Phonon-driven nodal surface superconductivity of Fermi arcs
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Phonon-driven nodal surface superconductivity of Fermi arcs".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Topological surface states of Weyl semimetals can develop a superconducting gap while bulk superconductivity remains absent in time-reversal-invariant Weyl semimetals through interactions between Fermi arc electrons and both surface and bulk phonons The combined effect of the Fermi arcs being disconnected and the weak screening of the Coulomb repulsion at the system’s surface causes nodes to appear in the superconducting gap, as observed recently by photoelectron spectroscopy experiments on PtBi2 This suggests manipulation of the Coulomb screening, e.g.
Kai: by a surface layer coating, as a pathway to engineer the critical temperature, as well as size and symmetry of the surface superconducting gap Mechanism for Nodal Superconductivity The formation of nodal superconductivity is driven by the interaction of Fermi arc electrons with both surface and bulk phonons in time-reversal-invariant Weyl semimetals The authors identify two competing pairing channels, intra-arc and inter-arc, whose relative strength is governed by the efficiency of Coulomb screening at the surface The combined effect of the Fermi arcs being disconnected and the weak screening of the Coulomb repulsion at the system’s surface causes nodes to appear in the superconducting gap Intra-arc processes naturally generate conventional nodeless pairing, whereas inter-arc processes support momentum-odd pairing When the Coulomb repulsion is weakly screened, it selectively suppresses small-momentum scattering, penalizing nodeless solutions and leaving the momentum-odd channel as the only robust pairing instability This produces nodes in the middle of the arc, in agreement with experimental observations Theoretical Framework and Hamiltonian The study employs a continuum description of time-reversal-invariant Weyl semimetals to derive a surface pairing theory where the effective interaction is generated by coupling of surface electrons to surface and bulk phonons The minimal two-band Hamiltonian describing the bulk electrons around the Γ point is given by Equation (1) The boundary condition at z = 0 requires that the matrix elements of the z-component of the current vanish on the boundary, leading to a free parameter α ∈]0, π/2] which controls the shape of isoenergetic contours in the surface Brillouin zone and localization of surface states The resulting two-dimensional band of surface states is described by Equation (2) Phonon and Coulomb Interactions The electron-phonon interaction Hamiltonian is derived from lattice strain modulation, consisting of a sum over contributions from the mentioned phonon modes λ and over the allowed frequencies The effective electron-electron interaction potential V = VC + Vp results from the superposition of Coulomb repulsion and phonon-mediated attraction The number of bulk bands grows with the transverse size L, which compensates for a 1/L suppression in the squared matrix elements, yielding a finite result The Coulomb term is given by Equation (5) Superconducting Gap and Critical Temperature The pairing Hamiltonian is formulated in BdG form as Equation (6) The gap equation is derived from this Hamiltonian, and the resulting gap equation has a specific sign structure depending on whether intra-arc or inter-arc processes are included When only intra-arc scattering is retained, the gap equation can be linearized near the critical temperature and written as a Fredholm equation of the second kind The largest eigenvalue (in absolute value) is indeed in the odd sector and negative, which denotes v(inter)min Substitution into Equation (93) yields the critical temperature (8) in the main text, with v(inter)min in the denominator Engineering Topological States The theory provides a material-independent mechanism for the emergence of nodes in the superconducting gap on Fermi arcs, consistent with recent observations in PtBi2 Surface gating or a proximitized polarizable layer can be used as active knobs to tune the value of qs in our model This provides a pathway to manipulate the Majorana hinge-states associated with the nodal i-wave superconductivity observed in PtBi2 The mechanism described here is very different from the proximity-induced surface superconductivity studied in
35–37: The theory is also relevant for other Weyl systems, e.g., for interpreting the reports of surface superconductivity in the type-II WS MoTe2 Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The theory underlines the role of the bulk degrees of freedom in establishing the surface superconductivity, which can be nodeless or nodal, depending on the scattering processes at its origin Nodal superconductivity appears as the generic outcome of pairing on disconnected surface Fermi surfaces, when both electron-phonon and competing weakly-screened long-range Coulomb interactions are present The effective interaction is maximal near the arc endpoints and suppressed around the center of the arc, reflecting the varying penetration depth of surface states into the bulk As a result, the effective pairing interaction along the arc is intrinsically anisotropic and nonuniform The authors