Characterizing the Scale Height and Filamentary Structure of Radiatively Cooled MADs
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Characterizing the Scale Height and Filamentary Structure of Radiatively Cooled MADs".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Radiative cooling can strongly influence the structure and dynamics of black hole accretion disks Here, we perform general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (GR-MHD) simulations of magnetically arrested disks (MADs) around a non-spinning black hole We identify, both analytically and numerically, a transition mass accretion rate above which radiative cooling becomes faster than the heating, which is assumed to occur via local coupling to the magnetic field Above this mass accretion rate, cooling substantially reduces the gas thermal pressure, leading to considerably thinner and denser accretion filaments, and a substantial increase in radiative efficiency, relative to lower accretion rates We introduce an alternative definition based on the polar position of the density maximum, which more robustly characterizes the filamentary structure of the disks in the presence of strong magnetic fields and cooling.
Vera: Simulation Setup and Cooling Physics The numerical simulations are carried out using GPU-accelerated code cuHARM The cooling rate is calculated by considering the synchrotron and bremsstrahlung emission processes for sub-Eddington mass accretion rates up to M˙ ≲ 10−4M˙Edd.
Jocelyn: The cooling rate is defined as Λ = q−br + q−s, where q−br and q−s are the cooling rates due to bremsstrahlung and synchrotron, respectively.
Vera: Synchrotron cooling clearly dominates the radiative losses throughout the domain.
Title and authors: Vera: So, focusing on this paper, "Characterizing the Scale Height and Filamentary Structure of Radiatively Cooled MADs," what are the core ideas they are pushing forward?
Jocelyn: Well, they’re trying to figure out how radiative cooling affects the disk structure and dynamics by looking at how magnetic field accumulation regulates gas accretion in these inner regions.
Subrahmanyan: They identify a transition mass accretion rate above which the radiative cooling becomes faster than the heating that drives the gas flow, which they assume happens through local coupling to the magnetic field.
Vera: So, if you look at this paper's summary, it’s identifying both analytically and numerically this critical mass accretion rate where cooling gets fast enough to change everything about how the gas flows.
Jocelyn: Above that mass, cooling substantially reduces the gas thermal pressure, which leads to considerably thinner and denser accretion filaments and a substantial increase in radiative efficiency compared to lower accretion rates.
Subrahmanyan: That shift in energy balance modifies the internal disk structure and causes a significant decline in the disk thickness as gas loses its pressure support.
Vera: The paper also introduces an alternative definition for the disk height based on where the density maximum is located, which they say more robustly characterizes filamentary structures in disks with strong magnetic fields and cooling.
Jocelyn: That means their new method identifies contiguous regions of significant density throughout the domain and computes a local thickness in the theta direction instead of relying on a fixed equatorial plane assumption.
Subrahmanyan: This new method is better because it captures the actual mass concentration rather than averaging over non-symmetric voids, which is a problem with the traditional density-weighted angular scale height definition.
The paper's summary: Vera: So, to summarize what this paper says, it’s that at lower accretion rates, cooling isn't efficient enough to significantly reduce the gas temperature, so filaments can maintain their vertical pressure support.
Jocelyn: But as the mass accretion rate gets higher—above that critical point—the disk becomes radiatively efficient, and the disk height sharply decreases up to a radius of approximately thirty to forty gravitational radii.
Subrahmanyan: This behavior is attributed to enhanced radiative cooling up to those radii causing strong filamentation at smaller radii, which is what drives the structural change we see.
Vera: It’s worth noting that synchrotron cooling dominates the radiative losses across all mass accretion rates they considered in this work, even compared to bremsstrahlung.
Jocelyn: That means if you're looking at cooled MADs, you should expect synchrotron emission to be the main driver of those radiative losses throughout the whole disk structure.
Subrahmanyan: The paper also shows that at lower rates, cooling isn't efficient enough to significantly reduce gas temperature, which is why the filaments sustain their vertical support in those regimes.
Vera: So we see a clear distinction between low and high accretion rates: one regime where pressure support holds up and one where radiative cooling dominates the structure.
