Holographic s - and p-wave superconductors from the 4D regularization of Einstein-Lovelock theory

arXiv:2606.26546 · hep-th · Submitted 2026-06-25 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Holographic s - and p-wave superconductors from the 4D regularization of Einstein-Lovelock theory".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Detailed Research Summary: Holographic s- and p-wave Superconductors from 4D Regularization of Einstein-Lovelock Theory This research investigates the holographic dual descriptions of (2 + 1)-dimensional s-wave and p-wave superconductors, utilizing a framework based on regularized four-dimensional (4D) Einstein-Lovelock gravity theories.

Kai: The core methodology involves constructing bulk geometries from exact black-brane solutions characterized by a fine-tuned Lovelock coupling constant (alpha) and the highest power of curvature (K).

Mira: Crucially, the study incorporates higher curvature corrections beyond the standard Gauss-Bonnet sector, allowing for a richer exploration of gravitational influences on condensed matter phenomena.

Kai: The findings demonstrate that these higher curvature terms significantly modify the phase structure of both s-wave and p-wave superconducting systems.

Title and authors: Kai: We’re moving into the paper's specific focus now. The title is "Holographic s - and p-wave superconductors from the 4D regularization of Einstein-Lovelock theory" <ref:2606.26546#pg1,Holographic s - and p-wave superconductors from the 4D regularization of Einstein>. That tells us exactly what we’re looking at.

Mira: It sets up the dual description for two types of superconductivity, s-wave and p-wave, using a specific type of gravity—the four dimensional regularized Einstein Lovelock gravity.

Lev: The core idea is that they are building these models using black brane solutions where they can control the higher curvature effects by tuning the Lovelock coupling constant alpha and the highest power of curvature K.

Kai: So, instead of just standard Einstein gravity, they are adding these higher order corrections beyond the Gauss-Bonnet term to see what happens.

Mira: They then analyze how scalar and vector operators dual to matter fields condense under these conditions, focusing on two different ways to fix the bulk field masses.

Lev: The paper specifically investigates how these choices of mass fixing play a nontrivial role in determining both the magnitude of the condensate and the critical temperature Tc.

Kai: It’s interesting because it shows that you aren't just looking at one fixed model, but how changing those parameters alters the outcome for s-wave and p-wave separately.

Mira: And they emphasize that these higher order terms are what allow them to systematically control those effects up to any Kth order in curvature.

Lev: So the methodology is quite systematic, starting with the bulk geometry construction and moving into analyzing the resulting dual matter fields under different mass prescriptions.

The paper's summary: Kai: What this summary tells us is that these higher curvature terms significantly modify both s-wave and p-wave systems. It’s not just a small tweak; it changes the phase structure entirely.

Mira: They emphasize that the critical temperature Tc is enhanced when you increase the maximal curvature order K, which means higher K gives you higher Tc phases than standard Einstein gravity predicts.

Lev: And they point out that this enhancement is particularly pronounced when alpha is negative, where negative values of the fine tuned coupling actively promote superconducting order.

Kai: That’s a key finding for me because it’s not universal; it depends heavily on that negative sign of alpha to get the best results.

Mira: They also found that positive alpha tends to suppress condensation and lower Tc, which is a good balancing point to have when modeling these systems.

Lev: Beyond the critical temperature, they showed that the optical conductivity exhibits a strong dependence on both alpha and K, deviating substantially from universal results you see in Einstein gravity.

Kai: And they found that higher curvature effects also enhance the superconducting gap scale across all the systems studied, which is another physical observable to look at.

Mira: Near their critical temperatures, all condensates display mean field scaling, which confirms that this is indeed a second order phase transition in these holographic models.

Lev: So the summary boils down to this: higher curvature corrections are a powerful tool for controlling condensation and Tc in holographic p-wave models specifically.

The paper's improvements: Kai: Now let's talk about the specific improvements they suggest for this work. They’re not just showing results, but suggesting how to make these descriptions better.

Mira: They are focusing on the fact that they can analyze both scalar and vector condensates under different mass-fixing prescriptions relative to either the AdS scale L or the effective AdS scale L eff.

Lev: That means they’re looking at how those choices of fixing the mass—relative to L versus L eff—play a nontrivial role in determining both the condensate structure and Tc.

Kai: I see that because it suggests a richer dependence on the effective AdS scale for p-wave systems compared to s-wave systems, which is a nice distinction.

Mira: Exactly. They are pointing out that this choice affects the vector condensate more than it does for s-wave condensates, suggesting a deeper connection to how the geometry behaves near the horizon.

Lev: From an error correction perspective, this implies that if you were building real hardware, your choice of scale might fundamentally change how many degrees of freedom you have to manage in that system.

Kai: And they also point out some interesting abnormal behavior near the Chern-Simons limit where condensation curves intersect each other as well as the Einstein gravity curve when alpha approaches its upper bound.

Mira: That intersection is a key feature because it distinguishes these higher order theories from simpler models where you might expect a smooth, single prediction.

Lev: So they are suggesting that exploring those limits, like near the Chern-Simons limit, is where you see the most interesting physics differentiating these theories.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up this paper on "Holographic s - and p-wave superconductors from the 4D regularization of Einstein-Lovelock theory", we’ve seen how higher curvature corrections significantly modify both systems <ref:2606.26546#pg1,Holographic s - and p-wave superconductors from the 4D regularization of Einstein>.

Mira: We established that negative values of alpha enhance condensation and facilitate scalar hair in s-wave systems, leading to higher critical temperatures than in standard Einstein gravity.

Lev: And for p-wave, the vector condensate is very sensitive to the mass fixing prescription relative to L versus L eff, which means these choices lead to qualitatively different patterns for condensates and critical temperatures.

Kai: In short, this paper confirms that regularized four dimensional Einstein Lovelock theory can naturally accommodate higher Tc superconductors under specific conditions of negative fine tuned coupling and high orders of curvature corrections.

Mira: It’s a good example of how the bulk gravitational sector imprints itself on observable superconducting properties through these higher order terms.

Lev: I just want to say that while this is mathematically interesting, the practical challenge remains figuring out how much real world overhead you need for error correction when you introduce all these Lovelock corrections.

Department of Physics, University of Sistan and Baluchestan · School of Physics, Damghan University

hep-th

Submitted: 2026-06-25

Updated: 2026-11-06

Comments: 40 pages, 24 figures

Journal ref: Eur. Phys. J. Plus (2026) 141:1243

DOI: 10.1140/epjp/s13360-026-08480-0

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 81/100

The gist: Holographic s- and p-wave Superconductors from 4D Regularization of Einstein-Lovelock Theory This research investigates the holographic dual descriptions of (2 + 1)-dimensional s-wave and p-wave…

Key concepts

Einstein-Lovelock Theory
This is a type of gravity theory that goes beyond standard Einstein gravity by including higher-order curvature corrections, like the Gauss-Bonnet term. These corrections are used in the holographic model to describe condensed matter systems like superconductors in a four-dimensional spacetime.
Fine-tuned Lovelock Coupling ($\alpha$)
This is a specific parameter within the Einstein-Lovelock theory that dictates how strongly the higher curvature terms influence the system. The study shows that negative values of $\alpha$ are crucial; they actively promote superconducting order and lead to higher critical temperatures ($T_c$) than predicted by simpler gravity models.
Higher Curvature Corrections
These are additional gravitational terms beyond the standard Einstein-Hilbert action, allowing for an exploration of more complex spacetime geometries. These corrections are essential because they significantly modify the phase structure of both s-wave and p-wave superconducting systems, amplifying their observable properties.
$T_c$ Enhancement
The critical temperature ($T_c$) is the temperature at which a material transitions into a superconducting state. The research demonstrates that higher curvature effects generally increase $T_c$. This enhancement is particularly strong when the fine-tuned coupling $\alpha$ is negative, meaning these theories naturally predict higher-$T_c$ superconductors than standard Einstein gravity.

Terminology

Summary

Holographic s- and p-wave Superconductors from 4D Regularization of Einstein-Lovelock Theory

This research investigates the holographic dual descriptions of (2 + 1)-dimensional s-wave and p-wave superconductors, utilizing a framework based on regularized four-dimensional (4D) Einstein-Lovelock gravity theories. The core methodology involves constructing bulk geometries from exact black-brane solutions characterized by a fine-tuned Lovelock coupling constant (alpha) and the highest power of curvature (K). p. 0 Crucially, the study incorporates higher curvature corrections beyond the standard Gauss-Bonnet sector, allowing for a richer exploration of gravitational influences on condensed matter phenomena. p. 0

The findings demonstrate that these higher curvature terms significantly modify the phase structure of both s-wave and p-wave superconducting systems. p. 0 A key observation is that higher curvature effects substantially enhance the sensitivity of both the superconducting condensates and their critical temperatures (T c) to the underlying gravitational couplings (alpha and K). p. 0 Specifically, it is found that T c generally increases as the maximal curvature order K increases, leading to higher- T c phases when compared to those predicted by standard Einstein gravity. p. 0 This enhancement is particularly pronounced for negative values of the fine-tuned Lovelock coupling constant alpha. p. 0 Conversely, positive alpha tends to suppress condensation and lower T c. p. 0 The fine-tuned coupling alpha acts as a critical parameter, where negative values actively promote superconducting order and higher- T c phases relative to Einstein gravity. p. 0

The impact of these gravitational corrections is also evident in the optical conductivity, which exhibits a strong dependence on both the Lovelock coupling alpha and the curvature order K, deviating substantially from the universal results obtained in Einstein gravity. p. 0 Furthermore, higher curvature effects are shown to enhance the superconducting gap scale across all studied systems. p. 0 Near their critical temperatures, all condensates display mean-field scaling, consistent with a second-order phase transition. p. 0

For s-wave superconductors, the investigation examines both scalar and vector condensates under different mass-fixing prescriptions relative to either the AdS scale (L) or the effective AdS scale (L eff). p. 0 The results indicate that negative values of alpha specifically facilitate the formation of scalar hair, which is typically associated with achieving higher critical temperatures than in Einstein gravity. p. 0

In contrast, for p-wave superconductors, the vector condensate exhibits a stronger sensitivity to the mass-fixing prescription compared to s-wave systems, suggesting a richer dependence on the effective AdS scale. p. 0 The paper concludes that higher curvature corrections serve as an efficient mechanism for controlling both condensation and the superconducting transition temperature in holographic p-wave models. p. 0 Overall, these results establish that higher curvature corrections play a significant role in shaping the superconducting phase, amplifying the imprint of the bulk gravitational sector on observable superconducting properties. p. 0 The regularized 4D Einstein-Lovelock theory is shown to naturally accommodate higher- T c superconductors relative to Einstein gravity under specific conditions of negative fine-tuned coupling and sufficiently high orders of curvature corrections. p. 0

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved understanding of holographic duality in higher-curvature gravity by allowing for any Kth order correction beyond Gauss-Bonnet terms. The improved AI can analyze how increasing K affects superconducting observables, as it is stated that higher curvature corrections significantly modify the phase structure of both s-wave and p-wave systems.

  2. Enhanced ability to predict the effect of fine-tuned Lovelock coupling alpha on critical temperature and condensate behavior across different quantization schemes. The AI can now differentiate between results based on the choice of quantization scheme and the prescription for fixing the scalar mass.

  3. Detailed analysis of the role of negative fine-tuned couplings in enhancing superconducting order. The improved system can specifically identify that negative values of alpha enhance the condensation and facilitate the formation of scalar hair in both s-wave and p-wave systems, leading to higher critical temperatures compared to Einstein gravity.

  4. Precision in predicting conductivity scaling with frequency for various models. The AI can now accurately predict that "Re[sigma(omega -> infinity)] decreases as alpha increases while noting that Im[sigma(omega -> infinity)] approaches zero, as expected."

  5. Robust comparison of mass-fixing prescriptions for vector fields in p-wave systems. The system can now compare the results of fixing the vector field mass relative to the AdS scale (L) versus the effective AdS scale (Leff), noting that these choices lead to qualitatively different patterns for condensates and critical temperatures.

  6. Identification of abnormal behavior near the Chern-Simons limit in specific regimes. The AI can now detect the qualitative deviations where condensation curves intersect each other as well as the Einstein-gravity curve when alpha approaches its upper bound, which is a key feature distinguishing higher-order theories from simpler models.

Sources

Related papers