Lepton g-2 non-universality of hadronic contributions and a sub-GeV window to New Physics

arXiv:2606.08329 · hep-ph, hep-th, nucl-th · Submitted 2026-06-06 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Lepton g-2 non-universality of hadronic contributions and a sub-GeV window to New Physics".

Paper summary: Kai: So to wrap up the paper "Lepton g-two non-universality of hadronic contributions and a sub-GeV window to New Physics," they are proposing this mu minus e quantity as a way to tackle the discrepancy between different evaluations of hadronic contributions in the muon anomalous magnetic moment <ref:2606.08329#pg1,Lepton g-2 non-universality of hadronic contributions and a sub-GeV>.

Mira: They argue that by using this specific linear combination, they achieve an exact cancellation of high energy effects, which is achieved through the mass ratio rescaling. This improves the ultraviolet behavior and fixes some issues that come up when you calculate a mu minus ae or a mu minus ae separately.

Lev: The core message is that this rescaled quantity, mu minus e equals a mu minus two times the square of the muon mass over electron mass times ae, acts as a natural window quantity for sub-GeV new physics. It can isolate those low energy hadronic contributions that are hard to pin down.

Kai: So what does this mean practically? It suggests that if we can improve our measurements of ae and alpha significantly—say to one ten to the thirteen level—then mu minus e becomes a really powerful probe for new physics below one gigaelectronvolt.

Mira: They are saying that this approach offers a clearer path because it isolates the low energy regime, which you can then treat with more predictive power using effective field theory frameworks compared to just looking at ae or ae separately.

Lev: The paper flags a limitation, though, and they state that their analysis assumes one hundred percent correlation between the calculations for a mu and ae. That's a major assumption we need to be aware of when you try to run this on real hardware or compare it to future experimental data.

Kai: So the main thing is that while this combination looks very promising for testing new physics, it depends heavily on getting those experimental measurements of ae and alpha much better, which they still need to achieve.

Conclusion: Kai: So, we're wrapping up this look at "Lepton g-two non-universality of hadronic contributions and a sub-GeV window to New Physics." Basically, they’ve built this new way to look at the discrepancy between different calculations for how strong interactions affect the muon's magnetic moment.

Mira: Exactly. The authors are proposing this specific combination of quantities as a natural low energy window. It’s designed to cancel out those high energy effects exactly because of how the scaling works in vacuum polarization kernels.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, that exact cancellation is what makes it promising for testing new physics below one gigaelectronvolt. It bypasses a lot of the noise you get when you look at mu minus ae or a mu minus ae on its own.

Kai: It sounds like they're trying to find a clean signal by removing the messy parts. They’re suggesting that if we can get our measurements of electron magnetic moment and alpha constant really precise, this new quantity could be a better way to see physics happening in the sub-GeV range.

Mira: That’s right. The whole point is isolating that low energy regime so we can use effective field theory to predict what we should see, rather than just dealing with the full complexity of the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution.

Lev: But they are upfront about one big assumption here—the calculation relies on assuming a perfect correlation between the measurements for a mu and an electron. That’s something we’d need to test really hard when we try to build any kind of real apparatus around it.

Kai: So, the outlook is that if those experimental errors in alpha and ae get better than one ten to the thirteen level, this quantity becomes a powerful tool for probing new physics below one gigaelectronvolt.

Mira: It’s conditional on that experimental improvement, but it shows a clear path toward isolating low energy effects with more predictive power than just looking at the muon or electron separately.

Lev: And that isolation is what makes it interesting for error correction research because you need to know exactly where the noise comes from to build reliable hardware.

Kai: We’ll keep digging into how this actually translates into constraints on dark photons and other new physics scenarios in our next segment.

