A Land-Sea Contrast Pattern in Surface Temperature and Atmospheric Circulation Trends in Recent Decades
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "A Land-Sea Contrast Pattern in Surface Temperature and Atmospheric Circulation Trends in Recent Decades".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. A warming of land relative to ocean has shaped observed surface temperature and atmospheric circulation trends, including the negative Inter-Decadal Pacific Oscillation (IPO)-like tendency across the Pacific basin Core Argument The authors argue that a warming of land relative to ocean is a dominant mechanism shaping observed atmospheric circulation trends, which in turn influence SST trends.
Kai: They further suggest that an underestimation of the land-sea warming ratio by climate models may explain some discrepancies between observed climate trends and those predicted by climate models.
Mira: Evidence of Land-Sea Contrast in Circulation The paper demonstrates how heating land relative to ocean alters atmospheric circulation, showing a first-order impact of inducing lower sea level pressure over land relative to ocean via a monsoon-like mechanism The seasonal cycle shows that as the northern hemisphere transitions from its cold season to warm season, land surface temperatures increase more than the surrounding ocean, with an overall sea level pressure decline over land relative to ocean.
Kai: This pattern is similar to the modeled response to land heating via altered land albedo and exhibits a negative IPO-like sea level pressure response with local maxima of sea level increase straddling the tropical Pacific to the north and south.
Paper summary: Mira: So looking at the whole paper, "A Land-Sea Contrast Pattern in Surface Temperature and Atmospheric Circulation Trends in Recent Decades," what's the final big picture they want us to take away about this land-sea contrast?
Kai: The core finding is that observed trends closely resemble the fast response seen in abrupt 4xCO2 experiments when you look at both the spatial pattern and the magnitude of the land-sea warming ratio.
Lev: They are saying that this faster response in abrupt forcing experiments, where the land-sea warming ratio is similar to what we see observed, shows a more similar negative Inter-Decadal Pacific Oscillation like trend than historical forcing climate model experiments do.
Mira: This suggests that the dominance of this land-sea contrast pattern has shaped both the anthropogenically forced component of observed surface temperature and its spatial patterns, as well as atmospheric circulation trends.
Kai: They are essentially saying this mechanism is important for understanding what we see in the Pacific basin right now.
Lev: And they're pointing out that this specific mechanism is not widely known to be an important process shaping trends over the Pacific, or that models are failing to capture its magnitude.
Mira: So, in simple terms, it suggests the faster warming of land is a significant driver for the negative IPO-like trend across the Pacific basin.
Kai: And this pattern is something we need to pay closer attention to because of what they’ve shown about how it influences circulation.
Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up this paper on "A Land-Sea Contrast Pattern in Surface Temperature and Atmospheric Circulation Trends in Recent Decades," they're really focusing on how that warming of land versus ocean is driving the observed negative trend across the Pacific basin.
Mira: Right, it seems like they found a strong link between this land-sea contrast and those specific circulation patterns, especially when comparing it to what we see in abrupt forcing experiments.
Lev: They're suggesting that if you look at the multi-model mean historical trend, this land-sea contrast has been shaping the part of temperature changes caused by human activity.
Kai: So, it’s not just about the overall warming; it’s about where that heat is going—the land versus the ocean—that dictates what we actually measure in circulation.
Mira: Exactly. And they point out that this pattern is something we haven't fully understood before when looking at how models behave under forcing.
Lev: If the models are underestimating how much heat is being taken up by the ocean, that could explain why their predictions don't match what we actually see in these trends.
Kai: So, it opens up a new way to think about future climate projections based on this land-sea ratio discrepancy.
Mira: It definitely suggests that if the land heat flux is a major driver of this difference, then our future projections for global and regional climate change might need to account for that higher land-sea warming ratio than models currently show.
Lev: And it leaves some big questions about the precise physical mechanisms involved, like how flow or precipitation changes are playing a role in that land heat partitioning.
