Differentially Private Consensus for Time-Delay Multi-agent Systems

arXiv:2606.15135 · eess.SY, cs.SY · Submitted 2026-06-13 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Robotics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest robotics and control papers.

Rosa: We're looking at the paper: "Differentially Private Consensus for Time-Delay Multi-agent Systems".

Dev: Here's the gist of the paper. Differentially private consensus for time-delay multi-agent systems is concerned with achieving differentially private consensus for discrete-time multi-agent systems with communication delays while protecting the entire delayed initial histories of all agents The purpose of the paper is to achieve differentially private consensus for such systems while protecting the entire delayed initial histories of all agents Problem Formulation and Privacy Framework The problem formulation introduces a discrete-time first-order integrator system with communication delays and privacy noises The protocol involves releasing a perturbed message where the entries of wj(k) are independent Laplace random variables with scale parameter bj(k) > 0 The global delayed initial history H is regarded as the private data to be protected Two global histories Ha and Hb are said to be ∆H-adjacent if there exists an agent i0 ∈ 1,..., N such that H a i = H b i, i 6= i0, and X 0 r=−d kxi0,a(r) − xi0,b(r)k1 ≤ ∆H The mechanism MT is said to be ε(T)-differentially private if P

MT(Ha) ∈ O: ≤ e ε(T)P

MT(Hb) ∈ O: holds for any two ∆H-adjacent histories Ha ∼ Hb and any measurable set O ⊆ (R nN)T +1 Consensus Analysis The paper establishes several consensus notions for the proposed system The system achieves mean square weak consensus if, for any initial condition and any i 6= j, limk→∞ Ekxi(k) − xj(k)k squared = 0 Mean square strong consensus is achieved if there exists a random vector x∗ ∈ R n with Ekx∗k squared < ∞ such that limk→∞ Ekxi(k) − x∗k squared = 0, i = 1,..., N Almost sure strong consensus exists if there exists a random vector x∗ with P(kx∗k < ∞) = 1 such that P

limk→∞ kxi(k) − x∗k = 0: = 1, i = 1,..., N Convergence Proof Techniques The convergence analysis relies on the difference resolvent function method and a backstepping technique The fundamental solutions for delayed difference equations are introduced to derive decay estimates for the fundamental solutions of the delayed difference equations The variation-of-constants formula is used to describe the state evolution from time t to k Exponential decay estimates are provided in Lemma 2.2 and Lemma 2.3, which serve as a key tool for the subsequent analysis Differential Privacy Guarantee A constructive parameter design is provided to achieve a prescribed infinite-horizon ε⋆-differential privacy level The noise variance is allowed to vary with time and even increase, relaxing restrictions where the noise variance is required to be constant or decaying The sensitivity with respect to the delayed initial history at time k is defined by S(k) = sup Ha,Hb∈H ΘT ∈O ρ(Ha, ΘT)(k)−ρ(Hb, ΘT)(k) 1 The mechanism MT is ε(T)-differentially private over the time horizon T, where ε(T) = X Tk=0 S(k)/bmin(k) Simulation Results Numerical simulations illustrate the theoretical results The simulation shows that the states of all agents approach a common trajectory, which verifies the consensus behavior of the closed-loop system The transmitted information exhibits persistent fluctuations due to the injected Laplace privacy noises, showing that the broadcasted data remain masked over time while the actual agent states still converge to consensus The simulation results show that the proposed mechanism can protect the delayed initial history while preserving consensus and satisfies the prescribed privacy level ε⋆ = 4.

Paper summary: Rosa: So, to wrap up what we just covered about "Differentially Private Consensus for Time-Delay Multi-agent Systems," the core idea is this: they are tackling the problem of getting a group of agents to agree on a common value in a system where messages take time to arrive and you need to keep track of every agent's history.

Dev: Right. The paper claims they can do this by using specific noise injections into the messages exchanged, specifically Laplace random variables with scale parameters that change over time. This noise is what provides the differential privacy guarantee for the entire process.

Taro: And this noise isn't just any random thing; it’s designed to work within a framework where we define adjacency between histories based on how close those initial states are, which sets up a way to measure privacy leakage across time.

Rosa: The paper is concerned with achieving differentially private consensus for discrete-time multi-agent systems with communication delays, and their primary purpose is to achieve that while protecting the entire delayed initial histories of all agents. That’s the central thesis.

Dev: So, they formally define what adjacency means between two histories, calling them delta H-adjacent if there exists an agent where their history matches except for one initial state difference which is bounded by some quantity delta H. This sets up the mathematical setup for how they measure privacy leakage across time.

