Planckian dissipation from classical hydrodynamics
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Planckian dissipation from classical hydrodynamics".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. In this work we ask what the self-consistency of a classical hydrodynamic description imposes on a quantum system and finds that Planckian scaling of the diffusion constant emerges as a price for maintaining classical hydrodynamics down to low temperatures.
Kai: The Core Mechanism The quantum fluctuation-dissipation theorem, when read in the time domain, acts as a blurring of the fine details of the correlation functions on a Plankian time-scale.
Mira: This blurring is tracked along rays inside the light cone for three phenomenological hydrodynamic equations—diffusion, telegraph and diffusive-telegraph—and reveals that the interior of the cone splits into a classical region where correlation and response satisfy the classical fluctuation–dissipation relation, and a quantum region where they deviate sharply from it.
Kai: Preserving a finite classical region as the temperature is lowered forces the effective relaxation rate to be at least Planckian, recovering bounds on diffusivity, equilibration time and shear viscosity.
Title and authors: Kai: So, we're looking at this paper today called "Planckian dissipation from classical hydrodynamics". It seems like it's tackling a really deep question about what happens when you try to use classical fluid equations to describe something that is fundamentally quantum.
Mira: Exactly. The title itself suggests that the problem isn't just about finding some new physics, but rather figuring out the cost of sticking with classical descriptions as we get colder.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, it sounds like they are trying to set a limit on how well any classical model can work when you push it down to very low temperatures.
Kai: They involve Laura Foini, Jorge Kurchan, and Silvia Pappalardi from the University of Paris and the École Normale Supérieure. They’re bringing in some serious theoretical physics background to tackle this issue of self-consistency.
Mira: And what they're doing is looking at how the quantum fluctuation dissipation theorem behaves when you look at it in time, which they say acts like a blurring effect on the fine details of correlation functions over a Planckian time scale.
Lev: That blurring is what makes things fuzzy, and they are tracking this fuzziness along rays inside the light cone for three specific hydrodynamic equations: diffusion, telegraph, and diffusive-telegraph.
Kai: So it’s not just one equation; they're testing how this works across different ways of describing transport—diffusion being the simplest, and then moving to more complex things like the telegraph and diffusive-telegraph equations.
The paper's summary: Kai: To summarize what the authors are saying, they find that inside the light cone, there is a split: a classical region where everything follows normal fluid rules, and a quantum region where the correlation and response functions deviate sharply from that.
Mira: That separation is determined by one thing: preserving that classical region to be finite as the temperature goes down forces the effective relaxation rate to be at least Planckian.
Lev: So what this means for us on hardware, it means you can't just keep using a purely classical description if you want it to stay consistent with quantum mechanics when it gets cold.
Kai: They derive a specific requirement for the dissipation rate, saying that lambda must be less than or equal to Omega, where Omega is defined by Planck’s constant and temperature.
Mira: They state this scaling isn't just an extra quantum constraint on how things move microscopically; it’s more like the minimal price a system has to pay just to remain describable by classical hydrodynamics in a finite space of spacetime.
Lev: That's interesting because it suggests that the constraints aren't just microscopic details, but constraints on the macroscopic description itself.
The paper's improvements: Kai: The authors suggest that this Planckian scaling of the diffusion constant is not an extra quantum constraint on the underlying dynamics, but rather a necessary condition for classical hydrodynamics to hold up at low temperatures.
Mira: They’ve defined a boundary between these two regimes as a critical ray, and that boundary is where diffusive hydrodynamics can be read classically if you keep it finite as temperature approaches zero.
Lev: That boundary is determined by an implicit equation for a critical velocity ac derived from matching conditions, and rays with that slope inherit this Planckian decay rate because the inertia of the system takes over near the cone.
Kai: This leads to a specific mathematical requirement: the critical dissipation is found to be lambda c equals one half Omega minus one plus alpha squared plus one over one plus alpha squared for that diffusive-telegraph case.