solved the gap equation while retaining momentum-dependence of the gap along the Fermi arc and isolated two distinct pairing channels distinguished by their symmetry under inversion along the arc The Coulomb repulsion selectively suppresses small momentum transfer, destabilizing nodeless gaps when screening is inefficient and leaving the nodal solution as the dominant instability The largest gap is therefore even under reflection kx → −kx This provides a material-independent mechanism for the emergence of nodes in the superconducting gap on Fermi arcs By isolating the minimal ingredients behind nodal pairing on Fermi arcs, our results provide a general principle for surface superconductivity in Weyl semimetals and a route toward engineering the nodal structure and topological interaction-driven states
1: Where the gains come from The theory is built upon deriving an effective electron-electron interaction Hamiltonian by second-order perturbation theory using a Schrieffer-Wolff transformation The resulting phonon-mediated electron-electron interaction in the form (62) is obtained after summing over all relevant contributions The final effective interaction is cast into the simpler form (4) because phonons do not couple to such degree of freedom This approach allows for the isolation of minimal physical ingredients responsible for pairing and node formation The authors compute matrix elements involving various families of phonon modes, finding that the largest matrix elements come from R phonons These vibrations have a component along the wavevector q and are exponentially damped along z How the training signal is built The critical temperature is computed from the negative eigenvalue of largest magnitude v(intra) min appearing in the exponential, with details provided in SM V The critical temperatures in the intra- and inter-arc channels can be very different, because the former depends on the minimal eigenvalue of the intra-arc potential, hence it is very sensitive to the Coulomb interaction and can be brought to zero by inefficient screening Conversely, the inter-arc potential is largely unaffected by Coulomb repulsion The net result is visualized in Fig.
Mira: 3 Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The authors show that nodal superconductivity appears as the generic outcome of pairing on disconnected surface Fermi surfaces, when both electron-phonon and competing weakly-screened long-range Coulomb interactions are present The study synthesizes the essential phenomenology observed in PtBi2: superconductivity on the surface is largely independent from the one in the bulk and is driven by Cooper pairing of Fermi-arc states The effective interaction along the arc is intrinsically anisotropic and nonuniform The authors solved the gap equation while retaining momentum-dependence of the gap along the Fermi arc and isolated two distinct pairing channels distinguished by their symmetry under inversion along the arc This provides a material-independent mechanism for the emergence of nodes in the superconducting gap on Fermi arcs consistent with recent observations in PtBi2 The theory is also relevant for other Weyl systems, e.g., for interpreting the reports of surface superconductivity in the type-II WS MoTe2 The authors compute matrix elements involving various families of phonon modes, finding that the largest matrix elements come from R phonons These vibrations have a component along the wavevector q and are exponentially damped along z Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The study synthesizes the essential phenomenology observed in PtBi2: superconductivity on the surface is largely independent from the one in the bulk and is driven by Cooper pairing of Fermi-arc states The effective interaction along the arc is intrinsically anisotropic and nonuniform The authors solved the gap equation while retaining momentum-dependence of the gap along the Fermi arc and isolated two distinct pairing channels distinguished by their symmetry under inversion along the arc This provides a material-independent mechanism for the emergence of nodes in the superconducting gap on Fermi arcs consistent with recent observations in PtBi2 The theory is also relevant for other Weyl systems, e.g., for interpreting the reports of surface superconductivity in the type-II WS MoTe2 The authors compute matrix elements involving various families of phonon modes, finding that the largest matrix elements come from R phonons These vibrations have a component along the wavevector q and are exponentially damped along z Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The study synthesizes the essential phenomenology observed in PtBi2: superconductivity on the surface is largely independent from the one in the bulk and is driven by Cooper pairing of Fermi-arc states The effective interaction along the arc is intrinsically anisotropic and nonuniform The authors solved the gap equation while retaining momentum-dependence of the gap along the Fermi arc and isolated two distinct pairing channels distinguished by their symmetry under inversion along the arc This provides a material-independent mechanism for the emergence of nodes in the superconducting gap on Fermi arcs consistent with recent observations in PtBi2 The theory is also relevant for other Weyl systems, e.g.
Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper titled "Phonon-driven nodal surface superconductivity of Fermi arcs". It’s really interesting because it tackles how you get superconductivity on just the edges of Weyl semimetals, while the inside stays normal.
Mira: Yeah, it zeroes in on what drives that state. The authors show that this doesn't happen by itself; they suggest it comes from a specific interaction between the Fermi arc electrons and both surface and bulk phonons in time-reversal-invariant Weyl semimetals.
Lev: From an error correction standpoint, the key here is isolating those minimal ingredients, which is what they do by using a continuum description of surface Fermi arc electrons coupled to bulk phonons.
Kai: Right, so how do they break it down? The paper identifies two competing pairing channels: intra-arc and inter-arc. The strength of these channels is then controlled by how well the Coulomb repulsion is screened right at the surface.
Mira: That's a big point because if that screening isn't good enough, it selectively suppresses those small momentum transfer scattering channels, which penalizes nodeless solutions and favors momentum odd pairing instead.
Lev: From an experimental standpoint, this means we’re looking for evidence of that suppression of small-momentum transfer when we probe the system near the arc center.
Kai: The paper then shows how this competition leads directly to nodes appearing in the superconducting gap right in the middle of those Fermi arcs, which matches what some people have seen experimentally with photoelectron spectroscopy on materials like PtBi2.
Mira: It’s a synthesis of different ideas because they use the minimal physical ingredients to derive an effective electron-electron interaction Hamiltonian, which is written as Hee equals Z dk (2pi) two Z dq (2pi) two V (k, q) c † k+q c † −k−q c−kck, four <ref:2606.02371#pg1>.
Lev: That interaction potential V is just the superposition of the Coulomb repulsion and the phonon-mediated attraction, which they write as Vp(k, q) equals P omega P lambda Vlambda (k, q, omega), where lambda is summed over all phonon families and omega sums over bands.
Kai: They focus on how surface states penetrate into the bulk to reshape that superconducting gap along the arc, and they find that surface phonons are actually not the main drivers of superconductivity in this case.
Mira: The paper argues that while surface phonons carry weight because they are localized near the boundary, they don't actually cause the buildup of superconductivity; instead, it’s really about how those electron-electron interactions play out.
Title and authors: Lev: They say that based only on observing surface phonons being localized around the boundary, you would expect them to be responsible for superconductivity because their matrix elements have the largest weight, but that's not the final story they present.
Kai: So what do we get from this analysis about how those interaction potentials shape the gap along the arc? The authors isolate two distinct pairing channels distinguished by their symmetry under inversion along the arc, which is a crucial piece of information for understanding why nodes appear.
Mira: That distinction between intra-arc and inter-arc processes is what determines whether you get conventional nodeless pairing or momentum odd pairing, which we saw earlier.
Lev: If we look at the gap equation derived from this BdG form, when only intra-arc scattering is retained, the gap equation can be linearized near the critical temperature and it becomes a Fredholm equation of the second kind.
Kai: And what they find is that the largest eigenvalue in absolute value ends up being in that odd sector and negative, which denotes v inter min.
Mira: That specific result leads to calculating the critical temperature, which they put in equation eight and it involves dividing by that inter-arc minimum value.
Lev: From an engineering view for us, the critical temperatures for the intra-arc and inter-arc channels can be very different because the intra-arc channel depends on a minimal eigenvalue of that intra-arc potential, which is very sensitive to how inefficient the Coulomb screening is.
Kai: And if we look at their suggestion for improvement, they provide a material independent mechanism for nodes emerging on Fermi arcs by isolating the minimal ingredients behind nodal pairing on Fermi arcs.
Mira: They also point out that this mechanism can be used to tune the value of qs in their model, which gives us a pathway to manipulate those Majorana hinge states associated with nodal i-wave superconductivity seen in PtBi2.
Lev: For real hardware, if we want to maximize the critical temperature for intra-arc pairing, we need to focus on how decreasing that parameter qs affects the minimal eigenvalue in equation eight.
Kai: And from what I see here, this is a material independent mechanism for node emergence on Fermi arcs because it relies only on surface states and the nature of the Coulomb repulsion.
Title and authors: Mira: It’s a general principle for surface superconductivity in Weyl semimetals, and it’s relevant when interpreting reports of surface superconductivity in other systems like type-II WS MoTe2.
Lev: The paper does acknowledge that its method is based on deriving an effective electron-electron interaction Hamiltonian by second-order perturbation theory using a Schrieffer-Wolff transformation.
Kai: They also found that the largest matrix elements come from R phonons, which have a component along the wavevector q and are exponentially damped along z, which tells us something about the phonon modes involved.
Mira: So to wrap up this discussion on "Phonon-driven nodal surface superconductivity of Fermi arcs," we see that nodal superconductivity appears as a generic outcome when both electron-phonon and competing weakly screened long-range Coulomb interactions are present.
Lev: The study synthesizes the essential phenomenology observed in PtBi2, showing that the effective interaction along the arc is intrinsically anisotropic and nonuniform because of how surface states penetrate into the bulk.
Kai: They solved the gap equation while keeping track of its momentum dependence along that Fermi arc and managed to isolate those two distinct pairing channels based on their symmetry under inversion along that arc.
Mira: This provides a material independent mechanism for nodes in the superconducting gap on Fermi arcs, which is consistent with recent observations in PtBi2.
Lev: The paper also points out a limitation: the method relies on considering the chemical potential as sufficiently close to the bulk nodes so that the density of states of bulk electrons is negligible compared to the surface density of states, which is a necessary assumption for isolating those minimal physical ingredients.
Kai: So, if we think about what this means for us in terms of engineering these materials, it gives us a clear pathway toward engineering the nodal structure and those topological interaction-driven states.
Mira: It’s about understanding that the bulk degrees of freedom establish whether the surface superconductivity ends up being nodeless or nodal, depending on the scattering processes at its origin.
Lev: We need to keep in mind that this entire framework is built upon deriving an effective electron-electron interaction Hamiltonian by second-order perturbation theory using a Schrieffer-Wolff transformation.
Kai: So, we're seeing how phonon coupling and Coulomb screening work together to produce this specific kind of superconductivity on the surface of Weyl semimetals. That’s what the paper is about.
The paper's summary: Kai: So we just finished looking at that paper on Fermi arcs and how they get nodal superconductivity, and now we're going to walk through what they actually found in their summary of it.
Mira: Right, so basically, the core takeaway is that this isn't some simple bulk effect happening across the whole material. It’s specifically about those surface states sitting on the Fermi arcs developing a superconducting gap while the bulk stays normal.
Lev: And they pinpoint exactly why this happens by focusing on how those surface electrons talk to both surface and bulk phonons simultaneously in time-reversal-invariant Weyl semimetals.
Kai: Exactly, and what I find really interesting is their breakdown of the competing pairing channels—intra-arc versus inter-arc. It’s not just one mechanism; it’s a competition between them that dictates whether you end up with a nodeless or a nodal gap structure.
Mira: That competition hinges entirely on how efficiently the Coulomb repulsion is screened right at the surface. If that screening is weak, it selectively kills the small momentum transfer scattering and leaves only the odd pairing channel as stable.
Lev: From my side, that means if you want to get those nodes appearing in the gap, you have to engineer a system where that Coulomb screening just isn't good enough to stabilize a nodeless solution.
Kai: So, what this changes for us is that it gives us a material-independent way to expect these nodes on Fermi arcs, which is really consistent with what we saw experimentally in materials like PtBi2. It’s not just some fluke result; there's a specific physical mechanism at play here.
Mira: The implication for theory is that we can use this framework to understand how the bulk degrees of freedom—the phonons and the Coulomb forces—set up whether you see a nodeless or nodal surface superconductivity.
Lev: And for actual hardware, it means we can start thinking about tuning these states. They suggest using things like a surface layer coating or even just surface gating as active knobs to change that screening efficiency and therefore engineer the critical temperature and the symmetry of the superconducting gap.
Kai: That’s really exciting because it moves us from just observing what happens to actively designing it. We can use this framework to manipulate those Majorana hinge states associated with nodal i-wave superconductivity we saw before.
