Conductivity of a Non-Galilean--Invariant Fermi Liquid: Exact Solution of the Kinetic Equation
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Conductivity of a Non-Galilean--Invariant Fermi Liquid".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We obtain an exact expression for the conductivity of a non-Galilean-invariant Fermi liquid with impurities by solving the kinetic equation with both screened Coulomb and z = 3 Pomeranchuk critical interactions The exact solution yields the optical response in the hydrodynamic regime, which is inaccessible within perturbation theory Near a z = 3 Pomeranchuk quantum critical point, consistency between the kinetic-equation and Kubo approaches requires proper inclusion of mass renormalization within the Eliashberg approximation.
Kai: Key Findings on Crossovers The low-T/high-T crossover in the dc resistivity and the collisionless/hydrodynamic crossover in the optical conductivity are controlled by τee/τi and omegaτee, respectively.
Mira: In particular, in the dc case we find that δρ(T) ≪ ρi throughout the temperature range of the Fermi-liquid regime.
Kai: The low-T/high-T crossover in the dc resistivity and the collisionless/hydrodynamic crossover in the optical conductivity are controlled by τee/τi and omegaτee, respectively.
Paper summary: Kai: So, wrapping up this paper "Conductivity of a Non-Galilean--Invariant Fermi Liquid: Exact Solution of the Kinetic Equation," it claims that by solving the kinetic equation exactly for both screened Coulomb and z equals three Pomeranchuk critical interactions, they get an exact expression for the conductivity <ref:2605.21774#pg1>.
Mira: The main thing is that electron-electron interactions only affect the conductivity through the quasiparticle scattering time, tau ee <ref:2605.21774#pg2>, and this is shown to be true for both models specified, Coulomb and Hertz-Millis <ref:2605.21774#pg3>.
Lev: The paper shows that near a quantum critical point, the quasiparticle scattering rate can become Planckian, meaning one over tau ee becomes proportional to energy <ref:2605.21774#pg3>.
Kai: This means they found a way to get an exact solution for the optical response in the hydrodynamic regime, which is usually inaccessible through perturbation theory <ref:2605.21774#pg1>.
Mira: It’s important that it shows how the crossovers between collisionless and hydrodynamic regimes are governed by tau ee over tau i and omega times tau ee over tau i <ref:2605.21774#pg1>.
Lev: The limitation they mention is that consistency between the kinetic equation and Kubo approaches requires proper inclusion of mass renormalization within the Eliashberg approximation <ref:2605.21774#pg1>.
Kai: Overall, this work provides a path to get an exact expression for conductivity in these systems by solving the kinetic equation exactly <ref:2605.21774#pg1>.
Conclusion: Kai: So, we’ve been looking at this paper on conductivity in these non-Galilean systems, and they've actually solved the kinetic equation exactly for two different kinds of interactions: screened Coulomb and z equals three Pomeranchuk critical interactions.
Mira: It’s interesting how they manage to get an exact expression for the optical response in that hydrodynamic regime, which is something usually impossible with standard perturbation theory.
Lev: From an error-correction standpoint, getting that exact solution means we can actually see the physics of transport without relying on approximations that might break down when you push the system harder.
Kai: Right, and they're showing how this applies to both models—the standard screened Coulomb interaction and this specific one near a quantum critical point.
Mira: They also highlight these crossover points, like when the collisionless behavior switches over to hydrodynamic behavior, controlled by things like tau ee over tau i.
Lev: That crossover information is crucial for us because it tells us exactly what kind of scattering mechanism dominates at different temperatures and frequencies in real hardware.
Kai: So, the big picture here is that we have a rigorous way to calculate how these systems conduct electricity when they are strongly coupled and interacting in a non-trivial way.
Mira: It really shows how important those specific interaction models are; you can't just use any generic scattering term and expect the same results.
Lev: The implication for us is that if we want to model real quantum materials, we need these kinds of exact solutions instead of just estimates.
Kai: Exactly, because getting this level of detail allows us to test our theoretical predictions against what we actually build and measure in the lab.
University of Florida · HSE University
cond-mat.str-el
Submitted: 2026-05-20
Updated: 2026-11-13
Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 114, L291103 (2026)
DOI: 10.1103/d791-lz1h
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 83/100
The gist: We obtain an exact expression for the conductivity of a non-Galilean-invariant Fermi liquid with impurities by solving the kinetic equation with both screened Coulomb and z = 3 Pomeranchuk critical…
Key concepts
- Non-Galilean-Invariant Fermi Liquid
- This describes a system where the usual Galilean invariance (symmetry under uniform velocity shifts) is broken. This often occurs in systems with strong interactions or specific critical points, affecting how particles move and respond to external forces.
- Screened Coulomb Interaction
- This model represents the electron-electron repulsion using a screened Coulomb potential, calculated within the random-phase approximation (RPA). It is one of two interaction models used in the study, providing insights into how long-range interactions affect transport properties in this Fermi liquid.
- z=3 Pomeranchuk Critical Point
- This refers to a specific quantum critical point characterized by a critical exponent z=3. Near this point, the electron-electron interaction is modeled using an effective Hertz-Millis (HM) interaction, which leads to Planckian behavior for the scattering rate at low energies.
- Hydrodynamic Regime
- This regime describes transport when the system behaves like a fluid on large length and time scales. In this limit, the optical conductivity reaches a specific value determined by thermodynamic quantities, contrasting with collisionless transport regimes.
Terminology
Summary
We obtain an exact expression for the conductivity of a non-Galilean-invariant Fermi liquid with impurities by solving the kinetic equation with both screened Coulomb and z = 3 Pomeranchuk critical interactions The exact solution yields the optical response in the hydrodynamic regime, which is inaccessible within perturbation theory Near a z = 3 Pomeranchuk quantum critical point, consistency between the kinetic-equation and Kubo approaches requires proper inclusion of mass renormalization within the Eliashberg approximation. p. 0 In
addition, the exact solution yields the optical response in the hydrodynamic regime, Ω ≪ 1/τee,
which is inaccessible within perturbation theory. Near a z = 3 Pomeranchuk quantum critical point,
consistency between the kinetic-equation and Kubo approaches requires proper inclusion of mass
renormalization within the Eliashberg approximation, which also ensures that the crossover between
the collisionless and hydrodynamic regimes in the optical conductivity occurs at the Planckian scale
Ω ∼ T.Where the paper says it
Key Findings on Crossovers
The low-T/high-T crossover in the dc resistivity and the collisionless/hydrodynamic crossover in the optical conductivity are controlled by τee/τi and omegaτee, respectively. p. 0 In this Letter, we obtain an exact result for the conductivity by solving the kinetic equation both at zero
and finite Ω. It shows that the low-T/high-T crossover
in the dc resistivity and the collisionless/hydrodynamic
crossover in the optical conductivity are controlled by
τee/τi and Ωτee, respectively, where τi
is the impurity
scattering time. Therefore, interpreting the previously
known asymptotic results in terms of a current relaxation
rate is misleading. In particular, in the dc case we find
that δρ(T) ≪ ρi throughout the temperature range of the