Mira: Requiring that this critical velocity ac stays positive as you lower the temperature forces the dissipation rate to track Omega, which means lambda is bounded by pi overhbar beta.
Lev: If we translate that constraint into what we see in experiments, it immediately lower-bounds the equilibration time for something like a system described in reference six and connects directly to the Kovtun–Son–Starinets bound on shear viscosity.
Conclusion: Kai: So, wrapping up this paper "Planckian dissipation from classical hydrodynamics", they conclude that Planckian timescales aren't some mysterious quantum quirk hiding in the details.
Mira: They are actually just the price you pay to keep describing a quantum system using classical hydrodynamics as you get down to very low temperatures.
Lev: From my side, it means that if we want a classical hydrodynamic description to be valid down low, the dissipation rate has to follow that Omega scaling.
Kai: That scaling immediately translates into a universal lower limit on shear viscosity, eta over s greater than or equal to pi over four pi kB.
Mira: So the main implication is that these Planckian timescales are constraints on relaxation times, not just a description of microscopic dynamics itself.
Institut für Theoretische Physik, Universität zu Kསln
cond-mat.stat-mech, cond-mat.quant-gas, cond-mat.str-el, hep-th
Submitted: 2026-05-19
Updated: 2026-11-05
Comments: 23 pages
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 73/100
The gist: In this work we ask what the self-consistency of a classical hydrodynamic description imposes on a quantum system and finds that Planckian scaling of the diffusion constant emerges as a price for…
Key concepts
- Quantum Fluctuation-Dissipation Theorem (FDT)
- The FDT relates fluctuations in a system to its response over time. In this work, reading it in the time domain shows that quantum effects blur fine details on a Planckian timescale. This blurring dictates where classical descriptions break down and where quantum deviations occur.
- Classical-Quantum Boundary
- This is the critical ray separating spacetime into a region where classical hydrodynamics works and a region dominated by quantum mechanics. The boundary is defined by the condition that the classical description must remain finite as temperature approaches absolute zero, setting limits on how fast things can relax.
- Planckian Scaling ($\Omega$)
- This refers to a specific quantum scale related to Planck's constant and temperature. The paper shows that for classical hydrodynamics to hold in a finite region, the dissipation rate must be bounded by this Planckian scale. This is not an arbitrary constraint but the minimum requirement for classical behavior.
- Diffusive-Telegraph Equation
- This is one of three phenomenological equations used to model transport. It bridges the gap between ballistic motion at short times and diffusive motion at long times. Analyzing this equation helps illustrate how different transport models are constrained by the Planckian scale when trying to keep them classical.
Terminology
Summary
In this work we ask what the self-consistency of a classical hydrodynamic description imposes on a quantum system and finds that Planckian scaling of the diffusion constant emerges as a price for maintaining classical hydrodynamics down to low temperatures. p. 1 Preserving a finite classical region as
the temperature is lowered forces the effective relaxation rate to be at least Planckian, recovering
bounds on diffusivity, equilibration time and shear viscosity. In this way, Planckian scaling of the
diffusion constant emerges not as a quantum constraint on microscopic dynamics, but as the price
a system pays to remain describable by classical hydrodynamics down to low temperatures.Where the paper says it
The Core Mechanism
The quantum fluctuation-dissipation theorem, when read in the time domain, acts as a blurring of the fine details of the correlation functions on a Plankian time-scale. This blurring is tracked along rays inside the light cone for three phenomenological hydrodynamic equations—diffusion, telegraph and diffusive-telegraph—and reveals that the interior of the cone splits into a classical region where correlation and response satisfy the classical fluctuation–dissipation relation, and a quantum region where they deviate sharply from it. p. 1 The quantum fluctuation-dissipation theorem, when read in the time domain,
acts as a blurring of the fine details of the correlation functions on a Plankian time-scale. We track
this blurring along rays inside the light cone for three phenomenological hydrodynamic equations
– diffusion, telegraph and diffusive-telegraph – and find that the interior of the cone splits into a
classical region, where correlation and response satisfy the classical fluctuation–dissipation relation,
and a quantum region, where they deviate sharply from it. We track
this blurring along rays inside the light cone for three phenomenological hydrodynamic equations
– diffusion, telegraph and diffusive-telegraph – and find that the interior of the cone splits into a
classical region, where correlation and response satisfy the classical fluctuation–dissipation relation,
and a quantum region, where they deviate sharply from it. Preserving a finite classical region as
the temperature is lowered forces the effective relaxation rate to be at least Planckian, recovering
bounds on diffusivity, equilibration time and shear viscosity.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Defining the Classical-Quantum Boundary
The boundary between these two regimes is a critical ray where diffusive hydrodynamics can be read classically, determined by the condition that the classical region remains finite as T → 0. This boundary is defined by an implicit equation for the critical velocity ac derived from matching conditions. p. 7 The boundary between the regimes is the set of rays
on which the saddle and the integration limit coincide, τ
∗ = 1. (10) this gives the
implicit equation for the critical velocity ac:
ac Φ
′
(ac) − Φ(ac) = Ω
λ
. (10) this gives the
implicit equation for the critical velocity ac:
ac Φ
′
(ac) − Φ(ac) = Ω
λ
. (13)
Rays with a < ac have classical diffusive dynamics; rays with a > ac inherit a Planckian
decay rate, since the vicinity of the cone is controlled by inertia rather than friction.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Derivation of the Planckian Bound
The requirement that ac remain finite as T → 0 imposes a bound on the dissipation rate, leading to a Planckian bound. Specifically, this constraint forces the dissipation rate to satisfy λ = v 2/(4D) <∼ Ω = π/ħβ. p. 1 We track
this blurring along rays inside the light cone for three phenomenological hydrodynamic equations
– diffusion, telegraph and diffusive-telegraph – and find that the interior of the cone splits into a
classical region, where correlation and response satisfy the classical fluctuation–dissipation relation,
and a quantum region, where they deviate sharply from it. Preserving a finite classical region as
the temperature is lowered forces the effective relaxation rate to be at least Planckian, recovering
bounds on diffusivity, equilibration time and shear viscosity. Since λ(a) ∼ a
2
v
2/(4D) at small a, demanding that ac remain finite as T → 0 imposes
v
2
4D
<∼ Ω = π
ℏβ
, (4)
a Planckian bound. The main novelty of the present perspective is that this scaling is not an
extra quantum constraint imposed on top of hydrodynamics, but the minimal requirement
for diffusive hydrodynamics to remain classical at low temperature in a finite region of
space-time.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Phenomenological Applications
The mechanism is illustrated using three equations for a conserved density:
-
Diffusion equation: This describes transport on long time and length scales but carries a well-known pathology: solutions spread with infinite speed. p. 2
Where the paper says it
As an illustration, we study the dynamics on rays x = avt inside the light cone (0 < a < 1), using three representative phenomenological equations for a conserved density: the diffusion equation (instantaneous propagation), the telegraph equation (finite relaxation time, finite speed v, hard light cone) and the diffusive-telegraph equation (a softer version of the latter). In all of them the long-time behaviour of the correlator on a ray takes the 3
-
Telegraph equation: This interpolates between a wave equation at short times and diffusion at late times, with effective constant D = v 2/(4λ), and possesses a sharp light cone at x = vt. p. 9
Where the paper says it
Telegraph equation If the current relaxes to Fick’s law with a finite time τ (Cattaneo’s law τ ∂tj+j = −D∇n), continuity gives the telegraph equation [24, 26] ∂ 2 t n + 4λ ∂tn = v 2∆n , (21) with 4λ = τ −1 and v 2 = D/τ . Unlike diffusion, the equation is hyperbolic: it interpolates between a wave equation at short times and diffusion at late times, with a sharp light cone |x| = vt built in.
