Thermodynamic Approach to Momentum Transport in Dense Fluids
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Thermodynamic Approach to Momentum Transport in Dense Fluids".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper presents a new framework for extending Chapman-Enskog theory beyond hard-sphere fluid models by using an exchange function related to thermodynamic properties.
Kai: This approach proposes an alternative to Modified Enskog Theory (MET) that incorporates potential interaction energy, and it is applied to predict the shear viscosity of various simulated fluid models across a wide range of densities and temperatures.
Mira: New Theoretical Framework The authors propose a general framework based around an exchange function that does not necessarily depend on effective hard-sphere parameters.
Kai: They introduce a convenient exchange function denoted as gˆ that depends on the total excluded volume fraction Vexclρ, as well as pairwise correlations, defined as gˆ = Vexclρg(σ+HS).
Paper summary: Kai: So we're talking about a paper called "Thermodynamic Approach to Momentum Transport in Dense Fluids," and it looks like the main idea is extending Chapman-Enskog theory beyond just hard-sphere fluids, which is pretty big because that's where we usually start Mira yeah, it suggests using an exchange function related to thermodynamic properties instead of just effective hard sphere parameters Kai right.
Lev: so if you look at what they propose, they introduce this convenient exchange function called g hat which depends on the total excluded volume fraction and pairwise correlations, defined as g hat equals Vexclrho times g of sigma plus HS Mira that quantity is directly proportional to the collision rate of hard spheres for hard spheres Kai
Kai: and what they do with it is rewrite an equation, like equation four, into this form where the left hand side becomes eta Enskog divided by eta zero equals a limit over rho of g hat over rho times one over g hat plus zero point eight plus zero point seven six one four times g hat Mira that expression captures all the density dependent deviation from the low-density limit Lev
Lev: but they also show how existing extensions like modified Enskog theory, or MET, fit into this new framework by setting a specific residual function for it at T times the derivative of Z with respect to T times rho Mira and there's another choice for kinetic theory called DHS kinetic theory where they use beta upot in equation seven Kai
Kai: and what's interesting here is that they suggest using a different choice, xres equals beta uex, for a broader set of fluid models inspired by kinetic DHS theory because it has the same leading order linear density term as MET at low density Mira
Lev: so this means the main gain from their framework is turning the problem of finding an expression for shear viscosity into finding a suitable function for xres Kai and they show that this choice, xres equals beta uex, is actually equivalent to setting xmet res equals T times derivative of Z with respect to T times rho in equation seven Mira
Kai: which they say captures more of the relevant physics underlying momentum exchange at elevated densities compared to using xmet res Lev and for the diatomic Lennard Jones fluids they introduce a heuristic modification by scaling beta uex by a fit parameter C, so g hat becomes Z minus one minus C beta uex Mira
Lev: and that specific modification with the fit parameter C is what improves accuracy for those diatomic Lennard Jones fluids from twenty percent down to five percent when you're fitting it right Kai
Kai: and the authors conclude that thermodynamic relations based on beta uex provide accurate descriptions of shear viscosity across a wide set of fluid models and simulation parameters Mira they suggest that the limitations of Chapman-Enskog theory aren't as severe as we often think if you choose the exchange function carefully Lev
Kai: but they also point out a limitation, specifically that xres equals beta uex on its own is a poor choice for diatomic Lennard Jones fluids, which is why they needed that fit parameter C to get better results Mira
Lev: so what this means for us in the real world is that we have a tool here to predict shear viscosity for these dense fluids without needing the effective hard sphere diameters which can be tricky to determine Kai but we still need careful choices about what function we pick for xres depending on the fluid type Mira
Kai: so if you're driving or cooking and you want to know how much resistance you'll feel from a dense fluid, this paper suggests that picking the right thermodynamic path instead of just using simple hard sphere models might give you a better prediction Lev
Mira: it means we can use these thermodynamic relations to model fluids even when the interactions aren't perfectly elastic, like in those diatomic LJ fluids, as long as we incorporate corrections for inelasticity Kai but the authors themselves flag that figuring out how xres depends on the actual microscopic characteristics of a fluid is still something that needs more investigation Lev
Kai: so for future work, they need to figure out how xres generally depends on those underlying microscopic things, because right now using beta uex alone isn't quite enough for everything Mira and that's where the real physics lies Lev
Conclusion: Kai: So we're looking at this paper called "Thermodynamic Approach to Momentum Transport in Dense Fluids," and it’s about taking that old Chapman-Enskog theory and making it work for fluids that are really dense, not just hard spheres.
Mira: Right, the authors are proposing a new way to look at how momentum moves in these systems by using an exchange function tied directly to the thermodynamic properties of the fluid.
Lev: So they’re trying to avoid relying solely on those effective hard sphere parameters and instead use something that depends on things like excluded volume and pairwise correlations.
Kai: They set up this general framework where any equation of state has to fit a certain shape, which is really neat because it shows how different theories like Modified Enskog Theory fit into this bigger picture.
Mira: The core idea they are pushing is that by choosing the right function for the residual term, xres equals beta uex, you get a description of shear viscosity that works across these many different fluid models.
Lev: And for those diatomic fluids where things aren't perfectly elastic because of bond stretching, they introduce a correction factor to make it work better with inelasticity.
Kai: So the big takeaway here is that this thermodynamic way of looking at things gives us a tool to predict shear viscosity for these dense fluids, but whether it’s perfect depends entirely on how carefully you pick your function for xres.
Mira: Exactly, and while it works well for a lot of models, they admit that using just beta uex isn't the best choice for diatomic liquids without that extra correction factor C.
Lev: So we’ve got a framework here that handles density dependence better than some standard kinetic theories, but we still need to figure out how xres connects to those microscopic details of the fluid itself.
Department of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering, Norwegian University of Science and Technology · Department of Chemistry and Biomedical Science, Norwegian University of Science and Technology
cond-mat.stat-mech, cond-mat.soft
Submitted: 2026-06-09
Updated: 2026-11-05
Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Research 8, 043132 (2026)
DOI: 10.1103/5z8g-qwyf
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 57/100
The gist: The paper presents a new framework for extending Chapman-Enskog theory beyond hard-sphere fluid models by using an exchange function related to thermodynamic properties.
Key concepts
- Exchange Function (ĝ)
- This function depends on the total excluded volume fraction and pairwise correlations, representing the collision rate of hard spheres for hard spheres. It is central to rewriting kinetic equations and capturing density-dependent deviations from low-density limits in fluid dynamics.
- Modified Enskog Theory (MET)
- MET is an existing extension of kinetic theory where the residual function Xres is set to -T (∂Z/∂T)ρ. The new framework shows that MET belongs to a broader class of theories, allowing for a more general description of momentum transport.
- Xres = βuex
- This choice for the residual function is proposed as a superior alternative to XMETres. It is motivated because it shares the same leading order (linear) density term as MET at low density and captures more relevant physics regarding momentum exchange at higher densities.
- Inelasticity Modification (C)
- For fluids with bond stretching, the authors modify Xres by scaling βuex with a fit parameter C. This adjustment accounts for inelastic interactions, improving accuracy for diatomic Lennard-Jones fluids from 20% error down to 5%.
Terminology
Summary
The paper presents a new framework for extending Chapman-Enskog theory beyond hard-sphere fluid models by using an exchange function related to thermodynamic properties. p. 0 de Wijn1 , ‡
1Department of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering,
Norwegian University of Science and Technology, NO-7491 Trondheim, Norway
2Department of Chemistry and Biomedical Science,
Norwegian University of Science and Technology, NO-7491 Trondheim, Norway
We present a new framework for extending Chapman-Enskog theory beyond the hard-sphere
fluid model. Rather than relying on effective hard sphere diameters, the approach makes use of
on an exchange function which can be related to the thermodynamic properties of the system. Based on our approach, we propose an alternative to MET that takes into account
the potential interaction energy associated with the inter-particle interactions in the fluid. The
proposed expression is applied to predicting the shear viscosity of several different simulated fluid
models across a wide set of densities 0.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
New Theoretical Framework
The authors propose a general framework based around an exchange function that does not necessarily depend on effective hard-sphere parameters. They introduce a convenient exchange function denoted as gˆ that depends on the total excluded volume fraction Vexclρ, as well as pairwise correlations, defined as gˆ = Vexclρg(σ+HS). p. 2 (4) g(σ
+
HS) always appears together with Vexclρ. We therefore introduce a convenient exchange function ˆg that depends on the total
excluded volume fraction Vexclρ, as well as pairwise correlations, defined as
gˆ = Vexclρg(σ
+
HS) . We therefore introduce a convenient exchange function ˆg that depends on the total
excluded volume fraction Vexclρ, as well as pairwise correlations, defined as
gˆ = Vexclρg(σ
+
HS) . (5)
When applied to hard spheres, this quantity is directly
proportional to the collision rate of hard spheres [12]. Thermodynamic Approach to Momentum Transport in Dense Fluids
Christopher Devik Fjeldstad,1 , ∗ Jonas Bueie,2, † and Astrid S. de Wijn1 , ‡
1Department of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering,
Norwegian University of Science and Technology, NO-7491 Trondheim, Norway
2Department of Chemistry and Biomedical Science,
Norwegian University of Science and Technology, NO-7491 Trondheim, Norway
We present a new framework for extending Chapman-Enskog theory beyond the hard-sphere
fluid model. Making use of the fact that Vexcl is independent of density, Eq. (4) can now be rewritten as
ηEnskog
η0
= lim
ρ→0
gˆ
ρ
ρ
1
gˆ
+ 0. The right
hand side of Eq. (6) captures all density dependent deviation from the low-density limit. In general, any equation of state has to reduce to Eq. (2) in the
limit of HS, which means that they must have the general form Z − 1 = ˆg + Xres, where Xres is an appropriate
residual function of the thermodynamic state, here defined as a property that vanishes for hard sphere fluids. In general, any equation of state has to reduce to Eq. (2) in the
limit of HS, which means that they must have the general form Z − 1 = ˆg + Xres, where Xres is an appropriate
residual function of the thermodynamic state, here defined as a property that vanishes for hard sphere fluids.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Existing Extensions and Choices
The framework demonstrates that MET and DHS kinetic theory both belong to this more general class of approaches. For MET, the residual function is set to XMETres = −T (∂Z/∂T)ρ in Eq. p. 2 In general, any equation of state has to reduce to Eq. (2) in the
limit of HS, which means that they must have the general form Z − 1 = ˆg + Xres, where Xres is an appropriate
residual function of the thermodynamic state, here defined as a property that vanishes for hard sphere fluids. Dipolar hard-sphere theory
Pousaneh and de Wijn [17] proposed DHS kinetic theory, derived for predicting the shear viscosity of DHS
fluids with particles that consist of hard spheres with
diameter σHS with a point dipole at their centre. This
approach makes use of the fact that [18] for DHS fluids
2π
3
σ
3
HSρg(σ
+
HS) = Z − 1 − βupot , (10)
where βupot = βhUpoti/N with Upot denoting the total
potential energy of the fluid. We show that two existing extensions to Enskog theory, modified Enskog theory and
kinetic dipolar hard-sphere (DHS) theory, both fit into
this framework. Inspired by kinetic DHS theory, we propose that the
relation Xres = βuex can be applied to a more general set
of fluid models. The assumptions underlying MET are expected to hold
at low density, and so a reasonable choice for Xres will
have to behave the same to leading (linear) order in the
density. If XMET
res is expanded in orders of ρ, the linear
term, corresponding to the second virial approximation,
is given by [8]
XMET
res ≈ −T
dB2(T )
dT ρ , (11)
at low density, where B2(T ) is the second virial coefficient.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Model Testing and Results
The approach is tested using three distinct fluid models: cut and shifted Mie fluids, full Mie fluids, and a diatomic Lennard-Jones fluid. For atomic Mie-type fluids, the predicted shear viscosity is close to the numerical shear viscosity of the simulated model fluids with typical relative errors lying in the range of δerror. p. 6 (4) with σHS = σ. In all cases, the predicted shear viscosity is close to
the numerical shear viscosity of the simulated model fluids, with typical relative errors δerror lying in the range
δerror . The fluid models considered include both the Weeks-Chandler-Anderson (WCA) fluid
and the Lennard-Jones (LJ) fluid. At low and intermediate density, here taken to be ρ
∗ ≤ 0. The fluid models considered include both the Weeks-Chandler-Anderson (WCA) fluid
and the Lennard-Jones (LJ) fluid. At low and intermediate density, here taken to be ρ
∗ ≤ 0. The fluid models considered include both the Weeks-Chandler-Anderson (WCA) fluid
and the Lennard-Jones (LJ) fluid. At low and intermediate density, here taken to be ρ
∗ ≤ 0. The fluid models considered include both the Weeks-Chandler-Anderson (WCA) fluid
and the Lennard-Jones (LJ) fluid. At low and intermediate density, here taken to be ρ
∗ ≤ 0. When ρ
∗ & 0. 35,
the errors generally get larger, although the magnitude
of the errors depends on the exact interaction model and
interaction parameters. When ρ
∗ & 0. 35,
the errors generally get larger, although the magnitude
of the errors depends on the exact interaction model and
interaction parameters. 35, the errors associated mean relative errors get
larger. When applied to diatomic molecular LJ fluids, the
overall mean relative errors are larger, between 15% and
30%.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Refining the Approach for Inelasticity
For diatomic LJ fluids, where interactions are not fully elastic due to bond stretching, the authors introduce a heuristic modification of Xres by scaling βuex by a fit parameter C, resulting in gˆ = Z − 1 − Cβuex. This approach yields mean relative errors associated with the fit in the range of 1. p. 9 To this end, we introduce
a heuristic modification of Xres, whereby βuex is scaled
by a fit parameter C. The mean relative errors associated
with the fit lie in the range of 1. (6)
to simulation data for the shear viscosity of diatomic LJ fluids. this trend, one should expect C < 1 when fitting the
resulting expression to data for inelastic model systems,
which is in agreement with the values obtained for C as
reported in Table III, indicating that the effective interaction strength is weakened by the presence of inelastic
interactions.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusion on Applicability
In general, thermodynamic relations relying on βuex provide accurate descriptions of the shear viscosity across a wide set of fluid models and simulation parameters. The success of this approach demonstrates that the limitations of Chapman-Enskog theory are not as severe as is often believed as long as the exchange function is chosen carefully. p. 9 Further work is needed to understand how
Xres generally depends on the underlying microscopic
characteristics of the fluid. Regardless, the success of our
approach demonstrates that the limitations of ChapmanEnskog theory are not as severe as is often believed as
long as the exchange function is chosen carefully. Further work is needed to understand how
Xres generally depends on the underlying microscopic
characteristics of the fluid. Regardless, the success of our
approach demonstrates that the limitations of ChapmanEnskog theory are not as severe as is often believed as
long as the exchange function is chosen carefully. Further work is needed to understand how
Xres generally depends on the underlying microscopic
characteristics of the fluid. Regardless, the success of our
approach demonstrates that the limitations of ChapmanEnskog theory are not as severe as is often believed as
long as the exchange function is chosen carefully. In general, we find that thermodynamic relations relying on βuex provide accurate descriptions of the shear
viscosity across a wide set of fluid models and simulation
parameters. Further work is needed to understand how
Xres generally depends on the underlying microscopic
characteristics of the fluid. a prediction error between roughly 20% and 30%. We
can thus conclude that Xres = βuex on its own is a poor
choice for the diatomic LJ fluids. a prediction error between roughly 20% and 30%. We
can thus conclude that Xres = βuex on its own is a poor
choice for the diatomic LJ fluids.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Pruning redundant reasoning tokens
The paper shows that the predicted shear viscosity is close to the numerical shear viscosity of the simulated model fluids with typical relative errors lying in the range of δerror. 5% when density is low. When density exceeds ρ∗. 35, prediction errors generally get larger. The overall mean relative errors for diatomic LJ fluids are larger, between 15% and 30%. p. 9 35, the errors associated mean relative errors get
larger. When applied to diatomic molecular LJ fluids, the
overall mean relative errors are larger, between 15% and
30%.Where the paper says it
How the training signal is built
The authors calculate the low-density limit of gˆ/ρ using Eq. (19) for monatomic fluids where an interaction potential φ(r) is known. p. 6 All predictions for the shear viscosity of model fluid systems using
either a cut and shifted Mie potential, the soft Mie-(10,
5) potential, or the diatomic LJ molecules, are calculated
using equilibrium simulation output data. Calculating limρ→0(ˆg/ρ)
For the monatomic fluids, we evaluate limρ→0(ˆg/ρ) by
expressing it in terms of a known interaction potential
φ(r) for an isotropic homogeneous fluid by using that
limρ→0 g(r) = e(r) where e(r) = exp [−βφ(r)] [12]. For diatomic molecules, φ(r) is not well-defined, and so
we cannot use numerical integration of Eq. Instead,
we estimate limρ→0 g/ρ ˆ from equilibrium simulation data
by linear extrapolation from two densities ρ1 and ρ2,
lim
ρ→0
gˆ
ρ
≈
gˆ1
ρ1
−
(ˆg2/ρ2) − (ˆg1/ρ1)
ρ2 − ρ1
ρ1 , (20)
where ˆg1 and ˆg2 correspond to ˆg obtained at densities ρ1
and ρ2. In all other cases η0 will be estimated based
on simulation data, as detailed below. We can obtain an initial estimate for η0 by linear extrapolation based on two viscosity data points obtained
from simulations at two different but low densities ρ1 and
ρ2, giving η
linear
0 = η1 − ρ1(η2 − η1)/(ρ2 − ρ1), where η1
and η2 correspond to the viscosity of a fluid at densities
ρ1 and ρ2.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the gains come from
The main gain of the proposed framework is that it turns the problem of finding an expression for shear viscosity into a problem of finding a suitable function for Xres. The choice Xres = βuex is shown to be equivalent to setting XMETres = −T (∂Z/∂T)ρ in Eq. p. 3 Given that that Xres = βuex has the correct lowdensity behavior regardless of internal degrees of freedom, and has been shown to work well at higher densities for at least one system with long-range interactions,
it is worth exploring this choice for Xres for a broader set
of fluid interaction models. The implicit assumption that
follows by setting Xres = βuex can be explored by considering how βuex is related to Z and g(r). It should be noted though
that the discrepancy is less severe at higher temperatures. Clearly Xres = βuex captures more of the relevant
physics underlying momentum exchange at elevated densities compared to Xres = XMET
res . It should be noted though
that the discrepancy is less severe at higher temperatures. Clearly Xres = βuex captures more of the relevant
physics underlying momentum exchange at elevated densities compared to Xres = XMET
res . We also investigate other interaction models, including a diatomic molecular
model, in order to better understand the limitations of our approach. INTRODUCTION
The transport properties of fluids are crucial for our
understanding of many processes, both natural and industrial. We also investigate other interaction models, including a diatomic molecular
model, in order to better understand the limitations of our approach. INTRODUCTION
The transport properties of fluids are crucial for our
understanding of many processes, both natural and industrial.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The authors conclude that thermodynamic relations relying on βuex provide accurate descriptions of the shear viscosity across a wide set of fluid models and simulation parameters. The success of this approach demonstrates that the limitations of Chapman-Enskog theory are not as severe as is often believed as long as the exchange function is chosen carefully. The authors conclude that Xres = βuex on its own is a poor choice for diatomic LJ fluids, suggesting that incorporating inelasticity via a fit parameter C is necessary for better accuracy.
The authors calculate the shear viscosity of atomic Mie-type fluids and diatomic LJ fluids and compare them to results from numerical simulations. The calculation of η0 for LJ fluid involves combining Eq. p. 5 All other values are estimated from simulation data using
Eq. In this work, η0 for the LJ fluid will be calculated by
combining Eq. (3) generally requires extensive numerical analysis, due to the complexity of evaluating σ
2
crossΩ
∗(2,2). In the specific case of the LJ fluid, accurate and convenient empirical expressions for σ
2
crossΩ
∗(2,2)
exist, such as the expression from Neufeld et al. Based on our approach, we propose an alternative to MET that takes into account
the potential interaction energy associated with the inter-particle interactions in the fluid. The
proposed expression is applied to predicting the shear viscosity of several different simulated fluid
models across a wide set of densities 0. (7) and thermodynamic output
from equilibrium simulations. The compressibility factor
Z = βp/ρ uses the calculated pressure of the simulated
fluid [25]. (18)
All predictions for the shear viscosity of a LJ fluid presented in this paper have been calculated using an expression for ˆg that is arrived at by combining either Eq. (17)
or (18) with the Thol et al. (17)
or (18) with the Thol et al. expression for fex.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The authors propose that the relation Xres = βuex can be applied to a more general set of fluid models inspired by kinetic DHS theory. This choice captures more of the relevant physics underlying momentum exchange at elevated densities compared to Xres = XMETres. The introduction of the fit parameter C for diatomic LJ fluids improves accuracy from 20% to 5%. The success of this approach demonstrates that the limitations of Chapman-Enskog theory are not as severe as is often believed as long as the exchange function is chosen carefully.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI can predict shear viscosity for complex fluids using a thermodynamic framework based on an exchange function that does not rely on effective hard sphere diameters. This allows for predictions across various fluid models including cut and shifted Mie fluids, full Mie fluids, and diatomic Lennard-Jones molecules.
-
Improved AI can distinguish between the performance of different residual functions for modifying the exchange function when predicting shear viscosity. The paper shows that Xres equals beta uex is well suited for atomic Mie-type fluids but requires a fit parameter C when applied to systems with inelastic interactions like diatomic LJ molecules, suggesting a more nuanced approach is needed for those cases.
-
Improved AI can predict the accuracy of shear viscosity predictions based on fluid density. The system can estimate that
At low and intermediate densities rho star less than 0.3, the mean relative prediction error stays below 4% in all cases,
but errors increase whenrho star greater than 0.35.
-
Improved AI can handle non-equilibrium simulations for viscosity calculation using a specific method developed by Muller-Plathe. This method relies on
the non-physical swapping of momentum between particles in order to induce a velocity gradient without adding energy to the system
to obtain the shear viscosity jz = -eta partial v x / z.
Abstract
We present a new framework for extending Chapman-Enskog theory beyond the hard-sphere fluid model. Rather than relying on effective hard sphere diameters, the approach makes use of on an exchange function which can be related to the thermodynamic properties of the system. We show that two existing extensions, including modified Enskog theory (MET), fit into this new framework. Based on our approach, we propose an alternative to MET that takes into account the potential interaction energy associated with the inter-particle interactions in the fluid. The proposed expression is applied to predicting the shear viscosity of several different simulated fluid models across a wide set of densities 0.05 at most ρ* at most 0.8 and temperatures 1.5 at most T* at most 4.0 in Lennard-Jones units. The fluid models considered include both the Weeks-Chandler-Anderson (WCA) fluid and the Lennard-Jones (LJ) fluid. At low and intermediate density, here taken to be ρ* at most 0.3, we report mean relative prediction errors between 2% and 4% for both these. Across all densities considered, the largest mean relative errors reported are 4.4% and 8.1% for the WCA fluid and LJ fluid respectively. We also investigate other interaction models, including a diatomic molecular model, in order to better understand the limitations of our approach.
Related papers
- Emergent long-tail dynamics in driven magnets with dynamical frustration
- Statistical Mechanics of Dynamical System Identification
- Second law of thermodynamics in closed quantum many-body systems
- Chemical potentials from structure factors: II. Charged multi-component mixtures
- Genuine quantum scars in Floquet chaotic many-body systems
- Stochastic Thermodynamics for Autoregressive Generative Models: A Non-Markovian Perspective