Instabilities of the continuous superradiant laser
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Instabilities of the continuous superradiant laser".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We investigate the intensity stability of the superradiant laser Our study focuses on the architecture where a continuous beam of atoms in an electronically excited state crosses the mode of a high-finesse Fabry-Perot cavity, which has been proposed as a new architecture of an active optical clock We show that such superradiant laser can become unstable and develop chaotic behavior We derive an analytical criterion for this instability and find that it may only occur when the lifetime of photons in the cavity is significantly shorter than the lifetime of atoms This criterion allows for refining the necessary parameters to run a superradiant laser as a frequency reference in the optical domain Modeling the System Dynamics The modeling of a superradiant laser is initiated by considering N atoms with ground and excited electronic levels g⟩, e⟩ resonantly coupled to a cavity.
Kai: The effective Hamiltonian H = H0 + κ 2i (b†⟨b⟩ − b⟨b†⟩) describes the system, where photons losses are thus described by a single leak-rate parameter κ corresponding to the cavity photon lifetime.
Mira: The evolution of the system is computed using mean-field approximation and leads to equations describing the dynamics of atomic and field operators.
Kai: Instability Criteria and Mapping The criterion for dynamical instability arises when one eigenvalue of the linearized matrix M has a positive real part, specifically when κ > 4ΓR N > κ 2(8ΓR + κ) / 4g 2(κ - 4ΓR).
Title and authors: Kai: So, we're looking at this paper titled "Instabilities of the continuous superradiant laser". It comes from Bruno Laburthe-Tolra, Martin Robert-de-Saint-Vincent, and Benjamin Pasquiou. They are investigating how stable a superradiant laser is when you have a continuous beam of atoms crossing the cavity mode.
Mira: Yeah, it's interesting because they propose this as a new way to build an active optical clock architecture. The core idea is that we can get instability and chaotic behavior in this system, which makes it less ideal for some kinds of measurements.
Lev: From my side, I'm thinking about how that instability translates to real hardware. If you were building this on a quantum computer or a sensor device, you'd need to know if your parameters are safe or if you're heading toward trouble.
Kai: Exactly. The summary of the paper says they show that this superradiant laser can become unstable and develop chaotic behavior, and they derive an analytical criterion for this instability. The key finding there is that it may only occur when the lifetime of photons in the cavity is significantly shorter than the lifetime of atoms.
Mira: That's a big thing because it gives us a way to refine how we set up our experimental parameters if we want to use this laser as a frequency reference in the optical domain. It links the physics directly to what you can actually control in your lab setup.
Lev: And that criterion is important, but I wonder what that means for scaling things up on real systems. If we're aiming for large atom numbers, how does this threshold change when you move away from small simulations?
Kai: Well, the modeling starts with considering N atoms in ground and excited electronic levels coupled to a cavity. They use an effective Hamiltonian that describes the system dynamics, where the loss of photons is described by a single leak-rate parameter kappa corresponding to the cavity photon lifetime.
Mira: That structure is what you need to start thinking about instability. They model it using mean-field approximation, which gives us equations describing how the atomic and field operators evolve in time. It’s a standard starting point for this kind of physics study, but they're looking at the non-linear consequences here.
Lev: I wonder if that mean-field approximation holds up when we introduce those chaotic behaviors they mention. In real hardware, noise and fluctuations are always present, and that's where things usually go sideways first.
Kai: The criterion for dynamical instability comes when one eigenvalue of a linearized matrix M has a positive real part, specifically when kappa is greater than four times Gamma R times N divided by the square of kappa minus four times Gamma R plus kappa divided by four times g squared minus k squared times eight Gamma R over eight g squared.
Title and authors: Mira: That mathematical threshold, that specific inequality for N, is what they found in good agreement with their Monte Carlo simulations. It's a quantitative link between the theory and the simulated results they got from running those random choice methods.
Lev: So, this gives us a numerical value to check against when designing an experiment. But what about the physical meaning of that instability? Is it something you can actually see in terms of power fluctuations or just mathematical chaos?
Kai: The mean-field description formally maps this instability onto the B´enard instability associated with fluid turbulence, and they even establish a direct mapping to the Lorenz-Haken model for turbulence when they rewrite equation three using variables renormalized to their steady-state value.
Mira: That mapping is really powerful because it connects laser dynamics to fluid turbulence. It means we can use tools from that field to predict how the laser behaves in this unstable regime, which is a huge conceptual step forward for us as theorists.
Lev: If it maps to turbulence, does that mean the system exhibits some kind of self-pulsing or oscillation? Because in hardware, you'd want predictable behavior, not something constantly fluctuating.
Kai: In the unstable regime where kappa is greater than four times Gamma R and N is greater than that instability threshold N star c, the system can exhibit a strange attractor. This suggests an analogy between laser dynamics and turbulence.
Mira: And for very large atom numbers, they found that a regular self-pulsing regime appears, which has similarities with periodic superradiance we've seen before in rare-earth ion-doped crystals. This oscillating regime is governed by an inverted pendulum, which is described by a non-damped Duffing equation.
Lev: An inverted pendulum suggests some kind of limit cycle behavior. That's something I could potentially model on a control system to see if we can stabilize it or if it's inherently unstable in the hardware context.
Kai: The behavior of the laser really depends on the relationship between kappa and Gamma R, leading to three types of lasers. When kappa is less than four times Gamma R, that's called the bad-cavity regime, and you get basic superradiant laser equations via adiabatic elimination of the electric field.
Mira: Then there's this intermediate cross-over regime where you see both regular and chaotic behaviors depending on the specific parameters. That crossover region is where things get really complicated for us as theorists because the assumptions change rapidly.
Lev: I always focus on what happens when we push past those regimes, especially when we think about error correction overhead. Does this paper suggest a path to avoid that chaotic behavior entirely in a practical setup?
Kai: The paper does point out that optimizing experimental design to minimize the cavity pulling coefficient leads to kappa being much greater than Gamma R, which increases the margin for stable superradiant lasing. This is key for making it usable as a frequency reference.
Title and authors: Mira: So, the implication is that if we want stability, we should aim for a bad-cavity regime where kappa is significantly larger than Gamma R. That puts us in a different set of dynamics entirely, which might be easier to manage experimentally.
Lev: And what about the linewidth when things are stable? I'm curious about the practical performance metrics, not just the chaos. What does it say about how precise we can get this clock signal?
Kai: The laser linewidth in the stable regime can be estimated by adding stochastic noises to the equations of the laser using a Langevin formalism. They find that the ultimate laser linewidth is set by atomic fluctuations at large atom number. In that bad-cavity regime, this linewidth is given by two times g squared kappa approximately equal to kappa much greater than Gamma R.
Mira: That formula gives us a concrete estimate for the noise floor of the measurement when we are in that stable condition. It tells us exactly what sets the ultimate precision of our optical clock reference in this setup.
Lev: And if we look at the unstable regime, what about phase drift? When things get chaotic, how does that affect our ability to keep a steady phase for long integration times?
Kai: The phase diffusion coefficient can be analyzed by incorporating quantum fluctuations via a truncated Wigner approximation. This allows them to predict that the phase diffusion coefficient is equal to one over four times rho squared G plus G plus GG plus.
Mira: That equation for the diffusion coefficient is important because it formalizes the intuition about how atomic noise drifts your phase, and it shows us exactly what kind of noise we are fighting when things go haywire.
Lev: So, if we look at this paper "Instabilities of the continuous superradiant laser", what's the big picture for someone who just wants to know if this is a stable thing we can build on?
Kai: Overall, it investigates the stability of this superradiant laser based on an architecture where the atomic medium is constantly refilled. The regime where such instabilities are expected to occur is relevant for some experiments being built, which raises concerns regarding the use of such lasers from the metrological point of view.
Mira: But they conclude that optimizing experimental design for metrological performance leads to kappa much greater than Gamma R and increases the margin for stable superradiant lasing. The work paves the way for future investigations of the unstable regime.
Lev: For me, it confirms that we have a clear path: optimize your cavity parameters to keep you away from that chaotic region where the instability criterion kicks in.
Kai: Exactly. It gives us tools to predict when things get weird and how to design experiments so we can use this laser reliably for measurements.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, to recap, this paper looks at how stable a superradiant laser is when you have atoms constantly feeding into it through this cavity setup.
Mira: It shows that this continuous beam system can actually become unstable and start acting chaotically.
Kai: And they found an analytical way to predict that instability—it only happens if the photons in the cavity last much shorter than the atoms do.
Mira: That lifetime comparison is a big deal because it gives us a clear rule for setting up experiments if we want to use this laser as a stable frequency reference in optical measurements.
Kai: So, they give us guidance on how to make things stable versus how to push into that chaotic regime.
Mira: It’s interesting because this instability isn't just mathematical noise; it maps onto fluid turbulence models, which means we can actually use tools from fluid dynamics to predict the laser's behavior.
Kai: That connection between laser chaos and turbulence is a pretty deep link for me, especially when we think about how complex systems behave.
Mira: And they also found that if you have a huge number of atoms, even in this unstable situation, you get a kind of regular self-pulsing behavior similar to what we see in some rare-earth ion crystals.
Kai: That self-pulsing part is the interesting counterpoint—it suggests that sometimes chaos isn't the only thing that happens when things get pushed hard.
Mira: It really depends on whether you are in a bad cavity regime, where the photon lifetime is short compared to atomic lifetime, or somewhere in between.
Kai: If we optimize our experimental design to make the cavity pulling coefficient really high, we can push into that bad-cavity regime and get a better margin for stable lasing.
Mira: That's the practical implication—design your setup to favor those stable conditions where you see regular superradiance instead of pure chaos.
Kai: So, they’ve given us a clear warning about what setups are risky, but also shown us exactly how to tune the parameters away from trouble.
The paper's improvements: Lev: So, we're looking at what these authors suggest as improvements for their instability study. What are they proposing to fix or enhance in this model?
Kai: They’re basically suggesting that if you want to get better at predicting the behavior, you need to use AI to map the laser dynamics directly onto those turbulence models.
Mira: That means training an AI system on the exact mathematical link between equation thirteen and equation fourteen so it can predict when things switch from regular laser behavior into a chaotic regime based on your experimental settings like kappa and Gamma R.
Lev: From my side, I’m thinking about what that actually means for running this on real hardware. If we could train an AI to tell us the exact transition points, it would help us design better control systems to keep the laser out of those unstable regions where things go sideways.
Kai: And they also suggest using quantum fluctuations and a truncated Wigner approximation when analyzing phase drift in unstable regimes.
Mira: That gives us a way to predict how much the phase will diffuse, showing that you can calculate that diffusion coefficient as one over four times rho squared G plus G plus GG plus.
Lev: That's useful because it tells us exactly what kind of noise we are dealing with when things get weird, which is crucial for designing robust error correction overhead.
Kai: The big idea here is that this paper provides a framework for an AI to do more than just describe the physics; it lets it actively predict instabilities in these continuous superradiant lasers.
Mira: It moves the research from just finding instability criteria to creating tools that can anticipate and manage those transitions in real-time.
Lev: If we can use this prediction capability, it could drastically reduce the overhead needed for stabilizing a superradiant laser on a physical platform.
Kai: It’s a lot of work to build that kind of mapping, but it opens up new avenues for understanding how these complex laser systems operate under extreme conditions.
Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up, this paper on "Instabilities of the continuous superradiant laser" shows that when you have atoms constantly feeding into a cavity, you can get chaotic behavior if you aren't careful with your parameters.
Mira: It’s important because it gives us a concrete way to know when we’re heading toward unstable physics, which is really useful for anyone building an active optical clock or any other laser reference.
Lev: From an error correction standpoint, this instability means we have to design our control systems to handle non-linear dynamics before we even worry about the noise in the measurement record.
Kai: The main thing is that by optimizing your cavity parameters so they are really short compared to the atomic lifetime, you increase your margin for stable superradiance.
Mira: That tuning leads you into a regime where you see more predictable behavior, like that regular self-pulsing we mentioned earlier.
Lev: I just want to say that understanding this transition helps us decide what level of control is actually necessary for a reliable hardware implementation versus what is purely theoretical chaos.
Kai: Yeah, so for anyone working on these systems right now, knowing the analytical criterion and how to tune kappa and Gamma R is key to making sure your setup stays stable.
Mira: It really opens up the door for future work in understanding these unstable regimes, which we can use as a benchmark when we start looking at more complex atomic setups.
Lev: I’m curious what happens next, because this instability criterion tells us where the dynamics break down; maybe our next paper should look at how to stabilize those specific chaotic attractors.
Bruno Laburthe-Tolra, Martin Robert-de-Saint-Vincent, Benjamin Pasquiou
Laboratoire de physique des lasers, CNRS, UMR 7538, University Sorbonne Paris Nord
quant-ph, cond-mat.quant-gas, physics.atom-ph
Submitted: 2026-06-19
Updated: 2026-11-09
Comments: 18 pages, 6 figures
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 83/100
The gist: We investigate the intensity stability of the superradiant laser Our study focuses on the architecture where a continuous beam of atoms in an electronically excited state crosses the mode of a…
Key concepts
- Superradiant Laser Architecture
- This setup involves a continuous beam of atoms in an excited state passing through a cavity mode. The system is modeled by considering N atoms coupled to the cavity, where the interaction leads to collective emission (superradiance). This architecture is proposed as a new design for active optical clocks.
- Instability Criterion
- An analytical threshold determines when the laser becomes dynamically unstable. Instability occurs when a specific relationship between cavity photon lifetime ($\kappa$) and atomic parameters ($N$, $\Gamma_R$, $g$) is met. Specifically, it requires the photon lifetime to be significantly shorter than the atomic lifetime for instability to manifest.
- Turbulence Mapping
- The mean-field description of this laser instability formally maps onto fluid turbulence models like the B´enard instability and the Lorenz-Haken model. This suggests that laser dynamics in certain regimes can exhibit chaotic behavior analogous to turbulent fluid flow, allowing for predictive modeling based on these established physical systems.
Terminology
Summary
We investigate the intensity stability of the superradiant laser Our study focuses on the architecture where a continuous beam of atoms in an electronically excited state crosses the mode of a high-finesse Fabry-Perot cavity, which has been proposed as a new architecture of an active optical clock We show that such superradiant laser can become unstable and develop chaotic behavior We derive an analytical criterion for this instability and find that it may only occur when the lifetime of photons in the cavity is significantly shorter than the lifetime of atoms This criterion allows for refining the necessary parameters to run a superradiant laser as a frequency reference in the optical domain
Modeling the System Dynamics
The modeling of a superradiant laser is initiated by considering N atoms with ground and excited electronic levels g⟩, e⟩ resonantly coupled to a cavity. The effective Hamiltonian H = H0 + κ 2i (b†⟨b⟩ − b⟨b†⟩) describes the system, where photons losses are thus described by a single leak-rate parameter κ corresponding to the cavity photon lifetime. p. 1 [9] and find the effective Hamiltonian H = H0 +
κ
2i
(b
†
⟨b⟩ − b⟨b
†
⟩). Photons losses
are thus described by a single leak-rate parameter κ corresponding to the cavity photon lifetime. From this expression we compute the evolution of the system (using i
dA
dt = [A, H]). We make the mean-field approximation and thus neglect
correlations between the atomic degrees of freedom and the cavity field, and we find:
i
d⟨b⟩
dt = g
X
j
⟨s
−
j
⟩ − i
2
κ⟨b⟩
i
d⟨b
†
⟩
dt = −g
X
j
⟨s
+
j
⟩ − i
2
κ⟨b
†
⟩
i
d⟨s
−
j
⟩
dt = −2g⟨b⟩⟨s
z
j
⟩
i
d⟨s
+
j
⟩
dt = 2g⟨b
†
⟩⟨s
z
j
⟩
i
d⟨s
z
j
⟩
dt = g⟨b⟩⟨s
+
j
⟩ − g⟨b
†
⟩⟨s
−
j
⟩ (2)
2.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Instability Criteria and Mapping
The criterion for dynamical instability arises when one eigenvalue of the linearized matrix M has a positive real part, specifically when κ > 4ΓR N > κ 2(8ΓR + κ) / 4g 2(κ - 4ΓR). This analytical threshold N∗c for instability is in good agreement with the Monte-Carlo results. p. 5 We find that the
criterion for the instability, corresponding to the real part of the eigenvalue becoming positive, is
κ > 4ΓR
N > κ
2
(8ΓR + κ)
4g
2(κ − 4ΓR)
≡ N
∗
c
. (8)
The analytical threshold N∗
c
for instability is in good agreement with our Monte-Carlo results of Fig. On the other hand, we also point out that the
superradiant laser, when in the unstable regime, can become an interesting playground for studying
chaos. At the mean-field level, there is a direct mapping to the B´enard instability associated with
fluid turbulence; however quantum fluctuations associated with photon out-coupling and atom
re-filling substantially modify the expected behaviors. 3 Connection to turbulence and to the Lorenz-Haken model
3. 1 Mapping laser equations to the Lorenz model for turbulence
We rewrite Eq. 1 Mapping laser equations to the Lorenz model for turbulence
We rewrite Eq. 3 using variables renormalized to their steady-state value, and using the critical number
for the lasing threshold Nc =
ΓRκ
2g
2 :
dβ
dt =
κ
2
ΣWhere the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Regimes of Laser Behavior
The behavior of the laser depends on the relationship between κ and ΓR, leading to three types of lasers:
-
When κ 4ΓR (bad-cavity regime), the basic superradiant laser equations are obtained via adiabatic elimination of the electric field. p. 5
Where the paper says it
• The second regime is when κ ≫ ΓR (bad-cavity regime), in which case it is natural to perform instead the adiabatic elimination of the electric field, db dt = db† dt = 0. Adiabatic elimination of the field leads to the basic superradiant laser equations [9]: dS− dt = 4g 2 κ S −S z − ΓRS − dSz dt = − 4g 2 κ S −S + − ΓRS z + Γ 2 (5) • The intermediate, cross-over regime is the one we are interested in.
-
The intermediate, cross-over regime includes both regular and chaotic behaviors. p. 5
Where the paper says it
For the two previous regimes, since equations were defined in a real plane (two real variables) and cannot reach infinite values, the Poincar´e-Bendixson theorem implies that no chaos can occur. As we shall see below, this is not the case when no adiabatic elimination is performed; the third, intermediate regime includes both regular and chaotic behaviors.
Metrological Implications and Linewidth
The laser linewidth in the stable regime can be estimated by adding stochastic noises to the equations of the laser using a Langevin formalism. The ultimate laser linewidth is found to be set by the atomic fluctuations at large atom number. p. 8 Indeed, in the case of the superradiant
laser, the linewidth is ∝ g
2/κ and, at large atom number and for κ ≫ ΓR, we have γi ∝ κ. For standard
lasers, the ultimate amplitude fluctuations arise because of fluctuations associated with spontaneous
emission [25], which introduces an amplitude drift that is damped by the cavity linewidth. In the multimode regime, deriving the rate equations from first principle also
implies neglecting the phase relations between the laser modes [11]. • The second regime is when κ ≫ ΓR (bad-cavity regime), in which case it is natural to perform
instead the adiabatic elimination of the electric field, db
dt =
db†
dt = 0.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Turbulence and Self-Pulsing
In the unstable regime where κ > 4ΓR and N > N∗c, the system can exhibit a strange attractor, suggesting an analogy between laser dynamics and turbulence. For very large atom numbers, a regular self-pulsing regime appears, which bears similarities with recently observed periodic superradiance using rare-earth ion-doped crystals. p. 0 We finally
discuss a more stable regime that appears at very large atom numbers, in which case the turbulent
laser gradually turns into a self-pulsing laser. This bears similarities with recently observed periodic
superradiance using rare-earth ion-doped crystals [15, 16, 17]. 5a uses the mean-field approximation and an
atom number high enough to be in the unstable regime. The figure suggests the existence of a strange
attractor, where the dynamical state more or less regularly alternates between oscillating around
one state and around a different one.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Experimental Relevance
The instability is relevant for some experiments being built, as the worst case N∗c /Nc is on the order of 15, which is reached for κ/ΓR ≃ 11. Optimizing experimental design to minimize the cavity pulling coefficient leads to κ >> ΓR and increases the margin for stable superradiant lasing. p. 5 • The second regime is when κ ≫ ΓR (bad-cavity regime), in which case it is natural to perform
instead the adiabatic elimination of the electric field, db
dt =
db†
dt = 0. Adiabatic elimination of the
field leads to the basic superradiant laser equations [9]:
dS−
dt =
4g
2
κ
S
−S
z − ΓRS
−
dSz
dt = −
4g
2
κ
S
−S
+ − ΓRS
z +
Γ
2
(5)
• The intermediate, cross-over regime is the one we are interested in. , due to atom motion [12, 13] or for separate ensembles of atoms [14], have been predicted. In this work, we show that the superradiant laser can indeed become unstable at large atom
numbers, in a parameter regime relevant to the experiments being built. , due to atom motion [12, 13] or for separate ensembles of atoms [14], have been predicted. In this work, we show that the superradiant laser can indeed become unstable at large atom
numbers, in a parameter regime relevant to the experiments being built. , due to atom motion [12, 13] or for separate ensembles of atoms [14], have been predicted. In this work, we show that the superradiant laser can indeed become unstable at large atom
numbers, in a parameter regime relevant to the experiments being built.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Appendix on Laser Linewidth
The laser linewidth can be derived by considering fluctuating Langevin forces that account for the drift of observables due to stochastic outcoupling and in-and-out-coupling of atoms. The phase diffusion coefficient is shown to be 2Dϕ = 1/4ρ 2⟨G+G + GG+⟩ / 1. p. 5 Thus, the usual rate equations for a laser fundamentally rely on the adiabatic elimination of the
atomic coherences. In the multimode regime, deriving the rate equations from first principle also
implies neglecting the phase relations between the laser modes [11]. Finally, we point-out the existence of a
regular self-pulsing regime at large atom numbers. 1 Introduction
The prospect of a superradiant laser in the bad-cavity regime has attracted considerable attention
both from the experimental point of view [1, 2, 3, 4, 5] and the theoretical point of view [6, 7, 8, 9]. Finally, we point-out the existence of a
regular self-pulsing regime at large atom numbers. 1 Introduction
The prospect of a superradiant laser in the bad-cavity regime has attracted considerable attention
both from the experimental point of view [1, 2, 3, 4, 5] and the theoretical point of view [6, 7, 8, 9]. For standard
lasers, the ultimate amplitude fluctuations arise because of fluctuations associated with spontaneous
emission [25], which introduces an amplitude drift that is damped by the cavity linewidth. The
case of the superradiant laser using a beam architecture is different, since the stochastic process that
introduces amplitude fluctuation is the outcoupling of atoms creating a drift of the collective atomic
coherences. For standard
lasers, the ultimate amplitude fluctuations arise because of fluctuations associated with spontaneous
emission [25], which introduces an amplitude drift that is damped by the cavity linewidth. The
case of the superradiant laser using a beam architecture is different, since the stochastic process that
introduces amplitude fluctuation is the outcoupling of atoms creating a drift of the collective atomic
coherences. This is in part motivated by possible applications as an optical frequency standard, or to improve the
stability of an ultra-stable laser (as it would truly realize a maser in the optical domain). The badcavity regime is useful for this prospect since the light emission is expected to be largely independent of
mirror vibrations, and the laser frequency is mostly set by the atomic resonance frequency. This is in part motivated by possible applications as an optical frequency standard, or to improve the
stability of an ultra-stable laser (as it would truly realize a maser in the optical domain). The badcavity regime is useful for this prospect since the light emission is expected to be largely independent of
mirror vibrations, and the laser frequency is mostly set by the atomic resonance frequency.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusions
This paper investigates the stability of the superradiant laser based on an architecture in which the atomic medium is constantly refilled. The regime where such instabilities are expected to occur is relevant for some experiments being built, which raises concerns regarding the use of such lasers from the metrological point of view. p. 0 , due to atom motion [12, 13] or for separate ensembles of atoms [14], have been predicted. In this work, we show that the superradiant laser can indeed become unstable at large atom
numbers, in a parameter regime relevant to the experiments being built. , due to atom motion [12, 13] or for separate ensembles of atoms [14], have been predicted. In this work, we show that the superradiant laser can indeed become unstable at large atom
numbers, in a parameter regime relevant to the experiments being built. In the case with the highest ΓR, the laser remains rather stable, while in
