Quantum criticality beyond thermodynamic stability
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Quantum Radio. Generated commentary on the latest quantum physics and condensed matter papers.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Quantum criticality beyond thermodynamic stability".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. For a many-body system in equilibrium described by a thermodynamically stable Hamiltonian, quantum criticality is typically linked to structural changes in the many-body ground state.
Kai: However, quadratic bosonic Hamiltonians (QBHs) can fail to possess a ground state.
Mira: The authors establish that criticality is significant for all dynamically stable QBHs or at the boundary of dynamical instability, irrespective of thermodynamic stability.
Kai: The central concept here is the naturally and unambiguously defined quasiparticle vacuum (QPV), which is Gaussian and coincides with the ground state when the QBH is thermodynamically stable.
Title and authors: Kai: So we’re talking about this paper called "Quantum criticality beyond thermodynamic stability". It's about quadratic bosonic Hamiltonians, or QBHs. These are systems that can be dynamically stable even if they don't have a ground state in equilibrium.
Mira: Right, so the authors are saying that quantum criticality isn't just for systems that have a nice ground state in equilibrium, which is what we usually think of when we talk about structural changes in the system. They found that this concept is actually important for all dynamically stable QBHs or right at the edge of where they become dynamically unstable, regardless of whether they are thermodynamically stable or not.
Lev: That means we can look at systems that might not settle down to a ground state and still have these critical points to study. But what’s the main idea here? They introduce something called the quasiparticle vacuum, or QPV.
Kai: Exactly. The QPV is Gaussian, and it matches the ground state when the system is thermodynamically stable. The key feature they identify is a spectral gap called the Krein gap, or Delta K rein.
Mira: That Krein gap tells us about the minimal spectral separation between creation and annihilation operators of these quasiparticles. If that Krein gap is greater than zero, it means the QPV is unique.
Lev: And they say that for dynamically stable QBHs with finite-range couplings, the correlations in this QPV are exponentially bounded unless that Krein gap closes at a specific point called an exceptional point or a Krein collision.
Kai: So the paper suggests that this Krein gap acts like the standard spectral gap for these dynamically stable QBHs. It’s not just about finding a ground state anymore; it’s about this dynamical stability boundary.
Mira: And they also show that thermodynamic stability can be separate from dynamical stability, which means we can have criticality in the QPV even when the system isn't thermodynamically stable in the first place.
Lev: That decoupling is important because it suggests that the behavior of this quasiparticle vacuum doesn't always map directly onto ground state criticality in simpler free boson systems.
Kai: And they point to how this works with long-range correlations in the QPV. They say those are only possible at these dynamical stability phase boundaries where the Krein gap is zero.
Mira: So, an exceptional point signals a transition where correlations switch from decaying exponentially to becoming long-range, and a Krein collision shows a more complicated path dependent scaling.
Lev: That’s the distinction they make between these two types of critical points. It gives us a way to characterize multicritical behavior in these QBH systems.
Kai: They also introduce some interesting concepts about how we measure this criticality using information geometry, which is useful for looking at equilibrium criticality indicators like entanglement entropy scaling.
Mira: And they use the quantum metric tensor, or QMT, as a diagnostic tool because it diverges precisely at these critical points they found through correlation functions.
Title and authors: Lev: That sounds like a good way to probe the multicritical nature of a Krein collision point, since it gives us something sharp to measure.
Kai: The fundamental difference they emphasize is that dynamical stability and instability matter more than thermodynamic stability for QBHs, especially when comparing them to fermions where a QPV ground state always exists.
Mira: And they suggest that dynamical stability might be the underlying reason for the exponential advantage in quantum simulation reported for certain QBHs, while dynamical instability marks a transition to PostBQP complexity.
Lev: If you think about running this on real hardware, that implies that we need to worry about whether the system stays in a dynamically stable regime or moves into that unstable region during the calculation.
Kai: And they propose lifting the stability requirements as a necessary step for classifying QBHs based on symmetry. That seems like a big conceptual shift for how we look at these systems.
Mira: So, to wrap up this paper "Quantum criticality beyond thermodynamic stability", they established that we need to broaden our definition of where we look for quantum critical behavior in bosonic systems. They showed that the Krein gap is the right tool, and the boundary between dynamical stability and instability is marked by exceptional points or Krein collisions.
Lev: And they also highlighted how this framework applies to dynamically unstable models from photonics, opto-mechanics, cavity QED, and magnonics. That shows its broad applicability beyond just simple condensed matter physics.
Kai: So what does this mean for us in the lab? It means we can use these dynamical stability boundaries to predict where quantum phase transitions might happen even when the system isn't in a perfect equilibrium state.
Mira: And it gives us a new way to look at entanglement entropy scaling, using information geometry indicators derived from this QPV structure.
Lev: For me, the main point is that we need to focus our error correction efforts on understanding these dynamical boundaries where the Krein gap closes. That’s where the complexity really lands for real hardware implementations of QBHs.
Kai: We're moving toward a way to identify critical behavior in systems that aren't strictly thermodynamically stable, using this new Krein gap concept.
Mira: It opens up a whole new avenue for analyzing quantum phase transitions in non-equilibrium steady states and photonics, including thermodynamically unstable models from areas like cavity QED.
Lev: And the paper clearly shows that the distinction between an exceptional point and a Krein collision is crucial for understanding how long-range correlations develop.
Kai: So, if you're looking at a QBH system, don't just look at thermodynamic stability; look at where its dynamical stability breaks down using this spectral gap analysis.
Mira: We’re leaving it there on the paper "Quantum criticality beyond thermodynamic stability", but keep an eye on how this framework connects to other areas like Moiré physics and fractional Chern insulators we discussed last time.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, to recap, this paper is moving beyond just looking at systems that are perfectly stable in equilibrium when we talk about quantum criticality.
Mira: Right, they’re focusing on quadratic bosonic Hamiltonians or QBHs, and they’re saying you still get these important critical points even if the system isn't thermodynamically stable.
Lev: It seems like the authors are proposing a new way to define what a spectral gap means for these systems, using this thing called the Krein gap.
Kai: Exactly. They introduce this Krein gap as the spectral separation between those quasiparticle operators, and they say it functions like the standard energy gap for these dynamically stable QBHs.
Mira: And they show that this allows us to look at criticality in a way that can be completely separate from what you usually find in simpler free boson systems.
Lev: They’re telling us that dynamical stability and thermodynamic stability can actually be decoupled, which means we can have different kinds of critical behavior depending on how you define the system.
Kai: And when the Krein gap is zero, that's where things get really interesting—that’s where you see long-range correlations in the quasiparticle vacuum.
Mira: They distinguish between two types of these zero-gap points: exceptional points and Krein collisions, which tells us how the scaling of those correlations behaves.
Lev: The exceptional point seems to be a transition from exponential decay to something more like long-range behavior, while the Krein collision is where you get this more path dependent scaling.
Kai: And they link this directly to entanglement entropy in the QPV; it scales inversely with that Krein gap when it’s positive.
Mira: It’s also using information geometry here, specifically the quantum metric tensor, which diverges exactly at those critical points they found through correlation functions.
Lev: That sounds like a really sharp diagnostic tool for pinpointing the exact nature of a multicritical point, especially at a Krein collision.
Kai: The big idea is that this framework applies to all dynamically stable QBHs or right at the edge of dynamical instability, which is much broader than just looking for ground state changes.
Mira: It extends this analysis to non-equilibrium steady states and photonics, meaning we can use this lens on models from cavity QED and magnonics too.
Lev: So, the practical implication is that if you're building real quantum hardware with these bosonic systems, you need to track where that Krein gap goes to zero because that’s where the complexity really lands for your error correction overhead.
The paper's improvements: Tom: So, to recap, they’re suggesting that this new way of looking at QBHs is powerful because it lets us look at criticality even when we don't have a perfectly stable equilibrium system.
