LIGO, LISA and Ultralight Axion-like Dark Matter
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "LIGO, LISA and Ultralight Axion-like Dark Matter".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. A coherent cosmic background of axion-like particles (ALPs) coupled to photons can produce a small periodic differential phase or polarization modulation for photons traversing separate arms in gravitational wave interferometers, peaked at a frequency associated with the particle mass, and suppressed whenever the dark-matter coherence length λcoh exceeds the arm length L.
Kai: Observable Schemes Because the two circular-polarization eigenmodes experience opposite-sign effective masses, a linearly polarized beam undergoes axion-induced polarization rotation rather than a uniform phase shift <ref:2606.16099#pg3>.
Mira: This suggests two complementary schemes to produce an observable differential signal in a Michelson-type interferometer <ref:2606.16099#pg3>.
Kai: a.
Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper, "LIGO, LISA and Ultralight Axion-like Dark Matter," and it's talking about how a background of axion-like particles coupled to photons can cause some small wiggles in gravitational wave detectors.
Mira: Right, the core idea here is that these axions create a periodic phase or polarization modulation for photons traveling through separate arms in an interferometer, and this wiggle peaks at a frequency tied directly to the particle's mass.
Lev: It claims this signal gets suppressed whenever the dark-matter coherence length, which we call lambda coh, is larger than the arm length L, which is kind of a constraint on how big these signals can be.
Kai: What's interesting about this paper is it lays out two different ways to actually see this signal. It says that because the two circular-polarization modes have opposite effective masses, a linearly polarized beam would experience polarization rotation instead of just a simple phase shift.
Mira: So they propose two setups: one where you inject circularly polarized light and read the differential phase between arms, and another where you keep linear polarization through the optics and measure a differential polarization rotation called theta.
Lev: That makes sense from an experimental standpoint, but then we have to look at how this coherence length thing plays out in practice because it really dictates the signal strength.
Kai: Exactly. The paper breaks down how things happen depending on whether lambda coh is bigger or smaller than the arm length L, and it shows that in the case where lambda coh is much bigger than L, the differential contribution comes from a dark-matter gradient between the arm endpoints.
Mira: And when lambda coh is much smaller than L, each arm basically samples independent coherence patches with random phases, which leads to a different scaling for how sensitive we are to this signal.
Lev: So when you look at the numbers they give, for the cancellation regime where lambda coh is bigger than L, the minimum detectable coupling you can find scales like delta v to the power of negative one over two at a fixed particle mass.
Paper summary: Kai: It also shows that for LISA's science band, which corresponds to a mass range around four times ten to the minus nineteen to four times ten to the minus sixteen electron volts, this sensitivity projection spans over thirteen orders of magnitude in mass below current lab limits.
Mira: And they project a minimum detectable coupling ga gamma-gamma less than five times ten to the minus fourteen g per GeV across most of that band, reaching around seven times ten to the minus fifteen g per GeV near zero point one hertz.
Lev: That's way below what we see in current tests, like the CAST helioscope bound, which is about a hundred thirty to a hundred forty times lower than that value.
Kai: And they mention that adding an RF heterodyne photodetection upgrade to either detector could extend the search sensitivity for LIGO or LISA to ga gamma-gamma around six point five times ten to the minus fourteen g per GeV at three times ten to the minus seven electron volts for LIGO.
Mira: For LISA, that would bring it down to about three point three times ten to the minus seventeen g per GeV at five times ten to the minus thirteen electron volts.
Lev: The paper flags a limitation in their analysis, specifically that details about an axion halo are not certain because they've carried out various theoretical analyses, but they don't have definitive information on the exact distribution of these dark matter streams.
Kai: And there's this point about how colder streams can affect things; they enhance the coherencetime but also worsen the cancellation suppression because that loss dominates when lambda coh is much larger than L.
Mira: It also notes that in the random-walk regime, which is when lambda coh is smaller than L, cold streams actually shift the peak mass up and improve our sensitivity in those specific conditions.
