Asymptotic Algebras and Holography of Information in CGHS Model
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Asymptotic Algebras and Holography of Information in CGHS Model".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Holography of Information (HoI) and island formula are two recent approaches to the black hole information loss paradox that yield different Page curves The difference between the Page curves has been argued to be rooted in the algebra that each approach focuses on This paper studies the candidate algebras for the CGHS model.
Kai: Model Setup and Boundary Analysis The study utilizes the CGHS model coupled to a massless scalar field to examine HoI and compare it with island approaches The model is analyzed by considering two cases: restricting HoI analysis to only the right boundary or considering both boundaries.
Mira: The physical metric in the CGHS model is conformally flat, and the analysis proceeds by constructing the radiative phase space at future null infinity The construction of the right-moving sector's symplectic form yields a boundary Hamiltonian.
Kai: Holographic Results for CGHS The analysis establishes HoI for the CGHS model coupled to a massless scalar by constructing the radiative phase space and asymptotic algebras at future null infinity The quantum state of the right-moving modes can be recovered from an arbitrarily small neighbourhood of the right future null infinity This leads to a flat Page curve when restricted to only the right boundary.
Paper summary: Lev: So, stepping back from the technical details of the CGHS model and these algebras, what's the actual big picture this paper is pushing for us to consider about black hole evaporation?
Kai: This paper is really zeroing in on how different mathematical frameworks—like HoI versus island formula—lead to different predictions for how information escapes a black hole <ref:2606.09346#pg1>.
Mira: The main point seems to be that the structure of the algebra, specifically whether it commutes or not, dictates whether you get a flat Page curve or something more complex <ref:2606.09346#pg1>.
Kai: So, when we look at this paper's title and authors, Waheed A. Dar and Nirmalya Kajuri and Rinkesh Panigrahi <ref:2606.09346#pg1>, they are essentially mapping out the algebraic landscape of how information behaves near a black hole horizon.
Lev: What does that mean for us as people who are trying to build error correction codes, like what Lev is working on? Does this tell us anything about the structure we need in our quantum systems?
Mira: It tells us that if we want a theory that accurately describes information retrieval, we need a specific kind of algebraic structure where the left and right modes interact in a way that respects those commutation relations <ref:2606.09346#pg1>.
Kai: It suggests there are two distinct paths for holography, one based on reconstructing states from the right boundary, and another that might require a more unified algebraic description to handle both sides <ref:2606.09346#pg1>.
Conclusion: Kai: So we're wrapping up this paper on "Asymptotic Algebras and Holography of Information in CGHS Model." It looks like they're comparing two different ways—holography versus the island formula—to figure out if information is truly lost when a black hole evaporates.
Mira: Exactly. The core tension is that these two approaches give you different pictures of what happens to the quantum information as the black hole shrinks, and those differences seem rooted in how they set up their math, their algebra.
Lev: From where I sit with real hardware, it’s interesting because if one approach is right and the other isn't, it tells us a lot about what kind of gravity theory we should even be building our simulations on. It suggests we need a more specific algebraic structure than just picking any symmetry group to make sense of the outgoing radiation.
Kai: And they point out that one way—the holography side—gives you a flat curve when you only look at the right boundary, meaning you can still get your initial state back from that edge, even if the black hole is still there. That’s a big deal for information recovery.
Mira: But then they show how the island calculation, which is more specific to certain holographic setups, gives you a curve that actually goes up and then falls as the black hole evaporates. That's where the disagreement lives between the two methods.
Lev: The authors conclude that this disagreement isn't just about picking a different algebra; it seems to be about having fundamentally different quantizations of gravity itself. If you want one side to be right, you’d need a quantization that respects certain commutation relations between the left and right sides of the system.
Kai: So what does this mean for our understanding of information localization? It implies that the idea of losing information might not be as straightforward as we first thought; it could depend heavily on how you define the boundary you're looking at.
Mira: Right. The paper suggests that one view—the holographic one—might be a generic feature of any theory with certain asymptotic structure, while the island formula is tied more tightly to specific holographic completions. It’s a distinction between a general property and a very specific setup.
Lev: It’s telling us that for error correction, we can't just assume everything works the same way across different theoretical models without checking those underlying algebraic assumptions first. That sets up some tough constraints for what we can actually build and measure at scale.
Waheed A. Dar, Nirmalya Kajuri, Rinkesh Panigrahi
National Institute of Technology Srinagar · Indian Institute of Technology Mandi
hep-th
Submitted: 2026-06-08
Updated: 2026-10-31
Comments: Version Accepted in Physical Review D
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 71/100
The gist: Holography of Information (HoI) and island formula are two recent approaches to the black hole information loss paradox that yield different Page curves The difference between the Page curves has…
Key concepts
- Holography of Information (HoI)
- This approach examines how the quantum state of right-moving modes near future null infinity can be recovered from a small neighborhood. For the CGHS model, this leads to a flat Page curve when only considering one boundary, implying information localization is possible.
- Island Formula
- The island computation calculates black hole entropy by considering an internal region of spacetime. In related models, this approach produces a rising and falling Page curve. It is compared against the holographic entropy derived from the algebra of radiative observables.
- Asymptotic Algebras (Arad(I+R) and Arad(I+L))
- These are mathematical structures representing the symmetries of spacetime at future null infinity (I+R) and past null infinity (I+L). The paper investigates whether exact commutativity between these algebras is possible, which is key to distinguishing between holographic and non-holographic quantizations.