-
Diffusive-telegraph equation: This version smooths the ballistic-to-diffusive crossover by adding a term proportional to the gradient of the time derivative of the density. p. 2
Where the paper says it
as correlators for which the quantum FDT reduces to its classical form? As an illustration, we study the dynamics on rays x = avt inside the light cone (0 < a < 1), using three representative phenomenological equations for a conserved density: the diffusion equation (instantaneous propagation), the telegraph equation (finite relaxation time, finite speed v, hard light cone) and the diffusive-telegraph equation (a softer version of the latter).
Conclusion and Implications
The paper concludes that Planckian timescales are not mysterious quantum manifestations but rather the price paid to keep describing a quantum system with classical hydrodynamics up to low temperatures. The scaling (16), rewritten as D >∼ v 2ħβ/(4π), immediately lower-bounds the local equilibration time of Ref. p. 8 (19)
When v is the light-cone velocity, this timescale matches that of Ref. [6], which lower-bounds
the equilibration time τeq
>∼ λ
−1
. Several incarnations of this idea have been discussed in the literature. On the transport
side, the Kovtun–Son–Starinets bound η/s ≥ ℏ/(4πkB) [4] sets a universal lower limit on
shear viscosity over entropy density. Preserving a finite classical region as
the temperature is lowered forces the effective relaxation rate to be at least Planckian, recovering
bounds on diffusivity, equilibration time and shear viscosity. In this way, Planckian scaling of the
diffusion constant emerges not as a quantum constraint on microscopic dynamics, but as the price
a system pays to remain describable by classical hydrodynamics down to low temperatures.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Methods
The quantum FDT in the time domain is recast as two convolutions involving kernels gomega and Domega, which are strongly peaked on the Planckian scale. The passage from C to F or Ψ amounts to blurring C on the Planckian timescale, where features finer than ħβ/π are washed out. p. 5 We assume two generic features. First, a
finite propagation speed v: the response cannot spread faster than some effective velocity,
so the response function is essentially confined to the light cone x < vt (and so is C, up to
a Planckian ‘leakage’ discussed below). 1: the classical wedge is bounded by a ray whose slope
depends on the single dimensionless ratio Ω/λ = 4DΩ/v2
. If one insists that a finite portion
of spacetime remain describable by classical hydrodynamics at arbitrarily low temperatures,
the only possibility is that λ itself be of order Ω:
λ =
v
2
4D
<∼ Ω = π
ℏβ
, (16)
a Planckian bound on the dissipation.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Phenomenological Hydrodynamics
The analysis involves computing the rate function Φ(a) for the three equations and solving the saddle-point integral to distinguish between the classical regime (where F inherits diffusive decay) and the quantum regime (where F acquires a Planckian envelope). The numerical illustration confirms this crossover, showing that for a ray slope a > ac, F no longer follows C but closely tracks the Planckian exponential. p. 3 The paper is organised as follows. In the Results section we derive, in the simplest possible
terms, the mechanism that produces the Planckian scaling (4), then specialise to three
phenomenological hydrodynamic equations – diffusion, telegraph and diffusive-telegraph –
and present numerical results illustrating the mechanism on the telegraph equation.Where the paper says it
Results
The critical dissipation is found to be λ Dtel c = 1/2omega−1 + a squared + 1/√1+a squared for the diffusive-telegraph case. Requiring ac > 0 as the temperature is lowered forces the dissipation rate to track Ω – a Planckian scaling that constrains the current relaxation rate λ <∼ π/(ħβ). p. 1 We track
this blurring along rays inside the light cone for three phenomenological hydrodynamic equations
– diffusion, telegraph and diffusive-telegraph – and find that the interior of the cone splits into a
classical region, where correlation and response satisfy the classical fluctuation–dissipation relation,
and a quantum region, where they deviate sharply from it. Preserving a finite classical region as
the temperature is lowered forces the effective relaxation rate to be at least Planckian, recovering
bounds on diffusivity, equilibration time and shear viscosity. A saddle-point evaluation of the Fourier solution at large times gives, for
|a| < 1,
C(x = avt, t) ∝
1
√
t
exph
−2λ t 1 −
√
1 − a
2
i
, (22)
so that
λ
tel(a) = 2λ
1 −
√
1 − a
2
. (23)
At small a this reduces to λa2
, the diffusive result; at the cone a → 1 it saturates at λ.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Discussion
The paper suggests that systems violating this bound become self-inconsistent with the quantum FDT, necessitating a switch to genuinely quantum hydrodynamics near the cone. The scaling (16) implies that classical hydrodynamic description is only possible if the dissipation rate tracks Ω. p. 1 Abstract
In this work we ask what the self-consistency of a classical hydrodynamic description imposes on
a quantum system. The quantum fluctuation-dissipation theorem, when read in the time domain,
acts as a blurring of the fine details of the correlation functions on a Plankian time-scale. Several incarnations of this idea have been discussed in the literature. On the transport
side, the Kovtun–Son–Starinets bound η/s ≥ ℏ/(4πkB) [4] sets a universal lower limit on
shear viscosity over entropy density. Preserving a finite classical region as
the temperature is lowered forces the effective relaxation rate to be at least Planckian, recovering
bounds on diffusivity, equilibration time and shear viscosity. In this way, Planckian scaling of the
diffusion constant emerges not as a quantum constraint on microscopic dynamics, but as the price
a system pays to remain describable by classical hydrodynamics down to low temperatures.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI system can perform self-consistent hydrodynamic simulations that incorporate Planckian constraints, specifically by identifying when a classical diffusive solution is consistent with quantum fluctuation dissipation theory down to low temperatures.
-
The improved system can predict the critical ray ac determined by the equation ac Φ' (ac) − Φ(ac) = omega/λ, allowing it to distinguish between regimes where
classical hydrodynamics can be read classically
and regions wherethe blurring dominates.
-
The AI system will automatically lower the dissipation rate lambda to ensure that a finite classical region survives as temperature is lowered, enforcing the Planckian bound lambda less than or equal to Omega.
-
The system can apply the results to three specific hydrodynamic equations—diffusion, telegraph, and diffusive-telegraph—to determine how their respective relaxation times are constrained by the Planckian scale Omega.
-
The improved AI can identify that
Planckian timescales are thus not a mysterious quantum manifestation: they are the price one pays to keep describing a quantum system with classical hydrodynamics up to the lowest temperature.
Abstract
Hydrodynamics describes the long-time, long-distance dynamics of interacting quantum systems by classical equations, yet at low temperature quantum fluctuations might eventually invalidate this classical picture. Here we ask what it takes for a quantum system to sustain a consistently classical hydrodynamic description. Our starting point is the quantum fluctuation-dissipation theorem which, when read in the time domain, acts as a blurring of the fine details of correlation functions on a Planckian time-scale. We analyse how this blurring interacts with the diffusive large-deviation form of correlators assuming the existence of a hydrodynamic light cone velocity, and show that the interior of the cone splits into a classical region, where correlation and response satisfy the classical fluctuation-dissipation relation, and a quantum region, where they deviate sharply from it. We illustrate the mechanism on three phenomenological hydrodynamic equations - diffusion, telegraph and diffusive-telegraph. Preserving a finite classical region as the temperature is lowered forces the current relaxation rate to be bounded from above by the Planckian rate. This bound connects to bounds on diffusivity, equilibration time and shear viscosity. In this way, a Planckian bound on dissipation emerges not as a quantum constraint on microscopic dynamics, but as the price a system pays to remain describable by classical hydrodynamics down to low temperatures.
Sources
Related papers
- Emergent long-tail dynamics in driven magnets with dynamical frustration
- Statistical Mechanics of Dynamical System Identification
- Second law of thermodynamics in closed quantum many-body systems
- Chemical potentials from structure factors: II. Charged multi-component mixtures
- Genuine quantum scars in Floquet chaotic many-body systems
- Stochastic Thermodynamics for Autoregressive Generative Models: A Non-Markovian Perspective