Finite-time memory detectors and fully constraining Faddeev-Kulish dressings in QED and gravity

arXiv:2605.06774 · hep-th · Submitted 2026-05-07 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Theory. The day in high-energy theory: gravity, strings, fields and the questions left open.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Finite-time memory detectors and fully constraining Faddeev-Kulish dressings in QED and gravity".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Finite-time memory detectors and fully constraining Faddeev-Kulish dressings in QED and gravity show that finite-time Faddeev-Kulish dressings can be fully constrained by symmetry, which uniquely reproduces the classical memory effect for both QED and perturbative quantum gravity <ref:2605.06774#pg16> The paper demonstrates how using this dressing to construct finite-time Fock spaces and a carefully defined detector allows recovery of both the first order gravitational memory and higher order Christodoulou contributions from the gravitational field <ref:2605.06774#pg19> Constraint Uniqueness The authors show that demanding that finite-time Faddeev-Kulish dressings fully constrain the gauge fixed form of these dressings, which is necessary to reproduce the classical, linear memory effect for all scattering processes <ref:2605.06774#pg20> This unique choice of dressing is claimed to be the only one that reproduces both the first order electromagnetic and gravity memory effects, as well as higher order contributions from gravitational waves in the gravity case <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The constraints on the gauge fixing function cµ are satisfied if qµ(k): S squared → S squared is any function homotopic to the antipodal map, but the unique rotationally invariant choice qµ(k) = (1, −kb) is required to correctly capture the memory effect <ref:2605.06774#pg19> Detector Formalism The paper develops a fully time dependent formalism for both QED and gravity which requires putting the Fock spaces and memory detector on constant time surfaces and handling the asymptotic limit carefully <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The authors define "finitetime detectors" by explicitly including the time dependence of Faddeev-Kulish dressings, noting that this dependence is encoded in the dressing at order 1/t <ref:2605.06774#pg19> This time dependence is crucial because it affects physical observables and must be retained to obtain mathematically consistent results <ref:2605.06774#pg20> QED Memory Results For massive scalar QED, the calculation shows that the dressing does not change the overall energy of the state because

Φ(t, p), Eγ: decays to zero in the limit of large t due to a factor proportional to 1/t <ref:2605.06774#pg19> By using this unique dressing, the calculation reproduces the classical electromagnetic effect derived in

6: for all scattering states <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The final result for QED memory is given by λ(yb) = n′ Xs s′=1 qs′ − n′ Xs s′=1 qs′p 2s'(ps' · yb) squared <ref:2605.06774#pg20> Gravitational Memory Results For perturbative quantum gravity, the unique dressing reproduces the classical gravitational memory effect derived in

1: for all scattering states, including higher order terms which include contributions from external hard gravitons suggested by Thorne

3: <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The eigenvalue of the detector is found to be λ(yb) = E(3)rr (∞) − X i=0,1

i: + 8π F − X i=0,1

i: <ref:2605.06774#pg20> This confirms that the memory detector reproduces the classical result in this theory <ref:2605.06774#pg20> Higher Order Corrections The formalism allows for the calculation of higher order perturbative corrections to the memory effect, also known as non-linear Christodoulou null memory, which arise due to higher order Feynman diagrams in inclusive in-in calculations <ref:2605.06774#pg20> These contributions are captured by including external hard gravitons, which appear at a higher order than the leading order contribution from Bieri and Garfinkle's treatment <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The paper suggests that describing sub-leading field effects like memory requires a more careful treatment of time dependence than is usually employed in scattering calculations <ref:2605.06774#pg20> Future Directions The formalism has promising future directions, such as extending these results to the sub-leading asymptotically conserved charges in gravity described in the literature

35–44: <ref:2605.06774#pg20> It would also be interesting to use this developed formalism and previous work to perform non-trivial memory detector calculations as was done for gravitational energy detectors in

24: <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The authors believe that this formalism is a step towards fully describing the properties of Fock spaces at finite distances from scattering processes <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The paper concludes that they have constructed the fully correct dressing formalism at leading order for both massive QED and perturbative quantum gravity coupled to a massive scalar <ref:2605.06774#pg20> A Definitions of memory detectors The authors define the QED memory detector as DX∆EM X (z, z) = −4π lim ω0→0 (∂zLω0

Fuz: (∞, y) + ∂zLω0

Fuz: (∞, y)) <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The gravitational memory detector is defined as DADB∆GR AB = lim ω0→0 r 8πG D2zLω0

∂uhzz: (∞, y) + D2zLω0

∂uhzz: (∞, y) <ref:2605.06774#pg20> These detectors are defined as distribution valued operators <ref:2605.06774#pg20> Detector Memory Calculations The calculation for the QED detector memory eigenvalue is shown to be reproduced by computing the commutator of the memory detector with the FK dressing and photon operators <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The result

DX∆EM X (z, z), iqs'Φ(t, ps'): reproduces the required term −qs' − qs'p 2s'(ps' · yb) squared <ref:2605.06774#pg20> This calculation requires taking the limit ω0 = 2πωp tps' · yb for consistency with conservation of large gauge charges <ref:2605.06774#pg20> Classical Memory Calculations The classical electromagnetic memory contribution from the outgoing state is shown to be DX∆EM X = E(2)r(∞) −

0: <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The radial component of the electric field sensed at a point in a direction y satisfies Er(∞) = −qp squared r squared (p · yb) squared <ref:2605.06774#pg20> Similarly, the gravitational memory eigenvalue λ(yb) is shown to be equal to the contribution due to the outgoing state plus a higher order contribution from external gravitons <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The final result for gravitational memory is derived by combining these terms <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The paper concludes that the correct choice of the dressing is achieved when it is chosen in this manner, which satisfies the requirements laid out in

