The Hunt for Red Dual AGNs I: Spatially-Resolved Mid-IR Dual AGNs in the DESI Legacy Imaging Surveys
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "The Hunt for Red Dual AGNs I".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Theoretical studies suggest that dual Active Galactic Nuclei (AGNs) represent a crucial phase in supermassive black hole growth driven by galaxy mergers, with systematic searches typically focusing on late-stage mergers (at most 10 kpc nuclear separations) and selecting AGNs based on optical diagnostics.
Vera: The authors present a new sample of 157 spatially resolved mid-IR dual AGN candidates, selected using mid-IR W1−W2 colors from the Wide-Field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE) and optically classified as galaxy merger candidates via imaging from the Dark Energy Camera Legacy Survey (DECaLS).
Jocelyn: Spectroscopic results are available for approximately two-thirds of this sample.
Vera: Of these, 76 candidates were confirmed to reside in galaxy mergers; among these, 13 were confirmed as bona fide mid-IR dual AGNs, while 63 represented strong dual AGN candidates requiring further investigation.
Paper summary: Vera: So we're looking at this paper called "The Hunt for Red Dual AGNs I: Spatially-Resolved Mid-IR Dual AGNs in the DESI Legacy Imaging Surveys". The main idea here is that dual Active Galactic Nuclei, those two black holes in one galaxy, are a key phase when galaxies merge.
Jocelyn: Right. And what this work claims is that they've found a new sample of one hundred fifty-seven spatially resolved mid-IR dual AGN candidates using WISE colors and looking at interactions from the Dark Energy Camera Legacy Survey.
Subrahmanyan: Why does that matter? Because these dual AGNs are thought to be driven by galaxy mergers, which are crucial for supermassive black hole growth. This gives us a way to study that process in action, especially in the later stages of a merger when they get really close together.
Vera: They found these candidates using mid-IR colors from WISE and optical classifications as galaxy mergers from DECaLS imaging. And they have spectroscopic redshifts for about two-thirds of this sample.
Jocelyn: That's good, but the numbers are interesting because out of those one hundred fifty-seven candidates, only seventy-six were confirmed to be in actual galaxy mergers.
Subrahmanyan: And among those seventy-six merger candidates, they found thirteen that were confirmed as real mid-IR dual AGNs, which is a decent confirmation rate for finding these systems.
Vera: But there are still sixty-three candidates that are strong dual AGN candidates that need more investigation. And the separations for the confirmed and high-confidence ones range from fourteen point five kiloparsecs up to one hundred twenty-nine kiloparsecs.
Jocelyn: And over half of those confirmed candidates, more than fifty percent, are at separations greater than fifty kiloparsecs. That tells us that these aren't always the tightest pairs you see in the immediate aftermath of a collision.
Subrahmanyan: The paper also notes that these confirmed systems show a variety of optical BPT classes, with Seyfert-Seyferts and Seyfert-HIIs being the most common types found in those pairs.
Vera: And they have some nice constraints on the environment, showing that seventy-six out of the one hundred fifty-seven mid-IR dual AGN candidates are in interacting systems where the nuclei have a redshift difference less than or equal to seven hundred kilometers per second and separations of at most one hundred thirty kiloparsecs.
Jocelyn: That's a fairly tight constraint on the environment they are finding these dual AGNs in, which is useful for seeing if we can find them with other telescopes.
Subrahmanyan: The methodology used relies on the AllWISE point source catalog and the WISE two-band color criterion from Stern et al. two thousand twelve to create this sample of spatially resolved mid-IR AGN pairs, relying on visual morphological examination to find those one hundred fifty-seven dual AGNs and candidates.
Vera: And they also found that forty-six out of those one hundred fifty-seven were identified as nondual AGN contaminants, which is important for understanding what we might be misidentifying.
Jocelyn: Now, looking at the Rank one and Rank zero point five dual AGN candidates with measured spectroscopic redshifts, they found that thirty of them, or about thirty-nine point four percent, have at least one additional companion within a separation of one hundred thirty kiloparsecs and a velocity difference less than or equal to seven hundred kilometers per second based on archival or follow-up optical spectroscopic observations.
Subrahmanyan: That finding suggests that some of these systems might be multi-mergers, which would imply even more complex merger dynamics than just two distinct nuclei interacting.
Vera: They also looked at the optical spectra for eighty-one out of one hundred fifty-two nuclei in those Rank one and Rank zero point five dual AGN candidates, and they found that fifty-four point three percent are optically classified as Seyferts, twenty point five percent as LINERs, sixteen point zero percent as composite nuclei, and twenty-seven point two percent as NII nuclei according to the N II BPT diagram.
Jocelyn: That gives a good picture of the types of activity we're seeing in these pairs, showing a wide range of optical types across the sample they studied.
Subrahmanyan: The success rate for their selection approach was about sixty percent, with a failure rate of about forty percent. And they did point out that if spectroscopic observations had been needed at the start instead of just morphology, the sample would have shrunk by roughly eighty-six percent and the Rank one dual AGN sample by seventy-eight percent.
Vera: So, this first search for dual AGNs using both spatially resolved mid-IR color selection and evidence of interactions has yielded a valuable sample, even if it had some limitations on how much spectroscopic confirmation was needed upfront.
Jocelyn: It seems like the next step is getting more multiwavelength follow-up observations to confirm and characterize this sample across radio, optical, and X-ray regimes.
Subrahmanyan: This work connects these mid-IR dual AGNs to the bigger picture of how massive galaxies grow through mergers, suggesting that these processes are happening in a way that's observable with current imaging surveys.
Conclusion: Vera: So we've looked at how these mid-IR dual AGN candidates are being found in galaxy mergers using WISE colors and imaging from the Dark Energy Camera Legacy Survey.
Jocelyn: And now we're talking about "The Hunt for Red Dual AGNs I: Spatially-Resolved Mid-IR Dual AGNs in the DESI Legacy Imaging Surveys."
Subrahmanyan: It’s a search for these dual black hole systems, driven by galaxy mergers, using spatially resolved mid-infrared data.
Vera: The authors found one hundred fifty-seven candidates, and they used mid-infrared colors from WISE and optical classifications as merger candidates from DECaLS imaging to select them.
Jocelyn: They then got spectroscopic redshifts for about two-thirds of those candidates to confirm the merger environment.
Subrahmanyan: What's interesting is that out of those one hundred fifty-seven only seventy-six were confirmed to be in actual galaxy mergers, and thirteen of those were confirmed as real mid-IR dual AGNs.
Vera: The main finding for me is that these confirmed systems have a range of nuclear separations from fourteen point five kiloparsecs up to one hundred twenty-nine kiloparsecs.
Jocelyn: And over half of those confirmed candidates, more than fifty percent are at separations greater than fifty kiloparsecs.
Subrahmanyan: That tells us these aren't always the tightest pairs you see right after a collision; they can be further apart.
Vera: They also show a mix of optical BPT types, with Seyfert-Seyferts and Seyfert-HIIs dominating the pairs sample found.
Jocelyn: And they confirmed that seventy-six out of those one hundred fifty-seven candidates are in interacting systems where the nuclei share a redshift difference less than or equal to seven hundred kilometers per second and separations of at most one hundred thirty kiloparsecs.
Subrahmanyan: That is a tight constraint on the environment we need to look for these dual AGNs.
Vera: The methodology used relied on the AllWISE point source catalog and the WISE two-band color criterion from Stern et al two thousand twelve to create this sample of spatially resolved mid-IR AGN pairs.
Jocelyn: They also found that forty six out of those one hundred fifty-seven were identified as nondual AGN contaminants, which is important for understanding what we might be misidentifying.
Subrahmanyan: Now, looking at the Rank one and Rank zero point five dual AGN candidates with measured spectroscopic redshifts, they found that thirty of them have at least one additional companion within a separation of one hundred thirty kiloparsecs and a velocity difference less than or equal to seven hundred kilometers per second.
Vera: That suggests some of these systems might be multi-mergers, which would imply even more complex merger dynamics than just two distinct nuclei interacting.
Jocelyn: They also looked at the optical spectra for eighty one out of one hundred fifty-two nuclei in those Rank one and Rank zero point five dual AGN candidates, and they found that fifty four point three percent are optically classified as Seyferts.
Subrahmanyan: The success rate for their selection approach was about sixty percent, with a failure rate of about forty percent.
Vera: They also pointed out that if spectroscopic observations had been needed at the start instead of just morphology, the sample would have shrunk by roughly eighty six percent and the Rank one dual AGN sample by seventy eight percent.
Jocelyn: So this first search for dual AGNs using both spatially resolved mid-IR color selection and evidence of interactions has yielded a valuable sample.
Subrahmanyan: Exhaustive multiwavelength follow-up observations are currently underway to confirm and characterize this sample across radio, optical, and X-ray regimes.
Ryan W. Pfeifle, Kimberly A. Weaver, Barry Rothberg, Miranda McCarthy, Emma Schwartzman, Nathan J. Secrest, Peter G. Boorman, Daniel Stern, Joanna Piotrowska, Kevin McCarthy, –Emily Moravec, –Jenna M. Cann, –Kimberly Engle, Kyla Mullaney, Ryan Tanner, Kelly Whalen
U.S. Naval Observatory · CRESST II · Oak Ridge Associated Universities NASA NPP Program · X-ray Astrophysics Laboratory NASA Goddard Space Flight Center Department of Physics and Astronomy George Mason University Southeastern Universities Research Association Center for Research and Exploration in Space Science and Technology NASA/GSFC U.S. Naval Research Laboratory Max-Planck-Institut für Extraterrestrische Physik Cahill Center for Astronomy and Astrophysics California Institute of Technology Jet Propulsion Laboratory Kavli Institute for the Physics and Mathematics of the Universe University of Tokyo Green Bank Observatory
astro-ph.GA
Submitted: 2026-05-13
Updated: 2026-11-05
Comments: 39 pages, including 5 tables, 10 figures, and 4 appendix sections. Resubmitted to ApJ; feedback welcome!
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 80/100
The gist: Theoretical studies suggest that dual Active Galactic Nuclei (AGNs) represent a crucial phase in supermassive black hole growth driven by galaxy mergers…
Key concepts
- Dual AGN
- This refers to two supermassive black holes residing in close proximity within a single galaxy, often resulting from a galaxy merger. The study focuses on identifying these pairs using mid-infrared color criteria and visual evidence of interaction.
- WISE W1−W2 Colors
- These are specific infrared colors derived from the Wide-Field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE) data. Using these colors helps select objects that are likely to be AGNs, specifically those exhibiting characteristics suggestive of dual AGN activity.
- BPT Diagram Classification
- The BPT diagram is a tool used in optical spectroscopy to classify the type of emission line present in an AGN's spectrum. In this study, it was used to categorize the nuclei within the dual AGN candidates into types like Seyferts or LINERs.
- Spatially Resolved
- This means that instead of looking at a single point, the researchers examined multiple objects and measured their physical locations relative to each other. This allowed them to determine if the identified pairs were truly physically interacting systems.
Terminology
Summary
Theoretical studies suggest that dual Active Galactic Nuclei (AGNs) represent a crucial phase in supermassive black hole growth driven by galaxy mergers, with systematic searches typically focusing on late-stage mergers (at most 10 kpc nuclear separations) and selecting AGNs based on optical diagnostics. p. 0 Box 2, Green Bank, WV 24944
ABSTRACT
Theoretical studies predict that dual AGNs are a critical stage of galaxy merger-driven supermassive
black hole growth. Systematic searches for dual AGNs typically target late-stage mergers (≤ 10 kpc
nuclear separations) and select AGNs based on optical diagnostics. Yet, simulations predict that
obscuration can occur early in the merger sequence, and that a significant fraction of dual AGNs can
be found beyond 10 kpc. Here, we report on a new sample of 157 spatially resolved mid-IR dual AGNs
candidates selected based upon their mid-IR W1 − W2 colors from the Wide-Field Infrared Survey
Explorer and optically classified as galaxy merger candidates using imaging from the Dark Energy
Camera Legacy Survey. Here, we report on a new sample of 157 spatially resolved mid-IR dual AGNs
candidates selected based upon their mid-IR W1 − W2 colors from the Wide-Field Infrared Survey
Explorer and optically classified as galaxy merger candidates using imaging from the Dark Energy
Camera Legacy Survey. Spectroscopic results are presented for approximately 2/3 of the sample. Spectroscopic results are presented for approximately 2/3 of the sample. 76
candidates have been confirmed to reside in galaxy mergers; among these, 13 have been confirmed
as bona fide mid-IR dual AGNs, while 63 represent strong dual AGN candidates that require further
examination.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The confirmed and high-confidence dual AGN candidates exhibit nuclear separations ranging from 14. p. 0 5-129
kpc; > 50% reside at separations > 50 kpc. Confirmed and high confidence candidates also exhibit a
diversity of nuclear optical BPT classes. The confirmed and high confidence dual AGN candidates exhibit separations of 14. 5-129
kpc; > 50% reside at separations > 50 kpc. Confirmed and high confidence candidates also exhibit a
diversity of nuclear optical BPT classes. Seyfert-Seyferts and Seyfert-HIIs dominate the overall BPT
pairs sample. In
76/111 mid-IR dual AGN candidates, the constituent
AGN candidates in a given pair have been confirmed
to reside at the same redshift (|∆v| ≤ 600 km s−1
) with
separations rp < 130 kpc and are therefore considered
interacting and/or merging galaxy systems. 13/76 of
these systems with nuclear redshift measurements have
been identified as Seyfert-Seyfert pairs, exhibited broad
lines indicative of AGNs, or were previously confirmed as
dual AGNs (see Sections 5.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Rank 1
bona fide dual AGNs.
The selection methodology employed utilizes the AllWISE point source catalog and the WISE two-band color criterion from Stern et al. p. 3 A major next step in understanding populations of mid-IR dual AGNs and how they compare to
samples selected at other wavelengths is to probe their
multiwavelength properties and environments. Outline for this Work
In this work, we use the AllWISE point source catalog
and the WISE two-band color criterion from Stern et al. (2012) to develop a sample of spatially-resolved midIR AGN pairs, and we rely upon a visual morphological examination to identify 157 spatially-resolved midIR dual AGNs and candidates. Section 2 details the
selection strategy for the mid-IR dual AGN candidate
sample identified in this work. In
76/111 mid-IR dual AGN candidates, the constituent
AGN candidates in a given pair have been confirmed
to reside at the same redshift (|∆v| ≤ 600 km s−1
) with
separations rp < 130 kpc and are therefore considered
interacting and/or merging galaxy systems. 13/76 of
these systems with nuclear redshift measurements have
been identified as Seyfert-Seyfert pairs, exhibited broad
lines indicative of AGNs, or were previously confirmed as
dual AGNs (see Sections 5. , these percentages will be superseded in a future work where spectroscopic completeness has been
achieved. A Sample of Spatially-Resolved Mid-IR Dual AGN
Candidates
Our spatially resolved mid-IR dual AGN candidate
sample currently consists of 111 systems within the DeCaLS footprint after removing 46 total contaminants
identified either through archival redshifts (Section 2. Conversely, candidates that do not
satisfy these rp and |∆v| criteria are rejected and demoted to Rank “−1”; such rejected candidates are not
included in our analysis. Redshift measurements alone are not sufficient, however, to elevate a candidate dual mid-IR AGN to Rank 1
(“confirmed dual AGN”) due to (1) potential color contamination among the closest pairs, and (2) potential
non-AGN contaminants driving the mid-IR colors. For the 76 Rank 1 and Rank 0. 5
candidates that have redshifts measured for both nuclei,
we plot the redshift versus projected separation distribution in Figure 2, where the mid-IR dual AGN candidates
are color coded by angular separation, gray data points
are Rank 1 and 0. In cases where multiple surveys provided a
redshift measurement for a single object, we ensured the
redshift measurements were relatively consistent across
the surveys, and we typically prioritized survey measurements in the following fashion based on spectral
resolution and depth: DESI > SDSS > LAMOST (and
these survey measurements almost always superseded
measurements from SIMBAD and NED). Once these
archival spectroscopic redshifts were gathered into a central table, we again removed all AGN pairs with physical separations > 130 kpc (when redshifts were available for one or both AGNs) and velocity differences
> 700 km s−1
(when redshifts were available for both
AGNs); see Section 2.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Preliminary results indicate that these mid-IR dual AGN candidates show a wide range of BPT optical types. p. 0 Here, we report on a new sample of 157 spatially resolved mid-IR dual AGNs
candidates selected based upon their mid-IR W1 − W2 colors from the Wide-Field Infrared Survey
Explorer and optically classified as galaxy merger candidates using imaging from the Dark Energy
Camera Legacy Survey. Spectroscopic results are presented for approximately 2/3 of the sample. 8 additional Rank 0. 5 dual AGN candidates (lacking redshifts
for both nuclei) are listed in Table 2 and 29 Rank 0 dual
AGN candidates are listed in Table 4; follow-up spectra
from ongoing and future spectroscopic campaigns will
be used to confirm or reject all remaining Rank +0. 12
systems exhibited pairs of Seyfert-Seyfert nuclei, one exhibited a Seyfert nucleus + broad line AGN pair; all 12
were elevated to Rank 1 mid-IR dual AGNs in this work. One additional system did not have sufficient spectral
coverage for BPT classification, but was previously confirmed as a bona fide triple AGN (J121857. Yet, simulations predict that
obscuration can occur early in the merger sequence, and that a significant fraction of dual AGNs can
be found beyond 10 kpc. Here, we report on a new sample of 157 spatially resolved mid-IR dual AGNs
candidates selected based upon their mid-IR W1 − W2 colors from the Wide-Field Infrared Survey
Explorer and optically classified as galaxy merger candidates using imaging from the Dark Energy
Camera Legacy Survey. 1981) emission line ratios or the presence of broad optical emission lines. Mid-IR dual AGN
candidates showing Composite-, LINER, and [HII]-like
line ratios are held at confidence ranks of “+0. 1981) emission line ratios to judge the dominant
optical photoionizing source. In order to classify nuclei
on the BPT diagram, we require ≥ 3σ detections for
the relevant emission lines (Kewley et al. 2019, and references therein). Furthermore, the mass, environmental, and dynamical evolution of kpc- and sub-kpc-scale dual AGNs govern the
pairing rate and properties of the gravitationally-bound
binary SMBH phase (e. 5)
and when performing follow-up analyses on the morphologically selected candidates (Section 5). Removal of Contaminating Pairs Based on
Redshift (Phase I)
To avoid biasing the sample toward optical spectroscopic selection, we did not require spectroscopic
redshifts for any mid-IR pair during the initial sample selection. 2019a), we
rely upon morphological evidence of galaxy pairs and/or
galaxy interactions to identify the bulk of our subsample of mid-IR dual AGNs/candidates. The early phase
of our selection strategy is thus relatively blind with
respect to optical spectroscopy (except when removing
contaminants), which comes with the benefit that we
can develop a relatively large sample of mid-IR dual
AGN candidates; requiring archival spectroscopic redshifts would have severely limited the pool of dual AGN
candidates identified hereafter (see Section 5 and 6. (2018, W1 − W2 > 0. 5) to preselect
late-stage (< 10 kpc) mergers; coupled with follow-up
Chandra X-ray imaging and ground-based spectroscopy,
mid-IR preselection yielded a relatively high fraction of
dual AGNs and candidates across a small pilot sample
(≳ 40 − 50%, Satyapal et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Develop a selection strategy that prioritizes mid-IR color selection (W1 - W2 >= 0.8, W2 < 15 mag) and visual morphological assessment of optical DeCaLS imaging to identify dual mid-IR AGN candidates, as this approach shows a success rate of approximately 60% in identifying dual mid-IR AGN candidates in interacting galaxies.
-
Implement a rigorous contaminant removal process by utilizing archival and follow-up spectroscopic redshifts (from DESI DR1, SDSS DR18, LAMOST DR1-9) to remove foreground-background pairs and other non-mergers based on physical criteria (rp <= 130 kpc and ∆v <= 700 km s−1).
-
Establish a dual AGN confidence rank convention (+1 to-1 in half integer steps) used to explicitly differentiate between subsets of systems, with Rank 1 candidates requiring spectroscopic confirmation of same redshift and physical separation/velocity difference criteria.
-
Integrate multiwavelength data analysis by correlating WISE W2 - W3 colors with WISE W1 and W2 luminosities against projected, physical separation to investigate potential relationships between these properties.
-
Use the BPT optical classification (Baldwin et al. 1981) from Gemini, Keck, Palomar, and SOAR spectroscopic observations to determine optical BPT classes for Rank 1 and Rank 0.5 candidates and use these classes as an indicator of AGN activity, while acknowledging that they do not rule out the presence of accreting SMBHs.
-
Incorporate a search for multi-mergers by re-examining DeCaLS optical imaging with a larger field of view to search for additional candidate galaxy companions associated with the mid-IR dual AGN candidates, as 30 out of 76 Rank 1 and Rank 0.5 dual AGN candidates have at least one additional companion within rp <= 130 kpc and ∆v <= 600 km s−1.
-
Utilize photometric redshift information cautiously, as the study demonstrates that
on the scales of smaller samples (such as that described in this work) pipeline-generated photometric redshifts are not sufficient for calculating accurate velocity differences and projected separations.
Abstract
Theoretical studies predict that dual AGNs are a critical stage of galaxy merger-driven supermassive black hole growth. Systematic searches for dual AGNs typically target late-stage mergers (at most10 kpc nuclear separations) and select AGNs based on optical diagnostics. Yet, simulations predict that obscuration can occur early in the merger sequence, and that a significant fraction of dual AGNs can be found beyond 10 kpc. Here, we report on a new sample of 155 spatially resolved mid-IR dual AGNs candidates selected based upon their mid-IR W1-W2 colors from the Wide-Field Infrared Survey Explorer and optically classified as galaxy merger candidates using imaging from the DESI Legacy Imaging Surveys. Preliminary spectroscopic results are presented for approximately 2/3 of the sample. 78 candidates have been confirmed to reside in galaxy mergers; among these, 13 have been confirmed as bona fide mid-IR dual AGNs, while 65 represent strong dual AGN candidates that require further examination. 48 candidates have been rejected as non-merger contaminants (foreground-background AGNs, separations inconsistent with interacting galaxies, etc.). 29 candidates still await spectroscopic coverage. The confirmed and high confidence dual AGN candidates exhibit separations of 14.5-129 kpc; >50% reside at separations >50 kpc. Confirmed and high confidence candidates also exhibit a diversity of nuclear optical BPT classes. Seyfert-Seyferts and Seyfert-HIIs dominate the overall BPT pairings. 31% of confirmed mid-IR dual AGNs reside in multi-mergers involving three or more galaxies. The diversity in AGN properties and environments identified in this work highlights the importance of multiwavelength selection strategies and analyses in the quest to holistically understand dual AGNs as a population.
Sources
Related papers
- The Pristine survey XXVIII. Journey to the Galactic outskirts: Mapping the outer halo red giant stars down to the very metal-poor end
- Origins of Extreme Emission-Line Ratios in z > 3 Galaxies: Insights from the Lumen Model
- The Kinematically Hot, Extremely Metal-Poor C-19 Stellar Stream in DESI DR2
- UV slopes of Starforming Galaxies in Strong Lensing fields at the Epoch of Reionization with JWST
- Evolution of Binaries Under Stochastic Perturbations
- The hydrodynamical response of cold circumgalactic clouds to quasar radiation