Underdetermination in the Quantum-Mechanical Bootstrap with Mixed Functional Operators

arXiv:2605.30536 · hep-th, hep-lat, quant-ph · Submitted 2026-05-28 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Underdetermination in the Quantum-Mechanical Bootstrap with Mixed Functional Operators".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The bootstrap method for quantum mechanics suffers from an ambiguity problem when dealing with potentials containing different types of functions like polynomial and exponential terms, which fails to yield correct energy spectra.

Kai: This issue arises because the method cannot distinguish between operators differing by arbitrary real constants, thereby leading to a failure to reproduce the spectrum for mixed potentials.

Mira: The paper proposes three resolutions to this ambiguity problem.

Kai: Ambiguity Problem in Mixed Potentials The bootstrap method fails to reproduce the energy spectrum of a Hamiltonian with a mixed potential because it cannot distinguish between operators differing by arbitrary real constants, such as distinguishing between the operators ˆx and ˆx − cx.

Paper summary: Mira: So looking at "Underdetermination in the Quantum-Mechanical Bootstrap with Mixed Functional Operators", they show that the method breaks down when potentials mix different function types like polynomials and exponentials <ref:2605.30536#pg1>.

Kai: Right. It really comes down to an ambiguity problem where the method can't tell those operators apart, which messes up the energy spectrum it produces >

Lev: This means if we use this tool on a system with mixed terms, our simulations need to be much more careful about what assumptions we're making about those operators to get any reliable results on real hardware <ref:2605.30536#pg1>.

Mira: The authors propose that imposing an additional positivity condition as a way to isolate those allowed regions and get the energy spectrum back, which they say works numerically for the mixed potential <ref:2605.30536#pg2>.

Kai: But they also flag that this fix isn't guaranteed to work in all situations, and the resulting allowed regions aren't as sharp as you might expect <ref:2605.30536#pg1>.

Lev: That lack of sharpness is a big deal for error correction overhead because we need precise bounds to define our error correction codes, not fuzzy regions <ref:2605.30536#pg1>.

Mira: So while it’s a promising fix for this specific mixed potential example, the general applicability of that positivity condition remains an open question <ref:2605.30536#pg2>.

Kai: It really highlights that just applying a standard technique isn't enough when you deal with complex quantum potentials; you have to account for structural underdetermination <ref:2605.30536#pg1>.

Lev: And those recursion relations they derived to simplify the expectation values show how much more complicated things get when you move from a simple oscillator to something mixed <ref:2605.30536#pg1>.

Mira: This paper suggests that for any system with multiple function types, we need these kinds of specific constraints just to make the math match reality <ref:2605.30536#pg1>.

Kai: It’s a good reminder that building models for real quantum hardware has to include checking for these kinds of ambiguities before you start running simulations <ref:2605.30536#pg1>.

Conclusion: Kai: So we've seen how this bootstrap method struggles when you mix different types of functions in a potential, like polynomials and exponentials >

Mira: Right. It really comes down to an ambiguity problem where the method can't tell those operators apart, which messes up the energy spectrum it produces >

Kai: It means if we use this tool on a system with mixed terms, we might not get the right energy levels unless we impose specific constraints >

Mira: The authors propose this additional positivity condition as a way to isolate those allowed regions and get the energy spectrum back, which they say works numerically for the mixed potential >

Kai: But they also flag that this fix isn't guaranteed to work in all situations, and the resulting allowed regions aren't as sharp as we might expect >

Mira: So while it’s a promising fix for this specific mixed potential example, the general applicability of that positivity condition remains an open question >

Kai: It boils down to how we constrain those operators so the bootstrap method actually yields the right energy levels instead of just giving us some arbitrary result >

Mira: This paper challenges researchers who rely solely on this bootstrap method, suggesting that when potentials mix functions, you need these specific constraints to get a physically meaningful spectrum >

Kai: And for real hardware development, it’s a reminder that simply applying a standard numerical technique isn't enough; you have to account for these kinds of structural underdetermination when you build your models >

Mira: We've looked at the math now, but what does this mean for the next step in building actual quantum computers?

Takeshi Moritaa, Worapat Piensuk, Pushkar Sonie

Graduate School of Science and Technology, Shizuoka University · The Graduate University for Advanced Studies, SOKENDAI · KEK Theory Center, Institute of Particle and Nuclear Studies, High Energy Accelerator Research Organization

hep-th, hep-lat, quant-ph

Submitted: 2026-05-28

Updated: 2026-11-13

Comments: 15 + 11 pages, 8 figures; v3: published version in Phys.Rev.D with a changed title and a major revision of section 2.2

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 75/100

The gist: The bootstrap method for quantum mechanics suffers from an ambiguity problem when dealing with potentials containing different types of functions like polynomial and exponential terms…

