Semileptonic sum rules in heavy-to-light charm decays

arXiv:2605.21908 · hep-ph, hep-ex · Submitted 2026-05-21 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Semileptonic sum rules in heavy-to-light charm decays".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We investigate semileptonic sum rules in heavy-to-light charm decays to check for consistency with Standard Model predictions and constrain new physics effects.

Kai: The relation can therefore provide a useful consistency check of charm semileptonic measurements.

Mira: Quark and lepton flavor transitions in semileptonic hadron decays provide important tests of the Standard Model (SM) and sensitive probes of new physics.

Kai: Such relations have recently been developed in studies of bottom-hadron semileptonic decays.

Title and authors: Kai: We're starting with the title and who wrote this paper, "Semileptonic sum rules in heavy-to-light charm decays". It’s a straightforward title, but it points to the core of the research.

Mira: The authors are KEK Theory Center people—Motoi Endoa, Syuhei Iguroc, Satoshi Mishimae, Takeru Uchiyamaf and Ryoutaro Watanabe—who are deeply involved in heavy flavor physics at KEK.

Lev: Their expertise is in the theory of particles and how they connect it to experimental observables. They know what’s going on at the LHCb and Belle II experiments, which is where these measurements come from.

Kai: They are motivated by finding ways to test the Standard Model against new physics effects by looking at quark flavor transitions like charm decays, which are often sensitive probes.

Mira: The motivation here is that we already have these relations developed in bottom hadron decays, and the authors want to see if those exact same relationships can be constructed for charm quarks.

Lev: That’s a big leap because the heavy-to-light relation isn't known to follow directly from heavy-quark symmetry, which is what usually guarantees these simple relations in bottom systems.

Kai: So they are essentially asking: if it works in bottom, does it work here? They are focusing on c to d lepton flavor universality ratios.

Mira: The focus is very specific: they examine the relation among the lepton-flavor universality ratios R mu e H for D to pion, D to rho, and Lambda charm to neutron decays.

Lev: That's a concrete set of channels they are using. They aren't just looking at one decay mode; they are combining three different hadronic modes into one test.

Kai: So the implication is that if this sum rule works for charm, it gives us a powerful new consistency check for our understanding of flavor transitions in the Standard Model.

Mira: It’s about checking if we have a consistent picture when we extend our analysis from bottom to charm quarks.

Lev: If they can build a predictive sum rule here, it means we can put much sharper limits on new physics operators affecting these charm decays than just looking at individual branching ratios.

The paper's summary: Kai: Now let’s talk about what the paper actually found in "Semileptonic sum rules in heavy-to-light charm decays". They are setting up a linear combination of those three ratios, delta, which they write as a function of the ratios R and some coefficients alpha and beta.

Mira: They define delta as being equal to R mu e H times some combinations of the D to pi, D to rho, and Lambda charm to neutron terms, with those alpha and beta parameters.

Lev: So they are trying to create a structure where if an exact sum rule exists, this delta combination vanishes for any choice of those coefficients. That’s the mathematical goal here.

Kai: The paper then shows that if an exact sum rule exists, you can choose alpha and beta independently of the Wilson coefficients such that delta goes to zero no matter what they are.

Mira: The numerical study then takes this structural idea and combines it with current constraints on those Wilson coefficients to estimate the possible size of violations. They find that the residual violation allowed by current bounds is at most at the percent level.

Lev: So they’re taking a theoretical structure—the vanishing sum rule—and putting it into a real world context where new physics might be small, and seeing how big that still allows the violation to be.

Kai: The key result here is that they are using this cancellation measure to predict the unmeasured ratio R mu e n. This prediction shows how much we can constrain it based on the inputs they’ve used.

Mira: They show that for delta as a function of alpha, there's a nontrivial cancellation of the residual violation in charm decays. It’s less efficient than bottom transitions, but it still gives us something to work with.

Lev: The fact that it's less efficient is important because it sets expectations for how much better this tool will be for other quarks later on.

Kai: So, in summary, they’ve shown that the charm case has a nontrivial cancellation of the residual violation, which is something we needed to know about these transitions.

The paper's improvements: Mira: The authors suggest several improvements they could make to their work. They are focusing on making the analysis more robust by incorporating more information into the sum rule itself.

Lev: What kind of structural changes are they proposing? Are we talking about changing how delta is defined, or something else?

Kai: They suggest improving the ability to predict charm decay ratios based on lepton-flavor universality by using an equation they call equation four point four. This new way lets them calculate R mu e n using experimental values for R mu e p and R mu e r, while incorporating that residual sum rule violation delta.

Mira: That sounds like a way to use the measured ratios from other decays, like D to pion and D to rho, as inputs into the prediction for the unmeasured neutron decay ratio.

Lev: If they can successfully incorporate delta into that equation four point four, it means they are making the new physics constraint more directly usable in a predictive way.

Kai: They also suggest enhancing the constraint analysis for New Physics by combining Wilson coefficient bounds with the cancellation measure epsilonkl to determine if a given set of Wilson coefficients allows for a violation below the percent level based on figure four and its associated constraints.

Mira: That means they are essentially creating a tool that lets us check if our current NP bounds are tight enough using this new structure.

Lev: That’s an important step because it moves it from just being a calculation to actually constraining the parameter space of new physics operators, which is what we really need to know.

Kai: They also suggest a method for quantifying the uncertainty for new physics predictions by using the derived form factor uncertainties and experimental input ranges. This helps determine that the final prediction uncertainty is dominated by inputs like R mu e p and R mu e r.

Mira: So they are acknowledging that while the precision is limited, they’re trying to quantify exactly where that limitation comes from so we know what’s driving the error.

Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up on "Semileptonic sum rules in heavy-to-light charm decays". The main point is that charm exhibits a nontrivial cancellation of the residual violation. They found this cancellation is less efficient than in bottom transitions, but it's still useful over a broad range of parameters.

Mira: So, they’ve shown that even with these limitations, the actual violation stays at most at the percent level and remains smaller than present experimental uncertainties for those mesonic inputs.

Lev: I think what this means is that we have a solid handle on where to look next—where the paper suggests we should focus our experimental effort on measuring things like lambda charm to neutron decay more precisely.

Kai: The whole point of this paper is to provide a useful consistency check for charm semileptonic measurements against Standard Model predictions, and it helps us understand potential new physics effects.

Mira: It’s a good piece of work because it gives us a concrete prediction with about four percent uncertainty for that neutron decay ratio, which is a tangible target.

Lev: And I just want to say that the whole thing hinges on having good form factor calculations if we want to take this prediction seriously for setting new physics limits.

Motoi Endoa, Syuhei Iguroc, Satoshi Mishimae, Takeru Uchiyamaf, Ryoutaro Watanabeg

KEK Theory Center · Graduate Institute for Advanced Studies SOKENDAI · Institute for Advanced Research Nagoya University Department of Liberal Arts Saitama Medical University Department of Physics Nagoya University Kobayashi-Maskawa Institute for the Origin of Particles and the Universe Nagoya University Institute of Particle Physics and Key Laboratory of Quark and Lepton Physics MOE Central China Normal University

hep-ph, hep-ex

Submitted: 2026-05-21

Updated: 2026-11-09

Comments: 27 pages, 6 figures, 2 tables, version published in PRD

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 78/100

The gist: We investigate semileptonic sum rules in heavy-to-light charm decays to check for consistency with Standard Model predictions and constrain new physics effects.

Key concepts

Semileptonic Sum Rules
These are mathematical relationships derived from heavy-to-light hadron decays that connect different decay rates. They are used to test the Standard Model by comparing predictions derived from these rules with experimental measurements, helping to search for discrepancies caused by new physics.
Lepton-Flavor Universality Ratios (R_X)
These ratios compare the decay rates involving different leptons, such as electron ($ ext{e}$) and muon ($ ext{ u}$), for a given quark transition. They are sensitive probes of lepton flavor universality; deviations from unity in these ratios could signal new physics beyond the Standard Model.
Cancellation Measure ($oldsymbol{eta}$)
This is a specific linear combination constructed from various normalized ratios designed to cancel out contributions from certain Standard Model parameters (Wilson coefficients). The goal is to create a relation where the residual violation, which would otherwise be large, is minimized or canceled out.
Wilson Coefficients ($oldsymbol{C}$)
These are fundamental parameters in quantum field theory that encode the short-distance effects of new physics. They determine the strength and nature of interactions between quarks and leptons. The analysis uses bounds on these coefficients to estimate the possible size of new physics violations.

Terminology

Summary

We investigate semileptonic sum rules in heavy-to-light charm decays to check for consistency with Standard Model predictions and constrain new physics effects. p. 0

Where the paper says it

KEK–TH–2838 Semileptonic sum rules in heavy-to-light charm decays Motoi Endoa,b , Syuhei Iguroc,d , Satoshi Mishimae , Takeru Uchiyamaf and Ryoutaro Watanabeg aKEK Theory Center, IPNS, KEK, Tsukuba 305–0801, Japan bGraduate Institute for Advanced Studies, SOKENDAI, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305–0801, Japan c Institute for Advanced Research (IAR), Nagoya University, Nagoya 464–8601, Japan dKobayashi-Maskawa Institute (KMI) for the Origin of Particles and the Universe, Nagoya University, Nagoya 464–8602, Japan eDepartment of Liberal Arts, Saitama Medical University, Moroyama, Saitama 350-0495, Japan fDepartment of Physics, Nagoya University, Nagoya 464-8602, Japan g Institute of Particle Physics and Key Laboratory of Quark and Lepton Physics (MOE), Central China Normal University, Wuhan, Hubei 430079, China Abstract We investigate semileptonic sum rules in heavy-to-light charm decays, motivated by analogous relations in b → c and b → u transitions. Focusing on the c → dℓν decays, D → πℓν, D → ρℓν, and Λc → nℓν, we examine a relation among their lepton-flavor universality ratios R µe H .

The relation can therefore provide a useful consistency check of charm semileptonic measurements. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Although the charm sum rule is less precise than the relations in bottom-hadron decays, current low-energy and high-pT constraints on new physics restrict the actual deviation from the relation to below the percent level. The relation can therefore provide a useful consistency check of charm semileptonic measurements.

Motivation and Context

Quark and lepton flavor transitions in semileptonic hadron decays provide important tests of the Standard Model (SM) and sensitive probes of new physics. Such relations have recently been developed in studies of bottom-hadron semileptonic decays. p. 1

Where the paper says it

These efforts motivate both studies of possible NP effects and complementary tests based on relations among different processes. Such relations have recently been developed in studies of bottom-hadron semileptonic decays [10–18].

A key feature is that certain combinations of the ratios RHc = BR(Hb → Hcτν)/BR(Hb → Hclν) for l = e, µ become almost insensitive to NP contributions. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In particular, explicit sum rules have been found among processes such as B → D(∗) τν and Λb → Λcτν. A key feature is that certain combinations of the ratios RHc = BR(Hb → Hcτν)/BR(Hb → Hcℓν) for ℓ = e, µ become almost insensitive to NP contributions.

This feature raises the question whether similar relations can be constructed for other quark-flavor transitions. p. 2
Where the paper says it

This feature raises the question whether similar relations can be constructed for other quark-flavor transitions. A numerical study of b → u semitauonic transitions was performed in Ref.

Sum Rule Construction and Cancellation

The authors focus on examining a relation among the lepton-flavor universality ratios RµeH. Focusing on the c → dlν decays, D → πlν, D → ρlν, and Λc → nlν. p. 0

Where the paper says it

KEK–TH–2838 Semileptonic sum rules in heavy-to-light charm decays Motoi Endoa,b , Syuhei Iguroc,d , Satoshi Mishimae , Takeru Uchiyamaf and Ryoutaro Watanabeg aKEK Theory Center, IPNS, KEK, Tsukuba 305–0801, Japan bGraduate Institute for Advanced Studies, SOKENDAI, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305–0801, Japan c Institute for Advanced Research (IAR), Nagoya University, Nagoya 464–8601, Japan dKobayashi-Maskawa Institute (KMI) for the Origin of Particles and the Universe, Nagoya University, Nagoya 464–8602, Japan eDepartment of Liberal Arts, Saitama Medical University, Moroyama, Saitama 350-0495, Japan fDepartment of Physics, Nagoya University, Nagoya 464-8602, Japan g Institute of Particle Physics and Key Laboratory of Quark and Lepton Physics (MOE), Central China Normal University, Wuhan, Hubei 430079, China Abstract We investigate semileptonic sum rules in heavy-to-light charm decays, motivated by analogous relations in b → c and b → u transitions. Focusing on the c → dℓν decays, D → πℓν, D → ρℓν, and Λc → nℓν, we examine a relation among their lepton-flavor universality ratios R µe H .

They construct a linear combination of the three normalized ratios which can be written as δ = RnRSM n − α RπRSM π − β RρRSM ρ=XklδklDµkDµ∗l. p. 5
Where the paper says it

In contrast, the |CT | 2 terms tend to be large, reflecting the factor of 8 multiplying the tensor contribution in the differential decay rates in Eqs. We construct a linear combination of the three normalized ratios, which can be written as δ = Rn RSM n − α Rπ RSM π − β Rρ RSM ρ = X kl δklD µ kD µ∗ l , (3.

If an exact sum rule exists, one can choose α and β independently of the Wilson coefficients such that δ vanishes for arbitrary values of the coefficients. p. 5
Where the paper says it

6) where k, l = VL, SL, SR, T. If an exact sum rule exists, one can choose α and β independently of the Wilson coefficients such that δ vanishes for arbitrary values of the coefficients.

Phenomenological Implications

The analysis combines the cancellation measure with current constraints on Wilson coefficients to estimate the possible size of violations. The preceding analysis shows that the residual violation allowed by the current bounds on the Wilson coefficients is at most at the percent level. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Although the cancellation at the coefficient level in the previous section is weaker than that in the bottom transitions, the actual violation of the sum rule also depends on the allowed size of the Wilson coefficients. We therefore combine the α scan described above with the current constraints on the Wilson coefficients.

As an application, they use the relation to predict the yet-unmeasured ratio Rµe n. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The relation can therefore provide a useful consistency check of charm semileptonic measurements. As an application, we derive a prediction for the yet-unmeasured ratio R µe n in Λc → nℓν.

Conclusion and Outlook

The study concludes that the charm case exhibits a nontrivial cancellation of the residual violation. Although this cancellation is less efficient compared to bottom transitions, the scan over α shows that the charm relation remains useful over a broad range of α. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Although the charm sum rule is less precise than the relations in bottom-hadron decays, current low-energy and high-pT constraints on new physics restrict the actual deviation from the relation to below the percent level. The relation can therefore provide a useful consistency check of charm semileptonic measurements.

The resulting prediction has an uncertainty of about 4%, providing a useful target for future measurements of Λc → nlν. p. 0
Where the paper says it

The relation can therefore provide a useful consistency check of charm semileptonic measurements. As an application, we derive a prediction for the yet-unmeasured ratio R µe n in Λc → nℓν.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

The relation can therefore provide a useful consistency check of charm semileptonic measurements. As an application, we derive a prediction for the yet-unmeasured ratio R µe n in Λc → nℓν.

Form Factor Details

The appendix summarizes the form factors and helicity amplitudes used in the analysis. For the D → π transition, they use the result of LQCD [38,39]. p. 2

Where the paper says it

In contrast, no experimental result has yet been reported for the baryonic process Λc → nℓν. On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40].

For the D → ρ transition, they adopt LCSR results of Ref. p. 6
Where the paper says it

We evaluate δkl and ϵkl for the reference choice of α. The results for the c → d transition are shown in the first row of Tables 1 and 2.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

We evaluate δkl and ϵkl for the reference choice of α. The results for the c → d transition are shown in the first row of Tables 1 and 2.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

We evaluate δkl and ϵkl for the reference choice of α. The results for the c → d transition are shown in the first row of Tables 1 and 2.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

We evaluate δkl and ϵkl for the reference choice of α. The results for the c → d transition are shown in the first row of Tables 1 and 2.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

We evaluate δkl and ϵkl for the reference choice of α. The results for the c → d transition are shown in the first row of Tables 1 and 2.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

We evaluate δkl and ϵkl for the reference choice of α. The results for the c → d transition are shown in the first row of Tables 1 and 2.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

We evaluate δkl and ϵkl for the reference choice of α. The results for the c → d transition are shown in the first row of Tables 1 and 2.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

We evaluate δkl and ϵkl for the reference choice of α. The results for the c → d transition are shown in the first row of Tables 1 and 2.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

We evaluate δkl and ϵkl for the reference choice of α. The results for the c → d transition are shown in the first row of Tables 1 and 2.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

We evaluate δkl and ϵkl for the reference choice of α. The results for the c → d transition are shown in the first row of Tables 1 and 2.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

We evaluate δkl and ϵkl for the reference choice of α. The results for the c → d transition are shown in the first row of Tables 1 and 2.

[42]. For the Λc → n form factors, they use the LQCD result [40]. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In contrast, no experimental result has yet been reported for the baryonic process Λc → nℓν. On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In contrast, no experimental result has yet been reported for the baryonic process Λc → nℓν. On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In contrast, no experimental result has yet been reported for the baryonic process Λc → nℓν. On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In contrast, no experimental result has yet been reported for the baryonic process Λc → nℓν. On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In contrast, no experimental result has yet been reported for the baryonic process Λc → nℓν. On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In contrast, no experimental result has yet been reported for the baryonic process Λc → nℓν. On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In contrast, no experimental result has yet been reported for the baryonic process Λc → nℓν. On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In contrast, no experimental result has yet been reported for the baryonic process Λc → nℓν. On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In contrast, no experimental result has yet been reported for the baryonic process Λc → nℓν. On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In contrast, no experimental result has yet been reported for the baryonic process Λc → nℓν. On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In contrast, no experimental result has yet been reported for the baryonic process Λc → nℓν. On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40].

For the D → ρ form factors, they follow Ref. p. 2
Where the paper says it

A numerical study of b → u semitauonic transitions was performed in Ref. #2 In contrast to the b → c case, this heavy-to-light relation is not known to follow from heavy-quark symmetry.

[42] and use relations based on heavy-quark symmetry. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The origin of these relations in b → c transitions has been clarified in Ref. [17] from the viewpoint of heavy-quark symmetry.

For the baryonic decay, they use the LQCD result [40]. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In contrast, no experimental result has yet been reported for the baryonic process Λc → nℓν. On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40].

For the D → π transition, they use the form factor definitions [43]. p. 2
Where the paper says it

In this work, we use the LCSR input for D → ρ. With these experimental data and form factor inputs, the sum rule studied here provides a consistency check among the charm semileptonic ratios.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In this work, we use the LCSR input for D → ρ. With these experimental data and form factor inputs, the sum rule studied here provides a consistency check among the charm semileptonic ratios.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In this work, we use the LCSR input for D → ρ. With these experimental data and form factor inputs, the sum rule studied here provides a consistency check among the charm semileptonic ratios.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In this work, we use the LCSR input for D → ρ. With these experimental data and form factor inputs, the sum rule studied here provides a consistency check among the charm semileptonic ratios.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In this work, we use the LCSR input for D → ρ. With these experimental data and form factor inputs, the sum rule studied here provides a consistency check among the charm semileptonic ratios.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In this work, we use the LCSR input for D → ρ. With these experimental data and form factor inputs, the sum rule studied here provides a consistency check among the charm semileptonic ratios.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In this work, we use the LCSR input for D → ρ. With these experimental data and form factor inputs, the sum rule studied here provides a consistency check among the charm semileptonic ratios.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In this work, we use the LCSR input for D → ρ. With these experimental data and form factor inputs, the sum rule studied here provides a consistency check among the charm semileptonic ratios.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In this work, we use the LCSR input for D → ρ. With these experimental data and form factor inputs, the sum rule studied here provides a consistency check among the charm semileptonic ratios.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

In this work, we use the LCSR input for D → ρ. With these experimental data and form factor inputs, the sum rule studied here provides a consistency check among the charm semileptonic ratios.

For the D → ρ transition, they adopt LCSR results of Ref. [42]. For the tensor form factors, no direct LCSR or lattice determination is available. p. 2
Where the paper says it

On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40]. For D → ρ, an early LQCD study treated the ρ meson as a stable particle [41], while a light-cone sum-rule (LCSR) calculation is also available [42].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40]. For D → ρ, an early LQCD study treated the ρ meson as a stable particle [41], while a light-cone sum-rule (LCSR) calculation is also available [42].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40]. For D → ρ, an early LQCD study treated the ρ meson as a stable particle [41], while a light-cone sum-rule (LCSR) calculation is also available [42].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40]. For D → ρ, an early LQCD study treated the ρ meson as a stable particle [41], while a light-cone sum-rule (LCSR) calculation is also available [42].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40]. For D → ρ, an early LQCD study treated the ρ meson as a stable particle [41], while a light-cone sum-rule (LCSR) calculation is also available [42].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40]. For D → ρ, an early LQCD study treated the ρ meson as a stable particle [41], while a light-cone sum-rule (LCSR) calculation is also available [42].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40]. For D → ρ, an early LQCD study treated the ρ meson as a stable particle [41], while a light-cone sum-rule (LCSR) calculation is also available [42].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40]. For D → ρ, an early LQCD study treated the ρ meson as a stable particle [41], while a light-cone sum-rule (LCSR) calculation is also available [42].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40]. For D → ρ, an early LQCD study treated the ρ meson as a stable particle [41], while a light-cone sum-rule (LCSR) calculation is also available [42].

p. 2
Where the paper says it

On the theoretical side, lattice QCD (LQCD) results are available for D → π [38, 39] and Λc → n [40]. For D → ρ, an early LQCD study treated the ρ meson as a stable particle [41], while a light-cone sum-rule (LCSR) calculation is also available [42].

For the D → ρ transition, they use relations based on heavy-quark symmetry. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The origin of these relations in b → c transitions has been clarified in Ref. [17] from the viewpoint of heavy-quark symmetry.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

The origin of these relations in b → c transitions has been clarified in Ref. [17] from the viewpoint of heavy-quark symmetry.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

The origin of these relations in b → c transitions has been clarified in Ref. [17] from the viewpoint of heavy-quark symmetry.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

The origin of these relations in b → c transitions has been clarified in Ref. [17] from the viewpoint of heavy-quark symmetry.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

The origin of these relations in b → c transitions has been clarified in Ref. [17] from the viewpoint of heavy-quark symmetry.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

The origin of these relations in b → c transitions has been clarified in Ref. [17] from the viewpoint of heavy-quark symmetry.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

The origin of these relations in b → c transitions has been clarified in Ref. [17] from the viewpoint of heavy-quark symmetry.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

The origin of these relations in b → c transitions has been clarified in Ref. [17] from the viewpoint of heavy-quark symmetry.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

The origin of these relations in b → c transitions has been clarified in Ref. [17] from the viewpoint of heavy-quark symmetry.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

The origin of these relations in b → c transitions has been clarified in Ref. [17] from the viewpoint of heavy-quark symmetry.

For the Λc → n form factors, they use the LQCD result [40]. For the D → π transition, they use the form factor definitions [43]. For the D → ρ transition, they adopt LCSR results of Ref. [42]. For the tensor form factors, no direct LCSR or lattice determination is available. For the D → ρ transition, they use relations based on heavy-quark symmetry. For the Λc → n form factors, they use the LQCD result [40]. For the D → π transition, they use the form factor definitions [43]. For the D → ρ transition, they adopt LCSR results of Ref. [42]. For the tensor form factors, no direct LCSR or lattice determination is available. For the D → ρ transition, they use relations based on heavy-quark symmetry. For the Λc → n form factors, they use the LQCD result [40]. For the D → π transition, they use the form factor definitions [43]. For the D → ρ transition, they adopt LCSR results of Ref. [42]. For the tensor form factors, no direct LCSR or lattice determination is available. For the D → ρ transition, they use relations based on heavy-quark symmetry. For the Λc → n form factors, they use the LQCD result [40]. For the D → π transition, they use the form factor definitions [43]. For the D → ρ transition, they adopt LCSR results of Ref. [42]. For the tensor form factors, no direct LCSR or lattice determination is available. For the D → ρ transition, they use relations based on heavy-quark symmetry. For the Λc → n form factors, they use the LQCD result [40]. For the D → π transition, they use the form factor definitions [43]. For the D → ρ transition, they adopt LCSR results of Ref. [42]. For the tensor form factors, no direct LCSR or lattice determination is available. For the D → ρ transition, they use relations based on heavy-quark symmetry. For the Λc → n form factors, they use the LQCD result [40]. For the D → π transition, they use the form factor definitions [43]. For the D → ρ transition, they adopt LCSR results of Ref. [42]. For the tensor form factors, no direct LCSR or lattice determination is available. For the D → ρ transition, they use relations based on heavy-quark symmetry. For the Λc → n form factors, they use the LQCD result [40]. For the D → π transition, they use the form factor definitions [43]. For the D → ρ transition, they adopt LCSR results of Ref. [42]. For the tensor form factors, no direct LCSR or lattice determination is available. For the D → ρ transition, they use relations based on heavy-quark symmetry. For the Λc → n form factors, they use the LQCD result [40]. For the D → π transition, they use the form factor definitions [43]. For the D → ρ transition, they adopt LCSR results of Ref. [42]. For the tensor form factors, no direct LCSR or lattice determination is available. For the D → ρ transition, they use relations based on heavy-quark symmetry. For the Λc → n form factors, they use the LQCD result [40]. For the D → π transition, they use the form factor definitions [43]. For the D → ρ transition, they adopt LCSR results of Ref. [42]. For the tensor form factors, no direct LCSR or lattice determination is available. For the D → ρ transition, they use relations based on heavy-quark symmetry. For the Λc → n form factors, they use the LQCD result [40].

Numerical Formulae and Constraints

The numerical formulae RµeH. are given by (3. p. 3

Where the paper says it

Throughout this paper, the Wilson coefficients are evaluated at µ = 2 GeV unless otherwise stated. 2 Decay rate For D → π −ℓν, the differential decay rate is given by dΓ(D → πℓν) dq2 = G2 F |Vcd| 2 192π 3 q 2 m3 D p λπ 1 − ρ 2 ℓ 2 × |1 + C ℓ VL | 2 1 + 1 2 ρ 2 ℓ (H π V,0 ) 2 + 3 2 ρ 2 ℓ (H π V,t) 2 + 3 2 |C ℓ SL + C ℓ SR | 2 (H π S ) 2 + 8 |C ℓ T | 2 (1 + 2ρ 2 ℓ )(H π T ) 2 − 3 Re (1 + C ℓ VL )(C ℓ SL + C ℓ SR ) ∗ ρℓH π SH π V,t − 12 Re (1 + C ℓ VL )C ℓ∗ T ρℓH π V,0H π T , (2.

1) where Hc and Hd denote the charm and down hadrons, respectively. p. 5
Where the paper says it

where Hc and Hd denote the charm and down hadrons, respectively. Since NP contributions are assumed only in the muon mode, the normalized ratios R µe Hd /Rµe,SM Hd are equivalent to the normalized muon-mode branching fractions and can be written as R µe X R µe,SM X = X ij a X ijD µ i D µ∗ j , (3.

The normalized ratios RµeX Rµe,SM X=Xij aXijDµi Dµ∗j. p. 5
Where the paper says it

where Hc and Hd denote the charm and down hadrons, respectively. Since NP contributions are assumed only in the muon mode, the normalized ratios R µe Hd /Rµe,SM Hd are equivalent to the normalized muon-mode branching fractions and can be written as R µe X R µe,SM X = X ij a X ijD µ i D µ∗ j , (3.

The numerical formulae are given by (3. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The hadronic amplitudes Hπ are functions of the form factors given explicitly in Appendix A. Compared with the formulae for b → clν transitions [14, 43], the CP-conjugate ℓν final state leads to the opposite sign for the scalar-vector interference terms.

3) Rµe πRµe, SM π= 1 + CµVL2 − 0. p. 2
Where the paper says it

For the D → ρ − channel, the electron mode has been measured by CLEO [30, 33] and BESIII [34, 35], while the muon mode is currently available only from BESIII [36]. A direct estimate of the lepton-flavor universality ratio is currently available only for D → π −, where Rµe π = BR(D0 → π −µν)/BR(D0 → π −eν) shows a mild deviation from the SM prediction at the 1.

39 Re[(1 + CµVL)Cµ∗SR] − 0.39 Re[(1 + CµVL)Cµ∗SL] + 3.94 Re[CµSLCµ∗SR] + 1.97 (CµSL2 + CµSR2) + 0.47 Re[(1 + CµVL)Cµ∗T] + 1.16 CµT2, (3.3).

Phenomenological Constraints and Prediction

The allowed violation is at most at the percent level. The sum-rule prediction for Rµe n as a function of α is shown in Figure 4. p. 2

Where the paper says it

We also compare the size of the sum rule violation with those in b → clν and b → ulν decays for l = e, µ, τ . 4, we discuss phenomenological implications of the violation under current constraints and present a sum rule prediction for Rµe n .

The resulting prediction has an uncertainty of about 4%, providing a useful target for future measurements of Λc → nlν.

Summary and Discussion

The authors found that the charm case exhibits a nontrivial cancellation of the residual violation. Although this cancellation is less efficient compared to b → c and b → u transitions, the scan over α shows that the charm relation remains useful over a broad range of α. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Although the charm sum rule is less precise than the relations in bottom-hadron decays, current low-energy and high-pT constraints on new physics restrict the actual deviation from the relation to below the percent level. The relation can therefore provide a useful consistency check of charm semileptonic measurements.

The actual violation is at most at the percent level and remains smaller than the present experimental uncertainties in the mesonic inputs. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Focusing on the c → dℓν decays, D → πℓν, D → ρℓν, and Λc → nℓν, we examine a relation among their lepton-flavor universality ratios R µe H . Although the charm sum rule is less precise than the relations in bottom-hadron decays, current low-energy and high-pT constraints on new physics restrict the actual deviation from the relation to below the percent level.

Acknowledgements

The authors thank Hiroyasu Yonaha, Andreas Crivellin and Teppei Kitahara for the inspiring and encouraging discussions. The work of S. p. 2

Where the paper says it

It is therefore natural to ask whether a similar relation can appear in charm decays. In this work, we address this question by focusing on c → dℓν transitions.

I. is also supported by Toyoaki scholarship foundation. p. 8
Where the paper says it

In summary, the analysis in this section shows that a cancellation in the sum rule construction is present also in the c → d case, although it is weaker than that in the bottom transitions. This conclusion is supported both by the reference choice δVLSL = 0 and by the scan over α.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved ability to predict charm decay ratios based on lepton-flavor universality by using Eq (4.4). The system can calculate Rmuen using experimental values for Rmuep and Rmuer, incorporating the residual sum rule violation delta.

  2. Enhanced constraint analysis for New Physics by combining Wilson coefficient bounds with the cancellation measure epsilonkl. The system can determine if a given set of Wilson coefficients allows for a violation below the percent level based on Fig 4 and its associated constraints.

  3. Quantitative uncertainty estimation for new physics predictions in charm decays by using the derived form factor uncertainties and experimental input ranges. The system can calculate the final prediction uncertainty, noting that it is dominated by mesonic inputs like Rmuer,ex rho.

  4. Identification of regions where cancellation efficiency is poor for specific operator combinations based on Eq (3.8) and Fig 2/4 analysis. The system can flag specific operator combinations such as SRSL, VLT, and T T as having larger residual violations in the charm case compared to bottom transitions.

Abstract

We investigate semileptonic sum rules in heavy-to-light charm decays, motivated by analogous relations in b to c and b to u transitions. Focusing on the c to d ν decays, D to π ν, D to ρ ν, and Λ c to n ν, we examine a relation among their lepton-flavor universality ratios R H μe. Although the charm sum rule is less precise than the relations in bottom-hadron decays, current low-energy and high- p T constraints on new physics restrict the actual deviation from the relation to below the percent level. The relation can therefore provide a useful consistency check of charm semileptonic measurements. As an application, we derive a prediction for the yet-unmeasured ratio R n μe, in Λ c to n ν.

Sources

Related papers