Toponium effects on quantum steering and Bell nonlocality of top quarks
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Toponium effects on quantum steering and Bell nonlocality of top quarks".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper investigates quantum steering and Bell nonlocality in top-quark pair production near threshold by including toponium effects that strengthen spin entanglement Near threshold, the toponium contribution strengthens the spin-singlet component and substantially enhances the entanglement between the two quark spins With current LHC data, quantum steering appears observable with a statistical significance around 10σ For Bell nonlocality, the statistical significance can also be high close to threshold, reaching about 9σ, although the feasibility of such a measurement will depend crucially on the control of systematic uncertainties.
Kai: Recent measurements of tt¯ production near threshold by the CMS
1: and ATLAS
2: collaborations have revealed a pronounced cross-section enhancement, compatible with the contribution of a short-lived quasi-bound state usually referred to as toponium This observation is especially relevant for collider studies of quantum correlations.
Mira: The dominant tt¯ production mechanism at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) is gluon fusion.
Kai: At threshold, gg → tt¯ produces a maximally-entangled spin-singlet state.
Paper summary: Kai: So we’re looking at this paper, "Toponium effects on quantum steering and Bell nonlocality of top quarks." It investigates if including toponium effects actually strengthens the spin entanglement when you produce top quark pairs near threshold.
Mira: Right. The main thesis here is that the toponium contribution substantially enhances the entanglement between those two quark spins, and because of that enhancement, quantum steering appears observable with a statistical significance around ten sigma with current LHC data <ref:2606.30768#pg1,quantum steering appears observable with a statistical significance around>.
Lev: That's interesting from a hardware side, because if you have to build real hardware to test this, you need to account for those systematic uncertainties mentioned in the paper.
Kai: Exactly. The paper notes that for Bell nonlocality, the statistical significance can also reach about nine sigma close to threshold, but it warns that the feasibility of measuring that depends crucially on controlling those systematic uncertainties <ref:2606.30768#pg1,for Bell nonlocality, the statistical significance can also>.
Mira: And they mention a specific cut for quantum steering: they selected two sets of cuts, one being the top quark invariant mass less than or equal to three hundred eighty GeV and velocity in the laboratory rest frame less than or equal to zero point nine.
Lev: When you look at what that means for real hardware, you're talking about those specific kinematic regions where you have the best chance of getting a signal, even though they are quite conservative.
Kai: The analysis they did found a statistical significance well above five sigma even in that most conservative case of top quark invariant mass less than or equal to three hundred eighty GeV and velocity less than or equal to zero point nine.
Mira: But then you look at the Bell nonlocality part, and it's much harder there. They found that with the selection mttbar less than or equal to three hundred seventy GeV and velocity less than or equal to zero point nine, including the toponium contribution, it only gives a one sigma significance.
Lev: That makes sense because you have that very low cross section of six point four three picobarns mentioned in the references, which pulls the statistical significance down to three point two sigma and six point six sigma when you tighten those mass cuts to less than or equal to three hundred sixty five GeV and three hundred sixty GeV respectively.
Kai: So, while quantum steering looks promising with a ten sigma significance, Bell nonlocality is less clear right now despite the enhancement from the toponium contribution. The paper really points out that the feasibility of that measurement hinges on how well those systematic uncertainties are controlled.
Mira: It also highlights that they used a specific way to model top pair production near threshold, which involves a pseudoscalar resonance called eta t with a mass of three hundred forty three giga electron volts and a width of two times the top quark width, which is three giga electron volts.
Lev: From an error-correction standpoint, modeling that resonant contribution adds another layer to the complexity you have to manage before you even think about running this on actual hardware.
Kai: So, what's the bigger picture here? The paper suggests that even with the uncertainty in systematic effects, there are good chances a five sigma measurement of quantum steering could be achieved with current LHC run two plus run three data.
Mira: And for Bell nonlocality, it offers some hope because even though reaching five sigma might be difficult due to larger systematics, including the toponium contribution gives some chance for that otherwise hopeless measurement.
Lev: It seems like the paper is really focusing on how those bound-state effects modify the expected spin correlations in a way that we need to account for if we want reliable results from future experiments.
Kai: Exactly. The whole point of this work, "Toponium effects on quantum steering and Bell nonlocality of top quarks," is to show what happens when you properly include those short-lived quasi-bound states, the toponium, in your analysis of quantum correlations in top pair production near threshold.
Mira: It matters because it suggests that these effects are significant enough to shift the statistical significance for steering from a lower level up to ten sigma with existing LHC data.
Lev: But for real quantum information experiments, we always have to worry about those systematic uncertainties that can muddy the waters and reduce what we can actually measure on a test bench.
Kai: So, looking ahead, the paper suggests that while quantum steering has a good outlook for five sigma with current data, Bell nonlocality will likely require tighter cuts and better control over systematics for any meaningful measurement to come.
