Fermion mass relations in one-parameter modular models

arXiv:2606.25027 · hep-ph, hep-th · Submitted 2026-06-23 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Fermion mass relations in one-parameter modular models".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Modular flavour symmetries provide a possible organizing principle for the Standard Model Yukawa sector by replacing generic couplings with a potentially small number of modular forms controlled by a single complex modulus The extreme limit of this idea, one-parameter modular models (OPMs), fixes each charged-fermion mass matrix by a single modular invariant contraction The study develops a systematic method to construct such models, showing that the OPM requirement is already highly constraining at the level of possible fermion hierarchies In a concrete realization, the charged-lepton and down-quark sectors are controlled by the common modulus, leading to exact mass relations at the flavour scale.

Kai: Framework of Modular Symmetry The framework considers global N = 1 supersymmetry where matter chiral superfields acquire their masses from Yukawa interactions characterized by cubic terms of the type W ⊃ Yijk(τ) ψiψjψk These are holomorphic functions that transform under the modular group SL(2,Z) as Y(kY)(τ)γ → Y(kY)(γτ) = (c τ + d) kY ρ(γ) Y(kY)(τ), where γ = a b c d!

Mira: ∈ SL(2,Z) The superpotential is invariant under modular transformations, leading to the condition that the sum of the matter field modular weights must equal the weight of the modular form, kY = kψi + kψj + kψk.

Kai: Conditions for One-Parameter Models To achieve an OPM, two conditions must be met in the extreme one-parameter case: 1) among the representations ri under which the VVMFs Y(k)ri transform, only one representation, r, can contract with ψc and ψ to produce a trivial (non-vanishing) singlet; 2) there is only one modular form of weight k furnishing the representation r.

Title and authors: Kai: Now let's talk about how they set up the math for this OPM idea. The paper starts by discussing the global N equal one supersymmetry where matter chiral superfields get their masses from Yukawa interactions characterized by cubic terms like W over Y i j k of tau psi i psi j psi k.

Mira: These Yukawa functions are holomorphic, meaning they have specific properties under modular transformations, and they transform according to this rule: Y over k you times tau gamma becomes a complicated expression involving the modular parameter tau and the transformation matrix gamma.

Lev: They state that for the superpotential to be invariant under those modular transformations, there’s a condition that says the sum of the matter field weights must equal the weight of the modular form, so k over Y equals k psi i plus k psi j plus k psi k.

Kai: That constraint is huge because it means for relatively low weights, there are only a few, or even just one, modular form available that can satisfy this condition.

Mira: This strongly constrains the flavour structures we can imagine and the observables we see in nature.

The paper's summary: Kai: Moving onto what they actually found for the OPM concept, they show that to get a true one-parameter model, you need two conditions to be met. First, among all the different representations under which these Yukawa functions transform, only one representation can contract with psi c and psi to produce a trivial singlet.

Mira: And the second condition is that there should only be one modular form of weight k available for that specific representation. This is what makes the model truly extreme.

Lev: They point out that for a model with three generations of massive fermions, all three generations have to participate in this contraction so each generation gets a mass, which means the fermions have to transform like a triplet under the finite modular group.

Kai: That’s why they classify the mass spectra based on where you are in the asymptotic region of that modulus tau. They define regions like tau equal to i infinity, omega equal to e two pi i over three, and tau equal to i.

Mira: These different regions correspond to different hierarchy types, H one through H five, which basically tells you the specific mass ratios for m one m two and m three.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper then moves into comparing these high-scale mass relations they derived from the modular construction with what we see in low-energy data by using renormalization group evolution and finite threshold corrections.

Mira: Running effects alone show a non-trivial alignment where both the down-quark hierarchies and the electron to tau hierarchy can match data for a single value of epsilon, but there’s still this main remaining discrepancy isolated in the muon to tau ratio.

Lev: The authors suggest that this discrepancy can be corrected by a selective charged lepton supersymmetry threshold effect, which shows that the double OPM structure already captures most of the charged-fermion hierarchy.

Kai: It sounds like they’re saying these high-scale relations are very good, but you need those low-energy corrections to nail down the final numbers for things like muons.