Taro: I’m still curious about that initial state difference, delta H. In a real system, how big can that gap be before it counts as two different private histories?

Rosa: Well, the definition of adjacency is set up such that if this difference is small enough—less than or equal to some delta H —then we can treat those two histories as neighbors for the privacy calculation. This threshold delta H is what you need to manage to control how much information you leak about the initial states.

Dev: And they build on that by defining a mechanism MT that is called epsilon(T) -differentially private if it holds that the probability of getting an output is bounded by e epsilon(T) times the probability for two histories that are delta H-adjacent. This gives us a quantifiable privacy guarantee based on this specific distance measure across a time horizon T.

Taro: So they are linking the convergence property with this privacy measure directly, showing how the consensus process interacts with the noise injection. That’s important because usually, you try to optimize one thing and then check if it still works for the other.

Rosa: And they go on to establish several consensus notions: mean square weak consensus, mean square strong consensus, and almost sure strong consensus. These are different ways of defining what "agreement" means in this delayed system.

Dev: They show that they can achieve these different levels of agreement, which shows the robustness of the proposed method across various desired convergence goals within the same privacy framework.

Taro: That’s good to see because it means if you need a very strong guarantee on convergence, like almost sure strong consensus, this mechanism is capable of delivering that while maintaining privacy. But what about when things go wrong in the real world?

Rosa: When things go wrong, say the network topology changes or there's unexpected noise in the environment, their analysis shows that they can still get back to a state where everyone is agreeing on something, even with those delays and noises present.

Dev: So they’re showing that this differential privacy approach doesn't just hold in a perfect mathematical model; it has some staying power when you consider the real-world imperfections we see in control loops.

Taro: It means the system is designed to be resilient enough to handle those real-world failures without completely losing its ability to function as intended under the privacy constraints of this paper.

Conclusion: Rosa: So, looking at this paper, "Differentially Private Consensus for Time-Delay Multi-agent Systems," the authors are trying to solve a complex problem where you need consensus in a system with communication delays while simultaneously protecting sensitive initial data.

Dev: Exactly. The title itself points out the two main challenges: time delays and differential privacy, which are often treated separately, but here they’re being combined into one system. The paper's authors aim to provide a solution that handles both requirements together effectively.

Taro: In simple terms, they found a way to inject noise—specifically Laplace noise—into the messages so that you can get consensus even when there are delays, without leaking private information about where every agent started.

Rosa: That’s the key result. They established that you can have mean square weak consensus or strong consensus for these systems while satisfying their defined differential privacy criteria, which involves a specific sensitivity calculation S(k).

Dev: The main implication is that this gives engineers and researchers a concrete tool to design multi-agent systems—especially those dealing with time delays—with built-in privacy protection for the initial conditions.

Taro: It tells us that if you’re building something where the past state matters and communication is delayed, you don't have to choose between achieving agreement and ensuring privacy; this paper suggests there’s a trade-off that allows both to be present.

Rosa: It really shows that for systems like this, the way we define consensus needs to evolve to incorporate these privacy constraints directly into the control logic rather than just bolting on noise at the end.

Dev: Ultimately, it moves the conversation toward designing these systems with privacy as a fundamental requirement from the start, which is a big shift in how we approach distributed control and autonomy.

Ming-Yu Wang, Xiaofeng Zong, Jimin Wang, Ji-Feng Zhang

School of Future Technology, China University of Geosciences · School of Artificial Intelligence and Automation, China University of Geosciences · School of Automation and Electrical Engineering, University of Science and Technology Beijing · School of Automation and Electrical Engineering, Zhongyuan University of Technology · State Key Laboratory of Mathematical Sciences, Academy of Mathematics and Systems Science, Chinese Academy of Sciences

eess.SY, cs.SY

Submitted: 2026-06-13

Updated: 2026-11-02

Comments: 19 pages, 4 figures

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 74/100

The gist: Differentially private consensus for time-delay multi-agent systems is concerned with achieving differentially private consensus for discrete-time multi-agent systems with communication delays while…

Key concepts

Differentially Private Consensus
This is the goal of making sure that even if an attacker knows some information about the agents' past states, they cannot learn anything specific about those past states by observing the transmitted messages. It balances achieving agreement among agents with protecting sensitive historical data.
Time-Delay Multi-agent Systems
These are groups of multiple agents where communication between them is not instantaneous; there is a measurable delay in when one agent receives information from another. The system must work correctly even when messages arrive late.
Laplace Random Variables
The noise added to the transmitted messages comes from Laplace random variables. This type of noise is used because it helps achieve differential privacy by adding small, random perturbations that obscure the true underlying data while maintaining mathematical properties for privacy guarantees.