25: and upholds two additional requirements <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The authors stress that keeping the full time dependence of the dressed states and detectors provides an interesting framework to calculate sub-leading effects in QFT scattering <ref:2605.06774#pg20> They believe this formalism is a step towards fully describing the properties of Fock spaces at finite distances from scattering processes <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The paper concludes that only the rotationally invariant choice of cµ(k) is correct <ref:2605.06774#pg20> B Detector memory calculations The calculation for the gravitational detector memory eigenvalue is shown to be reproduced by computing the commutator of DADB∆GR AB with the FK dressing and graviton operators <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The final result is found to be Λ(c, p) = −8ωp − 6p · yb <ref:2605.06774#pg20> This result is obtained by choosing the correct time dependence of ω0 and the unique rotationally invariant choice q(k) = (1, −kb) <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The requirement for the correct time dependence of ω0 was required and only the rotationally invariant choice of q(k) yields this result <ref:2605.06774#pg20> Classical Memory Calculations The calculation for the gravitational memory eigenvalue is shown to be equal to the contribution to the memory due to the outgoing state as derived by Bieri and Garfinkle in

5: , plus a higher order contribution from external gravitons <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The final result is shown to be λ(yb) = E(3)rr (∞) − X i=0,1

i: + 8π F − X i=0,1

i: <ref:2605.06774#pg20> This is what was required <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The authors stress once more that the correct t dependence of ω0 was required and only the rotationally invariant choice of cµν yields this result <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The final result for gravitational memory is derived by combining these terms <ref:2605.06774#pg20> Where the gains come from The authors show that the memory detector we have used in this paper is the full memory detector (classically) with higher order effects appearing from higher order Feynman diagrams, rather than from additional contributions to the memory detector <ref:2605.06774#pg20> This implies that no more soft emissions are relevant since the S-matrix is now IR finite <ref:2605.06774#pg20> Any contributions to the field at order 1/r are now encapsulated in the Faddeev-Kulish dressings of hard external particles <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The paper shows that this formalism may be used to calculate higher order perturbative corrections to the memory effect <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The authors believe that this is more than just a formality, and keeping the full t dependence of the dressed states and detectors provides an interesting framework to calculate sub-leading effects in QFT scattering <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The unique rotationally invariant choice of cµ is correct <ref:2605.06774#pg20> Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The paper shows that the dressing does not contribute to the total energy of the state calculated without dressings using the Riemann-Lebesgue lemma <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The authors show that by allowing us to include external hard gravitons, our formalism may be used to calculate higher order perturbative corrections to the memory effect <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The paper concludes that they have constructed the fully correct dressing formalism at leading order for both massive QED and perturbative quantum gravity coupled to a massive scalar <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The paper concludes that only the rotationally invariant choice of cµ is correct <ref:2605.06774#pg20> A Definitions of memory detectors In (A.1) the QED memory detector is written as DX∆EM X (z, z) = −4π lim ω0→0 (∂zLω0

Fuz: (∞, y) + ∂zLω0

Fuz: (∞, y)) <ref:2605.06774#pg20> In (A.5) the gravitational memory detector is defined as DADB∆GR AB = lim ω0→0 r 8πG D2zLω0

∂uhzz: (∞, y) + D2zLω0

∂uhzz: (∞, y) <ref:2605.06774#pg20> B Detector memory calculations The calculation for the QED detector memory eigenvalue is shown to be reproduced by computing the commutator of the memory detector with the FK dressing and photon operators <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The result

DX∆EM X (z, z), iqs'Φ(t, ps'): reproduces the required result <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The calculation for the gravitational detector memory eigenvalue is shown to be reproduced by computing the commutator of DADB∆GR AB with the FK dressing and graviton operators <ref:2605.06774#pg20> Classical Memory Calculations The final result for gravitational memory is derived by combining these terms <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The authors stress once more that the correct t dependence of ω0 was required and only the rotationally invariant choice of cµν yields this result <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The final result for gravitational memory is derived by combining these terms <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The paper concludes that the correct choice of the dressing is achieved when it is chosen in this manner, which satisfies the requirements laid out in

25: and upholds two additional requirements <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The authors stress once more that keeping the full time dependence of the dressed states and detectors provides an interesting framework to calculate sub-leading effects in QFT scattering <ref:2605.06774#pg20> They believe this formalism is a step towards fully describing the properties of Fock spaces at finite distances from scattering processes <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The paper concludes that only the rotationally invariant choice of cµ is correct <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The final result for gravitational memory is derived by combining these terms <ref:2605.06774#pg20> References The references listed are

1: K.S.

Kai: Christodoulou, D., The global nonlinear stability of the minkowski space, S´eminaire Equations aux d´eriv´ees partielles (Polytechnique) ´ (1989-1990) 1 <ref:2605.06774#pg19>

2: V.B.

Mira: Braginsky and K.S.

Kai: Thorne, Gravitational-wave bursts with memory and experimental prospects, Nature 327 (1987) 123 <ref:2605.06774#pg19>

3: K.S.

Paper summary: Mira: The paper is really focused on constraint uniqueness, showing that demanding these dressings fully constrain the gauge fixed form of them is necessary to reproduce the classical, linear memory effect for all scattering processes.

Kai: They claim this unique choice of dressing is the only one that reproduces both the first order electromagnetic and gravity memory effects, as well as those higher order contributions from gravitational waves in the gravity case.

Lev: That sounds like a very strong claim about how robust this method is across different theories. What are they saying about how you fix those gauge fixing functions?

Mira: They say that the constraints on the gauge fixing function c mu are satisfied if q mu of k, which is a mapping from a sphere to itself, is any function homotopic to the antipodal map.

Kai: But to actually capture the memory effect correctly, they say you need this unique rotationally invariant choice for q mu of k being equal to one comma minus k b.

Lev: So they're not just proposing a dressing; they're pinpointing exactly which mathematical structure is required to get the right physical outcome in both QED and gravity.

Conclusion: Kai: Looking at the title, "Finite-time memory detectors and fully constraining Faddeev-Kulish dressings in QED and gravity," it’s really about linking these time-dependent tools to observable effects in both electromagnetic fields and gravity.

Mira: What this paper boils down to is that by being very strict about how you constrain the mathematical dressing, you get a unique picture that correctly predicts the classical memory effect across those theories.

