A Consistent Comparison of Intracluster Light Assembly in Simulations I. Redshift Evolution and Progenitor Galaxies
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: I'm Vera.
Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "A Consistent Comparison of Intracluster Light Assembly in Simulations I. Redshift Evolution and Progenitor Galaxies".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. The study investigates the assembly of the intracluster light (ICL) in cluster-mass haloes using four hydrodynamical simulations: Horizon-AGN, TNG100, The Three Hundred Gizmo-Simba 7K, and Hydrangea.
Vera: A homogenized ICL identification framework is used for comparison.
Jocelyn: Key findings include: "For our fiducial ICL definition we obtain broadly consistent z ≈ 0 ICL stellar mass fractions (∼ 0.1 − 0.2) and, by tracking the progenitors of z ≈ 0 clusters back to z≳ 2, find no significant evolution in average ICL mass fractions." "Lower-mass satellites typically make slightly larger ICL contributions relative to their mass in every considered simulation, but which galaxies make the dominant contribution to the ICL is primarily controlled by the infalling satellite mass function.
Vera: Most ICL stars sourced from satellite galaxies are therefore expected to originate from galaxies with infall stellar masses above ∼ 1010 M⊙ and largely within 1010.5 − 1011.5 M⊙." "Whether the average ICL mass fraction falls with increasing redshift or does not evolve is determined by the ICL definition adopted." "Our finding of no evolution in the average ICL or BCG + ICL mass fraction in any simulation until at least z ∼ 2.
Paper summary: Vera: So, we started by looking at this paper, "A Consistent Comparison of Intracluster Light Assembly in Simulations I. Redshift Evolution and Progenitor Galaxies". The main point is comparing four different cosmological hydrodynamical simulations to see how the intracluster light assembles.
Jocelyn: They use Horizon-AGN, TNG100, The Three Hundred Gizmo-Simba 7K, and Hydrangea <ref:2606.20175#pg3,Horizon-AGN, TNG100, The Three Hundred>. And they use a homogenized identification framework to make sure their comparisons are valid across these different codes.
Subrahmanyan: The central claim is that for a standard definition of ICL mass fraction, they find broad consistency at z equals zero, showing no significant evolution in the average ICL mass fractions when tracking cluster progenitors back to redshifts greater than two.
Vera: That means their fiducial definition of ICL stellar mass fractions stays pretty stable over a wide range of cosmic time for these massive structures.
Jocelyn: They also found that while lower-mass satellites contribute slightly more ICL per unit mass, the dominant source is controlled by the satellite mass function, pointing toward infall masses above ten to the power of ten solar masses <ref:2606.20175#pg1>.
Subrahmanyan: The paper connects this to structure formation by predicting that the peak contributors to both ICL and BCG plus ICL stars are Milky Way mass galaxies in clusters smaller than ten to the power of fifteen solar masses at z equals zero <ref:2606.20175#pg1>.
Vera: That's a key prediction because it sets a scale for where we expect these assembly processes to be most efficient.
Jocelyn: They also observed that while evolution depends on the definition, there are hints of a common downturn starting at z greater than two in both the typical ICL fraction and the average BCG plus ICL fractions.
Subrahmanyan: This suggests some process is ramping up or changing its efficiency as we look further back in time, even if it's not a simple linear evolution.
Vera: So, what this means for us observing the sky is that the underlying physics of how light gets stripped from galaxies might be more robust than previously thought.
Jocelyn: It gives us a reference point for what to expect when we look at cluster environments across different redshifts and halo masses.
Subrahmanyan: We should watch those high-redshift trends closely because they could tell us something about the very first major galaxy mergers in these forming structures.
Conclusion: Vera: So, wrapping up this discussion on "A Consistent Comparison of Intracluster Light Assembly in Simulations I. Redshift Evolution and Progenitor Galaxies". The authors are Brown et al., with a team from Nottingham, EPFL, and Madrid.
Jocelyn: Their work really boils down to confirming that the way we measure intracluster light assembly matters a lot; different methods lead to different conclusions about evolution.
Subrahmanyan: They show that when you standardize the measurement process, those differences largely disappear when comparing simulations. The main takeaway is identifying Milky Way mass galaxies as the primary progenitors for these stars.
