, SVII and SVIII. High-q2(µ) (S V Br × 1e9 SM SV SVI SVII SVIII (0. p. 5181, 0.686))
TABLE IV: Minimum and maximum values of the observables for the SM and 2D scenarios SV, SVI, SVII and SVIII. High-q2(τ) (S V Br × 1e9 SM SV SVI SVII SVIII (0. p. 5 p. 5 p. 5 p. 5 p. 5287, 0.413))
TABLE IV: Minimum and maximum values of the observables for the SM and 2D scenarios SV, SVI, SVII and SVIII. High-q2(τ) (S V Br × 1e9 SM SV SVI SVII SVIII (0.324, 0.387))
TABLE IV: Minimum and maximum values of the observables for the SM and 2D scenarios SV, SVI, SVII and SVIII. High-q2(τ) (S V Br × 1e9 SM SV SVI SVII SVIII (0.380, 0.413))
TABLE IV: Minimum and maximum values of the observables for the SM and 2D scenarios SV, SVI, SVII and SVIII. High-q2(τ) (S V Br × 1e9 SM SV SVI SVII SVIII (0.380, 0.413)
TABLE IV: Minimum and maximum values of the observables for the SM and 2D scenarios SV, SVI, SVII and SVIII. High-q2(τ) (S V Br × 1e9 SM SV SVI SVII SVIII (0.324, 0.387)
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI system can perform comprehensive model-independent sensitivity studies by systematically exploring New Physics scenarios using a set of four observables: differential branching fraction, lepton forward-backward asymmetry, longitudinal helicity fraction, and normalized angular coefficients such as I2c, I3, I5, and I6s.
-
Improved AI system can correlate these four observables across different kinematic ranges for both muon and tau final states to identify regions where NP effects are most pronounced or where discrimination between specific 1D and 2D NP scenarios is clearest.
-
Improved AI system can perform detailed parameter space mapping by generating correlation plots between the integrated branching fraction, AFB, and fL for both 1D and 2D NP scenarios to constrain the allowed Wilson Coefficients WCs.
-
Improved AI system can predict the expected behavior of specific angular coefficients like I2c in different NP scenarios across varying q squared ranges, highlighting their strong dependence on the interference between weak annihilation amplitudes and NP-modified short-distance contributions.
-
Improved AI system can perform scenario comparison by systematically analyzing how observables behave under 1D versus 2D New Physics scenarios, noting that the 2D scenarios generally produce wider prediction ranges due to the simultaneous variation of two NP WCs.
Sources
- Test of lepton universality in $b \rightarrow s \ell^+ \ell^-$ decays
- Measurement of $C\!P$-averaged observables in the $B^{0}\rightarrow K^{*0}\mu^{+}\mu^{-}$ decay
- Angular analysis of the rare decay $B_s^0\to\phi\mu^+\mu^-$
- Angular analysis of the $B^+\to\pi^+\mu^+\mu^-$ decay
- First measurement of the differential branching fraction and $C\!P$ asymmetry of the $B^\pm\to\pi^\pm\mu^+\mu^-$ decay
- A Search for the Rare Decays B --> pi l+l- and B0 --> eta l+l-
- Search for $B \to \pi \ell^+\ell^-$ Decays at Belle
- Search for Rare $b \to d\ell^+\ell^-$ Transitions at Belle
- Evidence for the decay $B_{s}^0 \rightarrow \overline{K}{}^{*0}\mu^+\mu^-$
- The Belle II Physics Book
- Testing Leptoquark and $Z^{\prime}$ Models via $B\to K_{1}(1270,1400)\mu^{+}\mu^{-}$ Decays
- Polarized forward-backward asymmetries of lepton pair in $B\rightarrow K_{1}\ell^{+}\ell^{-}$ decay in the presence of New physics
- New Physics in $b\to s\ell\ell$ anomalies and its implications for the complementary neutral current decays
- Angular observables of the four-fold $B \to K_{1}(1270,1400)(\to V P) \ell^{+}\ell^{-}$ decays in and beyond the Standard Model
- $B\to K^\ast_2(1430)\ell^+\ell^-$ distributions in Standard Model at large recoil
- Implications of light $Z'$ on semileptonic $B(B_{s}) \to T\{K_2^*(1430)$ $(f_2'(1525))\} \ell^+\ell^-$ decays at large recoil
- Angular analysis of $B_s\, \to\, f_{2}'\,(1525)\,(\to K^+\,K^-)\,\mu^+ \,\mu^-$ decays as a probe to lepton flavor universality violation
- First observation of the decay Bc+ to J/psi pi+pi-pi+
- Model independent analysis of New Physics effects on $B_c \to (D_s,\,D^{\ast}_s)\,\mu^+\mu^-$ decay observables
- Combined analysis of $B_c \to D_s^{(*)}\,\mu ^+ \mu ^-$ and $B_c \to D_s^{(*)}\, \nu \bar{\nu}$ decays within $Z^{\prime}$ and leptoquark new physics models
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses