The effective gravitational action of a massless chiral fermion and the absence of parity-odd contributions

arXiv:2605.28045 · hep-th, gr-qc · Submitted 2026-05-27 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "The effective gravitational action of a massless chiral fermion and the absence of parity-odd contributions".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The effective gravitational action of a massless chiral fermion and the absence of parity-odd contributions proves that up to order four in the number of graviton fields, there are no parity-odd contributions to the renormalized gravitational effective action.

Kai: The Core Finding The main result is that by using the BPHZL renormalization scheme, up to order four in the number of graviton fields, there are no parity-odd contributions to the renormalized gravitational effective action.

Mira: Furthermore, modulo arbitrary UV finite diffeomorphism invariant counterterms, this effective action is equal to half the corresponding gravitational action for a Dirac fermion non-chirally coupled to gravity up to order four in the number of graviton fields.

Kai: This implies that the Weyl anomaly is purely parity-even and its value is half the value of the Weyl anomaly for a Dirac fermion non-chirally coupled to gravity.

Paper summary: Kai: To get into the specifics of the paper, we see they set up the problem by considering a massless left-handed fermion coupled to a background graviton field, h mu nu, on four-dimensional Minkowski spacetime.

Mira: They define this gravitational effective action by using a massless Dirac spinor chirally coupled to the graviton field for their calculations.

Lev: And they use Pauli-Villars regularization and the BPHZL renormalization procedures, which are methods they've refined from earlier work, specifically referencing twelve, thirteen, fourteen, and fifteen <ref:2605.28045#pg3,Pauli-Villars regularization and the BPHZL renormalization procedures>.

Kai: The analysis of contributions shows that in the one, two, three and four-point functions of the renormalized gravitational action, no parity-odd contributions exist.

Mira: They show this by analyzing the components derived from Wick's theorem where terms involving traces of Dirac matrices and a gamma five operator are shown to vanish because of properties like trr gamma lambda one gamma sigma one gamma nu two gamma sigma two gamma nu three gamma sigma three gamma five being zero.

Lev: That vanishing condition with the gamma five operator is key; it's what enforces the parity-even nature of those terms they are looking at.

Kai: They also discuss how the renormalization process breaks classical diffeomorphism invariance, leading to a term Brc mu nuh mu nu s which is linear in the ghost field and its derivatives.

Mira: But since there are no pure gravitational anomalies in four spacetime dimensions, they say this breaking can be removed by introducing appropriate UV finite counterterms.

Lev: So the point is that those counterterms must be parity-even because the regularized contributions were already parity-even, which restores invariance under infinitesimal diffeomorphisms.

Kai: And ultimately, they arrive at a renormalized gravitational effective action that is invariant under those infinitesimal diffeomorphisms after adding those specific counterterms.

Mira: The final conclusion here is that modulo arbitrary diffeomorphism invariant parity-even counterterms and up to four in the number of h mu nu 's, the renormalized gravitational effective action of the chiral theory is half the value of the renormalized gravitational effective action for a Dirac spinor non-chirally coupled to gravity.

Lev: So if you look at this on real hardware, running these calculations up to order four means we are looking at a very complex structure, but they've shown it simplifies nicely in terms of parity.

Kai: It really boils down to confirming that the Weyl anomaly doesn't involve any parity-odd terms in this setup.

Conclusion: Mira: So to wrap up on "The effective gravitational action of a massless chiral fermion and the absence of parity-odd contributions," they are essentially demonstrating that for this chiral theory, up to order four in the number of graviton fields, there are no parity-odd contributions.

Kai: The authors claim this holds modulo arbitrary UV finite diffeomorphism invariant parity-even counterterms, meaning any deviation from a fully invariant action is due to these even terms.

Lev: If you were trying to run this on a real quantum computer, knowing that the leading four-point contributions are parity-even means the error structure you have to worry about is constrained in this way.

Mira: This result implies that any breaking of classical Weyl symmetry must come from parity-even terms, and never from parity-odd contributions. This outcome they find agrees with references four, five, six, and seven <ref:2605.28045#pg3,with references 4 , 5 , 6 , and 7>.

Kai: It also means the Weyl anomaly itself doesn't involve any parity-odd terms in this theory under scrutiny. This is a bit of a strong statement about the structure of quantum gravity effects here.

Lev: And they note that this result holds even when using higher derivative regularization methods, which is good because it means it isn't just tied to one specific way of cutting off infinities.

Mira: They also suggest a specific form for the renormalized partition function, conjecturing it is given by Z rh mu nu s about integral D(g mu nu) eta mu nu h mu nu.

Kai: It's about tying the quantum effective action back to a path integral over the metric fluctuations themselves, which is something we can actually try to build on in our qubit simulations.

Lev: So what this means for the world is that when you look at chiral fermions interacting with gravity, you get a specific prediction about parity preservation in their quantum corrections up to that order.

Mira: The main implication is that the structure of the anomaly is simpler than some other theoretical expectations suggested. It settles this question by showing no parity-odd terms appear in the effective gravitational action.

Jesús Anero, Carmelo P. Martías

Departamento de FἿisica Teórica and Instituto de FἿisica Teórica (IFT-UAM/CSIC) · Universidad Complutense de Madrid (UCM), Departamento de FἿisica Teórica and IPARCOS, Facultad de Ciencias FἿisicas

hep-th, gr-qc

Submitted: 2026-05-27

Updated: 2026-10-29

Comments: 35 pages. NO figures. Typos corrected and minor comments added

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: The effective gravitational action of a massless chiral fermion and the absence of parity-odd contributions proves that up to order four in the number of graviton fields…

Key concepts

Chiral Fermion
This refers to a massless fermion whose left-handed and right-handed components transform differently under Lorentz transformations. In this context, it is coupled to gravity in a way that breaks parity symmetry, which is the central feature being analyzed in the paper.
Gravitational Effective Action
This is a quantum field theory description of how gravity behaves at low energies. The authors calculate this action by starting with a chirally coupled fermion and using renormalization techniques to handle infinities, revealing its structure up to four graviton interactions.
Parity-Odd Contributions
Parity symmetry relates particles with opposite handedness. The paper systematically proves that all calculated terms in the effective action that violate this parity symmetry (i.e., are parity-odd) vanish at the one, two, three, and four-point levels.

Terminology

Summary

The effective gravitational action of a massless chiral fermion and the absence of parity-odd contributions proves that up to order four in the number of graviton fields, there are no parity-odd contributions to the renormalized gravitational effective action. p. 0

Where the paper says it

es Abstract We consider the field theory of a quantum massless left handed fermion coupled to a background graviton field, hµν , on four-dimensional Minkowski spacetime. By using the BPHZL renormalization scheme, we prove that, up to order four in the number of graviton fields, there are no parity-odd contributions to the renormalized gravitational effective action.

The Core Finding

The main result is that by using the BPHZL renormalization scheme, up to order four in the number of graviton fields, there are no parity-odd contributions to the renormalized gravitational effective action. Furthermore, modulo arbitrary UV finite diffeomorphism invariant counterterms, this effective action is equal to half the corresponding gravitational action for a Dirac fermion non-chirally coupled to gravity up to order four in the number of graviton fields. p. 0

Where the paper says it

By using the BPHZL renormalization scheme, we prove that, up to order four in the number of graviton fields, there are no parity-odd contributions to the renormalized gravitational effective action. As a side result, we show that, modulo arbitrary UV finite diffeomorphism invariant parity-even counterterms, the gravitational effective action in question is equal, up to order four in the number of graviton fields, to half the corresponding gravitational action for a Dirac fermion non-chirally coupled to gravity.

This implies that the Weyl anomaly is purely parity-even and its value is half the value of the Weyl anomaly for a Dirac fermion non-chirally coupled to gravity. p. 0
Where the paper says it

As a side result, we show that, modulo arbitrary UV finite diffeomorphism invariant parity-even counterterms, the gravitational effective action in question is equal, up to order four in the number of graviton fields, to half the corresponding gravitational action for a Dirac fermion non-chirally coupled to gravity. Also as a side result, we conclude the the Weyl anomaly is purely parity-even and that its value is half the value of the Weyl anomaly for a Dirac fermion non-chirally coupled to gravity.