Kai: Yeah, those open questions about the specific physics are still there, even with this strong pattern they've identified.
Colorado State University
physics.ao-ph
Submitted: 2026-06-17
Updated: 2026-11-05
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 77/100
The gist: A warming of land relative to ocean has shaped observed surface temperature and atmospheric circulation trends…
Key concepts
- Land-Sea Warming Ratio
- This measures how much faster the land surface temperature warms compared to the surrounding ocean. The paper argues that this ratio is crucial because it influences atmospheric circulation patterns, such as sea level pressure changes over land versus ocean.
- Negative IPO-like Tendency
- This refers to a pattern observed in Pacific circulation where certain sea level pressure changes occur over land relative to the ocean. The authors link this specific pattern to the enhanced warming of land compared to the ocean, suggesting it is driven by this contrast.
- Abrupt Forcing Response
- This concept relates observed climate trends to experimental results from abrupt CO2 quadrupling experiments. The paper finds that the observed land-sea warming ratio closely matches the early response seen in these experiments, indicating a similar forcing mechanism at play in natural climate shifts.
Terminology
Summary
A warming of land relative to ocean has shaped observed surface temperature and atmospheric circulation trends, including the negative Inter-Decadal Pacific Oscillation (IPO)-like tendency across the Pacific basin
Core Argument
The authors argue that a warming of land relative to ocean is a dominant mechanism shaping observed atmospheric circulation trends, which in turn influence SST trends. They further suggest that an underestimation of the land-sea warming ratio by climate models may explain some discrepancies between observed climate trends and those predicted by climate models. p. 0 In this work, we broadly argue that
a warming of land relative to ocean is a dominant mechanism shaping observed atmospheric circulation trends, which in turn influence SST trends. We further suggest that an underestimation
of the land-sea warming ratio by climate models may explain some discrepancies between observed
climate trends and those predicted by climate models.Where the paper says it
Evidence of Land-Sea Contrast in Circulation
The paper demonstrates how heating land relative to ocean alters atmospheric circulation, showing a first-order impact of inducing lower sea level pressure over land relative to ocean via a monsoon-like mechanism The seasonal cycle shows that as the northern hemisphere transitions from its cold season to warm season, land surface temperatures increase more than the surrounding ocean, with an overall sea level pressure decline over land relative to ocean. This pattern is similar to the modeled response to land heating via altered land albedo and exhibits a negative IPO-like sea level pressure response with local maxima of sea level increase straddling the tropical Pacific to the north and south. p. 2 This is further evidenced
in the similarity of the seasonal sea level pressure change away from the equator (the seasonal
cycle is smaller near the equator) to that in the modeled response to land heating via altered land
albedo (Figure 2c,d). This response is similar to that in the prescribed global land temperature
increase experiments in Ackerley and Dommenget (2016) and Zhang and Merlis (2026), including
a tendency for sea level pressure to decrease over land relative to ocean and a negative IPOlike sea level pressure response with local maxima of sea level increase straddling the tropical
Pacific to the north and south.Where the paper says it
Model Discrepancies and Abrupt Forcing
Climate models underestimate the 1979-2025 land-sea warming ratio, which is much weaker than in observed trends. The observed land-sea warming ratio closely resembles the early response in abrupt CO2 quadrupling (4xCO2) experiments, suggesting that a too-weak land-sea warming ratio in models is associated with various trend discrepancies. p. 6 The close
resemblance of the 4xCO2 early response to observed trends and much weaker land-sea warming
ratio in modeled trends further suggests that a too-weak land-sea warming ratio in models is
associated with various trend discrepancies, including the much more prominent negative IPO-like
trend observed from 1979-2025 than models predict. Indeed, as mentioned, models with a higher
land-sea warming ratio tend to have a more negative IPO-like pattern in the Pacific that resembles
the abrupt 4xCO2 early response (Figure S1). , 2008; Toda et al. The multi-model mean land-sea warming ratio for the first two
