Freeze-in SU(2) vector dark matter at low reheating temperature
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Freeze-in SU(2) vector dark matter at low reheating temperature".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The freeze-in mechanism for dark matter (DM) requires extremely feeble interactions with the Standard Model (SM), preventing thermal equilibrium in the early Universe and typically evading experimental detection.
Kai: In this work, we investigate freeze-in production of SU(2)HS vector dark matter (VDM) in a low-TRH cosmology.
Mira: Model Description The paper considers an extension of the Standard Model (SM) by a non-Abelian gauge symmetry SU(2)HS, where SM particles are singlets under this new gauge group.
Kai: The model includes a BSM scalar doublet ϕ whose vacuum expectation value (VEV) spontaneously breaks the SU(2)HS, generating the mass of the DM candidate X.
Paper summary: Kai: So, wrapping up "Freeze-in SU(two) vector dark matter at low reheating temperature", the paper lays out a minimal BSM scenario based on the hidden SU(two)HS gauge symmetry <ref:2605.24473#pg1,Freeze-in SU(2) vector dark matter at low reheating temperature>. They show that this setup naturally generates three spin one vector gauge bosons, Xi.
Mira: And the stability of these Xi particles is guaranteed by an accidental custodial SO(three) symmetry arising from the SU(two)HS breaking without needing extra discrete symmetries <ref:2605.24473#pg3>. This framework allows for a freeze-in dark matter production mechanism where the couplings are stronger than in vanilla freeze-in models, but still within testable bounds.
Lev: From an engineering view, this means we're looking at a model where the DM is produced via these vector interactions rather than just simple scalar decays or annihilations. The key hurdle they identify is that you need to be careful about how the coupling g phi changes with the reheating temperature TRH because of that exponential suppression <ref:2605.24473#pg1, #pg2>.
Kai: Exactly. The paper shows that for a fixed dark matter mass, a larger gauge coupling g phi is needed to get the right relic density as the reheating temperature drops. This behavior comes directly from that Boltzmann suppression effect <ref:2605.24473#pg1>.
Mira: So in simple terms, this means if you're designing a dark matter model, you don't have to stick strictly to the usual freeze-out thermal production picture. You can explore scenarios where strong couplings are needed at lower temperatures and still get the right answer.
Lev: It suggests that the phenomenology of VDM in this SU(two)HS setup might be testable in future experiments like DARWIN, given these new coupling requirements <ref:2605.24473#pg1>.
Kai: That's it for this piece on "Freeze-in SU(two) vector dark matter at low reheating temperature" <ref:2605.24473#pg1,Freeze-in SU(2) vector dark matter at low reheating temperature>. It opens up a new way to think about how weak interactions can still produce dark matter candidates.
Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up this piece on "Freeze-in SU(two) vector dark matter at low reheating temperature," we looked at how these specific interactions work and what it actually means for finding this kind of dark matter in the universe.
Mira: The authors are looking at a minimal beyond the standard model scenario involving a hidden non-Abelian gauge symmetry, specifically SU(two)HS, which gives us three spin one vector dark matter candidates called Xi.
Lev: And they found that the stability of these Xi particles comes from an accidental custodial SO(three) symmetry that appears just from how they break the SU(two)HS group. That’s a neat feature because usually you need to add those extra discrete symmetries yourself.
Kai: It means we're dealing with vector dark matter that can be stable without needing those extra ad hoc rules, which is important for building consistent models.
Mira: The core finding is about the production rate: they show that if the reheating temperature of the early universe gets really low, you actually need stronger interactions between the dark matter and Standard Model particles to still get enough dark matter relic density.
Lev: That strong coupling requirement is what makes this setup interesting because it pushes us away from simpler freeze-in scenarios we usually think about.
Kai: The authors suggest that for a fixed mass of the dark matter, you need a larger gauge coupling, g phi, to get the right final abundance when the reheating temperature drops. That’s a big shift in parameter space compared to standard models.
Mira: So what this implies is that for vector dark matter in this SU(two)HS setup, we might be looking at couplings that are stronger than what we usually expect from minimal models.
Lev: It also means that future experiments trying to detect these particles, like DARWIN or even indirect searches looking for W plus W minus annihilation, will have to account for these potentially larger coupling strengths.
Kai: This work sets up a framework where the dynamics of the early universe, specifically its cooling rate or TRH, directly dictates what we need in terms of model couplings to get a viable dark matter density.
Mira: It really shows how subtle shifts in cosmology, like low reheating temperatures, can drastically change the parameter space for dark matter model building.
Lev: We've shown that this framework is viable within current experimental constraints, but it definitely points toward new regions of coupling space that future experiments need to explore.
School of Physical Sciences, Indian Association for the Cultivation of Science · Department of Physics, Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur · State Key Laboratory of Dark Matter Physics, Tsung-Dao Lee Institute & School of Physics and Astronomy, Shanghai Jiao Tong University · Key Laboratory for Particle Astrophysics and Cosmology (MOE) & Shanghai Key Laboratory for Particle Physics and Cosmology
hep-ph
Submitted: 2026-05-23
Updated: 2026-11-05
Comments: 22 pages, 7 figures; published in PRD
DOI: 10.1103/3n3s-8t46
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 85/100
The gist: The freeze-in mechanism for dark matter (DM) requires extremely feeble interactions with the Standard Model (SM)…
Key concepts
- Freeze-in Mechanism
- This process describes how dark matter is produced not from thermal equilibrium but through rare interactions with Standard Model particles in the early universe. It's a way to generate dark matter when its interactions are too weak for traditional thermal production methods.
- SU(2)HS Gauge Symmetry
- This is a new, non-Abelian gauge symmetry added to the Standard Model. SM particles are treated as singlets under this group. Spontaneous breaking of this symmetry generates the mass for the dark matter candidate X.
- Low Reheating Temperature Effects
- When the reheating temperature (TRH) is very low, DM production experiences an exponential suppression because its interaction rate becomes much slower than the expansion of the universe. To overcome this suppression and match observed DM density, stronger couplings are necessary.
Terminology
Summary
The freeze-in mechanism for dark matter (DM) requires extremely feeble interactions with the Standard Model (SM), preventing thermal equilibrium in the early Universe and typically evading experimental detection. p. 0 cn
Abstract. The freeze-in mechanism for dark matter (DM) requires extremely feeble interactions with the Standard Model (SM), preventing thermal equilibrium in the early Universe
and typically evading experimental detection. However, for sufficiently low reheating temperatures (TRH), the observed relic abundance can be realized with larger couplings, opening
prospects for experimental searches. In this work, we investigate freeze-in production of
SU(2)HS vector dark matter (VDM) in a low-TRH cosmology.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Model Description
The paper considers an extension of the Standard Model (SM) by a non-Abelian gauge symmetry SU(2)HS, where SM particles are singlets under this new gauge group. The model includes a BSM scalar doublet ϕ whose vacuum expectation value (VEV) spontaneously breaks the SU(2)HS, generating the mass of the DM candidate X. p. 2 Note that all
the SM particles are singlets under this new gauge group. The scalar sector of this BSM model
includes a BSM scalar doublet ϕ whose vacuum expectation value (VEV) spontaneously
breaks the SU(2)HS, generating the mass of the DM candidate X. The scalar sector of this BSM model
includes a BSM scalar doublet ϕ whose vacuum expectation value (VEV) spontaneously
breaks the SU(2)HS, generating the mass of the DM candidate X. The striking feature of
such a model is that the 3 DM candidates Xi become stable due to the custodial SO(3)
symmetry emerged from the SU(2)HS breaking without any imposition of additional discrete
symmetry that is commonly found in other DM models. Thus, the three components X
1,2,3
µ
collectively constitute a triply degenerate vector dark matter sector, with identical masses
and portal interactions. This stability arises dynamically from the residual custodial symmetry and does not require the imposition of an additional ad hoc Z2 symmetry, unlike many
Abelian vector dark matter constructions.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
DM Production Mechanism
The DM X gets produced from the BSM interactions of SM particles as well as the BSM scalar η. The evolution of X density is obtained by solving the Boltzmann equation as a function of temperature T. p. 5 The DM X gets produced from the BSM interactions
of SM particles as well as the BSM scalar η. The evolution of X density can be obtained by
solving the Boltzmann equation as a function of temperature T,
dYX
dT = −
Sent
HT
X
i=f,h,η,V
(Y
eq
i
)
2
⟨σv⟩ii→XX − (YX)
2
⟨σv⟩XX→ii
−
1
HT
X
j=h,η
h
(Y
eq
j
⟨Γ⟩j→XX − YX⟨Γ⟩XX→j )
i
, (3. Moreover, Sent stands for the comoving entropy
density, whereas H =
p
8πρrad/3/Mpl is the Hubble expansion rate with Mpl and ρrad being
the Planck mass and the total energy density, respectively. The initial condition is imposed
by setting YX = 0 at T = TRH. The thermal averages of the respective annihilation cross
section (σ) and decay width (Γ) are denoted by ⟨σv⟩ and ⟨Γ⟩, respectively. The production
cross sections for pair annihilation of SM fermions and gauge bosons are given as,
σff¯→XX =
1
Nc
m2
f
sin2
2β
256πsv2v
2
ϕ
1
s − m2
h + imhΓh
−
1
s − m2
η + imηΓη
2
(s
2 − 4m2
Xs + 12m4
X)
q
(s − 4m2
f
)(s − 4m2
X) (3.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Low Reheating Temperature Effects
The production rate suffers from a Boltzmann suppression when the DM mass is larger than the reheating temperature (TRH). Specifically, in the limit T << mX, the interaction rate and consequently YDM become exponentially suppressed as TRH decreases. p. 6 In this limit, the Bessel
function also behaves as K1 (
√
s/T) ∝
p
T /s1/2e
−
√
s/T . Thus, with an increase in the ratio
mX/TRH, the interaction rate and consequently YDM become exponentially suppressed as
observed in Fig. In such a scenario, when the reheating temperature
is smaller than the DM mass (m), only a sub-fraction of the particles annihilating to DM
can potentially generate DM that lies in the tail of the Boltzmann distribution function
with energy ≫ TRH and the overall DM production rate becomes suppressed by exp (−m/T)
[17]. Consequently, to satisfy the observed DM density, one needs to assume stronger DM
– 1 – words, it can be stated that to satisfy the same DM abundance, the associated DM couplings
should be higher for a lower value of TRH. This crucial feature serves as the primary focus
of this work.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Phenomenological Constraints and Results
Exhaustive numerical scans over various model parameters reveal that with higher gauge coupling (gϕ) and the mixing angle (sin β), the DM abundances increase as these parameters directly control the production cross-section. The paper finds that for mDM ∼ 100 GeV and TRH = 5 GeV one requires gϕ = O(10−1) to satisfy the observed relic density while fixing mη = 60 GeV and sin β = 0. p. 9 1
TRH=120 GeV
TRH=90 GeV
TRH=60 GeV
TRH=30 GeV
gφ
10
−6
10
−5
10
−4
10
−3
10
−2
10
−1
10
0
10
1
MDM (GeV)
500 1000 2000
(b)
Figure 4. Contours satisfying the observed relic density are shown in the gϕ–MDM plane. We perform a systematic study of the dark matter phenomenology and
identify the parameter space consistent with the observed relic abundance. In contrast to
conventional freeze-in scenarios, the required DM couplings can be sizable, rendering part of
the parameter space already constrained by existing direct searches like PandaX-4T and LZ,
while a significant region remains within the reach of future experiments such as DARWIN.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Experimental Constraints and Future Prospects
The study incorporates theoretical constraints such as perturbative unitarity and collider bounds, including constraints on the invisible decay width of the SM Higgs boson. Direct detection experiments like LZ [33] and PandaX-4T [34] impose stringent constraints on the spin-independent (SI) scattering cross section. p. 9 The DM candidate X interacts with nucleons via scalar mediation
through the Higgs boson h and the scalar η. The resulting spin-independent (SI) scattering
cross section is given by
σSI =
1
64π
f
2m2
N
v
2
ϕ
v
2
g
4
ϕ
sin2
(2β)
(m2
η − m2
h
)
2
m4
ηm4
h
µ
2
r
m2
X
, (4. In contrast to
conventional freeze-in scenarios, the required DM couplings can be sizable, rendering part of
the parameter space already constrained by existing direct searches like PandaX-4T and LZ,
while a significant region remains within the reach of future experiments such as DARWIN. Though one can realize the freeze-in mechanism for an abelian U(1)X vector DM models as
well, we find that the non-abelian structure of the SU(2)HS scenario leads to a distinct feature
due to a larger number of dark matter particles, resulting in an enlarged viable parameter
arXiv:2605. The channels are (a) fermion annihilation
via scalar mediator, (b) gauge boson annihilation via scalar mediator, (c) scalar annihilation via scalar
mediator, (d) scalar annihilation w/o mediator, (e) scalar annihilation via VDM mediator. For the
last one, there also exists a u-channel diagram, which is not shown explicitly.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusion
In this work, we consider a minimal beyond-the-Standard-Model (BSM) scenario where the SM particle spectrum is augmented by a hidden non-Abelian gauge symmetry SU(2)HS, giving rise to three spin-1 gauge bosons Xi(i = 1, 2, 3). The spontaneous breaking of SU(2)HS via the vacuum expectation value of ϕ generates a common mass for the three vector bosons, while the resulting SO(3) custodial symmetry ensures their stability. p. 2 The scalar sector of this BSM model
includes a BSM scalar doublet ϕ whose vacuum expectation value (VEV) spontaneously
breaks the SU(2)HS, generating the mass of the DM candidate X. The striking feature of
such a model is that the 3 DM candidates Xi become stable due to the custodial SO(3)
symmetry emerged from the SU(2)HS breaking without any imposition of additional discrete
symmetry that is commonly found in other DM models. However, for sufficiently low reheating temperatures (TRH), the observed relic abundance can be realized with larger couplings, opening
prospects for experimental searches. In this work, we investigate freeze-in production of
SU(2)HS vector dark matter (VDM) in a low-TRH cosmology.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
A Parametrization
Here we present the parametrization of the quartic couplings in terms of the masses of the physical scalars. If mη > mh, then m2h,η = λHυ2 + λϕυ2ϕ∓ (λϕυ2ϕ − λHυ2)/cos 2β. p. 4 Conversely, for mh > mη,
corresponding masses are obtained by interchanging the ± signs in the same equation. h, η
is related to the unphysical basis by,
h
η
=
cos β − sin β
sin β cos β
S
ϕ0
, with, tan 2β =
λϕHvvϕ
λϕv
2
ϕ − λHv
2
(2. 9)
Thus, the main interaction channel of X is through the Higgs portal (h, η) with SM
fermions and the SM gauge bosons governed by sin 2β × (gϕvϕ), which is important from
both production and detection aspects. Also there can be quartic vertex with h, η governed
by sin β(cos β) × gϕ and scalar portal interactions of hh(ηη) → XX governed by same sin β
and (gϕvϕ). Conversely, for mh > mη,
corresponding masses are obtained by interchanging the ± signs in the same equation. h, η
is related to the unphysical basis by,
h
η
=
cos β − sin β
sin β cos β
S
ϕ0
, with, tan 2β =
λϕHvvϕ
λϕv
2
ϕ − λHv
2
(2.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Cross-sections for hihj → XX
The amplitude for the process hihj → XX receives contributions from contact interaction, s-channel scalar exchange and, when allowed by the cubic hiXX vertices, t- and u-channel vector exchange. The required vector X–scalar couplings are ghXX = −g 2ϕvϕ/4 sin β, gηXX = g 2ϕvϕ/4 cos β. p. 0 In contrast to
conventional freeze-in scenarios, the required DM couplings can be sizable, rendering part of
the parameter space already constrained by existing direct searches like PandaX-4T and LZ,
while a significant region remains within the reach of future experiments such as DARWIN. Though one can realize the freeze-in mechanism for an abelian U(1)X vector DM models as
well, we find that the non-abelian structure of the SU(2)HS scenario leads to a distinct feature
due to a larger number of dark matter particles, resulting in an enlarged viable parameter
arXiv:2605.Where the paper says it
Interaction Lagrangian of scalar sector
In the mass eigenstate basis, the interaction terms in the Lagrangian is L ⊃ −1/6ρhh3 − 1/6ρηη3 − 1/2ρ1η2h − 1/2ρ2h2η. The scalar trilinear couplings are given by ρ1 = −6λϕvϕ cos squared β sin β + 6λHv sin squared β cos β + λϕH v cos cubed β − vϕ sin cubed β − 2v cos β sin squared β + 2vϕ cos squared β sin β. p. 4 9)
Thus, the main interaction channel of X is through the Higgs portal (h, η) with SM
fermions and the SM gauge bosons governed by sin 2β × (gϕvϕ), which is important from
both production and detection aspects. Also there can be quartic vertex with h, η governed
by sin β(cos β) × gϕ and scalar portal interactions of hh(ηη) → XX governed by same sin β
and (gϕvϕ).Where the paper says it
DARWIN
The paper shows that for a fixed DM mass, a larger gauge coupling gϕ is required to reproduce the correct relic density as the reheating temperature TRH decreases. This behaviour follows from the exponential suppression of the DM production rate at lower TRH. p. 1 Hence, in principle, one
can assume TRH as low as O(10) MeV. In such a scenario, when the reheating temperature
is smaller than the DM mass (m), only a sub-fraction of the particles annihilating to DM
can potentially generate DM that lies in the tail of the Boltzmann distribution function
with energy ≫ TRH and the overall DM production rate becomes suppressed by exp (−m/T)
[17]. 2(b) we showcase the variation YDM with different
values of gϕ for a fixed TRH = 100 GeV, the cyan, red, and blue lines correspond to gϕ =
5 × 10−8
, 5 × 10−7 and 5 × 10−6
. Needless to say, with an increase in the coupling gϕ, the
relevant collision terms increase as ∼ g
2
ϕ
, leading to an enhanced density of DM.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Results
The results show that for a fixed DM mass, a larger gauge coupling gϕ is required to reproduce the correct relic density as the reheating temperature TRH decreases. We find that with higher gauge coupling (gϕ) and the mixing angle (sin β), the DM abundances increase as these parameters directly control the production cross-section. p. 9 8)
These conditions impose constraints on gϕ and sin β for a benchmark mX and mη. Apart
from the invisible decay, Higgs signal strength measurements impose a weaker constraint on
mixing angle, which restricts sin β < 0. Indeed the scalar-annihilation channels, such as ηη →
XiXi and hη → XiXi
, increasing mη can increase the typical √
s and hence leads to a
Boltzmann suppression through K1(
√
s/T). However, the growth of YDM with mη is not
a purely kinematic phase-space effect, but rather a benchmark-dependent result due to the
interplay among scalar amplitudes and thermal suppression factors. As mentioned earlier, we are interested in the paradigm where DM mass is larger than
TRH, which leads to a Boltzmann-suppressed freeze-in production rate. As a result, such a
scenario requires a comparatively larger coupling, allowing us to explore a new parameter
regime with rich phenomenological insights.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Enhanced parameter space exploration for freeze-in dark matter systems by systematically mapping DM mass versus gauge coupling against reheating temperature and mediator masses using numerical solutions to the Boltzmann equation (eq 3.1).
-
Improved constraint evaluation for direct detection experiments by providing specific limits on the spin independent scattering cross section sigma SI based on the SU(2)HS model and comparing it against existing bounds from LZ and PandaX-4T experiments.
-
Refined indirect detection capability by calculating thermal average annihilation cross sections specifically for the XiXi to W+W- channel as a function of DM mass and reheating temperature, allowing for more precise comparison with Fermi-LAT and AMS constraints.
-
Development of a predictive model for required DM couplings in low reheating temperature regimes, identifying how the need to overcome Boltzmann suppression (exp (-mDM/TRH)) dictates larger coupling strengths.
-
Automated constraint checking against theoretical consistency conditions, such as perturbativity and vacuum stability bounds derived from scalar potential parameters like lambda H and lambda phi.
Abstract
The freeze-in mechanism for dark matter (DM) requires extremely feeble interactions with the Standard Model (SM), preventing thermal equilibrium in the early Universe and typically evading experimental detection. However, for sufficiently low reheating temperatures (T RH), the observed relic abundance can be realized with larger couplings, opening prospects for experimental searches. In this work, we investigate freeze-in production of SU(2) HS vector dark matter (VDM) in a low- T RH cosmology. The framework naturally contains three mass-degenerate stable VDM candidates without the need for any additional discrete symmetry. We perform a systematic study of the dark matter phenomenology and identify the parameter space consistent with the observed relic abundance. We work with the approximation of instantaneous reheating and consider the DM abundance to be negligible at T RH. In contrast to conventional freeze-in scenarios, the required DM couplings can be sizable, rendering part of the parameter space already constrained by existing direct searches like PandaX-4T and LZ, while a significant region remains within the reach of future experiments such as DARWIN. Though one can realize the freeze-in mechanism for an abelian U(1) X vector DM models as well, we find that the non-abelian structure of the SU(2) HS scenario leads to a distinct feature due to a larger number of dark matter particles, resulting in an enlarged viable parameter space due to the multiplicity of dark matter states.
Sources
- Planck 2018 results. VI. Cosmological parameters
- Dark Matter Candidates from Particle Physics and Methods of Detection
- The Waning of the WIMP? A Review of Models, Searches, and Constraints
- WIMP dark matter candidates and searches - current status and future prospects
- Dark Matter Results From 54-Ton-Day Exposure of PandaX-II Experiment
- Dark matter direct search sensitivity of the PandaX-4T experiment
- Projected WIMP Sensitivity of the XENONnT Dark Matter Experiment
- Search for dark matter annihilations towards the inner Galactic halo from 10 years of observations with H.E.S.S
- Search for dark matter and other new phenomena in events with an energetic jet and large missing transverse momentum using the ATLAS detector
- Freeze-In Production of FIMP Dark Matter
- The Dawn of FIMP Dark Matter: A Review of Models and Constraints
- Freeze-in at stronger coupling
- From WIMPs to FIMPs with Low Reheating Temperatures
- Gravitational production of sterile neutrinos
- Higgs portal vector dark matter at a low reheating temperature
- Higgs Portal Dark Matter Freeze-in at Stronger Coupling: Observational Benchmarks
- Minimal Dark Matter Freeze-in with Low Reheating Temperatures and Implications for Direct Detection
- $Z^\prime$-mediated dark matter freeze-in at stronger coupling
- $Z'$-Mediated Dark Matter with Low-Temperature Reheating
- Probing displaced (dark)photons from low reheating freeze-in at the LHC
Related papers
- MadNIS at NLO
- The NANOGrav 15-year data set: A Limit on Continuous Spin Gravitons
- DIS-secting the universe with high-energy neutrinos
- Crowdsourcing Gravitational Waves from Superradiant Axions
- Classification of g-modes for neutron stars with a strong transition: Novel universal relation including slow stable hybrid stars
- Scalar axion field of toroidal electromagnetic pulses