Measurement-Based Performance Evaluation of SmartRSUs with Heterogeneous Antenna Architectures for V2X Communications
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Computer Science. The day in computer science: software, systems and theory on arXiv.
Tom: I'm Tom.
Jane: And I'm Jane, here with Lu, Meng and our in-house large language model, Lalam.
Tom: We're looking at the paper: "Measurement-Based Performance Evaluation of SmartRSUs with Heterogeneous Antenna Architectures for V2X Communications".
Jane: Here's the gist of the paper. Measurement-based performance evaluation of two custom Smart Roadside Units featuring different V2X antenna architectures reveals trade-offs between integrated and external antenna configurations in realworld deployment scenarios Evaluation Scope The experimental campaign evaluates key V2X communication metrics, including coverage, received signal strength indicator (RSSI), packet loss, and end-to-end latency in both transmission (OBU-to-infrastructure) and reception (infrastructure-to-OBU) directions To ensure objective validation, a commercial off-the shelf V2X Roadside Unit is co-located on the same infrastructure and used as a performance benchmark, providing groundtruth reference measurements under identical environmental conditions through a controlled co-located deployment Antenna Configurations Compared The two SmartRSUs analyzed in this paper differ in their antenna architectures: one uses an integrated all-in-one rooftop module that combines GNSS and communication antennas, while the other employs external dual ITS-G5 antennas with a dedicated GNSS unit The first solution adopts an integrated all-in-one antenna module that combines GNSS and ITSG5 communications, whereas the second employs a separate design with a rooftop GNSS antenna and two external ITS-G5 dipole antennas Performance Metrics Analysis The results highlight a clear difference between the two antenna configurations The SmartRSU equipped with external ITS-G5 antennas consistently achieves higher RSSI values compared to the integrated solution Moreover, the coverage range is significantly extended: while the integrated antenna configuration provides reliable reception up to approximately 175 m, the external antenna solution maintains connectivity up to approximately 300 m The results again highlight the differences among the considered RSUs Latency and Control Latency measurements under controlled traffic conditions demonstrate that low-latency communication in the order of a few milliseconds is achievable with the proposed platform The results show that latency strongly depends on the selected modulation scheme BPSK yields an average latency of approximately 4 ms, which decreases to below 2 ms with QPSK and to approximately 1 ms with 16QAM Overall, this work confirms that SmartRSUs based on open and modular platforms can provide a flexible and effective alternative to proprietary solutions At the same time, the results emphasize that antenna configuration remains a critical design factor that must be carefully considered in real-world deployments Future work will extend this analysis to more complex scenarios, including higher traffic densities, multi-RSU cooperation, and the integration of sensing and communication functionalities for infrastructure-assisted applications References
Title and authors: Tom: So, we're talking about the paper "Measurement-Based Performance Evaluation of SmartRSUs with Heterogeneous Antenna Architectures for V2X Communications" today. It looks like they're really digging into how different antenna setups on these roadside units affect their actual performance in the real world, not just some theoretical stuff.
Jane: Yeah, and the authors are Marco Savarese, Gaetano Orazio Cauchi, Salvatore Iandolo, Antonio Solida, Martin Klapez, Maurizio Casoni, Micaela Verucchi, Enrico Vincenzi, Ignacio Sanudo Olmedo, Marko Bertogna, and Carlo Augusto Grazia. The title itself tells you right away that this is about comparing different antenna designs on Smart Roadside Units using real measurements.
Lu: What's interesting here is that they are testing two very different hardware approaches: one uses an all-in-one rooftop module combining GPS and communication, while the other uses a separate setup with a dedicated GPS unit and two external ITS G5 antennas. This sets up a direct comparison to see which architecture performs better in practice.
Meng: I'm curious about the setup first. How are they making sure this isn't just some lab test where everything is perfect? We need to know how robust these measurements are before we even look at the results of the "Measurement-Based Performance Evaluation of SmartRSUs with Heterogeneous Antenna Architectures for V2X Communications" paper.
Lalam: The paper mentions they used a commercial off-the-shelf V2X Roadside Unit co-located on the same infrastructure to act as a performance benchmark, which is what makes it measurement-based and trying to keep things fair.
Tom: Exactly. It’s not just measuring the hardware in isolation; they’re putting these units side by side with something real, like that commercial unit, under identical environmental conditions to get objective ground truth data on coverage and signal strength indicator, or RSSI.