Lev: For someone looking at this from an error correction standpoint, the point is that this formalism allows for calculating higher order perturbative corrections to the memory effect, which comes from those higher order Feynman diagrams in inclusive in-in calculations.

Kai: The authors stress that keeping the full time dependence of both the dressed states and detectors provides a framework for calculating sub-leading effects in quantum field theory scattering.

Mira: They conclude that this approach is a step towards fully describing the properties of Fock spaces at finite distances from scattering processes, and only that specific rotationally invariant choice for c mu is correct.

Department of Physics, Yale University

hep-th

Submitted: 2026-05-07

Updated: 2026-11-05

Comments: Updated to v2 to prepare for journal submission. Fixed typos, removed minor errors, added uniqueness proofs, and expanded introduction to better place work in context of literature

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/

Importance score: 88/100

The gist: Finite-time memory detectors and fully constraining Faddeev-Kulish dressings in QED and gravity show that finite-time Faddeev-Kulish dressings can be fully constrained by symmetry…

Key concepts

Faddeev-Kulish Dressing
This is a specific mathematical tool used in quantum field theory that modifies the standard state description. The paper shows that constraining this dressing uniquely reproduces the classical memory effect for both QED and gravity, which is necessary for consistent physical results.
Memory Detector Formalism
The authors create time-dependent formalisms for QED and gravity by placing Fock spaces on constant time surfaces. These detectors explicitly include the time dependence of the dressing, which is crucial because it affects physical observables and must be retained for mathematical consistency.
Constraint Uniqueness
The paper demonstrates that only one specific choice of the dressing function, $q_ u(k) = (1, -kb)$, correctly reproduces both the first-order electromagnetic and gravity memory effects. This unique choice is required to capture the correct physical memory signature.
Classical Memory Effect
This refers to the measurable effect where scattering processes leave a permanent imprint on the field, analogous to gravitational waves or electromagnetic radiation. The paper confirms that their unique dressing reproduces this classical effect for both QED and perturbative quantum gravity.

Terminology

Summary

Finite-time memory detectors and fully constraining Faddeev-Kulish dressings in QED and gravity show that finite-time Faddeev-Kulish dressings can be fully constrained by symmetry, which uniquely reproduces the classical memory effect for both QED and perturbative quantum gravity <ref:2605. p. 0

Where the paper says it

oertel@yale. edu Abstract: We show that for both QED and perturbative quantum gravity, finite-time Faddeev-Kulish dressings can be fully constrained by symmetry, and that this gives the unique choice which reproduces the classical memory effect.

06774#pg16> The paper demonstrates how using this dressing to construct finite-time Fock spaces and a carefully defined detector allows recovery of both the first order gravitational memory and higher order Christodoulou contributions from the gravitational field <ref:2605. p. 0
Where the paper says it

edu Abstract: We show that for both QED and perturbative quantum gravity, finite-time Faddeev-Kulish dressings can be fully constrained by symmetry, and that this gives the unique choice which reproduces the classical memory effect. For gravity, we show that using this dressing to construct finite-time Fock spaces, as well as a carefully defined finite-time memory detector allows us to recover both the first order gravitational memory, as well as higher order Christodoulou contributions from the gravitational field.

06774#pg19>

Constraint Uniqueness

The authors show that demanding that finite-time Faddeev-Kulish dressings fully constrain the gauge fixed form of these dressings, which is necessary to reproduce the classical, linear memory effect for all scattering processes <ref:2605.06774#pg20> This unique choice of dressing is claimed to be the only one that reproduces both the first order electromagnetic and gravity memory effects, as well as higher order contributions from gravitational waves in the gravity case <ref:2605. p. 5

Where the paper says it

We will show that the unique dressings we obtain exactly reproduce the classical, linear memory effect for all scattering processes, and that they are the only choice which does so. By this we mean that they reproduce the first order electromagnetic and gravity memory effects, and also the higher order contributions from gravitational waves in the gravity case.

06774#pg20> The constraints on the gauge fixing function cµ are satisfied if qµ(k): S squared → S squared is any function homotopic to the antipodal map, but the unique rotationally invariant choice qµ(k) = (1, −kb) is required to correctly capture the memory effect <ref:2605. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Then the conditions on cµ are satisfied if qµ is any function homotopic to the antipodal map. In [25] it is shown that any choice satisfying these conditions will produce a Fock space with the finite, correct S-matrix elements.

06774#pg19>

Detector Formalism

The paper develops a fully time dependent formalism for both QED and gravity which requires putting the Fock spaces and memory detector on constant time surfaces and handling the asymptotic limit carefully <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The authors define finitetime detectors by explicitly including the time dependence of Faddeev-Kulish dressings, noting that this dependence is encoded in the dressing at order 1/t <ref:2605.06774#pg19> This time dependence is crucial because it affects physical observables and must be retained to obtain mathematically consistent results <ref:2605. p. 2

Where the paper says it

3 This is the same t dependence that is dropped when one uses asymptotic Fock spaces and energy detectors to calculate the energy per unit solid angle measured by a calorimeter at the LHC. However, we will see that the memory effect is encoded into the time dependent FK dressings at order 1/t, and so this t dependence must be retained to obtain mathematically consistent results.

06774#pg20>

QED Memory Results

For massive scalar QED, the calculation shows that the dressing does not change the overall energy of the state because [Φ(t, p), Eγ] decays to zero in the limit of large t due to a factor proportional to 1/t <ref:2605.06774#pg19> By using this unique dressing, the calculation reproduces the classical electromagnetic effect derived in [6] for all scattering states <ref:2605. p. 7

Where the paper says it

The dressing does not change the overall energy of the state. The dressed Fock space exactly reproduces the classical electromagnetic effect derived in [6] for all scattering states.

06774#pg20> The final result for QED memory is given by λ(yb) = n′ Xs s′=1 qs′ − n′ Xs s′=1 qs′p 2s'(ps' · yb) squared <ref:2605.06774#pg20>

Gravitational Memory Results

For perturbative quantum gravity, the unique dressing reproduces the classical gravitational memory effect derived in [1] for all scattering states, including higher order terms which include contributions from external hard gravitons suggested by Thorne [3] <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The eigenvalue of the detector is found to be λ(yb) = E(3)rr (∞) − X i=0,1 [E(3)rr (∞)][i] + 8π F − X i=0,1 [F][i] <ref:2605. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We explain how these higher order perturbative corrections arise in inclusive in-in calculations. arXiv:2605.

