Navigating Independence: A Survey of Visually Impaired People's Experiences and Needs

arXiv:2606.00025 · cs.HC · Submitted 2026-04-15 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Computer Science. The day in computer science: software, systems and theory on arXiv.

Tom: We're looking at the paper: "Navigating Independence: A Survey of Visually Impaired People's Experiences and Needs".

Jane: Here's the gist of the paper. Independent navigation in unfamiliar environments remains a major challenge for blind and visually impaired individuals, despite the availability of assistive technologies <ref:2606.00025#pg2> The survey presents results from a fully accessible online survey investigating navigation experiences, challenges, and technology preferences among people with visual impairments worldwide <ref:2606.00025#pg4> Our results indicate that smartphone-based applications are the most used digital navigation aids, while a substantial proportion of participants report not using any assistive navigation technology due to cost, accessibility, or usability barriers <ref:2606.00025#pg2> Participants reported persistent difficulties in obstacle detection, wayfinding, and navigation in complex environments <ref:2606.00025#pg2> Survey Methodology The study investigates the experiences, challenges, and preferences of visually impaired individuals in unfamiliar environments through a fully accessible online questionnaire <ref:2606.00025#pg4> Accessibility was a central design requirement, and the questionnaire was tested and refined with input from a visually impaired user <ref:2606.00025#pg4> The questionnaire consisted of 17 closed-ended questions (12 single-choice and 5 multiple-selection) and two open-ended questions covering personal background, navigation experiences, and preferences <ref:2606.00025#pg4> Conditional branching was applied such that follow-up questions were shown only to participants who reported using digital assistive navigation technologies <ref:2606.00025#pg4> Eligibility was based on self-identification as blind or visually impaired, verified through early questions on vision status, onset, and severity <ref:2606.00025#pg4> Survey responses were cleaned by removing duplicate and incomplete submissions <ref:2606.00025#pg4> All questions were required, resulting in a dataset without missing values Responses were analyzed using quantitative methods for closed-ended questions and inductive thematic analysis for open-ended responses Given the exploratory nature of the study and the relatively small sample size, the analysis focuses on descriptive statistics Participant Demographics and Technology Use Participants represented diverse geographic regions and demographic groups, with the largest proportion from Western Europe and North America, followed by Africa and Eastern Europe The sample included a broad age distribution and a balanced representation of acquired and congenital visual impairment, with most participants reporting severe impairment or total blindness Table 1 shows the demographic breakdown of the 42 participants (Table 1 details demographics) Participants with total blindness and moderate impairment showed higher rates of nonuse (approximately one third), whereas no nonuse was observed among participants with mild impairment Among users, usage was primarily oriented toward outdoor or mixed environments Satisfaction levels varied, and many participants reported insufficient feedback, particularly in environments with dense obstacles Navigation Challenges and Preferences Participants reported frequent challenges related to route finding, landmark identification, and obstacle detection Table 3 shows that the most reported challenge was Finding indoor landmarks (52.9%) Obstacle Height at head level was reported most often (76.2%) Beyond device form, participants expressed preferences regarding how navigation information should be delivered Audio and multimodal feedback were the preferred options, whereas tactile-only and simple auditory cues were selected less often Table 5 shows that Wearable devices were favored (61.9%) Hands and arms was the most preferred Tactile Location (57.1%) Discussion and Implications The findings highlight persistent challenges faced by visually impaired individuals in wayfinding, spatial awareness, and obstacle avoidance These challenges likely arise because real-world environments contain complex and multi-level obstacles that are not fully captured by current assistive technologies or traditional mobility aids Outdoor environments remain especially challenging, contradicting current research attention on indoor navigation A clear gap is observed between the availability of assistive navigation technologies and their actual use This pattern reflects practical barriers reported by participants, including limited access, high cost, and the difficulty of obtaining suitable technologies It also highlights environmental constraints that may vary across countries, as well as reliance on alternative navigation strategies The paper presents the results of a fully accessible online survey examining navigation experiences, challenges, and preferences among visually impaired individuals They further reveal a gap between current technology use and user preferences, with participants often relying on available handheld solutions while expressing a clear preference for wearable, hands-free systems Participants emphasized ease of use, affordability, obstacle avoidance, and access to route information Future systems should support flexible device form factors and interaction modalities, prioritize safety and cognitive simplicity, and provide low-effort, adaptive, and multimodal feedback Affordability and practical accessibility should be treated as central design requirements Evaluation should extend beyond technical metrics to include usability, reliability, and real-world effectiveness The study contributes structured evidence that can inform future assistive navigation research and development REFERENCES Zimmermann-Janschitz, S., Mandl, B., Dückelmann, A.: Clustering the Mobility Needs of Persons with Visual Impairment or Legal Blindness.

Tom: Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board.

Jane: 2650, 66–73 (2017) Hara, K., Azenkot, S., Campbell, M., Bennett, C.L., Le, V., Pannella, S., Moore, R., Minckler, K., Ng, R.H., Froehlich, J.E.: Improving Public Transit Accessibility for Blind Riders by Crowdsourcing Bus Stop Landmark Locations with Google Street View: An Extended Analysis.

Tom: ACM Transactions on Accessible Computing 6, 1–23 (2015) Brunet, L., Darses, F., Auvray, M.: Strategies and needs of blind pedestrians during urban navigation.

Paper summary: Jane: So, this paper sets out to look at the navigation experiences and challenges faced by people with visual impairments globally through a very accessible online survey. Tom It’s a big effort because they made sure the questionnaire was tested with someone who is visually impaired to make sure it actually works for them. Lu I think what's interesting here is that they surveyed people from all over, trying to get diverse geographic and demographic groups in there, which is usually hard for these kinds of studies. Meng Diversity matters when you're shipping a product; if you only test on one group, the whole thing could break down later.

Tom: The key finding they pulled out right away is that smartphone-based applications are the most common digital navigation tools people use. Jane That’s one part of it, but what really stood out was that a lot of participants said they don't actually use any assistive navigation technology at all. Lu They cited cost, accessibility issues, and usability barriers as the reasons why people skip using these tools.

Tom: And then they detailed the specific difficulties participants face on the ground: persistent problems with obstacle detection, wayfinding, and just general navigation in complex settings. Jane It sounds like a big disconnect between what technology is available and what people actually need or are willing to use it for daily tasks.

Meng: From an engineering standpoint, that gap between availability and actual use tells me that the barriers aren't just about having software; they's about real-world factors like how easy it is to get the right device or if it fits their physical situation. Lu It really highlights that existing research often focuses on the technical side of making a system, but this survey grounds it in what actually happens when someone is trying to navigate an actual environment.

Tom: So, they're showing us that we need to look beyond just building a cool piece of software and consider the whole context of how people live and use it. Jane It sets up a lot of interesting questions about how we design these systems moving forward, because the current reality isn't matching what the ideal conditions might suggest.

Conclusion: Jane: So, looking at "Navigating Independence: A Survey of Visually Impaired People's Experiences and Needs," the authors are essentially summarizing a massive global effort to map out how people actually navigate their lives right now. Tom They show us that while we have these assistive tools like smartphone apps, there's still a real struggle with finding landmarks and avoiding obstacles in complex environments.

Lu: The paper points out that what users use in practice isn't always what they would prefer under perfect conditions; things like cost and ease of use really influence if a system gets used every day <ref:2606.00025#pg2>. Tom It’s about making sure the research we do, especially the technical stuff, is connected to the actual user experience in those real-world situations.

Meng: What this means for deployment is that if we design a system, it needs to be affordable and incredibly simple to use on a daily basis; if it's too complicated or too expensive, people won't adopt it <ref:2606.00025#pg2>. Jane And they suggest that future systems should focus on flexible device forms and multimodal feedback—meaning not just audio, but maybe incorporating tactile information as well.

Tom: So the implication is that we need to treat affordability and practical accessibility as central design requirements, not just a nice-to-have feature. Lu They provide structured evidence for this because they gathered data from people worldwide about their specific navigation needs and preferences <ref:2606.00025#pg4>.

Jane: It’s a call to action for researchers and developers to stop focusing only on the technical metrics of a system and start paying close attention to how that system actually helps or hinders someone trying to move through their day.

Banafshe Marziyeh Bamdad, Manuel Günther, Alireza Darvishy

Department of Informatics, University of Zurich, Switzerland · Institute of Computer Science, Zurich University of Applied Sciences, Switzerland

cs.HC

Submitted: 2026-04-15

Updated: 2026-04-15

Comments: 8 pages, 2 figures, 6 Tables. This paper has been accepted for presentation at the ICCHP 2026 conference (International Conference on Computers Helping People with Special Needs)

Journal ref: ICCHP 2026 Open Access Compendium (2026), pp. 197-205

Code: https://github.com/banafshebamdad/PhD-Survey-Visually-Impaired

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 79/100

The gist: Independent navigation in unfamiliar environments remains a major challenge for blind and visually impaired individuals…

Key concepts

Digital Navigation Aids
These are the technologies people with visual impairments use for guidance, such as smartphone applications. The study found that smartphone apps are the most popular tools used for navigation among participants.
Navigation Challenges
Participants frequently faced difficulties finding their way, identifying landmarks, and detecting obstacles in complex environments. Indoor landmark identification and obstacle height at head level were reported as the most significant challenges.
Technology Preferences
When considering how navigation information should be delivered, participants preferred audio and multimodal feedback over tactile-only or simple auditory cues. Wearable devices were also favored for their form factor.

Terminology

Summary

Independent navigation in unfamiliar environments remains a major challenge for blind and visually impaired individuals, despite the availability of assistive technologies <ref:2606. p. 000025#pg2> The survey presents results from a fully accessible online survey investigating navigation experiences, challenges, and technology preferences among people with visual impairments worldwide <ref:2606. p. 000025#pg4> Our results indicate that smartphone-based applications are the most used digital navigation aids, while a substantial proportion of participants report not using any assistive navigation technology due to cost, accessibility, or usability barriers <ref:2606. p. 000025#pg2> Participants reported persistent difficulties in obstacle detection, wayfinding, and navigation in complex environments <ref:2606. p. 000025#pg2>

Survey Methodology

The study investigates the experiences, challenges, and preferences of visually impaired individuals in unfamiliar environments through a fully accessible online questionnaire <ref:2606.00025#pg4> Accessibility was a central design requirement, and the questionnaire was tested and refined with input from a visually impaired user <ref:2606. p. 100025#pg4> The questionnaire consisted of 17 closed-ended questions (12 single-choice and 5 multiple-selection) and two open-ended questions covering personal background, navigation experiences, and preferences <ref:2606. p. 100025#pg4> Conditional branching was applied such that follow-up questions were shown only to participants who reported using digital assistive navigation technologies <ref:2606. p. 100025#pg4> Eligibility was based on self-identification as blind or visually impaired, verified through early questions on vision status, onset, and severity <ref:2606. p. 100025#pg4> Survey responses were cleaned by removing duplicate and incomplete submissions <ref:2606. p. 200025#pg4> All questions were required, resulting in a dataset without missing values Responses were analyzed using quantitative methods for closed-ended questions and inductive thematic analysis for open-ended responses Given the exploratory nature of the study and the relatively small sample size, the analysis focuses on descriptive statistics

Participant Demographics and Technology Use

Participants represented diverse geographic regions and demographic groups, with the largest proportion from Western Europe and North America, followed by Africa and Eastern Europe The sample included a broad age distribution and a balanced representation of acquired and congenital visual impairment, with most participants reporting severe impairment or total blindness Table 1 shows the demographic breakdown of the 42 participants

(Table 1 details demographics)

Participants with total blindness and moderate impairment showed higher rates of nonuse (approximately one third), whereas no nonuse was observed among participants with mild impairment Among users, usage was primarily oriented toward outdoor or mixed environments Satisfaction levels varied, and many participants reported insufficient feedback, particularly in environments with dense obstacles

Navigation Challenges and Preferences

Participants reported frequent challenges related to route finding, landmark identification, and obstacle detection Table 3 shows that the most reported challenge was Finding indoor landmarks (52.9%) Obstacle Height at head level was reported most often (76. p. 22%) Beyond device form, participants expressed preferences regarding how navigation information should be delivered Audio and multimodal feedback were the preferred options, whereas tactile-only and simple auditory cues were selected less often Table 5 shows that Wearable devices were favored (61. p. 39%) Hands and arms was the most preferred Tactile Location (57. p. 41%)

Discussion and Implications

The findings highlight persistent challenges faced by visually impaired individuals in wayfinding, spatial awareness, and obstacle avoidance These challenges likely arise because real-world environments contain complex and multi-level obstacles that are not fully captured by current assistive technologies or traditional mobility aids Outdoor environments remain especially challenging, contradicting current research attention on indoor navigation A clear gap is observed between the availability of assistive navigation technologies and their actual use This pattern reflects practical barriers reported by participants, including limited access, high cost, and the difficulty of obtaining suitable technologies It also highlights environmental constraints that may vary across countries, as well as reliance on alternative navigation strategies

Conclusion

The paper presents the results of a fully accessible online survey examining navigation experiences, challenges, and preferences among visually impaired individuals They further reveal a gap between current technology use and user preferences, with participants often relying on available handheld solutions while expressing a clear preference for wearable, hands-free systems Participants emphasized ease of use, affordability, obstacle avoidance, and access to route information Future systems should support flexible device form factors and interaction modalities, prioritize safety and cognitive simplicity, and provide low-effort, adaptive, and multimodal feedback Affordability and practical accessibility should be treated as central design requirements Evaluation should extend beyond technical metrics to include usability, reliability, and real-world effectiveness The study contributes structured evidence that can inform future assistive navigation research and development

REFERENCES

Zimmermann-Janschitz, S., Mandl, B. p. 6, Dückelmann, A. p. 6: Clustering the Mobility Needs of Persons with Visual Impairment or Legal Blindness. p. 6 Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board. p. 6 2650, 66–73 (2017)

Hara, K., Azenkot, S. p. 6, Campbell, M. p. 6, Bennett, C. p. 6L., Le, V., Pannella, S. p. 6, Moore, R. p. 6, Minckler, K. p. 6, Ng, R.H., Froehlich, J. p. 6E.: Improving Public Transit Accessibility for Blind Riders by Crowdsourcing Bus Stop Landmark Locations with Google Street View: An Extended Analysis. p. 6 ACM Transactions on Accessible Computing 6, 1–23 (2015)

Brunet, L., Darses, F. p. 6, Auvray, M. p. 6: Strategies and needs of blind pedestrians during urban navigation. p. 6 Le travail humain. p. 6 81, 141–171 (2018)

El-Taher, F.E.-Z., Miralles-Pechuán, L. p. 6, Courtney, J. p. 6, Millar, K. p. 6, Smith, C. p. 6, Mckeever, S. p. 6: A survey on outdoor navigation applications for people with visual impairments. p. 6 IEEE Access. p. 6 11, 14647–14666 (2023)

Golledge, R.G., Marston, J. p. 6R., Costanzo, C. p. 6M.: Attitudes of Visually Impaired Persons toward the Use of Public Transportation. p. 6 Journal of Visual Impairment & Blindness. p. 6 p. 6 91, 446–459 (1997)

Parkin, J., Smithies, N. p. 6: Accounting for the Needs of Blind and Visually Impaired People in Public Realm Design. p. 6 Journal of Urban Design. p. 6 17, 135–149 (2012)

Wong, S.: Traveling with blindness: A qualitative space-time approach to understanding visual impairment and urban mobility. p. 6 Health & Place. p. 6 49, 85–92 (2018)

Jeamwatthanachai, W., Wald, M., Wills, G. p. 6: Indoor navigation by blind people: Behaviors and challenges in unfamiliar spaces and buildings. p. 6 British Journal of Visual Impairment. p. 6 37, 140–153 (2606. p. 6019)

Papadopoulos, K., Charitakis, K. p. 6, Koustriava, E. p. 6, Kouroupetroglou, G. p. 6, Stiefelhagen, R. p. 6 p. 6, Stylianidis, E. p. 6, Gumus, S. p. 6S.: Environmental Information Required by Individuals with Visual Impairments Who Use Orientation and Mobility Aids to Navigate Campuses. p. 6 Journal of Visual Impairment & Blindness. 114, 263–276 (2020)

Müller, K., Engel, C. p. 6, Loitsch, C. p. 6, Stiefelhagen, R., Weber, G. p. 6: Traveling More Independently: A Study on the Diverse Needs and Challenges of People with Visual or Mobility Impairments in Unfamiliar Indoor Environments. p. 6 ACM Transactions on Accessible Computing. p. 6 15, 1–44 (2022)

Williams, M.A., Hurst, A. p. 6, Kane, S.K.: “Pray before you step out”: describing personal and situational blind navigation behaviors. p. 6 In: Proceedings of the 15th International ACM SIGACCESS Conference on Computers and Accessibility. p. 6 pp. 1–8. ACM, Bellevue Washington (2013)

Chaudary, B., Pohjolainen, S. p. 6, Aziz, S., Arhippainen, L. p. 6, Pulli, P. p. 6: Teleguidance-based remote navigation assistance for visually impaired and blind people—usability and user experience. p. 6 Virtual Reality. p. 6 27, 141–158 (2023)

Plikynas, D., Žvironas, A. p. 7, Budrionis, A. p. 7, Gudauskis, M. p. 7: Indoor navigation systems for visually impaired persons: Mapping the features of existing technologies to user needs. p. 7 Sensors. 20, 636 (2020)

Barontini, F., Catalano, M. p. 7G., Pallottino, L. p. 7, Leporini, B. p. 7, Bianchi, M. p. 7: Integrating wearable haptics and obstacle avoidance for the visually impaired in indoor navigation: A usercentered approach. p. 7 IEEE transactions on haptics. p. 7 14, 109–122 (2020)

Braun, V., Clarke, V. p. 7: Using thematic analysis in psychology. p. 7 Qualitative Research in Psychology. p. 7 3, 77–101 (2006)

Agresti, A., Coull, B. p. 7A.: Approximate is Better than “Exact” for Interval Estimation of Binomial Proportions. p. 7 The American Statistician. p. 7 52, 119–126 (1998)

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The paper reviews related work exploring navigation for blind and visually impaired individuals across outdoor and indoor settings Prior work has focused on outdoor navigation, highlighting challenges related to orientation, environmental awareness, and infrastructure accessibility Indoor navigation has also received considerable attention, especially in unfamiliar or structured environments such as public buildings and campuses Several studies have examined navigation behavior across different contexts and the use of assistive technologies in everyday scenarios

How the training signal is built

The survey methodology involved a fully accessible online questionnaire The questionnaire consisted of 17 closed-ended questions and two open-ended questions covering personal background, navigation experiences, and preferences Conditional branching was applied such that follow-up questions were shown only to participants who reported using digital assistive navigation technologies Eligibility was based on self-identification as blind or visually impaired, verified through early questions on vision status, onset, and severity Survey responses were cleaned by removing duplicate and incomplete submissions All questions were required, resulting in a dataset without missing values Responses were analyzed using quantitative methods for closed-ended questions and inductive thematic analysis for open-ended responses Given the exploratory nature of the study and the relatively small sample size, the analysis focuses on descriptive statistics

Where the gains come from

The results indicate that smartphone-based applications are the most used digital navigation aids A substantial proportion of participants report not using any digital navigation tools due to cost, accessibility, or usability barriers Participants reported persistent difficulties in obstacle detection, wayfinding, and navigation in complex environments Despite the use of these technologies, participants reported frequent challenges related to route finding, landmark identification, and obstacle detection Head-level obstacles were reported most often (76.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Wearable navigation systems should prioritize adaptability to real-world conditions by improving their ability to detect and communicate spatial information across different obstacle levels beyond ground-level hazards. This will address the finding that real-world environments contain complex and multi-level obstacles that are not fully captured by current assistive technologies or traditional mobility aids.

  2. AI systems should incorporate multimodal interaction strategies that respond to both user needs and situational constraints, supporting diverse feedback modalities like audio, tactile, and multimodal cues as preferred by users. This addresses the finding that no single feedback mechanism is universally effective and future systems should incorporate adaptable and multimodal interaction strategies.

  3. Navigation algorithms must be optimized for low mental load and low physical effort rather than strictly adhering to shortest route or fastest travel time metrics. This aligns with the user preference for features like Low mental load 22 (52.4%) and Low physical effort 20 (47.6%) over traditional efficiency metrics.

  4. Systems must enhance obstacle detection and feedback responsiveness, specifically focusing on mitigating the reported issues where users indicated limited time to react to obstacles, which suggests current systems may not deliver timely and actionable information in safety-critical situations.

Related papers