Jane: And what's the core of this evaluation? They are looking at several key V2X communication metrics: coverage range, RSSI values, packet loss rates in both directions—transmission and reception—and the end-to-end latency. It’s a comprehensive look at how these antennas translate into actual communication reliability.
Lu: I'm interested in the specific trade-offs they found between those two configurations because that’s where the real engineering insight is usually found in hardware design papers like this one about SmartRSUs with Heterogeneous Antenna Architectures for V2X Communications.
Meng: What kind of performance differences are we actually looking at? Are we talking about small gains or something that makes a big difference when you're trying to deploy this on a city street? I need to know what breaks at scale.
Lalam: The paper found that the SmartRSU equipped with external ITS G5 antennas consistently achieved higher RSSI values compared to the integrated solution, and they also saw a significant extension in coverage range.
Tom: So, if you take those numbers—the one hundred seventy-five meter coverage for the integrated one versus about three hundred meters for the external antenna solution—that’s a pretty tangible difference in deployment viability. That’s what matters when you're talking about real-world deployment scenarios.
Jane: And it doesn't just stop at range, because they also looked at how reliable the connection was, specifically mentioning packet loss and end-to-end latency under transmission and reception conditions. It shows the paper is looking at performance holistically.
Lu: Beyond just coverage and RSSI, I want to know what this means for non-line-of-sight situations, because that’s where antennas often struggle the most in real deployments of SmartRSUs with Heterogeneous Antenna Architectures for V2X Communications.
Meng: Can you elaborate on that? Does the external antenna setup actually make a difference when things aren't perfectly lined up, or is it just better for line-of-sight scenarios? Because if it’s only good in perfect conditions, then we need to know what the actual failure rate is.
Lalam: The results suggest that the improved system can offer more reliable communication in non-line-of-sight conditions because of better signal propagation characteristics, as evidenced by the results showing that the external antenna solution maintains connectivity where the integrated solution exhibits higher packet loss and limited coverage.
Tom: That’s a concrete result there. So, we've seen a difference in range and reliability under bad conditions because of the external antenna architecture versus the integrated one in this paper, Measurement-Based Performance Evaluation of SmartRSUs with Heterogeneous Antenna Architectures for V2X Communications.
Jane: And moving on to what they found about speed, latency is another big part of V2X. They measured end-to-end latency under controlled traffic conditions and found that low latency communication in the order of a few milliseconds was achievable with their proposed platform.
Lu: The paper also breaks down how modulation scheme impacts this, showing that BPSK yields an average latency of approximately four milliseconds, which then drops to below two milliseconds with QPSK, and finally down to about one millisecond with 16QAM. That shows a clear relationship between the modulation and the speed you can get for time-sensitive applications.
Meng: One millisecond is fast for driving or remote driving applications. But how much does that latency depend on the modulation choice? If we pick a slower scheme like BPSK, are we still going to be usable in an actual traffic scenario? I need to know if this one millisecond is consistent under load <ref:2606.13334#pg1>.
Lalam: They also mentioned that the V2X stack control offered by the proposed platform allows for full control of the communication stack on both OBU and RSU sides, which lets them do a detailed performance analysis that’s not typically possible with commercial devices.
Tom: That level of control is what makes this measurement-based approach powerful. It means they aren't just reporting a number; they’re proving *why* it performs that way by controlling every variable on both sides of the communication link in this paper, Measurement-Based Performance Evaluation of SmartRSUs with Heterogeneous Antenna Architectures for V2X Communications.
Jane: So, to wrap up the main findings, this paper confirms that SmartRSUs based on open and modular platforms can give us a flexible and effective alternative to proprietary solutions when we consider the design choices. But it also strongly emphasizes that antenna configuration remains a critical design factor you absolutely have to think about in real-world deployments.
Lu: I agree with Jane, the flexibility of the open platform is great, but they make it clear that picking an antenna setup is not just a preference; it’s a fundamental design decision that dictates how far and how reliably those V2X messages travel.
Meng: From my side, what's missing is the practical cost of implementing this external antenna system versus the integrated one. If the external one gives you one hundred fifty meters more coverage, is that extra hardware worth the deployment complexity and maintenance headaches?
Lalam: The paper notes that future work will extend this analysis to more complex scenarios, like higher traffic densities, multi-RSU cooperation, and integrating sensing and communication functionalities for infrastructure-assisted applications.
Tom: That sounds like a good direction for future research because real cities are getting way more complex. So, in summary of this paper on Measurement-Based Performance Evaluation of SmartRSUs with Heterogeneous Antenna Architectures for V2X Communications, we see clear wins with external antennas in coverage and reliability but acknowledge that the antenna choice is still central to the whole system.
Jane: And that's where we'll leave it for now. We’ve seen how different hardware configurations translate into real-world V2X performance metrics, and I think this paper gives us a solid baseline for thinking about future SmartRSU designs.
The paper's summary: Tom: So, we just looked at how different antenna setups on these roadside units affect their actual performance in the real world today. Now we're going to break down what these authors actually found in their summary of this paper, "Measurement-Based Performance Evaluation of SmartRSUs with Heterogeneous Antenna Architectures for V2X Communications."
Jane: Right. So essentially, they compared two distinct ways to build a Smart Roadside Unit. One used an all-in-one module that had both the GPS and the communication antenna built right in, and the other used separate parts: a dedicated GPS antenna on top and two separate external antennas for the communication part.
Lu: The core of their summary is showing that this hardware difference creates real performance gaps, not just theoretical ones. They measured things like how far you can actually talk to the unit—coverage—and how strong that signal is, which they call RSSI values.
Meng: So if I'm running a system in the field, what does that mean for my deployment? Are we talking about a small difference or something major?
Tom: They found it’s pretty major on coverage and reliability. The unit with the external antennas got much better signal strength, higher RSSI values. And their range extended way out—we're talking about going from maybe one hundred seventy-five meters to around three hundred meters of reliable connection.
Jane: It’s not just the distance, though; they looked at packet loss too, especially when the road isn't perfectly clear, what we call non-line-of-sight conditions. The external antenna setup handled those situations way better because it had different signal propagation characteristics.
Lu: And they also measured how fast things move—latency. They confirmed that you can get very low latency communication, maybe just a few milliseconds, which is crucial for time-sensitive stuff like remote driving applications. They showed how choosing a specific modulation scheme, like BPSK versus QPSK or 16QAM, directly changes that speed down to about one millisecond.
Meng: So the modulation choice matters a lot for the speed we can actually get out of this thing in traffic. That’s something I need to keep in mind when I’m picking my communication protocol for production.
Tom: Exactly. And what this really changes for us is that they proved you can use open, modular platforms instead of just sticking with one proprietary solution, and they showed that the antenna design is a critical factor you absolutely have to consider before you deploy anything in the field today.
Jane: The implication here is clear: if we want robust V2X deployment, we can't just pick whatever unit looks good on paper; we have to measure and choose the right physical antennas for our specific environment. Now, that leads us into what happens when these units start talking to each other and AI perception systems.
The paper's improvements: Tom: So we've seen how the authors compared their two antenna designs—the integrated versus the external ones—and now they’re laying out what they think we should actually do to make these Smart Roadside Units better in deployment, which is where my engineering brain gets excited.
Jane: They aren't just stopping at comparing hardware; they are suggesting concrete improvements based on those measurements. One big suggestion is that the external dual ITS G5 antennas really push performance further out than the integrated module did, giving you that extra hundred and twenty-five meters of range we talked about earlier.
Lu: They also pointed out a major win in handling bad signal conditions, non-line-of-sight scenarios. The external antenna solution maintains connectivity where the integrated one was dropping packets more often, which is a huge deal for real city environments.
Meng: So it’s not just about having bigger antennas; it’s about how they handle messy signals in reality. What does that mean for me when I'm trying to deploy this thing in an area with lots of buildings blocking the signal?
Tom: It means you need to look at the whole system, not just one part. They are pushing the idea that using open and modular platforms lets you tweak these antenna configurations easily, making it flexible instead of locked into a single proprietary design.
Jane: And they mentioned something really interesting about adding sensing capabilities. They discussed how integrating an intelligent camera platform onto the Smart Roadside Unit could allow the system to generate AI assisted perception messages, which they call ETSI-compliant Cooperative Awareness Messages, or CAMs, even for things that aren't connected directly.
Lu: That’s where it gets ambitious. If you can get sensing data from a camera and turn it into V2X messages for entities that aren't on the network yet, that opens up a whole new layer of infrastructure-assisted applications. It moves us past just communicating with cars to actually having the road itself "see" and report things.
Meng: That sounds like a lot of extra compute and data processing running on the roadside unit. What’s the trade-off there? Does that make it too expensive or too complex to run reliably in production?
Tom: That's exactly what they want us to think about. The paper confirms that this approach is flexible, but it sets up a clear path for future work where you integrate sensing and communication functionalities together, which is the next big step for these units.
Jane: So, the summary suggests that while the antenna choice matters a lot now, the real future lies in combining those communication bits with local perception to make infrastructure much smarter.
Conclusion: Tom: So we're wrapping up our look at "Measurement-Based Performance Evaluation of SmartRSUs with Heterogeneous Antenna Architectures for V2X Communications." Basically, we saw that choosing the right antenna setup—integrated versus external—makes a huge difference in how far you can actually communicate and how reliable that connection is.
Jane: That’s right. The authors showed that the external antennas give you better range and way more reliable connections under tricky conditions like non-line-of-sight, which is a big step for making these systems work reliably in real cities.
Lu: I think what’s really important is that this paper validates using open and modular platforms because it shows you can control the communication stack on both sides, which gives you a detailed performance analysis that commercial units don't offer.
Meng: So for us shipping models to production, the takeaway is that we need to treat antenna configuration as a critical design choice before we even start building anything. It’s not just about picking the cheapest hardware; it’s about picking the one that gives you a measurable performance boost in coverage and reliability.
Lalam: I'm confident in saying this because the measurements were direct, using a commercial benchmark to get ground truth data on coverage, RSSI values, and packet loss in both directions. The results are very solid regarding the physical layer performance of these two antenna types.
Tom: It’s solid because they didn't just make some claims; they showed us the numbers for latency too—how BPSK at four milliseconds drops down to about one millisecond with 16QAM, which is really important for time-sensitive applications.
Jane: And that speed detail shows how much control we have over the communication stack, which makes this platform very useful for things like remote driving where every millisecond counts.
Lu: It confirms the idea that these platforms are flexible because you can swap out components and still get a measurable improvement in real-world deployment scenarios.
Meng: I just hope that when we look at future work, they actually address the cost of implementing that external antenna system versus keeping everything integrated, because complexity always comes with an implementation headache.
Lalam: They did mention that future work will extend this analysis to more complex scenarios like higher traffic densities and multi-RSU cooperation, which is where these units will get even more demanding.
Tom: So, the final word on "Measurement-Based Performance Evaluation of SmartRSUs with Heterogeneous Antenna Architectures for V2X Communications" is that it sets a clear baseline showing how antenna design dictates real-world performance gains in coverage and signal strength.
Jane: It’s a practical study that tells us exactly which hardware configuration to lean towards when building these next generation Smart Roadside Units.
Lu: That groundwork is important because it points us toward integrating sensing and communication functionalities, which is the direction I think this research will take us next.
Meng: Right, so the focus shifts from just getting a signal to actually making that infrastructure smart by adding perception capabilities.
Marco Savarese, Gaetano Orazio Cauchi, Salvatore Iandolo, Antonio Solida, Martin Klapez, Maurizio Casoni, Micaela Verucchi, Enrico Vincenzi, Ignacio Sanudo Olmedo, Marko Bertogna
Department of Engineering Enzo Ferrari, University of Modena and Reggio Emilia · Hipert S.r.L. · MOST – Sustainable Mobility National Research Center
cs.NI
Submitted: 2026-06-11
Updated: 2026-06-11
Comments: Accepted for publication at the 2026 IEEE International Workshop on Metrology for Automotive (MetroAutomotive 2026)
DOI: 10.1109/MetroAutomotive69354.2026.11644677
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 77/100
The gist: Measurement-based performance evaluation of two custom Smart Roadside Units featuring different V2X antenna architectures reveals trade-offs between integrated and external antenna configurations in…
Key concepts
- Integrated Antenna Module
- This configuration uses a single all-in-one rooftop module combining both the GNSS and communication antennas into one unit. It is simpler to deploy but limited in its ability to maximize signal reception and coverage range compared to separate components.
- External Dual ITS-G5 Antennas
- This setup involves a separate design with a dedicated GNSS antenna on the roof and two external ITS-G5 dipole antennas for communication. This configuration proved superior, achieving higher signal strength (RSSI) and significantly greater coverage range (up to 300m).
- RSSI (Received Signal Strength Indicator)
- RSSI is a metric measuring how strong the radio signal is when it reaches the receiver. Higher RSSI values indicate a stronger connection between the Roadside Unit and other devices, which is essential for reliable V2X communication.
- Latency Modulation Schemes
- Latency refers to the delay in communication time. The study tested different modulation schemes: BPSK resulted in about 4ms latency, while QPSK reduced it to under 2ms, and 16QAM achieved approximately 1ms latency, showing how data encoding affects speed.
Terminology
Summary
Measurement-based performance evaluation of two custom Smart Roadside Units featuring different V2X antenna architectures reveals trade-offs between integrated and external antenna configurations in realworld deployment scenarios
Evaluation Scope
The experimental campaign evaluates key V2X communication metrics, including coverage, received signal strength indicator (RSSI), packet loss, and end-to-end latency in both transmission (OBU-to-infrastructure) and reception (infrastructure-to-OBU) directions To ensure objective validation, a commercial off-the shelf V2X Roadside Unit is co-located on the same infrastructure and used as a performance benchmark, providing groundtruth reference measurements under identical environmental conditions through a controlled co-located deployment
Antenna Configurations Compared
The two SmartRSUs analyzed in this paper differ in their antenna architectures: one uses an integrated all-in-one rooftop module that combines GNSS and communication antennas, while the other employs external dual ITS-G5 antennas with a dedicated GNSS unit The first solution adopts an integrated all-in-one antenna module that combines GNSS and ITSG5 communications, whereas the second employs a separate design with a rooftop GNSS antenna and two external ITS-G5 dipole antennas
Performance Metrics Analysis
The results highlight a clear difference between the two antenna configurations The SmartRSU equipped with external ITS-G5 antennas consistently achieves higher RSSI values compared to the integrated solution Moreover, the coverage range is significantly extended: while the integrated antenna configuration provides reliable reception up to approximately 175 m, the external antenna solution maintains connectivity up to approximately 300 m The results again highlight the differences among the considered RSUs
Latency and Control
Latency measurements under controlled traffic conditions demonstrate that low-latency communication in the order of a few milliseconds is achievable with the proposed platform The results show that latency strongly depends on the selected modulation scheme BPSK yields an average latency of approximately 4 ms, which decreases to below 2 ms with QPSK and to approximately 1 ms with 16QAM
Conclusion on Design Impact
Overall, this work confirms that SmartRSUs based on open and modular platforms can provide a flexible and effective alternative to proprietary solutions At the same time, the results emphasize that antenna configuration remains a critical design factor that must be carefully considered in real-world deployments Future work will extend this analysis to more complex scenarios, including higher traffic densities, multi-RSU cooperation, and the integration of sensing and communication functionalities for infrastructure-assisted applications
References
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved SmartRSU antenna design can achieve higher RSSI values over a wider coverage range, specifically extending connectivity from approximately 175 m to approximately 300 m when using external dual ITS-G5 antennas compared to the integrated all-in-one module.
-
The improved system can offer more reliable communication in non-line-of-sight (NLOS) conditions due to better signal propagation characteristics, as evidenced by the results showing that the external antenna solution maintains connectivity where the integrated solution exhibits higher packet loss and limited coverage.
-
The ODU platform, when integrated with an intelligent camera platform on a SmartRSU, enables AI assisted perception systems such as AI-CAM [2], allowing roadside sensing to generate ETSI-compliant Cooperative Awareness Messages (CAMs) for non-connected entities.
-
The system can support low latency communication in the order of a few milliseconds using BPSK modulation, which decreases further to below 2 milliseconds with QPSK and approximately 1 millisecond with 16QAM, confirming suitability for time-sensitive applications such as remote driving.
-
The V2X stack control offered by the proposed platform allows for full control of the communication stack on both OBU and RSU sides, enabling detailed performance analysis not typically possible with commercial devices.
Related papers
- Predicting Networks Before They Happen: Experimentation on a Real-Time V2X Digital Twin
- MultiMoQ: Multi-Access Media-Over-QUIC for Robust Immersive Video Streaming
- HiFiNet: Hierarchical Fault Identification in Wireless Sensor Networks via Edge-Based Classification and Graph Aggregation
- Flux: Optimal Scheduling of Optical Circuit Switches for LLM Training
- Tutorial on Closed-Loop and Application-Aware Digital Twins for Future Wireless Networks
- Claude Code Complete User Handbook