Key concepts

Ambiguity Problem in Mixed Potentials
The bootstrap method struggles when a Hamiltonian contains different function types, such as polynomials and exponentials. It cannot tell the difference between operators that only differ by an arbitrary real constant (e.g., $p$ versus $p-c$). This ambiguity prevents the method from correctly determining the energy spectrum for mixed systems.
Parity Condition
This condition is proposed as a resolution when the angular momentum quantum number $L$ is zero. It resolves the ambiguity by requiring that certain constant terms must be equal, specifically $cx = c ext{exp}$. This constraint allows the bootstrap method to successfully capture the correct energy eigenstates for these specific cases.
Positivity Condition ($ ext{Mcosh} oldsymbol{ heta} oldsymbol{ heta} oldsymbol{ heta} oldsymbol{ heta}$) Condition
This is an additional constraint derived from a $ ext{cosh}(x)$ inequality. Imposing this condition leads to the positive semi-definite condition $ ext{Mcosh}oldsymbol{ heta} oldsymbol{ heta} oldsymbol{ heta} oldsymbol{ heta} oldsymbol{ heta} eq 0$. This successfully creates isolated allowed regions that accurately reproduce the energy spectrum for mixed potentials.

Terminology

Summary

The bootstrap method for quantum mechanics suffers from an ambiguity problem when dealing with potentials containing different types of functions like polynomial and exponential terms, which fails to yield correct energy spectra. p. 0 This issue arises because the method cannot distinguish between operators differing by arbitrary real constants, thereby leading to a failure to reproduce the spectrum for mixed potentials. p. 5 The paper proposes three resolutions to this ambiguity problem. p. 9

Ambiguity Problem in Mixed Potentials

The bootstrap method fails to reproduce the energy spectrum of a Hamiltonian with a mixed potential because it cannot distinguish between operators differing by arbitrary real constants, such as distinguishing between the operators ˆx and ˆx − cx. This ambiguity effectively removes the L-dependence from the Hamiltonian, causing the bootstrap method to fail for systems like Hmixed. p. 5 Specifically, it cannot distinguish between e x and e(x-cexp), or between p and p-cp. p. 5 This ambiguity spoils the L dependence of the minimum value of Hmixed in classical mechanics. p. 8

Proposed Resolutions to Ambiguity

The paper presents three possible resolutions to the ambiguity problem in the mixed potential. These resolutions include:

  1. Using Taylor expansion, which is discarded because it loses the exact property of the allowed region.

  2. Imposing a parity condition when L = 0, which resolves the ambiguity by requiring cx = cexp. p. 1 This condition allows the bootstrap method to capture energy eigenstates. p. 7

  3. Imposing an additional positivity condition using the inequality derived from cosh(x) ≥ N/Xmax n=0 x 2n (2n)! p. 1! This condition leads to the positive semi-definite condition Mcosh ⪰ 0, which successfully yields isolated allowed regions reproducing the energy spectrum for the mixed potential. p. 4

Numerical Implementation and Results

The numerical bootstrap method is implemented by determining the allowed region by solving a linear programming problem for fixed energy values E. For the mixed potential, imposing both the parity condition and the additional positivity condition Mcosh ⪰ 0 yields isolated allowed regions that reproduce the energy spectrum. p. 1 The error of the ground state at (Kx, Ke, Kp, Nmax) = (2, 1, 1, 4) is O(10−6). p. 4

General Applicability and Limitations

The ambiguity problem generally arises whenever the bootstrap method is applied to a system where multiple types of functions appear. While the proposed prescription based on imposing the additional positivity condition (3. p. 15) is promising for the mixed potential, it is not clear whether it always works in more general settings. p. 2 Furthermore, the allowed regions obtained are not as sharp as those for the anharmonic oscillator. p. 5 The paper notes that performing the bootstrap analysis with larger values of Kx, Ke and Kp may improve the results but poses a significant numerical challenge. p. 4

Derivation of Recursion Relations

A systematic derivation of recursion relations among expectation values is presented to simplify the numerical bootstrap analysis. This derivation shows that for the anharmonic oscillator, all expectation values can be expressed in terms of a fixed set of three independent variables: E, ⟨xˆ⟩, and ⟨xˆ2⟩. p. 4 For the mixed potential, the number of independent variables increases with the moments and becomes unbounded. p. 4 This contrasts sharply with the anharmonic oscillator case where any expectation value can be reduced to a fixed set of three independent variables. p. 4 The final relation (A. p. 79) provides relations among expectation values that do not involve the operator ˆp. p. 4

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI system can accurately determine energy eigenvalues for mixed potential Hamiltonians by implementing resolution 3, which uses an additional positivity condition Mcosh greater than or equal to zero. This prescription successfully obtains isolated allowed regions that reproduce the energy spectrum, contrasting with the conventional method's failure.

  2. Improved AI system can handle systems where multiple types of functions appear by systematically applying inequality conditions similar to Eq (3.3). This allows the system to resolve ambiguity by imposing a positivity condition Mcosh greater than or equal to zero, leading to exact allowed regions in certain cases.

  3. Improved AI system can analyze quantum mechanics problems with polynomial and exponential terms without ambiguity by using the Taylor expansion prescription, although this sacrifices the exactness of the allowed region property. This method is useful when only polynomial operators are involved in the potential functions.

Sources

Related papers