the other case, the laser develops intensity oscillations that become more and more pronounced for
increasing atom number, until the laser becomes basically pulsed. This observation shows that the
intensity stability of the superradiant laser can be strongly sensitive to experimental parameters. In the case with the highest ΓR, the laser remains rather stable, while in
the other case, the laser develops intensity oscillations that become more and more pronounced for
increasing atom number, until the laser becomes basically pulsed. This observation shows that the
intensity stability of the superradiant laser can be strongly sensitive to experimental parameters.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
References
[1] M. A. Norcia, M. N. Winchester, J. R. K. Cline, and J. K. Thompson, Superradiance on the millihertz linewidth strontium clock transition, Sci. p. 7 Note that the predicted transition to self-pulsing toward a mode-locked ultra-short pulses regime [11]
cannot be observed in our model that does not take into account the spatial dependence of the electric
field along the cavity axis. 2 Generalization to the repumped superradiant laser
The connection between superradiance and turbulence is not specific to the case of the continuous
atomic beam approach.Where the paper says it
[9] B. Laburthe-Tolra, Z. p. 0 Instabilities of the continuous superradiant laser
Bruno Laburthe-Tolra1∗
, Martin Robert-de-Saint-Vincent1
, Benjamin Pasquiou1
June 23, 2026
1 Laboratoire de physique des lasers, CNRS, UMR 7538, Universit´e Sorbonne Paris Nord, F-93430
Villetaneuse, France
⋆
bruno. laburthe-tolra@univ-paris13. Instabilities of the continuous superradiant laser
Bruno Laburthe-Tolra1∗
, Martin Robert-de-Saint-Vincent1
, Benjamin Pasquiou1
June 23, 2026
1 Laboratoire de physique des lasers, CNRS, UMR 7538, Universit´e Sorbonne Paris Nord, F-93430
Villetaneuse, France
⋆
bruno. laburthe-tolra@univ-paris13. For standard
lasers, the ultimate amplitude fluctuations arise because of fluctuations associated with spontaneous
emission [25], which introduces an amplitude drift that is damped by the cavity linewidth. The
case of the superradiant laser using a beam architecture is different, since the stochastic process that
introduces amplitude fluctuation is the outcoupling of atoms creating a drift of the collective atomic
coherences. For standard
lasers, the ultimate amplitude fluctuations arise because of fluctuations associated with spontaneous
emission [25], which introduces an amplitude drift that is damped by the cavity linewidth. The
case of the superradiant laser using a beam architecture is different, since the stochastic process that
introduces amplitude fluctuation is the outcoupling of atoms creating a drift of the collective atomic
coherences.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[18] D. A. Tieri, M. Xu, D. Meiser, J. Cooper, and M. J. Holland, Theory of the crossover from lasing to steady state superradiance, arXiv:1702. p. 0 This bears similarities with recently observed periodic
superradiance using rare-earth ion-doped crystals [15, 16, 17]. 1
arXiv:2606. This bears similarities with recently observed periodic
superradiance using rare-earth ion-doped crystals [15, 16, 17]. 1
arXiv:2606. This bears similarities with recently observed periodic
superradiance using rare-earth ion-doped crystals [15, 16, 17]. 1
arXiv:2606.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[9] B. Laburthe-Tolra, Z. Amodjee, B. Pasquiou, and M. R. de Saint-Vincent, Correlations and linewidth of the atomic beam continuous superradiant laser, SciPost Phys. Core 6, 015 (2023)
[13] S. B. J¨ager, H. Liu, A. Shankar, J. Cooper, and M. J. Holland, Regular and bistable steady-state superradiant phases of an atomic beam traversing an optical cavity, Phys. p. 0 fr
Abstract
We investigate the intensity stability of the superradiant laser. Our study focuses on the
architecture where a continuous beam of atoms in an electronically excited state crosses the mode
of a high-finesse Fabry-Perot cavity, which has been proposed as a new architecture of an active
optical clock.Where the paper says it
[14] A. Patra, B. L. Altshuler, and E. A. Yuzbashyan, Driven-dissipative dynamics of atomic ensembles in a resonant cavity: Nonequilibrium phase diagram and periodically modulated superradiance, Phys. Rev. A 99, 033802 (18)
[15] H. Hara, J. Han, Y. Imai, N. Sasao, A. Yoshimi, K. Yoshimura, M. Yoshimura, and Y. Miyamoto, Periodic superradiance in an er:yso crystal, Phys. p. 0 We finally
discuss a more stable regime that appears at very large atom numbers, in which case the turbulent
laser gradually turns into a self-pulsing laser. This bears similarities with recently observed periodic
superradiance using rare-earth ion-doped crystals [15, 16, 17].Where the paper says it
[17] T. Xie, R. Fukumori, W.-K. Mok, J. Li, J. Choi, and A. Faraon, Observation of tunable superradiant frequency combs, arXiv:2604. p. 3 In the case with the highest ΓR, the laser remains rather stable, while in
the other case, the laser develops intensity oscillations that become more and more pronounced for
increasing atom number, until the laser becomes basically pulsed. This observation shows that the
intensity stability of the superradiant laser can be strongly sensitive to experimental parameters.Where the paper says it
[8] H. Liu, S. B. J¨ager, X. Yu, S Touzard, A Shankar, M. J Holland, and T L Nicholson Rugged mHz-linewidth superradiant laser driven by a hot atomic beam Phys. p. 8 For standard
lasers, the ultimate amplitude fluctuations arise because of fluctuations associated with spontaneous
emission [25], which introduces an amplitude drift that is damped by the cavity linewidth. The
case of the superradiant laser using a beam architecture is different, since the stochastic process that
introduces amplitude fluctuation is the outcoupling of atoms creating a drift of the collective atomic
coherences.Where the paper says it
[10] H. Haken, Analogy between higher instabilities in fluids and lasers, Physics Letters A 53, 77–78 (1)
[11] H. Haken, Light: Laser light dynamics, Vol. p. 0 This is in part motivated by possible applications as an optical frequency standard, or to improve the
stability of an ultra-stable laser (as it would truly realize a maser in the optical domain). The badcavity regime is useful for this prospect since the light emission is expected to be largely independent of
mirror vibrations, and the laser frequency is mostly set by the atomic resonance frequency. This is in part motivated by possible applications as an optical frequency standard, or to improve the
stability of an ultra-stable laser (as it would truly realize a maser in the optical domain). The badcavity regime is useful for this prospect since the light emission is expected to be largely independent of
mirror vibrations, and the laser frequency is mostly set by the atomic resonance frequency.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[4] S. A Sch¨affer, M Tang, M R Henriksen, A A Jørgensen, B T R Christensen, and J W Thomsen Lasing on a narrow transition in a cold thermal strontium ensemble Phys. Rev. A 101, 013819 (26)
[5] F Fam´a, S Zhou, B Heizenreder, M Tang, S Bennetts, S. B Jäger, S A Sch¨affer, and F Schreck Continuous cavity qed with an atomic beam Phys. p. 7 Note that the predicted transition to self-pulsing toward a mode-locked ultra-short pulses regime [11]
cannot be observed in our model that does not take into account the spatial dependence of the electric
field along the cavity axis. 2 Generalization to the repumped superradiant laser
The connection between superradiance and turbulence is not specific to the case of the continuous
atomic beam approach. Note that the predicted transition to self-pulsing toward a mode-locked ultra-short pulses regime [11]
cannot be observed in our model that does not take into account the spatial dependence of the electric
field along the cavity axis. 2 Generalization to the repumped superradiant laser
The connection between superradiance and turbulence is not specific to the case of the continuous
atomic beam approach.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[2] D Pan, B. Arora, Y mei Yu, B K Sahoo, and J Chen Optical-lattice-based Cs active clock with a continual superradiant lasing signal Phys. p. 0 fr
Abstract
We investigate the intensity stability of the superradiant laser. Our study focuses on the
architecture where a continuous beam of atoms in an electronically excited state crosses the mode
of a high-finesse Fabry-Perot cavity, which has been proposed as a new architecture of an active
optical clock.Where the paper says it
[3] T. Laske, H Winter, and A Hemmerich Pulse delay time statistics in a superradiant laser with calcium atoms Phys. p. 1 2 Monte-Carlo simulations
We perform Monte-Carlo simulations of the superradiant laser dynamics for a given intracavity atom
number N by simulating the 3N + 2 equations of Eqs. In order to take into account atoms leaving
and entering the cavity, we segment the simulation in a large number of temporal chunks, each of
duration τ = 1/Γ, corresponding to the typical insertion time of an atom in the cavity.Where the paper says it
[4] S. A Sch¨affer, M Tang, M R Henriksen, A A Jørgensen, B T R Christensen, and J W Thomsen Lasing on a narrow transition in a cold thermal strontium ensemble Phys. Rev. A 101, 013819 (26)
[5] F Fam´a, S Zhou, B Heizenreder, M Tang, S Bennetts, S. B Jäger, S A Sch¨affer, and F Schreck Continuous cavity qed with an atomic beam Phys. Rev. A 110, 063721 (24)
[8] H Liu, S. B Jäger, X Yu, S Touzard, A Shankar, M J Holland, and T L Nicholson Rugged mHz-linewidth superradiant laser driven by a hot atomic beam Phys. p. 8 For standard
lasers, the ultimate amplitude fluctuations arise because of fluctuations associated with spontaneous
emission [25], which introduces an amplitude drift that is damped by the cavity linewidth. The
case of the superradiant laser using a beam architecture is different, since the stochastic process that
introduces amplitude fluctuation is the outcoupling of atoms creating a drift of the collective atomic
coherences.Where the paper says it
[10] H. Haken, Analogy between higher instabilities in fluids and lasers, Physics Letters A 53, 77–78 (1)
[11] H. Haken, Light: Laser light dynamics, Vol. 2 (North-Holl. Publ. Co, Amsterdam, 1986)
[13] S. B J¨ager, H Liu, A Shankar, J Cooper, and M J Holland Regular and bistable steady-state superradiant phases of an atomic beam traversing an optical cavity Phys. p. 0 fr
Abstract
We investigate the intensity stability of the superradiant laser. Our study focuses on the
architecture where a continuous beam of atoms in an electronically excited state crosses the mode
of a high-finesse Fabry-Perot cavity, which has been proposed as a new architecture of an active
optical clock.Where the paper says it
[14] A Patra, B. L Altshuler, and E A Yuzbashyan Driven-dissipative dynamics of atomic ensembles in a resonant cavity Nonequilibrium phase diagram and periodically modulated superradiance Phys. Rev. A 99, 033802 (18)
[15] H Hara, J Han, Y Imai, N Sasao, A Yoshimi, K Yoshimura M. Yoshimura and Y. Miyamoto Periodic superradiance in an er:yso crystal Phys. p. 0 We finally
discuss a more stable regime that appears at very large atom numbers, in which case the turbulent
laser gradually turns into a self-pulsing laser. This bears similarities with recently observed periodic
superradiance using rare-earth ion-doped crystals [15, 16, 17].Where the paper says it
[16] H Hara, Y. Miyamoto, J Han, R Omoto, Y Imai, A Yoshimi, K Yoshimura M. Yoshimura and N Sasao Analytical and numerical studies of periodic superradiance Phys. p. 0 We finally