Fermi-liquid regime.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Model Setup and Interactions
The model considers a 2D system with a linear dispersion and an energy-independent τi. Two models of the electron-electron interaction are employed, the first being the screened Coulomb (C) interaction treated within the random-phase approximation (RPA). p. 0 We also
employ two models of the ee interaction. The first model is the screened Coulomb (C) interaction,
UC(q, ω), treated within the random-phase approximation
(RPA). The extension to dynamic screening does not modify the
main conclusions and will be discussed elsewhere. The second model is a FL near the z = 3 quantum
critical point (QCP), with the effective Hertz-Millis (HM)
ee interaction [11, 12],
UHM(q, ω) = g
q
2 + ξ−2 − iαω/q , α = gνF/vF, (1)
where ξ is the correlation length of the order parameter
and νF is the density of states.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Coulomb Interaction Results
For the Coulomb interaction model, in the dc limit (omega = 0), Eqs. (2a) and (2b) yield the known low-T behavior σee(0, T) ∝ T4 ln T. p. 1 In the dc limit (Ω = 0), Eqs. (2a) and
(2b) yield the known low-T behavior σee(0, T) ∝ T
4
ln T
[5, 6, 9] and the high-T saturation of the conductivity,
up to a Sommerfeld-type correction of order (T /ε)
2
[14,
15]. The O(T
2
) term is the Sommerfeld-like correction to the
Drude conductivity, consistent with the spectral analysis
of the collision operator [5, 15]. As announced, the T-dependent part of σ is smaller
than its residual value at least as T
2/ε2
F
, and the crossover
between the T
4
| ln T| and T
2
regimes occurs when γT τi ∼
1.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Hertz-Millis Interaction Results
For the Hertz-Millis interaction, the final result for the conductivity is still given by Eqs. (2a) and (2b), but with bare parameters replaced by their renormalized counterparts. p. 1 The final result
for the conductivity is still given by Eqs. (2a) and (2b),
but with the bare parameters replaced by their renormalized counterparts, v
∗
F
/vF = ε
∗
F
/εF = νF/ν∗
F = Z, where
Z = (1 − ∂ωRe Σ
R(ω))−1
is the quasiparticle residue [18]. (2a) and (2b),
but with the bare parameters replaced by their renormalized counterparts, v
∗
F
/vF = ε
∗
F
/εF = νF/ν∗
F = Z, where
Z = (1 − ∂ωRe Σ
R(ω))−1
is the quasiparticle residue [18]. Close enough to the QCP, Z ∼ vF/gξ ≪ 1 [19]. Accordingly, Z → Z(E) ∼ (E/E0)
1/3
. For the z = 3, d = 2 QCP, |Im Σ
R(E)| ∝ E2/3 and
Z(E) ∝ E1/3
; hence the renormalized rate 1/τ ∗
ee becomes
Planckian: 1/τ ∗
ee ∼ E, while |Im Σ
R(E)| itself is superPlanckian.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Optical Conductivity Limits
For the optical conductivity, in the impurity-free limit (τi → ∞), whenomega ≫ γT, Re σee(omega, T) = 4πe2T2γT /15εFomega2 ∝ T4 ln T/omega2. In the hydrodynamic regime, Re σee(omega → 0+, T) = π2/2e21g2/εF vF4 Zξ4 / ln(EFL/T). p. 1 In the hydrodynamic regime,
Ω ≪ 1/τ ∗
ee(0, T) ≪ T, one finds Re σee(Ω → 0, T) ∼
e
2v
4
F
/Z2
g
2
ε
2
F
ξ
4LHM(T); here the factor Z
−2
remains. The KE assumes well-defined quasiparticles and thus
does not apply in the non-FL regime, where E ≫ EFL We
can nevertheless obtain the qualitative behavior in this
regime by replacing ξ
−1 with its dynamic counterpart,
ξ
−1 → ξ
−1
(E) ∼ (g/vF)(E/E0)
1/3
, where E0 ∼ g
2/εF, as
in Refs.Where the paper says it
Kinetic Equation Formalism
The kinetic equation for a strongly-coupled FL is derived from the linearized collision integral, leading to an integral equation for Ho(ξ). The resulting scaling form of σee(omega, T) is announced in Eq. p. 2 (15) into
