Atomic-scale visualization of the toroidal order in a trimeric Dy(III) single-molecule toroic

arXiv:2606.10077 · cond-mat.str-el · Submitted 2026-06-08 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Atomic-scale visualization of the toroidal order in a trimeric Dy(III) single-molecule toroic".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Single-molecule toroics offer a unique platform for next-generation quantum devices utilizing head-to-tail spin alignments in the compoundsThe single most informative sentence about the paper's subject and finding is: Polarized neutron diffraction has unambiguously determined the head-to-tail spin alignment in

Dy3(OH)(teaH2)3(paa)3: Cl(OMe)·3MeOH·PhCN (Dy3-2), mapping the atomic susceptibility tensor of Dy3+ ions and confirming the toroidal moment in the SMT The paper reports observation and probe of the toroidal moment in

Dy3(OH)(teaH2)3(paa)3: Cl(OMe)

teaH3: triethanolamine; paaH: N-(2-pyridyl)-acetoacetamide: from mapping of Dy3+ magnetic susceptibility tensors by polarized neutron diffraction (PND) The combined use of PND, variable-field neutron diffraction, ab initio calculations, and magnetometry is introduced as a robust and quantitative methodology to probe molecular-scale toroidal magnetism Experimental Methodology The researchers employed an integrated approach to study the toroidal moment using several advanced techniques

Dy3(OH)(teaH2)3(paa)3: Cl(OMe)·3MeOH·PhCN (Dy3-2) The methodology involved: 1.

Kai: Polarized neutron diffraction (PND) to probe the local magnetic anisotropy that leads to a head-to-tail spin alignment in a Dy3-based SMT PND directly reveals the local magnetic anisotropy that leads to a head-to-tail spin alignment in a Dy3-based SMT 2.

Mira: Single-crystal neutron diffraction (SCND) at TOPAZ to determine the structure of Dy3-2 SCND was used to determine the structure of Dy3-2 3.

Kai: Variable magnetic field single-crystal neutron diffraction to demonstrate field-induced magnetization along the c-axis with toroidal moments anti-parallelly stacked Variable-field neutron diffraction demonstrates field-induced magnetization along the c-axis with toroidal moments anti-parallelly stacked 4.

Paper summary: Kai: So to summarize this paper, its main thrust is that single-molecule toroics offer a unique platform for next generation quantum devices because of their head-to-tail spin alignments in these compounds.

Mira: The core claim is that polarized neutron diffraction unambiguously determined the head-to-tail spin alignment in

Dy3(OH)(teaH2)three(paa)three: Cl(OMe)·3MeOH·PhCN, which maps the atomic susceptibility tensor of Dy three plus ions and confirms the toroidal moment in the SMT <ref:2606.10077#pg1>.

Lev: What matters for us is that they are using this as a tool to probe molecular-scale toroidal magnetism using an integrated approach that includes polarized neutron diffraction, variable field neutron diffraction, ab initio calculations, and magnetometry.

Kai: This methodology is presented as a robust way to move beyond earlier indirect methods when you want to validate experimentally molecular-scale toroidal magnetism.

Mira: They also report on the observation and probe of the toroidal moment in

Dy3(OH)(teaH2)three(paa)three: Cl(OMe), which was done by mapping Dy three plus magnetic susceptibility tensors through polarized neutron diffraction <ref:2606.10077#pg1>.

Lev: It sounds like they’re showing a complete picture, from structure to ground state magnetism, which is what we need when you’re trying to engineer a functional quantum material.

Kai: Essentially, they are providing definite experimental proof of the toroidal spin alignment in an SMT compound and showing how it behaves under various conditions.

Conclusion: Kai: Thinking about the title, "Atomic-scale visualization," it’s telling us that we are finally getting a direct look at how these spins are organized on an atomic level, which is pretty exciting for visualizing quantum states.

Mira: The authors of this paper have successfully used polarized neutron diffraction to achieve this visualization for the first time in an SMT compound, confirming the toroidal order in

Dy3(OH)(teaH2)three(paa)three: Cl(OMe) <ref:2606.10077#pg1>.

Lev: What does that mean practically is that we can start to design experiments knowing precisely where those moments are pointing before we even build the hardware.

Kai: It means you can predict the magnetic behavior, like the energy barrier they calculated as one hundred twelve centimeters minus one kelvin, which is a critical parameter for controlling spin relaxation.

Mira: And because they confirmed that toroidic order is odd under both space inversion and time reversal, this suggests this ordering has inherent spin chirality, which is an effective way to gain magnetoelectric effects.

Lev: So if we can reliably control that chirality, it opens up possibilities for creating novel quantum gates or sensors based on these molecular systems.

Kai: The implication is that single-molecule toroics are not just interesting theoretical concepts anymore; they are becoming a tangible platform where we can test and manipulate these exotic spin states experimentally.

Department of Chemistry University of Tennessee Knoxville · Neutron Scattering Division Oak Ridge National Laboratory · SmartState Center for Experimental Nanoscale Physics Department of Physics and Astronomy University of South Carolina · Department of Chemistry Indian Institute of Technology Bombay · Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry Kennesaw State University

cond-mat.str-el

Submitted: 2026-06-08

Updated: 2026-11-11

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 80/100

The gist: Single-molecule toroics offer a unique platform for next-generation quantum devices utilizing head-to-tail spin alignments in the compoundsThe single most informative sentence about the paper's…

Key concepts

Toroidal Moment
This refers to a specific type of magnetic ordering where the spins of atoms are arranged in a circular, ring-like pattern rather than just along an axis. In this material, the Dy(III) ions form such a structure, which is responsible for its unique magnetic properties and slow relaxation behavior.
Polarized Neutron Diffraction (PND)
PND is a technique that uses polarized neutrons to probe the local magnetic anisotropy of atoms. By analyzing how these neutrons interact with the material's internal magnetic fields, researchers could directly map out the spin alignment and confirm the head-to-tail spin arrangement in the Dy3+ ions.
Single-Molecule Toroics (SMT)
SMTs are single molecules that exhibit slow magnetic relaxation, meaning they can retain their magnetic state for a long time. This paper focuses on a specific type of SMT where the magnetic behavior is driven by the unique toroidal spin alignment within the molecule's structure.

Terminology

Summary

Single-molecule toroics offer a unique platform for next-generation quantum devices utilizing head-to-tail spin alignments in the compoundsThe single most informative sentence about the paper's subject and finding is: Polarized neutron diffraction has unambiguously determined the head-to-tail spin alignment in [Dy3(OH)(teaH2)3(paa)3]Cl(OMe)·3MeOH·PhCN (Dy3-2), mapping the atomic susceptibility tensor of Dy3+ ions and confirming the toroidal moment in the SMT The paper reports observation and probe of the toroidal moment in [Dy3(OH)(teaH2)3(paa)3]Cl(OMe) [teaH3: triethanolamine; paaH: N-(2-pyridyl)-acetoacetamide] from mapping of Dy3+ magnetic susceptibility tensors by polarized neutron diffraction (PND) The combined use of PND, variable-field neutron diffraction, ab initio calculations, and magnetometry is introduced as a robust and quantitative methodology to probe molecular-scale toroidal magnetism

Experimental Methodology

The researchers employed an integrated approach to study the toroidal moment using several advanced techniques

[Dy3(OH)(teaH2)3(paa)3]Cl(OMe)·3MeOH·PhCN (Dy3-2)

The methodology involved:

  1. Polarized neutron diffraction (PND) to probe the local magnetic anisotropy that leads to a head-to-tail spin alignment in a Dy3-based SMT PND directly reveals the local magnetic anisotropy that leads to a head-to-tail spin alignment in a Dy3-based SMT

  2. Single-crystal neutron diffraction (SCND) at TOPAZ to determine the structure of Dy3-2 SCND was used to determine the structure of Dy3-2

  3. Variable magnetic field single-crystal neutron diffraction to demonstrate field-induced magnetization along the c-axis with toroidal moments anti-parallelly stacked Variable-field neutron diffraction demonstrates field-induced magnetization along the c-axis with toroidal moments anti-parallelly stacked

  4. Magnetometry to confirm the toroidal ground state and provide couplings consistent with a toroidal ground state

Structural Characterization

The structural determination of Dy3-2 was achieved through combined X-ray and neutron diffraction studies

Key structural findings include:

  1. The structure of Dy3-2 in the trigonal P-3c1 (No. p. 6 165) space group was confirmed by both SCXRD and SCND This confirms the triangular Dy3 core of Dy3-2 in space group P3‾c1 (No. p. 6 165)

  2. Neutron diffraction established a triangular Dy3 core of Dy3-2 in space group P3‾c1 capped by a μ3-OH bridge in the dication [Dy3(OH)(teaH2)3(paa)3]2+ The O8–H8 distance was found to be 0. p. 5937(1) Å, confirming μ3-OH− rather than an μ3-O2− oxo bridging ligand

  3. Continuous shape measurements (CShM) revealed that the best fit for both Dy3-1 and Dy3-2 is the triangular dodecahedron

Magnetic Characterization

Magnetic properties were investigated using magnetometry and PND to probe spin alignment

The magnetic measurements yielded several key results:

  1. DC susceptibility measurements showed that the magnetic susceptibility measured at 0. p. 31 T varies smoothly with temperature without any anomaly for both the single crystal and polycrystal forms The averaged χM T from the single-crystal sample is consistent with the expected value of 42. p. 65 cm3 K mol-1 for three non-interacting Dy3+ ions

  2. The Curie-Weiss temperatures were found to be CW = -151 K for Dy3-2⊥, 25. p. 645 K for Dy3-2‖, and-15. p. 08 K for Dy3-2poly Negative and positive Curie-Weiss temperatures are indicative of antiferromagnetic (AFM) and ferromagnetic (FM) couplings, respectively

  3. The refined magnetization tensor derived from PND showed that the head-to-tail spin alignment can be expected in the ab plane for antiferromagnetically coupled spin trimer, while the toroidal moment would be pointed along the c-axis

Theoretical Validation

Ab initio calculations were used to provide theoretical evidence consistent with experimental findings

Calculations utilized the CASSCF/RASSI-SO method to investigate magnetic properties

The theoretical analysis confirmed that the ground-state magnetic moment of 8.77 μB arises from uncompensated magnetic moments of the Dy3+ centers within the circular toroidal arrangement The calculated gtensors and energy levels are consistent with a low-symmetry ligand field at Dy3+ sites in the Dy3–2 core

The calculated exchange/dipolar interactions between neighboring DyIII–DyIII ions in 1 were found to be antiferromagnetic and very weak in magnitude The total interaction strength was found to be JIsing,tot ≈ 1.6 cm−1

Conclusions

Polarized neutron diffraction has unambiguously determined the head-to-tail spin alignment in [Dy3(OH)(teaH2)3(paa)3]Cl(OMe)·3MeOH·PhCN (Dy3-2), mapping the atomic susceptibility tensor of Dy3+ ions and confirming the toroidal moment in the SMT Variable-field neutron diffraction has validated the expected toroidic order, showing the AFM ordering of the Dy3+ ions Dy3-2 shows typical SMT characteristics in DC susceptibility studies, both for polycrystalline and single crystal samples Results of ab initio CASSCF calculations are consistent with those from the experiments This work is, to our knowledge, the first definite experimental proof of the toroidal spin alignment in an SMT compound

Methods

The methods employed included:

  1. Single-crystal neutron diffraction to determine the structure of Dy3-2 was performed at TOPAZ at ORNL

  2. Polarized neutron diffraction (PND) was used to perform single-crystal PND measurements with a polarized neutron beam of 1. p. 2542 Å from a bent Si-220 monochromator

  3. Neutron diffraction under magnetic fields was performed at 1. p. 05 K with variable magnetic fields from 0 to 4 T

Data Availability and Associate Content

Additional data and figures are provided in Supplementary information, including synthesis, crystallization, single-crystal X-ray diffraction, and computational details Other data may be made available upon request The authors thank Drs. Alexandria N. Bone, Pagnareach Tin, and Adam T. Hand for their help in the selection of the Dy3 compound for the current study

References in SI

The supplementary information contains detailed data on synthesis, crystallization, and computational details The authors thank US National Science Foundation (CHE-2055499 and CHE-2349345 to ZLX) for financial support of this research The beam times were allocated to DEMAND (Dimensional Extreme Magnetic Neutron Diffractometer, HB-3A) on proposals IPTS-29385, -30682, and-31432

Magnetic Susceptibility Measurements

DC susceptibility measurements were completed using a Quantum Design MPMS-7 T Magnetization by variable temperature and variable magnetic field was collected Measurements were taken of a powdered sample as well as single crystals oriented in multiple directions

Polarized Neutron Diffraction

DEMAND diffractometer was used to perform single-crystal PND measurements with a polarized neutron beam of 1.542 Å from a bent Si-220 monochromator The sample was measured at 5 K with H∥ab and a permanent magnetic set was used to fix the field to 0. p. 36 T

Neutron Diffraction under Magnetic Fields

DEMAND was also used to perform the field studies. The sample was measured at 1. p. 35 K with variable magnetic fields from 0 to 4 T Data subtraction and integration was completed using FulProf

Author Contributions

The author contributions are as follows:

M. Jenkins synthesized and performed preliminary characterization of Dy3-1 and Dy3-2 He studied crystal stabilities and developed the method to grow large crystals of Dy3-2

Jenkins, X. Wang, and C. p. 0 Hoffmann solved the structure of Dy3-2 using single-crystal Xray diffraction B. p. 2 Watson-Sanders, Wang, and Hoffmann solved the structure of Dy3-2 using single-crystal neutron diffraction on TOPAZ at ORNL

J. Xing and R. p. 0 Jin completed magnetic susceptibility measurements and analysis

M. Marshall, Jenkins, H. p. 0 Cao, and Xue participated in the two neutron diffraction experiments on DEMAND at ORNL

Marshall completed neutron diffraction data analyses from the two experiments

M. Satheeshkumar and G. p. 0 Rajaraman conducted computational studies

Xue, Cao, and Jin initiated the project

Competing Interests

The authors declare no competing financial interest The authors declare no competing financial interest

Materials and Correspondence

The correspondence for specific roles is as follows: G. Rajaraman for ab initio calculations, H. p. 2 Cao for neutron studies, R. p. 0 Jin for magnetometry studies, and Z-L. p. 0 Xue for synthesis and other characterizations The correspondence details are listed in the Materials and correspondence section

References

The references cited in the paper are as follows:

1 Tang, J. et al. Dysprosium Triangles Showing Single-Molecule Magnet Behavior of Thermally Excited Spin States

2 Chibotaru, L. F., Ungur, L. p. 2 & Soncini, A. The Origin of Nonmagnetic Kramers Doublets in the Ground State of Dysprosium Triangles: Evidence for a Toroidal Magnetic Moment

3 Murray, K. Ed., Single Molecule Toroics (with contributions by K. p. 0 S. Murray, K. R. Vignesh, K. Hymas, A. Soncini, S. K. Langley, G Rajaraman, X. p. 2-L Li, J Tang, H.-L Zhang, Y.-Q Zhai, Y-Z Zheng D Plokhov A Pyatakov A Popov A K Zvezdin)

4 Georgeot B. & Mila F Chirality of triangular antiferromagnetic clusters as a qubit

5 Carretta S., Santini P., Amoretti G., Troiani F. & Affronte M Spin triangles as optimal units for molecule-based quantum gates

6 Baniodeh A., Magnani N., Bräse S., Anson C. E. & Powell A. K Ligand field variations: tuning the toroidal moment of Dy6 rings

7 Chauhan D. et al. Ultraslow Relaxation of Toroidal State in Ferrotoroidal Dysprosium Complex J Am Chem Soc 147, 39572–39581

8 Chen Y. et al. Unconventional Nuclear-Spin-Dependent Toroidal Ground States in Isotopologue ADy4 [2 × 2] Complexes J Am Chem Soc 148, 17324–17332

9 Zhu Z. et al. Homochiral toroidal spin state in Dy(III)-based single-molecule toroics Nat. p. 0 Chem. (2026)

10 Li X.-L., Ma Z. & Tang J Recent Developments of Nontraditional Single-Molecule Toroics Chem Eur. p. 0 J. 30, e202304369

11 Gnewuch S. & Rodriguez E. E The fourth ferroic order: Current status on ferrotoroidic materials J Solid State Chem. p. 1 271, 175–190

--- Page 56 ---

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The paper establishes a new benchmark framework for investigating SMTs by introducing an integrated approach combining PND, variable-field neutron diffraction, ab initio calculations, and magnetometry This methodology overcomes limitations of earlier indirect methods to validate experimentally molecular-scale toroidal magnetism

How the training signal is built

The magnetic structure in Dy3-2 was derived by refining the single-crystal neutron diffraction data at 2.0 and 0.0 T A magnetic symmetry analysis using Bilbao crystallographic server was carried out, considering k = 0 and the parent space group P-3c1 (No. p. 6 165) The resulting refined magnetic moment within the ab plane was 4. p. 36(3) μB, while a fixed moment along the c-axis of 2. p. 025 μB, to match the bulk magnetization data Antiferromagnetic order from anti-parallelly stacked toroidal moments is observed along the caxis, which is consistent with the bulk magnetic susceptibly measurements

Where the gains come from

The study provides a definite experimental proof of toroidal spin alignment in an SMT compound The theoretical analysis confirms that the ground-state magnetic moment of 8.77 μB arises from uncompensated magnetic moments of the Dy3+ centers within the circular toroidal arrangement The calculated energy barrier is Ucal = 112 cm−1 This work is, to our knowledge, the first definite experimental proof of the toroidal spin alignment in an SMT compound The authors speculate that protonation state, and thus pH, may provide a viable handle for tuning toroidal behavior in SMTs

Magnetic Anisotropy and Relaxation

The magnetic anisotropy of Dy3+ spins was determined by PND, showing that the head-to-tail spin alignment can be expected in the ab plane for antiferromagnetically coupled spin trimer The calculated energy barrier is Ucal = 112 cm−1 The ground-state magnetic moment of 8.77 μB (Fig. p. 7 S10) arises from uncompensated magnetic moments of the Dy3+ centers within the circular toroidal arrangement and is markedly smaller than the value expected for three non-interacting Dy3+ ions (30 μB) The toroidally ordered ground states are separated from the magnetic spin-flip states by an energy gap of 1. p. 1

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI system can perform robust, quantitative molecular-scale toroidal magnetism studies by integrating polarized neutron diffraction (PND), variable magnetic field single-crystal neutron diffraction, ab initio calculations, and magnetometry.

  2. The improved system can establish a benchmark framework for investigating single-molecule toroics by overcoming limitations of earlier indirect methods through this integrated approach.

  3. The system can unambiguously determine the toroidal moment in SMTs by mapping Dy3+ magnetic susceptibility tensors using PND, as shown in the text: PND directly reveals the local magnetic anisotropy that leads to a head-to-tail spin alignment in a Dy3-based SMT.

  4. The AI can validate experimental molecular-scale toroidal magnetism by correlating PND results showing toroidal moments are anti-parallelly stacked with magnetometry providing couplings consistent with a toroidal ground state.

  5. The system can analyze magnetic data to determine anisotropic magnetic interactions by fitting susceptibility using the Curie-Weiss formula and observing that differences are observed when data is replotted as 1/chi vs T: it is more or less linear for Dy3-2poly but nonlinear for Dy3-2‖ and Dy3-2⊥, suggesting anisotropic magnetic interactions.

  6. The system can model the ground state magnetic properties by using ab initio CASSCF/RASSI calculations to show that "The ground-state magnetic moment of 8.77 μB (Fig. S10) arises from uncompensated magnetic moments of the Dy3+ centers within the circular toroidal arrangement and is markedly smaller than the value expected for three non-interacting Dy3+ ions (30 μB)."

  7. The system can investigate the role of protonation state in stabilizing toroidal states by performing ab initio calculations on model 2 and finding that the proton in the bridging OH−ligand plays a critical role in stabilizing the toroidal state, suggesting that protonation state, and thus pH, may provide a viable handle for tuning toroidal behavior in SMTs.

  8. The AI can perform structural determination by using single-crystal X-ray diffraction and single-crystal neutron diffraction to confirm the structure of Dy3-2 as having a triangular Dy3 core of Dy3-2 in space group P3c1 (No. 165) capped by a μ3-OH bridge.

  9. The system can predict magnetic behavior by calculating exchange interaction constants using Density Functional Theory and fitting with the Lines model, yielding an initial guess for total interaction strength of JIsing,tot ≈ 1.6 cm−1 (Fig. 8).

Related papers