Mira: It sets up a clear path forward for material design, showing that controlling the interaction potential between surface electrons and the lattice vibrations is a direct route to engineering topological interaction-driven states in Weyl systems.
Lev: But there's still a bit of overhead here on real hardware, so we need to keep in mind that this theoretical model is built on assuming the chemical potential is very close to those bulk nodes for it to work cleanly.
Kai: Yeah, that’s the caveat—it’s a necessary assumption for isolating these minimal ingredients, but it tells us exactly where the theory stops working and where we need more experimental data.
Mira: So, in short, the paper synthesizes the essential phenomenology of PtBi2 and gives us a general principle for engineering nodal structure on Fermi arcs across different Weyl systems.
Lev: We'll follow up next time by looking at how this mechanism compares to other surface superconductivity models we’ve been working on.
The paper's improvements: Tom: So we're moving on to what these authors suggest are ways to actually improve this theory, now that they’ve laid out their core findings.
Kai: They’re suggesting that the mechanism for getting those nodes can be made more material-independent by isolating the absolute minimal ingredients responsible for nodal pairing on Fermi arcs.
Mira: That means they want to strip away everything extra and focus only on the surface states and how they interact with Coulomb repulsion and phonons.
Lev: From an error correction view, that’s a good thing because it simplifies things for building real hardware; you don't need to account for every single bulk band interaction when trying to stabilize those states.
Kai: They also propose using the parameter qs in their model as an active knob, suggesting that a surface layer coating or surface gating could be used to tune this value and engineer the critical temperature and symmetry of the gap.
Mira: That’s a direct pathway for material design, showing how external manipulation of the dielectric environment can directly influence those topological interaction-driven states.
Lev: If we look at that tuning idea, we need to assess how decreasing that qs value actually affects that minimal eigenvalue in equation eight before we can even start designing the coating.
Kai: And they’re pointing out a specific way to diagnose the pairing channel, suggesting AI could predict whether a material will be nodal or nodeless based on its surface Coulomb screening efficiency.
Mira: That moves us toward experimental diagnostics, because if we can measure that screening efficiency with high fidelity, we can predict the resulting superconducting symmetry before we even synthesize the material.
Lev: I think that’s where the real overhead lands for error correction; if AI tells you which way to tune it, you still have to build a system capable of achieving that precise surface environment control.
Kai: So, this isn't just abstract theory anymore; it’s giving us actionable targets for how we can manipulate the superconducting properties of Weyl semimetals using surface engineering techniques.
Mira: It really solidifies the idea that understanding these interaction potentials is key to controlling the topology of these states.
Lev: And next time, we need to look at how this material-independent mechanism compares to other models for surface superconductivity in different topological insulators and Weyl systems.
Conclusion: Kai: So we’ve got to wrap up this look at "Phonon-driven nodal surface superconductivity of Fermi arcs." It boils down to saying that nodal superconductivity on those Fermi arcs isn't just a coincidence; it’s driven by the interplay between electron-phonon interactions and how efficiently Coulomb repulsion is screened right at the surface.
Mira: Exactly, and this mechanism shows that the bulk degrees of freedom—the phonons and the Coulomb forces—are what fundamentally determine whether you end up with a nodeless or a nodal gap structure on those edges.
Lev: For us building hardware, it means we need to pay close attention to those surface conditions because they are what dictate whether we can actually achieve that critical temperature we’re aiming for.
Kai: The implications are that this gives us a material-independent principle for expecting these nodes on Fermi arcs, which is super consistent with the experimental results we've seen in PtBi2. It validates the idea that surface superconductivity isn't just some isolated bulk thing; it’s driven by what happens right at the boundary.
Mira: The real world takeaway is that we can start engineering these properties by using surface gating or thin coatings to actively tune that Coulomb screening efficiency, which is a huge step toward controlling the gap symmetry.
Lev: From an error correction point of view, if we can reliably control those surface parameters, it makes the task of stabilizing those nodal states on real hardware much more tractable.
Kai: So, "Phonon-driven nodal surface superconductivity of Fermi arcs" gives us a concrete recipe for how to approach these systems experimentally. It’s about understanding the physics at the boundary.
Mira: And that understanding is what allows us to move beyond just observing phenomena and start designing materials with specific superconducting properties.
Lev: We can't ignore the caveats, though; remember that this whole framework relies on assuming the chemical potential is very close to those bulk nodes for it to work cleanly, which tells us where our next experimental efforts should focus.
Kai: It’s a lot of material science distilled into a clear picture of how surface physics dictates topological states.
Mira: Exactly, and we’ll take all this insight from the paper and use it as we look at the next set of papers on directly transitioning between different topological phases.
Leibniz Institute for Solid State and Materials Research · Department of Mathematics, City St George’s, University of London · Würzburg-Dresden Cluster of Excellence ctd.qmat
cond-mat.supr-con
Submitted: 2026-06-01
Updated: 2026-11-06
Comments: 19 pages, 4 figures; v2: accepted version, including Supplemental Material
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 92/100
The gist: Topological surface states of Weyl semimetals can develop a superconducting gap while bulk superconductivity remains absent in time-reversal-invariant Weyl semimetals through interactions between…
Key concepts
- Fermi Arcs
- These are disconnected segments of the Fermi surface in Weyl semimetals. The paper shows that superconductivity on these arcs is driven by pairing between these states, which is key to understanding nodal superconductivity.
- Intra-arc vs. Inter-arc Pairing
- There are two competing pairing channels: intra-arc and inter-arc. Intra-arc processes favor conventional nodeless pairing, while inter-arc processes support momentum-odd (nodal) pairing. The relative strength depends on how effectively the surface Coulomb repulsion is screened.
- Coulomb Screening Efficiency
- This refers to how well the surface of the material screens long-range Coulomb repulsion. Weak screening allows for momentum-odd pairing, which leads to nodes in the superconducting gap, a phenomenon observed experimentally.
Terminology
Summary
Topological surface states of Weyl semimetals can develop a superconducting gap while bulk superconductivity remains absent in time-reversal-invariant Weyl semimetals through interactions between Fermi arc electrons and both surface and bulk phonons The combined effect of the Fermi arcs being disconnected and the weak screening of the Coulomb repulsion at the system’s surface causes nodes to appear in the superconducting gap, as observed recently by photoelectron spectroscopy experiments on PtBi2 This suggests manipulation of the Coulomb screening, e. p. 0g. by a surface layer coating, as a pathway to engineer the critical temperature, as well as size and symmetry of the surface superconducting gap
Mechanism for Nodal Superconductivity
The formation of nodal superconductivity is driven by the interaction of Fermi arc electrons with both surface and bulk phonons in time-reversal-invariant Weyl semimetals The authors identify two competing pairing channels, intra-arc and inter-arc, whose relative strength is governed by the efficiency of Coulomb screening at the surface The combined effect of the Fermi arcs being disconnected and the weak screening of the Coulomb repulsion at the system’s surface causes nodes to appear in the superconducting gap Intra-arc processes naturally generate conventional nodeless pairing, whereas inter-arc processes support momentum-odd pairing When the Coulomb repulsion is weakly screened, it selectively suppresses small-momentum scattering, penalizing nodeless solutions and leaving the momentum-odd channel as the only robust pairing instability This produces nodes in the middle of the arc, in agreement with experimental observations
Theoretical Framework and Hamiltonian
The study employs a continuum description of time-reversal-invariant Weyl semimetals to derive a surface pairing theory where the effective interaction is generated by coupling of surface electrons to surface and bulk phonons The minimal two-band Hamiltonian describing the bulk electrons around the Γ point is given by Equation (1) The boundary condition at z = 0 requires that the matrix elements of the z-component of the current vanish on the boundary, leading to a free parameter α ∈]0, π/2] which controls the shape of isoenergetic contours in the surface Brillouin zone and localization of surface states The resulting two-dimensional band of surface states is described by Equation (2)
Phonon and Coulomb Interactions
The electron-phonon interaction Hamiltonian is derived from lattice strain modulation, consisting of a sum over contributions from the mentioned phonon modes λ and over the allowed frequencies The effective electron-electron interaction potential V = VC + Vp results from the superposition of Coulomb repulsion and phonon-mediated attraction The number of bulk bands grows with the transverse size L, which compensates for a 1/L suppression in the squared matrix elements, yielding a finite result The Coulomb term is given by Equation (5)