Lev: So for someone on a real detector trying to build this, it means the overhead really lands on how you handle those coherence times and how you manage the noise from those random phases when you're looking at smaller coherence lengths.
Paper summary: Kai: It’s clear that the combined reach from LISA's native science band plus some heterodyne upgrades on both ground and space detectors covers a huge range of masses, all while staying below current laboratory constraints.
Mira: So, to wrap up this paper "LIGO, LISA and Ultralight Axion-like Dark Matter," it shows that if axion-like particles are coupled to photons, they offer a way to probe dark matter on different scales.
Lev: The title really captures the scope because it’s not just one experiment; it's looking at how these effects show up in both LIGO and LISA.
Kai: It’s about connecting high-frequency gravitational wave measurements with probes of ultralight dark matter fields, using photons as the mediator.
Mira: And the implications are that we could potentially find evidence for these particles across a massive range of masses, far beyond what current experiments can reach in just one band.
Lev: The main thing this paper does is map out the sensitivity projections based on different dark matter coherence length regimes and shows where upgrades make the most sense.
Kai: It points towards the idea that augmenting either LIGO or LISA with an RF heterodyne photodetection chain extends our reach into regions where spatial coherence doesn't dampen a possible interference signal, which happens when lambda coh is smaller than L at higher masses.
Mira: And then there are the directional signatures they discuss, which involve how the local dark-matter halo has a bulk flow due to the Sun moving through our Galactic rest frame.
Lev: That bulk flow leads to an annual modulation of frequency shifts that's around ten to the minus seven hertz, and also a sidereal modulation with a period of twenty-three hours fifty-six minutes.
Kai: It’s interesting because it means even when both detectors are in the cancellation regime where lambda coh is bigger than L, you can still get a differential signal due to these directional effects.
Mira: So, to conclude this paper, the authors are showing that combining LISA's native band with heterodyne upgrades on both ground and space-based detectors gives us sensitivity below all current laboratory constraints across over thirteen orders of magnitude in mass.
Lev: It’s a broad projection for finding photon-coupled ultralight dark matter via phase modulation.
Conclusion: Kai: So we've been talking about how axion-like particles coupled to photons might actually leave a signature in gravitational wave detectors, and now we're wrapping up this paper, "LIGO, LISA and Ultralight Axion-like Dark Matter."
Mira: It really connects the high-frequency gravitational waves from LIGO with the low-frequency ones from LISA to probe ultralight dark matter fields.
Lev: The authors are looking at how this coupling shows up in two different ways depending on whether you look at circular polarization or linear polarization.
Kai: They're suggesting that by combining both ground and space detectors, we could get a really broad sensitivity across many different masses of these particles.
Mira: It seems the main implication is that if these axions exist, we might be able to find evidence for them over a huge range of particle masses, far beyond what current lab experiments can see alone.
Lev: They project reaching sensitivity below current laboratory constraints across more than thirteen orders of magnitude in mass by using LISA's native science band and adding some RF upgrades.
Kai: That suggests that augmenting either LIGO or LISA with an RF heterodyne detection chain could extend our reach into regimes where the spatial coherence doesn't suppress the signal anymore.
Mira: And they also pointed out these directional signatures, like annual and sidereal modulations coming from the local dark matter halo bulk flow.
Lev: That means even in those cancellation regimes where things are suppressed, you can still get a differential signal due to how the dark matter is moving relative to us.
Lawrence M. Krauss
The Origins Project Foundation
hep-ph, astro-ph.CO
Submitted: 2026-06-15
Updated: 2026-10-28
Comments: 9 pages, 2 figures, 1 table. v2: substantially revised to include references to, and comparison with, prior work on interferometric axion searches, and to correct sensitivity estimates; accepted for publication in Phys. Rev. D
DOI: 10.1103/4tzy-gbfy
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 67/100
The gist: A coherent cosmic background of axion-like particles (ALPs) coupled to photons can produce a small periodic differential phase or polarization modulation for photons traversing separate arms in…
Key concepts
- Axion-like Particles (ALPs)
- These are hypothetical particles that can interact with photons. When they exist in a cosmic background, they can induce a small periodic modulation—a tiny ripple—in the phase or polarization of light passing through them. This effect is dependent on the particle's mass and how it couples to photons.