discuss a more stable regime that appears at very large atom numbers, in which case the turbulent
laser gradually turns into a self-pulsing laser. This bears similarities with recently observed periodic
superradiance using rare-earth ion-doped crystals [15, 16, 17].Where the paper says it
[20] S. B J¨ager, M J Holland, and G Morigi Superradiant optomechanical phases of cold atomic gases in optical resonators Phys. p. 8 1 Intensity fluctuations
We consider the stable regime and investigate the intensity fluctuations as a function of the experimental parameters. To do so, we focus on the situation where κ > ΓR (the superradiant regime, in which
the optical field adapts more or less rapidly to the atomic variables), and the laser is still stable (i.Where the paper says it
[24] J A Fleck, Quantum theory of laser radiation ii. statistical aspects of laser light Phys. p. 0 This is in part motivated by possible applications as an optical frequency standard, or to improve the
stability of an ultra-stable laser (as it would truly realize a maser in the optical domain). The badcavity regime is useful for this prospect since the light emission is expected to be largely independent of
mirror vibrations, and the laser frequency is mostly set by the atomic resonance frequency.Where the paper says it
[25] J A Fleck, Nonlinear laser noise and coherence Journal of Applied Physics 37, 188–193 (1966)
[29] M P van Exter, S J M Kuppens, and J P Woerdman Theory for the linewidth of a bad-cavity laser Phys. Rev. A 51, 809 (95)
Appendix on the laser linewidth
The phase diffusion coefficient is shown to be 2Dϕ = 1/4ρ 2⟨G+G + GG+⟩ / 1. This formalizes the intuitive introduction of Eq. 28 regarding the drift associated with atomic noise. The linewidth is mostly set by the photon out-coupling close to threshold and mostly set by the atomic fluctuations at large atom number.
The paper investigates the stability of the superradiant laser based on an architecture in which the atomic medium is constantly refilled. The regime where such instabilities are expected to occur is relevant for some experiments being built, which raises concerns regarding the use of such lasers from the metrological point of view. Nevertheless, optimizing the experimental design for metrological performance leads to κ >> ΓR and increases the margin for stable superradiant lasing. The work paves the way for future investigations of the unstable regime.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI systems can perform instability prediction for continuous superradiant lasers by implementing an analytical criterion derived from a mean-field description, specifically that
it may only occur when the lifetime of photons in the cavity is significantly shorter than the lifetime of atoms.
-
The system can be trained to map laser dynamics to turbulence models by learning the exact mapping between Eq. 13 and Eq. 14, allowing it to predict transitions between regular laser behavior and chaotic regimes based on experimental parameters like kappa and Gamma R.
-
The AI can estimate the laser linewidth in the stable regime by using the derived formula Delta nu2 equal to g squared kappa kappa squared Gamma R plus kappa squared N over N minus Nc, which corresponds to the ultimate laser linewidth of the superradiant laser at large atom numbers.
-
The system can analyze phase drift in unstable regimes by incorporating quantum fluctuations via a Truncated Wigner Approximation, allowing it to predict that
the phase diffusion coefficient is shown to be 2Dphi equal to 1 over 4 rho squared G plus G plus GG plus
. -
The AI can distinguish between different laser architectures by recognizing the mathematical mapping where the mean equations for the repumped superradiant laser are identical when setting Gamma R/2 equals Gamma1 and Gamma2, enabling it to predict instabilities in those specific setups.
Abstract
We investigate the intensity stability of the superradiant laser. Our study focuses on the architecture where a continuous beam of atoms in an electronically excited state crosses the mode of a high-finesse Fabry-Perot cavity, which has been proposed as a new architecture of an active optical clock. We show that such superradiant laser can become unstable and develop chaotic behavior. We derive an analytical criterion for this instability and find that it may only occur when the lifetime of photons in the cavity is significantly shorter than the lifetime of atoms. This criterion allows for refining the necessary parameters to run a superradiant laser as a frequency reference in the optical domain. In particular, we point-out the consequences of the instability on intensity fluctuations and laser linewidth. On the other hand, we also point out that the superradiant laser, when in the unstable regime, can become an interesting playground for studying chaos. At the mean-field level, there is a direct mapping to the Bénard instability associated with fluid turbulence; however quantum fluctuations associated with photon out-coupling and atom re-filling substantially modify the expected behaviors. Finally, we point-out the existence of a regular self-pulsing regime at large atom numbers.
Sources
- Observation of Tunable Superradiant Frequency Combs
- Theory of the crossover from lasing to steady state superradiance
Related papers
- Computational regimes in matrix-product-state-based quantum trajectory simulations
- Toward chemically accurate quantum simulations on quantum hardware: A quantum-HPC hybrid approach
- Transversal surface-code game with reconfigurable qubits
- Fulqrum: a generalized framework for quantum subspace diagonalization
- Flux-Activated Resonant Control of a Bosonic Quantum Memory
- Machine learning the effects of many quantum measurements