Superconducting Gap and Critical Temperature
The pairing Hamiltonian is formulated in BdG form as Equation (6) The gap equation is derived from this Hamiltonian, and the resulting gap equation has a specific sign structure depending on whether intra-arc or inter-arc processes are included When only intra-arc scattering is retained, the gap equation can be linearized near the critical temperature and written as a Fredholm equation of the second kind The largest eigenvalue (in absolute value) is indeed in the odd sector and negative, which denotes v(inter)min Substitution into Equation (93) yields the critical temperature (8) in the main text, with v(inter)min in the denominator
Engineering Topological States
The theory provides a material-independent mechanism for the emergence of nodes in the superconducting gap on Fermi arcs, consistent with recent observations in PtBi2 Surface gating or a proximitized polarizable layer can be used as active knobs to tune the value of qs in our model This provides a pathway to manipulate the Majorana hinge-states associated with the nodal i-wave superconductivity observed in PtBi2 The mechanism described here is very different from the proximity-induced surface superconductivity studied in [35–37] The theory is also relevant for other Weyl systems, e.g., for interpreting the reports of surface superconductivity in the type-II WS MoTe2
Pruning redundant reasoning tokens
The theory underlines the role of the bulk degrees of freedom in establishing the surface superconductivity, which can be nodeless or nodal, depending on the scattering processes at its origin Nodal superconductivity appears as the generic outcome of pairing on disconnected surface Fermi surfaces, when both electron-phonon and competing weakly-screened long-range Coulomb interactions are present The effective interaction is maximal near the arc endpoints and suppressed around the center of the arc, reflecting the varying penetration depth of surface states into the bulk As a result, the effective pairing interaction along the arc is intrinsically anisotropic and nonuniform The authors solved the gap equation while retaining momentum-dependence of the gap along the Fermi arc and isolated two distinct pairing channels distinguished by their symmetry under inversion along the arc The Coulomb repulsion selectively suppresses small momentum transfer, destabilizing nodeless gaps when screening is inefficient and leaving the nodal solution as the dominant instability The largest gap is therefore even under reflection kx → −kx This provides a material-independent mechanism for the emergence of nodes in the superconducting gap on Fermi arcs By isolating the minimal ingredients behind nodal pairing on Fermi arcs, our results provide a general principle for surface superconductivity in Weyl semimetals and a route toward engineering the nodal structure and topological interaction-driven states [1]
Where the gains come from
The theory is built upon deriving an effective electron-electron interaction Hamiltonian by second-order perturbation theory using a Schrieffer-Wolff transformation The resulting phonon-mediated electron-electron interaction in the form (62) is obtained after summing over all relevant contributions The final effective interaction is cast into the simpler form (4) because phonons do not couple to such degree of freedom This approach allows for the isolation of minimal physical ingredients responsible for pairing and node formation The authors compute matrix elements involving various families of phonon modes, finding that the largest matrix elements come from R phonons These vibrations have a component along the wavevector q and are exponentially damped along z
How the training signal is built
The critical temperature is computed from the negative eigenvalue of largest magnitude v(intra) min appearing in the exponential, with details provided in SM V The critical temperatures in the intra- and inter-arc channels can be very different, because the former depends on the minimal eigenvalue of the intra-arc potential, hence it is very sensitive to the Coulomb interaction and can be brought to zero by inefficient screening Conversely, the inter-arc potential is largely unaffected by Coulomb repulsion The net result is visualized in Fig. 3
The authors show that nodal superconductivity appears as the generic outcome of pairing on disconnected surface Fermi surfaces, when both electron-phonon and competing weakly-screened long-range Coulomb interactions are present The study synthesizes the essential phenomenology observed in PtBi2: superconductivity on the surface is largely independent from the one in the bulk and is driven by Cooper pairing of Fermi-arc states The effective interaction along the arc is intrinsically anisotropic and nonuniform The authors solved the gap equation while retaining momentum-dependence of the gap along the Fermi arc and isolated two distinct pairing channels distinguished by their symmetry under inversion along the arc This provides a material-independent mechanism for the emergence of nodes in the superconducting gap on Fermi arcs consistent with recent observations in PtBi2 The theory is also relevant for other Weyl systems, e.g., for interpreting the reports of surface superconductivity in the type-II WS MoTe2 The authors compute matrix elements involving various families of phonon modes, finding that the largest matrix elements come from R phonons These vibrations have a component along the wavevector q and are exponentially damped along z
The study synthesizes the essential phenomenology observed in PtBi2: superconductivity on the surface is largely independent from the one in the bulk and is driven by Cooper pairing of Fermi-arc states The effective interaction along the arc is intrinsically anisotropic and nonuniform The authors solved the gap equation while retaining momentum-dependence of the gap along the Fermi arc and isolated two distinct pairing channels distinguished by their symmetry under inversion along the arc This provides a material-independent mechanism for the emergence of nodes in the superconducting gap on Fermi arcs consistent with recent observations in PtBi2 The theory is also relevant for other Weyl systems, e.g., for interpreting the reports of surface superconductivity in the type-II WS MoTe2 The authors compute matrix elements involving various families of phonon modes, finding that the largest matrix elements come from R phonons These vibrations have a component along the wavevector q and are exponentially damped along z
The study synthesizes the essential phenomenology observed in PtBi2: superconductivity on the surface is largely independent from the one in the bulk and is driven by Cooper pairing of Fermi-arc states The effective interaction along the arc is intrinsically anisotropic and nonuniform The authors solved the gap equation while retaining momentum-dependence of the gap along the Fermi arc and isolated two distinct pairing channels distinguished by their symmetry under inversion along the arc This provides a material-independent mechanism for the emergence of nodes in the superconducting gap on Fermi arcs consistent with recent observations in PtBi2 The theory is also relevant for other Weyl systems, e.g.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI can predict whether a topological surface superconductor (TSSC) material will exhibit nodal or nodeless superconductivity based on a material's Coulomb screening efficiency at its surface, as this is governed by
the efficiency of Coulomb screening at the surface.
-
Improved AI can design materials with tunable superconducting properties by suggesting modifications to the dielectric environment, such as
a surface layer coating
orsurface gating,
to engineer the critical temperature and symmetry of the superconducting gap. -
Improved AI can diagnose whether a reported surface superconductivity in a Weyl semimetal is likely driven by intra-arc or inter-arc pairing channels by analyzing scattering processes, as
intra-arc processes naturally generate conventional nodeless pairing, whereas interarc processes support momentum-odd pairing.
-
Improved AI can screen potential surface engineering strategies for maximizing the critical temperature of intra-arc pairing by assessing how
decreasing the value of qs
affects the minimal eigenvalue in equation (8). -
Improved AI can classify the parity eigenvalue of a gap solution on Fermi arcs by determining if it is even or odd, which is crucial for understanding whether a solution satisfies
the condition 1 = -2v(j)intra ln 2e gamma pi beta homegaD
or1 = 2varjinter ln 2e gamma pi beta homegaD.
Sources
- Robust two-dimensional surface superconductivity and vortex lattice in the Weyl semimetal $\gamma$-PtBi$_2$
- Phonon-mediated intrinsic topological superconductivity in Fermi arcs
- Mechanism for Nodal Topological Superconductivity on PtBi$_2$ Surface
- Three Lectures On Topological Phases Of Matter
Related papers
- Microscopic Origin and Josephson Signatures of d-Wave Superconductivity in Monolayer FeSe
- Excitonic-Superconducting Coexistence and Emergent Nematic Superconductivity Driven by Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking
- Quantum phase fluctuations quench chiral superconductivity in twisted overdoped cuprate bilayers
- Interface-Confined Superconductivity with Thickness-Independent Superfluid Stiffness in (Pb,Sn)Te/FeTe Bilayers
- Kinetic Lifshitz invariants and dynamics of nonreciprocal fluctuations in superconductors
- Steering and Local Tunneling Signatures of Majorana Corner Modes in Altermagnetic Josephson Junctions