- Dark Matter Coherence Length ($\lambda_{coh}$)
- This length describes how far the dark matter field is correlated. If this length is much larger than the interferometer arm length ($L$), the signal depends on gradients between arm ends. If it's much smaller than $L$, each arm samples independent patches, leading to a different statistical response.
- Differential Interferometer Response
- This refers to how the two arms of an interferometer respond differently to the axion field. Because circular polarization modes have opposite effective masses, they cause rotation rather than a uniform phase shift. The differential response is crucial for extracting the signal from noise in both measurement schemes.
- Observable Schemes
- There are two ways to detect this effect: one involves injecting circularly polarized light and measuring the resulting differential phase (Scheme a). The other keeps linear polarization through optics and measures the differential polarization rotation ($\Delta\theta$) linearly in a specific gauge (Scheme b).
Terminology
Summary
A coherent cosmic background of axion-like particles (ALPs) coupled to photons can produce a small periodic differential phase or polarization modulation for photons traversing separate arms in gravitational wave interferometers, peaked at a frequency associated with the particle mass, and suppressed whenever the dark-matter coherence length λcoh exceeds the arm length L. p. 0 LIGO, LISA and Ultralight Axion-like Dark Matter
Lawrence M. Krauss1
1The Origins Project Foundation, Phoenix AZ 85027∗
(Dated: June 16, 2026)
A coherent cosmic background of axion-like particles (ALPs) coupled to photons can produce a
small periodic differential phase or polarization modulation for photons traversing separate arms
in gravitational wave interferometers, peaked at a frequency associated with the particle mass, and
suppressed whenever the dark-matter coherence length λcoh exceeds the arm length L.Where the paper says it
Observable Schemes
Because the two circular-polarization eigenmodes experience opposite-sign effective masses, a linearly polarized beam undergoes axion-induced polarization rotation rather than a uniform phase shift <ref:2606.16099#pg3>. This suggests two complementary schemes to produce an observable differential signal in a Michelson-type interferometer <ref:2606. p. 1 TWO OBSERVABLE SCHEMES
Because the two circular-polarization eigenmodes
experience opposite-sign effective masses, a linearlypolarized beam undergoes axion-induced polarization rotation rather than a uniform phase shift. This suggests
two complementary schemes to produce an observable
differential signal in a Michelson-type interferometer.Where the paper says it
a. Circular-polarization phase readout involves injecting circularly polarized light and is sensitive to the differential phase between arms <ref:2606. p. 1 (i) Circular-polarization phase readout. Inject
circularly polarized light into the interferometer.Where the paper says it
b. Polarimetric interferometer keeps linear polarization through the optics and encodes the differential polarization rotation ∆θ = (β1 − β2) sin(mat) linearly in gaγγ <ref:2606. p. 1 The transmitted intensity then encodes the differential polarization rotation
∆θ = (β1 − β2) sin(mat) linearly in gaγγ. This scheme
treats the interferometer as a polarimetric instrument,
an interferometric analogue of a Pulsar Polarization Array [6–8].Where the paper says it
Differential Interferometer Response
In both of these schemes the role of the dark-matter coherence length λcoh = 2π/(maδv) in setting the differential interferometer response deserves careful treatment <ref:2606.16099#pg4>.
-
When λcoh ≫ L, the leading non-vanishing differential contribution comes from the DM gradient between the arm endpoints, and ∆Φrms/β ∼ L/λcoh (λcoh > L) <ref:2606. p. 1
16099#pg4>.Where the paper says it
(5) When the dark-matter coherence length exceeds the arm length, λcoh ≫ L, the DM field is approximately uniform across the apparatus to zeroth order in L/λcoh and both arms experience the same time-varying mass. The leading non-vanishing differential contribution comes from the DM gradient between the arm endpoints, which 10−3 10−2 10−1 100 101 102 103 10−3 10−2 10−1 100 random walk cancellation peak λcoh/L ∆Φrms/β FIG.