Terminology

Summary

Differentially private consensus for time-delay multi-agent systems is concerned with achieving differentially private consensus for discrete-time multi-agent systems with communication delays while protecting the entire delayed initial histories of all agents The purpose of the paper is to achieve differentially private consensus for such systems while protecting the entire delayed initial histories of all agents

Problem Formulation and Privacy Framework

The problem formulation introduces a discrete-time first-order integrator system with communication delays and privacy noises The protocol involves releasing a perturbed message where the entries of wj(k) are independent Laplace random variables with scale parameter bj(k) > 0 The global delayed initial history H is regarded as the private data to be protected Two global histories Ha and Hb are said to be ∆H-adjacent if there exists an agent i0 ∈ 1,..., N such that H a i = H b i, i 6= i0, and X 0 r=−d kxi0,a(r) − xi0,b(r)k1 ≤ ∆H The mechanism MT is said to be ε(T)-differentially private if P[MT(Ha) ∈ O] ≤ e ε(T)P[MT(Hb) ∈ O] holds for any two ∆H-adjacent histories Ha ∼ Hb and any measurable set O ⊆ (R nN)T +1

Consensus Analysis

The paper establishes several consensus notions for the proposed system The system achieves mean square weak consensus if, for any initial condition and any i 6= j, limk→∞ Ekxi(k) − xj(k)k squared = 0 Mean square strong consensus is achieved if there exists a random vector x∗ ∈ R n with Ekx∗k squared < ∞ such that limk→∞ Ekxi(k) − x∗k squared = 0, i = 1,..., N Almost sure strong consensus exists if there exists a random vector x∗ with P(kx∗k < ∞) = 1 such that P[limk→∞ kxi(k) − x∗k = 0] = 1, i = 1,. p. 3.., N

Convergence Proof Techniques

The convergence analysis relies on the difference resolvent function method and a backstepping technique The fundamental solutions for delayed difference equations are introduced to derive decay estimates for the fundamental solutions of the delayed difference equations The variation-of-constants formula is used to describe the state evolution from time t to k Exponential decay estimates are provided in Lemma 2.2 and Lemma 2. p. 23, which serve as a key tool for the subsequent analysis

Differential Privacy Guarantee

A constructive parameter design is provided to achieve a prescribed infinite-horizon ε⋆-differential privacy level The noise variance is allowed to vary with time and even increase, relaxing restrictions where the noise variance is required to be constant or decaying The sensitivity with respect to the delayed initial history at time k is defined by S(k) = sup Ha,Hb∈H ΘT ∈O ρ(Ha, ΘT)(k)−ρ(Hb, ΘT)(k) 1 The mechanism MT is ε(T)-differentially private over the time horizon T, where ε(T) = X Tk=0 S(k)/bmin(k)

Simulation Results

Numerical simulations illustrate the theoretical results The simulation shows that the states of all agents approach a common trajectory, which verifies the consensus behavior of the closed-loop system The transmitted information exhibits persistent fluctuations due to the injected Laplace privacy noises, showing that the broadcasted data remain masked over time while the actual agent states still converge to consensus The simulation results show that the proposed mechanism can protect the delayed initial history while preserving consensus and satisfies the prescribed privacy level ε⋆ = 4.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved Agent State Estimation Under Delay and Privacy: The system can maintain consensus among agents even when state information is corrupted by communication delays and injected Laplace privacy noise, ensuring that only a prescribed level of privacy is leaked into the observed data.

  2. Robust Consensus in Dynamic Topologies: The AI system can achieve mean square strong consensus on general directed graphs containing a spanning tree, meaning all agents will converge to a common value despite network changes and stochastic communication errors.

  3. Adaptive Privacy Noise Scaling: The mechanism allows for time-varying noise variance, enabling the privacy protection level to increase over time without compromising the convergence of the consensus algorithm, which is crucial for long-running systems.

  4. Prescribed Infinite Horizon Privacy Guarantees: The system can be designed with a constructive parameter design to achieve a specific infinite horizon epsilon star differential privacy level, allowing for tailored trade-offs between privacy and accuracy as required by regulatory standards.

  5. Strong Consensus Under No Constant Noise Bounds: The system achieves mean square strong consensus and almost sure strong consensus even when the noise variance does not decay to zero, provided certain conditions on the control gain sequence c(k) are met, relaxing previous constraints on noise behavior.

Related papers