Conclusion: Kai: So we've looked at how including toponium effects changes our understanding of quantum steering and Bell nonlocality in top quark pair production near threshold, and now we're wrapping up the big picture with Kai and Mira.
Mira: Basically, the paper is about those short-lived quasi-bound states, toponium, how they boost the entanglement between top quarks when you make them close together.
Kai: Yeah, it really boils down to seeing if that extra physics from toponium is strong enough to push quantum steering up to ten sigma significance with current LHC data.
Lev: From my side in error correction, the main thing I see is how much those systematic uncertainties are going to eat into any potential measurement when we try to build real hardware for this.
Mira: Right, and the paper shows that while Bell nonlocality is tougher to see near threshold, those toponium effects do help boost that statistical significance.
Kai: So even though it's harder than steering, they found a way to get a better number for Bell nonlocality by using tighter cuts on the top quark mass.
Lev: But that’s where I push back a little; those tighter cuts often mean you’re fighting bigger systematic errors when you try to implement it in actual hardware.
Mira: It really shows how crucial those assumptions are, because the theoretical enhancement from toponium has to actually overcome the practical noise of the experiment.
Kai: So, for anyone just listening who isn't doing quantum physics, this paper means that we need to pay close attention to these subtle effects in collider experiments if we want reliable tests of quantum correlations.
Mira: Exactly. It tells us that while steering looks pretty solid right now, Bell nonlocality still has a lot more work ahead before we can claim anything concrete.
Lev: And the next step is figuring out what kind of precision we actually need to build those error correction codes to measure these things properly.
J. A. Aguilar-Saavedra, S. Rodríguez-Benítez
Instituto de Física Teórica, IFT-UAM/CSIC
hep-ph, hep-ex, quant-ph
Submitted: 2026-06-29
Updated: 2026-11-14
Comments: Latex 7 pages. Minor corrections and updated estimates. Final version to appear in PRD
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 79/100
The gist: The paper investigates quantum steering and Bell nonlocality in top-quark pair production near threshold by including toponium effects that strengthen spin entanglement Near threshold…
Key concepts
- Toponium
- This refers to a short-lived quasi-bound state of top quarks formed near the production threshold. This effect strengthens the spin-singlet component and significantly enhances the entanglement between the two top quark spins, which is crucial for observing quantum correlations.
- Quantum Steering
- Quantum steering is a stronger form of quantum correlation than entanglement. The paper examines how to measure this phenomenon in top-pair production by analyzing angular distributions of charged leptons to determine spin correlation coefficients.
- Bell Nonlocality
- Bell nonlocality is another strong form of quantum correlation tested using Bell inequalities. While difficult to observe near threshold, the inclusion of the toponium contribution substantially boosts the statistical significance for this measurement.
Terminology
Summary
The paper investigates quantum steering and Bell nonlocality in top-quark pair production near threshold by including toponium effects that strengthen spin entanglement Near threshold, the toponium contribution strengthens the spin-singlet component and substantially enhances the entanglement between the two quark spins With current LHC data, quantum steering appears observable with a statistical significance around 10σ For Bell nonlocality, the statistical significance can also be high close to threshold, reaching about 9σ, although the feasibility of such a measurement will depend crucially on the control of systematic uncertainties. p. 0
Introduction and Motivation
Recent measurements of tt¯ production near threshold by the CMS [1] and ATLAS [2] collaborations have revealed a pronounced cross-section enhancement, compatible with the contribution of a short-lived quasi-bound state usually referred to as toponium This observation is especially relevant for collider studies of quantum correlations. The dominant tt¯ production mechanism at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) is gluon fusion. p. 0 At threshold, gg → tt¯ produces a maximally-entangled spin-singlet state. p. 0 On the other hand, the pseudoscalar colour-singlet component associated with toponium formation contributes as a spin-singlet state even for non-zero velocity of the top quarks, and therefore strengthens the entanglement between the top and antitop spins [4]. p. 0 Quantum steering [5] and Bell nonlocality [6] are stronger forms of quantum correlation than entanglement. p. 0
Quantum Correlations from Angular Distributions
The spin state of the tt¯ pair is described by the density operator ρ = 1/4 " (1) where i, j = 1, 2, 3 The coefficients Cij can then be determined from the angular distributions of the charged leptons in the rest frame of their parent top quark. The spin correlation coefficients can therefore be obtained from fits to the distributions in Eq. p. 1 (3). Equivalently, one can use the forward-backward asymmetries Aij = N(cos θi a cos θj b > 0) − N(cos θi a cos θj b 0) + N(cos θi a cos θj b < 0) = 1/4 αaαbCij, (4) with N(·) standing for the number of events. p. 1
Top Pair Modelling and Data Analysis
The interpretation of angular distributions in terms of expected values of tt¯ spin observables is strictly valid for the leading-order (LO) process pp → tt¯→ W+bW−¯b, with both top quarks nearly on-shell Toponium production is modelled as a pseudoscalar resonance ηt, with mass mηt ≃ 2mt − 2 = 343 GeV and width Γηt ≃ 2Γt = 3 GeV [18]. The final state is reconstructed assuming the kinematics of nearly on-shell production of a top quark pair that decays as tt¯ → bW+¯bW− → bl+ν¯bl−ν¯. p. 3 The statistical uncertainties of the unfolded histograms are propagated through the covariance matrix, which is estimated by RooUnfold. p. 3
Quantum Steering Near Threshold
Because the near-threshold entanglement measurements by ATLAS [32] and CMS [3] have systematic uncertainties that have roughly the same size as the statistical ones, we do not attempt an optimisation of the kinematical region for the measurement of quantum steering. We select two sets of cuts: • tt¯ invariant mass mtt¯ ≤ 380 GeV, and tt¯ velocity in the laboratory rest frame β ≤ 0. p. 39 • mtt¯ ≤ 370 GeV, β ≤ 0. p. 29. Our analysis finds a statistical significance well above 5σ even in the most conservative case of mtt¯ ≤ 380 GeV, β ≤ 0. p. 49.
Bell Nonlocality Near Threshold
Bell nonlocality is much more difficult to observe near threshold. The selection mtt¯ ≤ 370 GeV, β ≤ 0. p. 49 used in the previous section yields EB (a) = 0. p. 40128 ± 0.0145 ± 0.0067, EB (b) = 0. p. 40171 ± 0.0131 ± 0.026, including the toponium contribution, that is, only 1σ significance. p. 4 The toponium contribution greatly enhances the statistical significance of EB. p. 4 However, the feasibility of a measurement cannot be established without a proper evaluation of systematic uncertainties. p. 4 With the lower cross section σηt = 6. p. 443 pb from Refs. p. 4 [22, 23] the statistical significance is reduced to 3. p. 42σ and 6.6σ for mtt¯ ≤ 365, 360 GeV, respectively. p. 4
Conclusion
In this work we have addressed quantum steering and Bell nonlocality in top pair production near threshold, focusing on the toponium contribution that has not been included in previous analyses. Our results for quantum steering are quite encouraging: even bearing in mind that systematic uncertainties are important, the statistical significance at the 10σ level we obtain suggests that there are good chances that a measurement at the 5σ level may be achieved with current LHC Run 2 + Run 3 data. p. 5 Prospects for Bell nonlocality are less clear. p. 5 Although we have shown that a high statistical significance may be achieved with a tighter cut on the tt¯ invariant mass, such a measurement will likely suffer from larger systematics. p. 5 In any case, our updated estimates including the toponium contribution provide some hope for this otherwise hopeless measurement, even if 5σ may be difficult to reach. p. 5
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This work has been supported by the Spanish Research Agency (Agencia Estatal de Investigación) through projects PID2022-142545NB-C21, CEX2020-001007-S and grant PRE2022-101860 funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/50110039. p. 5
[4] J. A. Aguilar-Saavedra, “Toponium hunter’s guide,” Phys. p. 5 Rev. D 110 (2024) no. p. 55, 054032 [arXiv:2407. p. 520330 [hep-ph]]. p. 5
[9] J. A. Aguilar-Saavedra and J. p. 0 A. Casas, “Improved tests of entanglement and Bell inequalities with LHC tops,” Eur. p. 5 Phys. J C 82 (2022) no 8, 666 [arXiv:2205. p. 600542 [hep-ph]]. p. 6
[13] S. Jevtic, M. J. W. Hall, M. R. Anderson, M. p. 6 Zwierz and H. p. 6 M. Wiseman, “Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen steering and the steering ellipsoid,” J Opt Soc Am B 32 (2015) no4, A40-A49 [arXiv:1411. p. 61517 [quant-ph]]. p. 6
[30] J. A. Aguilar-Saavedra, M. p. 0 C. N. Fiolhais, P. p. 6 MartínRamiro, J. p. 6 M. Moreno and A. p. 6 Onofre, “A template method to measure the tt¯ polarisation,” Eur Phys J C 82 (2022) no 2, 134 [arXiv:2111. p. 610394 [hep-ph]]. p. 6
[31] V. Khachatryan et al. p. 6, “Jet energy scale and resolution in the CMS experiment in pp collisions at 8 TeV,” JINST 12 (2017) no. p. 602, P02014 [arXiv:1607. p. 603663 [hepex]]. p. 6
[32] G. Aad et al., “Observation of quantum entanglement with top quarks at the ATLAS detector,” Nature 633 (2024) no8, 8030, 542-547 [arXiv:2311. p. 607288 [hep-ex]]. p. 6
[16] J. Alwall, R. Frederix, S. p. 6 Frixione, V. p. 6 Hirschi, F. p. 6 Maltoni, O. p. 6 Mattelaer, H. p. 6 S Shao, T Stelzer, P Torrielli and M Zaro, “The automated computation of tree-level and next-to-leading order differential cross sections and their matching to parton shower simulations,” JHEP 07 (2014), 079 [arXiv:1405. p. 60301 [hep-ph]]. p. 6
[23] Y. Sumino and H. p. 6 Yokoya, “Bound-state effects on kinematical distributions of top quarks at hadron colliders,” JHEP 09 (2010), 034 [erratum: JHEP 06 (2016), 037] [arXiv:1007. p. 60075 [hep-ph]]. p. 6
[24] T. Sjostrand, S. p. 6 Mrenna and P. p. 6 Z. Skands, “A Brief Introduction to PYTHIA 8. p. 61,” Comput Phys Commun 178 (2008), 852-867 [arXiv:0710. p. 63820 [hep-ph]]. p. 6
[25] J. de Favereau et al. p. 6, “DELPHES 3, A modular framework for fast simulation of a generic collider experiment,” JHEP 02 (2014), 057 [arXiv:1307. p. 66346 [hep-ex]]. p. 6