-
In the opposite limit λcoh ≪ L, each arm samples N = L/λcoh independent coherence patches with random phases, leading to ∆Φrms/β ∼ r(1/2)λcoh/L (λcoh. p. 1
Where the paper says it
Modelling the local DM as a plane wave with wavevector kDM = ma δv and averaging over the ensemble of DM-field realizations (equivalently, over directions and over many coherence times), one finds ∆Φrms β ∼ L λcoh (λcoh > L). (6) In the opposite limit λcoh ≪ L, each arm samples N = L/λcoh independent coherence patches with random phases.
The two branches (6) and (7) meet at λcoh = L, where the differential response peaks at unity <ref:2606. p. 1 The differential phase is a random walk of
O(
√
N) steps of amplitude gaγγ√
2ρDMλcoh:
∆Φrms
β
∼
r
λcoh
L
(λcoh < L). (7)
The two branches (6) and (7) meet at λcoh = L, where
the differential response peaks at unity.Where the paper says it
Signal-to-Noise and Reach Projections
For a probe-photon flux N˙ and an observation time T ≫ Tcoh = 1/(maδv2), the shot-noise-limited signal-tonoise in the sideband at omega = ma is SNR2 ∝ ∆Φ2rms N˙/pT Tcoh <ref:2606.16099#pg5>.
The sensitivity projection in the cancellation regime (λcoh > L) yields gaγγ,min ≃ λcoh(ma, δv)/L · 1/√2ρDM L · 1/pN˙√T Tcoh <ref:2606. p. 2 Crucially, the broadening of the signal in frequency space
(the 1/Tcoh linewidth) and the spatial coherence-length
suppression ∆Φrms/β both descend from the same underlying velocity dispersion δv, and both must be retained
simultaneously when projecting the reach. Substituting (6) in the cancellation regime and solving
for the minimum detectable coupling at SNR = 1,
gaγγ,min ≃
λcoh(ma, δv)
L
·
1
√
2ρDM L
·
1
p
N˙
√
T Tcoh
.Where the paper says it
In the cancellation regime (λcoh > L), gaγγ,min ∝ δv−1/2 at fixed ma <ref:2606. p. 2 Substituting (6) in the cancellation regime and solving
for the minimum detectable coupling at SNR = 1,
gaγγ,min ≃
λcoh(ma, δv)
L
·
1
√
2ρDM L
·
1
p
N˙
√
T Tcoh
. (9)
In the cancellation regime (λcoh ≫ L), λcoh/L ∝
1/(maδv) and √
Tcoh ∝ 1/δv, so that gaγγ,min ∝ δv−1/2
at fixed ma.Where the paper says it
LISA and LIGO Projections
For LISA’s native science band, the projected sensitivity to a photon-coupled ultralight DM field spans over thirteen orders of magnitude in mass with gaγγ,min below CAST throughout.
Augmenting either LIGO OR LISA with an RF heterodyne photodetection chain extends the reach into the regime where spatial coherence does not damp a possible interference signal, namely λcoh < L at higher masses. p. 5 For LIGO in its native mode, however, achievable sensitivity unfortunately falls below that of existing
experiments. Augmenting either LIGO OR LISA with an RF heterodyne photodetection chain extends the reach into the
a regime where spatial coherence does not damp a possible interference signal, namely λcoh < L at higher
masses.Where the paper says it
Directional Signatures
The local dark-matter halo carries a bulk flow with respect to the Sun arising from the Sun’s motion through the Galactic rest frame <ref:2606.16099#pg6>.