- Information Localization
- This concept suggests that information about the black hole can be contained within a small region of spacetime, rather than being lost to infinity. The one-sided Page curve result demonstrates that this localization and information loss are logically independent.
Terminology
Summary
Holography of Information (HoI) and island formula are two recent approaches to the black hole information loss paradox that yield different Page curves The difference between the Page curves has been argued to be rooted in the algebra that each approach focuses on This paper studies the candidate algebras for the CGHS model. p. 0
Model Setup and Boundary Analysis
The study utilizes the CGHS model coupled to a massless scalar field to examine HoI and compare it with island approaches The model is analyzed by considering two cases: restricting HoI analysis to only the right boundary or considering both boundaries. The physical metric in the CGHS model is conformally flat, and the analysis proceeds by constructing the radiative phase space at future null infinity The construction of the right-moving sector's symplectic form yields a boundary Hamiltonian.
Holographic Results for CGHS
The analysis establishes HoI for the CGHS model coupled to a massless scalar by constructing the radiative phase space and asymptotic algebras at future null infinity The quantum state of the right-moving modes can be recovered from an arbitrarily small neighbourhood of the right future null infinity This leads to a flat Page curve when restricted to only the right boundary. The results suggest that the differences between the two approaches stem from inequivalent quantizations of gravity, rather than just the choice of algebra. p. 1
Island vs. Holography Tension
The island computation for an evaporating black hole in the closely related RST model produces a Page curve that rises and then falls The authors find that the island entropy computed by [39] should equal the von Neumann entropy of the algebra of radiative observables at the right boundary. This equality is incompatible with exact commutativity of Arad(I+R) and Arad(I+L) because a reconstruction would commute with the left radiative algebra, which does not commute among itself. p. 1
Implications for Information Localization
The one-sided Page curve is flat even when a horizon is present but no singularity reaches I+R This demonstrates that information localization and information loss can be logically independent, as the accessible state can still be recovered from a small boundary neighbourhood. The paper suggests that HoI could be a generic feature of gravitational theories with suitable asymptotic structure, while the island formula is specific to theories with a holographic UV completion. p. 0
Conclusion on Algebraic Differences
The source of disagreement between the island and HoI approaches in the CGHS/RST context stems from inequivalent quantizations of gravity The authors conclude that a quantization which respects the commutativity of Arad(I+R) and Arad(I+L) would be non-holographic, suggesting a distinction between the two notions of holography. The paper concludes that information localization and information loss can be logically independent. p. 0
Appendix Details
The analysis involves constructing the covariant phase space, obtaining the radiative phase space at I+R, and deriving the boundary Hamiltonian The construction of the right-cut charge QB(u) is used to construct the asymptotic gravitational algebra The two-sided result shows that for a pure initial state, the two-sided Page curve would be flat at zero. The one-sided result implies that the corresponding Page curve will be flat. p. 1 The paper confirms that the quantum state on the complete physical I+R can be recovered from an arbitrarily small neighbourhood of its past boundary. p. 1 The entropy of any right past segment, once a fixed entropy convention is chosen, is independent of its upper endpoint. p. 0 The final result shows that the accessible state can be recovered from a neighbourhood of the past endpoint. p. 0 The paper notes that the same argument applies in the two-sided case. p. 1 The second part of the analysis examined the tension between HoI and the island formula. p. 1 The authors note three implications regarding these results. p. 1
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved state recovery for black holes will allow AI systems to reconstruct pure global states from arbitrarily small neighborhoods of past corners, which is crucial for verifying unitarity in quantum gravity simulations.
-
The system can utilize one-sided holography results to determine the entropy of a restricted state, enabling AI to quantify information localization even when a horizon is present and information loss occurs.
-
AI models can distinguish between holographic approaches and island formula results by analyzing the commutation relations of radiative algebras, potentially revealing whether a theory requires non-holographic quantization to reconcile these results.
Sources
- Average Entropy of a Subsystem
- Information in Black Hole Radiation
- The Holographic Nature of Null Infinity
- A physical protocol for observers near the boundary to obtain bulk information in quantum gravity
- Holography from the Wheeler-DeWitt equation
- Squinting at massive fields from infinity
- Holography of information in de Sitter space
- Holographic observers for time-band algebras
- Holography of Information in a Ball of Finite Radius
- A toy model of black hole complementarity
- A Toy Model of the Information Paradox in Empty Space
- Is Holography Implicit in Canonical Gravity?
- The entropy of bulk quantum fields and the entanglement wedge of an evaporating black hole
- Entanglement Wedge Reconstruction and the Information Paradox
- The Page curve of Hawking radiation from semiclassical geometry
- Replica wormholes and the black hole interior
- Replica Wormholes and the Entropy of Hawking Radiation
- The entropy of Hawking radiation
- Islands outside the horizon
- Entanglement islands in higher dimensions
Related papers
- The facts on quantum self-dual Einstein gravity and self-dual Yang-Mills theory
- Quantum Langlands correspondence for Painlev'e II
- Fortuitous BMN Operators from Multiple Cores
- Building far-from-equilibrium effective field theories using shift symmetries
- Inflation, Cosmic Perturbations and Non-Gaussianities
- Wavefunctions of AdS 3 Universes and T-deformed Torus Partition Functions