Eq. (9), we obtain the scaling form of σee(Ω, T), announced in Eq. Beyond reproducing these limits, the exact solution
also establishes that the low-T/high-T crossover occurs
when γT ∼ 1/τi
, with γT ≡ 1/τee(0, T). Moreover, since
|σee|/σi(0) ≲ (T /εF)
2 ≪ 1, the ee contribution remains
small, rather than order one, in the degenerate regime. 4
where β is related to λ as specified after Eq. The
double integral above defines the exact solution and can
be evaluated to any desired numerical accuracy.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Origin of Suppression
The suppression of the current relaxation in isotropic FLs arises because the current density for an electron with energy εk relative to εF can be decomposed into the conserved part, proportional to the momentum, and the non-conserved part, proportional to the thermal current. This mechanism is different from that in a 2D FL where odd angular harmonics of the distribution function relax as T4. p. 5 Because the correlation function
of the non-conserved part contains a factor of ε
2
k
, the
current relaxation is suppressed. We stress that this mechanism is different from the one
operative in a 2D FL, where odd angular harmonics of the
distribution function relax as T
4
[33]. We stress that this mechanism is different from the one
operative in a 2D FL, where odd angular harmonics of the
distribution function relax as T
4
[33]. The latter effect
describes free decay rather than driven transport.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Kinetic Equation with Coulomb Interaction
The linearized ee collision integral is given by [24] and the function F can be decomposed into the even and odd in energy parts. The resulting conductivity can be expressed via either Fe or Fo, and we will focus on the latter. p. 2 (9)
The relation between Fe and Fo follows from momentum
conservation, R
k
Iee(f) k = 0, which implies that
Z
dε Fe(ε) n
′
(ε) = −2
Z
dε ε
εF
Fo(ε) n
′
(ε). (10)
Therefore, the conductivity can be expressed via either
Fe or Fo, and we will focus on the latter.Where the paper says it
Kinetic Equation with Hertz-Millis Interaction
The scattering kernel is obtained from the static Hertz-Millis interaction in Eq. (1) as W(q) = 2πZ4 g2(q2 + ξ−2)2, and the conductivity is still given by Eqs. p. 1 )
Main results: Hertz-Millis interaction. The final result
for the conductivity is still given by Eqs. The conductivity is still given by Eqs. (2a) and
(2b), provided one replaces
1
τee(E)
→
1
τ
∗
ee(E)
=
E
2LHM(E)
2εHM
, εHM =
2π
3
g
2ε
∗
F
v
∗
F
Zξ 4
,
FIG. and εF → ε
∗
F
everywhere. The high-frequency limit then
yields
Re σee(Ω, 0) = 1
160π
4
e
2
g
2
Zξ
v
∗
F
4
Ω
2
ln EFL
|Ω|
. In the hydrodynamic regime,
Ω ≪ 1/τ ∗
ee(0, T) ≪ T, one finds Re σee(Ω → 0, T) ∼
e
2v
4
F
/Z2
g
2
ε
2
F
ξ
4LHM(T); here the factor Z
−2
remains. The KE assumes well-defined quasiparticles and thus
does not apply in the non-FL regime, where E ≫ EFL We
can nevertheless obtain the qualitative behavior in this
regime by replacing ξ
−1 with its dynamic counterpart,
ξ
−1 → ξ
−1
(E) ∼ (g/vF)(E/E0)
1/3
, where E0 ∼ g
2/εF, as
in Refs. In the hydrodynamic regime,
Re σee(Ω → 0
+, T) = π
2
2
e
2
1
g
2ε
∗2
F
v
∗
F
Zξ 4
1
ln(EFL/T)
. (19)
The crossover between these two limits, as well as the intermediate regime γT ≪ Ω ≪ T, is captured qualitativelyWhere the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Precise determination of crossover regimes in conductivity: The system can now accurately predict when
the crossovers between the collisionless and hydrodynamic regimes occur when 1/τee becomes comparable to the larger of the impurity scattering rate and the probe frequency, Omega.
-
Accurate prediction of low-temperature dc resistivity scaling: The improved system can calculate that "the dc resistivity of an isotropic, non-Galilean–invariant FL with impurities is given by ρ(T) = ρi + δρ(T), where ρi is the residual resistivity and δρ(T) ∝ T4 (up to a logarithmic factor in two dimensions) is independent of impurity scattering."
-
High-frequency optical response calculation: The system can yield
the optical response in the hydrodynamic regime, Omega ≪ 1/τee, which is inaccessible within perturbation theory,
providing exact results for conductivity where traditional methods fail. -
Renormalization and QCP behavior modeling: The AI can correctly incorporate
mass renormalization within the Eliashberg approximation
near a z = 3 Pomeranchuk quantum critical point, ensuring thatthe crossover between the collisionless and hydrodynamic regimes in the optical conductivity occurs at the Planckian scale Omega ∼ T.
-
Detailed analysis of interaction models: The system can distinguish results based on interaction type, providing distinct outcomes for
the screened Coulomb (C) interaction
versus theFL near the z = 3 quantum critical point (QCP).
-
Non-canonical scaling interpretation: The AI can move beyond misleading interpretations by confirming that in the dc case,
deltaρ(T) ≪ ρi throughout the temperature range of the Fermi-liquid regime,
refuting previous assumptions about anO(1) ee contribution to the resistivity.
-
Frequency and temperature dependence mapping: The improved system can map out how conductivity changes across different regimes, such as showing that
the low-T/high-T crossover occurs when γT τi ∼ 1
for the Coulomb interaction. -
Optical conductivity in the impurity-free limit: For clean systems, the AI provides exact results for optical conductivity that reproduce both
the collisionless result Re σee(omega, T) ≡ Re σee(omega, T) ∝ E4LC(E)/omega2
andthe finite hydrodynamic limit Re σee(omega → 0+, T) ∼ e2T2/γT εF.
-
QCP behavior in optical response: Near a QCP, the system can model the conductivity scaling as
Re σee(omega, 0) ∝ omega2 /3
andRe σee(omega → 0+, T) ∝ T2/3,
with a crossover at Omega ∼ T.
Abstract
We obtain an exact expression for the conductivity of a non-Galilean-invariant Fermi liquid with impurities by solving the kinetic equation with both screened Coulomb and z=3 Pomeranchuk critical interactions. While consistent with previous asymptotic results, our solution shows that electron-electron interactions enter the conductivity solely via the quasiparticle scattering time, τ ee. Accordingly, the crossovers between the collisionless and hydrodynamic regimes occur when 1/τ ee becomes comparable to the larger of the impurity scattering rate and the probe frequency, Ω. Importantly, this crossover is governed by the quasiparticle scattering rate, rather than by a suppressed effective current-relaxation rate. The exact solution also shows that the electron-electron correction to the dc conductivity remains parametrically smaller than the residual conductivity throughout the Fermi-liquid regime. For the optical conductivity, our solution also provides access to the hydrodynamic regime, Ω much less than 1/τ ee, which is inaccessible within perturbation theory. Near a z=3 Pomeranchuk quantum critical point, consistency between the kinetic-equation and Kubo approaches requires proper inclusion of mass renormalization within the Eliashberg approximation, which also ensures that the crossover between the collisionless and hydrodynamic regimes in the optical conductivity occurs at the Planckian scale Ω about T.
Related papers
- Coupled Magnetic and Lattice Excitations in Multiferroic Ba3HoRu2O9: Insights from Neutron Scattering, Raman Spectroscopy, and Machine-Learned Phonon Calculations
- Gossamer Superconductivity in Moir'e WSe 2 Bilayer
- Spin-density wave of ferrimagnetic building blocks masking the ferromagnetic quantum-critical point in NbFe2
- Raman Circular Dichroism and spinon Quantum Geometry of Chiral Quantum Spin Liquids
- Twin Algebras: Condensable Algebras beyond Anyons
- Spin supersolid in triangular lattice easy-axis spin-1/2 antiferromagnet: a fermionic parton perspective