[26] M. Cacciari, G. p. 6 p. 6 P. Salam and G. p. 6 p. 6 Soyez, “FastJet User Manual,” Eur Phys J C 72 (2012), 1896 [arXiv:1111. p. 66097 [hep-ph]]. p. 6
[27] M. Cacciari, G. P. Salam and G. Soyez, “The antikt jet clustering algorithm,” JHEP 04 (2008), 063 [arXiv:0802. p. 61189 [hep-ph]]. p. 6
[28] S. Chatrchyan et al. p. 6, “Identification of b-Quark Jets with the CMS Experiment,” JINST 8 (2013), P04013 [arXiv:1211. p. 64462 [hep-ex]]. p. 6
[33] G. D’Agostini, “A Multidimensional unfolding method based on Bayes’ theorem,” Nucl Instrum Meth A 362 (1995), 487-498 [arXiv:1995]. p. 6
[34] T. Adye, “Unfolding algorithms and tests using RooUnfold,” arXiv:1105. p. 61160 [physics. p. 6data-an].
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improve simulation accuracy by incorporating toponium effects into Monte Carlo generation using MadGraph [16] with a pseudoscalar resonance ηt, as this strengthens entanglement and enhances observables. This allows AI systems to better predict quantum steering and Bell nonlocality in top-pair production near threshold.
-
Enhance event reconstruction performance by implementing the unfolding procedure described in Ref. [33] using RooUnfold [34] to obtain statistical sensitivity for quantum correlation observables from angular distributions, which is crucial for extracting spin correlation coefficients Cij. This enables AI systems to determine whether the quantum state produced in the threshold region is entangled, steerable, or Bell nonlocal.
-
Develop a method for assessing experimental feasibility by using updated estimates that include the toponium contribution when evaluating Bell nonlocality witnesses EB, as this
greatly enhances the statistical significance of EB
compared to previous analyses. This allows AI systems to provide more realistic expectations for measuring Bell nonlocality near threshold, even if systematic uncertainties are larger. -
Improve quantum steering sensitivity by analyzing independent sub-samples using three random partitions of the event sample and calculating the steering witness ES, as this yields a statistical significance well above 5sigma even in the most conservative cases. This suggests that AI systems can reliably suggest achievable measurement levels for quantum steering at current LHC data.
Sources
- Observation of a pseudoscalar excess at the top quark pair production threshold
- Observation of a cross-section enhancement near the t production threshold in sqrt s =13 TeV pp collisions with the ATLAS detector
- Observation of quantum entanglement in top quark pair production in proton-proton collisions at $\sqrt{s}$ = 13 TeV
- Toponium Hunter's Guide
- Steering, Entanglement, Nonlocality, and the EPR Paradox
- Quantum discord and steering in top quarks at the LHC
- Quantum information with top quarks in QCD
- Improved tests of entanglement and Bell inequalities with LHC tops
- Experimental characterization of the hierarchy of quantum correlations in top quark pairs
- A set of top quark spin correlation and polarization observables for the LHC: Standard Model predictions and new physics contributions
- QCD-corrected spin analysing power of jets in decays of polarized top quarks
- Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen steering and the steering ellipsoid
- The automated computation of tree-level and next-to-leading order differential cross sections, and their matching to parton shower simulations
- Parton distributions from high-precision collider data
- Quantum tops at circular lepton colliders
- Signatures of toponium formation in LHC run 2 data
- Simulating toponium formation signals at the LHC
- Updated predictions for toponium production at the LHC
- Top-quark pair production near threshold at LHC
- Bound-state effects on kinematical distributions of top quarks at hadron colliders
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses