Charge Collection Efficiency in Air-Vented Plane-Parallel Ionisation Chambers at Ultra-High Dose Rates: A Self-Consistent Garfield++ Monte Carlo Model Including Space-Charge Effects and Ion Recombination
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Charge Collection Efficiency in Air-Vented Plane-Parallel Ionisation Chambers at Ultra-High Dose Rates".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) irradiation used in FLASH radiotherapy can lead to significant reductions in charge collection efficiency (CCE) in plane-parallel ionisation chambers (PPICs) due to enhanced ion recombination, while the high charge densities involved can also induce strong space-charge-induced electric-field distortions Modeling Coupled Effects The developed Monte Carlo model couples particle transport, electron attachment, recombination processes, and dynamic electric-field distortions The implementation was validated against analytical and numerical models from the literature The framework extends the Garfield++ Monte Carlo particle-transport framework by implementing ion–ion recombination and self-consistent space-charge electric field calculations Physical Mechanisms of Charge Transport The dominant mechanism responsible for the formation of negative ions in air is the attachment of electrons to oxygen molecules Two different attachment mechanisms exist: two-body and three-body attachment Electron transport is performed using AvalancheMicroscopic, which tracks electrons collision-by-collision at the microscopic level, while ion transport is handled by AvalancheMC, which uses Monte Carlo techniques to simulate ion drift lines Implementation of Recombination and Space Charge In ion–ion recombination processes, a distinction is usually made between initial and volume recombination Initial recombination occurs between ions of opposite charge created within the same ionisation track of an incident particle Volume recombination corresponds to recombination between ions originating from different particle tracks In contrast, volume recombination corresponds to recombination between ions originating from different particle tracks Impact of UHDR on Free Electron Fraction The reduction of the CCE under UHDR conditions is mainly driven by the decrease of the FEF caused by electric-field-dependent electron attachment The FEF p is given by p = 1/η d (1 − exp(−η d)) (21) As the DPP increases, the FEF progressively decreases This behaviour can be explained by the strong electric field distortion induced by space charge The results suggest that this behaviour originates from the strong dependence of the electron attachment coefficient on the local electric field The reduction of the CCE under UHDR conditions cannot be explained by a longer coexistence time of positive and negative ions within the chamber This observation suggests that the UHDR dosimetry problem in ionisation chambers may be largely reduced to the accurate description of the FEF evolution The implementation of these physical mechanisms within Garfield++ provides a complete, flexible, and self-consistent Monte Carlo framework capable of accurately reproducing UHDR effects in ionisation chambers Code Availability The two main physical processes implemented in this work, namely ion–ion recombination and space-charge electric-field calculations based on spatial grid discretisation, have been integrated into the open-source Garfield++ software (https://garfieldpp.docs.cern.ch) The complete simulation framework developed in this work, named GarFLIC (Garfield++ for FLASH Ionisation Chamber), is openly available at https://gitlab.com/blond-bay/garflic/tree/1.0.0 Acknowledgements This work and the associated doctoral research of Pierre Gérard Ortega were funded by the Walloon Region through the PIT ProtherWal programme under grant agreement No.
Kai: 7289 Computational resources have been provided by the Consortium des Équipements de Calcul Intensif (CÉCI), funded by the Fonds de la Recherche Scientifique de Belgique (F.R.S.-FNRS) under Grant No.
Mira: 2.5020.11 and by the Walloon Region The authors gratefully acknowledge José Paz Martín for his valuable support and insightful discussions References
1: V.
Kai: Favaudon et al.
Paper summary: Mira: So, looking at the Charge Collection Efficiency in Air-Vented Plane-Parallel Ionisation Chambers at Ultra-High Dose Rates: A Self-Consistent Garfield++ Monte Carlo Model Including Space-Charge Effects and Ion Recombination, we see they are putting together a self consistent Monte Carlo model to handle both ion recombination and space charge effects.
Lev: It’s about getting a picture of what happens when you have those intense dose rates and all that ion activity happening inside the chamber simultaneously <ref:2606.24384#pg1>.
Kai: It sets a new standard for modeling these challenging phenomena in ion chambers.
Conclusion: Kai: So, we’re wrapping up this talk on "Charge Collection Efficiency in Air-Vented Plane-Parallel Ionisation Chambers at Ultra-High Dose Rates: A Self-Consistent Garfield++ Monte Carlo Model Including Space-Charge Effects and Ion Recombination."
Mira: It boils down to taking a standard simulation and adding the complex stuff—how ions recombine and how the electric field gets messed up by all those ions.
Lev: What this means for us is that when you’re pushing these devices to their limits with high dose rates, you can't just use simple old models anymore because they miss that dynamic distortion.
Kai: I mean if we’re building experimental setups, we need to know exactly how the charge actually gets collected at those high speeds, and this model is trying to capture that self-consistent reality.
Mira: And the authors say their method is more accurate than previous approaches because it accounts for how the electron attachment coefficient changes based on that local electric field.
Lev: That dependence on the electric field is a huge thing; it suggests we need to focus our error analysis on that specific relationship when designing real hardware.
Kai: So if you look at the title, "Charge Collection Efficiency in Air-Vented Plane-Parallel Ionisation Chambers at Ultra-High Dose Rates: A Self-Consistent Garfield++ Monte Carlo Model Including Space-Charge Effects and Ion Recombination," it really tells you exactly what physics they are trying to handle.
Mira: They are tackling the coupling between ion recombination and space charge effects, which is usually treated separately in simpler models.
Lev: The core research here is building a self-consistent Monte Carlo framework that handles these things together for the first time in this context.
Kai: It’s about getting a picture of what happens when you have those intense dose rates and all that ion activity happening inside the chamber simultaneously.
Mira: And they show that this approach reveals how much the free electron fraction changes depending on where you are in the chamber, which is critical for accurate measurement.
Lev: It points toward a new way to think about ultra high dose rate dosimetry problems, moving beyond just static measurements to understanding the dynamic evolution of charge collection.
Kai: This work gives us a very detailed tool to simulate these complex physical interactions under extreme conditions.
Mira: And since they made the framework open source, researchers can use it to test their own assumptions about how recombination and space charge interact in these chambers.
Lev: So this paper is providing the necessary physics for anyone trying to design or measure detectors in FLASH environments.
Kai: It sets a new standard for modeling these challenging phenomena in ion chambers.
Mira: This opens up a whole new level of testing how those physical mechanisms actually play out when you crank up the dose rate.
Lev: We need to see if this framework holds up when we move from simulation to building actual hardware components that need to survive those conditions.
Service de Physique des particules elementaires (IIHE) University libre de Bruxelles · Ion Beam Applications SA
physics.med-ph, physics.ins-det
Submitted: 2026-06-23
Updated: 2026-09-17
Comments: 18 pages, 11 figures
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 71/100
The gist: Ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) irradiation used in FLASH radiotherapy can lead to significant reductions in charge collection efficiency (CCE) in plane-parallel ionisation chambers (PPICs) due to…
Key concepts
- Charge Collection Efficiency (CCE)
- This measures how effectively an ionization chamber collects the charge produced by incident radiation. In this context, it is reduced under UHDR because strong electric fields distort the space, affecting electron movement and collection.
- Ion-Ion Recombination
- This process describes when positive and negative ions created in the same track recombine. The model distinguishes between initial recombination (ions from the same track) and volume recombination (ions from different tracks), both of which affect charge transport.
- Space-Charge Electric Field Distortions
- When high densities of ions are present, they create a strong electric field distortion. This distortion is a key factor in reducing CCE under UHDR because the electron attachment coefficient becomes dependent on this local electric field strength.
Terminology
Summary
Ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) irradiation used in FLASH radiotherapy can lead to significant reductions in charge collection efficiency (CCE) in plane-parallel ionisation chambers (PPICs) due to enhanced ion recombination, while the high charge densities involved can also induce strong space-charge-induced electric-field distortions
Modeling Coupled Effects
The developed Monte Carlo model couples particle transport, electron attachment, recombination processes, and dynamic electric-field distortions The implementation was validated against analytical and numerical models from the literature The framework extends the Garfield++ Monte Carlo particle-transport framework by implementing ion–ion recombination and self-consistent space-charge electric field calculations
Physical Mechanisms of Charge Transport
The dominant mechanism responsible for the formation of negative ions in air is the attachment of electrons to oxygen molecules Two different attachment mechanisms exist: two-body and three-body attachment Electron transport is performed using AvalancheMicroscopic, which tracks electrons collision-by-collision at the microscopic level, while ion transport is handled by AvalancheMC, which uses Monte Carlo techniques to simulate ion drift lines
Implementation of Recombination and Space Charge
In ion–ion recombination processes, a distinction is usually made between initial and volume recombination Initial recombination occurs between ions of opposite charge created within the same ionisation track of an incident particle Volume recombination corresponds to recombination between ions originating from different particle tracks In contrast, volume recombination corresponds to recombination between ions originating from different particle tracks
Impact of UHDR on Free Electron Fraction
The reduction of the CCE under UHDR conditions is mainly driven by the decrease of the FEF caused by electric-field-dependent electron attachment The FEF p is given by p = 1/η d (1 − exp(−η d)) (21) As the DPP increases, the FEF progressively decreases This behaviour can be explained by the strong electric field distortion induced by space charge
Conclusion and Future Directions
The results suggest that this behaviour originates from the strong dependence of the electron attachment coefficient on the local electric field The reduction of the CCE under UHDR conditions cannot be explained by a longer coexistence time of positive and negative ions within the chamber This observation suggests that the UHDR dosimetry problem in ionisation chambers may be largely reduced to the accurate description of the FEF evolution The implementation of these physical mechanisms within Garfield++ provides a complete, flexible, and self-consistent Monte Carlo framework capable of accurately reproducing UHDR effects in ionisation chambers
Code Availability
The two main physical processes implemented in this work, namely ion–ion recombination and space-charge electric-field calculations based on spatial grid discretisation, have been integrated into the open-source Garfield++ software (https://garfieldpp.docs.cern.ch) The complete simulation framework developed in this work, named GarFLIC (Garfield++ for FLASH Ionisation Chamber), is openly available at https://gitlab. p. 0 This finding indicates that the complex problem of
recombination under UHDR conditions may be largely governed by the evolution of the FEF, opening
promising perspectives for the development of improved analytical models and real-time correction
methods for ionisation chamber dosimetry under UHDR irradiation conditions. This work provides a flexible and self-consistent Monte Carlo framework for investigating recombination
phenomena and improving dosimetry models for FLASH radiotherapy.Where the paper says it
Acknowledgements
This work and the associated doctoral research of Pierre Gérard Ortega were funded by the Walloon Region through the PIT ProtherWal programme under grant agreement No. 7289 Computational resources have been provided by the Consortium des Équipements de Calcul Intensif (CÉCI), funded by the Fonds de la Recherche Scientifique de Belgique (F.R.S.-FNRS) under Grant No. 2.5020.11 and by the Walloon Region The authors gratefully acknowledge José Paz Martín for his valuable support and insightful discussions
References
[1] V. Favaudon et al. p. 0 This work provides a flexible and self-consistent Monte Carlo framework for investigating recombination
phenomena and improving dosimetry models for FLASH radiotherapy. Keywords: plane-parallel ionisation chambers, UHDR, charge collection efficiency, recombination,
space charge, Monte Carlo simulation
1 Introduction
Since the discovery of what is now referred to as
the FLASH effect by Favaudon et al. Subsequent studies have confirmed normal-tissue sparing in a variety of preclinical models and tissues. In
particular, FLASH irradiation was shown to improve
survival following abdominal irradiation in mice [2],
preserve cognitive function after whole-brain irradiation [3], and reduce brain toxicity using both electron
and X-ray beams [4, 5]. Keywords: plane-parallel ionisation chambers, UHDR, charge collection efficiency, recombination,
space charge, Monte Carlo simulation
1 Introduction
Since the discovery of what is now referred to as
the FLASH effect by Favaudon et al. [1] in 2014,
research on ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) radiation
(≥ 40 Gy s−1
) has grown rapidly.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[2] B. W. Loo et al. “(P003) Delivery of Ultra-Rapid Flash Radiation Therapy and Demonstration of Normal Tissue Sparing After Abdominal Irradiation of Mice”. p. 0 Subsequent studies have confirmed normal-tissue sparing in a variety of preclinical models and tissues. In
particular, FLASH irradiation was shown to improve
survival following abdominal irradiation in mice [2],
preserve cognitive function after whole-brain irradiation [3], and reduce brain toxicity using both electron
and X-ray beams [4, 5]. be
widen the therapeutic window of radiotherapy. Ionisation chambers (ICs) are the reference
dosimeters recommended by the International Atomic
Energy Agency (IAEA) [7] for the determination of absorbed dose to water.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[3] P. Montay-Gruel et al. “Irradiation in a flash: Unique sparing of memory in mice after whole brain irradiation with dose rates above 100Gy/s”. p. 0 Subsequent studies have confirmed normal-tissue sparing in a variety of preclinical models and tissues. In
particular, FLASH irradiation was shown to improve
survival following abdominal irradiation in mice [2],
preserve cognitive function after whole-brain irradiation [3], and reduce brain toxicity using both electron
and X-ray beams [4, 5]. Charge Collection Efficiency in Air-Vented
Plane-Parallel Ionisation Chambers at Ultra-High Dose
Rates
A Self-Consistent Garfield++ Monte Carlo Model Including Space-Charge
Effects and Ion Recombination
Pierre Gérard Ortega1,∗
, Gilles De Lentdecker1
, Quentin Flandroy2
, Jarrick Nys2
1 Service de Physique des particules élémentaires (IIHE), Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB), Brussels, Belgium
2
Ion Beam Applications SA, Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium
September 18, 2026
Abstract
Ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) irradiation used in FLASH radiotherapy can lead to significant reductions
in charge collection efficiency (CCE) in plane-parallel ionisation chambers (PPICs) due to enhanced ion
recombination, while the high charge densities involved can also induce strong space-charge-induced
electric-field distortions. To investigate these coupled effects, we extended the Garfield++ Monte Carlo
particle-transport framework by implementing ion–ion recombination and self-consistent space-charge
electric field calculations. be
widen the therapeutic window of radiotherapy. Ionisation chambers (ICs) are the reference
dosimeters recommended by the International Atomic
Energy Agency (IAEA) [7] for the determination of absorbed dose to water.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[4] P. Montay-Gruel et al. “X-rays can trigger the FLASH effect: Ultra-high dose-rate synchrotron light source prevents normal brain injury after whole brain irradiation in mice”. p. 0 In
particular, FLASH irradiation was shown to improve
survival following abdominal irradiation in mice [2],
preserve cognitive function after whole-brain irradiation [3], and reduce brain toxicity using both electron
and X-ray beams [4, 5]. The FLASH effect has also
been demonstrated in larger animals and veterinary
cancer patients [6], further highlighting its potential to
∗Corresponding author: pierre. Charge Collection Efficiency in Air-Vented
Plane-Parallel Ionisation Chambers at Ultra-High Dose
Rates
A Self-Consistent Garfield++ Monte Carlo Model Including Space-Charge
Effects and Ion Recombination
Pierre Gérard Ortega1,∗
, Gilles De Lentdecker1
, Quentin Flandroy2
, Jarrick Nys2
1 Service de Physique des particules élémentaires (IIHE), Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB), Brussels, Belgium
2
Ion Beam Applications SA, Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium
September 18, 2026
Abstract
Ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) irradiation used in FLASH radiotherapy can lead to significant reductions
in charge collection efficiency (CCE) in plane-parallel ionisation chambers (PPICs) due to enhanced ion
recombination, while the high charge densities involved can also induce strong space-charge-induced
electric-field distortions. To investigate these coupled effects, we extended the Garfield++ Monte Carlo
particle-transport framework by implementing ion–ion recombination and self-consistent space-charge
electric field calculations.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[5] P. Montay-Gruel et al. “Long-term neurocognitive benefits of FLASH radiotherapy driven by reduced reactive oxygen species”. In: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 116.22 (2019), pp. 10943–10951. doi: 10.1073/pnas. 1901777 >
[6] M.-C. Vozenin et al. “The Advantage of FLASH Radiotherapy Confirmed in Mini-pig and Catcancer Patients”. p. 0 Subsequent studies have confirmed normal-tissue sparing in a variety of preclinical models and tissues. In
particular, FLASH irradiation was shown to improve
survival following abdominal irradiation in mice [2],
preserve cognitive function after whole-brain irradiation [3], and reduce brain toxicity using both electron
and X-ray beams [4, 5]. Keywords: plane-parallel ionisation chambers, UHDR, charge collection efficiency, recombination,
space charge, Monte Carlo simulation
1 Introduction
Since the discovery of what is now referred to as
the FLASH effect by Favaudon et al. [1] in 2014,
research on ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) radiation
(≥ 40 Gy s−1
) has grown rapidly.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[7] INTERNATIONAL ATOMIC ENERGY AGENCY. Absorbed Dose Determination in External Beam Radiotherapy. p. 0 Ionisation chambers (ICs) are the reference
dosimeters recommended by the International Atomic
Energy Agency (IAEA) [7] for the determination of absorbed dose to water. In particular, plane-parallel ionisation chambers (PPICs) are widely used in radiotherapy both for reference dosimetry and for beam monitoring during patient treatment. be
widen the therapeutic window of radiotherapy. Ionisation chambers (ICs) are the reference
dosimeters recommended by the International Atomic
Energy Agency (IAEA) [7] for the determination of absorbed dose to water. be
widen the therapeutic window of radiotherapy. Ionisation chambers (ICs) are the reference
dosimeters recommended by the International Atomic
Energy Agency (IAEA) [7] for the determination of absorbed dose to water.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[8] “Metrology for advanced radiotherapy using particle beams with ultra-high dose rates”. In: Physics in Medicine & Biology 69. p. 0 1
arXiv:2606. 24384v2 [physics. 1
arXiv:2606. 24384v2 [physics. 10
1 10
0 10
1 10
2
10
24
10
25
Magboltz
Davies and Chantry (1985)
de Urquijo (2024)
Reduced electric field E/N [Td]
Ele
ctro
n
m
o
bility
e
N [V
1 m 1 s
1
]
(a) Electron mobility in dry air. 10
1 10
0 10
1 10
2
10
48
10
47
Magboltz
Davies and Chantry (1985)
de Urquijo (2024)
Reduced electric field E/N [Td]
Atta
c
h
m
e
nt c
o
e
f
ficie
nt /N
2
[m5
]
(b) Electron attachment coefficient in dry air.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[9] A. Bourgouin et al. “Charge collection efficiency of commercially available parallel-plate ionisation chambers in ultra-high dose-per-pulse electron beams”. p. 0 In particular, plane-parallel ionisation chambers (PPICs) are widely used in radiotherapy both for reference dosimetry and for beam monitoring during patient treatment. However, dosimetry
under UHDR conditions remains challenging [8], and
experimental studies of commercially available PPICs
have shown a strong dependence of their charge collection efficiency on dose per pulse, while also highlighting the need for improved ion recombination models
for accurate dosimetry under UHDR conditions [9]. 1
arXiv:2606. 24384v2 [physics. 1
arXiv:2606. 24384v2 [physics.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[10] J. W. Boag. “Ionization Measurements at Very High Intensities. p. 0 Charge Collection Efficiency in Air-Vented
Plane-Parallel Ionisation Chambers at Ultra-High Dose
Rates
A Self-Consistent Garfield++ Monte Carlo Model Including Space-Charge
Effects and Ion Recombination
Pierre Gérard Ortega1,∗
, Gilles De Lentdecker1
, Quentin Flandroy2
, Jarrick Nys2
1 Service de Physique des particules élémentaires (IIHE), Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB), Brussels, Belgium
2
Ion Beam Applications SA, Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium
September 18, 2026
Abstract
Ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) irradiation used in FLASH radiotherapy can lead to significant reductions
in charge collection efficiency (CCE) in plane-parallel ionisation chambers (PPICs) due to enhanced ion
recombination, while the high charge densities involved can also induce strong space-charge-induced
electric-field distortions. To investigate these coupled effects, we extended the Garfield++ Monte Carlo
particle-transport framework by implementing ion–ion recombination and self-consistent space-charge
electric field calculations. Several studies [17,
18, 19] have shown that these distortions can locally exceed the nominal applied electric field by several times. To better understand recombination effects in
PPICs under UHDR pulsed beams, we extended the
Garfield++ [20] framework and developed a selfconsistent Monte Carlo simulation coupling particle
transport, electron attachment, ion–ion recombination,
and space-charge effects.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[11] J. W. Boag, E. Hochhäuser, and O. p. 1 Under conventional radiotherapy conditions, ion
recombination corrections are commonly performed using the two-voltage method, which is based on the
model originally developed by Boag [10] in 1950. This
model was later extended by Boag, Hochhäuser, and
Balk [11] in 1996 to account for the fraction of electrons
escaping attachment to electronegative molecules, referred to as the free electron fraction (FEF). Keywords: plane-parallel ionisation chambers, UHDR, charge collection efficiency, recombination,
space charge, Monte Carlo simulation
1 Introduction
Since the discovery of what is now referred to as
the FLASH effect by Favaudon et al. [1] in 2014,
research on ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) radiation
(≥ 40 Gy s−1
) has grown rapidly. 1
arXiv:2606. 24384v2 [physics. Under conventional radiotherapy conditions, ion
recombination corrections are commonly performed using the two-voltage method, which is based on the
model originally developed by Boag [10] in 1950. This
model was later extended by Boag, Hochhäuser, and
Balk [11] in 1996 to account for the fraction of electrons
escaping attachment to electronegative molecules, referred to as the free electron fraction (FEF).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[12] P. R. Almond et al. “AAPM’s TG-51 protocol for clinical reference dosimetry of high-energy photon and electron beams”. p. 0 Ionisation chambers (ICs) are the reference
dosimeters recommended by the International Atomic
Energy Agency (IAEA) [7] for the determination of absorbed dose to water. In particular, plane-parallel ionisation chambers (PPICs) are widely used in radiotherapy both for reference dosimetry and for beam monitoring during patient treatment. 1
arXiv:2606. 24384v2 [physics.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[13] R. F. Laitano et al. “Charge Collection Efficiency in Ionization Chambers Exposed to Electron Beams with High Dose per Pulse”. p. 0 In particular, plane-parallel ionisation chambers (PPICs) are widely used in radiotherapy both for reference dosimetry and for beam monitoring during patient treatment. However, dosimetry
under UHDR conditions remains challenging [8], and
experimental studies of commercially available PPICs
have shown a strong dependence of their charge collection efficiency on dose per pulse, while also highlighting the need for improved ion recombination models
for accurate dosimetry under UHDR conditions [9]. 1
arXiv:2606. 24384v2 [physics.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[14] J. D. Fenwick and S. p. 6 In all charge-transport simulations presented here,
electron–ion pairs were generated directly and uniformly within the irradiated volume. A square temporal pulse profile was used, except for the comparison
with the Boag and Fenwick models in Section 4. Charge Collection Efficiency in Air-Vented
Plane-Parallel Ionisation Chambers at Ultra-High Dose
Rates
A Self-Consistent Garfield++ Monte Carlo Model Including Space-Charge
Effects and Ion Recombination
Pierre Gérard Ortega1,∗
, Gilles De Lentdecker1
, Quentin Flandroy2
, Jarrick Nys2
1 Service de Physique des particules élémentaires (IIHE), Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB), Brussels, Belgium
2
Ion Beam Applications SA, Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium
September 18, 2026
Abstract
Ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) irradiation used in FLASH radiotherapy can lead to significant reductions
in charge collection efficiency (CCE) in plane-parallel ionisation chambers (PPICs) due to enhanced ion
recombination, while the high charge densities involved can also induce strong space-charge-induced
electric-field distortions. To investigate these coupled effects, we extended the Garfield++ Monte Carlo
particle-transport framework by implementing ion–ion recombination and self-consistent space-charge
electric field calculations. 4 Results and discussion
4. 1 Charge collection efficiency without
space charge
In 2023, Fenwick and Kumar [14] revisited Boag’s
model proposed in 1996 and highlighted one of its main
limitations: the oversimplified assumption regarding
the spatial distribution of anions.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[15] M. Orts et al. “Monte Carlo Simulation of Initial and Volume Ion Recombination Correction Factor in Plane Parallel Ionization Chambers Exposed to Ion Beams”. p. 0 Charge Collection Efficiency in Air-Vented
Plane-Parallel Ionisation Chambers at Ultra-High Dose
Rates
A Self-Consistent Garfield++ Monte Carlo Model Including Space-Charge
Effects and Ion Recombination
Pierre Gérard Ortega1,∗
, Gilles De Lentdecker1
, Quentin Flandroy2
, Jarrick Nys2
1 Service de Physique des particules élémentaires (IIHE), Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB), Brussels, Belgium
2
Ion Beam Applications SA, Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium
September 18, 2026
Abstract
Ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) irradiation used in FLASH radiotherapy can lead to significant reductions
in charge collection efficiency (CCE) in plane-parallel ionisation chambers (PPICs) due to enhanced ion
recombination, while the high charge densities involved can also induce strong space-charge-induced
electric-field distortions. To investigate these coupled effects, we extended the Garfield++ Monte Carlo
particle-transport framework by implementing ion–ion recombination and self-consistent space-charge
electric field calculations. 10
1 10
0 10
1 10
2
10
24
10
25
Magboltz
Davies and Chantry (1985)
de Urquijo (2024)
Reduced electric field E/N [Td]
Ele
ctro
n
m
o
bility
e
N [V
1 m 1 s
1
]
(a) Electron mobility in dry air. 10
1 10
0 10
1 10
2
10
48
10
47
Magboltz
Davies and Chantry (1985)
de Urquijo (2024)
Reduced electric field E/N [Td]
Atta
c
h
m
e
nt c
o
e
f
ficie
nt /N
2
[m5
]
(b) Electron attachment coefficient in dry air.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[17] R. Kranzer et al. p. 7 In particular, the electric field can locally
exceed four times the nominal applied field, while dropping to nearly zero in other regions of the chamber. Moreover, very good agreement is observed with
the results reported by Kranzer et al. Charge Collection Efficiency in Air-Vented
Plane-Parallel Ionisation Chambers at Ultra-High Dose
Rates
A Self-Consistent Garfield++ Monte Carlo Model Including Space-Charge
Effects and Ion Recombination
Pierre Gérard Ortega1,∗
, Gilles De Lentdecker1
, Quentin Flandroy2
, Jarrick Nys2
1 Service de Physique des particules élémentaires (IIHE), Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB), Brussels, Belgium
2
Ion Beam Applications SA, Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium
September 18, 2026
Abstract
Ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) irradiation used in FLASH radiotherapy can lead to significant reductions
in charge collection efficiency (CCE) in plane-parallel ionisation chambers (PPICs) due to enhanced ion
recombination, while the high charge densities involved can also induce strong space-charge-induced
electric-field distortions. To investigate these coupled effects, we extended the Garfield++ Monte Carlo
particle-transport framework by implementing ion–ion recombination and self-consistent space-charge
electric field calculations. 1
arXiv:2606. 24384v2 [physics.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[18] L. Baack et al. “Reduction of Recombination Effects in Large Plane Parallel Beam Monitors for FLASH Radiotherapy with Scanned Ion Beams”. p. 0 Charge Collection Efficiency in Air-Vented
Plane-Parallel Ionisation Chambers at Ultra-High Dose
Rates
A Self-Consistent Garfield++ Monte Carlo Model Including Space-Charge
Effects and Ion Recombination
Pierre Gérard Ortega1,∗
, Gilles De Lentdecker1
, Quentin Flandroy2
, Jarrick Nys2
1 Service de Physique des particules élémentaires (IIHE), Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB), Brussels, Belgium
2
Ion Beam Applications SA, Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium
September 18, 2026
Abstract
Ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) irradiation used in FLASH radiotherapy can lead to significant reductions
in charge collection efficiency (CCE) in plane-parallel ionisation chambers (PPICs) due to enhanced ion
recombination, while the high charge densities involved can also induce strong space-charge-induced
electric-field distortions. To investigate these coupled effects, we extended the Garfield++ Monte Carlo
particle-transport framework by implementing ion–ion recombination and self-consistent space-charge
electric field calculations. 1
arXiv:2606. 24384v2 [physics.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[35] R. Brun and F. Rademakers. “ROOT: An Object Oriented Data Analysis Framework”. p. 2 To achieve this, several existing Garfield++ classes and methods were extended to account for space-charge effects and ion–ion
recombination. 1 Garfield++ simulation toolkit
Garfield++ [20] is an object-oriented simulation toolkit
dedicated to the study of charged particle transport
and interactions in gases and semiconductors.Where the paper says it
[36] I. B. Smirnov. “Modeling of Ionization Produced by Fast Charged Particles in Gases”. p. 2 Originally developed by Rob Veenhof and now actively
maintained at CERN, Garfield++ combines Monte
Carlo transport techniques with electric and magnetic
field maps to simulate charged particle transport in detector systems. The framework interfaces with several external
packages, including ROOT [35] for visualisation, Magboltz [24] for the calculation of electron transport properties in gas mixtures, and Heed [36] for the simulation
of primary ionisation produced by charged particles.Where the paper says it
[37] H. Schindler. “Microscopic Simulation of Particle Detectors”. p. 1 1 Electron swarm parameters and attachment processes
The dominant mechanism responsible for the formation
of negative ions in air is the attachment of electrons
to oxygen molecules. Unlike noble gases, often used
in gaseous detectors to avoid such phenomena, oxygen
requires only a relatively low collision energy to capture
free electrons.Where the paper says it
[38] J. M. Dawson. “Particle Simulation of Plasmas”. p. 1 Several studies [17,
18, 19] have shown that these distortions can locally exceed the nominal applied electric field by several times. To better understand recombination effects in
PPICs under UHDR pulsed beams, we extended the
Garfield++ [20] framework and developed a selfconsistent Monte Carlo simulation coupling particle
transport, electron attachment, ion–ion recombination,
and space-charge effects. 1
arXiv:2606. 24384v2 [physics.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[39] J. Villasenor and O. Buneman. “Rigorous Charge Conservation for Local Electromagnetic Field Solvers”. p. 0 Charge Collection Efficiency in Air-Vented
Plane-Parallel Ionisation Chambers at Ultra-High Dose
Rates
A Self-Consistent Garfield++ Monte Carlo Model Including Space-Charge
Effects and Ion Recombination
Pierre Gérard Ortega1,∗
, Gilles De Lentdecker1
, Quentin Flandroy2
, Jarrick Nys2
1 Service de Physique des particules élémentaires (IIHE), Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB), Brussels, Belgium
2
Ion Beam Applications SA, Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium
September 18, 2026
Abstract
Ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) irradiation used in FLASH radiotherapy can lead to significant reductions
in charge collection efficiency (CCE) in plane-parallel ionisation chambers (PPICs) due to enhanced ion
recombination, while the high charge densities involved can also induce strong space-charge-induced
electric-field distortions. To investigate these coupled effects, we extended the Garfield++ Monte Carlo
particle-transport framework by implementing ion–ion recombination and self-consistent space-charge
electric field calculations. 1
arXiv:2606. 24384v2 [physics.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[40] C. K. Birdsall, A. B. Langdon, and A. B. Langdon. Plasma Physics via Computer Simulation. p. 0 1
arXiv:2606. 24384v2 [physics.Where the paper says it
[41] R. W. Hockney and J. W. Eastwood. Computer Simulation Using Particles. p. 2 The TrackHeed class simulates the ionisation pattern
produced by relativistic charged particles. Electron
transport is performed using AvalancheMicroscopic,
which tracks electrons collision-by-collision at the microscopic level, while ion transport is handled by
AvalancheMC, which uses Monte Carlo techniques to
simulate ion drift lines.Where the paper says it
[42] L. Seidel. “Über ein Verfahren, die Gleichungen, auf welche die Methode der kleinsten Quadrate führt, sowie lineare Gleichungen überhaupt, durch successive Annäherung aufzulösen.” In: Abhandlungen der Mathematisch-Physikalischen Klasse der Königlich Bayerischen Akademie der Wissenschaften 11.3 (1874), pp.: 81–108. url: https: //www. biodiversitylibrary. org / item/110049>
[43] D. Young. “Iterative Methods for Solving Partial Difference Equations of Elliptic Type”. p. 5 A detailed description of the
algorithm is given in Appendix B. Solving the Poisson equation with an iterative
method is computationally advantageous in comparison, for instance, with the particle-to-particle or nodeto-node methods.Where the paper says it
[44] W. Shockley. “Currents to Conductors Induced by a Moving Point Charge”. p. 5 The
total electric field is the sum of the electric fields of
each component. This class also allows the calculation
of currents induced by drifting charged particles using
the Shockley–Ramo theorem [44, 45]. 1
arXiv:2606. 24384v2 [physics.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[45] S. Ramo. “Currents Induced by Electron Motion”. p. 5 This class also allows the calculation
of currents induced by drifting charged particles using
the Shockley–Ramo theorem [44, 45]. The pulse structure can be recreated in two different ways: either by assuming that ionisation is homogeneous and isotropic in the chamber and distributing the electron–ion pairs accordingly, or by using theWhere the paper says it
[46] D. C. Meeker. “Improvised Asymptotic Boundary Conditions for Electrostatic Finite Elements”. p. 7 This configuration provides a known analytical solution for the
electric field while remaining representative of charge
distributions encountered in PPICs. To approximate open boundary conditions within
a finite computational domain, mixed boundary conditions were applied. Keywords: plane-parallel ionisation chambers, UHDR, charge collection efficiency, recombination,
space charge, Monte Carlo simulation
1 Introduction
Since the discovery of what is now referred to as
the FLASH effect by Favaudon et al. [1] in 2014,
research on ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) radiation
(≥ 40 Gy s−1
) has grown rapidly.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[47] J. Jin. The Finite Element Method in Electromagnetics. p. 7 This configuration provides a known analytical solution for the
electric field while remaining representative of charge
distributions encountered in PPICs. To approximate open boundary conditions within
a finite computational domain, mixed boundary conditions were applied.Where the paper says it
[48] J. Paz-Martín et al. p. 8 Such perturbations strongly affect electron and ion
transport properties, including drift velocity, mobility,
and electron attachment coefficient, thereby modifying
the free electron fraction. 3 Free electron fraction
Following the work of Paz-Martín et al. Charge Collection Efficiency in Air-Vented
Plane-Parallel Ionisation Chambers at Ultra-High Dose
Rates
A Self-Consistent Garfield++ Monte Carlo Model Including Space-Charge
Effects and Ion Recombination
Pierre Gérard Ortega1,∗
, Gilles De Lentdecker1
, Quentin Flandroy2
, Jarrick Nys2
1 Service de Physique des particules élémentaires (IIHE), Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB), Brussels, Belgium
2
Ion Beam Applications SA, Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium
September 18, 2026
Abstract
Ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) irradiation used in FLASH radiotherapy can lead to significant reductions
in charge collection efficiency (CCE) in plane-parallel ionisation chambers (PPICs) due to enhanced ion
recombination, while the high charge densities involved can also induce strong space-charge-induced
electric-field distortions. To investigate these coupled effects, we extended the Garfield++ Monte Carlo
particle-transport framework by implementing ion–ion recombination and self-consistent space-charge
electric field calculations.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[33] S. McGowan. “Ion-Ion Recombination in Laboratory Air”. p. 0 Charge Collection Efficiency in Air-Vented
Plane-Parallel Ionisation Chambers at Ultra-High Dose
Rates
A Self-Consistent Garfield++ Monte Carlo Model Including Space-Charge
Effects and Ion Recombination
Pierre Gérard Ortega1,∗
, Gilles De Lentdecker1
, Quentin Flandroy2
, Jarrick Nys2
1 Service de Physique des particules élémentaires (IIHE), Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB), Brussels, Belgium
2
Ion Beam Applications SA, Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium
September 18, 2026
Abstract
Ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) irradiation used in FLASH radiotherapy can lead to significant reductions
in charge collection efficiency (CCE) in plane-parallel ionisation chambers (PPICs) due to enhanced ion
recombination, while the high charge densities involved can also induce strong space-charge-induced
electric-field distortions. To investigate these coupled effects, we extended the Garfield++ Monte Carlo
particle-transport framework by implementing ion–ion recombination and self-consistent space-charge
electric field calculations. 1
arXiv:2606. 24384v2 [physics.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved dosimetry models can accurately predict charge collection efficiency under ultra-high dose rate irradiation by incorporating self-consistent space-charge electric field calculations and ion recombination processes, as demonstrated by extending Garfield++ to couple particle transport, electron attachment, and ion ion recombination.
-
The improved system can calculate the free electron fraction (FEF) under ultra-high dose rate conditions by accounting for electric field dependent electron attachment, which is shown to be the primary driver of CCE reduction.
-
The AI system can simulate the temporal evolution of electric field distortions inside ionization chambers, reproducing results like
the electric field can locally exceed four times the nominal applied field or drop to nearly zero in some regions of the chamber
after a pulse. -
The framework enables the development of real-time correction methods for ionisation chamber dosimetry under ultra-high dose rate irradiation by providing a flexible and self-consistent Monte Carlo simulation environment.
-
The system can accurately reproduce charge collection efficiency as a function of dose per pulse (DPP) by comparing simulation results with experimental data, validating the model's ability to handle space-charge effects and recombination under UHDR conditions.
Abstract
Ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) irradiation used in FLASH radiotherapy can lead to significant reductions in charge collection efficiency (CCE) in plane-parallel ionisation chambers (PPICs) due to enhanced ion recombination, while the high charge densities involved can also induce strong space-charge-induced electric-field distortions. To investigate these coupled effects, we extended the Garfield++ Monte Carlo particle-transport framework by implementing ion--ion recombination and self-consistent space-charge electric field calculations. The developed Monte Carlo model couples particle transport, electron attachment, recombination processes, and dynamic electric-field distortions. The implementation was validated against analytical and numerical models from the literature. Excellent agreement was obtained for the free electron fraction (FEF), CCE, induced current, and electric field evolution under UHDR conditions. The simulations show that space charge can locally increase the electric field by more than a factor of four or reduce it to nearly zero in some regions of the chamber. The results further suggest that the reduction of the CCE under UHDR conditions is mainly driven by the decrease of the FEF caused by electric-field-dependent electron attachment. This finding indicates that the complex problem of recombination under UHDR conditions may be largely governed by the evolution of the FEF, opening promising perspectives for the development of improved analytical models and real-time correction methods for ionisation chamber dosimetry under UHDR irradiation conditions. This work provides a flexible and self-consistent Monte Carlo framework for investigating recombination phenomena and improving dosimetry models for FLASH radiotherapy.
Related papers
- BART Online Open-Source Sequence Toolbox for Computational MRI
- Constrained estimation of rotational invariants of the cumulant expansion (RICE) for rapid tensor-valued diffusion MRI
- Improved Myelin Water Fraction Estimation and Uncertainty Mapping in Multicomponent T2 Relaxometry via NNLS Bootstrap Aggregation
- Radiation damage to normal mammalian tissue in vivo with laser-driven protons at ultra-high instantaneous dose rate
- Fast ungated five-dimensional cardiac MRI on a 1.5 T MR-linac for MRI-guided radiotherapy
- BEAM3R: Beam's-eye-view architecture with Mamba-3 for implicit dose reconstruction