a. Annual modulation produces an annual frequency shift ∆fsig/fsig ∼ v⊕v⊙ cos γ/c2 ∼ 10−7 <ref:2606. p. 3 The peak-to-trough amplitude is ∆v/v ≈
2v⊕ cos γ/v⊙ ≈ 14%. The DM-induced sideband acquires
a corresponding annual frequency shift from the Dopplershifted kinetic-energy term in the DM dispersion relation:
∆fsig
fsig
∼
v⊕v⊙ cos γ
c
2
∼ 10−7
.Where the paper says it
b. Sidereal modulation contributes a non-zero differential signal between the arms even when both are individually in the cancellation regime λcoh > L, with a sidereal period of 23 h 56 m <ref:2606. p. 3 The two perpendicular arms of a Michelson interferometer cannot both align with ˆvwind simultaneously:
when one is aligned, the other is orthogonal. This geometric asymmetry contributes a non-zero differential signal between the arms even when both are individually in
the cancellation regime λcoh > L, with a sidereal-periodWhere the paper says it
Conclusion
The combined reach — LISA native plus heterodyne upgrades on both ground- and space-based detectors — spans over thirteen orders of magnitude in mass with sensitivity below all current laboratory constraints throughout. This constitutes the broadest projected sensitivity to photon-coupled ultralight DM via phase-modulation. p. 3 The combined LISA reach — native band plus heterodyne extension — covers 4 × 10−19 eV up to ∼ 10−5
eV,
more than thirteen orders of magnitude in mass, with
gaγγ,min below CAST throughout. This constitutes the
broadest projected sensitivity to photon-coupled ultralight DM via phase-modulation.Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved sensitivity to axion-like dark matter backgrounds in gravitational wave interferometers can be achieved by incorporating RF heterodyne photodetection chains, extending LIGO's reach to gaγγ ∼ 6.5 × 10−14 GeV−1 at ma ∼ 3 × 10−7 eV and LISA's reach to gaγγ ∼ 3.3 × 10−17 GeV−1 at ma ∼ 5 × 10−13 eV.
-
The improved AI system can perform matched filter peak finding in the scienceband Fourier spectrum for LISA, as the signal is a
narrowband sinusoid at a known frequency ma,
which reduces the search to this method across the appropriate Q linewidth. -
The system can discriminate a true ALP dark matter origin from detector artifacts by checking for predicted dependences of gaγγ,min on velocity dispersion in the cancellation regime:
as substructure becomes colder, the signal weakens.
-
The AI can identify potential dark matter streams by looking for a
sharp narrowband signal with strong directional dependence
if a cold stream contributes to the local dark matter halo with anisotropic velocity dispersion.
Abstract
Interferometric searches for axion-like dark matter (ALP DM) via the induced photon birefringence in a coherent background have been proposed and analyzed by several authors over the past decade, with tabletop experiments (LIDA, ADBC, DANCE) reporting first results and detailed calculations available for both ground-based (LIGO, GEO600 via DarkGEO) and space-based (LISA, TianQin, Taiji, BBO via Gué et al. and Yao et al.) gravitational-wave detectors. We revisit this class of measurements within the framework of Krauss (2019), and provide a detailed treatment of the interplay between the DM coherence length λ coh, the interferometer arm length L, and the detector transfer function, with attention to the distinct suppression regimes λ coh > L (cancellation) and λ coh < L (random walk). For LIGO the sensitivity is set by the Fabry-Pérot arm cavity response peaking sharply near the cavity free spectral range, reproducing the results of Nagano et al.; the naive single-pass estimate substantially overstates the reach and cannot be applied directly. For LISA, with the polarization-sensitive modification proposed by Gué et al. or Yao et al., the natural mass range m a about 4 times10-19 -- 4 times10-16 eV (LISA science band) is accessible and the projected reach g aγγ few times 10-13 GeV-1 (realistic optical-metrology noise) improves on the CAST bound over most of the band by up to about two orders of magnitude. We discuss directional signatures from the Galactic DM wind, both annual and sidereal, as a discrimination tool for candidate signals. Local DM substructure with anisotropic velocity dispersion can shift and enhance the reach in specific mass windows.
Sources
- Axions and Atomic Clocks
- Pulsar Polarization Array Limits on Ultralight Axion-like Dark Matter
- Some theoretical and experimental aspects of axion physics
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses