Quasi Parton Distribution Functions in Covariant Quark Models

arXiv:2605.12373 · hep-ph · Submitted 2026-05-12 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Phenomenology. The day in particle phenomenology: models, signatures and constraints.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Quasi Parton Distribution Functions in Covariant Quark Models".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Quasi parton distribution functions (QPDFs) are defined in terms of QCD fields at spacelike separations evaluated in matrix elements of hadrons moving with velocity v, and this work studies their convergence and sum rules in quark models, which is important because these objects can be studied in lattice QCD General Framework for QPDFs The paper first discusses the general definition and properties of QPDFs within effective approaches without explicit gauge field degrees of freedom, assuming Lorentz symmetry and appropriate regularization or renormalization if divergences occur The unpolarized PDF is defined in terms of Lorentz-invariant amplitudes A q i and A q¯ i which characterize the Lorentz structure of quark and antiquark correlators, and it shows how QPDFs converge to PDFs It is noted that the QPDF in Eq.

Kai: (4) corresponds to the QCD definition of Ref.

3: where QPDFs were introduced with applications to lattice QCD in mind Covariant Parton Model Results The authors choose the Covariant Parton Model (CPM) as a specific model illustration, deriving analytical results for the small-xv behavior of QPDFs and the energy-momentum tensor form factor at zero momentum transfer The CPM results practically constitute a Wandzura-Wilczek approximation for the QPDFs and automatically entail the complete target-mass corrections They derive numerical results for the QPDFs for flavors u, d, ¯u, ¯d, s, ¯s in the CPM and compare their convergence for choices Γ = γ0 and γ3 Convergence and Sum Rules Analysis The paper demonstrates that if the PDF flavor sum rule R 1−1 dx f q 1(x) = Nq is fulfilled in a quark model, then so are the sum rules (9, 11) for the QPDFs The momentum sum rule for QPDFs is also investigated, yielding results that recover the expected velocity dependence for both choices of Γ The CPM results satisfy the flavor number sum rule R 1−1 dx f q 1(x) = Nq in the toy model case Model Comparison and Lattice Insights The study compares the two choices of Gamma, finding that for larger xv, the results are basically the same, but for smaller xv, QPDF with Γ = γ3 converges significantly faster towards the PDF The authors also present a comparison to a lattice QCD calculation, investigating differences in QPDFs to gain insight into offshellness effects The CPM results entail the complete target-mass corrections The advantage of the CPM model framework is its fully field-theoretical description of the unintegrated quark correlator which allows one to describe QPDFs and TMDs in terms of PDFs which serve as input for this model The next steps will include applications to polarized QPDFs and subleading twist The CPM results entail the complete target-mass corrections Appendix Details Appendix A provides conventions of QPDFs in literature, noting that the different conventions can be simply stated as Dq(xv, Γ, v)this work = 1/v Dq(xv, Γ, v)Ref.

5: Appendix C derives the energy-momentum tensor form factors Aq(0) and c¯q(0) in the forward limit The results in Eq.

Paper summary: Kai: So, looking at the whole paper "Quasi Parton Distribution Functions in Covariant Quark Models," it seems the authors have successfully shown how to define these QPDFs and proved some key properties like convergence and sum rules within a specific quark model framework >

Mira: The implication is that by using models without explicit gauge field degrees of freedom, you can still get results that connect to the standard parton distributions, which is useful for setting up lattice QCD calculations >

Lev: The CPM results automatically include the complete target mass corrections, which simplifies things for researchers trying to map these theoretical concepts onto real-world simulations >

Kai: The paper concludes by showing that the Covariant Parton Model framework is efficient because it describes QPDFs using PDFs as input for its structure, and they also state that their next steps will be applying this approach to polarized QPDFs and subleading twist effects >

Mira: It’s a solid piece of work because it lays out the foundation for how these functions can be studied in lattice QCD, even if the convergence isn't perfectly uniform across all velocities or flavors >

Conclusion: Kai: So, we've been looking at how these quasi parton distribution functions are defined in these quark models today >

Mira: Right, they're basically ways to describe quarks and antiquarks when they aren't perfectly free, you know >

Lev: They show us how those non-free effects fit into the standard parton distributions we see in experiments >

Kai: The authors are using a specific framework called the covariant parton model to do this work today >

Mira: They're checking how these functions converge towards the real parton distribution as you move to higher velocities and energy scales >

Lev: And they’ve done some interesting comparisons with lattice QCD calculations to see if the model matches what we expect from simulations >

Kai: The main point here is that this model gives us a concrete way to study these things without needing explicit gauge fields in the calculation itself today >

Mira: It's about taking something theoretical, like an unintegrated quark correlator, and turning it into something we can actually use as input for those lattice QCD simulations >

Lev: If the convergence is good, then these model results become a reliable bridge between theory and real-world measurements of the proton structure >

Kai: The authors are setting up the next steps by applying this idea to polarized parton distribution functions and subleading twist effects >

Mira: Which means we can start looking at things like spin physics and more detailed momentum distributions in these models >

Lev: That’s where real hardware testing comes in, because if the convergence holds across different velocities, that means the error we introduce is manageable for running on a real computer later >

F. Aslan, A. Tandogan, P. Schweitzer

Department of Physics, University of Connecticut

hep-ph

Submitted: 2026-05-12

Updated: 2026-10-30

Comments: 25 pages, 7 figures, 1 table, typos fixed, published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 114 (2026) 076028

DOI: 10.1103/bl2f-xygk

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 79/100

The gist: Quasi parton distribution functions (QPDFs) are defined in terms of QCD fields at spacelike separations evaluated in matrix elements of hadrons moving with velocity v…

Key concepts

Quasi Parton Distribution Functions (QPDFs)
These functions describe quarks inside hadrons when the hadron is moving at a velocity 'v'. They are defined using QCD fields at spacelike separations and are crucial for studying how parton distributions behave in systems with motion, which is important for lattice QCD simulations.
Covariant Parton Model (CPM)
The CPM is a specific theoretical model used to illustrate QPDFs. It provides an effective framework that describes the unintegrated quark correlator. A key feature of this model is that it automatically includes complete target-mass corrections, making its results physically more complete than simpler approximations.
Convergence and Sum Rules
The paper checks if QPDFs obey certain sum rules (like flavor number and momentum sum rules) within the CPM framework. It also analyzes how quickly QPDFs approach standard PDFs as the velocity 'v' changes, showing that for smaller 'xv', one choice of parameters ($\Gamma = \gamma_3$) converges faster than others.
Target-Mass Corrections
These are corrections to the parton distribution functions that account for the fact that the hadron is not at rest (i.e., it has a velocity 'v'). The CPM results are unique because they incorporate these target-mass corrections completely, providing a more accurate description of how QPDFs relate to standard PDFs.

Terminology

Summary

Quasi parton distribution functions (QPDFs) are defined in terms of QCD fields at spacelike separations evaluated in matrix elements of hadrons moving with velocity v, and this work studies their convergence and sum rules in quark models, which is important because these objects can be studied in lattice QCD

General Framework for QPDFs

The paper first discusses the general definition and properties of QPDFs within effective approaches without explicit gauge field degrees of freedom, assuming Lorentz symmetry and appropriate regularization or renormalization if divergences occur The unpolarized PDF is defined in terms of Lorentz-invariant amplitudes A q i and A q¯ i which characterize the Lorentz structure of quark and antiquark correlators, and it shows how QPDFs converge to PDFs It is noted that the QPDF in Eq. (4) corresponds to the QCD definition of Ref. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Except for the Wilson line absent in quark models, Eq. (4) corresponds to the QCD definition of Ref.

[3] where QPDFs were introduced with applications to lattice QCD in mind

Covariant Parton Model Results

The authors choose the Covariant Parton Model (CPM) as a specific model illustration, deriving analytical results for the small-xv behavior of QPDFs and the energy-momentum tensor form factor at zero momentum transfer The CPM results practically constitute a Wandzura-Wilczek approximation for the QPDFs and automatically entail the complete target-mass corrections They derive numerical results for the QPDFs for flavors u, d, ¯u, ¯d, s, ¯s in the CPM and compare their convergence for choices Γ = γ0 and γ3

Convergence and Sum Rules Analysis

The paper demonstrates that if the PDF flavor sum rule R 1−1 dx f q 1(x) = Nq is fulfilled in a quark model, then so are the sum rules (9, 11) for the QPDFs The momentum sum rule for QPDFs is also investigated, yielding results that recover the expected velocity dependence for both choices of Γ The CPM results satisfy the flavor number sum rule R 1−1 dx f q 1(x) = Nq in the toy model case

Model Comparison and Lattice Insights

The study compares the two choices of Gamma, finding that for larger xv, the results are basically the same, but for smaller xv, QPDF with Γ = γ3 converges significantly faster towards the PDF The authors also present a comparison to a lattice QCD calculation, investigating differences in QPDFs to gain insight into offshellness effects The CPM results entail the complete target-mass corrections

Conclusions on Model Utility

The advantage of the CPM model framework is its fully field-theoretical description of the unintegrated quark correlator which allows one to describe QPDFs and TMDs in terms of PDFs which serve as input for this model The next steps will include applications to polarized QPDFs and subleading twist The CPM results entail the complete target-mass corrections

Appendix Details

Appendix A provides conventions of QPDFs in literature, noting that the different conventions can be simply stated as Dq(xv, Γ, v)this work = 1/v Dq(xv, Γ, v)Ref. [5] Appendix C derives the energy-momentum tensor form factors Aq(0) and c¯q(0) in the forward limit The results in Eq. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Remarkably, the CPM results practically constitute a Wandzura-Wilczek approximation for the QPDFs and automatically entail the complete target-mass corrections. The Appendices contain derivations of the CPM expressions for the electromagnetic and energy-momentum tensor form factors at t = 0 required for the sum rules.

(60) are based purely on Lorentz symmetry and free field theory The CPM predicts Da(xv, γ3, v) ≥ 0 for all velocities 0 < v ≤ 1 The relation (63) shows that Dq(xv, γ0, v) contains the expression for Dq(xv, γ3, v) “diluted” by an additional power of nucleon velocity and “contaminated” by the extra term ∆Dq±(xv, v) proportional to (1 − v2) The results in Eq. p. 7
Where the paper says it

(33c), the QPDF Dq (xv, γ3 , v) is defined by C 3 (P, z) = 2P 3Mq (ν, −z 2 3 ) + 2M2 z 3J q (ν, −z 2 3 ) = 2P 3 Z ∞ −∞ dxv e iνxvDq (xv, γ3 , v) (41) which can be inverted and simplified using z 3 = ν P 3 as follows v Dq (xv, γ0 , v) = Z ∞ −∞ dν 2π e −iνxv Mq (ν, −z 2 3 ) Dq (xv, γ3 , v) = Z ∞ −∞ dν 2π e −iνxv Mq (ν, −z 2 3 ) + M2 P 2 3 νJ q (ν, −z 2 3 ) (42) where we have included for comparison the result for Dq (xv, γ0 , v) discussed already in Sec. Since Dq (xv, γ3 , v) contains the power-suppressed term M2 P 2 3 νJ q (ν, −z 2 3 ), the choice Γ = γ 0 appears preferable because in Dq (xv, γ0 , v) this power-suppressed term is absent to begin with [34, 35].

(46a) coincide with those in Eq. p. 8
Where the paper says it

(42) and taking the ν-integrals we obtain Dq (xv, γ0 , v) = 2 Z d 4 k δ xv − k 3 P3 A q 2 + xv + P ·k P 2 3 1 + M2 P 2 3 A q 3 q 1 + M2 P 2 3 (46a) Dq (xv, γ3 , v) = 2 Z d 4 k δ xv − k 3 P3 A q 2 + xv A q 3 (46b) The expressions in Eq. (46) coincide with those in Eq.

(20) as one can immediately see for Dq(xv, γ3, v) The QPDFs approach the PDF limit when the nucleon velocity v → 1 The results in Eq. p. 8
Where the paper says it

(46) coincide with those in Eq. (20) as one can immediately see for Dq (xv, γ3 , v) and, after some algebra, also for Dq (xv, γ0 , v).

(67) can be viewed as predictions of the WW-type approximation The QPDFs have non-zero support for 0 < xv < xv,max with xv,max as shown in Tab. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We derive analytical results for the small-xv behavior of QPDFs and the energy-momentum tensor form factor ¯c q (t) at zero momentum transfer. These results are of interest as they correspond to a Wandzura-Wilczek-type approximation.

I The convergence of the QPDFs towards the corresponding PDFs is relatively uniform as v approaches unity (to be contrasted with the case for Γ = γ0 as evident for ¯u at xv = 0. p. 8
Where the paper says it

However, revisiting the situation in momentum-space in terms of the A q i (P · k, k2 ) amplitudes reveals that the inclusion of the power-correction term proportional to J q (ν, −z 2 3 ) in the case of Γ = γ 3 has actually a positive side effect: it cancels out power corrections present in the term proportional to Mq (ν, −z 2 3 ) which remain uncompensated in Dq (xv, γ0 , v), see Eqs. This in turn suggests that Dq (xv, γ3 , v) might be a better candidate for faster convergence towards PDFs.

5) The results in Eq. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We choose the Covariant Parton Model (CPM) as an illustration. We derive analytical results for the small-xv behavior of QPDFs and the energy-momentum tensor form factor ¯c q (t) at zero momentum transfer.

(45c) coincide with those in Eq. p. 8
Where the paper says it

(45a) stays as it is, while in the Γ = γ 3 case in Eq. (45b) all the power corrections highlighted in color mutually compensate and we obtain Γ = γ 3 : Mq (ν, − ν 2 P 2 3 ) + M2 P 2 3 νJ q (ν, −z 2 3 ) = 2 Z d 4 k eiν k 3 P 3 A q 2 + k 3 P3 A q 3 , (45c) which is rather remarkable.

(20) The QPDFs are always positive for all velocities 0 < v ≤ 1 The results in Eq. p. 7
Where the paper says it

(44) with z 3 = ν P 3 and choosing Γ = γ 0 or γ 3 yields for ν-integrands of the two choices the following expressions in terms of Ai-amplitudes Γ = γ 0 : Mq (ν, − ν 2 P 2 3 ) = 2 Z d 4 k eiν k 3 P 3 A q 2 + k 3 P 3 + P ·k P 2 3 1 + M2 P 2 3 A q 3 (45a) Γ = γ 3 : Mq (ν, − ν 2 P 2 3 ) + M2 P 2 3 νJ q (ν, −z 2 3 ) = 2 Z d 4 k eiν k 3 P 3 A q 2 + k 3 P 3 + P ·k P 2 3 1 + M2 P 2 3 A q 3 | {z } Mq(ν,− ν 2 P 2 3 ) + k 3 P 3 M2 P 2 3 − P ·k P 2 3 1 + M2 P 2 3 A q 3 | {z } M2 P 2 3 νJ q(ν,− ν 2 P 2 3 ) (45b) The ratio k 3 P 3 corresponds to xv which asymptotically approaches x. The frame-independent factor P · k appears always in a ratio with respect to P 2 3 which makes it a power correction for P 3 → ∞.

(64, 66, 67) can be viewed as predictions of the WW-type approximation The QPDFs exhibit the same large-xv behavior and are larger than the PDF at large xv The convergence is overall faster for antiquark QPDFs than for quark QPDFs in the CPM The results in Eq. p. 8
Where the paper says it

The other power corrections cannot be avoided. Since the practical goal is to study the QPDFs at very large P 3 ≫ M where the power corrections become small and QPDFs approach the PDF limit, there is a lot of practical interest to start with a representation of QPDFs which is more likely to exhibit faster convergence towards PDFs.

(48, 49) no longer holds for QPDFs The effects of quarks described in terms of Gq(P · k) “leak” into the antiquark region for v < 1 The leaking reflects the fact that a probabilistic parton density interpretation, and hence distinction of quarks and antiquarks, requires the infinite momentum frame The QPDFs are elegantly and efficiently described using the nucleon velocity v rather than the nucleon momentum Pz as a variable The CPM results entail the complete target-mass corrections

Numerical Results Summary

The numerical results show that for the selected velocities v = 0.5, 0.7, 0.9, the convergence of the QPDFs towards the corresponding PDFs is relatively uniform The only exception is xvDu¯(xv, γ0, v) at the velocity v = 0. p. 8

Where the paper says it

However, revisiting the situation in momentum-space in terms of the A q i (P · k, k2 ) amplitudes reveals that the inclusion of the power-correction term proportional to J q (ν, −z 2 3 ) in the case of Γ = γ 3 has actually a positive side effect: it cancels out power corrections present in the term proportional to Mq (ν, −z 2 3 ) which remain uncompensated in Dq (xv, γ0 , v), see Eqs. This in turn suggests that Dq (xv, γ3 , v) might be a better candidate for faster convergence towards PDFs.

5 which shows a “wiggle” for xv ≲ 0. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The variable P · k appears naturally in the momentum-space description of the quark correlator and is of course a Lorentz scalar. (2) shows that xv is velocity-dependent and becomes equal to x only for v → 1.

3 For v = 0.9 the QPDFs agree with the PDFs for 10−2 ≤ xv ≲ 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

These objects can be studied in lattice QCD. In the limit when v approaches the speed of light, QPDFs converge to PDFs.

8 already within about 5 % accuracy The convergence is overall faster for antiquark QPDFs than for quark QPDFs in the CPM In the region of larger xv ≳ 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We provide general proofs for the convergence and sum rules of the unpolarized quark and antiquark QPDFs for both choices γ 0 and γ 3 . We choose the Covariant Parton Model (CPM) as an illustration.

3 the two choices Γ = γ0 or Γ = γ3 are very similar The QPDF with Γ = γ3 converges towards the PDF significantly faster in the region xv ≲ 0. p. 8
Where the paper says it

However, revisiting the situation in momentum-space in terms of the A q i (P · k, k2 ) amplitudes reveals that the inclusion of the power-correction term proportional to J q (ν, −z 2 3 ) in the case of Γ = γ 3 has actually a positive side effect: it cancels out power corrections present in the term proportional to Mq (ν, −z 2 3 ) which remain uncompensated in Dq (xv, γ0 , v), see Eqs. This in turn suggests that Dq (xv, γ3 , v) might be a better candidate for faster convergence towards PDFs.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Ability to predict lattice QCD results by identifying model assumptions versus systematic effects, specifically recognizing that the truncation of the Fourier transform is among the most challenging systematic effects [24].

  2. Capability to perform a cross-check of model computations by verifying relations like Equation (13) against direct numerical calculation in models, as shown in Fig. 6 which provides an important cross check for the numerics and serves as a theoretical consistency test of the model.

  3. Skill to distinguish between QPDF convergence rates based on the choice of Gamma, noting that the QPDF with Gamma = gamma 3 converges towards the PDF significantly faster in smaller xv regions.

  4. Proficiency in analyzing flavor-dependent effects in QPDFs, specifically identifying that the leaking effect of the larger d-antiquark contribution on the smaller d-quark QPDF is more pronounced than in the u-flavor case which causes a slower convergence.

  5. Capacity to compare model results with lattice QCD calculations by analyzing the difference between them, noting that the presence of uncontrolled systematic uncertainties cannot be excluded and investigating whether the observed difference is due to offshellness effect or might include also systematic effects.

Abstract

Quasi parton distribution functions (QPDFs) are defined in terms of QCD fields at spacelike separations evaluated in matrix elements of hadrons moving with velocity v. These objects can be studied in lattice QCD. In the limit when v approaches the speed of light, QPDFs converge to PDFs. It is insightful to study QPDFs and their convergence in models. In this work, we first study the QPDFs in a broad class of quark models characterized by one common feature, namely the absence of gauge degrees of freedom. We provide general proofs for the convergence and sum rules of the unpolarized quark and antiquark QPDFs for both choices γ 0 and γ cubed. We choose the Covariant Parton Model (CPM) as an illustration. We derive analytical results for the small- x v behavior of QPDFs and the energy-momentum tensor form factor c bar q(t) at zero momentum transfer. These results are of interest as they correspond to a Wandzura-Wilczek-type approximation.

Sources

Related papers