Institut f¨ur Kernphysik, Johannes Gutenberg-Universit¤t Mainz · William I. Fine Theoretical Physics Institute · Theoretical Physics Department, CERN

hep-ph, hep-th, nucl-th

Submitted: 2026-06-06

Updated: 2026-11-17

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: Lepton g − 2 non-universality of hadronic contributions and a sub-GeV window to New Physics is proposed as a natural low-energy window quantity that may directly probe the current discrepancy…

Key concepts

$a_ u - e$
This is a linear combination of muon and electron anomalous magnetic moments designed to cancel out high-energy contributions. It exploits scaling properties of vacuum polarization kernels to ensure an exact cancellation, leaving the low-energy, sub-GeV physics visible.
Hadronic Vacuum Polarization (HVP)
HVP is a major theoretical uncertainty in calculating lepton g-2 because it involves interactions with virtual hadronic particles. The paper analyzes how this contribution behaves differently when combined into $a_ u - e$, allowing for better handling of uncertainties from lattice QCD and data-driven methods.
Sub-GeV Window to New Physics
This refers to the energy range below 1 GeV where new physics effects, such as dark photons, might manifest. The quantity $a_ u - e$ is specifically designed to amplify sensitivity in this low-energy regime compared to standard measurements like $a_ u$ or $a_e$.
EFT Frameworks
Effective Field Theory (EFT) frameworks are used to treat the isolated low-energy regime probed by $a_ u - e$. This approach offers greater predictive power for New Physics searches in this specific energy window than analyzing the full, uncancelled observables.

Terminology

Summary

Lepton g − 2 non-universality of hadronic contributions and a sub-GeV window to New Physics is proposed as a natural low-energy window quantity that may directly probe the current discrepancy between the data-driven and lattice-QCD evaluations of hadronic contributions The rescaling ensures an exact cancellation of the short-range effects, thereby improving the UV behavior and bypassing a number of issues that arise in aµ or ae separately This is promising for tests of New Physics, conditional to significant improvements in experimental measurements of ae and α

The Proposed Combination

The paper introduces the linear combination aµ−e ≡ aµ − (mµ/me)2ae as a natural low-energy window quantity that may directly probe the current discrepancy between the data-driven and lattice-QCD evaluations of hadronic contributions The authors propose this combination because it ensures an exact cancellation of high-energy effects, which is the main advantage of this quantity over the previously considered combination This cancellation is achieved by exploiting the scaling properties of vacuum polarization kernels, where aµ−e obeys an analogous representation with a kernel Kµ−e(s) = Kµ(s) − m2µ/m2e Ke(s) ∼= −m4µ/s2, which suppresses the high-energy region

Hadronic Contribution Analysis

The quantity aµ−e serves to elucidate the existing discrepancy not only between lattice and data-driven evaluations but also among different datadriven evaluations as their uncertainties improve The uncertainty of aµ−e is computed under the assumption of 100% correlation between aµ and ae calculations, leading to σµ−e = σµ − (mµ/me)2σe For example, in Table I, the uncertainty of aµ−e is significantly reduced compared to aµ for both lattice QCD and data-driven approaches The sub-GeV contributions survive in aµ−e while higher-energy contributions cancel exactly

Illustrative Channels

The authors illustrate the mechanism using specific hadronic channels to show the effectiveness of this combination In the π+π− channel, sub-GeV contributions such as the ρ-meson resonance survive in aµ−e while higher-energy contributions cancel exactly The calculation of a π0γ contribution via HVP in χPT allows for a parameter-free prediction because the low-energy constant cancels out in the rescaled difference aµ−e

Ultimate Sensitivity to New Physics

The ultimate sensitivity to New Physics is enhanced because flavor non-universal BSM scenarios that deviate from a specific scaling can be constrained by aµ−e For example, in supersymmetric models, the correction to aµ−e can be written as aBSMµ−e = m2µ/Λ2µ − 1/Λ2e The analysis suggests that sub-GeV dark photons can be better probed by aµ−e conditional on experimental improvement of ae and α This indicates that aµ−e may provide a deeper reach into the parameter space of subGeV New Physics than aµ or ae considered separately The constraints on the mixing angle of the dark photon can be substantially improved in this hypothetical regime

Conclusion and Outlook

The paper concludes that aµ−e provides a clear advantage due to the large cancellation of uncertainties in HVP µ−e Future improvements in α and ae at the precision level better than 10−13 would make aµ−e a powerful and complementary probe of low-energy hadronic effects With aµ−e, one can isolate the low-energy regime, which can be treated within EFT frameworks with greater predictive power than aµ or ae separately Potential new physics below GeV is also more amplified in aµ−e than purely leptonic (g−2) observables

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

M. P. thanks Gerald Gabrielse for the initial discussion of hadronic uncertainties in ae that led to this study; S. p. 6 L. thanks Volodymyr Biloshytskyi for helpful discussions, while V. p. 6 P. acknowledges insightful conversations with Bogdan Malaescu, Harvey Meyer, and Matthias Neubert This work is supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) through the Collaborative Research Center 1660 “Hadrons and Nuclei as Discovery Tools” (grant 514321794). p. 6 M. P. work is supported in part by the DOE grant DE-SC0011842. p. 6 M. P. also acknowledges the financial support provided by CERN

REFERENCES

[1] X. Fan, T. G. Myers, B. A. D. Sukra, and G. p. 6 Gabrielse, Measurement of the Electron Magnetic Moment, Phys. p. 6 Rev. Lett 130 071801 (2023), arXiv:2209. p. 613084 [physics-atom-ph]. p. 6

[2] D. P. Aguillard et al. p. 6, Muon g-2, Measurement of the Positive Muon Anomalous Magnetic Moment to 127 ppb, Phys. p. 6 Rev. Lett 135 101802 (2025), arXiv:2506. p. 603069 [hep-ex]. p. 6

[3] K. Melnikov and A. p. 6 Vainshtein, Theory of the muon anomalous magnetic moment, Springer Tracts Mod Phys. p. 6, Vol. 216 (2006) pp 1–176 [hep-ph]. p. 6

[4] F. Jegerlehner, The Anomalous Magnetic Moment of the Muon, Springer Tracts Mod. p. 6 Phys., Vol. 274 (2017) pp 1–693 [hep-ph]. p. 6

[5] T. Aoyama et al. p. 6, The anomalous magnetic moment of the muon in the Standard Model, Phys. p. 6 Rept 887 1 (2020), arXiv:2006. p. 604822 [hep-ph]. p. 6

[6] R. Aliberti et al. p. 6, The anomalous magnetic moment of the muon in the standard model: an update, Phys. p. 6 Rept 1143 1 (2025), arXiv:2505. p. 621476 [hep-ph]. p. 6

[7] G. F. Giudice, P. p. 6 Paradisi, and A. p. 6 Strumia, Correlation between the Higgs Decay Rate to Two Photons and the Muon g - 2, JHEP 10 186, arXiv:1207. p. 66393 [hep-ph]. p. 6

[8] S. G. Karshenboim and V. p. 6 A. Shelyuto, Hadronic vacuum-polarization contribution to various QED observables, Eur Phys J D 75 49 (2021) [hep-ph]. p. 6

[9] L. Di Luzio, A. p. 6 Keshavarzi, A. p. 6 Masiero, and P. p. 6 Paradisi, Model-Independent Tests of the Hadronic Vacuum Polarization Contribution to the Muon g-2, Phys Rev Lett 134 011902 (2025) [hep-ph]. p. 6

[10] D. Giusti and S. p. 6 Simula, Ratios of the hadronic contributions to the lepton g − 2 from Lattice QCD+QED simulations, Phys Rev D 102 054503 (2020) [hep-lat]. p. 6

[11] A. Antognini, F. p. 6 Hagelstein, and V. p. 6 Pascalutsa, The proton structure in and out of muonic hydrogen, Ann Rev Nucl Part Sci 72 389 (2022) [nuclth]. p. 6

[12] T. Blum et al., Calculation of the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution to the muon anomalous magnetic moment, Phys Rev Lett 121 022003 (2018) [hep-lat]. p. 7

[13] A. Boccaletti et al. p. 7, Hybrid calculation of hadronic vacuum polarization in muon g − 2 to 0. p. 748%, Nature 653 373 (2026) [hep-lat]. p. 7

[14] S. Borsanyi et al. p. 7, Hadronic vacuum polarization contribution to the anomalous magnetic moments of leptons from first principles, Phys Rev Lett 121 022002 (2018) [hep-lat]. p. 7

[15] A. Keshavarzi, D. p. 6 Nomura, and T. p. 7 Teubner, g − 2 of charged leptons, α(MZ), and the hyperfine splitting of muonium, Phys Rev D 101 014029 (2020) [hep-ph]. p. 7

[16] M. Bauer et al., Axionlike Particles, Lepton-Flavor Violation, and a New Explanation of aµ and ae, Phys Rev Lett 124 211803 (2020) [hep-ph]. p. 7

[17] M. Bauer et al., The Low-Energy Effective Theory of Axions and ALPs, JHEP 04 063, arXiv:2012. p. 712272 [hep-ph]. p. 7

[18] A. M. Galda and M. p. 7 Neubert, ALP-LEFT Interference and the Muon (g − 2), JHEP 11 015, arXiv:2308. p. 701338 [hep-ph]. p. 7

[19] A. Pustyntsev and M. p. 7 Vanderhaeghen, Implications of recent (g-2)µ measurements for MeV-GeV dark sector searches, Phys Rev D 112 095001 (2025) [hep-ph]. p. 7

[20] C. Bouchiat and L. p. 7 Michel, La r´esonance dans la diffusion meson π— meson π et le moment magnétique anormal du meson µ, J Phys Radium 22 121 (1961) [hep-ex]. p. 7

[21] S. J. Brodsky and E. p. 7 de Rafael, Suggested boson-lepton pair couplings and the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon, Phys Rev 168 1620 (1968) [hep-ph]. p. 7

[22] B. E. Lautrup and E. p. 7 De Rafael, Calculation of the sixthorder contribution from the fourth-order vacuum polarization to the difference of the anomalous magnetic moments of muon and electron, Phys Rev 174 1835 (1968) [hep-ph]. p. 7

[23] M. Gourdin and E. p. 7 De Rafael, Hadronic contributions to the muon g-factor, Nucl Phys B 10 667 (1969) [hep-ph]. p. 7

[24] D. Bernecker and H. p. 2 B. Meyer, Vector Correlators in Lattice QCD: Methods and applications, Eur Phys J A 47 148 (2011) [hep-lat]. p. 7

[25] A. Beltran et al. p. 7, Higher-order hadronic vacuum polarization contribution to the muon g − 2 from lattice QCD (2026), arXiv:2603. p. 706806 [hep-lat]. p. 7

[39] P. J. Mohr, D. B. Newell, B. N. Taylor, and E. p. 7 Tiesinga, CODATA recommended values of the fundamental physical constants: 2022 (Rev Mod Phys 97 025002 2025) [hep-ph]. p. 7

[41] R. H. Parker, C. Yu, W. Zhong, B. Estey, and H. p. 7 M¨uller, Measurement of the fine-structure constant as a test of the Standard Model, Science 360 191 (2018) [physics-atom-ph]. p. 7

[5] Generally this feature should be derived via Schwinger’s sum rule, of which the dispersive representation for the HVP contribution is a particular case [38]

--- Page 1 ---

Lepton g − 2 non-universality of hadronic contributions and a sub-GeV window to New Physics

Siyuan Li and Vladimir Pascalutsa Institut f¨ur Kernphysik, Johannes Gutenberg-Universit¨at Mainz, D-55128 Mainz, Germany Maxim Pospelov William I. Fine Theoretical Physics Institute,University of Minnesota MN 55455, United States and Theoretical Physics Department CERN 1 Esplanade des Particules CH-1211 Geneva 23 Switzerland (Dated: June 17, 2026)

--- Page 2 ---

The anomalous magnetic moments of the electron and muon, ae and aµ, are some of the best-measured quantities in physics [1, 2] They also come out as a basic prediction of the Standard Model (SM), thus allowing for its stringent precision test and New-Physics constraints [3–5] The dominant theoretical uncertainty in aµ comes from the leading-order (LO) hadronic vacuum polarization (HVP) contribution, for which lattice-QCD and data-driven determinations exhibit a persistent tension (as per 2025 White Paper of the ‘g − 2 Theory Initiative’ [6]) Moreover, the datasets used in the data-driven evaluations are not entirely consistent with one another, which has led to the omission of this approach from the current SM value altogether

--- Page 3 ---

The largest part of the HVP contribution in the datadriven approach comes from the π+π− channel On the theory side, this contribution can roughly be understood using a vector-meson-dominance (VMD) type model, where the photon couples to the pion via the ρ-meson Using the specific VMD model of Ref. [27], we obtain the values in Table II, where they are compared to a state-of-the-art data-driven evaluation Fig. p. 3 4 shows the corresponding integrands, illustrating the large cancellation between the muon and rescaled electron g − 2 Sub-GeV contributions, such as the ρ-meson resonance, survive in aµ−e

--- Page 4 ---

The pseudoscalars (π0, η, η′) dominate the hadronic light-by-light contribution (HLbL), as also prominently appear in the isospin-breaking correction to the HVP contribution The UV-divergence can be ameliorated by inserting an empirical pion transition form factor (TFF) in the πγγ vertex Fortunately, this UV-divergence exactly cancels from the combined quantity aµ−e, which allows us to consider the χPT predictions as they are

--- Page 5 ---

The VMD results serve a qualitative purpose and no effort to estimate uncertainties is made here Substituting the corresponding expression for the spectral function into the dispersive representation with the kernel (5), we obtain aµ−e = α 3m2π0 1728 π5 f2πr 4 h r2 4r4 + 81r2 + 66 −6 √4r2 − 1/64r4 + 28r2 − 11 arccos(1/2r) − 6(2r6 +9r4−11) log r + 18(6r2 + 1)log2 r + arccos(2/sqrt r) This value can be compared to the contribution to muon alone Performing the same calculation for the electron (with the TFF of Ref. [27]) and forming the combination, we obtain aµ−e(with TFF) ≃ -0. p. 445 × 10−11

--- Page 6 ---

It is easy to see that aµ−e would provide a deeper reach into ε2 for all mA′ < 1 GeV It is assumed that the only limitation comes from the HVP error, and it is taken to be δaHVP µ = 1. × 10−9 and δaHVP e ≃ (me/mµ)2δaHVP µ In that hypothetical regime, the constraints (or more precisely, sensitivity limits) on the mixing angle of the dark photon can be substantially improved It is easy to see that aµ−e would provide a deeper reach into ε2 for all mA′ < 1 GeV

--- Page 7 ---

With aµ−e, one can isolate the low-energy regime, which can be treated within EFT frameworks with greater predictive power than aµ or ae separately We have illustrated this point using the example of the π0γ contribution Finally, potential new physics below GeV is also more amplified in aµ−e than purely leptonic (g−2) observables With aµ−e, one can isolate the low-energy regime, which can be treated within EFT frameworks with greater predictive power than aµ or ae separately

--- Page 8 ---

The paper is 2606.083291.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved calculation of hadronic vacuum polarization uncertainty for muon g-2 by approximately 85 percent using a new linear combination quantity, a mu minus e, which ensures an exact cancellation of the short-range effects.

  2. Ability to probe sub-GeV New Physics scenarios with greater reach than separate measurements of muon g-2 or electron g-2 by utilizing the natural low-energy window quantity a mu minus e.

  3. Enhanced ability to constrain flavor non-universal Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) physics, specifically deviations from a m two over m two scaling in loop diagrams, by using the expression a BSM mu minus e = m two over lambda squared mu minus one over lambda squared e.

  4. Increased sensitivity to sub-GeV dark photons by using a mu minus e observable which is better probed than purely leptonic g-2 observables, conditional on experimental improvement of ae and alpha measurements.

  5. More rigorous comparison between theoretical evaluations of hadronic contributions to a mu minus e from data-driven dispersive approaches and lattice QCD evaluations, as the paper shows that the agreement appears better for a mu minus e than for a mu and ae individually.

Sources

Related papers