06774#pg20> This confirms that the memory detector reproduces the classical result in this theory <ref:2605. p. 0
Where the paper says it

edu Abstract: We show that for both QED and perturbative quantum gravity, finite-time Faddeev-Kulish dressings can be fully constrained by symmetry, and that this gives the unique choice which reproduces the classical memory effect. For gravity, we show that using this dressing to construct finite-time Fock spaces, as well as a carefully defined finite-time memory detector allows us to recover both the first order gravitational memory, as well as higher order Christodoulou contributions from the gravitational field.

06774#pg20>

Higher Order Corrections

The formalism allows for the calculation of higher order perturbative corrections to the memory effect, also known as non-linear Christodoulou null memory, which arise due to higher order Feynman diagrams in inclusive in-in calculations <ref:2605.06774#pg20> These contributions are captured by including external hard gravitons, which appear at a higher order than the leading order contribution from Bieri and Garfinkle's treatment <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The paper suggests that describing sub-leading field effects like memory requires a more careful treatment of time dependence than is usually employed in scattering calculations <ref:2605. p. 6

Where the paper says it

The ordinary scattering Feynman rules and LSZ formula are derived by assuming these states become free in the limit of large |t|. For ordinary scattering calculations this limit is often taken implicitly, but to reproduce sub-leading effects like the memory effect one must be more careful.

06774#pg20>

Future Directions

The formalism has promising future directions, such as extending these results to the sub-leading asymptotically conserved charges in gravity described in the literature [35–44] <ref:2605.06774#pg20> It would also be interesting to use this developed formalism and previous work to perform non-trivial memory detector calculations as was done for gravitational energy detectors in [24] <ref:2605. p. 1

Where the paper says it

More recently, Bieri and Garfinkle used the Weyl tensor to rederive the memory effect in gravity to first order in perturbation theory in a gauge invariant manner [5]. 1 Much interesting work has also been done recently to formalise how to calculate the memory effect in QED and perturbative quantum gravity using QFT scattering technology [7–15] and these methods have recently been generalised to include scattering processes containing external hard gravitons using time dependent detectors and gauge fixed FK dressed Fock spaces [16].

06774#pg20> The authors believe that this formalism is a step towards fully describing the properties of Fock spaces at finite distances from scattering processes <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The paper concludes that they have constructed the fully correct dressing formalism at leading order for both massive QED and perturbative quantum gravity coupled to a massive scalar <ref:2605. p. 5
Where the paper says it

The theories we consider are massive scalar QED and a massive scalar coupled to perturbative quantum gravity. To the best of our knowledge it has not been robustly argued before how dressings should be chosen in order to exactly reproduce these subleading effects, or why only one choice of dressing is physically correct.

p. 5
Where the paper says it

The theories we consider are massive scalar QED and a massive scalar coupled to perturbative quantum gravity. To the best of our knowledge it has not been robustly argued before how dressings should be chosen in order to exactly reproduce these subleading effects, or why only one choice of dressing is physically correct.

06774#pg20>

A Definitions of memory detectors

The authors define the QED memory detector as DX∆EM X (z, z) = −4π lim ω0→0 (∂zLω0 [Fuz](∞, y) + ∂zLω0 [Fuz](∞, y)) <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The gravitational memory detector is defined as DADB∆GR AB = lim ω0→0 r 8πG D2zLω0 [∂uhzz](∞, y) + D2zLω0 [∂uhzz](∞, y) <ref:2605. p. 0

Where the paper says it

edu Abstract: We show that for both QED and perturbative quantum gravity, finite-time Faddeev-Kulish dressings can be fully constrained by symmetry, and that this gives the unique choice which reproduces the classical memory effect. For gravity, we show that using this dressing to construct finite-time Fock spaces, as well as a carefully defined finite-time memory detector allows us to recover both the first order gravitational memory, as well as higher order Christodoulou contributions from the gravitational field.

06774#pg20> These detectors are defined as distribution valued operators <ref:2605. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Naively taking these limits first (as one often gets away with in scattering calculations) is exactly what prevents one from obtaining a fully consistent and physically correct Fock space. For more on detectors as distribution valued operators see [16].

06774#pg20>

Detector Memory Calculations

The calculation for the QED detector memory eigenvalue is shown to be reproduced by computing the commutator of the memory detector with the FK dressing and photon operators <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The result [DX∆EM X (z, z), iqs'Φ(t, ps')] reproduces the required term −qs' − qs'p 2s'(ps' · yb) squared <ref:2605.06774#pg20> This calculation requires taking the limit ω0 = 2πωp tps' · yb for consistency with conservation of large gauge charges <ref:2605.06774#pg20>

Classical Memory Calculations

The classical electromagnetic memory contribution from the outgoing state is shown to be DX∆EM X = E(2)r(∞) − [E(2)r(∞)][0] <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The radial component of the electric field sensed at a point in a direction y satisfies Er(∞) = −qp squared r squared (p · yb) squared <ref:2605. p. 8

Where the paper says it

One can show that in the absence of charged massless fields [6] DX∆EM X = E (2) r (∞) − [E (2) r (∞)][0] − E (2) r (−∞) − [E (2) r (−∞)][0] , (2. 20) where E (2) r (u) is the radial component at order 1/r2 in a large r expansion of the electric field due to the source at constant retarded time u.

06774#pg20> Similarly, the gravitational memory eigenvalue λ(yb) is shown to be equal to the contribution due to the outgoing state plus a higher order contribution from external gravitons <ref:2605. p. 3
Where the paper says it

1) where E (3) rr (u) ∼ 1/r3 is the electric part of the Weyl tensor to leading order in a large r expansion at constant retarded time u, and F is the energy per unit solid angle radiated to infinity due to massless particles, which to first order in perturbation theory does not include gravitons. In [16] it is shown that acting the properly defined memory detector on states including external hard gravitons leads to the same formula, but with F including energy contributions from gravitons produced in the scattering event.

06774#pg20> The final result for gravitational memory is derived by combining these terms <ref:2605. p. 4
Where the paper says it

However, we will see that these terms affect physical observables and must be included in memory calculations. Here we will show that the mathematical conditions on dressings derived in the works [25] and [26] can be strengthened slightly such that the dressing is uniquely – 4 –

p. 4
Where the paper says it

However, we will see that these terms affect physical observables and must be included in memory calculations. Here we will show that the mathematical conditions on dressings derived in the works [25] and [26] can be strengthened slightly such that the dressing is uniquely – 4 –

p. 4
Where the paper says it

However, we will see that these terms affect physical observables and must be included in memory calculations. Here we will show that the mathematical conditions on dressings derived in the works [25] and [26] can be strengthened slightly such that the dressing is uniquely – 4 –

p. 4
Where the paper says it

However, we will see that these terms affect physical observables and must be included in memory calculations. Here we will show that the mathematical conditions on dressings derived in the works [25] and [26] can be strengthened slightly such that the dressing is uniquely – 4 –

06774#pg20>

Conclusion

The paper concludes that the correct choice of the dressing is achieved when it is chosen in this manner, which satisfies the requirements laid out in [25] and upholds two additional requirements <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The authors stress that keeping the full time dependence of the dressed states and detectors provides an interesting framework to calculate sub-leading effects in QFT scattering <ref:2605. p. 9

Where the paper says it

We believe that this is more than just a formality, and keeping the full t dependence of the dressed states and detectors provides an interesting framework to calculate sub-leading effects in QFT scattering. The effective t dependence of the ω0 is why we refer to the memory detector as a ‘finite-time detector’.

06774#pg20> They believe this formalism is a step towards fully describing the properties of Fock spaces at finite distances from scattering processes <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The paper concludes that only the rotationally invariant choice of cµ(k) is correct <ref:2605. p. 9
Where the paper says it

However, the cµ part of the dressing is needed to obtain the physical Fock space, and thus must be included. Our result is then that only the rotationally invariant choice of cµ is correct.

06774#pg20>

B Detector memory calculations

The calculation for the gravitational detector memory eigenvalue is shown to be reproduced by computing the commutator of DADB∆GR AB with the FK dressing and graviton operators <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The final result is found to be Λ(c, p) = −8ωp − 6p · yb <ref:2605.06774#pg20> This result is obtained by choosing the correct time dependence of ω0 and the unique rotationally invariant choice q(k) = (1, −kb) <ref:2605. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Our result is then that only the rotationally invariant choice of cµ is correct. Note also that the t limit must be taken carefully with the ω0 → 0 limit as shown in Appendix B.

06774#pg20> The requirement for the correct time dependence of ω0 was required and only the rotationally invariant choice of q(k) yields this result <ref:2605. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Our result is then that only the rotationally invariant choice of cµ is correct. Note also that the t limit must be taken carefully with the ω0 → 0 limit as shown in Appendix B.

06774#pg20>

The calculation for the gravitational memory eigenvalue is shown to be equal to the contribution to the memory due to the outgoing state as derived by Bieri and Garfinkle in [5], plus a higher order contribution from external gravitons <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The final result is shown to be λ(yb) = E(3)rr (∞) − X i=0,1 [E(3)rr (∞)][i] + 8π F − X i=0,1 [F][i] <ref:2605. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Our result is then that only the rotationally invariant choice of cµ is correct. Note also that the t limit must be taken carefully with the ω0 → 0 limit as shown in Appendix B.

06774#pg20> This is what was required <ref:2605. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We explain how these higher order perturbative corrections arise in inclusive in-in calculations. arXiv:2605.

06774#pg20> The authors stress once more that the correct t dependence of ω0 was required and only the rotationally invariant choice of cµν yields this result <ref:2605. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Our result is then that only the rotationally invariant choice of cµ is correct. Note also that the t limit must be taken carefully with the ω0 → 0 limit as shown in Appendix B.

p. 9
Where the paper says it

Our result is then that only the rotationally invariant choice of cµ is correct. Note also that the t limit must be taken carefully with the ω0 → 0 limit as shown in Appendix B.

06774#pg20> The final result for gravitational memory is derived by combining these terms <ref:2605.06774#pg20>

Where the gains come from

The authors show that the memory detector we have used in this paper is the full memory detector (classically) with higher order effects appearing from higher order Feynman diagrams, rather than from additional contributions to the memory detector <ref:2605.06774#pg20> This implies that no more soft emissions are relevant since the S-matrix is now IR finite <ref:2605.06774#pg20> Any contributions to the field at order 1/r are now encapsulated in the Faddeev-Kulish dressings of hard external particles <ref:2605. p. 0

Where the paper says it

edu Abstract: We show that for both QED and perturbative quantum gravity, finite-time Faddeev-Kulish dressings can be fully constrained by symmetry, and that this gives the unique choice which reproduces the classical memory effect. For gravity, we show that using this dressing to construct finite-time Fock spaces, as well as a carefully defined finite-time memory detector allows us to recover both the first order gravitational memory, as well as higher order Christodoulou contributions from the gravitational field.

06774#pg20> The paper shows that this formalism may be used to calculate higher order perturbative corrections to the memory effect <ref:2605. p. 3
Where the paper says it

In the scattering technology developed here and in [16] the hard graviton contributions are higher order in perturbation theory since attaching outgoing gravitons to Feynman diagrams requires including additional vertices. Thus, as we will argue in this paper, inclusive in-in calculations using the memory detector defined in [16] in fact capture higher order perturbative corrections through higher order Feynman diagrams.

06774#pg20> The authors believe that this is more than just a formality, and keeping the full t dependence of the dressed states and detectors provides an interesting framework to calculate sub-leading effects in QFT scattering <ref:2605. p. 9
Where the paper says it

The t dependence was also required to understand why the dressing does not contribute to the total energy of the state. We believe that this is more than just a formality, and keeping the full t dependence of the dressed states and detectors provides an interesting framework to calculate sub-leading effects in QFT scattering.

06774#pg20> The unique rotationally invariant choice of cµ is correct <ref:2605. p. 7
Where the paper says it

In [25] it is shown that any choice satisfying these conditions will produce a Fock space with the finite, correct S-matrix elements. However, here we will show that whilst this is true, in order to correctly capture the memory effect and thus construct the true physical Fock space including sub-leading effects, one must choose the unique rotationally invariant qµ qµ(k) = (1, −kb) .

06774#pg20>

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The paper shows that the dressing does not contribute to the total energy of the state calculated without dressings using the Riemann-Lebesgue lemma <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The authors show that by allowing us to include external hard gravitons, our formalism may be used to calculate higher order perturbative corrections to the memory effect <ref:2605. p. 1

Where the paper says it

More recently, Bieri and Garfinkle used the Weyl tensor to rederive the memory effect in gravity to first order in perturbation theory in a gauge invariant manner [5]. 1 Much interesting work has also been done recently to formalise how to calculate the memory effect in QED and perturbative quantum gravity using QFT scattering technology [7–15] and these methods have recently been generalised to include scattering processes containing external hard gravitons using time dependent detectors and gauge fixed FK dressed Fock spaces [16].

06774#pg20> The paper concludes that they have constructed the fully correct dressing formalism at leading order for both massive QED and perturbative quantum gravity coupled to a massive scalar <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The paper concludes that only the rotationally invariant choice of cµ is correct <ref:2605. p. 9
Where the paper says it

However, the cµ part of the dressing is needed to obtain the physical Fock space, and thus must be included. Our result is then that only the rotationally invariant choice of cµ is correct.

p. 9
Where the paper says it

However, the cµ part of the dressing is needed to obtain the physical Fock space, and thus must be included. Our result is then that only the rotationally invariant choice of cµ is correct.

06774#pg20>

In (A.1) the QED memory detector is written as DX∆EM X (z, z) = −4π lim ω0→0 (∂zLω0 [Fuz](∞, y) + ∂zLω0 [Fuz](∞, y)) <ref:2605. p. 8

Where the paper says it

We have DX∆EM X (z, z) = −4π lim ω0→0 (∂zLω0 [Fuz](∞, y) + ∂zLω0 [Fuz](∞, y)) . 21) Here the stereographic coordinates {z, z} refer to the direction in which the detector approaches the celestial sphere, and this direction is parametrized by the null vector y where y = (1, z + z 1 + |z| 2 , i z − z 1 + |z| 2 , 1 − |z| 2 1 + |z| 2 ) .

06774#pg20> In (A.5) the gravitational memory detector is defined as DADB∆GR AB = lim ω0→0 r 8πG D2zLω0 [∂uhzz](∞, y) + D2zLω0 [∂uhzz](∞, y) <ref:2605. p. 0
Where the paper says it

edu Abstract: We show that for both QED and perturbative quantum gravity, finite-time Faddeev-Kulish dressings can be fully constrained by symmetry, and that this gives the unique choice which reproduces the classical memory effect. For gravity, we show that using this dressing to construct finite-time Fock spaces, as well as a carefully defined finite-time memory detector allows us to recover both the first order gravitational memory, as well as higher order Christodoulou contributions from the gravitational field.

06774#pg20>

The calculation for the QED detector memory eigenvalue is shown to be reproduced by computing the commutator of the memory detector with the FK dressing and photon operators <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The result [DX∆EM X (z, z), iqs'Φ(t, ps')] reproduces the required result <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The calculation for the gravitational detector memory eigenvalue is shown to be reproduced by computing the commutator of DADB∆GR AB with the FK dressing and graviton operators <ref:2605. p. 5

Where the paper says it

To the best of our knowledge it has also not been shown before how to calculate higher order perturbative contributions to gravitational memory using tim dependent scattering technology. In the appendices we cover the mathematical nuances of our detector definitions and calculations, and explicitly show that our results are reproduced by classical calculations.

06774#pg20>

The final result for gravitational memory is derived by combining these terms <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The authors stress once more that the correct t dependence of ω0 was required and only the rotationally invariant choice of cµν yields this result <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The final result for gravitational memory is derived by combining these terms <ref:2605.06774#pg20>

The paper concludes that the correct choice of the dressing is achieved when it is chosen in this manner, which satisfies the requirements laid out in [25] and upholds two additional requirements <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The authors stress once more that keeping the full time dependence of the dressed states and detectors provides an interesting framework to calculate sub-leading effects in QFT scattering <ref:2605. p. 9

Where the paper says it

We believe that this is more than just a formality, and keeping the full t dependence of the dressed states and detectors provides an interesting framework to calculate sub-leading effects in QFT scattering. The effective t dependence of the ω0 is why we refer to the memory detector as a ‘finite-time detector’.

06774#pg20> They believe this formalism is a step towards fully describing the properties of Fock spaces at finite distances from scattering processes <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The paper concludes that only the rotationally invariant choice of cµ is correct <ref:2605.06774#pg20> The final result for gravitational memory is derived by combining these terms <ref:2605.06774#pg20>

References

The references listed are [1] K.S. Christodoulou, D. p. 0

Where the paper says it

edu Abstract: We show that for both QED and perturbative quantum gravity, finite-time Faddeev-Kulish dressings can be fully constrained by symmetry, and that this gives the unique choice which reproduces the classical memory effect. For gravity, we show that using this dressing to construct finite-time Fock spaces, as well as a carefully defined finite-time memory detector allows us to recover both the first order gravitational memory, as well as higher order Christodoulou contributions from the gravitational field.

, The global nonlinear stability of the minkowski space, S´eminaire Equations aux d´eriv´ees partielles (Polytechnique) ´ (1989-1990) 1 <ref:2605.06774#pg19> [2] V.B. Braginsky and K.S. Thorne, Gravitational-wave bursts with memory and experimental prospects, Nature 327 (1987) 123 <ref:2605. p. 3
Where the paper says it

In [16] it is shown that acting the properly defined memory detector on states including external hard gravitons leads to the same formula, but with F including energy contributions from gravitons produced in the scattering event. This was already predicted by Thorne in 1992 [3].

06774#pg19> [3] K.S. Thorne, Gravitational-wave bursts with memory: The christodoulou effect, Phys. p. 0
Where the paper says it

edu Abstract: We show that for both QED and perturbative quantum gravity, finite-time Faddeev-Kulish dressings can be fully constrained by symmetry, and that this gives the unique choice which reproduces the classical memory effect. For gravity, we show that using this dressing to construct finite-time Fock spaces, as well as a carefully defined finite-time memory detector allows us to recover both the first order gravitational memory, as well as higher order Christodoulou contributions from the gravitational field.

Rev. D 45 (1992) 520 <ref:2605. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We explain how these higher order perturbative corrections arise in inclusive in-in calculations. arXiv:2605.

06774#pg19> [4] A.G. Wiseman and C.M. Will, Christodoulou’s nonlinear gravitational wave memory: Evaluation in the quadrupole approximation, Phys. p. 0
Where the paper says it

edu Abstract: We show that for both QED and perturbative quantum gravity, finite-time Faddeev-Kulish dressings can be fully constrained by symmetry, and that this gives the unique choice which reproduces the classical memory effect. For gravity, we show that using this dressing to construct finite-time Fock spaces, as well as a carefully defined finite-time memory detector allows us to recover both the first order gravitational memory, as well as higher order Christodoulou contributions from the gravitational field.

Rev. D 44 (1991) R2945 <ref:2605. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We explain how these higher order perturbative corrections arise in inclusive in-in calculations. arXiv:2605.

06774#pg19> [5] L. Bieri and D. p. 1
Where the paper says it

It has also been calculated in perturbation theory [2–4]. More recently, Bieri and Garfinkle used the Weyl tensor to rederive the memory effect in gravity to first order in perturbation theory in a gauge invariant manner [5].

p. 1
Where the paper says it

It has also been calculated in perturbation theory [2–4]. More recently, Bieri and Garfinkle used the Weyl tensor to rederive the memory effect in gravity to first order in perturbation theory in a gauge invariant manner [5].

Garfinkle, Perturbative and gauge invariant treatment of gravitational wave memory, Physical Review D 89 (2014) <ref:2605. p. 1
Where the paper says it

More recently, Bieri and Garfinkle used the Weyl tensor to rederive the memory effect in gravity to first order in perturbation theory in a gauge invariant manner [5]. 1 Much interesting work has also been done recently to formalise how to calculate the memory effect in QED and perturbative quantum gravity using QFT scattering technology [7–15] and these methods have recently been generalised to include scattering processes containing external hard gravitons using time dependent detectors and gauge fixed FK dressed Fock spaces [16].

06774#pg19> [6] L. Bieri and D. Garfinkle, An electromagnetic analogue of gravitational wave memory, Classical and Quantum Gravity 30 (2013) 195009 <ref:2605. p. 5
Where the paper says it

By this we mean that they reproduce the first order electromagnetic and gravity memory effects, and also the higher order contributions from gravitational waves in the gravity case. The theories we consider are massive scalar QED and a massive scalar coupled to perturbative quantum gravity.

06774#pg19> [7] B. Gabai and A. Sever, Large gauge symmetries and asymptotic states in qed, Journal of High Energy Physics 2016 (2016) <ref:2605.06774#pg19> [8] S. Pasterski, Asymptotic Symmetries and Electromagnetic Memory, JHEP 09 (2017) 154 <ref:2605. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Prepared for submission to JHEP Finite-time memory detectors and fully constraining Faddeev-Kulish dressings in QED and gravity Brett Oertel,a aDepartment of Physics, Yale University, 217 Prospect St, New Haven, CT 06511, USA E-mail: brett. oertel@yale.

06774#pg19> [9] A. Strominger and A. Zhiboedov, Gravitational Memory, BMS Supertranslations and Soft Theorems, JHEP 01 (2016) 086 <ref:2605. p. 3
Where the paper says it

FK dressings play a critical role in the memory calculations we will perform. However, FK dressings historically arose for a different reason, namely to resolve the IR divergences in the S-matrices of QED and perturbative quantum gravity which occur as external photons and gravitons become soft (these are described by the Weinberg soft theorems [28]).

06774#pg19> [10] S. Choi, U. Kol and R. Akhoury, Asymptotic dynamics in perturbative quantum gravity and bms supertranslations, Journal of High Energy Physics 2018 (2018) <ref:2605. p. 3
Where the paper says it

However, FK dressings historically arose for a different reason, namely to resolve the IR divergences in the S-matrices of QED and perturbative quantum gravity which occur as external photons and gravitons become soft (these are described by the Weinberg soft theorems [28]). In 1965 Chung showed how to write down IR safe asymptotic states consisting of massive particles in QED [29].

06774#pg19> [11] K. Prabhu, G. Satishchandran and R.M. Wald, Infrared finite scattering theory in quantum field theory and quantum gravity, Phys. p. 9
Where the paper says it

The effective t dependence of the ω0 is why we refer to the memory detector as a ‘finite-time detector’. 3 Perturbative quantum gravity Now we will tell an analogous story in a theory consisting of a massive scalar field coupled to perturbative quantum gravity.

Rev. D 106 (2022) 066005 <ref:2605. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We explain how these higher order perturbative corrections arise in inclusive in-in calculations. arXiv:2605.

06774#pg19> [12] H. Hirai and S. p. 6
Where the paper says it

We will see that in general it is physically needed to describe subleading effects. The function φ is any smoothing function and is needed to make certain 7A time dependent formalism for QED dressings was also constructed in a series of papers by Hirai and Sugishita [12–14].

p. 6
Where the paper says it

We will see that in general it is physically needed to describe subleading effects. The function φ is any smoothing function and is needed to make certain 7A time dependent formalism for QED dressings was also constructed in a series of papers by Hirai and Sugishita [12–14].

p. 6
Where the paper says it

We will see that in general it is physically needed to describe subleading effects. The function φ is any smoothing function and is needed to make certain 7A time dependent formalism for QED dressings was also constructed in a series of papers by Hirai and Sugishita [12–14].

Sugishita, Dressed states from gauge invariance, Journal of High Energy Physics 2019 (2019) <ref:2605.06774#pg19> [13] H. Hirai and S. Sugishita, Ir finite s-matrix by gauge invariant dressed states, Journal of High Energy Physics 2021 (2021) <ref:2605. p. 3
Where the paper says it

In 1965 Chung showed how to write down IR safe asymptotic states consisting of massive particles in QED [29]. To do this, Chung ‘dressed’ charged particles with an infinite number of photons such that the S-matrix elements of these states are finite.

06774#pg19> [14] H. Hirai and S. Sugishita, Dress code for infrared safe scattering in qed, Progress of Theoretical and Experimental Physics 2023 (2023) <ref:2605.06774#pg19> [15] I. Moult, S.A. Narayanan and S. Pasterski, Memory correlators and ward identities in the ’in-in’ formalism, 2025 <ref:2605. p. 2
Where the paper says it

3That a t dependent formalism is necessary is noted in [14]. 4Since we include the time dependence explicitly we refer to the memory detectors we define as ‘finitetime detectors’.

06774#pg19> [16] B. Oertel, I. Moult and S. Pasterski, Asymptotic charges as detectors and the memory effect in massive QED and perturbative quantum gravity, 2604. p. 1
Where the paper says it

More recently, Bieri and Garfinkle used the Weyl tensor to rederive the memory effect in gravity to first order in perturbation theory in a gauge invariant manner [5]. 1 Much interesting work has also been done recently to formalise how to calculate the memory effect in QED and perturbative quantum gravity using QFT scattering technology [7–15] and these methods have recently been generalised to include scattering processes containing external hard gravitons using time dependent detectors and gauge fixed FK dressed Fock spaces [16].

19866 <ref:2605. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We explain how these higher order perturbative corrections arise in inclusive in-in calculations. arXiv:2605.

06774#pg19> [17] N. Christ, B. Hasslacher and A.H. Mueller, Light-cone behavior of perturbation theory, Phys. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The full non-linear memory effect was first calculated in classical gravity by Christodoulou [1]. It has also been calculated in perturbation theory [2–4].

Rev. D 6 (1972) 3543 <ref:2605. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We explain how these higher order perturbative corrections arise in inclusive in-in calculations. arXiv:2605.

06774#pg19> [18] R.A. Brandt and G. Preparata, Operator product expansions near the light cone, Nuclear Physics B 27 (1971) 541 <ref:2605.06774#pg19> [19] G.F. Sterman, Jet Structure in e+ e- Annihilation with Massless Hadrons,. p. 5
Where the paper says it

1) where we are using the constant time commutation relations [a(p), a† (q)] = 2ωp(2π) d−1 δ d−1 (p − q) , [b(p), b† (q)] = 2ωp(2π) d−1 δ d−1 (p − q) , [αr(p), α† s (q)] = 2δrsωp(2π) d−1 δ d−1 (p − q) . 2) In canonical quantisation the canonical scattering Fock spaces are formed by acting on the vacuum with creation or annihilation operators defined on constant time slices with large |t|, i.

<ref:2605.06774#pg19> [20] C.L. Basham, L.S. Brown, S.D. Ellis and S.T. Love, Energy correlations in electron-positron annihilation in quantum chromodynamics: Asymptotically free perturbation theory, Phys. p. 1
Where the paper says it

More recently, Bieri and Garfinkle used the Weyl tensor to rederive the memory effect in gravity to first order in perturbation theory in a gauge invariant manner [5]. 1 Much interesting work has also been done recently to formalise how to calculate the memory effect in QED and perturbative quantum gravity using QFT scattering technology [7–15] and these methods have recently been generalised to include scattering processes containing external hard gravitons using time dependent detectors and gauge fixed FK dressed Fock spaces [16].

Rev. D 19 (1979) 2018 <ref:2605. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We explain how these higher order perturbative corrections arise in inclusive in-in calculations. arXiv:2605.

06774#pg19> [21] D.M. Hofman and J. Maldacena, Conformal collider physics: energy and charge correlations, Journal of High Energy Physics 2008 (2008) 012–012 <ref:2605. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Prepared for submission to JHEP Finite-time memory detectors and fully constraining Faddeev-Kulish dressings in QED and gravity Brett Oertel,a aDepartment of Physics, Yale University, 217 Prospect St, New Haven, CT 06511, USA E-mail: brett. oertel@yale.

06774#pg19> [22] S. Caron-Huot, M.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can perform fully time dependent calculations for QED and perturbative quantum gravity by implementing Faddeev-Kulish dressings to construct gauge fixed Fock spaces. This allows the system to consistently handle soft limits in a manner that reproduces classical memory effects.

  2. The system can calculate higher order perturbative corrections to gravitational memory, known as non-linear Christodoulou null memory, by utilizing inclusive in-in calculations with a detector defined on constant time surfaces.

  3. The AI can derive the unique rotationally invariant choice for the dressing function by enforcing constraints that ensure it reproduces the classical electromagnetic effect for all scattering states while maintaining IR finiteness and energy conservation.

  4. The system can calculate gravitational memory contributions from outgoing hard gravitons, which are captured through higher order Feynman diagrams in inclusive in-in calculations, a feature neglected in lower order treatments like Bieri and Garfinkle's.

Abstract

We show that for both QED and perturbative quantum gravity, time dependent Faddeev-Kulish dressings can be fully constrained either by symmetry, or by demanding that they reproduce the correct outgoing classical memory contribution. For gravity, we show that using this dressing to construct finite-time Fock spaces allows us to recover both the first order gravitational memory, as well as higher order Christodoulou contributions from the gravitational field. We explain how these higher order perturbative corrections arise in inclusive in-in calculations.

Sources

Related papers