Short-range correlated pair formation and nuclear shell structure

arXiv:2606.07754 · nucl-ex, nucl-th · Submitted 2026-06-05 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Experiment. The day in nuclear experiment: beams, targets and what came out.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Short-range correlated pair formation and nuclear shell structure".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Short-range correlated (SRC) nucleon pairs are dominated by neutron-proton pairs with large relative and smaller center-of-mass momenta <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The authors investigate how the formation of these short-range correlated pairs is influenced by nuclear shell structure, revealing that intra-shell pairing is much stronger than inter-shell pairing <ref:2606.07754#pg2> This research is important because it shows the critical role of low-momentum nuclear structure in determining the probability of high-momentum nucleon pairing <ref:2606.07754#pg2>.

Kai: SRC Pair Dominance and Structure Short-range correlated (SRC) nucleon pairs are caused by brief, high-momentum interactions between two nucleons, which are dominated by neutron-proton pairs with large relative and smaller center-of-mass momenta <ref:2606.07754#pg2> Measurements of 40,48Ca and 54Fe showed that intra-shell pairing was much stronger than inter-shell pairing <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The independent-particle shell model provides a firstorder description of nuclei in which nucleons occupy mean-field orbitals, but valence orbitals contain only about two-thirds the expected number of protons <ref:2606.07754#pg2> Many of these “missing” nucleons belong to temporary high-momentum short-range correlated (SRC) nucleon-nucleon (NN) pairs <ref:2606.07754#pg2> These nucleons account for most of the kinetic energy of the nucleons and have been linked to the modification of bound-nucleon structure and to neutron star properties <ref:2606.07754#pg2> Experimental Evidence for Intra-shell Pairing Experiments have established that nearly all highmomentum nucleons belong to SRC pairs, which are predominantly proton–neutron pairs with large relative and smaller center-of-mass momentum <ref:2606.07754#pg2> Inclusive A(e, e′) electron-scattering measurements showed that the fraction of nucleons in correlated pairs increases by about 10% from C to Pb, consistent with nuclear saturation <ref:2606.07754#pg2> However, a recent measurement of (e, e′p) proton-knockout from SRC pairs in 40Ca, 48Ca, and 54Fe showed that adding six 1f7/2 protons increased the number of high-initial-momentum protons by a surprising 50% <ref:2606.07754#pg2> These results challenged previous expectation that SRC pair formation is governed by global properties such as mass A, or neutron-to-proton asymmetry N/Z and indicated that intra-shell SRC pairing is far more favorable than inter-shell pairing <ref:2606.07754#pg2> Sensitivity to Nuclear Structure The fraction of SRC protons increased much more rapidly from A = 9 to 12 and from A = 40 to 54 than from A = 9 to 197, which shows the importance of low-momentum nuclear structure on the probability of high-momentum nucleon pairing <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The SRC pairing increase from 9Be (J = 3/2) to 10B (J = 3) is much larger than that from 10B to 12C (J = 0), implying that the total angular momentum is less important than the cluster structure of 9Be <ref:2606.07754#pg2> This suggests that adding one proton to 9Be increased the number of SRC protons by about 50%, from 0.53 to 0.77, much greater than the 25% increase in the number of protons (from 4 to 5) <ref:2606.07754#pg2> Model Comparison and Conclusion The spatial overlap model and the Wiringa pair-counting model both described the data better than more sophisticated models <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The results complement the shell effects seen in 40Ca, 48Ca, and 54Fe where intra-shell pairing was much stronger than inter-shell pairing <ref:2606.07754#pg2> In conclusion, these results show the importance of low-momentum structure for high-momentum SRC pairing <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The momentumdistribution calculations agreed with the measured ratios of the boron nuclei to carbon to within the experimental uncertainties <ref:2606.07754#pg2> Data and Analysis Details The experiment utilized electron-scattering proton-knockout from SRC pairs in a range of nuclei spanning mass A, asymmetry N/Z, and shell occupancy, including 9Be, 10B, 11B, 12C, 40Ca, 48Ca, and 54Fe <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The analysis involved calculating per-nucleus cross-section ratios to carbon as a function of missing momentum (pmiss) <ref:2606.07754#pg2> Systematic uncertainties were determined by randomly sampling each cut from a Gaussian distribution with an appropriate mean and sigma, which resulted in a standard deviation for the cross-section ratios that was taken as the systematic uncertainty <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The calculated cross section ratios of the light nuclei to carbon do not depend on pmiss for 375 ≤ pmiss ≤ 700 MeV/c, consistent with SRC dominance for these kinematics <ref:2606.07754#pg2> Uncertainty Quantification The total systematic uncertainty was determined by adding the standard deviation of the distribution from cut variation to the statistical uncertainty <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The experimental uncertainties were quantified in percent for radiative corrections, cut variations, and transparency corrections <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The systematic uncertainties associated with the radiative corrections, cut variations, and transparency corrections were determined directly for the single ratios of each nucleus A to C <ref:2606.07754#pg2> All uncertainties are in percent <ref:2606.07754#pg2> Target Information The target information is summarized in Table II, which details the target areal densities and purities for the various nuclei used in the experiment <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The 48Ca oil contamination decreased exponentially from about 3% to about 0.5% during the data taking as the oil evaporated in the vacuum of the target chamber <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The total oil contamination values were consistent with the measured H contamination for (CH2)n mineral oil <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The 48Ca target contained 10% 40Ca <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The Ca(e, e′) to measure the total target thickness in each run <ref:2606.07754#pg2> Kinematic Coverage and Event Selection Cuts The kinematic coverage for xb, Q2, θrq, Pmiss are shown in Figs.

Mira: 2 to 5 <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The event selection cuts include a cut on xbj > 1.2 <ref:2606.07754#pg2> A cut on Q2 > 1.8 (GeV/c)2 was required to suppress the non-quasielastic contribution from meson exchange currents <ref:2606.07754#pg2> A cut on xB ≥ 1.2 was required to reduce inelastic scattering contributions, such as from nucleonic excitations <ref:2606.07754#pg2> Finally, a cut requiring the angle between the reconstructed recoil momentum (⃗precoil = −⃗pmiss) and ⃗q be small: θrq < 40◦ was applied to minimize the effect of low pmiss protons rescattering <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The mean values and standard deviations of the Gaussian distributions for the cut variations are listed in Table IV <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The total systematic uncertainty was determined by adding the standard deviation of this distribution to the statistical uncertainty <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The mean values and standard deviations of the Gaussian distributions for the cut variations are listed in Table IV <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The total systematic uncertainty was determined by adding the standard deviation of this distribution to the statistical uncertainty <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The mean values and standard deviations of the Gaussian distributions for the cut variations are listed in Table IV <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The total systematic uncertainty was determined by adding the standard deviation of this distribution to the statistical uncertainty <ref:2606.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper, "Short-range correlated pair formation and nuclear shell structure," and what it's about is essentially how those short-range correlated pairs in nucleons actually get formed inside the nucleus.

Mira: It sounds like the title points us toward a connection between those short-range pairs and the underlying structure of the nucleus itself, specifically the shell structure.

Lev: From my side, I'm interested in what this implies for our error correction models because if we can better predict where these pairs form based on structure, we might reduce the overhead needed to run real hardware simulations.

Kai: Exactly. We're dealing with these high-momentum interactions, and this paper seems to be trying to map out how the specific arrangement of nucleons—the shell structure—affects those pairs.

Mira: It’s important because it suggests that we can move beyond just looking at the overall mass of a nucleus or the neutron-to-proton ratio as the main driver for these correlations.

Lev: I wonder if this means we need to build models that account for these specific shell effects in our error correction algorithms, rather than treating them as some kind of noise.

Kai: Right. It's about seeing how local structure dictates the probability of those high-momentum nucleon pairings >

The paper's summary: Mira: The authors summarize that short-range correlated nucleon pairs are overwhelmingly dominated by neutron-proton pairs when we look at the large relative and smaller center-of-mass momenta.

Kai: That’s a key finding, and it reinforces what we see in the data, where those neutron proton interactions really take the lead in forming these SRC pairs >

Lev: When you talk about dominance like that, it means our simulations need to focus heavily on those specific configurations rather than just averaging over all possible nucleon interactions.

Mira: And they're showing that when they look at specific isotopes, like 40Ca and 54Fe, the intra-shell pairing is much stronger than the inter-shell pairing > <ref:2606.07754#pg2>

Kai: That’s a direct challenge to thinking that global properties like mass A or neutron to proton asymmetry N over Z are the only things governing this behavior.

Lev: So it's suggesting that local structure matters more than global averages in determining if those high-momentum pairs actually form >

Mira: And they link these missing nucleons, the ones not accounted for by the independent-particle shell model, to both kinetic energy and even neutron star properties >

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper points out a few ways they improved the understanding of this topic, specifically by looking at how different nuclei behave when we vary their shell occupancy.

Mira: They highlight that the fraction of SRC protons increased much more rapidly from A equals nine to twelve and from A equals forty to fifty-four than it did when you looked across a much wider mass range, like nine up to one hundred ninety-seven >

Lev: That's useful because it shows us exactly where the sensitivity is—it’s not uniformly spread across all nuclei; there are these specific regions of structure that amplify the pairing effect >

Kai: And they also noted a comparison between different light nuclei, like 9Be and 10B, showing that the increase in SRC protons from 9Be with angular momentum J equals three over two to 10B with J equals three was much larger than the jump from 10B to twelveC > <ref:2606.07754#pg1>

Mira: That comparison suggests that the total angular momentum isn't as important as the specific cluster structure of those light nuclei when it comes to SRC pairing formation >

Lev: If we can use that kind of structural information, maybe we can develop better ways to predict how adding a single nucleon will affect the pairing probability in complex systems >

Kai: And they used spatial overlap and wiringa pair-counting models, finding that those two models described the data better than more sophisticated ones like AV18 or SRG for nuclei like 10B and 11B > <ref:2606.07754#pg1>

Conclusion: Mira: So to wrap up the paper "Short-range correlated pair formation and nuclear shell structure," it really emphasizes that low-momentum structure is critical for determining the probability of high-momentum nucleon pairing >

Kai: It shows that we can't just rely on broad properties like mass A or N over Z to predict these effects; you have to account for the specific local shell configuration >

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, this means our next generation of error correction methods needs to incorporate these structural sensitivities so they aren't fighting against the actual physics of how those pairs are forming >

Mira: This work gives us a better handle on how we should be modeling missing nucleons and what physical assumptions we need to make when predicting their properties >

Kai: It’s a solid foundation for understanding why certain nuclei behave differently in terms of their internal correlations, especially when you're looking at those high-momentum components >

Lev: I think the comparison between different models for 10B and 11B gives us some concrete benchmarks to test if our methods can actually capture these subtle structural effects > <ref:2606.07754#pg1>

Mira: This paper helps us refine our theoretical assumptions about how nucleons pair up in a nucleus, which is essential for any accurate prediction of nuclear structure modifications >

Kai: That's it for this one. We’ll keep an eye on how these structural insights translate into the next set of experimental measurements >

Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility · University of Tennessee · Old Dominion University · The Catholic University of America · Florida International University · Massachusetts Institute of Technology · School of Physics and Astronomy, Tel Aviv University · Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory · “University of Washington”

nucl-ex, nucl-th

Submitted: 2026-06-05

Updated: 2026-10-27

Comments: 5 pages, 3 figures, to be submitted to Physics Letters B. Includes online-only supplemental information. New version has new figures for PLB and updated calculations and references

Code: https://github.com/JeffersonLab/simc_

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 87/100

The gist: Short-range correlated (SRC) nucleon pairs are dominated by neutron-proton pairs with large relative and smaller center-of-mass momenta <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The authors investigate how the formation…

Key concepts

Short-range correlated (SRC) pairs
These are brief, high-momentum interactions between two nucleons. They are primarily dominated by neutron-proton pairs with large relative and small center-of-mass momenta. These pairs account for most of the kinetic energy of nucleons and are linked to modifications in bound nucleon structure.
Intra-shell vs. Inter-shell pairing
This comparison shows that pairing within the same nuclear shell is much stronger than pairing between different shells. Experiments on nuclei like 40Ca and 54Fe confirmed this, suggesting that the specific shell occupancy significantly affects how nucleons pair up.
Low-momentum nuclear structure sensitivity
The probability of forming high-momentum nucleon pairs is highly sensitive to the low-momentum structure of the nucleus. The rapid increase in SRC proton fractions observed between light nuclei (like 9Be to 12C) compared to heavier ones demonstrates this dependence, indicating that cluster structure matters more than total mass.
Momentum distribution calculations
Advanced many-body models were used to calculate nucleon momentum distributions. These calculations successfully described the data for light nuclei like $^{10}$B and $^{11}$B, providing a reliable framework for predicting missing momentum spectra in new experiments.

Terminology

Summary

Short-range correlated (SRC) nucleon pairs are dominated by neutron-proton pairs with large relative and smaller center-of-mass momenta <ref:2606. p. 007754#pg2> The authors investigate how the formation of these short-range correlated pairs is influenced by nuclear shell structure, revealing that intra-shell pairing is much stronger than inter-shell pairing <ref:2606. p. 007754#pg2> This research is important because it shows the critical role of low-momentum nuclear structure in determining the probability of high-momentum nucleon pairing <ref:2606. p. 007754#pg2>.

SRC Pair Dominance and Structure

Short-range correlated (SRC) nucleon pairs are caused by brief, high-momentum interactions between two nucleons, which are dominated by neutron-proton pairs with large relative and smaller center-of-mass momenta <ref:2606.07754#pg2> Measurements of 40,48Ca and 54Fe showed that intra-shell pairing was much stronger than inter-shell pairing <ref:2606. p. 007754#pg2> The independent-particle shell model provides a firstorder description of nuclei in which nucleons occupy mean-field orbitals, but valence orbitals contain only about two-thirds the expected number of protons <ref:2606. p. 007754#pg2> Many of these “missing” nucleons belong to temporary high-momentum short-range correlated (SRC) nucleon-nucleon (NN) pairs <ref:2606. p. 007754#pg2> These nucleons account for most of the kinetic energy of the nucleons and have been linked to the modification of bound-nucleon structure and to neutron star properties <ref:2606. p. 007754#pg2>

Experimental Evidence for Intra-shell Pairing

Experiments have established that nearly all highmomentum nucleons belong to SRC pairs, which are predominantly proton–neutron pairs with large relative and smaller center-of-mass momentum <ref:2606.07754#pg2> Inclusive A(e, e′) electron-scattering measurements showed that the fraction of nucleons in correlated pairs increases by about 10% from C to Pb, consistent with nuclear saturation <ref:2606. p. 007754#pg2> However, a recent measurement of (e, e′p) proton-knockout from SRC pairs in 40Ca, 48Ca, and 54Fe showed that adding six 1f7/2 protons increased the number of high-initial-momentum protons by a surprising 50% <ref:2606. p. 107754#pg2> These results challenged previous expectation that SRC pair formation is governed by global properties such as mass A, or neutron-to-proton asymmetry N/Z and indicated that intra-shell SRC pairing is far more favorable than inter-shell pairing <ref:2606. p. 107754#pg2>

Sensitivity to Nuclear Structure

The fraction of SRC protons increased much more rapidly from A = 9 to 12 and from A = 40 to 54 than from A = 9 to 197, which shows the importance of low-momentum nuclear structure on the probability of high-momentum nucleon pairing <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The SRC pairing increase from 9Be (J = 3/2) to 10B (J = 3) is much larger than that from 10B to 12C (J = 0), implying that the total angular momentum is less important than the cluster structure of 9Be <ref:2606. p. 207754#pg2> This suggests that adding one proton to 9Be increased the number of SRC protons by about 50%, from 0. p. 253 to 0.77, much greater than the 25% increase in the number of protons (from 4 to 5) <ref:2606. p. 207754#pg2>

Model Comparison and Conclusion

The spatial overlap model and the Wiringa pair-counting model both described the data better than more sophisticated models <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The results complement the shell effects seen in 40Ca, 48Ca, and 54Fe where intra-shell pairing was much stronger than inter -shell pairing <ref:2606.07754#pg2> In conclusion, these results show the importance of low-momentum structure for high-momentum SRC pairing <ref:2606. p. 407754#pg2> The momentumdistribution calculations agreed with the measured ratios of the boron nuclei to carbon to within the experimental uncertainties <ref:2606. p. 407754#pg2>

Data and Analysis Details

The experiment utilized electron-scattering proton-knockout from SRC pairs in a range of nuclei spanning mass A, asymmetry N/Z, and shell occupancy, including 9Be, 10B, 11B, 12C, 40Ca, 48Ca, and 54Fe <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The analysis involved calculating per-nucleus cross-section ratios to carbon as a function of missing momentum (pmiss) <ref:2606. p. 207754#pg2> Systematic uncertainties were determined by randomly sampling each cut from a Gaussian distribution with an appropriate mean and sigma, which resulted in a standard deviation for the cross-section ratios that was taken as the systematic uncertainty <ref:2606. p. 207754#pg2> The calculated cross section ratios of the light nuclei to carbon do not depend on pmiss for 375 ≤ pmiss ≤ 700 MeV/c, consistent with SRC dominance for these kinematics <ref:2606. p. 207754#pg2>

Uncertainty Quantification

The total systematic uncertainty was determined by adding the standard deviation of the distribution from cut variation to the statistical uncertainty <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The experimental uncertainties were quantified in percent for radiative corrections, cut variations, and transparency corrections <ref:2606. p. 207754#pg2> The systematic uncertainties associated with the radiative corrections, cut variations, and transparency corrections were determined directly for the single ratios of each nucleus A to C <ref:2606. p. 207754#pg2> All uncertainties are in percent <ref:2606. p. 007754#pg2>

Target Information

The target information is summarized in Table II, which details the target areal densities and purities for the various nuclei used in the experiment <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The 48Ca oil contamination decreased exponentially from about 3% to about 0. p. 95% during the data taking as the oil evaporated in the vacuum of the target chamber <ref:2606. p. 907754#pg2> The total oil contamination values were consistent with the measured H contamination for (CH2)n mineral oil <ref:2606. p. 907754#pg2> The 48Ca target contained 10% 40Ca <ref:2606. p. 607754#pg2> The Ca(e, e′) to measure the total target thickness in each run <ref:2606. p. 907754#pg2>

Kinematic Coverage and Event Selection Cuts

The kinematic coverage for xb, Q2, θrq, Pmiss are shown in Figs. 2 to 5 <ref:2606. p. 007754#pg2> The event selection cuts include a cut on xbj > 1. p. 72 <ref:2606. p. 007754#pg2> A cut on Q2 > 1. p. 18 (GeV/c)2 was required to suppress the non-quasielastic contribution from meson exchange currents <ref:2606. p. 107754#pg2> A cut on xB ≥ 1. p. 12 was required to reduce inelastic scattering contributions, such as from nucleonic excitations <ref:2606. p. 107754#pg2> Finally, a cut requiring the angle between the reconstructed recoil momentum (⃗precoil = −⃗pmiss) and ⃗q be small: θrq < 40◦ was applied to minimize the effect of low pmiss protons rescattering <ref:2606. p. 107754#pg2> The mean values and standard deviations of the Gaussian distributions for the cut variations are listed in Table IV <ref:2606. p. 2 p. 2 p. 207754#pg2> The total systematic uncertainty was determined by adding the standard deviation of this distribution to the statistical uncertainty <ref:2606. p. 2 p. 2 p. 207754#pg2> The mean values and standard deviations of the Gaussian distributions for the cut variations are listed in Table IV <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The total systematic uncertainty was determined by adding the standard deviation of this distribution to the statistical uncertainty <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The mean values and standard deviations of the Gaussian distributions for the cut variations are listed in Table IV <ref:2606.07754#pg2> The total systematic uncertainty was determined by adding the standard deviation of this distribution to the statistical uncertainty <ref:2606.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved prediction of high-momentum nucleon structure in heavy nuclei by incorporating shell effects into SRC pair probability calculations. The improved AI system can accurately predict that intra-shell pairing was much stronger than inter-shell pairing based on mass A and N/Z, which is crucial for understanding nuclear structure modifications.

  2. Enhanced classification of nucleon pairs based on nuclear properties like angular momentum and cluster structure. The improved system can distinguish between pair formation mechanisms by recognizing that the SRC pairing increase from 9Be (J = 3/2) to 10B (J = 3) is much larger than that from 10B to 12C (J = 0), guiding predictions for heavier systems.

  3. Refined analysis of experimental data to isolate the influence of low-momentum nuclear structure on high-momentum nucleon pairing. The improved system can specifically identify that the fraction of SRC protons increased much more rapidly from A = 9 to 12 and from A = 40 to 54 than from A = 9 to 197, allowing for better extrapolation of SRC probability across different mass ranges.

  4. More accurate modeling of nucleon momentum distributions in nuclei using advanced many-body methods. The improved system can utilize the successful comparison where All three models, AV18, SRG, and LCA, described the data very well for 10B and 11B, leading to superior predictions for missing momentum spectra in new experiments.

  5. Better interpretation of experimental observables by applying systematic correction factors derived from radiative and transparency effects. The improved system can automatically apply the empirically determined radiative correction factors (e.g., 0.741 for light nuclei) and transparency corrections to raw cross-section ratios, reducing analysis uncertainty as shown in Table III.

Sources

Related papers