Methodology and Setup

The authors construct the quantum theory by considering a single massless left-handed fermion coupled to the graviton field on four-dimensional Minkowski spacetime. They define the gravitational effective action using a massless Dirac spinor chirally coupled to the graviton field and regularize it with Pauli-Villars regularization and BPHZL renormalization procedures. p. 2

Where the paper says it

To show that, at one-loop, the one, two, three and four-point contributions to the gravitational effective action of a background graviton field coupled to a single massless left handed spinor carry no parity-odd contributions, we shall define the gravitational effective action by using a massless Dirac spinor chirally coupled to the graviton field. We shall regularize and renormalize such effective action by employing the Pauli-Villars regularization and the BPHZL renormalization procedures formulated in [12] –see also [13, 14, 15].

The process involves defining the partition function using a spectator right-handed fermion field to formally define the effective action. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Let Zrhµνs denote the partition function of the model. To define it in perturbation theory around a Minkowski background, we shall introduce a spectator right-handed fermion field –i.

Analysis of Contributions

The paper systematically shows that no parity-odd contributions exist in the one, two, three and four-point functions of the renormalized gravitational action. This is demonstrated by analyzing the components of the effective action derived from Wick's theorem, where terms involving traces of Dirac matrices and a gamma five operator are shown to vanish due to properties like trrγλ1 γσ1 γν2 γσ2 γν3 γσ3 γ5s being zero. Specifically, the calculation shows that terms like xSspiny pP V, c q 0 are parity-even. p. 2

Where the paper says it

However, it is well known that the diffeomorphism invariance of this theory is not anomalous (we are in 4 dimensions) and, hence, as discussed in the previous paragraph, the invariance under diffeomorphisms can always be restored by introducing appropriate counterterms. What is key is that these counterterms up to order four (included) in the number of fields have no parity-odd terms, for we shall show that the regularized gravitational effective action defined as in [12] carries no parity-odd contributions up to four in the number of fields.

Restoration of Symmetries

The renormalization process breaks classical diffeomorphism invariance, resulting in a term Brcµ, hµνs which is linear in the ghost field and its derivatives. However, since there are no pure gravitational anomalies in four spacetime dimensions, this breaking can be removed by introducing appropriate UV finite counterterms. p. 2

Where the paper says it

However, it is well known that the diffeomorphism invariance of this theory is not anomalous (we are in 4 dimensions) and, hence, as discussed in the previous paragraph, the invariance under diffeomorphisms can always be restored by introducing appropriate counterterms. What is key is that these counterterms up to order four (included) in the number of fields have no parity-odd terms, for we shall show that the regularized gravitational effective action defined as in [12] carries no parity-odd contributions up to four in the number of fields.

These counterterms are shown to be parity-even because the regularized contributions were parity-even. p. 0
Where the paper says it

By using the BPHZL renormalization scheme, we prove that, up to order four in the number of graviton fields, there are no parity-odd contributions to the renormalized gravitational effective action. As a side result, we show that, modulo arbitrary UV finite diffeomorphism invariant parity-even counterterms, the gravitational effective action in question is equal, up to order four in the number of graviton fields, to half the corresponding gravitational action for a Dirac fermion non-chirally coupled to gravity.

This leads to a renormalized gravitational effective action that is invariant under infinitesimal diffeomorphisms. p. 0
Where the paper says it

By using the BPHZL renormalization scheme, we prove that, up to order four in the number of graviton fields, there are no parity-odd contributions to the renormalized gravitational effective action. As a side result, we show that, modulo arbitrary UV finite diffeomorphism invariant parity-even counterterms, the gravitational effective action in question is equal, up to order four in the number of graviton fields, to half the corresponding gravitational action for a Dirac fermion non-chirally coupled to gravity.

Conclusion and Implications

The final conclusion is that modulo arbitrary diffeomorphism invariant parity-even counterterms and up to four in the number of hµν's, the renormalized gravitational effective action of the chiral theory is half the value of the renormalized gravitational effective action of a Dirac spinor non-chirally coupled to gravity. This implies that any breaking of classical Weyl symmetry is due to parity-even terms, never to parity-odd contributions. p. 2

Where the paper says it

However, it is well known that the diffeomorphism invariance of this theory is not anomalous (we are in 4 dimensions) and, hence, as discussed in the previous paragraph, the invariance under diffeomorphisms can always be restored by introducing appropriate counterterms. What is key is that these counterterms up to order four (included) in the number of fields have no parity-odd terms, for we shall show that the regularized gravitational effective action defined as in [12] carries no parity-odd contributions up to four in the number of fields.

The lack of parity-odd contributions in the effective gravitational action implies that the Weyl anomaly does not involve parity-odd terms. p. 1
Where the paper says it

This pole structure, which is parity-odd and UV finite, gives rise to the gauge anomaly and goes away when the anomaly cancellation conditions are satisfied. Hence, the fact that there are no purely gravitational anomalies in four dimensions rises the question as to whether the renormalized three-point part of the gravitational effective action carries any one-loop parity-odd contributions coming from Weyl fermions running along the loop.

This outcome is in complete agreement with the results presented in [4, 5, 6, 7] and utter disagreement with the result in [8, 9]. The paper also shows that this result holds even when using higher derivative regularization methods. p. 3
Where the paper says it

In this section 5, we show that the renormalized effective gravitational action does not contain parity-odd contributions, up to order four in the number of graviton fields, and that its value is half the value of the corresponding dimensionally renormalized gravitational effective action of a Dirac field non-chirally coupled to the graviton field on Minkowski spacetime. The use of higher derivative regularizations to draw the same conclusions as with the Pauli-Villars regularization of Ref.

The renormalized partition function is conjectured to be given by Zrhµνs “ a D(, where D denotes the Dirac operator for the perturbative metric gµν “ ηµν hµν. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Then, the classical action of the model reads S “ 1 2 ż d 4x epxq e µ a pxq riψ¯ Lpxqγ a pDµψLqpxq ´ ipDµψ¯ Lqpxqγ aψLpxqs, where DµψLpxq “ BµψLpxq ´ i 2 ωµabpxq γ abψLpxq, Dµψ¯ Lpxq “ Bµψ¯ Lpxq ` i 2 ψ¯ Lpxqγ ab ωµabpxq. Since we shall construct the quantum theory for the fermions in perturbation theory around Minkowski spacetime, we shall express the metric, gµν , the vierbein e a µ , the inverse vierbein, e µ a , and the spin connection, ωa,bc as follows gµν “ ηµν ` κhµν, e a µ “ δ a µ ` κE p1q a µ ` κ 2E p2q a µ ` .

Detailed Computations

The authors provide detailed computations for terms like T1 and T2 in (4.6) to show the parity-even nature of the contributions. p. 0

Where the paper says it

By using the BPHZL renormalization scheme, we prove that, up to order four in the number of graviton fields, there are no parity-odd contributions to the renormalized gravitational effective action. As a side result, we show that, modulo arbitrary UV finite diffeomorphism invariant parity-even counterterms, the gravitational effective action in question is equal, up to order four in the number of graviton fields, to half the corresponding gravitational action for a Dirac fermion non-chirally coupled to gravity.

These calculations involve complex expressions derived from Wick's theorem and properties of Dirac matrices to confirm that all resulting terms are parity-even. The final result confirms that the one, two, three and four-point contribution to the regularized gravitational effective action WpP V q rhµνs are free from parity-odd terms. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Secondly, that we agree with references [4, 5, 6] and [7] in that there is no parity-odd contribution to the Weyl anomaly for the theory under scrutiny. To show that, at one-loop, the one, two, three and four-point contributions to the gravitational effective action of a background graviton field coupled to a single massless left handed spinor carry no parity-odd contributions, we shall define the gravitational effective action by using a massless Dirac spinor chirally coupled to the graviton field.

The structure of the final result suggests a renormalization prescription where Zrhµνs is given by Zrhµνs “ a D(, where D denotes the Dirac operator for the perturbative metric gµν “ ηµν hµν. The paper concludes that in perturbation theory around Minkowski the partition function, the renormalized partition function of our theory, Zrhµνs, is given by Zrhµνs “ a D(, where D denotes the Dirac operator for the perturbative metric gµν “ ηµµ ν h µ ν. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Let Zrhµνs denote the partition function of the model. To define it in perturbation theory around a Minkowski background, we shall introduce a spectator right-handed fermion field –i.

Restoration of Invariance

The appendix reviews BRST transformations and how diffeomorphism invariance is broken by BPHZL renormalization. It is shown that the renormalized effective action WpBP HZLq rhµνs does not satisfy the BRST invariance condition (B. p. 2

Where the paper says it

However, it is well known that the diffeomorphism invariance of this theory is not anomalous (we are in 4 dimensions) and, hence, as discussed in the previous paragraph, the invariance under diffeomorphisms can always be restored by introducing appropriate counterterms. What is key is that these counterterms up to order four (included) in the number of fields have no parity-odd terms, for we shall show that the regularized gravitational effective action defined as in [12] carries no parity-odd contributions up to four in the number of fields.

1), but it can be made invariant by adding appropriate UV finite counterterms. p. 0
Where the paper says it

By using the BPHZL renormalization scheme, we prove that, up to order four in the number of graviton fields, there are no parity-odd contributions to the renormalized gravitational effective action. As a side result, we show that, modulo arbitrary UV finite diffeomorphism invariant parity-even counterterms, the gravitational effective action in question is equal, up to order four in the number of graviton fields, to half the corresponding gravitational action for a Dirac fermion non-chirally coupled to gravity.

The new renormalized gravitational effective action Wpdinvq rhµνs is annihilated by the BRST operator s, meaning it is invariant under infinitesimal diffeomorphisms. p. 0
Where the paper says it

By using the BPHZL renormalization scheme, we prove that, up to order four in the number of graviton fields, there are no parity-odd contributions to the renormalized gravitational effective action. As a side result, we show that, modulo arbitrary UV finite diffeomorphism invariant parity-even counterterms, the gravitational effective action in question is equal, up to order four in the number of graviton fields, to half the corresponding gravitational action for a Dirac fermion non-chirally coupled to gravity.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Parity-even Effective Action Calculation: The AI can accurately calculate that "modulo arbitrary diffeomorphism invariant parity-even counterterms and up to four in the number of hµν’s, the renormalized gravitational effective action of our chiral theory is half the renormalized gravitational effective action of a Dirac fermion non-chirally coupled to gravity."

  2. Weyl Anomaly Prediction: The system can predict that the Weyl anomaly does not involve parity-odd terms, which is consistent with results in [4, 5, 6, 7] and contradicts those in [8, 9].

  3. Counterterm Identification: The AI can identify that appropriate UV finite counterterms can be introduced to make the new renormalized one-point, two-point, three-point and four point contributions to the effective gravitational action preserve diffeomorphism invariance by ensuring they are parity-even.

  4. Model Comparison: The system can determine that for one-, two-, three-, and four-point functions of the regularized gravitational effective action, no parity-odd contribution occurs here, which is crucial for verifying anomaly cancellation properties.

  5. Higher Derivative Method Application: The AI can apply higher derivative regularization methods to confirm that the cancellation mechanism of the parity-odd contributions displayed in section 4, does not depend on the actual form of Gpregq ppq, provided it yields regularized integrals.

Abstract

We consider the field theory of a quantum massless left handed fermion coupled to a background graviton field, h μν, on four-dimensional Minkowski spacetime. By using the BPHZL renormalization scheme, we prove that, up to order four in the number of graviton fields, there are no parity-odd contributions to the renormalized gravitational effective action. As a side result, we show that, modulo arbitrary UV finite diffeomorphism invariant parity-even counterterms, the gravitational effective action in question is equal, up to order four in the number of graviton fields, to half the corresponding gravitational action for a Dirac fermion non-chirally coupled to gravity. Also as a side result, we conclude the the Weyl anomaly is purely parity-even and that its value is half the value of the Weyl anomaly for a Dirac fermion non-chirally coupled to gravity.

Sources

Related papers