Kai: They are proposing using the Krein gap as the main tool for finding critical behavior, and they say this makes sense whether the system is thermodynamically stable or not.
Mira: The paper is pushing for this concept to be applied to everything from photonics and cavity QED right into condensed matter physics like Moiré systems.
Lev: They are also emphasizing that we need a clearer way to distinguish between different types of critical points, specifically by looking at the path dependence when you approach a Krein collision versus an exceptional point.
Kai: That path dependence is important because it gives us more nuance in understanding how long-range correlations develop and where they start.
Mira: And they suggest using the quantum metric tensor, that QMT, as a diagnostic tool because it diverges precisely at these critical points identified through correlation functions.
Lev: That divergence is key for probing the multicritical nature of a Krein collision, giving us a sharp way to measure that specific singularity.
Kai: So what does this mean for the hardware side? It means we can use information geometry indicators derived from this QPV structure to monitor state sensitivity near these critical regions.
Mira: They’re essentially providing a new set of equilibrium criticality indicators, like scaling in entanglement entropy, but tied directly to the dynamical stability boundary.
Lev: The paper also touches on the bigger picture by saying that lifting the requirement for thermodynamic stability might be necessary if we want to classify QBHs based purely on symmetry.
Kai: That’s a big conceptual step toward topological classifications, suggesting that dynamical stability is a more fundamental property than strict thermodynamic stability in this context.
Mira: It also hints at why dynamical stability might be the reason we see certain advantages in quantum simulation reported for some QBHs, linking it to PostBQP complexity.
Lev: So, the paper’s improvements point toward making our error correction efforts more focused on tracking these dynamical boundaries where the Krein gap closes.
Kai: It means we should be looking at those zero-gap points as the primary targets for understanding where computational complexity transitions occur in these systems.
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, the paper "Quantum criticality beyond thermodynamic stability" argues that we can find important quantum critical behavior in systems that aren't perfectly stable at equilibrium by focusing on dynamical stability boundaries and the Krein gap.
Mira: Exactly, they show this concept applies broadly to quadratic bosonic Hamiltonians and even into areas like cavity QED, which is really pushing how we think about phase transitions.
Lev: From my side, it’s important because it gives us a concrete way to look at the complexity of running simulations on real hardware; tracking that Krein gap closing is where the error overhead lands.
Kai: It seems like this work fundamentally changes our definition of what constitutes a critical point in these bosonic systems, moving beyond just standard energy gaps.
Mira: They’re proposing a new framework for understanding entanglement and quantum metric tensor divergence at these boundaries, which should be useful for analyzing non-equilibrium states.
Lev: I think the distinction between an exceptional point and a Krein collision is crucial because it tells us if the correlations are long-range or just exponentially bounded.
Kai: It’s a fine way to characterize multicritical behavior, separating the smooth transitions from more complicated path dependent scaling.
Mira: So, while they don't solve all the stability issues for QBHs yet, this framework opens up a new avenue for analyzing quantum phase transitions in non-equilibrium steady states and photonics.
Lev: I’m still thinking about how robust this is when you try to implement it on actual superconducting circuits where we have those decoherence issues that limit our measurement record fidelity.
Kai: That fidelity is definitely the next hurdle, but having this theoretical tool should help us design better measurements for those specific dynamic regimes.
Mira: The work suggests that lifting the requirement for thermodynamic stability might be a necessary step if we want to achieve topological classifications based purely on symmetry for these systems.
Lev: It’s a big shift conceptually, moving away from relying solely on ground state properties when analyzing these bosonic models.
Kai: So, it’s clear that understanding the dynamical stability of QBHs and using the Krein gap as our spectral gap is a major step forward in this area.
Mira: This paper "Quantum criticality beyond thermodynamic stability" gives us a lot to chew on regarding where we should be focusing our theoretical efforts next.
Department of Physics and Astronomy, Dartmouth College · Department of Physics, Boston College · Department of Physics, SUNY Polytechnic Institute
quant-ph
Submitted: 2026-05-05
Updated: 2026-11-09
Comments: 38 pages, 8 figures
Journal ref: New J. Phys. 28 114504 (2026)
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 88/100
The gist: For a many-body system in equilibrium described by a thermodynamically stable Hamiltonian, quantum criticality is typically linked to structural changes in the many-body ground state.
Key concepts
- Krein Gap ($\Delta K_{\text{rein}}$)
- This is a new spectral gap for dynamically stable QBHs, measuring the minimal spectral separation between creation and annihilation operators. It vanishes only at exceptional points (EPs) or Krein collisions (KCs), serving as the key diagnostic for criticality in these systems.
- Quasiparticle Vacuum (QPV)
- The QPV is a unique, Gaussian state that coincides with the ground state when a QBH is thermodynamically stable. Its properties, like correlation boundedness and entanglement scaling, reveal critical behavior related to dynamical stability.
- Dynamical Stability vs. Thermodynamic Stability
- A key finding is that criticality in the QPV is governed by dynamical stability rather than thermodynamic stability. This means systems can exhibit quantum criticality even if they are not stable in the traditional thermodynamic sense, which is crucial for understanding certain bosonic models.
Terminology
Summary
For a many-body system in equilibrium described by a thermodynamically stable Hamiltonian, quantum criticality is typically linked to structural changes in the many-body ground state. p. 0 Flynn2,1
, Emilio Cobanera3,1
, and Lorenza Viola1
1Department of Physics and Astronomy, Dartmouth College, 6127 Wilder Laboratory, Hanover, NH 03755, USA
2Department of Physics, Boston College, 140 Commonwealth Avenue, Chestnut Hill, MA 02467, USA
3Department of Physics, SUNY Polytechnic Institute, 100 Seymour Avenue, Utica, NY 13502, USA
Abstract. For a many-body system in equilibrium, described by a thermodynamically stable Hamiltonian, quantum
criticality is associated with structural changes of the many-body ground state. For a many-body system in equilibrium, described by a thermodynamically stable Hamiltonian, quantum
criticality is associated with structural changes of the many-body ground state. However, there exist physically relevant
models, notably, certain quadratic bosonic Hamiltonians (QBHs), which fail to have a ground state. From a dynamical systemtheory standpoint, QBHs can be either dynamically stable or unstable. We show that criticality is a meaningful concept for the
entire class of QBHs that are dynamically stable or at the boundary of instability – regardless of thermodynamic stability –
and that the key state for such QBHs is a naturally and unambiguously defined quasiparticle vacuum. We show that criticality is a meaningful concept for the
entire class of QBHs that are dynamically stable or at the boundary of instability – regardless of thermodynamic stability –
and that the key state for such QBHs is a naturally and unambiguously defined quasiparticle vacuum. This state is Gaussian,
and coincides with the ground state if the QBH is thermodynamically stable. This state is Gaussian,
and coincides with the ground state if the QBH is thermodynamically stable. We identify a relevant spectral gap, the Krein
gap, associated to the minimal spectral separation between creation and annihilation operators, and show that the quasiparticle
vacuum is unique when the Krein gap is positive. Second, a
QBH can be thermodynamically unstable and yet still display dynamical stability phases separated by a critical phase
boundary. This is because a dynamically stable QBH away from a stability phase boundary is associated to a unique
quasiparticle vacuum (QPV), the state annihilated by all the (quasiparticle) normal modes of the Hamiltonian. We identify a relevant spectral gap, the Krein
gap, associated to the minimal spectral separation between creation and annihilation operators, and show that the quasiparticle
vacuum is unique when the Krein gap is positive. In addition, we prove that, for dynamically stable QBHs with finite-range
couplings, correlations are exponentially bounded unless the Krein gap closes – which is associated with one of two kinds
of spectral degeneracies: an exceptional point (physically, a free-particle-like collective mode) or a Krein collision (often a
bosonic zero mode). As a consequence, long-range correlations can ensue in the quasiparticle vacuum. We conclude that (i)
the Krein gap takes the role of the spectral gap for dynamically stable QBHs, and (ii) the boundary of dynamical stability
and criticality (associated to exceptional points) or multicriticality (associated to Krein collisions) are one and the same. We conclude that (i)
the Krein gap takes the role of the spectral gap for dynamically stable QBHs, and (ii) the boundary of dynamical stability
and criticality (associated to exceptional points) or multicriticality (associated to Krein collisions) are one and the same. Alongside long-range correlations, we find that bosonic critical behavior beyond thermodynamic stability is witnessed by the
scaling of the entanglement entropy and other indicators of equilibrium criticality from information geometry.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The Krein gap (delta K rein) is introduced as a new many-body spectral gap for dynamically stable QBHs, measuring the minimal distance between quasiparticle energy bands of opposite Krein signature or the distance to the nearest dynamical stability phase boundary in parameter space; it vanishes only at an EP or KC. p. 3 Criticality in quadratic bosonic Hamiltonians 4
eigenvectors of ±1 Krein signature, with respect to an indefinite metric that arises from bosonic commutation
relations [31, 6]. We show that ∆Krein quantifies the minimal distance between quasiparticle energy bands
of opposite Krein signature or, equivalently, the distance to the nearest dynamical stability phase boundary in
parameter space. Crucially – for arbitrary spatial dimension and number of internal degrees of freedom
– a unique, translationally invariant QPV always exists if ∆Krein is positive. • We prove that if ∆Krein > 0, the two-point (equal-time) spatial correlation functions in the QPV are exponentially
bounded. Hence, correlation functions computed in the QPV are blind to
transitions out of thermodynamic stability, unless they happen to coincide with a transition out of dynamical
stability as well. This implies that criticality in the QPV can be logically disconnected from GS criticality in free
boson systems: formally, given a thermodynamically and dynamically stable QBH H, there exists a dynamically
stable, but thermodynamically unstable H′
, with |GSH⟩ = |QPVH′ ⟩, such that H and H′
can be continuously
connected without closing ∆Krein. Within the mathematical literature, LTI dynamical systems generated by pseudo-Hermitian matrices have been
long studied [36]. In particular, a comprehensive characterization of the stability phase boundaries of such systems
has been obtained [31]. • Through analyzing illustrative examples, we find that, generically, an EP displays characteristics of a standard
quantum critical point – as it is parametrically approached, the correlation length diverges and, at the EP,
correlation functions tend to be long-range. KCs, found at the intersection of loci of EPs, share instead points of
contact with multicritical points, with their critical properties being highly dependent on the path of approach in
parameter space and their behavior at the KC harder to pin down. KCs, found at the intersection of loci of EPs, share instead points of
contact with multicritical points, with their critical properties being highly dependent on the path of approach in
parameter space and their behavior at the KC harder to pin down. • We show that the bipartite EE in the QPV obeys an area law and, as a Krein-gap closing is approached, it scales
inversely with ∆Krein – consistently extending existing results for thermodynamically stable QBHs [14, 19]. These conclusions are further corroborated by analyzing our representative
models through the lenses of information-geometric tools used for identifying quantum phase transitions [32]
and appropriately modified to account for the pseudo-Hermitian metric inherent to QBHs. Specifically, by
analyzing the behavior of the quantum fidelity and the quantum metric tensor (QMT) [33], we find that the points
in parameter space we have identified as (multi-)critical through diverging correlation functions consistently
coincide with singularities of the QMT. We show that criticality is a meaningful concept for the
entire class of QBHs that are dynamically stable or at the boundary of instability – regardless of thermodynamic stability –
and that the key state for such QBHs is a naturally and unambiguously defined quasiparticle vacuum. This state is Gaussian,
and coincides with the ground state if the QBH is thermodynamically stable. In this work, we propose to extend the range of applicability of the theory of critical phenomena to the entire
class of dynamically stable QBHs (see Fig. 1), by showing how – irrespective of thermodynamic stability – the QPV
furnishes the relevant state that can become critical (and even multicritical) at a dynamical stability phase transition. This is, in turn, consistent with another no-go theorem, also proved therein: any
two thermodynamically stable (in particular, gapped) QBHs in the same symmetry class (whatever the many-body
classifying symmetries may be) can be deformed into each other adiabatically, without closing the many-body energy
gap or leaving the symmetry class. These results suggest themselves as two sides of the same coin: thermodynamically
stable QBHs do not support symmetry-protected topological quantum phases.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improve QBH simulation by using a new notion of spectral gap called the Krein gap to identify critical behavior in systems that are not thermodynamically stable, as
the Krein gap takes the role of the spectral gap for dynamically stable QBHs.
-
Enable analysis of quantum phase transitions in non-equilibrium steady states and photonics by applying the framework to
all dynamically stable QBHs through the lens of critical phenomena, including thermodynamically unstable models from photonics, opto-mechanics, cavity-QED, and magnonics.
-
Develop a method to distinguish between different types of critical points in QBH systems by analyzing
the path-dependence at the KC
versusEPs,
which allows for more nuanced characterization of multicritical behavior wherethe scaling of the correlations being highly dependent upon the path of approach.
-
Create a diagnostic tool for quantum phase transitions using information geometry by employing the quantum metric tensor (QMT) to probe state distinguishability and sensitivity to parameter changes near critical singularities.
Abstract
For a many-body system in equilibrium, described by a thermodynamically stable Hamiltonian, quantum criticality is associated with structural changes of the many-body ground state. However, there exist physically relevant models, notably, certain quadratic bosonic Hamiltonians (QBHs), which fail to have a ground state. QBHs can be dynamically stable or unstable. We show the notion of criticality is meaningful for the entire class of QBHs that are dynamically stable or at the boundary of instability, regardless of thermodynamic stability, and that the key state for such QBHs is a naturally and unambiguously defined quasiparticle vacuum (QPV). This state is Gaussian, and coincides with the ground state if the QBH is thermodynamically stable. We identify a relevant spectral gap, the Krein gap, associated to the minimal spectral separation between creation and annihilation operators, and show that the QPV is unique when the Krein gap is positive. We prove that, for dynamically stable QBHs with finite-range couplings, correlations are exponentially bounded unless the Krein gap closes, which is associated with one of two spectral degeneracies: an exceptional point or a Krein collision. Consequently, long-range QPV correlations can ensue. Thus, the Krein gap takes the role of the spectral gap for dynamically stable QBHs, and the boundary of dynamical stability and criticality (associated to exceptional points) or multicriticality (associated to Krein collisions) are the same. We also find that bosonic critical behavior beyond thermodynamic stability is witnessed by the scaling of the entanglement entropy and other indicators of equilibrium criticality from information geometry. Our framework opens the door to investigating all dynamically stable QBHs through the lens of critical phenomena, including thermodynamically unstable ones from photonics, cavity-QED, and magnonics.
Sources
- Noise-driven quantum criticality
- Emergent spatiotemporal order and nonreciprocity in driven-dissipative nonlinear magnetic systems
- Dynamical metastability and transient topological magnons in interacting driven-dissipative magnetic systems
- Many-body symmetry-protected zero boundary modes of synthetic photo-magnonic crystals
- Quantum geometry of bosonic Bogoliubov quasiparticles
- Complexity of Quadratic Bosonic Hamiltonian Simulation: BQP-Completeness and PostBQP-Hardness
- Enhanced dissipative criticality at an exceptional point
Related papers
- Computational regimes in matrix-product-state-based quantum trajectory simulations
- Toward chemically accurate quantum simulations on quantum hardware: A quantum-HPC hybrid approach
- Transversal surface-code game with reconfigurable qubits
- Fulqrum: a generalized framework for quantum subspace diagonalization
- Flux-Activated Resonant Control of a Bosonic Quantum Memory
- Machine learning the effects of many quantum measurements