Predicting the conditions for observing the Mpemba effect
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Predicting the conditions for observing the Mpemba effect".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The study investigates the conditions for observing the Mpemba effect within one-dimensional overdamped Langevin dynamics by classifying potential landscapes based on boundaries and internal structure, establishing that boundary presence is primarily responsible for driving this counterintuitive relaxation phenomenon <ref:2606.03445#pg2> Classification of Potential Landscapes The researchers classify one-dimensional potentials based on the number of wells, their symmetry properties, and the existence of walls to determine the conditions for observing the Mpemba effect <ref:2606.03445#pg3>.
Kai: They establish that the existence of the effect is primarily driven by boundaries, either hard or soft, rather than specific internal structure such as metastability or the number of minima <ref:2606.03445#pg2> Mechanism of Relaxation Dynamics The mechanism underlying the Mpemba effect is elucidated by analyzing the spectral properties of the Fokker-Planck operator and demonstrating that its first nontrivial eigenmode's derivative acts as a Dirac delta peak in the low-temperature regime <ref:2606.03445#pg2>.
Mira: This behavior, combined with initial population dynamics induced by a wall, constitutes the interplay driving the effect <ref:2606.03445#pg2> Role of Boundary Conditions The analysis shows that for single-well systems, the Mpemba effect necessitates an asymmetric potential in the presence of at least one wall <ref:2606.03445#pg2>.
Kai: For double-well systems, the effect emerges not only in asymmetric potentials with at least one wall but also in symmetric potentials <ref:2606.03445#pg2>.
Paper summary: Kai: So this paper, "Predicting the conditions for observing the Mpemba effect," it’s looking at one-dimensional overdamped Langevin dynamics to figure out exactly what kind of potential landscape you need to see that counterintuitive relaxation happen.
Mira: Right, so they are classifying these potentials based on things like how many wells there are, if they are symmetric or asymmetric, and whether they have walls in them, and the main point is that the presence of boundaries drives this effect more than anything else.
Lev: But what does that mean for us when we think about building hardware? Are we talking about just any boundary, or some specific kind of wall structure?
Kai: They look at both hard and soft walls, and they find the existence of the Mpemba effect is primarily driven by these boundaries, not by some internal feature like how many minima there are or if it's metastable.
Mira: That’s a key distinction because if we only focused on internal structure, we might miss the real mechanism driving this relaxation phenomenon.
Lev: If the boundary is what matters most, then maybe engineering a specific type of barrier—hard or soft—is more important than just tuning the shape of the wells themselves.
Kai: Exactly. They show that for single-well systems, you need an asymmetric potential with at least one wall to see this effect happen at all.
Mira: And for double-well systems, it’s not just about having an asymmetric potential with a wall; they found it can even happen in symmetric potentials too.
Lev: That’s interesting because it broadens the scope of what we need to consider when designing these relaxation processes in hardware simulations.
Kai: And they also look at how the dynamics work, analyzing the spectral properties of the Fokker-Planck operator and showing that its first nontrivial eigenmode’s derivative acts like a Dirac delta peak in the low-temperature regime.
Mira: So it connects the big picture of dynamics to a very specific mathematical property, which then interacts with initial conditions induced by a wall to drive this effect.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, understanding that spectral behavior means we need to look at how these energy scales interact during the relaxation process in our simulations.
Kai: The paper also shows you can engineer landscapes capable of producing multistage Mpemba effects, which means you can get multiple Mpemba temperatures.
Mira: That’s a significant result because it moves beyond just finding one temperature and shows how to create systems with several different relaxation anomalies.
Lev: If we can engineer multistage effects, that implies we could potentially design systems where the initial temperature dictates which relaxation regime the system enters as it cools down.
Kai: They achieve this by constructing asymmetric landscapes where different power-law behaviors dominate at distinct energy scales, forcing population shifts between wells as the initial temperature increases.
Mira: That sounds like a recipe for controlling complexity in a single physical system, allowing us to tune the relaxation pathways across different temperature regimes.
Lev: But what about when we look at systems that don't have walls? The paper discusses the unbounded asymmetric double-well potential and finds that the second left eigenfunction has a fixed sign bias between the wells in the low-temperature regime.
Kai: Which means you can’t solve for zero derivative of that eigenfunction, so you preclude any Mpemba effect for an unbounded asymmetric double-well potential.
Mira: So it confirms that without some kind of boundary condition—even in a double-well setup—the effect seems impossible to observe under these conditions.
Lev: That makes sense because if there’s no wall, the system just settles into a fixed bias, so the temperature difference doesn't matter as much for this specific relaxation anomaly.
Kai: The paper also proves that a Mpemba temperature, we call it beta M, can be guaranteed by analyzing the energy difference between the left and right regions crossing zero because it’s continuous and its limits at zero and infinity are opposite.
Mira: That means having a wall on the shallower side guarantees at least one such Mpemba temperature even for a simple two-well system with m equals two, according to equation one-one.
Lev: So if we build a potential with an asymmetric double well and put a wall where it’s shallower, we have this guaranteed relaxation feature built in.
Kai: The paper provides a recipe for designing systems with an arbitrary number of relaxation anomalies by tuning the competition between different power-law behaviors at distinct energy scales.
Mira: That systematic approach is useful because it gives us a way to engineer potentials with any number of Mpemba temperatures we want, just by controlling those competing power laws.
Lev: That sounds like a powerful tool for designing custom energy landscapes in quantum simulators where we can precisely control the relaxation dynamics.
Kai: To wrap up, the core finding of "Predicting the conditions for observing the Mpemba effect" is that this anomalous relaxation phenomenon is fundamentally tied to the presence of boundaries, whether hard or soft, rather than to some specific internal features of the potential landscape.
Mira: It’s a unified classification across single-well and double-well potentials that really highlights how crucial boundary conditions and asymmetry are in this study.
Lev: So we’re looking at this effect not as some magical thing happening randomly, but as a predictable consequence of how we shape the energy landscape with boundaries in mind.
Conclusion: Kai: So, we're wrapping up this look at the paper "Predicting the conditions for observing the Mpemba effect."
Mira: The main thing is they figured out that you need boundaries to see this counterintuitive relaxation happen in one-dimensional dynamics.
Lev: It’s about classifying these potential landscapes based on things like how many wells there are and whether they have walls in them.
Kai: And the authors found that the presence of a wall is actually what drives the whole effect, not some specific internal structure inside the potential itself.
Mira: Yeah, so it’s less about having a certain number of minima and more about those external boundaries—hard or soft—that really matter.
Lev: That makes sense from an engineering standpoint because if you're building a system, you need to focus on those interface conditions rather than just the shape of the potential wells.
Kai: The paper also showed they can even engineer landscapes that produce multiple stages of this relaxation anomaly, meaning several different Mpemba temperatures.
Mira: That’s interesting because it means we can design systems where the cooling process itself has distinct phases driven by those boundary interactions.
Lev: If you want to build a quantum simulator where you control the temperature evolution in specific steps, this framework gives you a recipe for that construction.
Kai: The authors also pointed out some limitations, like needing to consider higher-order modes for a full treatment of the sufficient condition.
Mira: So, while they found the core mechanism tied to boundaries and asymmetry, there’s still more mathematical rigor needed before it’s perfectly finalized.
Lev: That leaves us wondering how we map those theoretical boundary conditions onto what we can actually build with physical qubits or simulators right now.
Center for Gravitational Physics and Quantum Information, Yukawa Institute for Theoretical Physics, Kyoto University · CNRS Laboratoire Ypatia des Sciences Mathématiques (LYSM), University of Rome · Laboratoire Matière et Systèmes Complexes (MSC), Université Paris Cité & CNRS
cond-mat.stat-mech
Submitted: 2026-06-02
Updated: 2026-11-11
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 78/100
The gist: The study investigates the conditions for observing the Mpemba effect within one-dimensional overdamped Langevin dynamics by classifying potential landscapes based on boundaries and internal…
Key concepts
- Mpemba effect
- A counterintuitive relaxation phenomenon observed in certain physical systems where a hotter system can relax faster than a colder one. This paper explores the specific conditions under which this effect occurs in one-dimensional overdamped Langevin dynamics.
- Potential Landscape Classification
- Researchers categorize one-dimensional potentials based on features like the number of wells, their symmetry, and the presence of walls. This classification helps determine which structural elements are necessary or sufficient for observing the Mpemba effect.
- Boundary Presence
- The study concludes that boundaries, whether hard or soft, are the fundamental drivers of the Mpemba effect. The existence of a wall is a crucial prerequisite for this phenomenon, regardless of other internal potential features like metastability.
- Multistage Effects Engineering
- The framework allows researchers to design potentials that exhibit multiple Mpemba temperatures. This is achieved by tuning how different power-law behaviors compete at various energy scales, enabling the creation of systems with an arbitrary number of relaxation anomalies.
Terminology
Summary
The study investigates the conditions for observing the Mpemba effect within one-dimensional overdamped Langevin dynamics by classifying potential landscapes based on boundaries and internal structure, establishing that boundary presence is primarily responsible for driving this counterintuitive relaxation phenomenon <ref:2606. p. 0 In this study, we investigate the conditions for the Mpemba effect within one-dimensional
overdamped Langevin dynamics. We classify the potential landscapes based on the presence of single
or double wells, their symmetry properties, and the existence of walls.Where the paper says it
Classification of Potential Landscapes
The researchers classify one-dimensional potentials based on the number of wells, their symmetry properties, and the existence of walls to determine the conditions for observing the Mpemba effect <ref:2606.03445#pg3>. They establish that the existence of the effect is primarily driven by boundaries, either hard or soft, rather than specific internal structure such as metastability or the number of minima <ref:2606. p. 0 We classify the potential landscapes based on the presence of single
or double wells, their symmetry properties, and the existence of walls. We establish that the existence
of the effect is primarily driven by the presence of boundaries, either hard or soft, rather than the
specific internal structure of the potential landscape, such as metastability or the number of minima.Where the paper says it
Mechanism of Relaxation Dynamics
The mechanism underlying the Mpemba effect is elucidated by analyzing the spectral properties of the Fokker-Planck operator and demonstrating that its first nontrivial eigenmode's derivative acts as a Dirac delta peak in the low-temperature regime <ref:2606.03445#pg2>. This behavior, combined with initial population dynamics induced by a wall, constitutes the interplay driving the effect <ref:2606. p. 0 By employing a spectral decomposition of the Fokker-Planck operator, we analyze the behavior of
the first nontrivial eigenmode and demonstrate that its derivative acts as a Dirac delta peak in the
low-temperature regime. This helps us elucidate the mechanism underlying the Mpemba effect: it
appears as the interplay between this behavior and the initial population dynamics in a non-trivial
way induced by the presence of the wall.Where the paper says it
Role of Boundary Conditions
The analysis shows that for single-well systems, the Mpemba effect necessitates an asymmetric potential in the presence of at least one wall <ref:2606.03445#pg2>. For double-well systems, the effect emerges not only in asymmetric potentials with at least one wall but also in symmetric potentials <ref:2606. p. 1 For single-well systems, the Mpemba effect necessitates an asymmetric potential in the presence of at least
one wall. Double-well systems exhibit more nuanced behavior: the effect emerges not only in asymmetric potentials with at least one wall but also in symmetric potentials. Double-well systems exhibit more nuanced behavior: the effect emerges not only in asymmetric potentials with at least one wall but also in symmetric potentials. Our analysis indicates that the presence of a wall
is generally a crucial prerequisite for the Mpemba effect,
independent of the potential’s internal structure.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Engineering Multistage Effects
The framework allows for the engineering of potential landscapes capable of producing multistage Mpemba transitions, which involves multiple Mpemba temperatures <ref:2606.03445#pg2>. This is achieved by constructing asymmetric landscapes where different power-law behaviors dominate at distinct energy scales, forcing population shifts between wells as the initial temperature increases <ref:2606. p. 4 If
the potential remains softer for x < x∗ at higher energies, a2 continues to rise. Conversely, if the potential
growth becomes steeper on the left than it is on the right
at higher energy scales, and the population shifts toward
the right of x
∗
.Where the paper says it
Absence of Effect in Unbounded Systems
For an unbounded asymmetric double-well potential, the second left eigenfunction has a fixed sign bias between the wells in the low-temperature regime, prohibiting the solution of ∂a2/∂βi = 0 and thus precluding the existence of an Mpemba effect <ref:2606.03445#pg2>. This confirms that there is no Mpemba effect for an asymmetric double-well potential if the system is unbounded <ref:2606. p. 9 In
subsection IV C, as in [72], we explore the low bath temperature limit of ℓ2, and we show how the results of the
single-well analysis can be used almost directly when the
wall is located far away from the center of the potential. In subsection IV D, we prove the absence of the Mpemba
effect confined in an asymmetric double-well potential
with an infinitely large system (this goes beyond [72] or
the previous section because the proof can be used even
for m = 2 in Eq.Where the paper says it
Boundary-Induced Anomaly
The existence of a Mpemba temperature, βM, can be guaranteed by analyzing the energy difference between the left and right regions, which must cross zero because δU(βi) is continuous and its limits at βi → 0 and βi → ∞ are opposite <ref:2606.03445#pg2>. This proves that a wall on the shallower side guarantees at least one Mpemba temperature, even for m = 2 in Eq. p. 5 We consider an even potential, which is smooth enough
(at least C
1
) around x = 0. We now introduce a hard
wall at the center of the symmetric potential and another
one at x = L+ > 0, as illustrated in Fig. In particular, it was shown that even in simple polynomial potentials, the Mpemba effect can arise due to the interplay between the spatial confinement and the temperature dependence of the probability distribution, rather
than the detailed structure of local minima. This insight
challenges the conventional intuition that associates the
arXiv:2606.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Multistage Effect Recipe
A recipe for designing systems with an arbitrary number of relaxation anomalies is provided by constructing potentials exhibiting three Mpemba temperatures by tuning the competition between different power-law behaviors at distinct energy scales <ref:2606.03445#pg2>. This systematic approach allows for engineering potentials with an arbitrary number of such Mpemba temperatures <ref:2606. p. 0 Our analysis provides a unified classification across singleand double-well potentials, highlighting the crucial role of boundary conditions and asymmetry. Furthermore, we demonstrate that this framework allows for the engineering of potential landscapes
capable of producing multistage Mpemba transitions.Where the paper says it
Conclusion
The work concludes that the existence of this anomalous relaxation phenomenon is fundamentally tied to the presence of boundaries, whether hard or soft, rather than to the specific internal features of the potential landscape <ref:2606.03445#pg2>. The analysis provides a unified classification across single- and double-well potentials, highlighting the crucial role of boundary conditions and asymmetry <ref:2606. p. 0 This helps us elucidate the mechanism underlying the Mpemba effect: it
appears as the interplay between this behavior and the initial population dynamics in a non-trivial
way induced by the presence of the wall. Our analysis provides a unified classification across singleand double-well potentials, highlighting the crucial role of boundary conditions and asymmetry.Where the paper says it
Open Questions
Several open questions remain for future exploration, including requiring a full treatment of the sufficient condition by accounting for higher-order modes like a3 <ref:2606.03445#pg2>. Additionally, a more rigorous mapping between hard and soft wall regimes would be beneficial <ref:2606.03445#pg2>. Finally, extending this wall-induced framework to higher-dimensional systems and quantum mechanical relaxation remains a promising frontier for further research <ref:2606.03445#pg2>.
Acknowledgments
The authors acknowledge the useful exchange of communications with John Bechhoefer, Siddharth Sane, Marija Vucelja and Apurba Biswas <ref:2606.03445#pg2>. HH also thanks Satoshi Takada for fruitful discussions, and was partially supported by JSPS KAKENHI Grant No. JP26K06960 <ref:2606. p. 0 In particular, it was shown that even in simple polynomial potentials, the Mpemba effect can arise due to the interplay between the spatial confinement and the temperature dependence of the probability distribution, rather
than the detailed structure of local minima. This insight
challenges the conventional intuition that associates the
arXiv:2606. In particular, it was shown that even in simple polynomial potentials, the Mpemba effect can arise due to the interplay between the spatial confinement and the temperature dependence of the probability distribution, rather
than the detailed structure of local minima. This insight
challenges the conventional intuition that associates the
arXiv:2606. In particular, it was shown that even in simple polynomial potentials, the Mpemba effect can arise due to the interplay between the spatial confinement and the temperature dependence of the probability distribution, rather
than the detailed structure of local minima. This insight
challenges the conventional intuition that associates the
arXiv:2606. Predicting the conditions for observing the Mpemba effect
Yue Liu,1 Tan Van Vu,1 Rapha¨el Ch´etrite,2 Fr´ed´eric van Wijland,3, 1 and Hisao Hayakawa1
1Center for Gravitational Physics and Quantum Information,
Yukawa Institute for Theoretical Physics, Kyoto University,
Kitashirakawa Oiwakecho, Sakyo-ku, Kyoto 606-8502, Japan
2CNRS Laboratoire Ypatia des Sciences Math´ematiques (LYSM), Piazzale Aldo Moro 5, 00185 Rome, Italy
3Laboratoire Mati`ere et Syst`emes Complexes (MSC),
Universit´e Paris Cit´e & CNRS (UMR 7057), 75013 Paris, France
The Mpemba effect, a counterintuitive phenomenon where a hotter system relaxes faster than a
colder one, has been widely observed in various nonequilibrium systems. Despite this progress, the
fundamental structural features of the energy landscape required for its emergence remain a subject
of debate.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Data Availability
The data are not publicly available upon publication <ref:2606.03445#pg2>. The data are available from the authors upon reasonable request <ref:2606.03445#pg2>.
Appendix A
In the main text, we have focused on the m > 2 case <ref:2606.03445#pg2>. This appendix briefly explains what needs to be modified when m = 2 and when there exists a hard wall <ref:2606.03445#pg2>.
Appendix B
In this Appendix, we analyze the structural properties of the first non-trivial left eigenmode l2(x) governed by the adjoint Fokker-Planck operator <ref:2606.03445#pg2>. To evaluate whether a quadratic profile l2(x) ∼ const. p. 4 (18)
This naively suggests that ℓ2(x) approaches a constant
as |x| ≃ L±(≫ 1). However, this argument breaks down for a quadratic
potential (m = 2). This asymptotic behavior holds for |x| large enough, and it can be probed
by the particle provided that the walls at ±L± are sufficiently far away. A key finding of Ref.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Appendix C
The function Dν(x) denotes the parabolic cylinder (Weber) function, which is defined as a solution of the differential equation d2y/dx2 + ν + 1/2 - x 2/4 y = 0 <ref:2606.03445#pg2>.
Appendix D
This appendix gives a fully self-contained and detailed proof that, for an asymmetric double-well potential, the second left eigenfunction l2(x) of the Fokker-Planck operator has a fixed sign bias between the left and right wells in the low-temperature regime <ref:2606.03445#pg2>.
Appendix E
This appendix provides a mathematically explicit and self-contained proof of the sign correlation between the factor V (x) − ⟨V⟩βi and the spatial location relative to the dominant probability weight <ref:2606.03445#pg2>.
Appendix F
In this Appendix, we provide a proof for the existence of the Mpemba temperature βM in an asymmetric double-well potential with a wall on the shallow side, which is on the domain [−L−, ∞] <ref:2606.03445#pg2>.
Appendix A: The m = 2 case
In this appendix we explain what needs to be modified when m = 2 and when there exists a hard wall <ref:2606.03445#pg2>.
Appendix B: Asymptotic behavior of the eigenmode l2(x) and the harmonic potential benchmark
In this Appendix, we analyze the structural properties of the first non-trivial left eigenmode l2(x) governed by the adjoint Fokker-Planck operator <ref:2606.03445#pg2>.
Appendix C: Properties of parabolic cylinder functions
The function Dν(x) denotes the parabolic cylinder (Weber) function, which is defined as a solution of the differential equation d2y/dx2 + ν + 1/2 - x 2/4 y = 0 <ref:2606.03445#pg2>.
Appendix D: Rigorous proof of the fixed sign bias of l2(x)
This appendix gives a fully self-contained and detailed proof that, for an asymmetric double-well potential, the second left eigenfunction l2(x) of the Fokker-Planck operator has a fixed sign bias between the left and right wells in the low-temperature regime <ref:2606.03445#pg2>.
Appendix E: Rigorous proof of the sign correlation of V (x) − ⟨V⟩βi
This appendix provides a mathematically explicit and self-contained proof of the sign correlation between the factor V (x) − ⟨V⟩βi and the spatial location relative to the dominant probability weight <ref:2606.03445#pg2>.
Appendix F: Proof of the existence of the Mpemba temperature
In this Appendix, we provide a proof for the existence of the Mpemba temperature βM in an asymmetric double-well potential with a wall on the shallow side, which is on the domain [−L−, ∞] <ref:2606.03445#pg2>.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
1
The AI system can be engineered to classify one-dimensional overdamped Langevin dynamics based on potential landscapes using a decision tree that categorizes systems by number of wells, parity, and boundary conditions to predict whether the Mpemba effect is guaranteed or absent.
2
The system can utilize spectral decomposition of the Fokker Planck operator, specifically analyzing the behavior of the first nontrivial eigenmode, to elucidate the mechanism underlying the Mpemba effect by demonstrating that its derivative acts as a Dirac delta peak in low-temperature regimes.
3
The AI can be used to engineer potential landscapes capable of producing multistage Mpemba transitions by applying a unified framework that highlights the crucial role of boundary conditions and asymmetry over specific internal structures like metastability.
4
The system can incorporate a mathematical definition of the Mpemba effect based on the Kullback-Leibler divergence, allowing it to quantify relaxation process distance and identify the Mpemba temperature where this distance exhibits non-monotonic behavior with respect to initial temperature.
5
The AI can perform numerical simulations of the backward Fokker Planck equation on finite intervals to evaluate overlap coefficients a2 across various bath temperatures and determine the Mpemba temperature by locating its extremum.
Abstract
The Mpemba effect, a counterintuitive phenomenon where a hotter system relaxes faster than a colder one, has been widely observed in various nonequilibrium systems. Despite this progress, the fundamental structural features of the energy landscape required for its emergence remain a subject of debate. In this study, we investigate the conditions for the Mpemba effect within one-dimensional overdamped Langevin dynamics. We classify the potential landscapes based on the presence of single or double wells, their symmetry properties, and the existence of walls. We establish that the existence of the effect is primarily driven by the presence of boundaries, either hard or soft, rather than the specific internal structure of the potential landscape, such as metastability or the number of minima. By employing a spectral decomposition of the Fokker-Planck operator, we analyze the behavior of the first nontrivial eigenmode and demonstrate that its derivative acts as a Dirac delta peak in the low-temperature regime. This helps us elucidate the mechanism underlying the Mpemba effect: it appears as the interplay between this behavior and the initial population dynamics in a non-trivial way induced by the presence of the wall. Our analysis provides a unified classification across single- and double-well potentials, highlighting the crucial role of boundary conditions and asymmetry. Furthermore, we demonstrate that this framework allows for the engineering of potential landscapes capable of producing multistage Mpemba transitions.
Sources
- Reply to Burridge & Linden: Hot water may freeze sooner than cold
- Microscopic theory of Mpemba effects and a no-Mpemba theorem for monotone many-body systems
- The Mpemba effect likes to hit a wall
- Entropy, Divergence, and Majorization in Classical and Quantum Thermodynamics
- Mpemba effect in a two-dimensional bistable potential
Related papers
- Emergent long-tail dynamics in driven magnets with dynamical frustration
- Statistical Mechanics of Dynamical System Identification
- Second law of thermodynamics in closed quantum many-body systems
- Chemical potentials from structure factors: II. Charged multi-component mixtures
- Genuine quantum scars in Floquet chaotic many-body systems
- Stochastic Thermodynamics for Autoregressive Generative Models: A Non-Markovian Perspective