Vera: It's important because it provides a consistent picture of where we expect this stellar material to come from in real clusters.
Jocelyn: This helps us refine our understanding of the processes—tidal stripping and mergers—that build up the intracluster light over cosmic time.
Subrahmanyan: For cosmology, this constrains how much mass is transferred between galaxies and the surrounding cluster environment during structure formation.
Vera: And for observational astronomers, it gives us a clearer target: focus on those Milky Way mass galaxies in clusters under ten to the power of fifteen solar masses at z equals zero <ref:2606.20175#pg1>.
Jocelyn: It tells us that we need to look for evidence of this assembly process across different redshifts, especially around z greater than two where they saw that change in trends.
Harley J. Brown, Garreth Martin, Frazer R. Pearce, Yannick M. Bahé, Joseph Butler, Weiguang Cui, Nina A. Hatch, Álexander Knebe
School of Physics & Astronomy, University of Nottingham · Laboratoire d’Astrophysique, École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL) · Departamento de Fsica Teoric@ica, Universidad Autonoma de Madrid · Centro de Investigación Avanzada en Fsica Fundamental, Universidad Autonoma de Madrid · Institute for Astronomy, Royal Observatory Edinburgh · International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research, University of Western Australia
astro-ph.GA
Submitted: 2026-06-18
Updated: 2026-10-29
Comments: 25 pages, 14 figures, accepted for publication in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
Project page: https://garrethmartin.github.io/interactive-profiles-ICL/index.html#stripping
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 88/100
The gist: The study investigates the assembly of the intracluster light (ICL) in cluster-mass haloes using four hydrodynamical simulations: Horizon-AGN, TNG100, The Three Hundred Gizmo-Simba 7K, and Hydrangea.
Key concepts
- Intracluster Light (ICL)
- ICL is a diffuse halo of stars found between galaxies within a cluster. It forms through various processes, primarily the tidal stripping and gravitational interactions of smaller galaxies as they fall into a larger cluster environment.
- Hydrodynamical Simulations
- These are computer models that simulate the complex physics of galaxy formation and evolution within dark matter halos. Four different simulations (Horizon-AGN, TNG100, etc.) were used to test how ICL assembly varies across different cosmic environments.
- Satellite Infall Mass Function
- This describes the distribution of stellar masses of smaller galaxies that fall into a larger cluster over time. The study found that the mass function of these infalling satellites primarily controls which galaxies contribute most significantly to the total ICL mass.
- Redshift Evolution
- Redshift is a measure related to how far away an object is in space and how much the universe has expanded since it emitted light. The paper examined whether the average amount of ICL changes as we look back in time (i.e., at higher redshifts).
Terminology
Summary
The study investigates the assembly of the intracluster light (ICL) in cluster-mass haloes using four hydrodynamical simulations: Horizon-AGN, TNG100, The Three Hundred Gizmo-Simba 7K, and Hydrangea. p. 0 A homogenized ICL identification framework is used for comparison. p. 0
Key findings include:
"For our fiducial ICL definition we obtain broadly consistent z ≈ 0 ICL stellar mass fractions (∼ 0.1 − 0.2) and, by tracking the progenitors of z ≈ 0 clusters back to z≳ 2, find no significant evolution in average ICL mass fractions. p. 0"
"Lower-mass satellites typically make slightly larger ICL contributions relative to their mass in every considered simulation, but which galaxies make the dominant contribution to the ICL is primarily controlled by the infalling satellite mass function. Most ICL stars sourced from satellite galaxies are therefore expected to originate from galaxies with infall stellar masses above ∼ 1010 M⊙ and largely within 1010. p. 05 − 1011. p. 05 M⊙."
Whether the average ICL mass fraction falls with increasing redshift or does not evolve is determined by the ICL definition adopted.
"Our finding of no evolution in the average ICL or BCG + ICL mass fraction in any simulation until at least z ∼ 2. At z≳ 2 there are hints of a common downturn in typical ICL fraction and the average BCG + ICL fractions all begin to rise. p. 6.."
The study compares different BCG-ICL separation methodologies, finding that when homogenized to a consistent definition, no significant inter-simulation discrepancies exist regarding ICL mass fractions. The main progenitor objects of ICL stars are predicted to be massive galaxies, typically Milky Way mass galaxies. p. 1 Furthermore, the analysis suggests that more massive satellites generally experience more rapid orbital decay and have deeper potential wells but are less readily stripped of stars by gravitational interactions compared to less massive satellites. p. 1 The peak contributors of ICL and BCG + ICL stars are predicted to be roughly Milky Way mass galaxies in clusters with halo masses less than 1015 M⊙ at z ≈ 0. p. 8
The study concludes that the conflicting findings from prior theoretical studies regarding typical ICL stellar mass fractions and their redshift evolution may stem entirely from the differing methodologies employed for ICL extraction. p. 6 The authors defer investigation into assembly channels beyond satellite liberation, such as pre-processed ICL and in-situ star formation, to a forthcoming companion paper. p. 8
Key words:
methods: numerical – galaxies: clusters: general – galaxies: evolution
Relevant sections:
(Abstract)
(Section 6 Conclusions)
(Section 3.1 Distribution of cluster stellar mass at z ≈ 0)
(Section 3.2 ICL mass fraction evolution)
(Section 5.2 Inter-simulation differences)
(Section 4 Assembly of ICL from cluster satellites)
**(Table 1 Key methods and properties of the four cosmological hydrodynamical simulations used in this work.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Better simulation comparison for ICL assembly by using a homogenized ICL identification framework across different codes allows for more robust testing of theoretical predictions against numerical artifacts. This enables AI systems to predict how ICL mass fractions evolve with redshift based on consistent definitions, rather than being misled by disparate extraction methodologies.
-
Improved progenitor galaxy identification capabilities allow AI systems to determine the dominant sources of ICL stars by fitting cubic spline functions to the liberated fraction of satellite stellar mass as a function of infall stellar mass M star. This capability enables AI to predict that
comparatively higher average flib-ICL fractions at lower infall masses, which decrease with increasing infall mass until M star ∼ 1010 M⊙, at which point they level out around flib-ICL ∼ 0.05 − 0.1.
-
Enhanced sensitivity to simulation resolution and galaxy identification criteria enables AI systems to quantify systematic errors in ICL fractions across different simulations. This allows for the prediction that "The typical ICL stellar mass fractions of the The300 GS-7K sample under our fiducial ICL methodology fall to ∼ 0.16 – indicating that the ICL fractions in The300 GS-7K from our main analysis include a small contribution from the stellar mass of neglected, poorly-resolved galaxies."
-
Predictive modeling of peak progenitor masses allows AI systems to forecast which galaxy masses contribute most significantly to the ICL. This system can predict that
the peak contributors of ICL stars in M178c ≲ 1015 M⊙ clusters at z ≈ 0 to be roughly Milky Way mass galaxies (infall stellar mass ∼ 1011 M⊙).
-
Redshift evolution prediction under consistent definitions allows AI systems to differentiate between intrinsic physical evolution and methodological biases. This enables the AI to predict that
all four simulations reproduce the same redshift evolution trend when subject to a consistent definition
versus the non-evolution found when using fixed stellar density thresholds.
Sources
- Tracing Structure: Shape and Centroid Deviations in 39 Strong Lensing Clusters as a Test of Cluster Formation Predictions
- A New Public Release of the GIZMO Code
- Mature but Still Growing: JWST Detection of the Earliest Intracluster Light at z ~ 2
- Age and metallicity of low-mass galaxies: from their centres to their stellar halos
Related papers
- The Pristine survey XXVIII. Journey to the Galactic outskirts: Mapping the outer halo red giant stars down to the very metal-poor end
- Origins of Extreme Emission-Line Ratios in z > 3 Galaxies: Insights from the Lumen Model
- The Kinematically Hot, Extremely Metal-Poor C-19 Stellar Stream in DESI DR2
- UV slopes of Starforming Galaxies in Strong Lensing fields at the Epoch of Reionization with JWST
- Evolution of Binaries Under Stochastic Perturbations
- The hydrodynamical response of cold circumgalactic clouds to quasar radiation