The paper's improvements: Jocelyn: They suggest that the traditional definition of disk height, which assumes density peaks at the midplane, doesn't actually represent the disk thickness accurately anymore.
Vera: That’s a key improvement; their new definition captures the actual mass concentration rather than a fixed geometric plane, allowing it to follow the local path of filaments instead of averaging over non-symmetric voids.
Subrahmanyan: This new diagnostic is supposed to be more accurate because it follows the local path of those filaments when cooling is involved, whereas the old one just gives you an average thickness.
Jocelyn: They also analytically derive conditions under which radiative cooling significantly affects disk structure, finding a critical mass accretion rate above which cooling becomes substantial enough to have a notable effect beyond some prescribed radius.
Vera: So they are providing a concrete threshold for when you should expect this structural change in the disk height based on the accretion rate you’re seeing.
Subrahmanyan: And they show that the disk height decreases monotonically with radius towards the black hole for high mass accretion rates, while at lower rates, disks maintain a relatively constant and puffed-up disk height.
Jocelyn: It’s telling us that the environment—the accretion rate—determines whether we see these thin filaments or thicker structures near the center.
Conclusion: Vera: So wrapping up this paper, the main implication is that traditional measurements of disk height can be misleading because they don't account for how cooling fundamentally alters the density distribution in these systems.
Jocelyn: The new method based on the polar position of density maximum gives us a better way to characterize the actual mass concentration and follow those filament paths more accurately.
Subrahmanyan: This work suggests that localized synchrotron hotspots within these filaments might produce different variability patterns depending on whether you are looking at lower or higher accretion rates.
Vera: And because synchrotron cooling is dominant across the entire range studied, this could have major implications for how we model the appearance of cooled MADs in real observations.
Jocelyn: So we’re leaving this paper thinking about how to better measure the structure of these disks by focusing on where the mass actually concentrates rather than a simple geometric height.
Subrahmanyan: For me, it’s important that we keep pushing for observational constraints that can tell us whether these theoretical models accurately predict those sharp transitions in structure based on accretion rates.
Vera: It’s a solid piece of work by Singh, Bégué, and Pe’er characterizing the scale height and filamentary structure of radiatively cooled MADs.
Akshay Singh, Damien Bégué, Asaf Pe’er
Bar-Ilan University
astro-ph.HE
Submitted: 2026-05-10
Updated: 2026-10-28
Comments: Accepted for publication in Astrophysical Journal after minor corrections
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 92/100
The gist: Radiative cooling can strongly influence the structure and dynamics of black hole accretion disks Here…
Key concepts
- Magnetically Arrested Disks (MADs)
- These are black hole accretion disks where strong magnetic fields are threaded through the disk, effectively arresting the inflow of matter. The magnetic pressure balances the gravitational pull, leading to a specific, highly magnetized structure around the black hole that is central to this research.
- Radiative Cooling ($\Lambda$)
- This refers to how quickly gas loses energy by emitting radiation (synchrotron and bremsstrahlung). In this study, cooling is modeled as coupling locally to the magnetic field. Synchrotron cooling is found to be the dominant loss mechanism across all tested accretion rates.
- Density-Weighted Angular Scale Height
- This is a standard way to measure how thick an accretion disk appears vertically by weighting density measurements across different radii. The paper argues this method can be misleading in MAD flows because it assumes the densest part of the disk is always at the equatorial plane.
- Maximum-Density Based Disk Height
- This alternative diagnostic measures thickness by locating the highest point of gas density in a given region, rather than assuming a fixed midplane. This method is proposed as more robust for characterizing filamentary structures influenced by strong magnetic fields and cooling.
Terminology
Summary
Radiative cooling can strongly influence the structure and dynamics of black hole accretion disks Here, we perform general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (GR-MHD) simulations of magnetically arrested disks (MADs) around a non-spinning black hole We identify, both analytically and numerically, a transition mass accretion rate above which radiative cooling becomes faster than the heating, which is assumed to occur via local coupling to the magnetic field Above this mass accretion rate, cooling substantially reduces the gas thermal pressure, leading to considerably thinner and denser accretion filaments, and a substantial increase in radiative efficiency, relative to lower accretion rates We introduce an alternative definition based on the polar position of the density maximum, which more robustly characterizes the filamentary structure of the disks in the presence of strong magnetic fields and cooling. p. 0 We identify, both analytically and numerically, a transition mass accretion rate above which radiative
cooling becomes faster than the heating, which is assumed to occur via local coupling to the magnetic
field. Above this mass accretion rate, cooling substantially reduces the gas thermal pressure, leading to
considerably thinner and denser accretion filaments, and a substantial increase in radiative efficiency,
relative to lower accretion rates.Where the paper says it
Simulation Setup and Cooling Physics
The numerical simulations are carried out using GPU-accelerated code cuHARM The cooling rate is calculated by considering the synchrotron and bremsstrahlung emission processes for sub-Eddington mass accretion rates up to M˙ ≲ 10−4M˙Edd. The cooling rate is defined as Λ = q−br + q−s, where q−br and q−s are the cooling rates due to bremsstrahlung and synchrotron, respectively. p. 2 In this subsection we use real physical units. We define
Λ = q
−
br + q
−
s
, (6)
where q
−
br and q
−
s are the cooling rates due to bremsstrahlung and synchrotron, respectively. The top-right and bottom-left panels in Figure 1 compare the synchrotron and bremsstrahlung power. Synchrotron
cooling clearly dominates the radiative losses throughout the domain (note the different color scales). Rybicki & Lightman 1986)
q
−
s =
4
3
cσT γ
2
eβ
2
eUBne erg cm−3
s
−1
, (10)
Here, σT is the Thomson cross-section, γe is the electron Lorentz factor (corresponding to the normalized velocity βe),
and UB = b
2/2 (note that in the units used here, Ub = pb). Both the synchrotron and bremsstrahlung cooling rates depend on the electron temperature (Te), which we set as a
constant fraction of the proton temperature; this assumption corresponds to a strong coupling between electrons and
protons.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Structural Diagnostics and Scale Height
A commonly adopted diagnostic for the vertical thickness of accretion disks is the density-weighted angular scale height (Equation 14). This definition implicitly assumes that the equatorial plane coincides with the physical midplane of the disk. p. 6 This definition is well
motivated and widely used in simulations of weakly magnetized (SANE) disks, where the density distribution is
approximately symmetric about the equator. However, this diagnostic implicitly assumes that the equatorial plane
coincides with the physical midplane of the disk. We demonstrate that the
traditional definition of disk height can be misleading for MADs. We propose an alternative definition based on the
position of the density maximum, which more accurately captures the disk behavior under the influence of radiative
cooling. The cells with densities below a fraction ffloor = 10 of this maximum, ρ < ρmax,global/ffloor, are excluded from
further analysis. This threshold is used to identify contiguous regions of significant density throughout the domain.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Critical Accretion Rate Analysis
The results show that the disk height decreases as the rate of radiative cooling increases. The authors analytically derive conditions under which radiative cooling significantly affects the disk structure, finding a critical mass accretion rate above which cooling becomes substantial enough to have a notable effect on the structure and scale height of the accretion disk beyond some prescribed radius. p. 9 This occurs, as at high accretion rate, substantial radiative cooling
causes considerable loss of gas pressure, enforcing strong filamentation at small radii, as seen in Figure 2 above. Here,
we analytically derive the conditions under which radiative cooling significantly affects the disk structure. In this region, there is a
considerable difference in disk height between disks with a very high accretion rate (10−4M˙
Edd) compared to those
with lower accretion rates. This behavior is attributed to enhanced radiative cooling up to these radii: the disk loses
internal energy through radiation, which reduces thermal pressure support and leads to a substantial decrease in the
scale height in the inner regions.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Physical Interpretation of Results
The analysis reveals that at lower accretion rates, cooling is not efficient enough to significantly reduce the gas temperature, allowing filaments to sustain their vertical pressure support. In contrast, at higher mass accretion rates, the disk becomes radiatively efficient, and the disk height sharply decreases due to enhanced radiative cooling up to a radius of approximately 30–40 rg. p. 5 The radiative efficiency increases with the increase in the mass accretion rate due to enhanced cooling. Conversely,
it decreases with increasing radius, where the disk becomes less efficient at radiating energy. In this region, there is a
considerable difference in disk height between disks with a very high accretion rate (10−4M˙
Edd) compared to those
with lower accretion rates. This behavior is attributed to enhanced radiative cooling up to these radii: the disk loses
internal energy through radiation, which reduces thermal pressure support and leads to a substantial decrease in the
scale height in the inner regions. In contrast, bremsstrahlung cooling is
much weaker everywhere and exhibits a more spatially extended distribution, with relatively higher values toward the
dense midplane due to its sole density and temperature dependence. Across all accretion rates considered in this work,Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusions and Future Directions
The traditional definition of disk height does not accurately represent the disk thickness because it inherently assumes that the density peaks at the disk midplane. The new definition captures the actual mass concentration rather than a fixed geometric plane, allowing the diagnostic to follow the local path of filaments rather than averaging over non-symmetric voids. The work suggests that localized synchrotron hotspots within these filaments may produce different variability patterns depending on the mass accretion rate. p. 1 We showed that at higher accretion rates, the cooling rate due to synchrotron emission is sufficient
to counterbalance the energy input from gravitational infall, leading to a notable change in the disk structure, a
modulation of the MAD parameter, ϕB (ratio of magnetic flux to the mass accretion rate), and the jet efficiency, ηjet
(ratio of energy flux to mass accretion rate). These results underscored the role of radiative losses in reshaping the
force balance within the disk: as cooling becomes more effective, the thermal pressure support diminishes, and the
magnetic stresses and the dynamical force become increasingly dominant in sustaining the disk equilibrium. Draft version May 12, 2026
Typeset using LATEX default style in AASTeX631
Characterizing the Scale Height and Filamentary Structure of Radiatively Cooled MADs
Akshay Singh ,
1 Damien Bégué ,
1 and Asaf Pe’er 1
1Bar-Ilan University, Ramat-Gan 5290002, Israel. ABSTRACT
Radiative cooling can strongly influence the structure and dynamics of black hole accretion disks.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
References
Abramowicz, M. A., & Fragile, P. p. 0 The characteristics and configuration of these
disks are determined by factors such as the rate at which mass is accreted onto the BH and the nature of the magnetic
fields, either generated within the disk itself or carried along with the accreting material from far distances (for reviews
see, e. , Abramowicz & Fragile 2013; Yuan & Narayan 2014). The characteristics and configuration of these
disks are determined by factors such as the rate at which mass is accreted onto the BH and the nature of the magnetic
fields, either generated within the disk itself or carried along with the accreting material from far distances (for reviews
see, e. , Abramowicz & Fragile 2013; Yuan & Narayan 2014).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Asahina, Y., Takahashi, H. R., & Ohsuga, K. 2020, ApJ, 901, 96
Balbus, S. A., & Hawley, J. p. 3 In this work, we consider large disks
with rin = 20rg and rp,max = 41rg. The basic disk model is rendered unstable in order to initiate accretion through the
development of magneto-rotational instability (Balbus & Hawley 1998) by introducing minor random perturbationWhere the paper says it
Bégué, D., Pe’er, A., Zhang, G. p. 1 2021; Dihingia et al. 2023; Zhang et al. 2021; Dihingia et al. 2023; Zhang et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Bisnovatyi-Kogan, G. S., & Ruzmaikin, A. p. 0 Within the framework of magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), two primary regimes of accretion have emerged based on
the configuration and strength of the magnetic field: the Standard and Normal Evolution (SANE) state (Narayan et al. 2012) and the Magnetically Arrested Disk (MAD) state (Bisnovatyi-Kogan & Ruzmaikin 1976; Narayan et al.Where the paper says it
Bronzwaer, T., Davelaar, J., Younsi, Z., et al. 2018, A&A, 613, A2
Chael, A. 2025, MNRAS, 537, 2496
Chan, H.-S., Dexter, J., & Begelman, M. C. 2026, arXiv e-prints
Dibi, S., Drappeau, S. p. 3 Previous works (Dibi et al. 2012; Drappeau et al. The characteristics and configuration of these
disks are determined by factors such as the rate at which mass is accreted onto the BH and the nature of the magnetic
fields, either generated within the disk itself or carried along with the accreting material from far distances (for reviews
see, e. , Abramowicz & Fragile 2013; Yuan & Narayan 2014).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Dihingia, I. K., Mizuno, Y., Fromm, C. M., & Rezzolla, L. p. 2 2006), cuHARM uses the finite volume method to
numerically evolve the GRMHD equations (for reviews, see e. Martí & Müller 2003; Rezzolla & Zanotti 2013; Martí
& Müller 2015).Where the paper says it
Drappeau, S., Dibi, S., Dexter, J., Markoff, S., & Fragile, P. C. 2013, MNRAS, 431, 2872
Esin, A. A., Narayan, R. p. 0 The characteristics and configuration of these
disks are determined by factors such as the rate at which mass is accreted onto the BH and the nature of the magnetic
fields, either generated within the disk itself or carried along with the accreting material from far distances (for reviews
see, e. , Abramowicz & Fragile 2013; Yuan & Narayan 2014). The characteristics and configuration of these
disks are determined by factors such as the rate at which mass is accreted onto the BH and the nature of the magnetic
fields, either generated within the disk itself or carried along with the accreting material from far distances (for reviews
see, e. , Abramowicz & Fragile 2013; Yuan & Narayan 2014). The characteristics and configuration of these
disks are determined by factors such as the rate at which mass is accreted onto the BH and the nature of the magnetic
fields, either generated within the disk itself or carried along with the accreting material from far distances (for reviews
see, e. , Abramowicz & Fragile 2013; Yuan & Narayan 2014). The characteristics and configuration of these
disks are determined by factors such as the rate at which mass is accreted onto the BH and the nature of the magnetic
fields, either generated within the disk itself or carried along with the accreting material from far distances (for reviews
see, e. , Abramowicz & Fragile 2013; Yuan & Narayan 2014).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Event Horizon Telescope Collaboration, Akiyama, K., & Alberdi, e. a. 2022, The Astrophysical Journal Letters, 930, L12
Fishbone, L. G., & Moncrief, V. p. 3 In the definitions above, the subscript "ph" refers
to a quantity with physical units (in cgs). Initial conditions
We begin our simulations by initializing an un-magnetized axisymmetric torus in hydrostatic equilibrium around
a non-rotating BH following Fishbone & Moncrief (1976).Where the paper says it
Fragile, P. C., & Meier, D. p. 2 We use the cooling
prescription provided by Esin et al. (1996) and Fragile & Meier (2009).Where the paper says it
Fragile, P. C., Middleton, M. J., Bollimpalli, D. A., & Smith, Z. 2025, MNRAS, 540, 2820
Gammie, C. F., McKinney, J. p. 0 2012),
MADs accumulate enough magnetic flux in the vicinity of the BH to dynamically influence the inward flow. In this
state, the magnetic pressure becomes comparable to the ram pressure of the infalling gas (Tchekhovskoy & McKinney
2012; Narayan et al. 2012),
MADs accumulate enough magnetic flux in the vicinity of the BH to dynamically influence the inward flow. In this
state, the magnetic pressure becomes comparable to the ram pressure of the infalling gas (Tchekhovskoy & McKinney
2012; Narayan et al. Note that a factor of √
4π is
implicitly included in the electromagnetic field. The no-monopole constraint on the magnetic field ∇ · ⃗ B⃗ = 0 is written in the form
∂i(
√
−gBi
) = 0, (5)
and is numerically satisfied with the flux-CT method (Tóth 2000; Gammie et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Igumenshchev, I. V. 2008, ApJ, 677, 317
Kawazura, Y., Barnes, M., & Schekochihin, A. A. 2019, Proceedings of the National Academy of Science, 116, 771
Liska, M., Tchekhovskoy, A. p. 0 2012),
MADs accumulate enough magnetic flux in the vicinity of the BH to dynamically influence the inward flow. In this
state, the magnetic pressure becomes comparable to the ram pressure of the infalling gas (Tchekhovskoy & McKinney
2012; Narayan et al. 2012),
MADs accumulate enough magnetic flux in the vicinity of the BH to dynamically influence the inward flow. In this
state, the magnetic pressure becomes comparable to the ram pressure of the infalling gas (Tchekhovskoy & McKinney
2012; Narayan et al. 2012),
MADs accumulate enough magnetic flux in the vicinity of the BH to dynamically influence the inward flow. In this
state, the magnetic pressure becomes comparable to the ram pressure of the infalling gas (Tchekhovskoy & McKinney
2012; Narayan et al. 2012),
MADs accumulate enough magnetic flux in the vicinity of the BH to dynamically influence the inward flow. In this
state, the magnetic pressure becomes comparable to the ram pressure of the infalling gas (Tchekhovskoy & McKinney
2012; Narayan et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Liska, M. T. P., Kaaz, N., Chatterjee, K., Emami, R., & Musoke, G. 2024, ApJ, 966, 47
Liska, M. T. P., Kaaz, N., Musoke, G., Tchekhovskoy, A., & Porth, O. p. 1 2012; Tchekhovskoy & McKinney 2012; Liska et al. 2020; Porth et al.Where the paper says it
Liska, M. T. P., Musoke, G., Tchekhovskoy, A., Porth, O. p. 1 2012; Tchekhovskoy & McKinney 2012; Liska et al. 2020; Porth et al.Where the paper says it
Lubow, S. H., Papaloizou, J. C. B., & Pringle, J. E. 1994, MNRAS, 267, 235
Martí, J. M., & Müller, E. p. 2 2006), cuHARM uses the finite volume method to
numerically evolve the GRMHD equations (for reviews, see e. Martí & Müller 2003; Rezzolla & Zanotti 2013; Martí
& Müller 2015).Where the paper says it
McKinney, J. C., & Gammie, C. p. 2 3
The numerical simulations presented in this work are carried out using the GPU-accelerated code cuHARM (Bégué
et al. Similarly to HARM (Gammie et al. 3
The numerical simulations presented in this work are carried out using the GPU-accelerated code cuHARM (Bégué
et al. Similarly to HARM (Gammie et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
McKinney, J. C., Tchekhovskoy, A., Sadowski, A., & Narayan, R. p. 0 The characteristics and configuration of these
disks are determined by factors such as the rate at which mass is accreted onto the BH and the nature of the magnetic
fields, either generated within the disk itself or carried along with the accreting material from far distances (for reviews
see, e. , Abramowicz & Fragile 2013; Yuan & Narayan 2014). The characteristics and configuration of these
disks are determined by factors such as the rate at which mass is accreted onto the BH and the nature of the magnetic
fields, either generated within the disk itself or carried along with the accreting material from far distances (for reviews
see, e. , Abramowicz & Fragile 2013; Yuan & Narayan 2014). The characteristics and configuration of these
disks are determined by factors such as the rate at which mass is accreted onto the BH and the nature of the magnetic
fields, either generated within the disk itself or carried along with the accreting material from far distances (for reviews
see, e. , Abramowicz & Fragile 2013; Yuan & Narayan 2014).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Narayan, R., Chael, A. p. 1 2017; Liska et al. 2022; Chael 2025; Wallace et al.Where the paper says it
Narayan, R., Igumenshchev, I. p. 0 2012) and the Magnetically Arrested Disk (MAD) state (Bisnovatyi-Kogan & Ruzmaikin 1976; Narayan et al. 2003;
Igumenshchev 2008). The characteristics and configuration of these
disks are determined by factors such as the rate at which mass is accreted onto the BH and the nature of the magnetic
fields, either generated within the disk itself or carried along with the accreting material from far distances (for reviews
see, e. , Abramowicz & Fragile 2013; Yuan & Narayan 2014).Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Narayan, R., Sadowski, A., Penna, R. F., & Kulkarni, A. K. 2012, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 426, 3241
Noble, S. C., Gammie, C. p. 2 3
The numerical simulations presented in this work are carried out using the GPU-accelerated code cuHARM (Bégué
et al. Similarly to HARM (Gammie et al.Where the paper says it
Porth, O., Mizuno, Y., Younsi, Z., & Fromm, C. M. 2021, MNRAS, 502, 2023
Porth, O., Chatterjee, K., Narayan, R., et al. 2019, ApJS, 243, 26
Rezzolla, L., & Zanotti, O. p. 2 2006), cuHARM uses the finite volume method to
numerically evolve the GRMHD equations (for reviews, see e. Martí & Müller 2003; Rezzolla & Zanotti 2013; Martí
& Müller 2015).Where the paper says it
Ripperda, B., Liska, M. p. 1 , Igumenshchev 2008; Narayan et al. 2012; Tchekhovskoy & McKinney 2012; Liska et al. , Igumenshchev 2008; Narayan et al. 2012; Tchekhovskoy & McKinney 2012; Liska et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Rowan, M. E., Sironi, L., & Narayan, R. 2019, ApJ, 873, 2
Rybicki, G. B., & Lightman, A. p. 3 The cooling rate by synchrotron radiation (per unit volume) is given by (e. Rybicki & Lightman 1986)
q
−
s =
4
3
cσT γ
2
eβ
2
eUBne erg cm−3
s
−1
, (10)
Here, σT is the Thomson cross-section, γe is the electron Lorentz factor (corresponding to the normalized velocity βe),
and UB = b
2/2 (note that in the units used here, Ub = pb).Where the paper says it
Salas, L., Liska, M., Markoff, S., et al. 2024, arXiv e-prints
Singh, A., Bégué, D. p. 0 Draft version May 12, 2026
Typeset using LATEX default style in AASTeX631
Characterizing the Scale Height and Filamentary Structure of Radiatively Cooled MADs
Akshay Singh ,
1 Damien Bégué ,
1 and Asaf Pe’er 1
1Bar-Ilan University, Ramat-Gan 5290002, Israel. ABSTRACT
Radiative cooling can strongly influence the structure and dynamics of black hole accretion disks. Draft version May 12, 2026
Typeset using LATEX default style in AASTeX631
Characterizing the Scale Height and Filamentary Structure of Radiatively Cooled MADs
Akshay Singh ,
1 Damien Bégué ,
1 and Asaf Pe’er 1
1Bar-Ilan University, Ramat-Gan 5290002, Israel. ABSTRACT
Radiative cooling can strongly influence the structure and dynamics of black hole accretion disks. Draft version May 12, 2026
Typeset using LATEX default style in AASTeX631
Characterizing the Scale Height and Filamentary Structure of Radiatively Cooled MADs
Akshay Singh ,
1 Damien Bégué ,
1 and Asaf Pe’er 1
1Bar-Ilan University, Ramat-Gan 5290002, Israel. ABSTRACT
Radiative cooling can strongly influence the structure and dynamics of black hole accretion disks.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Sądowski, A., Wielgus, M., Narayan, R., et al. 2017, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 466, 705
Stepney, S., & Guilbert, P. p. 3 (9)
In these equations, Θe = kBTe/mec
2
is the dimensionless electron temperature where Te is the electron temperature,
kB is the Boltzmann constant, me is the mass of the electron, and the c is the speed of light. In the calculations of
the cooling rate, the protons thermal motion is neglected (Stepney & Guilbert 1983).Where the paper says it
Tchekhovskoy, A., & McKinney, J. p. 0 2012),
MADs accumulate enough magnetic flux in the vicinity of the BH to dynamically influence the inward flow. In this
state, the magnetic pressure becomes comparable to the ram pressure of the infalling gas (Tchekhovskoy & McKinney
2012; Narayan et al. 2012),
MADs accumulate enough magnetic flux in the vicinity of the BH to dynamically influence the inward flow. In this
state, the magnetic pressure becomes comparable to the ram pressure of the infalling gas (Tchekhovskoy & McKinney
2012; Narayan et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Tchekhovskoy, A., Narayan, R., & McKinney, J. C. 2011, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society: Letters, 418, L79
Tóth, G. 2000, Journal of Computational Physics, 161, 605
Wallace, J., Bégué, D., & Pe’er, A. 2025, arXiv e-prints
White, C. J., Mullen, P. D., Jiang, Y.-F., et al. 2023, ApJ, 949, 103
Wong, G. N., Du, Y., Prather, B. S., & Gammie, C. F. 2021, ApJ, 914, 55
Yoon, D., Chatterjee, K., Markoff, S. B., et al. 2020, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 499, 3178
You, B., Cao, X., Yan, Z., et al. 2023, Science, 381, 961
Yuan, F., & Narayan, R. 2014, ARA&A, 52, 529
Zhang, G. Q., Bégué, D., Pe’er, A., & Zhang, B. p. 1 2021; Dihingia et al. 2023; Zhang et al.Where the paper says it
Zhang, L., Stone, J. M., Mullen, P. D., et al. 2025, ApJ, 995, 26
Acknowledgement
The Research required numerical calculations that were carried out on the NVIDIA Israel-1 supercomputer, using time generously allocated to us by NVIDIA.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI can accurately predict disk scale height using an alternative definition based on polar position of density maximum, which
more robustly characterizes the filamentary structure of the disks in the presence of strong magnetic fields and cooling.
-
Improved AI can determine a critical mass accretion rate above which radiative cooling becomes faster than heating, leading to
considerably thinner and denser accretion filaments
by identifying where cooling is sufficient to counterbalance gravitational infall. -
Improved AI can distinguish between the traditional density-weighted angular scale height (Equation 14) and the new maximum-density-based disk height (Equation 15), allowing it to identify when the standard definition
becomes misleading in MAD flows.
-
Improved AI can predict the radius where cooling substantially affects disk structure, finding that
the disk height decreases monotonically with radius towards the BH
for high mass accretion rates, whereas lower rate disks show arelatively constant and puffed up disk height.
-
Improved AI can calculate the physical impact of synchrotron cooling versus bremsstrahlung cooling across different mass accretion rates, confirming that
synchrotron emission remains the dominant cooling mechanism
throughout the studied range.
Abstract
Radiative cooling can strongly influence the structure and dynamics of black hole accretion disks. Here, we perform general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (GR-MHD) simulations of magnetically arrested disks (MADs) around a non-spinning black hole. Radiative cooling is consistently included in the simulations and its intensity is scaled by the mass accretion rate ranging from 10-7 to 10-4 M dot Edd. Considering synchrotron and bremsstrahlung emission, we quantify how radiative losses modify the disk structure and the accretion dynamics. In the inner MAD disk regions, accumulation of magnetic field regulates gas accretion, enforcing the gas into a discrete interchange-driven filamentary structure. We identify, both analytically and numerically, a transition mass accretion rate above which radiative cooling becomes faster than the heating, which is assumed to occur via local coupling to the magnetic field. Above this mass accretion rate, cooling substantially reduces the gas thermal pressure, leading to considerably thinner and denser accretion filaments, and a substantial increase in radiative efficiency, relative to lower accretion rates. We show that under these conditions, conventional measures of the disk scale height become misleading in MAD flows. We therefore introduce an alternative definition based on the polar position of the density maximum, which more robustly characterizes the filamentary structure of the disks in the presence of strong magnetic fields and cooling.
Sources
- Electron-positron Pair Production in Global GRMHD Simulations of Black Hole Accretion Flows
- Two-temperature treatments in magnetically arrested disk GRMHD simulations more accurately predict light curves of Sagittarius A*
- Direct Solution of the Time-Dependent Covariant Radiative Transfer Equation and its Coupling to General Relativistic Magnetohydrodynamics with cuHARM
Related papers
- Low- T/W instabilities in differentially rotating neutron stars resembling merger remnants
- The imprint of individual neutron star spins on ejecta, r-process nucleosynthesis, and kilonovae in binary neutron star mergers
- Early panchromatic spectra reveal helium in the thermonuclear supernova 2024kce
- The Double-Peaked Calcium-Strong SN 2025coe: Progenitor Constraints from Early Interaction and Ejecta Asymmetries
- The pulsar population of Omega Centauri: New TRAPUM searches, timing, and cluster dynamics with MeerKAT and Parkes
- One year of broadband radio monitoring of the enigmatic transient GRB 250702B reveals the evolution of the relativistic jet