Flowing with Displacements and Tilts: Surface Operators in O(N) Models

arXiv:2606.03974 · hep-th · Submitted 2026-06-02 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Flowing with Displacements and Tilts".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Defect conformal field theories have special operators of protected dimension known as displacements and tilts <ref:2606.03974#pg2>.

Kai: This paper presents an elegant approach using conformal perturbation theory to study these operators and their flows between different defect renormalization group fixed points <ref:2606.03974#pg2>.

Mira: The displacements D and tilts t are distinguished operators arising from the breaking of global symmetries by a defect and the normalisations of their two-point functions characterize the defect <ref:2606.03974#pg2>.

Kai: For a p dimensional defect, they have protected dimensions ∆D = p+ 1 and ∆t = p <ref:2606.03974#pg2>.

Paper summary: Kai: To start, the paper says they focus on how these displacements and tilts change under renormalization group flows and what happens at different fixed points >

Mira: Basically, they introduce a method using conformal perturbation theory to look at the behavior of these operators as the system flows >

Lev: The methodology involves deforming the bulk theory with one O(N) singlet field and one traceless symmetric tensor, or combining all fields into a completely unconstrained real N by N deformation >

Kai: They then determine the fixed points by finding where the beta functions derived from these bulk operators are zero >

Mira: They find a trivial fixed point called D zero where h s equals zero and h t ij equals zero, but they also look for nontrivial O(N) symmetric fixed points >

Lev: The stability of that nontrivial fixed point depends on a condition involving the gamma T and the CSSS terms, specifically if gamma T CSSS is greater than two times gamma SCST T >

Kai: And they show that at these generic D zero fixed points, the residual symmetry is O n by O m >

Mira: Then they couple the action to extra sources called u in O(N) and v in R d to figure out how the tilt and displacement normalizations are determined >

Conclusion: Kai: So, looking at "Flowing with Displacements and Tilts: Surface Operators in O(N) Models", the main point is that they found a unified way to study surface defects using conformal perturbation theory >

Mira: They managed to reproduce results from the Wilson Fisher O(N) model and extended those findings to other models like the long range model and the chiral O N by O two model >

Lev: The key finding is that these displacement and tilt normalizations have protected integer dimensions, and they show how this protection stays along renormalization group flows because they solve callan symanzik equations for those constants CD and Ct >

Kai: It means that these operators have dimensions protected at all scales, which is important because it's not just a thing that happens at one point >

Mira: And they also found some interesting things about the stability of the fixed points, like how reality conditions depend on the sign of a discriminant >

Lev: They also noted that for N greater than twenty-two in the antichiral bulk theory, all those symmetric saddles are real, but in the chiral bulk theory, they're generally complex >

Jake Belton, Nadav Drukker, Biswajit Sahoo

King’s College London

hep-th

Submitted: 2026-06-02

Updated: 2026-11-02

Comments: 52 pages

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 87/100

The gist: Defect conformal field theories have special operators of protected dimension known as displacements and tilts <ref:2606.03974#pg2>.

Key concepts

Displacements (D) and Tilts (t)
These are special operators arising from breaking global symmetries by a defect. Their specific dimensions ($\Delta D = p+1$ and $\Delta t = p$ for a $p$-dimensional defect) are protected, meaning they don't change under renormalization group flow, which is crucial for characterizing the defect.
Conformal Perturbation Theory
This is the mathematical tool used to study how these operators behave during renormalization group (RG) flows. It involves deforming bulk theories with small fields and analyzing the resulting perturbative spectra to understand operator evolution between fixed points.
Renormalization Group (RG) Flows
These describe how a physical system changes as its energy scale is varied. The paper analyzes the flow of operators like D and t between different stable or unstable fixed points in the theory, revealing how their properties, such as dimension protection, are preserved during this evolution.

Terminology

Summary

Defect conformal field theories have special operators of protected dimension known as displacements and tilts <ref:2606. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Flowing with Displacements and Tilts: Surface Operators in O(N) Models Jake Belton∗ , Nadav Drukker† , and Biswajit Sahoo‡ Department of Mathematics, King’s College London, London, WC2R 2LS, United Kingdom Abstract Defect conformal field theories have special operators of protected dimension known as displacements and tilts. They arise due to the breaking of global symmetries by the defect and the normalisations of their two-point functions are characteristics of the defect.

03974#pg2>. This paper presents an elegant approach using conformal perturbation theory to study these operators and their flows between different defect renormalization group fixed points <ref:2606. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In the case of surface defects, these normalisations are related to some of the anomaly coefficients in the surface effective action. To study these operators and their flows between different defect renormalization group fixed points we present an elegant approach using conformal perturbation theory that easily reproduces the known examples from the critical Wilson–Fisher O(N) model in 4−ε dimensions and allows us to construct new ones in other multiscalar theories.

03974#pg2>.

Introduction to Defect Operators

The displacements D and tilts t are distinguished operators arising from the breaking of global symmetries by a defect and the normalisations of their two-point functions characterize the defect <ref:2606.03974#pg2>. For a p dimensional defect, they have protected dimensions ∆D = p+ 1 and ∆t = p <ref:2606. p. 1

Where the paper says it

For the formal definitions, see the top of Section 4. For a p dimensional defect, they have protected dimensions ∆D = p+ 1 and ∆t = p.

03974#pg2>. The normalizations are given by specific correlators involving the defect structure <ref:2606. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Those relations were widely expanded in [4–11], to include displacements, correlators involving other operators and bulk–defect correlators. For a surface operator, the constants CD and Ct are also related to defect anomalies.

03974#pg2>. These constants CD and Ct are related to defect anomalies, specifically CD is related to an anomaly term arising from nontrivial embeddings, while Ct is related to anomalies from nonuniform global symmetry breaking <ref:2606. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In particular, CD is related to an anomaly term arising from nontrivial embeddings, so roughly the extrinsic curvature, see, e. Ct is related to anomalies from nonuniform global symmetry breaking, see e.

03974#pg2>.

Methodology for Flow Analysis

The study employs conformal perturbation theory to analyze the behavior of D, t, CD, and Ct under renormalization group (RG) flows <ref:2606.03974#pg2>. The problem is formulated in terms of arbitrary O(N) bulk theories with perturbative spectra <ref:2606. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The particular models presented in this work exhibit fixed-point collisions and defect conformal manifolds with distinct types of tilt operators. We first formulate the problem in terms of arbitrary O(N) bulk theories with perturbative spectra.

03974#pg2>. The input involves a small set of generic anomalous dimensions and three-point coefficients for operators near dimension two in specified O(N) representations <ref:2606. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We first formulate the problem in terms of arbitrary O(N) bulk theories with perturbative spectra. The input is a small set of generic anomalous dimensions and three-point coefficients for operators near dimension two in specified O(N) representations, together with the current and descendant data needed to track displacements.

03974#pg2>. The analysis proceeds by deforming the bulk theory with one O(N) singlet field and one traceless-symmetric tensor, or by combining all fields into a completely unconstrained real N × N deformation <ref:2606. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In Section 2 we analyse the possible defect fixed points arising from deforming a bulk theory by one O(N) singlet field and one traceless-symmetric tensor. In Section 3 we additionally turn on an antisymmetric field, or combining all fields together, a completely unconstrained real N × N deformation.

03974#pg2>.

Analysis of Fixed Points and Stability

The fixed points are determined by the zeros of the beta functions derived from the bulk operators <ref:2606.03974#pg2>. The trivial fixed point is D0: hS,D0 = 0, hT,D0ij = 0 <ref:2606. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Given that there are multiple fixed points, we label them as Dn rather than the traditional asterisk. The trivial fixed point is D0 : h S,D0 = 0, hT,D0 ij = 0, (2.

03974#pg2>. A nontrivial O(N) symmetric fixed point exists as long as CSSS ≠ 0 and γS. p. 5
Where the paper says it

The trivial fixed point is D0 : h S,D0 = 0, hT,D0 ij = 0, (2. 20) and the nontrivial O(N) symmetric fixed point exists as long as CSSS ̸= 0 and γS < 0 and is DN : h T,DN ij = 0, hS,DN = − γS πCSSS .

The analysis of the stability matrix reveals that the fixed point DN is stable if γT CSSS > 2γSCST T <ref:2606. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Looking at (2. 39), we see that the symmetric fixed point DN is stable iff γT CSSS > 2γSCST T .

03974#pg2>. The residual symmetry at generic Dn fixed points is O(n) × O(m) <ref:2606. p. 8
Where the paper says it

21), the singlet and symmetric traceless operators have anomalous dimensions γ DN S = −γS, γ DN T = γT − 2CST T CSSS γS. 39) For the generic Dn fixed point with CT T T ̸= 0, n ̸= m, the residual symmetry is O(n) × O(m).

03974#pg2>.

Protected Operators and Flows

The tilt and displacement normalisations are determined by coupling the action to extra sources u ∈ O(N) and v ∈ R d <ref:2606.03974#pg2>. At separated points, the two-point functions are given by (1. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Given that there are multiple fixed points, we label them as Dn rather than the traditional asterisk. The trivial fixed point is D0 : h S,D0 = 0, hT,D0 ij = 0, (2.

1) <ref:2606. p. 0
Where the paper says it

com ‡biswajit. uk 1 arXiv:2606.

03974#pg2>. The protected tilt normalization Ct is found to be proportional to 2hDn,n − hDn,m squared <ref:2606. p. 1
Where the paper says it

20 4 Protected operators and their flows 23 4. 1 Tilt and displacement normalisations for scalar–tensor defects .

03974#pg2>. The displacement normalization CD is given by (4. p. 5
Where the paper says it

17) and (2. Given that there are multiple fixed points, we label them as Dn rather than the traditional asterisk.

11) <ref:2606. p. 0
Where the paper says it

com ‡biswajit. uk 1 arXiv:2606.

03974#pg2>.

Examples and Applications

The work specializes to concrete models such as the critical O(N) Wilson–Fisher theory in d = 4 − ε <ref:2606.03974#pg2>. The long range Wilson–Fisher theory exhibits a family of fixed-point collisions when its nonlocality parameter is varied <ref:2606. p. 2

Where the paper says it

We then look at the long-range WF theory [32], which is a nonlocal generalisation of the theory with one extra continuous parameter, parameterising the nonlocality. As its nonlocality parameter is varied, this model exhibits a family of fixed-point collisions.

03974#pg2>. The chiral O(N) × O(2) model provides a rich setting with defect conformal manifolds including O(N)/(U(p) × O(n)) <ref:2606. p. 2
Where the paper says it

This is a rather rich theory with a multitude of surface operators and we do not attempt to classify them all, just find relatively symmetric ones. Still, the resulting spaces of defects, or defect conformal manifolds, include O(N)/(U(p)×O(N−2p)), which is homogeneous but not symmetric.

03974#pg2>. The tricritical Wilson–Fisher theory in d = 3 − ε is also studied, showing that the symmetric fixed point is stable only for N ≤ 10 <ref:2606. p. 2
Where the paper says it

For the most part we employ conformal perturbation theory techniques valid for any theory in d dimensions with O(N) symmetry and operators of dimension close to two and three in different O(N) representations. This includes the Wilson–Fisher (WF) critical O(N) model in d = 4 − ε, for which surface operators were studied in [27–30].

03974#pg2>.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The paper concludes with a discussion on the protection of dimensions at all scales, showing that Ct and CD arise from two-point functions satisfying Callan–Symanzik equations <ref:2606.03974#pg2>. The analysis of flows along different trajectories confirms the protection of the dimension at all scales <ref:2606. p. 2

Where the paper says it

The anomaly coefficients related to CD and Ct, which are the focus of this paper are not monotonic, but since their values at the fixed points are of importance, it is natural to explore them also along the flows. While defects with their protected operators exist in different dimensions, we focus on surface defects because there is a large family of such defects that are accessible perturbatively.

03974#pg2>. The study also reveals that for N ≥ 22, all symmetry-breaking fixed points in the antichiral bulk theory are real, while those in the chiral bulk theory are generally complex <ref:2606. p. 5
Where the paper says it

14) Equivalently, we can choose the sign CT jU = q (d − 2)Cj + O(ε). 2 Surface perturbation and fixed points Our main objects of study are flat surface operators achieved by perturbing the bulk theory by the scalar and symmetric traceless operators Sdef = SUV + µ −γS h S Z R2 d 2 τ S + µ −γT h T ij Z R2 d 2 τ Tij .

03974#pg2>.

Summary of Key Findings

The paper establishes a unified approach to study surface defects at first order in conformal perturbation theory <ref:2606.03974#pg2>. It reproduces results from the Wilson–Fisher O(N) model and extends them to other models like the long range model and chiral O(N) × O(2) model <ref:2606. p. 1

Where the paper says it

2 Long range Wilson–Fisher theory in d = 4 − ε . 3 The chiral O(N) × O(2) model .

03974#pg2>. The analysis successfully determines the displacement and tilt normalisations at fixed points, showing that these operators have protected integer dimensions <ref:2606. p. 1
Where the paper says it

20 4 Protected operators and their flows 23 4. 1 Tilt and displacement normalisations for scalar–tensor defects .

p. 1
Where the paper says it

20 4 Protected operators and their flows 23 4. 1 Tilt and displacement normalisations for scalar–tensor defects .

03974#pg2>. Furthermore, the paper demonstrates how the protection of dimension is maintained along RG flows by solving Callan–Symanzik equations for Ct and CD <ref:2606. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In particular, surface defects and two-dimensional boundaries satisfy the b-theorem [20] (see also [21–23]) for the anomaly coefficient associated to the Euler density. The anomaly coefficients related to CD and Ct, which are the focus of this paper are not monotonic, but since their values at the fixed points are of importance, it is natural to explore them also along the flows.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In particular, surface defects and two-dimensional boundaries satisfy the b-theorem [20] (see also [21–23]) for the anomaly coefficient associated to the Euler density. The anomaly coefficients related to CD and Ct, which are the focus of this paper are not monotonic, but since their values at the fixed points are of importance, it is natural to explore them also along the flows.

03974#pg2>.

Stability and Reality Conditions

The stability analysis shows that the symmetric fixed point DN is stable if γT CSSS > 2γSCST T <ref:2606.03974#pg2>. For the U(p) × O(n) fixed points, reality conditions are derived from the quadratic equation for hS,Dn,N2 and depend on the sign of the discriminant σ 2p <ref:2606. p. 6

Where the paper says it

17) gives a quadratic equation. Defining the rescaled discriminant σ 2 n = 9ν 2 N2 + 36nm N CST T C2 T T T γT γ 2 S (2γSCST T − γT CSSS) (2.

03974#pg2>. For N ≥ 22 in the antichiral bulk theory, all U(p) × O(n) symmetric saddles Cp± are real <ref:2606. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In Section 2 we analyse the possible defect fixed points arising from deforming a bulk theory by one O(N) singlet field and one traceless-symmetric tensor. In Section 3 we additionally turn on an antisymmetric field, or combining all fields together, a completely unconstrained real N × N deformation.

03974#pg2>.

Operator Spectrum at Fixed Points

The anomalous dimensions of the operators near dimension two at generic Dn fixed points are determined by the stability matrix diagonalization <ref:2606.03974#pg2>. The eigenvalues for the singlet mixing matrix are given by (2. p. 8

Where the paper says it

The resulting two operators are denoted O±. Their anomalous-dimension mixing matrix, in the original basis, is Γ Dn singlet = γS + 2πCSSSh S,Dn 2πCST T h T,Dn 2πCST T h T,Dn −γT − 2πCST T h S,Dn !

42) <ref:2606. p. 0
Where the paper says it

com ‡biswajit. uk 1 arXiv:2606.

03974#pg2>. The anomalous dimensions of near dimension three operators are derived from the decomposition under O(N) → U(p) × O(n) <ref:2606. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We first formulate the problem in terms of arbitrary O(N) bulk theories with perturbative spectra. The input is a small set of generic anomalous dimensions and three-point coefficients for operators near dimension two in specified O(N) representations, together with the current and descendant data needed to track displacements.

03974#pg2>.

RG Flow Behavior

The RG flow along the O(N)-symmetric trajectory is governed by a single running coupling h S satisfying s dh S ds = −γSh S − πCSSSh S squared <ref:2606.03974#pg2>. The flow between symmetry-breaking fixed points is described by coupled evolution equations for h S and h n <ref:2606. p. 2

Where the paper says it

It also allows for the flow analysis to be model independent. In Section 2 we analyse the possible defect fixed points arising from deforming a bulk theory by one O(N) singlet field and one traceless-symmetric tensor.

03974#pg2>. The protected tilt operator has zero anomalous dimension at all scales <ref:2606.03974#pg2>.

Specific Model Results

For the critical O(N) Wilson–Fisher theory in d = 4 − ε, the fixed points are explicitly calculated, yielding specific values for h S,DN and hT,DN <ref:2606.03974#pg2>. The long range WF theory shows a family of fixed-point collisions as its nonlocality parameter is varied <ref:2606. p. 2

Where the paper says it

We then look at the long-range WF theory [32], which is a nonlocal generalisation of the theory with one extra continuous parameter, parameterising the nonlocality. As its nonlocality parameter is varied, this model exhibits a family of fixed-point collisions.

03974#pg2>. The chiral O(N) × O(2) model exhibits specific stability properties depending on N. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We then look at the long-range WF theory [32], which is a nonlocal generalisation of the theory with one extra continuous parameter, parameterising the nonlocality. As its nonlocality parameter is varied, this model exhibits a family of fixed-point collisions.

The tricritical theory is stable for N ≤ 10 and unstable otherwise <ref:2606. p. 1
Where the paper says it

3 The chiral O(N) × O(2) model . 4 Tricritical Wilson–Fisher theory in d = 3 − ε .

03974#pg2>.

Displacement and Tilt Normalisations in Examples

The displacement normalisation CD for the O(N) symmetric endpoint DN WF is found to be proportional to 2∆S h S,DN WF squared <ref:2606.03974#pg2>. The tilt normalisation Ct for the symmetry-breaking fixed point DWF n is given by (4. p. 8

Where the paper says it

39) For the generic Dn fixed point with CT T T ̸= 0, n ̸= m, the residual symmetry is O(n) × O(m). The traceless symmetric Tij decomposes into two traceless symmetrics Tn and Tm, a bifundamental tilt t and a singlet.

8) <ref:2606. p. 0
Where the paper says it

com ‡biswajit. uk 1 arXiv:2606.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

com ‡biswajit. uk 1 arXiv:2606.

03974#pg2>. In the long range WF theory, CD and Ct are determined by plugging the fixed-point couplings into (4. p. 2
Where the paper says it

We then look at the long-range WF theory [32], which is a nonlocal generalisation of the theory with one extra continuous parameter, parameterising the nonlocality. As its nonlocality parameter is varied, this model exhibits a family of fixed-point collisions.

11) and (4.8) <ref:2606.03974#pg2>. The analysis confirms that for the O(N) symmetric defect, C DN,LR D = 2∆S h S,DN LR squared <ref:2606. p. 2
Where the paper says it

It also allows for the flow analysis to be model independent. In Section 2 we analyse the possible defect fixed points arising from deforming a bulk theory by one O(N) singlet field and one traceless-symmetric tensor.

03974#pg2>.

Summary of Results

The paper provides a unified framework to study surface defects at first order in conformal perturbation theory <ref:2606.03974#pg2>. It successfully reproduces results from the Wilson–Fisher O(N) model and extends them to other models like the long range model and chiral O(N) × O(2) model <ref:2606. p. 1

Where the paper says it

2 Long range Wilson–Fisher theory in d = 4 − ε . 3 The chiral O(N) × O(2) model .

03974#pg2>. The analysis successfully determines the displacement and tilt normalisations at fixed points, showing that these operators have protected integer dimensions <ref:2606.03974#pg2>. Furthermore, the paper demonstrates how the protection of dimension is maintained along RG flows by solving Callan–Symanzik equations for Ct and CD <ref:2606.03974#pg2>.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved ability to calculate defect normalizations: The system can now compute C Dn t and C Dn D exactly for specific CFTs like critical O(N) Wilson-Fisher theory in d = 4 - epsilon by substituting leading order fixed point couplings into equations like (4.8) and (4.11).

  2. Enhanced flow analysis of surface operators: The system can now track the RG flows along the Dn to DN trajectory by solving the coupled evolution equations for h S and h n in Section 4.3, providing explicit forms for C Dn D and C Dn t along these paths.

  3. Classification of fixed-point collisions: The AI can now analyze the discriminant equation (2.27) across various theories to determine which fixed-point collisions are possible, such as finding that for the WF theory, the collision occurs at N = 6 where n = m = 3 and N = 10 where (n, m) = (1, 9).

  4. Determination of complex fixed points: The system can now solve for the roots of the cubic equation in Section 2.6 to find non-trivial fixed points with nonzero h Z, providing explicit solutions for couplings like h Cp+ N2 and η Cp+ N2 at specific N values.

  5. Analysis of stability regions: The AI can check the reality conditions derived from (3.11) and (3.10) to determine which symmetry-breaking fixed points are real or complex for different ranges of N, such as finding that for the chiral bulk fixed point, all U(p) x O(n) symmetric saddles are real when 22 <= N <= 33.

Abstract

Defect conformal field theories have special operators of protected dimension known as displacements and tilts. They arise due to the breaking of global symmetries by the defect and the normalisations of their two-point functions are characteristics of the defect. In the case of surface defects, these normalisations are related to some of the anomaly coefficients in the surface effective action. To study these operators and their flows between different defect renormalization group fixed points we present an elegant approach using conformal perturbation theory that easily reproduces the known examples from the critical Wilson-Fisher O(N) model in 4-epsilon dimensions and allows us to construct new ones in other multiscalar theories. In all the systems that we study the flows are short and under full control, as is the change of the displacement and tilt normalizations. We point out some novel features like the existence of vortices when the defect conformal manifold is not simply connected. In addition to regular human labour, this work relied heavily on generative AI; see full disclosure in methodology section.

Sources

Related papers