years after CO2 quadrupling compared to the average over years 1900-1950 in historical forcing experiments is 2. Next, we show that this surface temperature and atmospheric
circulation pattern is seen in both modeled and observed trends over recent decades (Section 3. We then explain that the observed land-sea warming ratio is much stronger than climate models
predict, and show that observed trends closely resemble the early response in abrupt CO2 quadrupling (4xCO2) experiments, in which the land-sea warming ratio is similar to that observed (Section
3. Additionally, even though SSTs are fixed in the land heating
experiments, there is a slight cooling of near-surface air temperature along the east flanks of induced
extratropical Pacific surface highs and increase along the west flank, and similar fully coupled land
heating experiments show an SST response that resembles the observed negative-IPO-like trend
(Dommenget, 2009; G¨unther et al. 2 Land-Sea Contrast in Observed and Modeled Trends
Consider ERA5 Reanalysis 1979-2025 trends (Figure 2e,f): A prominent pattern of surface temperature trends is the faster warming of land relative to ocean.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Implications for Future Projections
Attributing the underlying causes of the weaker modeled land-sea warming ratio compared to the observed trend could constrain projections of large-scale future climate change. If the discrepancy is due to an underestimation of ocean heat uptake by climate models, this situation would be analogous to the land-sea warming ratio decreasing with time in abrupt 4xCO2 experiments as ocean heat uptake gradually diminishes. p. 8 For instance, if the discrepancy is due to an underestimation of ocean heat uptake by
climate models, then the discrepancy will decay in the long term, although the timescale is uncertain. This situation would be analogous to the land-sea warming ratio decreasing with time in abrupt
9 Such an
explanation is consistent with models failing to capture a decline in specific humidity over semi-arid
regions (Simpson et al. If the heat flux partition over land is indeed the source of the landsea warming ratio discrepancy, there is potential for the future land-sea warming ratio to remain
higher than models predict, which our findings suggest would have major implications for global
and regional climate change and the prediction of it.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Open Questions
Several open questions remain regarding the specific mechanisms that shape the response to land-sea contrast, such as advection by climatological flow or changes in precipitation and associated latent heating. Another question concerns what sets geopotential heights aloft, as an anomalous surface high over the cooler ocean does not necessarily coincide with relatively low geopotential heights aloft in the observed trend. p. 7 Considering the factors that complicate the dynamic response to land-sea thermal contrast, a
related question is what sets geopotential heights aloft, including in the observed trend. The net
effect of the complicating factors described above is that an anomalous surface high over the cooler
ocean does not necessarily coincide with relatively low geopotential heights aloft. We argue that both ocean and land surface temperature
evolutions need to be correct: adjusting one or the other to be in line with observed trends may
impose an artificial land-sea contrast pattern. Similarly, as discussed in Shaw and Voigt (2016),
land-sea contrast should be taken into account in direct radiative forcing experiments, where a
radiative forcing is applied with fixed SSTs.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Summary of Findings
The analysis concludes that observed trends closely resemble the fast response in abrupt 4xCO2 experiments in terms of both spatial pattern and magnitude, where the land-sea warming ratio is similar to that in the observed trend. The findings suggest that the faster warming of land is an important driver of the observed negative IPO-like trend across the Pacific basin. p. 8 Finally, observed trends closely resemble the fast response in abrupt 4xCO2 experiments in terms
of both spatial pattern and magnitude, in which the land-sea warming ratio, which is substantially
underestimated in climate model simulations of recent decades, is similar to that in the observed
trend. Importantly, our analysis suggests that the faster warming of land is an important driver of
the observed negative IPO-like trend across the Pacific basin. Importantly, our analysis suggests that the faster warming of land is an important driver of
the observed negative IPO-like trend across the Pacific basin. Such a mechanism is, to date, not
widely known to be an important process shaping trends over the Pacific or the inability of models
to capture the magnitude of such a trend. , 2025; Clement
et al. The abrupt 4xCO2 early response, where the land-sea warming ratio is similar to in
the observed trend, displays a more similar negative IPO-like trend as in the observed trend than
in historical forcing climate model experiments (see Andrews et al. The dominance of the land-sea contrast pattern in the multi-model mean historical trend,
i. the forced response predicted by climate models, suggests that land-sea contrast has shaped the
anthropogenically-forced component of observed surface temperature, including spatial patterns of
SST trends, and atmospheric circulation trends.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Acknowledgements
Benjamin O Johnson and Maria Rugenstein were supported through NOAA grant NA23OAR4310596. Jackson Tobin created the schematic in Figure 1. p. 9 6 Acknowledgements
Benjamin O Johnson and Maria Rugenstein were supported through NOAA grant NA23OAR4310596. Jackson Tobin created the schematic in Figure 1. Jackson Tobin created the schematic in Figure 1. We thank Moritz G¨unther and Melissa Garvais
for their helpful feedback.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improve climate model projections by incorporating a land-sea warming ratio that matches observed trends, as
it is only in the early response of abrupt CO2 quadrupling climate model simulations that climate models are able to recreate the observed land-sea warming ratio.
This will constrain future projections by addressing theunderestimation of the land-sea warming ratio by climate models.
-
Enhance regional trend prediction accuracy by using a mechanism that accounts for land heating altering atmospheric circulation, as
a warming of land relative to ocean is a dominant mechanism shaping observed atmospheric circulation trends.
This allows the system to better capture how this contrast influences sea level pressure trends and SST patterns. -
Improve the simulation of abrupt climate change scenarios by refining the representation of surface energy partitioning, specifically by accounting for
the sensible to latent heat flux partition,
which is suggested as a source of discrepancy between models and observations regarding the land-sea warming ratio. This will lead to more realistic predictions of how land heating affects atmospheric circulation. -
Increase the fidelity of Pacific basin trend analysis by incorporating the role of land-sea contrast in shaping specific regional patterns, such as
the faster warming of land is an important driver of the observed negative IPO-like trend across the Pacific basin.
This allows for a more accurate diagnosis of why models underestimate this specific long-term variability. -
Develop a robust uncertainty assessment framework by incorporating observational uncertainties, noting that
Observational uncertainty may be important in other regions as well,
such as in sea level pressure trends over the North Atlantic wherea notable qualitative discrepancy between ERA5 sea level pressure trends and modeled trends is over the north Atlantic.
Abstract
We argue land-sea contrast is an important driver of spatial patterns of observed surface temperature and atmospheric circulation trends, including the negative Inter-Decadal Pacific Oscillation (IPO)-like tendency across the Pacific basin. Observed and modeled trends display an overall decline in sea level pressure over the faster-warming land, with a spatial pattern that resembles the seasonal cycle and modeled response to land heating. Coupled historical forcing climate model simulations underestimate the land-sea warming ratio. It is only in the early response of abrupt CO2 quadrupling climate model simulations that climate models are able to recreate the observed land-sea warming ratio, in which case a negative IPO-like sea level pressure trend and surface warming pattern over the Pacific comparable to observed trends are seen. We propose that some discrepancies between observed trends and those predicted by climate models are explained by the underestimation of the land-sea warming ratio by climate models.
Sources
Related papers
- Anthropogenic Heat in Urban Climate Systems: Forcing, Sensitivity, and Feedback
- NORi: An ML-Augmented Ocean Boundary Layer Parameterization
- A Checklist to assess the energy and carbon impacts of ML/AI applications in Earth System Modeling
- Skillful Thunderstorm Forecasts Learned Directly from Observations
- Wind vector retrieval from miniaturized wave-enabled sea-surface drifters
- Stochastic coupling of climate variables and ice volume over the Late Pleistocene glacial cycles