Mira: What this means for us is that the double OPM structure already accounts for most of the charged fermion hierarchy, and whatever is left over is just a specific pattern of threshold effects.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up on "Fermion mass relations in one-parameter modular models," they show that OPMs can actually lead to viable charged-fermion mass relations once you account for the renormalization group evolution and those selective threshold corrections we just discussed.

Mira: The construction gives a controlled proof of existence by showing the high-scale OPM structure captures most of the charged fermion hierarchy, while the remaining adjustment can be associated with a specific pattern of threshold effects.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, this is good because it means we can isolate where the model needs to be tweaked for real hardware implementation.

Kai: And looking ahead, they suggest searching for an explicit OPM that realizes the p over q equal to two up-quark hierarchy and embedding it into a complete construction that leads to a viable C k m matrix.

Mira: They also hint at this pattern possibly being related to an H six type hierarchy for the up quarks versus an H five hierarchy controlling the down quarks.

Lev: If we can find that explicit realization, it would give us a concrete target for building those error correction schemes we talked about earlier.

Salvador Centelles Chuliáa, Ã Xueqi Li, Ã Xiang-Gan Liu, ™ Omar Medina, J. T. Penedo

Instituto de Fマica Corpuscular, Universidad de Valencia-CSIC · Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California, Irvine · Instituto de Fマica, Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mîxico · INFN Sezione di Roma Tre

hep-ph, hep-th

Submitted: 2026-06-23

Updated: 2026-11-09

Comments: 26 pages, 5 figures, 4 tables. v2 matches the accepted JHEP version, with the discussion of the hypothetical H6 hierarchy retained in the main text

License: http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/

Importance score: 73/100

The gist: Modular flavour symmetries provide a possible organizing principle for the Standard Model Yukawa sector by replacing generic couplings with a potentially small number of modular forms controlled by a…

Key concepts

Modular Symmetry
This framework uses the modular group SL(2,Z) to describe how matter fields transform under certain interactions. The superpotential must be invariant under these transformations, which imposes strict conditions on the sum of the matter field modular weights to ensure consistency.
One-Parameter Models (OPMs)
OPMs are an extreme case of modular models where every charged-fermion mass matrix is fixed by a single modular invariant contraction. This simplifies the complex flavor structure into a highly constrained system, suggesting that fermion hierarchies are not arbitrarily flexible but follow specific patterns.
Renormalization Group (RG) Running
This process accounts for how fermion masses change as energy scales vary, from the high flavour scale to lower energies. RG evolution is used to compare the exact mass relations derived from modular theory with experimental data, helping to reconcile theoretical predictions with low-energy measurements.
Threshold Corrections
These are finite corrections applied at specific energy thresholds, such as those related to supersymmetry breaking. Including these corrections allows the model to account for small discrepancies between high-scale predictions and low-energy data, such as the muon mass ratio.

Terminology

Summary

Modular flavour symmetries provide a possible organizing principle for the Standard Model Yukawa sector by replacing generic couplings with a potentially small number of modular forms controlled by a single complex modulus The extreme limit of this idea, one-parameter modular models (OPMs), fixes each charged-fermion mass matrix by a single modular invariant contraction The study develops a systematic method to construct such models, showing that the OPM requirement is already highly constraining at the level of possible fermion hierarchies In a concrete realization, the charged-lepton and down-quark sectors are controlled by the common modulus, leading to exact mass relations at the flavour scale. p. 0

Where the paper says it

04510, M´exico 4 INFN Sezione di Roma Tre, Via della Vasca Navale 84, 00146, Roma, Italy Modular flavour symmetries provide a possible organizing principle for the Standard Model Yukawa sector, by replacing generic couplings with a potentially small number of modular forms controlled by a single complex modulus. We study the extreme limit of this idea: one-parameter modular models (OPMs), in which each charged-fermion mass matrix is fixed by a single modular invariant contraction.

Framework of Modular Symmetry

The framework considers global N = 1 supersymmetry where matter chiral superfields acquire their masses from Yukawa interactions characterized by cubic terms of the type W ⊃ Yijk(τ) ψiψjψk These are holomorphic functions that transform under the modular group SL(2,Z) as Y(kY)(τ)γ → Y(kY)(γτ) = (c τ + d) kY ρ(γ) Y(kY)(τ), where γ = a b c d! ∈ SL(2,Z) The superpotential is invariant under modular transformations, leading to the condition that the sum of the matter field modular weights must equal the weight of the modular form, kY = kψi + kψj + kψk. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Then, together with eq. (2), one finds that, in each superpotential term, the sum of the matter field modular weights must equal the weight of the modular form, kY = kψi + kψj + kψk .

Conditions for One-Parameter Models

To achieve an OPM, two conditions must be met in the extreme one-parameter case: 1) among the representations ri under which the VVMFs Y(k)ri transform, only one representation, r, can contract with ψc and ψ to produce a trivial (non-vanishing) singlet; 2) there is only one modular form of weight k furnishing the representation r. For a model with three generations of massive fermions, all three generations must participate in the contraction so that each generation acquires a mass. p. 2

Where the paper says it

there is only one modular form of weight k furnishing the representation r; If either of these conditions is not met, more than one contraction will be present. For a model with three generations of massive fermions, all three generations must participate in the contraction so that each generation acquires a mass.

This implies that fermions must transform as a triplet of the finite modular group. p. 3
Where the paper says it

4 Type Max rank at τsym Leading spectrum Possible asymptotic regions I 1 c1 ϵ p : c2 ϵ q : 1 τ ≃ i∞ II 2 c1 ϵ p : c2 : 1 τ ≃ i∞, i III 3 c1 : c2 : 1 τ ≃ i∞, i, ω TABLE I: Classification of mass spectra in OPMs, where p, q ̸= 0 and the constants ci follow from the expansion coefficients of modular forms and Clebsch–Gordan (CG) coefficients of the finite modular group. fermions must transform as a triplet of the finite modular group.

Classification of Mass Spectra

The classification of mass spectra in OPMs is summarized in Table I, which categorizes the leading spectrum based on the asymptotic region of the modulus VEV. The possible asymptotic regions are defined by τ ≃ i∞, ω = e 2πi/3, and i, and these points correspond to different hierarchy types H1 through H5. p. 3

Where the paper says it

By expanding mass matrix elements around these points in terms of a small deviation parameter ϵ ∼ |τ − τsym|, one can categorize the resulting mass hierarchies into three types, as presented in Table I. 4 Note that some spectra are not available in a given asymptotic region.

The hierarchy label determines the mass ratios m1: m2: m3. p. 5
Where the paper says it

6 Hierarchy label Leading spectrum m1 : m2 : m3 Finite modular group p/q H1 4 √ 2 ϵ 3 : 2 ϵ : 1 ∆(96) 3 H2 4 √ 2 ϵ 6 : 2 ϵ 2 : 1 ∆(384) 3 H3 2 √ 2 ϵ 4 : √ 2 ϵ : 1 ∆(384) 4 H4 8 ϵ 7 : √ 2 ϵ : 1 ∆(384) 7 H5 4 ϵ 5 : 2√ 2 ϵ 3 : 1 ∆(384) 5/3 TABLE II: Mass hierarchies obtained within OPMs and the associated flavour groups. Note that H1 is physically equivalent to H2.

Running and Threshold Corrections

The mass relations derived at the flavour scale MF are compared with low-energy data through renormalization group (RG) evolution and finite threshold corrections. Running effects alone reveal a non-trivial alignment where both down-quark hierarchies and the electron-to-tau hierarchy can be brought into agreement with data for a common value of ϵ, while the main remaining discrepancy is isolated in the muon-to-tau ratio. p. 8

Where the paper says it

(22) remains far from unity and is not rescued by running. This identifies the muon mass prediction as the main discrepancy: the model tends to predict a muon mass around 20% higher than the experimentally measured one.

This discrepancy can be corrected by a selective charged-lepton SUSY threshold effect, which shows that the double OPM structure already captures most of the charged-fermion hierarchy. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In a concrete realization, the charged-lepton and down-quark sectors are controlled by the common modulus, leading to exact mass relations at the flavour scale, m 5 s = 2√ 2 m 3 dm 2 b , m 3 µ = √ 2 mem 2 τ , m 2 smτ = √ 2 mem 2 b . We show that, once renormalization-group evolution and selective supersymmetric threshold effects are included, these high-scale relations can be made compatible with low-energy charged-fermion data.

Hints for Quark Flavour Puzzle

The one-parameter predictions are genuinely restrictive, defining a discrete set of predictive curves in the hierarchy plane rather than a flexible parametrization. The observed up-quark hierarchy points towards a potential curve of the same kind, described by p/q = 2, which suggests a possible modular origin for both quark mass hierarchies and CKM mixing controlled by a common small parameter ϵ ∼ θC. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We develop a systematic method to construct such models, showing that the OPM requirement is already highly constraining at the level of possible fermion hierarchies. In a concrete realization, the charged-lepton and down-quark sectors are controlled by the common modulus, leading to exact mass relations at the flavour scale, m 5 s = 2√ 2 m 3 dm 2 b , m 3 µ = √ 2 mem 2 τ , m 2 smτ = √ 2 mem 2 b .

This observation hints at a possible modular construction where the down-quark sector is controlled by the H5 hierarchy, while the up-quark sector is controlled by an H6-type hierarchy. p. 0
Where the paper says it

de M´exico C. 04510, M´exico 4 INFN Sezione di Roma Tre, Via della Vasca Navale 84, 00146, Roma, Italy Modular flavour symmetries provide a possible organizing principle for the Standard Model Yukawa sector, by replacing generic couplings with a potentially small number of modular forms controlled by a single complex modulus.

Conclusions and Future Directions

The work demonstrates that OPMs can lead to viable charged-fermion mass relations once RG evolution and selective threshold corrections are taken into account. The construction provides a controlled proof of existence by showing the high-scale OPM structure captures most of the charged-fermion hierarchy, while the remaining adjustment can be associated with a specific pattern of threshold effects. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We show that, once renormalization-group evolution and selective supersymmetric threshold effects are included, these high-scale relations can be made compatible with low-energy charged-fermion data. Our results provide a working proof of principle for OPMs and point towards a possible route to the flavour puzzle through highly constrained constructions.

Future research should focus on searching for an explicit OPM realizing the p/q = 2 up-quark hierarchy and embedding it in a complete construction leading to a viable CKM matrix. The construction also suggests a possible broader direction by investigating modular-covariant soft terms and systematic treatment of finite threshold corrections. p. 8
Where the paper says it

We do not specify the mediation mechanism of SUSY breaking. Instead, we first isolate the effect of RG running, and later include finite SUSY threshold corrections at MSUSY, treating the soft spectrum phenomenologically.

Appendix A: VVMFs and OPMs

The appendix collects the complete list of OPM triplet pairs found, where the superpotential takes the form Wf = αf Y(2)rY(τ) ψcψ1H, (A1). The leading behaviour of relevant VVMFs close to the cusp is shown in equation (A6), which involves theta constants. The resulting Yukawa matrices are given by equations (A3a) through (A3d), which produce the hierarchy patterns H2 through H5. The leading-order mass relations derived from these models are fixed by the modular construction and do not rely on additional order-one flavour coefficients. p. 7

Where the paper says it

For a given value of ϵ = e −π Im τ/8 , the mass hierarchies are fixed exactly by the modular structure, i. without invoking additional O(1) flavour coefficients beyond the single, overall parameters αd,e.

The model predicts three exact high-scale mass relations m5s = 2√2 m3dm2b, m3µ = √2 mem2τ, and m2smτ = √2 memmb

Table III and Table IV

The tables list the triplet pairs leading to one-parameter models based on ∆(96) and ∆(384), showing that the pairwise degeneracy of the OPMs observed in Table III and Table IV is a direct manifestation of the outer automorphisms of the finite modular groups. The leading behaviour of the relevant ∆(384) sextet VVMFs close to the cusp is given by equation (A2), which involves theta constants.

Table II and Table I

Table II lists the mass hierarchies obtained within OPMs, and Table I classifies the mass spectra in OPMs based on asymptotic regions. The meta-relation m2m3 p/q = √2 m1m3 is independent of ϵ and relates fermion masses within a given sector. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Curiously, for all the found OPMs (cf. Table II), the coefficients c1 and c2 describing the leading-order spectrum, in the notation c1 ϵ p : c2 ϵ q : 1, additionally obey √ 2 c1 = c p/q 2 , leading to the meta-relation m2 m3 p q = √ 2 m1 m3 , (11) which is independent of ϵ and relates fermion masses within a given sector.

The total number of possible assignments of representations for left-handed and right-handed fermion fields is finite. p. 7
Where the paper says it

8 Md(τ ) = αd vd   − √ 2 Y (2) 64,3 0 √ 2 Y (2) 64,4 Y (2) 64,5 − √ 2 Y (2) 64,1 −Y (2) 64,6 −Y (2) 64,6 − √ 2 Y (2) 64,2 Y (2) 64,5   ∼   2 √ 2 ϵ 8 0 − √ 2 4 √ 2 ϵ 5 −20 ϵ 11 12√ 2 ϵ 13 12√ 2 ϵ 13 −4 ϵ 3 4 √ 2 ϵ 5   + O(ϵ 16), (19) in a right-left convention. Both determinants are non-vanishing and seen to be O(ϵ 8 ).

The dimension of VVMF spaces is also known to be finite. p. 1
Where the paper says it

FRAMEWORK We consider a simple setup in flavour modular symmetry. We work in global N = 1 supersymmetry, with matter chiral superfields ψ i acquiring their masses from the Yukawa interactions in the superpotential, characterized by cubic terms of the type W ⊃ Yijk(τ ) ψiψjψk , (1) where the Yijk are the components of a vector-valued modular form (VVMF) (or modular form multiplet).

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Enhanced predictive power for fermion mass hierarchies by linking them to modular forms. The improved system can construct exact mass relations at the flavour scale based on one-parameter modular models (OPMs), which are highly constraining at the level of possible fermion hierarchies.

  2. Systematic search and classification of viable OPMs for different finite modular groups. The system can perform a systematic search, such as singling out Delta(96) and Delta(384), to find specific hierarchy patterns that are naturally close to observed charged-lepton and down-quark spectra.

  3. Precise determination of mass relations through renormalization group running and threshold corrections. The improved AI can confront high-scale modular relations with low-energy data by including renormalization group evolution between the flavour scale and the electroweak scale, as well as finite SUSY threshold corrections to isolate discrepancies like the muon mass prediction.

  4. Identification of specific physical constraints on OPM construction via representation theory. The system can enforce conditions such as among the representations r under which the VVMFs Y(k) ri transform, only one representation, r, can contract with psi c and psi to produce a trivial (non-vanishing) singlet.

  5. Generation of discrete sets of predictive curves in the hierarchy plane. Instead of flexible parametrization, the system can provide a discrete set of predictive curves in the hierarchy plane based on modular constructions, showing that OPMs do not provide a flexible parametrization of fermion masses, but rather a discrete set.

  6. Discovery and analysis of meta-relations between fermion masses. The system can derive exact relations such as m2 smτ = sqrt(2 mem2 b and m3 µ = sqrt(2 mem2 τ, which are fixed by the modular construction and do not rely on additional order-one flavour coefficients.

  7. Guidance for future theoretical research based on hierarchy pattern matching. The system can suggest hypothetical patterns, such as the H6 hierarchy, that follow the simple (integer) p/q = 2 scaling selected by the up-quark hierarchy and intersect the up-quark region under certain conditions.

Abstract

Modular flavour symmetries provide a possible organizing principle for the Standard Model Yukawa sector, by replacing generic couplings with a potentially small number of modular forms controlled by a single complex modulus. We study the extreme limit of this idea: One-Parameter Models, in which each charged-fermion mass matrix is fixed by a single modular invariant contraction. We develop a systematic method to construct such models, showing that the One-Parameter Model requirement is already highly constraining at the level of possible fermion hierarchies. In a concrete realization, the charged-lepton and down-quark sectors are controlled by the common modulus, leading to exact mass relations at the flavour scale, m s 5 = 2 sqrt 2,m d 3m b squared, m μ cubed = sqrt 2,m e m τ squared, m s 2m τ= sqrt 2,m e m b squared. We show that, once renormalization-group evolution and selective supersymmetric threshold effects are included, these high-scale relations can be made compatible with low-energy charged-fermion data. Our results provide a working proof of principle for One-Parameter Models and point towards a possible route to the flavour puzzle through highly constrained constructions.

Sources

Related papers